Addressing reverse inference in psychiatric neuroimaging: Meta-analyses of task-related brain activation in common mental disorders

Human Brain Mapping

Volumn 38, Issue 4, 2017, Pages 1846-1864

  Sprooten, Emma ^a   Rasgon, Alexander ^a   Goodman, Morgan ^a   Carlin, Ariella ^a   Leibu, Evan ^a   Lee, Won Hee ^a   Frangou, Sophia ^a  

^a MOUNT SINAI SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Anxiety disorders; Bipolar disorder; Functional magnetic resonance imaging; Major depressive disorder; Meta analyses; Obsessive compulsive disorder; Research domain criteria; Schizophrenia

Indexed keywords

AMYGDALA; ANGULAR GYRUS; ANTERIOR CINGULATE; ANXIETY DISORDER; ARTICLE; BIPOLAR DISORDER; BRAIN MAPPING; BRAIN STEM; CASE CONTROL STUDY; CAUDATE NUCLEUS; FRONTAL OPERCULUM; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; FUNCTIONAL NEUROIMAGING; GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER; GLOBUS PALLIDUS; HIPPOCAMPUS; HUMAN; INFERIOR FRONTAL GYRUS; INFERIOR TEMPORAL GYRUS; INSULA; LINGUAL GYRUS; MAJOR DEPRESSION; MIDDLE FRONTAL GYRUS; MIDDLE TEMPORAL GYRUS; NEUROANATOMY; NUCLEUS ACCUMBENS; OBSESSIVE COMPULSIVE DISORDER; ORBITAL CORTEX; PANIC; PARAHIPPOCAMPAL GYRUS; PARIETAL OPERCULUM; PARS OPERCULARIS; PHOBIA; POSTCENTRAL GYRUS; POSTERIOR CINGULATE; POSTTRAUMATIC STRESS DISORDER; PRECUNEUS; PRIMARY MOTOR CORTEX; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUTAMEN; SCHIZOPHRENIA; SUPERIOR FRONTAL GYRUS; SUPERIOR PARIETAL LOBULE; SUPERIOR TEMPORAL GYRUS; SUPPLEMENTARY MOTOR AREA; SUPRAMARGINAL GYRUS; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; THALAMUS; BIBLIOGRAPHIC DATABASE; BLOOD; BRAIN; CLASSIFICATION; DIAGNOSTIC IMAGING; FEMALE; IMAGE PROCESSING; MALE; MENTAL DISEASE; META ANALYSIS; NUCLEAR MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; PATHOLOGY; STATISTICS AND NUMERICAL DATA;

OXYGEN;

BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; CASE-CONTROL STUDIES; DATABASES, BIBLIOGRAPHIC; FEMALE; HUMANS; IMAGE PROCESSING, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MENTAL DISORDERS; OXYGEN;

EID: 85008499927     PISSN: 10659471     EISSN: 10970193     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/hbm.23486     Document Type: Article

References (57)

1. Arnone D, Cavanagh J, Gerber D, Lawrie SM, Ebmeier KP, McIntosh AM (2009): Magnetic resonance imaging studies in bipolar disorder and schizophrenia: Meta-analysis. Br J Psychiatry 195:194–201.
2. Beesdo K, Pine DS, Lieb R, Wittchen HU (2010): Incidence and risk patterns of anxiety and depressive disorders and categorization of generalized anxiety disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 67:47–57.
3. Buckley PF, Miller BJ, Lehrer DS, Castle DJ (2009): Psychiatric comorbidities and schizophrenia. Schizophr Bull 35:383–402.
4. Chen CH, Suckling J, Lennox BR, Ooi C, Bullmore ET (2011): A quantitative meta-analysis of fMRI studies in bipolar disorder. Bipolar Disord 13:1–15.
5. Cross-Disorder Group of the Psychiatric Genomics Consortium (2013): Identification of risk loci with shared effects on five major psychiatric disorders: A genome-wide analysis. Lancet 381:1371–1379.
6. Crossley NA, Mechelli A, Scott J, Carletti F, Fox PT, McGuire P, Bullmore ET (2014): The hubs of the human connectome are generally implicated in the anatomy of brain disorders. Brain 137:2382–2395.
7. Crossley NA, Mechelli A, Ginestet C, Rubinov M, Bullmore ET, McGuire P (2016): Altered hub functioning and compensatory activations in the connectome: A meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging studies in schizophrenia. Schizophr. Bull 42:434–442.
8. Cuthbert BN (2014): The RDoC framework: Facilitating transition from ICD/DSM to approaches that integrate neuroscience and psychopathology. World Psychiatry 13:28–35.
9. Del Casale A, Rapinesi C, Kotzalidis GD, De Rossi P, Curto M, Janiri D, Criscuolo S, Alessi MC, Ferri VR, De Giorgi R, Sani G, Ferracuti S, Girardi P, Brugnoli R (2015): Executive functions in obsessive-compulsive disorder: An activation likelihood estimate meta-analysis of fMRI studies. World J Biol Psychiatry 17:378–393.
10. Delvecchio G, Sugranyes G, Frangou S (2013): Evidence of diagnostic specificity in the neural correlates of facial affect processing in bipolar disorder and schizophrenia: A meta-analysis of functional imaging studies. Psychol Med 43:5532569.
11. Desikan RS, Segonne F, Fischl B, Quinn BT, Dickerson BC, Blacker D, Buckner RL, Dale AM, Maguire RP, Hyman BT, Albert MS, Killiany RJ (2006): An automated labeling system for subdividing the human cerebral cortex on MRI scans into gyral based regions of interest. Neuroimage 31:968–980.
12. DeVylder JE, Burnette D, Yang LH (2014): Co-occurrence of psychotic experiences and common mental health conditions across four racially and ethnically diverse population samples. Psychol Med 44:3503–3513.
13. Doherty JL, Owen MJ (2014): Genomic insights into the overlap between psychiatric disorders: Implications for research and clinical practice. Genome Med 6:29.
14. Eisen JL, Rasmussen SA (1993): Obsessive compulsive disorder with psychotic features. J Clin Psychiatry 54:373–379.
15. Etkin A, Wager TD (2007): Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: A meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. Am J Psychiatry 164:1476–1488.
16. Evans AC, Collins DL, Mills SR, Brown ED, Kelly RL, Peters TM (1993): 3D statistical neuroanatomical models from 305 MRI volumes. Proc IEEE-Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference. pp1813–1817.
17. Fineberg NA, Potenza MN, Chamberlain SR, Berlin HA, Menzies L, Bechara A, Sahakian BJ, Robbins TW, Bullmore ET, Hollander E (2010): Probing compulsive and impulsive behaviors, from animal models to endophenotypes: a narrative review. Neuropsychopharmacology 35:591–604.
18. Fox PT, Parsons LM, Lancaster JL (1998): Beyond the single study: Function/location metanalysis in cognitive neuroimaging. Curr Opin Neurobiol 8:178–187.
19. Frazier JA, Chiu S, Breeze JL, Makris N, Lange N, Kennedy DN, Herbert MR, Bent EK, Koneru VK, Dieterich ME, Hodge SM, Rauch SL, Grant PE, Cohen BM, Seidman LJ, Caviness VS, Biederman J (2005): Structural brain magnetic resonance imaging of limbic and thalamic volumes in pediatric bipolar disorder. Am J Psychiatry 162:1256–1265.
20. Gentili C, Cristea IA, Angstadt M, Klumpp H, Tozzi L, Phan KL, Pietrini P (2016): Beyond emotions: A meta-analysis of neural response within face processing system in social anxiety. Exp Biol Med (Maywood) 241:225–237.
21. Goodkind M, Eickhoff SB, Oathes DJ, Jiang Y, Chang A, Jones- Hagata LB, Ortega BN, Zaiko YV, Roach EL, Korgaonkar MS, Grieve SM, Galatzer-Levy I, Fox PT, Etkin A (2015): Identification of a common neurobiological substrate for mental illness. JAMA Psychiatry 72:305–315.
22. Gorun A, Cieslak K, Harkavy-Friedman J, Deptula A, Goetz D, Goetz R, Malaspina D (2015): Frequent comorbidity and predictors of social anxiety in persons with schizophrenia: A retrospective cohort study. Prim Care Companion CNS Disord 17:289–295.
23. Graham J, Salimi-Khorshidi G, Hagan C, Walsh N, Goodyer I, Lennox B, Suckling J (2013): Meta-analytic evidence for neuroimaging models of depression: State or trait? J Affect Disord 151:423–431.
24. Graybiel AM, Rauch SL (2000): Toward a neurobiology of obsessive- compulsive disorder. Neuron 28:343–347.
25. Hibar DP, Westlye LT, van Erp TGM, Rasmussen J, Leonardo CD, Faskowitz J, Haukvik UK, Hartberg CB, Doan NT, Agartz I, Dale AM, Gruber O, Krämer B, Trost S, Liberg B, Abé C, Ekman CJ, Ingvar M, Landén M, Fears SC, Freimer NB, Bearden CE, The Costa Rica/Colombia Consortium for Genetic Investigation of Bipolar Endophenotypes, Sprooten E, Glahn DC, Pearlson GD, Emsell L, Kenney J, Scanlon C, McDonald C, Cannon DM, Almeida J, Versace A, Caseras X, Lawrence NS, Phillips ML, Dima D, Delvecchio G, Frangou S, Satterthwaite TD, Wolf D, Houenou J, Henry C, Malt UF, Bøen E, Elvsåshagen T, Young AH, Lloyd AJ, Goodwin GM, Mackay CE, Bourne C, Bilderbeck A, Abramovic L, Boks MP, van Haren NEM, Ophoff RA, Kahn RS, Bauer M, Pfennig A, Alda M, Hajek T, Mwangi B, Soares JC, Nickson T, Dimitrova R, Sussmann JE, Hagenaars S, Whalley HC, McIntosh AM, Thompson PM, Andreassen OA; The ENIGMA Bipolar Disorder Working Group (2016): Subcortical volumetric abnormalities in bipolar disorder. Mol Psychiatry 21:1710–1716.
26. Insel T, Cuthbert B, Garvey M, Heinssen R, Pine DS, Quinn K, Sanislow C, Wang P (2010): Research domain criteria (RDoC): Toward a new classification framework for research on mental disorders. Am J Psychiatry 167:748–751.
27. Ipser JC, Singh L, Stein DJ (2013): Meta-analysis of functional brain imaging in specific phobia. Psychiatry Clin Neurosci 67: 311–322.
28. Kempton MJ, Salvador Z, MunafÒ MR, Geddes JR, Simmons A, Frangou S, Williams SC (2011): Structural neuroimaging studies in major depressive disorder. Meta-analysis and comparison with bipolar disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry 68:675–690.
29. Kessler RC, McGonagle KA, Zhao S, Nelson CB, Hughes M, Eshleman S, Wittchen H-U, Kendler KS (1994): Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of dsm-iii-r psychiatric disorders in the united states: Results from the national comorbidity survey. Arch Gen Psychiatry 51:8–19.
30. Kim SW, Jeong BO, Kim JM, Shin IS, Hwang MY, Paul Amminger G, Nelson B, Berk M, McGorry P, Yoon JS (2015): Associations of obsessive-compulsive symptoms with clinical and neurocognitive features in schizophrenia according to stage of illness. Psychiatry Res 30:368–375. 226
31. Koenen KC, Moffitt TE, Roberts AL, Martin LT, Kubzansky L, Harrington H, Poulton R, Caspi A (2009): Childhood IQ and adult mental disorders: A test of the cognitive reserve hypothesis. Am J Psychiatry 166:50–57.
32. Markon KE (2010): Modeling psychopathology structure: A symptom-level analysis of axis i and ii disorders. Psychol Med 40:273–288.
33. Menon V (2011): Large-scale brain networks and psychopathology: A unifying triple network model. Trends Cogn Sci 15: 483–506.
34. Milad MR, Rauch SL (2012): Obsessive-compulsive disorder: beyond segregated cortico-striatal pathways. Trends Cogn Sci 16:43–51.
35. Miller CH, Hamilton JP, Sacchet MD, Gotlib IH (2015): Meta-analysis of Functional Neuroimaging of Major Depressive Disorder in Youth. JAMA Psychiatry 72:1045–1053.
36. Minzenberg MJ, Laird AR, Thelen S, Carter CS, Glahn DC (2009): Meta-analysis of 41 functional neuroimaging studies of executive function in schizophrenia. Arch Gen Psychiatry 66: 811–822.
37. Muldoon SF, Bassett DS (2014): Why network neuroscience? Compelling evidence and current frontiers. Phys Life Rev 11: 455–457.
38. Network and Pathway Analysis Subgroup of Psychiatric Genomics Consortium (2015): Psychiatric genome-wide association study analyses implicate neuronal, immune and histone pathways. Nat Neurosci 18:199–209.
39. OConghaile A, DeLisi LE (2015): Distinguishing schizophrenia from posttraumatic stress disorder with psychosis. Curr Opin Psychiatry 28:249–255.
40. Paulus M (2015): Pragmatism instead of mechanism: A call for impactful biological psychiatry. JAMA Psychiatry 72:631–632.
41. Pearlson GD (2015): Etiologic, phenomenologic, and endophenotypic overlap of schizophrenia and bipolar disorder. Annu Rev Clin Psychol 11:251–281.
42. Pessoa L (2014): Understanding brain networks and brain organization. Phys Life Rev 11:400–435.
43. Poldrack RA (2011): Inferring mental states from neuroimaging data: From reverse inference to large-scale decoding. Neuron 72:692–697.
44. Poldrack RA (2006): Can cognitive processes be inferred from neuroimaging data? Trends Cogn Sci 10:59–63.
45. Price CJ, Friston KJ (2005): Functional ontologies for cognition: The systematic definition of structure and function. Cogn Neuropsychol 22:262–275.
46. Rosen C, Marvin R, Reilly JL, Deleon O, Harris MS, Keedy SK, Solari H, Weiden P, Sweeney JA (2012): Phenomenology of first-episode psychosis in schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and unipolar depression: A comparative analysis. Clin Schizophr Relat Psychoses 6:145–151.
47. Sanislow CA, Pine DS, Quinn KJ, Kozak MJ, Garvey MA, Heinssen RK, Wang PS, Cuthbert BN (2010): Developing constructs for psychopathology research: Research domain criteria. J Abnorm Psychol 119:631–639.
48. Schmaal L, Veltman DJ, van Erp TG, Sämann PG, Frodl T, Jahanshad N, Loehrer E, Tiemeier H, Hofman A, Niessen WJ, Vernooij MW, Ikram MA, Wittfeld K, Grabe HJ, Block A, Hegenscheid K, Völzke H, Hoehn D, Czisch M, Lagopoulos J, Hatton SN, Hickie IB, Goya-Maldonado R, Krämer B, Gruber O, Couvy-Duchesne B, Rentería ME, Strike LT, Mills NT, de Zubicaray GI, McMahon KL, Medland SE, Martin NG, Gillespie NA, Wright MJ, Hall GB, MacQueen GM, Frey EM, Carballedo A, van Velzen LS, van Tol MJ, van der Wee NJ, Veer IM, Walter H, Schnell K, Schramm E, Normann C, Schoepf D, Konrad C, Zurowski B, Nickson T, McIntosh AM, Papmeyer M, Whalley HC, Sussmann JE, Godlewska BR, Cowen PJ, Fischer FH, Rose M, Penninx BW, Thompson PM, Hibar DP (2016): Subcortical brain alterations in major depressive disorder: Findings from the ENIGMA Major Depressive Disorder working group. Mol Psychiatry 21:806–812.
49. Shanmugan S, Wolf DH, Calkins ME, Moore TM, Ruparel K, Hopson RD, Vandekar SN, Roalf DR, Elliott MA, Jackson C, Gennatas ED, Leibenluft E, Pine DS, Shinohara RT, Hakonarson H, Gur RC, Gur RE, Satterthwaite TD (2016): Common and dissociable mechanisms of executive system dysfunction across psychiatric disorders in youth. Am J Psychiatry 173:517–526.
50. Talairach J, Tournoux P (1988): Co-planar Stereotaxic Atlas of the Human Brain: 3-Dimensional Proportional System—An Approach to Cerebral Imaging. New York, NY: Thieme Medical Publishers.
51. Vaidyanathan U, Patrick CJ, Iacono WG (2012): Examining the overlap between bipolar disorder, nonaffective psychosis, and common mental disorders using latent class analysis. Psychopathology 45:361–365.
52. van Erp TG, Hibar DP, Rasmussen JM, Glahn DC, Pearlson GD, Andreassen OA, Agartz I, Westlye LT, Haukvik UK, Dale AM, Melle I, Hartberg CB, Gruber O, Kraemer B, Zilles D, Donohoe G, Kelly S, McDonald C, Morris DW, Cannon DM, Corvin A, Machielsen MW, Koenders L, de Haan L, Veltman DJ, Satterthwaite TD, Wolf DH, Gur RC, Gur RE, Potkin SG, Mathalon DH, Mueller BA, Preda A, Macciardi F, Ehrlich S, Walton E, Hass J, Calhoun VD, Bockholt HJ, Sponheim SR, Shoemaker JM, van Haren NE, Pol HE, Ophoff RA, Kahn RS, Roiz-Santiañez R, Crespo-Facorro B, Wang L, Alpert KI, Jönsson EG, Dimitrova R, Bois C, Whalley HC, McIntosh AM, Lawrie SM, Hashimoto R, Thompson PM, Turner JA (2016): Subcortical brain volume abnormalities in 2028 individuals with schizophrenia and 2540 healthy controls via the ENIGMA consortium. Mol Psychiatry 21:547–553.
53. Ventura J, Hellemann GS, Thames AD, Koellner V, Nuechterlein KH (2009): Symptoms as mediators of the relationship between neurocognition and functional outcome in schizophrenia: A meta-analysis. Schizophr Res. Sep 113:189–199.
54. Ventura J, Thames AD, Wood RC, Guzik LH, Hellemann GS (2010): Disorganization and reality distortion in schizophrenia: A meta-analysis of the relationship between positive symptoms and neurocognitive deficits. Schizophr Res 121:1–14.
55. Wager TD, Lindquist M, Kaplan L (2007): Meta-analysis of functional neuroimaging data: Current and future directions. Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci 2:150–158.
56. Wood J, Ahmari SE (2015): A framework for understanding the emerging role of corticolimbic-ventral striatal networks in OCD-associated repetitive behaviors. Front Syst Neurosci 9: 171.
57. Zou Q, Ross TJ, Gu H, Geng X, Zuo XN, Hong LE, Gao JH, Stein EA, Zang YF, Yang Y (2013): Intrinsic resting-state activity predicts working memory brain activation and behavioral performance. Hum Brain Mapp 34:3204–3215.