Constructing an “Evil Genius”: News uses of mythic archetypes to make sense of bin Laden

Journalism Studies

Volumn 6, Issue 3, 2005, Pages 285-299

  Winch, Samuel P ^a  

^a PENNSYLVANIA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Archetype; Enemy Other; Evil Genius; Myth; Orientalism; Osama bin Laden; Rhetorical Analysis; Worthy Adversary

Indexed keywords

EID: 84983037927     PISSN: 1461670X     EISSN: 14699699     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/14616700500131851     Document Type: Article

References (78)

1. Aristotle (1971 [ca 330 bc]) Rhetoric, reprinted in:The Works of Aristotle, Volume II, Chicago:Encyclopaedia Britannica, Book I, Chap. 9, sec. 1368a.
2. Baldauf, Scott, and Bowers, Faye, (2001) “Origins of bin Laden Network”, Christian Science Monitor (Boston), 14 September, p. 6.
3. Balz, Dan, (2001) “Bush Warns of Casualties of War; President Says Bin Laden Is Wanted ‘Dead or Alive’”, Washington Post, 18 September, p. A1.
4. Barkin, Steve M., 1984. “The journalist as Storyteller:an interdisciplinary perspective”. American Journalism, 1 (2):27–33.
5. Bellamy, Christopher, (2001) “He May Look Medieval, but bin Laden Is a Modern Tactician of Rare Genius”, The Independent (London), 24 September, p. 4.
6. Bird, S. Elizabeth. 1990. “Storytelling on the Far Side:journalism and the weekly tabloid”. Critical Studies in Mass Communication, 7:380–5.
7. Bird, S. Elizabeth, and Dardenne, Robert W., 1988. “Myth, Chronicle, and Story:exploring the narrative qualities of news”. In Media, Myths, and Narratives, Edited by:Carey, James W., 67–86. Newbury Park:Sage.
8. Boxer, Sarah, (2001) “The Banality of Terror; Dreams of Holy War Over a Quiet Evening”, New York Times, 16 December, sec. 4, p. 1.
9. Brennan, Bonnie, and Duffy, Margaret. 2003. “‘If a Problem Cannot be Solved, Enlarge it’:an ideological critique of the ‘other’ in Pearl Harbor and September 11 New York Times coverage”. Journalism Studies, 4 (1):3–14.
10. Brill, Leslie, (2003) “Terrorism, Crowds and Power, and the Dogs of War”, Anthropological Quarterly 76 (1), Winter, p. 89.
11. Brown, Ben, (2001) “Grand Master of Evil Who Is Way Ahead of the Game”, Scotland on Sunday, 30 September, p. 12.
12. Brownstein, Bill, (2001) “Trying to Understand the Fanatic”, The Gazette (Montreal), 11 October, p. A4.
13. Burke, Jason, and Whitaker, Brian, (1999) “A Year of Living Dangerously:caveman terrorist spooks the West; Jason Burke in Islamabad and Brian Whitaker strip away the ‘James Bond’ hype heaped on Osama bin Laden”, The Observer (London), 3 January, p. 15.
14. Burke, Kenneth. 1969. A Grammar of Motives, Berkeley:University of California Press.
15. Burns, John F., (2001) “A Nation Challenged:the wanted man; Bin Laden taunts U.S. and praises hijackers”, New York Times, 8 October, p. A1.
16. Bush, George W., (2001) “Address by George W. Bush, President of the United States Delivered to the Nation, Washington, D.C., September 11, 2001”, reprinted in:Vital Speeches of the Day 67(24), 1 October, p. 738.
17. Canon, Scott, (2001) “In Use of ‘Evildoers,’ Bush Is Taking Page from Koran”, San Diego Union-Tribune, 14 October, p. A13.
18. Christensen, Peter. 2002. “The Political Appeal of Dr. Fu Manchu”. In The Devil Himself:villainy in detective fiction and film, Edited by:Gillis, Stacy, and Gates, Philippa. 79–89. Westport, CT:Greenwood Press.
19. Cole, Timothy M., (1996) “The Bush Administration's Foreign Policy”, Political Communication 13, January, pp. 93–113.
20. Cornwell, Tim, (2001) “Video Showed the Cunning of the Arch-enemy”, The Scotsman, 10 October, p. 5.
21. Crime in the United States:2000 uniform crime reports (2001) Washington, DC:Federal Bureau of Investigation.
22. Curtis, Adam, (2004) The Power of Nightmares, Part III:the shadows in the cave [television documentary], broadcast 3 November 2004 on channel BBC2 in the UK. Written and produced by Adam Curtis, transcription by Mike Conley from http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/video1040.htm, accessed 1 January 2005.
23. DeYoung, Karen, (2001) “Allies are Cautious on ‘Bush Doctrine’”, Washington Post, 16 October, p. A1.
24. Delacourt, Susan, (2001) “‘Scary’ Terrorist just a Vacuous Idiot”, Ottawa Citizen, 15 December, p. B6.
25. Dowd, Maureen, (2001) “Season of the witch”, New York Times, 14 October, sec. 4, p. 13.
26. Finn, Robin, (2001) “Like Nostradamus, but Carrying Anthrax Pills”, New York Times, 2 October, p. D2.
27. Ford, Peter, (2001) “Europe Cringes at Bush ‘Crusade’ Against Terrorists”, Christian Science Monitor (Boston), 19 September, p. 12.
28. Friedman, Thomas L., (2001) “World War III”, New York Times, 13 September, p. A27.
29. Galloway, George, (2001) “Against:military action will make matters worse”, The Scotsman, 15 September, p. 6.
30. Gans, Herbert. 1980. Deciding What's News, New York:Vintage Books.
31. Gerbner, George, Gross, Larry, and Signorielli, Nancy. 1986. “Living with Television:the dynamics of the cultivation process”. In Perspectives on Media Effects, Edited by:Bryant, Jennings, and Zillmann, Dolf. 17–40. Hillsdale, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
32. Gerstle, C. Andrew, and Milner, Anthony C., (Eds) (1994) Recovering the Orient:artists, scholars, appropriations, Amsterdam:Harwood Academic Publishers.
33. Gitlin, Todd. 1980. The Whole World Is Watching, Berkeley:University of California Press.
34. Glover, Ross. 2002. “The War on _____”. In Collateral Language:a user's guide to America's new war, Edited by:Collins, John, and Glover, Ross. 207–22. New York:New York University Press.
35. Guzy, M. W., (2002) “Upon review he's no Dr. No”, St. Louis Post Dispatch, 2 January, p. B7.
36. Hallin, Daniel C., 1987. “Hegemony:the American news media from Vietnam to El Salvador, a study of ideological change and its limits”. In Political Communication Research, 3–25. Norwood, NJ:Ablex.
37. Harle, Vilho. 2000. The Enemy with a Thousand Faces, Westport, CT:Praeger.
38. Hartley, John. 1982. Understanding News, London:Routledge.
39. Hasian, Marouf A., Jr. 2003. “The Past as Prologue:Osama bin Laden, the embassy bombings, and the ideological origins of America's ‘War on Terrorism’”. In Studies in Terrorism:media scholarship and the enigma of terror, Edited by:Chitty, Naren, Rush, Ramona R., and Semati, Mehdi. 121–7. Penang, Malaysia:Southbound.
40. Herman, Edward S., and Chomsky, Noam. 1988. Manufacturing Consent:the political economy of the mass media, New York:Pantheon.
41. Ivie, Robert, (1980) “Images of Savagery in American Justifications of War”, Communication Monographs 47, November, p. 289.
42. Jamieson, Kathleen Hall, and Waldman, Paula. 2003. The Press Effect, New York:Oxford University Press.
43. Keen, Sam. 1986. Faces of the Enemy, San Francisco:Harper & Row.
44. Lapham, Lewis. 2002. Theater of War, New York:New Press.
45. Lule, Jack. 2001. Daily News, Eternal Stories:the mythological role of journalism, New York:Guilford Press.
46. MacDougall, Robert, (1999) “Red, Brown and Yellow Perils:images of the American enemy in the 1940s and 1950s”, Journal of Popular Culture 32 (4), Spring, pp. 59–75.
47. Macintyre, Ben, (2001) “Betraying bin Laden”, The Times (London), 10 October, Features section.
48. Magnet, Julia, (2001) “His Grasp of Spin Is Chilling”, The Daily Telegraph (London), 16 November, p. 23.
49. Medhurst, Martin J., and Benson, Thomas W., (Eds) (1984) Rhetorical Dimensions in Media:a critical casebook, Dubuque, IA:Kendall/Hunt.
50. Mehnert, Ute, (1995) Deutschland, Amerika, und die “Gelbe Gefahr”:Zur Karriere eines Schlagworts in der Größen Politik, 1905–1917, Stuttgart:Franz Steiner [in German].
51. Miller, Judith, (2001) “Bin Laden's Media Savvy:expert timing of threats”, New York Times, 9 October, p. B6.
52. Molotch, Harvey, and Lester, Marilyn, (1974) “News as Purposive Behavior:on the strategic use of routine events, accidents, and scandals”, American Sociological Review 39, February, pp. 101–12.
53. Morris, Rosalind C., (2002) “Theses on the Questions of War:history, media, terror”, Social Text 20 (3), p. 152.
54. Nathanson, Charles E., 1988. “The Social Construction of the Soviet Threat:a study in the politics of representation”. Alternatives, XIII:443
55. Nelson, Jill, (1999) “Bombing Can Create Anti-U.S. Folk Heroes”, USA Today, 16 April, p. 15A.
56. Odone, Cristina, (2001) “It's Sheikh Guevara:Osama bin Laden is a master self-publicist and media manipulator”, The Observer (London), 7 October, p. 27.
57. Peters, Ralph, (1999) “Soldier vs. Warrior:the modern mismatch”, The Washington Post, 7 March, p. B01.
58. Reagan, Ronald, (1982) Speech to the House of Commons, London, 8 June.
59. Reese, Stephen D., 2001. “Prologue—Framing Public Life:a bridging model for media research”. In Framing Public Life:perspectives on media and our understanding of the social world, Edited by:Reese, Stephen D., Gandy, Oscar H., and Grant, August E., 7–31. Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum.
60. Reeves, Phil, (2001) “Egypt, the Breeding Ground for Islamic Terrorism”, The Independent, 12 October, p. 3.
61. Reid, Melanie, (2001) “We Must Dismantle the Mythic Cult of bin Laden”, The Herald (Glasgow), 9 October, p. 18.
62. Rohmer, Sax [Arthur Sarsfield Ward]. 2001 [1913]. The Insidious Dr. Fu Manchu, Lincoln, NE:New Millenium Library.
63. Ruth, David E., 1996. Inventing the Public Enemy:the gangster in American culture, 1918–1934, Chicago:University of Chicago Press.
64. Said, Edward W., 1978. Orientalism, New York:Pantheon Books.
65. San Francisco Chronicle (2001) “Bin Laden's Evil Genius” [editorial], 10 October, p. A18.
66. Semati, M. Mehdi. 2001. “Sex, Violence, and Terrorism in Hollywood's International Political Imagery”. In Media, Sex, Violence, and Drugs in the Global Village, Edited by:Kamalipour, Yahya R., and Rampal, Kuldip R., 235–60. Lanham, MD:Rowman & Littlefield.
67. Sennott, Charles M., (2001) “Bin Laden at Top of Suspects List”, Boston Globe (Extra Edition), 11 September, p. A1.
68. Shibutani, Tamotsu. 1970. “On the Personification of Adversaries”. In Human Nature and Collective Behavior, Edited by:Shibutani, Tamotsu. 223–33. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice Hall.
69. Smith, Bill, (2001) “Americans Don't Have to Look Far for Their Villain”, St. Louis Post-Dispatch, 14 October, p. B5.
70. Sullivan, Andrew, (2001) “The Way We Live Now:12-9-01; High impact”, New York Times, 9 December, sec. 6, p. 25.
71. Tuchman, Gaye. 1978. Making News, New York:The Free Press.
72. Tuman, Joseph S., 2003. Communicating Terror:the rhetorical dimensions of terrorism, Thousand Oaks, CA:Sage.
73. Van Ash, Cay, and Rohmer, Elizabeth Sax. 1972. Master of Villainy, Bowling Green, OH:Bowling Green University Popular Press.
74. Wander, Philip. 1984. “The Rhetoric of American Foreign Policy”. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 70:339–61.
75. Weiner, Tim, (1999) “U.S. Hard Put to Find Proof Bin Laden Directed Attacks”, New York Times, 13 April, p. A1.
76. Wilcox, Philip C., Jr. 2002. “United States”. In Combating Terrorism:strategies of ten countries, Edited by:Alexander, Yonah. 29–65. Ann Arbor:University of Michigan Press.
77. Winch, Samuel P., 1997. Mapping the Cultural Space of Journalism, Westport, CT:Praeger.
78. Winfield, Betty Houchin, Friedman, Barbara, and Trisnadi, Vivara. 2002. “History as the Metaphor Through Which the Current World Is Viewed:British and American newspapers’ uses of history following the 11 September 2001 terrorist attacks”. Journalism Studies, 3 (2):289–300.