The development of collective reliability: A study of therapeutic decision-making

Theoretical Issues in Ergonomics Science

Volumn 9, Issue 3, 2008, Pages 223-254

  Mollo, Vanina ^a   Falzon, Pierre ^a  

^a University of Paris Cité   (France)

Author keywords

Confrontation method; Evidence based medicine; Knowledge development; Reliability; Therapeutic decision making

Indexed keywords

EID: 85007869550     PISSN: 1463922X     EISSN: 1464536X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/14639220701195186     Document Type: Article

References (59)

1. BAKER, D.P., GUSTAFSON, S., BEAUBIEN, J.M., SALAS, E. and BARACH, P., 2005, Medical team programs in health care. Advances in Patient Safety, 4, pp. 253–267.
2. BARTHE, B. and QUÉINNEC, Y., 1999, Terminologie et perspectives d’analyse du travail collectif en ergonomie. L’Année Psychologique, 99, pp. 663–686.
3. BENSING, J.P.D., 2000, Bridging the gap. The separate worlds of evidence-based medicine and patient-centered medicine. Patient Education and Counseling, 39, pp. 17–25.
4. BOURRIER, M., 1998, Le pouvoir sur les règles: la gestion des procédures de maintenance dans l’industrie nuclé aire. Performances Humaines et Techniques, 94, pp. 30–36.
5. BOURRIER, M., 2003, Transgression et conformité dans l’industrie nuclé aire. In La Puissance des norms, C. Durand and A. Pichon (Eds), pp. 135–160 (Paris: L’harmattan).
6. BOURRIER, M. and LAROCHE, H., 2000, Les approches organisationnelles de la fiabilité. Actes du séminaire, Le Risque de Défaillance et Son Contrôle par les Individus et les Organisations Dans les Activités à Hauts Risques (Gif sur Yvette: C.N.R.S.).
7. BREHMER, B., 1991, Distributed decision making: some notes on the literature. In Distributed Decision Making: Cognitive Models for Cooperative Work, J. Rasmussen, B. Brehmer and J. Leplat (Eds), pp. 3–18 (New York: John Wiley & Sons).
8. CASTEL, P. and MERLE, I., 2002, Quand les normes de pratiques deviennent une ressource pour les médecins. Sociologie du Travail, 44, pp. 337–355.
9. CHRISTENSEN, C. and ABBOTT, A.S., 2003, Team medical decision making. In Decision Making in Health Care. Theory, Psychology and Applications, G.B. Chapman and F.A. Sonnenberg (Eds), pp. 267–285 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
10. CHRISTENSEN, C., LARSON, J.R., ABBOTT, A.S., ARDOLINO, A., FRANZ, T. and PFEIFFER, C., 2000, Decision making of clinical teams: communication patterns and diagnostic error. Medical Decision Making, 20, pp. 45–50.
11. DAVIDOFF, F., HAYNES, B., SACKETT, D. and SMITH, R., 1995, Evidence-based medicine. British Medical Journal, 310, pp. 1085–1086.
12. DEKKER, S., 2003, Failure to adapt or adaptations that fail: contrasting models on procedures and safety. Applied Ergonomics, 34, pp. 233–238.
13. EVERAERE, C., 1999, Autonomie et Collectifs de Travail, p. 95 (Lyon: ANACT).
14. EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE WORKING GROUP, 1992, Evidence-based medicine. A new approach to teaching practice for medicine. Journal of the American Medical Association, 268, pp. 2420–2425.
15. FALZON, P., 1994, Les activités méta-fonctionnelles et leur assistance. Le Travail Humain, 57(1), pp. 1–23.
16. FALZON, P., SAUVAGNAC, C., MHAMDI, A. and DARSES, F., 1997, Transformer le travail; de quelques activités métafonctionnelles collectives. XXXIIth Congress of the SELF, Lyon: 17–19 September 1997.
17. Fox, E., 2001, Introduction to cooperative learning. Available online at: http://ei.cs.vt.edu/_mm/s01/docs/cooplearning.doc
18. FREEMAN, A.C. and SWEENEY, K., 2001, Why general practitioners do not implement evidence: qualitative study. British Medical Journal, 323(7303), pp. 1–5.
19. HAYNES, R.B., 2002, What kind of evidence is it that evidence-based medicine advocates want health care providers and consumers to pay attention to? BMC Health Services Research, 2, p. 7.
20. HOC, J.M., 1996, Supervision et Contrôle de Processus: la Cognition En Situation Dynamique (Grenoble: PUG).
21. HOWITT, A. and ARMSTRONG, D., 1999, Implementing evidence-based medicine in general practice: audit and qualitative study of antithrombotic treatment for atrial fibrillation. British Medical Journal, 318 (7194), pp. 1324–1327.
22. JOHNSON, D.W., MARUYAMA, G., JOHNSON, R. and NELSON, D., 1981, Effects of cooperative, competitive and individualistic goal structures on achievement: a meta-analysis. Psychological Bulletin, 89, pp. 47–62.
23. KARSENTY, L., 2003, Ergonomie cognitive des communications: la question du contexte partagé. Thèse d’habilitation à diriger des recherche, Université de Paris V, Paris.
24. KEE, F. and OWEN, T., 2004, Decision-making in a multidisciplinary cancer team: does team discussion result in better quality decisions? Medical Decision Making, 24, pp. 602–613.
25. KNOTTNERUS, A. and DINANT, G.J., 1997, Medicine based evidence, a prerequisite for evidence based medicine. British Medical Journal, 315 (7116), pp. 1109–1110.
26. LARSON, J.R., CHRISTENSEN, C., FRANZ, T. and ABBOTT, A.S., 1998, Diagnosing groups: the pooling, management, and impact of shared and unshared case information in tem-based medical decision making. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75, pp. 93–108.
27. LARSON, J.R., SARGIS, E.G. and BAUMAN, C.W., 2004, Shared knowledge and subgroup influence during decision-making discussions. Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 17, pp. 245–262.
28. LEPLAT, J., 1993, Ergonomie et activités collectives. In Les Aspects Collectifs du Travail: Actes du XXVII° Congrès de la SELF, F. Six and X. Vaxevanoglou (Eds), pp. 7–27 (Toulouse: Octarè s).
29. LLORY, M. and LLORY, A., 1998, Les procédures et le débat sur la sécurité. Performances Humaines et Techniques, 95, pp. 18–23.
30. MACLEAN, A., YOUNG, R.M., BELLOTTI, V.M. and MORAN, T.P., 1996, Questions, options and criteria: elements of design space analysis. In Design Rationale: Concepts, Techniques and Use, T.P. Moran and J.M. Carroll (Eds), pp. 53–105 (Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates).
31. MOLLO, V., 2002, La construction des procédures par la pratique: le rôle des outils ergonomiques. In J.M. Evesque, A.M. Gautier, Y. Schwartz et al. (Eds), XXXVIIth Congress of the SELF, Les évolutions de la prescription. Aix-en-Provence: SELF, pp. 201–208.
32. MOLLO, V., 2004a, Normalisation et adaptation des règles en cancérologie. In XXXIXth Congress of the SELF, Ergonomie et normalisation., P. Rey, E. Ollagnier, V. Gonik and D. Ramaciotti (Eds), pp. 221–229 (Toulouse: Octarè s).
33. MOLLO, V., 2004b, Usage des ressources, adaptation des savoirs et gestion de l’autonomie dans la décision thérapeutique. Thèse d’Ergonomie. CNAM, Paris.
34. MOLLO, V., 2007, Les collectifs de travail comme ressource: de l’usage formel à l’usage ré el. Psychologie de l’interaction, in press.
35. MOLLO, V. and FALZON, P., 2003a, Formalizing confrontation methods: a categorization attempt. In XVth Thriennial Congress of International Ergonomics Association, Ergonomics in the Digital Age, 24–29 August 2003, Seoul, Korea.
36. MOLLO, V. and FALZON, P., 2003b, De l’expertise locale à la science … et retour. In XXXVIIIth Congress of the SELF, Models et pratiques d’analyse du Travail: 1988–2003, 15 ans d’évolution. Paris: SELF, pp. 439–447.
37. MOLLO, V. and FALZON, P., 2004, Auto- and allo-confrontation as tools for reflective activities. Applied Ergonomics, 35, pp. 531–540.
38. NORMAN, D.A., 1993, Les artefacts cognitifs. Raisons Pratiques, 4, pp. 15–34.
39. PESTIAUX, D., 1998, La médecine basée sur les évidences. Louvain Médical, 117, pp. 283–288.
40. PETTIGREW, T.F. and TROPP, L.R., 2006, A meta-analytic test of intergroup contact theory. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 90, pp. 751–783.
41. PIZZI, L., GOLDFARB, N.I. and NASH, M.D., 2001, Crew Resource Management and its application in medicine. In Making Health Care Safer: A Critical Analysis of Patient Safety Practices, K.G. Shojania, B.W. Duncan, K.M. McDonald and R.M. Wachter (Eds), pp. 501–510 (Rockville, MD: US Department of Health and Human Services, Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality).
42. RASMUSSEN, J., 1997, Risk management in a dynamic society: a modelling problem. Safety Science, 27, pp. 183–213.
43. REASON, J., 1993, L’erreur Humaine (Paris: PUF).
44. REASON, J., PARKER, D. and LAWTON, R., 1998, Organizational controls and safety: the varieties of rule-related behaviour. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology, 71, pp. 289–304.
45. SACKETT, D.L., ROSENBERG, W.M.C., GRAY, J.A.M., HAYNES, R.B. and RICHARDSON, W.S., 1996, Evidence-based medicine, what it is, and what it isn’t. British Medical Journal, 312(7023), pp. 71–72.
46. SALAS, E., BURKE, S., BOWERS, C.A. and WILSON, K.A., 2001, Team training in the skies: does Crew Resource Management (CRM) training work? Human Factors, 43, pp. 641–674.
47. SALAS, E., FOWLKES, J.E., STOUT, R.J., MILANOVICH, D.M. and PRINCE, C., 1999a, Does CRM training improve teamwork skills in the cockpit? Two evaluation studies. Human Factors, 41, pp. 326–343.
48. SALAS, E., PRINCE, C., BOWERS, C.A., STOUT, R.J., OSER, R.L. and CANNON-BOWERS, J.A., 1999b, A methodology for enhancing Crew Resource Management Training. Human Factors, 41, pp. 161–172.
49. SAUVAGNAC, C., (2000), La construction de connaissances par l’utilisation et la conception de procédures. Contribution au cadre théorique des activités métafonctionnelles. Thèse de doctorat en Ergonomie. CNAM, Paris.
50. SAUVAGNAC, C., BECKENDORF, V., LESUR, A., LUPORSI, E., STINES, J., FALZON, P. and BEY, P., 1999a, Des traitements standard aux cas particuliers: la place des comités de décision thérapeutique en cancérologie. Bulletin du Cancer, 86, pp. 767–772.
51. SAUVAGNAC, C. and FALZON, P., 1999, Gestion des savoirs et politique qualité: le roˆ le de l’ergonomie. XXXIVth Congress of the SELF, Ergonomie et relation santé-travail, fiabilité des systems et des organisations, critères de gestion des entreprises. Caen: SELF, pp. 545–554.
52. SAUVAGNAC, C., STINES, J., LESUR, A., FALZON, P. and BEY, P., 1999b, Application of therapeutic protocols: a tool to manage medical knowledge. In Computer Science Series as Artificial Intelligence in Medicine. Proceedings of the Joint European Conference on AIMDM’ 99, W. Horms, Y. Shadar, G. Lindberg, S. Andteasur and J. Wyatt (Eds), p. 5 (Berlin: Springer).
53. SCHMIDT, K., 1991, Cooperative work: a conceptual framework. In Distributed Decision Making. Cognitive Models for Cooperative Work, J. Rasmussen, B. Brehmer and J. Leplat (Eds), pp. 75–100 (New York: John Wiley & Sons).
54. SETBON, M., 2000, La qualité des soins, nouveau paradigme de l’action collective? Sociologie du Travail, 42, pp. 51–68.
55. STRAUS, S.E. and SACKETT, D.L., 1998, Using research findings in clinical practice. British Medical Journal, 317(7154), pp. 339–342.
56. TIETSE, S., 2003, Internet et capitalisation des connaissances en médecine: construction de la valeur d’usage des outils de l’internet par les médecins hospitalo-universitaires. Thèse de doctorat en sciences de l’information et de la communication. Université Claude Bernard, Lyon.
57. TROPP, L.R. and PETTIGREW, T.F., 2005, Relationships between intergroup contact and prejudice among minority and majority status groups. Psychological Science, 16, pp. 951–957.
58. VALOT, C., WEILL-FASSINA, A., GUYOT, S. and AMALBERTI, R., 1995, Vers un modè le pour l’analyse ergonomique des grands systèmes. XXXth Congress of the SELF, Ergonomie et production industrielle: l’home dans les nouvelles organisations. Biarritz: SELF, pp. 272–279.
59. WINQUIST, J.R. and LARSON, J.R., 1998, Information pooling: when it impacts group decision making. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 74, pp. 371–377.