Do fish remains provide reliable palaeoenvironmental records? An examination of the effects of cooking on the morphology and chemistry of fish otoliths, vertebrae and scales

Journal of Archaeological Science

Volumn 74, Issue , 2016, Pages 45-59

  Disspain, Morgan C F ^a   Ulm, Sean ^b   Izzo, Christopher ^a   Gillanders, Bronwyn M ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE   (Australia)

^b JAMES COOK UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

Experimental archaeology; Icthyoarchaeology; Otolith; Palaeoenvironmental reconstruction; Stable isotopes; Trace element analysis; Zooarchaeology

Indexed keywords

ARCHAEOLOGY; EXPERIMENTAL STUDY; FISH; MORPHOLOGY; OTOLITH; PALEOENVIRONMENT; RECONSTRUCTION; STABLE ISOTOPE;

ARGYROSOMUS JAPONICUS;

EID: 84991087379     PISSN: 03054403     EISSN: 10959238     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jas.2016.08.010     Document Type: Article

References (79)

1. Anderson, M.J., Ter Braak, C.J.F., Permutation tests for multi-factorial analysis of variance. J. Stat. Comput. Simul. 73:2 (2003), 85–113.
2. Andrus, C.F.T., Crowe, D.E., Alteration of otolith aragonite: effects of prehistoric cooking methods on otolith chemistry. J. Archaeol. Sci. 29:3 (2002), 291–299.
3. Arkhipkin, A.I., Schuchert, P.C., Danyushevsky, L., Otolith chemistry reveals fine population structure and close affinity to the Pacific and Atlantic oceanic spawning grounds in the migratory southern blue whiting (Micromesistius australis australis). Fish. Res. 96:2–3 (2009), 188–194.
4. Barrett, J.H., Orton, D., Johnstone, C., Harland, J., Van Neer, W., Ervynck, A., Roberts, C., Locker, A., Amundsen, C., Enghoff, I.B., Hamilton-Dyer, S., Heinrich, D., Hufthammer, A.K., Jones, A.K.G., Jonsson, L., Makowiecki, D., Pope, P., O'Connell, T.C., de Roo, T., Richards, M., Interpreting the expansion of sea fishing in medieval Europe using stable isotope analysis of archaeological cod bones. J. Archaeol. Sci. 38:7 (2011), 1516–1524.
5. Bath, G.E., Thorrold, S.R., Jones, C.M., Campana, S.E., McLaren, J.W., Lam, J.W.H., Strontium and barium uptake in aragonitic otoliths of marine fish. Geochimica Cosmochimica Acta 64:10 (2000), 1705–1714.
6. Berndt, R.M., Berndt, C.H., Stanton, J.E., The World that Was: the Yaraldi of the Murray River and the Lakes, South Australia. 1993, UBC Press, Vancouver.
7. Boschin, F., Zanolli, C., Bernardini, F., Princivalle, F., Tuniz, C., A look from the inside: MicroCT analysis of burned bones., 6(2), 2015, 9.
8. Campana, S.E., Chemistry and composition of fish otoliths: pathways, mechanisms and applications. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 188 (1999), 263–297.
9. Campana, S.E., Chouinard, G.A., Hanson, J.M., Frechet, A., Brattey, J., Otolith elemental fingerprints as biological tracers of fish stocks. Fish. Res. 46:1–3 (2000), 343–357.
10. 18O profiles of hardhead catfish and Atlantic croaker otoliths as a method of determining seasonal use of fishes. Anthropol. Pap. Am. Mus. Nat. Hist. 97 (2012), 83–101.
11. Disspain, M.C.F., Ulm, S., Gillanders, B.M., Otoliths in archaeology: methods, applications and future prospects. J. Archaeol. Sci. Rep. 6 (2016), 623–632.
12. Disspain, M.C.F., Wallis, L.A., Gillanders, B.M., Developing baseline data to understand environmental change: a geochemical study of archaeological otoliths from the Coorong, South Australia. J. Archaeol. Sci. 38:8 (2011), 1842–1857.
13. Disspain, M.C.F., Wilson, C.J., Gillanders, B.M., Morphological and chemical analysis of archaeological fish otoliths from the Lower Murray River, South Australia. Archaeol. Ocean. 47 (2012), 141–150.
14. Doubleday, Z.A., Harris, H.H., Izzo, C., Gillanders, B.M., Strontium randomly substituting for calcium in fish otolith aragonite. Anal. Chem. 86 (2014), 865–869.
15. Dove, S.G., Gillanders, B.M., Kingsford, M.J., An investigation of chronological differences in the deposition of trace metals in the otoliths of two temperate reef fishes. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 205 (1996), 15–33.
16. Dufour, E., Holmden, C., Van Neer, W., Zazzo, A., Patterson, W.P., Degryse, P., Keppens, E., Oxygen and strontium isotopes as provenance indicators of fish at archaeological sites: the case study of Sagalassos, SW Turkey. J. Archaeol. Sci. 34:8 (2007), 1226–1239.
17. Elsdon, T.S., Gillanders, B.M., Interactive effects of temperature and salinity on otolith chemistry: challenges for determining environmental histories of fish. Can. J. Fish. Aquatic Sci. 59:11 (2002), 1796–1808.
18. Elsdon, T.S., Gillanders, B.M., Relationship between water and otolith elemental concentrations in juvenile black bream. Acanthopagrus Butcheri. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 260 (2003), 263–272.
19. Elsdon, T.S., Gillanders, B.M., Alternative life-history patterns of estuarine fish: barium in otoliths elucidates freshwater residency. Can. J. Fish. Aquatic Sci. 62 (2005), 1143–1152.
20. Elsdon, T.S., Gillanders, B.M., Strontium incorporation into calcified structures: separating the effects of ambient water concentration and exposure time. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 285 (2005), 233–243.
21. Elsdon, T.S., Wells, B.K., Campana, S.E., Gillanders, B.M., Jones, C.M., Limburg, K.E., Secor, D.E., Thorrold, S.R., Walther, B.D., Otolith chemistry to describe movements and life-history parameters of fishes: hypotheses, assumptions, limitations, and inferences. Oceanogr. Mar. Biol. Annu. Rev. 46 (2008), 296–330.
22. Ferguson, G.J., Ward, T.M., Ivey, A., Barnes, T., Life history of Argyrosomus japonicus, a large sciaenid at the southern part of its global distribution: implications for fisheries management. Fish. Res. 151 (2014), 148–157.
23. Fernandes, R., Meadows, J., Dreves, A., Nadeau, M.-J., Grootes, P., A preliminary study on the influence of cooking on the C and N isotopic composition of multiple organic fractions of fish (mackerel and haddock). J. Archaeol. Sci. 50 (2014), 153–159.
24. Gabriel, S., Prista, N., Costa, M.J., Estimating meagre (Argyrosomus regius) size from otoliths and vertebrae. J. Archaeol. Sci. 39:9 (2012), 2859–2865.
25. Gillanders, B.M., Munro, A.R., Hypersaline waters pose new challenges for reconstructing environmental histories of fish based on otolith chemistry. Limnol. Oceanogr. 57:4 (2012), 1136–1158.
26. Grupe, G., Hummel, S., Trace element studies on experimentally cremated bone. I. Alteration of the chemical composition at high temperatures. J. Archaeol. Sci. 18:2 (1991), 177–186.
27. 13C in otoliths from freshwater fish. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 17:5 (2003), 463–471.
28. Hamer, P.A., Jenkins, G.P., Coutin, P., Barium variation in Pagrus auratus (Sparidae) otoliths: a potential indicator of migration between an embayment and ocean waters in south-eastern Australia. Estuar. Coast. Shelf Sci. 68:3–4 (2006), 686–702.
29. Homsey, L.K., Walker, R.B., Hollenbach, K.D., What's for dinner? Investigating food-processing technologies at Dust Cave, Alabama. Southeast. Archaeol. 29:1 (2010), 182–196.
30. Hufthammer, A.K., Høie, H., Folkvord, A., Geffen, A.J., Andersson, C., Ninnemann, U.S., Seasonality of human site occupation based on stable oxygen isotope ratios of cod otoliths. J. Archaeol. Sci. 37:1 (2010), 78–83.
31. Ishimaru, E., Tayasu, I., Umino, T., Yumoto, T., Reconstruction of ancient trade routes in the Japanese Archipelago using carbon and nitrogen stable isotope analysis: identification of the stock origins of marine fish found at the inland Yokkaichi site, Hiroshima Prefecture, Japan. J. Isl. Coast. Archaeol. 6:1 (2011), 160–163.
32. Jenkin, G., Conquest of the Ngarrindjeri. 1979, Rigby Ltd, Adelaide.
33. 18O isotopic disequilibria in fish otoliths: metabolic and kinetic effects. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 75 (1991), 181–203.
34. Kalvoda, J., Novak, M., Babek, O., Brzobohaty, R., Hola, M., Holoubek, I., Kanicky, V., Skoda, R., Compositional changes in fish scale hydroxylapatite during early diagenesis; an example from an abandoned meander. Biogeochemistry 94:3 (2009), 197–215.
35. Koon, H.E.C., Nicholson, R.A., Collins, M.J., A practical approach to the identification of low temperature heated bone using TEM. J. Archaeol. Sci. 30:11 (2003), 1393–1399.
36. Koon, H.E.C., O'Connor, T.P., Collins, M.J., Sorting the butchered from the boiled. J. Archaeol. Sci. 37:1 (2010), 62–69.
37. Larsen, S.C., Recrystallization of Biogenic Aragonite Shells from Archaeological Contexts and Implications for Palaeoenvironmental Reconstruction., 2015, Western Washington University Unpublished Master of Arts thesis.
38. Long, K., Stern, N., Williams, I.S., Kinsley, L., Wood, R., Sporcic, K., Smith, T., Fallon, S., Kokkonen, H., Moffat, I., Grün, R., Fish otolith geochemistry, environmental conditions and human occupation at Lake Mungo, Australia. Quat. Sci. Rev. 88 (2014), 82–95.
39. Lubinski, P.M., Fish heads, fish heads: an experiment on differential bone preservation in a salmonid fish. J. Archaeol. Sci. 23:2 (1996), 175–181.
40. Luebbers, R.A., The Coorong Report: an Archaeological Survey of the Northern Coorong., 1982 (Unpublished report prepared for the South Australian Department for Environment and Planning).
41. Miller, M.B., Clough, A.M., Batson, J.N., Vachet, R.W., Transition metal binding to cod otolith proteins. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 329:1 (2006), 135–143.
42. Milton, D.A., Chenery, S.R., The effect of otolith storage methods on the concentrations of elements detected by laser-ablation ICPMS. J. Fish Biol. 53:4 (1998), 785–794.
43. Morales-Nin, B., Geffen, A.J., Perez-Mayol, S., Palmer, M., Gonzalez-Quiros, R., Grau, A., Seasonal and ontogenic migrations of meagre (Argyrosomus regius) determined by otolith geochemical signatures. Fish. Res. 127–128 (2012), 154–165.
44. Nicholson, R.A., An investigation into the effects on fish bone of passage through the human gut: some experiments and comparisons with archaeological material. Circaea 10:1 (1993), 38–51.
45. Nicholson, R.A., Out of the frying pan into the fire: what value are burnt fish bones to archaeology?. Archaeofauna 4 (1995), 47–64.
46. Orton, D.C., Makowiecki, D., de Roo, T., Johnstone, C., Harland, J., Jonsson, L., Heinrich, D., Enghoff, I.B., Lõugas, L., van Neer, W., Ervynck, A., Hufthammer, A.K., Amundsen, C., Jones, A.K.G., Locker, A., Hamilton-Dyer, S., Pope, P., MacKenzie, B.R., Richards, M., O'Connell, T.C., Barrett, J.H., Stable isotope evidence for late medieval (14th-15th C) origins of the eastern Baltic cod (Gadus morhua) fishery. PLoS ONE, 6(11), 2011, e27568.
47. Privat, K., O'Connell, T., Hedges, R., The distinction between freshwater- and terrestrial-based diets: methodological concerns and archaeological applications of sulphur stable isotope analysis. J. Archaeol. Sci. 34:8 (2007), 1197–1204.
48. Proctor, C.H., Thresher, R.E., Effects of specimen handling and otolith preparation on concentration of elements in fish otoliths. Mar. Biol. 131 (1998), 681–694.
49. Quinn, T.J., Deriso, R.B., Quantitative Fish Dynamics. 1999, Oxford University Press, New York.
50. Reis-Santos, P., Tanner, S.E., Elsdon, T.S., Cabral, H.N., Gillanders, B.M., Effects of temperature, salinity and water composition on otolith elemental incorporation of Dicentrarchus labrax. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 446:0 (2013), 245–252.
51. Richter, J., Experimental study of heat induced morphological changes in fish bone collagen. J. Archaeol. Sci. 13:5 (1986), 477–481.
52. Roberts, S.J., Smith, C.I., Millard, A., Collins, M.J., The taphonomy of cooked bone: characterizing boiling and its physico-chemical effects. Archaeometry 44:3 (2002), 485–494.
53. Robins, R., Stock, E.C., The burning question: a study of molluscan remains from a midden on Moreton Island. Solomon, S., Davidson, I., Watson, D., (eds.) Problem Solving in Taphonomy, 1990, University of Queensland Anthropology Museum, St Lucia, 80–100.
54. Robson, H., Andersen, S., Craig, O., Fischer, A., Glykou, A., Hartz, S., Lübke, H., Schmölcke, U., Heron, C., Carbon and nitrogen isotope signals in eel bone collagen from Mesolithic and Neolithic sites in northern Europe. J. Archaeol. Sci. 39:7 (2012), 2003–2011.
55. Rooker, J., Zdanowicz, V., Secor, D., Chemistry of tuna otoliths: assessment of base composition and postmortem handling effects. Mar. Biol. 139:1 (2001), 35–43.
56. Rowell, K., Dettman, D., Dietz, R., Nitrogen isotopes in otoliths reconstruct ancient trophic position. Environ. Biol. Fishes 89:3 (2010), 415–425.
57. Rowell, K., Flessa, K., Dettman, D.L., Roman, M., The importance of Colorado River flow to nursery habitats of the Gulf corvina (Cynoscion othonopterus). Can. J. Fish. Aquatic Sci. 62 (2005), 2874–2885.
58. Rowell, K., Flessa, K., Dettman, D.L., Roman, M., Gerber, L.R., Findley, L.T., Diverting the Colorado River leads to a dramatic life history shift in an endangered marine fish. Biol. Conserv. 141 (2008), 1138–1148.
59. Shipman, P., Foster, G., Schoeninger, M., Burnt bones and teeth: an experimental study of color, morphology, crystal structure and shrinkage. J. Archaeol. Sci. 11:4 (1984), 307–325.
60. Spennemann, D.H.R., Colley, S.M., Fire in a pit: the effects of burning on faunal remains. Archaeozoologia 3 (1989), 51–64.
61. Spötl, C., Vennemann, T.W., Continuous-flow isotope ratio mass spectrometric analysis of carbonate minerals. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 17:9 (2003), 1004–1006.
62. Stiner, M.C., Kuhn, S.L., Weiner, S., Bar-Yosef, O., Differential burning, recrystallization, and fragmentation of archaeological bone. J. Archaeol. Sci. 22:2 (1995), 223–237.
63. Surge, D., Walker, K.J., Oxygen isotope composition of modern and archaeological otolith from the estuarine hardhead catfish (Ariopsis felis) and their potential to record low-latitude climate change. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol. 228 (2005), 179–191.
64. Tanner, S.E., Reis-Santos, P., Vasconcelos, R.P., Fonseca, V.F., França, S., Cabral, H.N., Thorrold, S.R., Does otolith geochemistry record ambient environmental conditions in a temperate tidal estuary?. J. Exp. Mar. Biol. Ecol. 441:0 (2013), 7–15.
65. Taplin, G., The Narrinyeri. Woods, J.D., (eds.) The Native Tribes of South Australia, 1879, E.S. Wigg and Son, Adelaide, 1–156.
66. Thompson, T.J.U., Chudek, J.A., A novel approach to the visualisation of heat-induced structural change in bone. Sci. Justice 47:2 (2007), 99–104.
67. 18O fractionation in aragonitic otoliths of marine fish. Geochimica Cosmochimica Acta 61:14 (1997), 2909–2919.
68. Thorrold, S.R., Jones, C.M., Swart, P.K., Targett, T.E., Accurate classification of juvenile weakfish Cynoscion regalis to estuarine nursery areas based on chemical signatures on otoliths. Mar. Ecol. Prog. Ser. 173 (1998), 253–265.
69. Waite, A.J., Swart, P.K., The inversion of aragonite to calcite during the sampling of skeletal archives: implications for proxy interpretation. Rapid Commun. Mass Spectrom. 29:10 (2015), 955–964.
70. Wang, T., Surge, D., Walker, K.J., Isotopic evidence for climate change during the Vandal Minimum from Ariopsis felis otoliths and Mercenaria campechiensis shells, southwest Florida, USA. Holocene 21:7 (2011), 1081–1091.
71. Wang, T., Surge, D., Walker, K.J., Seasonal climate change across the Roman Warm Period/Vandal Minimum transition using isotope sclerochronology in archaeological shells and otoliths, southwest Florida, USA. Quat. Int. 308–309:0 (2013), 230–241.
72. Wells, B.K., Rieman, B.E., Clayton, J.L., Horan, D.L., Jones, C.M., Relationships between water, otolith, and scale chemistries of Westslope cutthroat trout from the Coeur d'Alene River, Idaho: the potential application of hard-part chemistry to describe movements in freshwater. Trans. Am. Fish. Soc. 132:3 (2003), 409–424.
73. West, C.F., Wischniowski, S., Johnston, C., Pacific cod (Gadus macrocephalus) as a paleothermometer: otolith oxygen isotope reconstruction. J. Archaeol. Sci. 39:10 (2012), 3277–3283.
74. Willis, L.M., Boehm, A.R., Fish bones, cut marks, and burial: implications for taphonomy and faunal analysis. J. Archaeol. Sci. 45 (2014), 20–25.
75. Willis, L.M., Eren, M.I., Rick, T.C., Does butchering fish leave cut marks?. J. Archaeol. Sci. 35:5 (2008), 1438–1444.
76. Yankowski, A., Kerdsap, P., Chang, D., “Please pass the salt”- an ethnoarchaeological study of salt and salt fermented fish production, use and trade in northeast Thailand. J. Indo-Pacific Archaeol., 37, 2015.
77. Zazzo, A., Saliège, J.-F., Lebon, M., Lepetz, S., Moreau, C., Radiocarbon dating of calcined bones: insights from combustion experiments under natural conditions. Radiocarbon 54:3/4 (2012), 855–866.
78. Zazzo, A., Smith, G.R., Patterson, W.P., Dufour, E., Life history reconstruction of modern and fossil sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) by oxygen isotopic analysis of otoliths, vertebrae and teeth: implications for palaeoenvironmental reconstructions. Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 249 (2006), 200–215.
79. Zohar, I., Cooke, R., The impact of salting and drying on fish bones: preliminary observations on four marine species from Parita Bay, Panama. Archaeofauna 6 (1997), 59–66.