Comparison of connectivity analyses for resting state EEG data

Journal of Neural Engineering

Volumn 14, Issue 3, 2017, Pages

  Olejarczyk, Elzbieta ^a   Marzetti, Laura ^b   Pizzella, Vittorio ^b   Zappasodi, Filippo ^b  

^a INSTITUTE OF BIOCYBERNETICS AND BIOMEDICAL ENGINEERING   (Poland)

^b UNIVERSITY OF CHIETI   (Italy)

Author keywords

directed transfer function; EEG; functional and effective connectivity; graph theory; multivariate transfer entropy; phase locking value; resting state

Indexed keywords

DIRECTED GRAPHS; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; ENTROPY; GRAPH THEORY; LOCKS (FASTENERS); SYNCHRONIZATION;

DIRECTED TRANSFER FUNCTIONS; EFFECTIVE CONNECTIVITIES; PHASE LOCKING VALUE; RESTING STATE; TRANSFER ENTROPY;

TRANSFER FUNCTIONS;

ADULT; ARTICLE; BIVARIATE ANALYSIS; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CONTROLLED STUDY; DIRECTED TRANSFER FUNCTION; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPH ELECTRODE; ENTROPY; EYELID CLOSURE; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL CONNECTIVITY; HUMAN; MALE; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; NONLINEAR SYSTEM; NORMAL HUMAN; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RESTING STATE NETWORK; TRANSFER ENTROPY; YOUNG ADULT; ALGORITHM; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; BRAIN; COMPUTER SIMULATION; CONNECTOME; EVALUATION STUDY; NERVE CELL NETWORK; PATHOPHYSIOLOGY; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; REPRODUCIBILITY; REST; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; STATISTICAL MODEL;

ALGORITHMS; BRAIN; COMPUTER SIMULATION; CONNECTOME; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MODELS, NEUROLOGICAL; MODELS, STATISTICAL; MULTIVARIATE ANALYSIS; NERVE NET; NONLINEAR DYNAMICS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; REST; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 85020483458     PISSN: 17412560     EISSN: 17412552     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1088/1741-2552/aa6401     Document Type: Article

References (114)

1. Adrian E D 1944 Brain rhythms Nature 153 360-2
2. Adrian E D and Matthews B H C 1934 The Berger rhythm: potential changes from the occipital lobes in man Brain 57 355-84
3. Ahmadlou M and Adeli H 2011 Functional community analysis of brain: a new approach for EEG-based investigation of the brain pathology Neuroimage 58 401-8
4. Akaike H 1974 A new look at the statistical model identification IEEE Trans. Automatic Control 19 716-23
5. Andrzejak R G, Lehnertz K, Mormann F, Rieke C, David P and Elger C E 2001 Indications of nonlinear deterministic and finite-dimensional structures in time series of brain electrical activity: dependence on recording region and brain state Phys. Rev. E 64 061907
6. Baccalá L and Sameshima K 2001 Partial directed coherence: a new concept in neural structure determination Biol. Cybern. 84 463-74
7. Barbati G, Porcaro C, Zappasodi F, Rossini P M and Tecchio F 2004 Optimization of ICA approach for artifact identification and removal in MEG signals Clin. Neurophys. 115 1220-32
8. Barnett L, Barrett A and Seth A 2009 Granger causality and transfer entropy are equivalent for Gaussian variables Phys. Rev. Lett. 103 238701
9. Bassett D S and Bullmore E T 2006 Small-world brain networks Neuroscientist 12 512-23
10. Bassett D S and Bullmore E T 2009 Human brain networks in health and disease Curr. Opin. Neurol. 22 340-7
11. Bassett D S and Gazzaniga M S 2011 Understanding complexity in the human brain Trends Cogn. Sci. 15 200-9
12. Berger H 1929 Uber das Elektrenkephalogramm des Menschen Arch. Psychiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten 87 527-70
13. Blinowska K and Kaminski M 2006 Multivariate signal analysis by parametric models handbook of time series analysis Recent Theorethical Developments and Applications (New York: Wiley) 373-411
14. Blinowska K and Kaminski M 2013 Functional brain networks: random, 'small world' or deterministic? PLoS One 8 e78763
15. Bullmore E and Sporns O 2009 Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 10 186-98
16. Burkitt G R, Silberstein R B, Cadusch P J and Wood A W 2000 Steady-state visual evoked potentials and travelling waves Clin. Neurophys. 111 246-58
17. Buzsaki G and Wang X J 2012 Mechanisms of gamma oscillations Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 35 203-25
18. Cao L 1997 Practical method for determining the minimum embedding dimension of a scalar time series Physica A 110 43-50
19. Chella F, Pizzella V, Zappasodi F and Marzetti L 2016 Impact of the reference choice on scalp EEG connectivity estimation J. Neural Eng. 13 036016
20. Chen J L, Ros T and Gruzelier J H 2013 Dynamic changes of ICA-derived EEG functional connectivity in the resting state Hum. Brain Mapp. 34 852-68
21. Chiang S and Haneef Z 2014 Graph theory findings in the pathophysiology of temporal lobe epilepsy Clin. Neurophysiol. 125 1295-305
22. Ciulla C, Takeda T and Endo H 1999 MEG characterization of spontaneous alpha rhythm in the human brain Brain Topogr. 11 211-22
23. Cover T M and Thomas J A 1991 Elements of Information Theory (New York: Wiley)
24. De Vico Fallani F, Astolfi L, Cincotti F, Mattia D, Marciani M G, Salinari S, Kurths J, Gao S, Cichocki A and Colosimo A 2007 Cortical functional connectivity networks in normal and spinal cord injured patients: evaluation by graph analysis Hum. Brain Mapp. 28 1334-46
25. Di Lanzo C, Marzetti L, Zappasodi F, De Vico Fallani F and Pizzella V 2012 Redundancy as a graph-based index of frequency specific MEG functional connectivity Comput. Math. Methods Med. 2012 207305
26. Engel A K, Gerloff C, Hilgetag C C and Nolte G 2013 Intrinsic coupling modes: multiscale interactions in ongoing brain activity Neuron 80 867-86
27. Faes L, Marinazzo D, Nollo G and Porta A 2016 An information-theoretic framework to map the spatio-temporal dynamics of the scalp electroencephalogram IEEE Trans. Biomed. Eng. 63 2488-96
28. Fell J and Axmacher N 2011 The role of phase synchronization in memory processes Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 12 105-18
29. Fries P 2005 A mechanism for cognitive dynamics: neuronal communication through neuronal coherence Trends Cogn. Sci. 9 474-80
30. Fries P 2009 Neuronal gamma-band synchronization as a fundamental process in cortical computation Annu. Rev. Neurosci. 32 209-24
31. Fries P 2015 Rhythms for cognition: communication through coherence Neuron 88 220-35
32. Friston K J 2011 Functional and effective connectivity: a review Brain Connectivity 1 13-6
33. Granger C W J 1969 Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods Econometrica 37 424-38
34. Hari R, Salmelin R, Makela J P, Salenius S and Helle M 1997 Magnetoencephalographic cortical rhythms Int. J. Psychophysiol. 26 51-62
35. He Y and Evans A 2010 Graph theoretical modeling of brain connectivity Curr. Opin. Neurol. 23 341-50
36. Helfrich R F, Knepper H, Nolte G, Sengelmann M, Konig P, Schneider T R and Engel A K 2016 Spectral fingerprints of large-scale cortical dynamics during ambiguous motion perception Hum. Brain Mapp. 37 4099-111
37. Hillebrand A, Tewarie P, van Dellen E, Yu M, Carbo E W S, Douw L, Gouw A A, van Straaten E C W and Stam C J 2016 Direction of information flow in large-scale resting-state networks is frequency-dependent Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 113 3867-72
38. Hlavackova-Schindler K, Palus M, Vejmelka M and Bhattacharya J 2007 Causality detection based on information-theoretic approaches in time series analysis Phys. Rep. 441 1-46
39. Honey C J, Koetter R, Breakspear M and Sporns O 2007 Network structure of cerebral cortex shapes functional connectivity on multiple time scales Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 104 10240-5
40. Ito J, Nikolaev A R and van Leeuwen C 2005 Spatial and temporal structure of phase synchronization of spontaneous alpha EEG activity Biol. Cybern. 92 54-60
41. Jalili M and Knyazeva M G 2011 EEG-based functional networks in schizophrenia Comput. Biol. Med. 41 1178-86
42. Jann K, Dierks T, Boesch C, Kottlow M, Strik W and Koenig T 2009 BOLD correlates of EEG alpha phase-locking and the fMRI default mode network Neuroimage 45 903-16
43. Jin S H, Jeong W, Lee D S, Jeon B S and Chung C K 2014 Preserved high-centrality hubs but efficient network reorganization during eyes-open state compared with eyes-closed resting state: an MEG study J. Neurophysiol. 111 1455-65
44. Joudaki A, Salehi N, Jalili M and Knyazeva M G 2012 EEG-based functional brain networks: does the network size matter? PLoS One 7 e35673
45. Kaminski M J and Blinowska K J 1991 A new method of the description of the information flow in the brain structures Biol. Cybern. 65 203-10
46. Kaminski M, Brzezicka A, Kaminski J and Blinowska K 2016 Measures of coupling between neural populations based on Granger causality principle Frontiers Comput. Neurosci. 10 114
47. Kamitake T, Harashima H and Miyakawa H 1984 A time-series analysis method based on the directed transformation Electon. Commun. Japan 67 1-9
48. Kantz H and Schreiber T 1997 Nonlinear Time Series Analysis (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
49. Kawasaki M, Uno Y, Mori J, Kobata K and Kitajo K 2014 Transcranial magnetic stimulation induced global propagation of transient phase resetting associated with directional information flow Frontiers Hum. Neurosci. 8 173
50. Kirst C, Timme M and Battaglia D 2016 Dynamic information routing in complex networks Nat. Commun. 7 11061
51. Klonowski W, Olejarczyk E and Stepien R 2000 Nonlinear dynamics of EEG-signal reveals influence of magnetic field on the brain Conf. Proc., IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (Chicago) vol 22 pp 2955-8
52. Klonowski W, Olejarczyk E and Stepien R 2002 Complexity of EEG-signal in time domain - possible biomedical application AIP Conf. Proc. (Potsdam) vol 622 pp 155-60
53. Knyazev G G, Slobodskoj-Plusnin J Y, Bocharov A V and Pylkova L V 2011 The default mode network and EEG α oscillations: an independent component analysis Brain Res. 1402 67-79
54. Lehnertz K, Andrzejak R G, Arnhold J, Kreuz T, Mormann F, Rieke C, Widman G and Elger C E 2001 Nonlinear EEG analysis in epilepsy: its possible use for interictal focus localization, seizure anticipation, and prevention J. Clin. Neurophysiol. 18 209-22
55. Lehnertz K, Arnhold J, Grassberger P and Elger C E 2000 Chaos in Brain? (Singapore: World Scientific)
56. Linkenkaer-Hansen K, Nikouline V V, Palva J M and Ilmoniemi R J 2001 Long-range temporal correlations and scaling behavior in human brain oscillations J. Neurosci. 21 1370-7
57. Lowet E, Roberts M J, Bonizzi P, Karel J and De Weerd P 2016 Quantifying neural oscillatory synchronization: a comparison between spectral coherence and phase-locking value approaches PLoS One 11 e0146443
58. MacLean S E and Ward L M 2014 Temporo-frontal phase synchronization supports hierarchical network for mismatch negativity Clin. Neurophysiol. 125 1604-17
59. Manshanden I, De Munck J C, Simon N R and Lopes da Silva F H 2002 Source localization of MEG sleep spindles and the relation to sources of alpha band rhythms Clin Neurophysiol. 113 1937-47
60. Marzetti L, Nolte G, Perrucci M G, Romani G L and Del Gratta C 2007 The use of standardized infinity reference in EEG coherency studies Neuroimage 36 48-63
61. Marzetti L, Della Penna S, Snyder A Z, Pizzella V, Nolte G, de Pasquale F, Romani G L and Corbetta M 2013 Frequency specific interactions of MEG resting state activity within and across brain networks as revealed by the multivariate interaction measure Neuroimage 79 172-83
62. Marzetti L, Di Lanzo C, Zappasodi F, Chella F, Raffone A and Pizzella V 2014 Magnetoencephalographic alpha band connectivity reveals differential default mode network interactions during focused attention and open monitoring meditation Front Hum. Neurosci. 8 832
63. Michel C M, Lehmann D, Henggeler B and Brandeis D 1992 Localization of the sources of EEG delta, theta, alpha and beta frequency bands using the FFT dipole approximation Electroencephalogr. Clin. Neurophysiol. 82 38-44
64. Micheloyannis S 2012 Graph-based network analysis in schizophrenia World J. Psychiatr. 2 1-12
65. Miraglia F, Vecchio F, Bramanti P and Rossini P M 2016 EEG characteristics in 'eyes-open' versus 'eyes-closed' conditions: small-world network architecture in healthy aging and age-related brain degeneration Clin. Neurophysiol. 127 1261-8
66. Mormann F, Lehnertz K, David P and Elger C 2000 Mean phase coherence as a measure for phase synchronization and its application to the EEG of epilepsy patients Physica D 144 358-69
67. Mo J, Liu Y, Huang H and Ding M 2013 Coupling between visual alpha oscillations and default mode activity Neuroimage 68 112-8
68. Montalto A, Faes L and Marinazzo D 2014 MuTE: a MATLAB toolbox to compare established and novel estimators of the multivariate transfer entropy PLoS One 9 e109462
69. Niso G, Bruna R, Pereda E, Gutierrez R, Bajo R, Maestu F and del Pozo F 2013 HERMES: towards an integrated toolbox to characterize functional and effective brain connectivity Neuroinformatics 11 405-34
70. Olejarczyk E 2011 Fractal dimension in time domain - application in EEG-signal analysis Classification and Application of Fractals (New York: Nova Science Publishers) 161-85
71. Olejarczyk E, Sobieszek A, Rudner R, Marciniak R, Wartak M, Stasiowski M and Jalowiecki P 2009 Evaluation of the EEG-signal during volatile anaesthesia: methodological approach Biocybern. Biomed. Eng. 29 3-28
72. Patel P, Khosla D, Al-Dayeh L and Singht M 1999 Distributed source imaging of alpha activity using a maximum entropy principle Clin. Neurophysiol. 110 538-49
73. Ponten S C, Bartolomei F and Stam C J 2007 Small-world networks and epilepsy: graph theoretical analysis of intracerebrally recorded mesial temporal lobeseizures Clin. Neurophysiol. 118 918-27
74. Pyka M, Beckmann C F, Schoning S, Hauke S, Heider D, Kugel H, Arolt V and Konrad C 2009 Impact of working memory load on fMRI resting state pattern in subsequent resting phases PLoS One 4 e7198
75. Rosenblum M, Pikovsky A, Kurths J, Schafer C and Tass P A 2001 Phase synchronization: from theory to data analysis Neuroinformatics 4 279-321
76. Rosenblum M G, Pikovsky A S and Kurths J 1997 From phase to lag synchronization in coupled chaotic oscillators Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 4193-6
77. Rubinov M, Knock S A, Stam C J, Micheloyannis S, Harris A W, Williams L M and Breakspear M 2009 Small-world properties of nonlinear brain activity in schizophrenia Hum. Brain Mapp. 30 403-16
78. Rubinov M and Sporns O 2010 Complex network measures of brain connectivity: uses and interpretations NeuroImage 52 1059-69
79. Sadaghiani S, Scheeringa R, Lehongre K, Morillon B, Giraud A L, D'Esposito M and Kleinschmidt A 2012 Alpha-band phase synchrony is related to activity in the fronto-parietal adaptive control network J. Neurosci. 32 14305-10
80. Saito Y and Harashima H 1981 Tracking of information within multichannel EEG record - causal analysis in EEG Recent Advances in EEG and EMG Data Processing ed N Yamaguchi and K Fujisawa (Amsterdam: Elsevier)
81. Sanz-Arigita E J, Schoonheim M M, Damoiseaux J S, Rombouts S A R B, Maris E, Barkhof F, Scheltens P and Stam C J 2010 Loss of 'small-world' networks in Alzheimer's disease: graph analysis of fMRI resting-state functional connectivity PLoS One 5 e13788
82. Schoffelen J M and Gross J 2009 Source connectivity analysis with MEG and EEG Hum. Brain Mapp. 30 1857-65
83. Schomer D L and Lopes da Silva F 2012 Niedermeyer's Electroencephalography: Basic Principles, Clinical Applications, and Related Fields (Baltimore, MD: Williams & Wilkins)
84. Schreiber T 2000 Measuring information transfer Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 461-4
85. Shannon C E 1948 A mathematical theory of communication Bell Syst. Tech. J. 27 379-423
86. Sporns O, Tononi G and Edelman G M 2000 Theoretical neuroanatomy and the connectivity of the cerebral cortex Cereb. Cortex 10 127-41
87. Sporns O, Tononi G and Kotter R 2005 The human connectome: a structural description of the human brain PLoS Comput. Biol. 1 e42
88. Sporns O 2011 The human connectome: a complex network Ann. New York Acad. Sci. 1224 109-25
89. Sporns O 2013 Network attributes for segregation and integration in the human brain Curr. Opin. Neurobiol. 23 162-71
90. Stam C J, Pijn J P, Suffczynski P and Lopes da Silva F H 1999 Dynamics of the human alpha rhythm: evidence for non-linearity? Clin. Neurophysiol. 110 1801-13
91. Stam C J 2005 Nonlinear dynamical analysis of EEG and MEG: review of an emerging field Clin. Neurophysiol. 116 2266-301
92. Stam C J 2006 Nonlinear Brain Dynamics (New York: Nova Science Publishers)
93. Stam C J and Reijneveld J C 2007a Graph theoretical analysis of complex networks in the brain Nonlinear Biomed. Phys. 1 3
94. Stam C J, Jones B E, Nolte G, Breakspear M and Scheltens P 2007b Small-world networks and functional connectivity in Alzheimer's disease Cereb. Cortex 17 92-9
95. Stam C J 2010 Characterization of anatomical and functional connectivity in the brain: a complex networks perspective Int. J. Psychophysiol. 77 186-94
96. Stam C J, van Straaten E C, Van Dellen E, Tewarie P, Gong G, Hillebrand A, Meier J and Van Mieghem P 2016 The relation between structural and functional connectivity patterns in complex brain networks Int. J. Psychophysiol. 103 149-60
97. Tan B, Kong X, Yang P, Jin Z and Ling L 2013 The difference of brain functional connectivity between eyes-closed and eyes-open using graph theoretical analysis Comput. Math. Methods Med. 2013 976365
98. Theiler J, Eubank S, Longtin A, Galdrikian B and Farmer J D 1992 Testing for nonlinearity in time series: the method of surrogate data Physica D 58 77-94
99. Tononi G, Sporns O and Edelman G M 1994 A measure for brain complexity: relating functional segregation and integration in the nervous system Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 91 5033-7
100. Van den Heuvel M P and Fornito A 2014 Brain networks in schizophrenia Neuropsychol. Rev. 24 32-48
101. Van den Heuvel M P and Hulshoff Pol H E 2010 Exploring the brain network: a review on resting-state fMRI functional connectivity Eur. Neuropsychopharmacol. 20 519-34
102. Van Wijk B C, Stam C J and Daffertshofer A 2010 Comparing brain networks of different size and connectivity density using graph theory PLoS One 5 e13701
103. Varela F, Lachaux J, Rodriguez E and Martinerie J 2001 The brainweb: phase synchronization and large-scale integration Nat. Rev. Neurosci. 2 229-39
104. Vecchio F, Miraglia F, Marra C, Quaranta D, Vita M G, Bramanti P and Rossini P M 2014 Human brain networks in cognitive decline: a graph theoretical analysis of cortical connectivity from EEG data J. Alzheimers Dis. 41 113-27
105. Vicente R, Wibral M, Lindner M and Pipa G 2011 Transfer entropy-a model-free measure of effective connectivity for the neurosciences J. Comput. Neurosci. 30 45-67
106. Wang G and Takigawa M 1992 Directed coherence as a measure of interhemispheric correlation of EEG Int. J. Psychophysiol. 13 119-28
107. Wang J, Zuo X, Dai Z, Xia M, Zhao Z, Zhao X, Jia J, Han Y and He Y 2013 Disrupted functional brain connectome in individuals at risk for Alzheimer's disease Biol. Psychiatry 73 472-81
108. Wiener N 1956 The theory of prediction Modern Mathematics for Engineers (New York: McGraw-Hill)
109. Williamson S J, Kaufman L, Lu Z L, Wang J Z and Karron D 1997 Study of human occipital alpha rhythm: the alphon hypothesis and alpha suppression Int. J. Psychophysiol. 26 63-76
110. Xu P et al 2014 Different topological organization of human brain functional networks with eyes open versus eyes closed Neuroimage 90 246-55
111. Zappasodi F, Marzetti L, Olejarczyk E, Tecchio F and Pizzella V 2015 Age-related changes in electroencephalographic signal complexity PLoS One 10 e0141995
112. Zappasodi F, Olejarczyk E, Marzetti L, Assenza G, Pizzella V and Tecchio F 2014 Fractal dimension of EEG activity senses neuronal impairment in acute stroke PLoS One 9 e100199
113. Zhang J, Wang J, Wu Q, Kuang W, Huang X, He Y and Gong Q 2011 Disrupted brain connectivity networks in drug-naive, first-episode major depressive disorder Biol. Psychiatry 70 334-42
114. Zochowski M and Dzakpasu R 2004 Conditional entropies, phase synchronization and changes in the directionality of information flow in neural systems J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 37 3823-34