Using qualitative and quantitative methods to choose a habitat quality metric for air pollution policy evaluation

PLoS ONE

Volumn 11, Issue 8, 2016, Pages

  Rowe, Edwin C ^a   Ford, Adriana E S ^b,c   Smart, Simon M ^a   Henrys, Peter A ^a   Ashmore, Mike R ^b  

^a CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF YORK   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF GREENWICH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

AIR POLLUTION; DRIVER; GRASSLAND; HABITAT QUALITY; HEATHLAND; HUMAN; INDICATOR ORGANISM; NONHUMAN; QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS; QUANTITATIVE STUDY; SEMI STRUCTURED INTERVIEW; SPECIES RICHNESS; ALGORITHM; ANALYSIS; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; FEMALE; LEGISLATION AND JURISPRUDENCE; MALE; PROCEDURES; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; QUESTIONNAIRE; THEORETICAL MODEL;

AIR POLLUTION; ALGORITHMS; CONSERVATION OF NATURAL RESOURCES; ECOSYSTEM; ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MODELS, THEORETICAL; QUALITATIVE RESEARCH; SURVEYS AND QUESTIONNAIRES;

EID: 84991011039     PISSN: None     EISSN: 19326203     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0161085     Document Type: Article

References (95)

1. Kampa M, Castanas E (2008) Human health effects of air pollution. Environmental Pollution 151: 362-367. PMID: 17646040
2. Sala OE, Chapin FS, Armesto JJ, Berlow E, Bloomfield J, Dirzo R, et al. (2000) Biodiversity-Global biodiversity scenarios for the year 2100. Science 287: 1770-1774. PMID: 10710299
3. Bleeker A, Hicks WK, Dentener E, Galloway J, Erisman JW (2011) N deposition as a threat to the World's protected areas under the Convention on Biological Diversity. Environmental Pollution 159: 2280-2288. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2010.10.036 PMID: 21122958
4. Hodgson JG, Tallowin J, Dennis RLH, Thompson K, Poschlod P, Dhanoa MS, et al. (2014) Leaf nitrogen and canopy height identify processes leading to plant and butterfly diversity loss in agricultural landscapes. Functional Ecology 28: 1284-1291.
5. Feest A, van Swaay C, van Hinsberg A (2014) Nitrogen deposition and the reduction of butterfly biodiversity quality in the Netherlands. Ecological Indicators 39: 115-119.
6. Emmett BA, Rowe EC, Stevens CJ, Gowing DJ, Henrys PA, Maskell LC, et al. (2011) Interpretation of evidence of nitrogen impacts on vegetation in relation to UK biodiversity objectives.: JNCC Report 449.
7. JNCC, Peterborough, UK. 105 p. 7.
8. Henrys PA, Stevens CJ, Smart SM, Maskell LC, Walker KJ, Preston CD, et al. (2011) Impacts of nitrogen deposition on vascular plants in Britain: An analysis of two national observation networks. Biogeosciences 8: 3501-3518.
9. Stevens CJ, Smart SM, Henrys PA, Maskell LC, Walker KJ, Preston CD, et al. (2011) Collation of evidence of nitrogen impacts on vegetation in relation to UK biodiversity objectives.: JNCC Report 447. JNCC, Peterborough, UK.
10. Pierik M, van Ruijven J, Bezemer TM, Geerts R, Berendse F (2011) Recovery of plant species richness during long-term fertilization of a species-rich grassland. Ecology 92: 1393-1398. PMID: 21870612
11. Bobbink R, Hicks K, Galloway J, Spranger T, Alkemade R, Ashmore M, et al. (2010) Global assessment of nitrogen deposition effects on terrestrial plant diversity: A synthesis. Ecological Applications 20: 30-59. PMID: 20349829
12. Erisman JW, Galloway JN, Seitzinger S, Bleeker A, Dise NB, Petrescu AMR, et al. (2013) Consequences of human modification of the global nitrogen cycle. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 368.
13. Butchart SHM, Walpole M, Collen B, van Strien A, Scharlemann JPW, Almond REA, et al. (2010) Global Biodiversity: Indicators of Recent Declines. Science 328: 1164-1168. doi: 10.1126/science. 1187512 PMID: 20430971
14. de Vries W, Wamelink W, van Dobben H, Kros H, Reinds G- J, Mol-Dijkstra J, et al. (2010) Use of dynamic soil-vegetation models to assess impacts of nitrogen deposition on plant species composition and to estimate critical loads: An overview. Ecological Applications 20: 60-79.
15. Rowe EC, Wamelink GWW, Smart SM, Butler A, Henrys PA, van Dobben HF, et al. (2015) Field survey based models for exploring nitrogen and acidity effects on plant diversity and assessing long-term critical loads. In: De Vries W, Hettelingh J-P, Posch M, editors. Critical loads for nitrogen, acidity and metals for terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems: Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands. pp. 297-326.
16. Schlutow A, Dirnböck T, T. P, Scheuschner T (2015) Use of an empirical model approach for modelling trends of ecological sustainability. In: De Vries W, Hettelingh J-P, editors. Critical loads and dynamic risk assessments: Nitrogen, acidity and metals in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems: Springer, Dordrecht, Netherlands. pp. 381-402.
17. Belyazid S, Kurz D, Braun S, Sverdrup H, Rihm B, Hettelingh JP (2011) A dynamic modelling approach for estimating critical loads of nitrogen based on plant community changes under a changing climate. Environmental Pollution 159: 789-801. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2010.11.005 PMID: 21145634
18. Smart SM, Scott WA, Whitaker J, Hill MO, Roy DB, Critchley CN, et al. (2010) Empirical realised niche models for British higher and lower plants-development and preliminary testing. Journal of Vegetation Science 21: 643-656.
19. Reinds GJ, Bonten L, Mol-Dijkstra JP, Wamelink GWW, Goedhart P (2012) Combined effects of air pollution and climate change on species diversity in Europe: First assessments with VSD+ linked to vegetation models. In: Posch M, Hettelingh JP, editors. CCE Status Report 2012: Co-ordination Centre for Effects. pp. 49-61.
20. Henrys PA, Smart SM, Rowe EC, Jarvis SG, Fang Z, Evans CD, et al. (2015) Niche models for British plants and lichens obtained using an ensemble approach. New Journal of Botany 5: 89-100.
21. Margules C, Usher MB (1981) Criteria used in assessing wildlife conservation potential-A review. Biological Conservation 21: 79-109.
22. Feest A (2013) The utility of the Streamlining European Biodiversity Indicators 2010 (SEBI 2010). Ecological Indicators 28: 16-21.
23. Leroy B, Le Viol I, Petillon J (2014) Complementarity of rarity, specialisation and functional diversity metrics to assess community responses to environmental changes, using an example of spider communities in salt marshes. Ecological Indicators 46: 351-357.
24. EEA (2007) Halting the loss of biodiversity by 2010: Proposal for a first set of indicators to monitor progress in Europe. European Environment Agency, Technical report No 11/2007.
25. Nilsson J, Grennfelt P (1988) Critical loads for sulphur and nitrogen. Report 188: 15. Copenhagen, Denmark: UNECE/Nordic Council of Ministers.
26. Amann M, Bertok I, Borken-Kleefeld J, Cofala J, Heyes C, Hoglund-Isaksson L, et al. (2011) Cost-effective control of air quality and greenhouse gases in Europe: Modeling and policy applications. Environmental Modelling & Software 26: 1489-1501.
27. Pearsall J, editor (1998) The New Oxford Dictionary of English.: Oxford University Press. 2152 p. 27.
28. Isbell F, Calcagno V, Hector A, Connolly J, Harpole WS, Reich PB, et al. (2011) High plant diversity is needed to maintain ecosystem services. Nature 477: 199-U196. doi: 10.1038/nature10282 PMID: 21832994
29. Nicholson E, Keith DA, Wilcove DS (2009) Assessing the threat status of ecological communities. Conservation Biology 23: 259-274. doi: 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2008.01158.x PMID: 19245533
30. Mace GM, Stuart SN (1994) Draft IUCN Red List Categories, Version 2.2. Species 21-22: 13-24.
31. IUCN (2009) The IUCN Red List of threatened species.
32. Miller JR (2005) Biodiversity conservation and the extinction of experience. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 20: 430-434.
33. Davis MA, Chew MK, Hobbs RJ, Lugo AE, Ewel JJ, Vermeij GJ, et al. (2011) Don't judge species by their origins. Nature 474: 153-154. doi: 10.1038/474153a PMID: 21654782
34. Simberloff D, Alexander J, Allendorf F, Aronson J, Antunes PM, Bacher S, et al. (2011) Non-natives: 141 scientists object. Nature 475: 36-36.
35. Van Der Wal R, Fischer A, Selge S, Larson BMH (2015) Neither the public nor experts judge species primarily on their origins. Environmental Conservation 42: 349-355.
36. Ridder B (2007) An exploration of the value of naturalness and wild nature. Journal of Agricultural & Environmental Ethics 20: 195-213.
37. Heckenberger MJ, Russell JC, Toney JR, Schmidt MJ (2007) The legacy of cultural landscapes in the Brazilian Amazon: Implications for biodiversity. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B-Biological Sciences 362: 197-208.
38. Failing L, Gregory R (2003) Ten common mistakes in designing biodiversity indicators for forest policy. Journal of Environmental Management 68: 121-132. PMID: 12781752
39. Hull RB, Richert D, Seekamp E, Robertson D, Buhyoff GJ (2003) Understandings of environmental quality: Ambiguities and values held by environmental professionals. Environmental Management 31: 1-13. PMID: 12447571
40. Fischer A, Young JC (2007) Understanding mental constructs of biodiversity: Implications for biodiversity management and conservation. Biological Conservation 136: 271-282.
41. Suckall N, Fraser E, Quinn C (2009) How class shapes perceptions of nature: Implications for managing visitor perceptions in upland UK. In: Bonn A, Hubacek K, Allott T, Stewart J, editors. Drivers of environmental change in uplands: Routledge. pp. 393-403.
42. Goncalves B, Marques A, Soares A, Pereira HM (2015) Biodiversity offsets: From current challenges to harmonized metrics. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 14: 61-67.
43. Mooney HA, Duraiappah A, Larigauderie A (2013) Evolution of natural and social science interactions in global change research programs. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 110: 3665-3672. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1107484110 PMID: 23297237
44. Suter GW (1993) A critique of ecosystem health concepts and indexes. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 12: 1533-1539.
45. UNEP (2014) Developing indicators for national targets as part of NBSAP updating: Examples of the Biodiversity Indicator Development Framework in practice.: United Nations Environment Programme/World Conservation Monitoring Centre. Available: Http://www.bipindicators.net/.
46. Maskell LC, Smart SM, Bullock JM, Thompson K, Stevens CJ (2010) Nitrogen deposition causes widespread loss of species richness in British habitats. Global Change Biology 16: 671-679.
47. Field CD, Dise NB, Payne RJ, Britton AJ, Emmett BA, Helliwell RC, et al. (2014) The role of nitrogen deposition in widespread plant community change across semi-natural habitats. Ecosystems 17: 864-877.
48. Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J (2007) Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): A 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. International Journal for Quality in Health Care 19: 349-357. PMID: 17872937
49. Marshall MN (1996) Sampling for qualitative research. Family Practice 13: 522-525. PMID: 9023528
50. Verheyen K, Baeten L, De Frenne P, Bernhardt-Romermann M, Brunet J, Cornelis J, et al. (2012) Driving factors behind the eutrophication signal in understorey plant communities of deciduous temperate forests. Journal of Ecology 100: 352-365.
51. Brock K, Rodriguez G, Rowe EC, Zaragoza L (1995) Reflecciones sobre una experiencia de trabajo rural participativa: Problemas y temas de discussion. [Reflections on an experience of participatory rural work: Problems and discussion themes.]. Memorias del Segundo Congreso Internacional sobre Sistemas Agropecuarias. Universidad Autonoma del Estado de Mexico.
52. Ford-Thompson AES, Snell CJ, Saunders G, White PCL (2015) Dimensions of local public attitudes towards invasive species management in protected areas. Wildlife Research 42: 60-74
53. Scientific Software Development (2013) ATLAS.ti Version 6.2. Scientific Software Development GmbH., Berlin
54. Strauss A, Corbin J (1998) Basics of qualitative research: Grounded theory procedures and techniques. 2nd edition.: Sage Publications Inc., Newbury Park, CA, USA.
55. Rodwell JS, editor (1991-2000) British Plant Communities. Volumes 1-5.: Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
56. Smart SM (2000) MAVIS: Modular Analysis of Vegetation Information System.: Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, Lancaster, UK. Available: Http://www.ceh.ac.uk/services/modular-Analysis-vegetationinformation- system-mavis.
57. Magurran AE (1988) Ecological diversity and its measurement. London: Croon Helm Ltd. 179 p.
58. EEA (2014) European Nature Information System. EEA (European Environment Agency), Copenhagen, Denmark. Available: Http://eunis.eea.europa.eu/index.jsp.
59. NBN (2013) National Biodiversity Network Habitats Dictionary. Available: Http://habitats.nbn.org.uk/.
60. JNCC (2007) Assessing conservation status: The UK approach. Second Report by the UK under Article 17 on the implementation of the Habitats Directive from January 2001 to December 2006.: Joint Nature Conservation Committee, Peterborough.
61. Preston CD, Pearman DA, Dines TD (2002) New Atlas of the British and Irish Flora.: Oxford University Press. 910 p.
62. Goldsmith FB, editor (1991) Monitoring for conservation and ecology. London: Chapman and Hall. 275 p.
63. Czekanowski J (1909) Zur differential Diagnose der Neandertalgruppe. Korrespbl dt Ges Anthrop 40: 44-47.
64. Yoshioka PM (2008) Misidentification of the Bray-Curtis similarity index. Marine Ecology Progress Series 368: 309-310.
65. Tipping E, Henrys PA, Maskell LC, Smart SM (2013) Nitrogen deposition effects on plant species diversity: Threshold loads from field data. Environmental Pollution 179: 218-223. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol. 2013.04.008 PMID: 23688734
66. JNCC (2004) Common Standards Monitoring Guidance for Lowland Grassland. Version February 2004.
67. JNCC (2004) Common Standards Monitoring Guidance for Lowland Wetland Habitats. Version February 2004.: 61.
68. JNCC (2009) Common Standards Monitoring Guidance for Lowland Heathland. Version February 2009.: 47.
69. JNCC (2006) Common Standards Monitoring Guidance for Upland habitats. Version October 2006.
70. Stevens CJ, Dise NB, Gowing DJG, Mountford JO (2006) Loss of forb diversity in relation to nitrogen deposition in the UK: Regional trends and potential controls. Global Change Biology 12: 1823-1833.
71. Ellenberg H, Weber HE, Dull R, Wirth V, Werner W, Paulissen D (1992) Zeigerwerte von pflanzen in mitteleuropa: 2nd ed. Scripta Geobotanica 18: 1-258.
72. Hill MO, Preston CD, Roy DB (2004) PLANTATT: Attributes of British and Irish plants: Status, size, life history, geography and habitats.: Centre for Ecology and Hydrology. Available: Http://nora.nerc.ac.uk/9535/.
73. Hill MO, Preston CD, Bosanquet SDS, Roy DB (2007) BRYOATT-Attributes of British and Irish mosses, liverworts and hornworts with information on native status, size, life form, life history, geography and habitat.: Centre for Ecology and Hydrology. 88 p.
74. Hill MO, Carey PD (1997) Prediction of yield in the Rothamsted Park Grass Experiment by Ellenberg indicator values. Journal of Vegetation Science 8: 579-586.
75. Wagner M, Kahmen A, Schlumprecht H, Audorff V, Perner J, Buchmann N, et al. (2007) Prediction of herbage yield in grassland: How well do Ellenberg N-values perform? Applied Vegetation Science 10: 15-24.
76. van den Berg LJL, Jones L, Sheppard L, Smart SM, Bobbink R, Dise NB, et al. (in press) Evidence for differential effects of reduced and oxidised nitrogen deposition on vegetation independent of nitrogen load. Environmental Pollution.
77. Stanton JC, Semmens BX, McKann PC, Will T, Thogmartin WE (2016) Flexible risk metrics for identifying and monitoring conservation-priority species. Ecological Indicators 61: 683-692.
78. van Strien AJ, Soldaat LL, Gregory RD (2012) Desirable mathematical properties of indicators for biodiversity change. Ecological Indicators 14: 202-208.
79. Mascia MB, Brosius JP, Dobson TA, Forbes BC, Horowitz L, McKean MA, et al. (2003) Conservation and the social sciences. Conservation Biology 17: 649-650.
80. Bowers K, Boutin C (2008) Evaluating the relationship between floristic quality and measures of plant biodiversity along stream bank habitats. Ecological Indicators 8: 466-475.
81. Medeiros HR, Bochio GM, Ribeiro MC, Torezan JM, dos Anjos L (2015) Combining plant and bird data increases the accuracy of an Index of Biotic Integrity to assess conservation levels of tropical forest fragments. Journal for Nature Conservation 25: 1-7.
82. Wallis de Vries MF, Van Swaay CAM (2006) Global warming and excess nitrogen may induce butterfly decline by microclimatic cooling. Global Change Biology 12: 1620-1626.
83. Lewandowski AS, Noss RF, Parsons DR (2010) The Effectiveness of Surrogate Taxa for the Representation of Biodiversity. Conservation Biology 24: 1367-1377. doi: 10.1111/j.1523-1739.2010.01513.x PMID: 20455907
84. Fleishman E, Noss RF, Noon BR (2006) Utility and limitations of species richness metrics for conservation planning. Ecological Indicators 6: 543-553.
85. Tucker CM, Cadotte MW, Davies TJ, Rebelo TG (2012) Incorporating Geographical and Evolutionary Rarity into Conservation Prioritization. Conservation Biology 26: 593-601. doi: 10.1111/j.1523-1739. 2012.01845.x PMID: 22624595
86. Arponen A, Heikkinen RK, Thomas CD, Moilanen A (2005) The value of biodiversity in reserve selection: Representation, species weighting, and benefit functions. Conservation Biology 19: 2009-2014.
87. Landi S, Chiarucci A (2010) Is floristic quality assessment reliable in human-managed ecosystems? Systematics and Biodiversity 8: 269-280.
88. Carignan V, Villard MA (2002) Selecting indicator species to monitor ecological integrity: A review. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 78: 45-61. PMID: 12197640
89. Siddig AAH, Ellison AM, Ochs A, Villar-Leeman C, Lau MK (2016) How do ecologists select and use indicator species to monitor ecological change? Insights from 14 years of publication in Ecological Indicators. Ecological Indicators 60: 223-230.
90. Munoz JM, Alcantara J (2013) The value of indicator species for landscape characterization. Plant Biosystems 147: 418-428.
91. Hayes M, Boyle P, Moran J, Gormally M (2015) Assessing the biodiversity value of wet grasslands: Can selected plant and insect taxa be used as rapid indicators of species richness at a local scale? Biodiversity and Conservation 24: 2535-2549.
92. JNCC (2004) Common Standards Monitoring: Introduction to the guidance manual.
93. Trindade J, Loyola RD (2011) Performance and Consistency of Indicator Groups in Two Biodiversity Hotspots. PLoS ONE 6.
94. ICPMM (2014) Final Chair's report of 24th CCE Workshop and the 30th meeting of the Programme Task Force, 7th-10th April 2014 in Rome, Italy.: International Cooperative Programme on Modelling and Mapping of Critical Loads and Levels and Air Pollution Effects, Risks and Trends. Available: Http://wge-cce.org/Activities/Workshops/Past-workshops/Italy-2014. 40 p.
95. Rowe EC, Ford-Thompson A, Monteith D, van Hinsberg A, Smart S, Henrys P, et al. (2013) A biodiversity metric for interpreting outputs of models of atmospheric nitrogen pollution impacts on habitats.: Final report on Defra project AQ0828, "Research to define a biodiversity metric to inform the UK's response to the CCE 'Call for Data 2012-2014'. CEH project NEC04988. Centre for Ecology and Hydrology, ECW, Deiniol Road, Bangor, LL57 2UW, UK. Available: Https://uk-Air.defra.gov.uk/assets/documents/reports/cat10/1511251354-AQ0828-DivMet-Final-report-v1.1-22012014.pdf. 90 p.