Defining disease in the context of overdiagnosis

Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy

Volumn 20, Issue 2, 2017, Pages 269-280

  Walker, Mary Jean ^a   Rogers, Wendy ^a  

^a MACQUARIE UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

Disease definition; Dysfunction; Overdiagnosis; Pr cising definition; Spectral disease

Indexed keywords

DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS; HEALTH SERVICE; HUMAN; RISK;

DIAGNOSIS, DIFFERENTIAL; HUMANS; MEDICAL OVERUSE; RISK;

EID: 84995519431     PISSN: 13867423     EISSN: 15728633     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11019-016-9748-8     Document Type: Article

References (42)

1. Armstrong, D. 1995. The rise of surveillance medicine. Sociology of Health & Illness 17(3): 393–404.
2. Autier, P. 2015. Doubtful health benefit of screening from 40 years of age. Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology 12: 570–572. doi:10.1038/nrclinonc.2015.162.
3. Barratt, A. 2015. Overdiagnosis in mammography screening: A 45-year journey from shadowy idea to acknowledged reality. BMJ 350: h867.
4. Black, W.C. 1998. Advances in radiology and the real versus apparent effects of early diagnosis. European Journal of Radiology 27: 116–122.
5. Boorse, C. 1976. Wright on functions. Philosophical Review 85(1): 70–86.
6. Boorse, C. 1977. Health as a theoretical concept. Philosophy of Science 44: 542–573.
7. Boorse, C. 1997. A rebuttal on health. In What is disease?, ed. J. Humber, and R. Almeder, 3–134. New Jersey: Humana Press.
8. Carter, S.M., W. Rogers, I. Heath, C. Degeling, J. Doust, and A. Barratt. 2015. The challenge of overdiagnosis begins with its definition. BMJ 350: h869.
9. Coon, E.R., R.A. Quinonez, V.A. Moyer, and A.R. Schroeder. 2014. Overdiagnosis: How our compulsion for diagnosis may be harming children. Pediatrics. doi:10.1542/peds.2014-1778.
10. Engelhardt, H.T. 1975. The concepts of health and disease. In Evaluation and explanation in the biomedical sciences, ed. H.T. Engelhardt, and S.F. Spicker, 125–141. Dordrecht: D Reidel.
11. Esserman, L.J., I.M. Thompson, and B. Reid. 2013. Overdiagnosis and overtreatment in cancer: An opportunity for improvement. Journal of the American Medical Association 310(8): 797–798.
12. Esserman, L.J., I.M. Thompson, B. Reid, P. Nelson, D.F. Ransohoff, H.G. Welch, S. Hwang, D.A. Berry, K.W. Kinsler, W.C. Black, M. Bissell, H. Parnes, and S. Srivastava. 2014. Addressing overdiagnosis and overtreatment in cancer: A prescription for change. Lancet Oncology 15: e234–e242.
13. Glas, N.A., et al. 2014. Effect of implementation of the mass breast cancer screening programme in older women in the Netherlands: Population based study. BMJ 349: g5410.
14. Godlee, F. 2012. Preventing overdiagnosis. BMJ 344: e3973.
15. Harach, H.R., K.O. Franssila, and V. Wasenius. 1985. Occult papillary carcinoma of the thyroid: A “normal” finding in Finland. A systematic autopsy study. Cancer 56(3): 531–538.
16. Hersch, J., J. Janson, A. Barrat, L. Irwig, N. Houssami, K. Howard, H. Dhillon, and K. McCaffery. 2013. Women’s views on overdiagnosis in breast cancer screening: A qualitative study. BMJ 346: f158.
17. Hoda, U. 2014. Overdiagnosis of pulmonary emboli by CT pulmonary angiograms. Thorax 69: 925.
18. Hofmann, B. 2013. Diagnosing overdiagnosis: Conceptual challenges and suggested solutions. European Journal of Epidemiology 29: 599–604.
19. Hofmann, B. 2016. Medicalization and overdiagnosis: Different but alike. Medicine, Healthcare and Philosophy 19(2): 253–264.
20. Margolis, E., and S. Laurence. 1999. Concepts and cognitive science. In Concepts, ed. E. Margolis, and S. Laurence, 3–81. New Jersey: MIT Press.
21. Moynihan, R.N., G.P.E. Cooke, J.A. Doust, L. Bero, S. Hill, and P.P. Glasziou. 2013. Expanding disease definitions in guidelines and expert panel ties to industry: A cross-sectional study of common conditions in the United States. PLOS Medicine 10(8): e1001500.
22. Moynihan, R., J. Doust, and D. Henry. 2012. Preventing overdiagnosis: How to stop harming the healthy. BMJ 344: e3502.
23. Moynihan, R., D. Henry, and K.G.M. Moons. 2014. Using evidence to combat overdiagnosis and overtreatment: Evaluating treatments, tests, and disease definitions in the time of too much. PLoS Medicine 11(7): e1001655.
24. Nordby, H. 2007. The analytic-synthetic distinction and conceptual analysis of basic health concepts. Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy 9: 169–180.
25. Nordenfelt, L. 1987. On the Nature of health: An action-theoretic approach. Dordrecht: D. Reidel Publishing.
26. Nordenfelt, L. 1993. Concepts of health and their consequences for health care. Theoretical Medicine 14: 277–285.
27. Pickering, T.G. 2006. Now we are sick: Labelling and hypertension. Journal of Clinical Hypertension 8(1): 57–60.
28. Rogers, W.A., and Y. Mintzker. 2016. Getting clearer on overdiagnosis. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 22(4): 580–587.
29. Rogers, W.A., Walker, M.J. Forthcoming. The line drawing problem in defining disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy.
30. Sadegh-Zadeh, K. 2000. Fuzzy health, illness, and disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 25: 605–638.
31. Sadegh-Zadeh, K. 2008. The prototype resemblance theory of disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 33: 106–139.
32. Schwartz, P.H. 2004. An alternative to conceptual analysis in the function debate. Monist 87(1): 136–153.
33. Schwartz, P.H. 2007a. Defining dysfunction: Natural selection, design, and drawing a line. Philosophy of Science 74: 364–385.
34. Schwartz, P.H. 2007b. Decision and discovery in defining disease. In Establishing medical reality, ed. H. Kincaid, and J. McKitrick, 47–63. Dordrecht: Springer.
35. Schwartz, P.H. 2008. Risk and disease. Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 51: 320–334.
36. Smith, E., E. Shoben, and L.J. Rips. 1974. Structure and process in semantic memory: A featural model for semantic decisions. Psychological Review 81(3): 214–241.
37. Wakefield, J. 2014. The biostatistical theory versus the harmful dysfunction analysis, Part 1: Is dysfunction a sufficient condition for medical disorder? Journal of Medicine and Philosophy 39: 648–682.
38. Walker, M.J., Rogers, W.A. Forthcoming (a). Diagnosis, narrative identity, and asymptomatic disease. Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics.
39. Walker, M.J., Rogers, W.A. Forthcoming (b). A new approach to defining disease. Journal of Medicine and Philosophy.
40. Welch, H.G., L. Schwartz, and S. Woloshin. 2011. Overdiagnosed: Making people sick in the pursuit of health. Boston: Beacon Press.
41. Wittgenstein, L. 1953. Philosophical Investigations, trans. G.E.M. Anscombe. Oxford: Blackwell.
42. Worrall, J., and J. Worrall. 2001. Defining disease: Much ado about nothing? Analecta Husserliana 72: 33–56.