Developmental Outcomes of Foster Children: A Meta-Analytic Comparison With Children From the General Population and Children at Risk Who Remained at Home

Child Maltreatment

Volumn 21, Issue 3, 2016, Pages 198-217

  Goemans, Anouk ^a   van Geel, Mitch ^a   van Beem, Merel ^a   Vedder, Paul ^a  

^a LEIDEN UNIVERSITY   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

child development; child welfare; comparison; foster care; meta analysis

Indexed keywords

CHILD; CHILD DEVELOPMENT; CHILD WELFARE; CONTROLLED STUDY; FOSTER CARE; HUMAN; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS; POPULATION; PSYCINFO; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; ADOLESCENT; CHILD ABUSE; COMPARATIVE STUDY; FOSTER CHILD; INFANT; NEWBORN; PRESCHOOL CHILD; PSYCHOLOGY; UNITED STATES;

ADOLESCENT; CHILD; CHILD ABUSE; CHILD, FOSTER; CHILD, PRESCHOOL; FOSTER HOME CARE; HUMANS; INFANT; INFANT, NEWBORN; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84982883539     PISSN: 10775595     EISSN: 15526119     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/1077559516657637     Document Type: Review

References (109)

1. H.S.*BadaJ.LangerJ.TwomeyC.BursiL.LagasseC.R.Bauer…P.L.Maza (2008). Importance of stability in early living arrangements on behavior outcomes of children with and without prenatal drug exposure. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, 29, 173–182.
2. R.P.BarthA.Price (1999). Shared family care: Providing services to parents and children placed together in out-of-home care. Child Welfare, 78, 88–107.
3. S.G.*Beatty (1995). Levels of emotional adjustment in children in foster care. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 57, 1–110.
4. M.I.BenedictS.ZuravinM.SomerfieldD.Brandt (1996). The reported health and functioning of children maltreated while in family foster care. Child Abuse & Neglect, 20, 561–571.
5. I.M.*BernedoM.D.SalasM.A.García-MartínM.J.Fuentes (2011). Teacher assessment of behavior problems in foster care children. Children and Youth Services Review, 34, 615–621.
6. N.Biehal (2007). Reuniting children with their families: Reconsidering the evidence on timing, contact and outcomes. British Journal of Social Work, 37, 807–823.
7. I.L.BongersH.M.KootJ.Van der EndeF.C.Verhulst (2003). The normative development of child and adolescent problem behavior. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 112, 179–192.
8. M.BorensteinL.HedgesJ.HigginsH.Rothstein (2005). Comprehensive meta-analysis (Version 2) [Computer software]. Englewood, NJ: Biostat.
9. M.BorensteinL.V.HedgesJ.P.HigginsH.R.Rothstein (2009). Introduction to meta-analysis. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley.
10. R.H.BradleyR.F.Corwyn (2002). Socioeconomic status and child development. Annual Review of Psychology, 53, 371–399.
11. P.A.BritnerD.G.Mossler (2002). Professionals’ decision-making about out-of-home placements following instances of child abuse. Child Abuse & Neglect, 26, 317–332.
12. J.*BruceP.A.FisherA.M.GrahamW.E.MooreS.J.PeakeA.M.Mannering (2013). Patterns of brain activation in foster children and nonmaltreated children during an inhibitory control task. Development and Psychopathology, 25, 931–941.
13. B.J.*BurnsS.D.PhillipsH.R.WagnerR.P.BarthD.J.KolkoY.CampbellJ.Landsverk (2004). Mental health need and access to mental health services by youths involved with child welfare: A national survey. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 43, 960–970.
14. K.A.CampbellA.M.ThomasL.J.CookH.T.Keenan (2012). Longitudinal experiences of children remaining at home after a first-time investigation for suspected maltreatment. The Journal of Pediatrics, 161, 340–347.
15. J.A.*CarboneM.G.SawyerA.K.SearleP.J.Robinson (2007). The health-related quality of life of children and adolescents in home-based foster care. Quality of Life Research: An International Journal of Quality of Life Aspects of Treatment, Care and Rehabilitation, 16, 1157–1166.
16. C.Cederna-MekoS.M.KochJ.R.Wall (2013). Youth with oppositional defiant disorder at entry into home-based treatment, foster care, and residential treatment. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 23, 895–906.
17. M.F.ChambersA.M.SaundersB.D.NewC.L.WilliamsA.Stachurska (2010). Assessment of children coming into care: Processes, pitfalls and partnerships. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 15, 511–527.
18. M.*ColtonA.HeathJ.Aldgate (1995). School attainment and behaviour of foster children: A longitudinal study. In (Eds.), The art and science of childcare (pp.67–83). Aldershot, England: Arena.
19. H.CooperL.V.HedgesJ.C.Valentine (2009). The handbook of research synthesis and meta-analysis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
20. P.A.CurtisG.AlexanderL.A.Lunghofer (2001). A literature review comparing the outcomes of residential group care and therapeutic foster care. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 18, 377–392.
21. M.*DamnjanoviçA.LakiçD.StevanoviçA.JovanoviçJ.JanciçM.JovanoviçL.Leposaviç (2012). Self-assessment of the quality of life of children and adolescents in the child welfare system of Serbia. Vojnosanitetski Pregled. Military-medical and Pharmaceutical Review, 69, 469–474.
22. B.K.*Davis (2000). Source monitoring and frontal lobe functioning among conduct disordered and non-conduct disordered youths. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 61, 1–56.
23. A.S.DetskyC.D.NaylorK.O’RourkeA.J.McGeerK.A.L’Abbé (1992). Incorporating variations in the quality of individual randomized trials into meta-analysis. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 45, 255–265.
24. M.DozierK.AlbusP.A.FisherS.Sepulveda (2002). Interventions for foster parents: Implications for developmental theory. Development and Psychopathology, 14, 843–860.
25. M.DozierJ.KaufmanR.KobakT.G.O’ConnorA.Sagi-SchwartzS.Scott…C.H.Zeanah (2014). Consensus statement on group care for children and adolescents: A statement of policy of the American Orthopsychiatric Association. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 84, 219–225.
26. S.DuvalR.Tweedie (2000). Trim and fill: A simple funnel-plot-based method of testing and adjusting for publication bias in meta-analysis. Biometrics, 56, 455–463.
27. M.EggerG.D.SmithA.N.Phillips (1997). Meta-analysis: Principles and procedures. BMJ, 315, 1533–1537.
28. E.M.Z.FarmerB.J.BurnsM.V.ChapmanS.D.PhillipsA.AngoldE.J.Costello (2001). Use of mental health services by youth in contact with social services. Social Service Review, 75, 605–624.
29. E.*Fernandez (2008). Unravelling emotional, behavioural and educational outcomes in a longitudinal study of children in foster-care. British Journal of Social Work, 38, 1283–1301.
30. P.A.FisherB.BurrastonK.Pears (2005). The early intervention foster care program: Permanent placement outcomes from a randomized trial. Child Maltreatment, 10, 61–71.
31. P.A.FisherP.ChamberlainL.D.Leve (2009). Improving the lives of foster children through evidenced-based interventions. Vulnerable Children and Youth Studies, 4, 122–127.
32. G.Frank (1980). Treatment needs of children in foster care. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 50, 256–263.
33. M.M.GarwoodW.Close (2001). Identifying the psychological needs of foster children. Child Psychiatry and Human Development, 32, 125–135.
34. N.GilbertN.PartonM.Skivenes (2011). Child protection systems: International trends and orientations. New York: Oxford University Press.
35. A.GoemansM.Van GeelP.Vedder (2015). Over three decades of longitudinal research on the development of foster children: A meta-analysis. Child Abuse & Neglect, 42, 121–134.
36. B.J.Harden (2004). Safety and stability for foster children: A developmental perspective. The Future of Children, 14, 31–47.
37. J.S.HarmanG.E.ChildsK.J.Kelleher (2000). Mental health care utilization and expenditures by children in foster care. Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, 154, 1114–1117.
38. C.A.*HeflingerC.G.SimpkinsT.Combs-Orme (2000). Using the CBCL to determine the clinical status of children in state custody. Children and Youth Services Review, 22, 55–73.
39. J.J.HudziakW.CopelandC.StangerM.Wadsworth (2004). Screening for DSM-IV externalizing disorders with the Child Behavior Checklist: A receiver−operating characteristic analysis. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 45, 1299–1307.
40. T.B.Huedo-MedinaJ.Sánchez-MecaF.Marin-MartinezJ.Botella (2006). Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I index?Psychological Methods, 11, 193–206.
41. T.C.*HulseyR.White (1989). Family characteristics and measures of behavior in foster and nonfoster children. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 59, 502–509.
42. M.S.HurlburtL.K.LeslieJ.LandsverkR.P.BarthB.J.BurnsR.D.Gibbons…J.Zhang (2004). Contextual predictors of mental health service use among children open to child welfare. Archives of General Psychiatry, 61, 1217–1224.
43. H.*JacobsenV.MoeT.IvarssonT.Wentzel-LarsenL.Smith (2013). Cognitive development and social-emotional functioning in young foster children: A follow-up study from 2 to 3 years of age. Child Psychiatry and Human Development, 44, 666–677.
44. A.*JanssensD.Deboutte (2010). Psychopathology among children and adolescents in child welfare: A comparison across different types of placement in Flanders, Belgium. Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 64, 353–359.
45. S.H.JeeM.SzilagyiA.M.ConnW.NilsenS.TothC.D.BaldwinP.G.Szilagyi (2011). Validating office-based screening for psychosocial strengths and difficulties among youths in foster care. Pediatrics, 127, 904–910.
46. S.H.JeeM.SzilagyiC.OvenshireA.NortonA.M.ConnA.BlumkinP.G.Szilagyi (2010). Improved detection of developmental delays among young children in foster care. Pediatrics, 125, 282–289.
47. M.S.JellinekM.LittleK.BenedictJ.M.MurphyM.PaganoF.PoitrastD.Quinn (1995). Placement outcomes of 206 severely maltreated children in the Boston Juvenile Court system: A 7.5-year follow-up study. Child Abuse & Neglect, 19, 1051–1064.
48. L.Jones (1993). Decision making in child welfare: A critical review of the literature. Child and Adolescent Social Work Journal, 10, 241–262.
49. D.E.JohnsonD.GuthrieA.T.SmykeS.F.KogaN.A.FoxC.H.ZeanahC.A.Nelson (2010). Growth and associations between auxology, caregiving environment, and cognition in socially deprived Romanian children randomized to foster vs ongoing institutional care. Archives of pediatrics & adolescent medicine, 164, 507–516.
50. M.Jonson-ReidB.Drake (2016). Child well-being: Where is it in our data systems?Journal of Public Child Welfare, 1–14. doi:10.1080/15548732.2016.1155524
51. M.A.JosephT.G.O’ConnorJ.A.BriskmanB.MaughanS.Scott (2014). The formation of secure new attachments by children who were maltreated: An observational study of adolescents in foster care. Development and Psychopathology, 26, 67–80.
52. E.M.Kinard (1982). Experiencing child abuse: Effects on emotional adjustment. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 52, 82–91.
53. D.J.KolkoA.E.Kazdin (1993). Emotional/behavioral problems in clinic and nonclinic children: Correspondence among child, parent and teacher reports. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 34, 991–1006.
54. P.LanierP.L.KohlR.RaghavanW.Auslander (2014). A preliminary examination of child well-being of physically abused and neglected children compared to a normative pediatric population. Child Maltreatment. doi:10.1177/1077559514557517
55. C.R.LawrenceE.A.CarlsonB.Egeland (2006). The impact of foster care on development. Development and Psychopathology, 18, 57–76.
56. S.LehmannO.E.HavikT.HavikE.R.Heiervang (2013). Mental disorders in foster children: a study of prevalence, comorbidity and risk factors. Child and Adolescent Psychiatry and Mental Health, 7, 1–12.
57. M.*LeiferJ.P.Shapiro (1995). Longitudinal study of the psychological effects of sexual abuse in African American girls in foster care and those who remain home. Journal of Child Sexual Abuse: Research, Treatment, & Program Innovations for Victims, Survivors, & Offenders, 4, 27–44.
58. L.K.LeslieJ.N.GordonW.GangerK.Gist (2002). Developmental delay in young children in child welfare by initial placement type. Infant Mental Health Journal, 23, 496–516.
59. L.K.LeslieJ.N.GordonK.LambrosK.PremjiJ.PeoplesK.Gist (2005). Addressing the developmental and mental health needs of young children in foster care. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, 26, 140–151.
60. L.K.LeslieJ.N.GordonL.MenekenK.PremjiK.L.MichelmoreW.Ganger (2005). The physical, developmental, and mental health needs of young children in child welfare by initial placement type. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, 26, 177–185.
61. D.Lindsey (1992). Reliability of the foster care placement decision: A review. Research on Social Work Practice, 2, 65–80.
62. E.C.LloydR.P.Barth (2011). Developmental outcomes after five years for foster children returned home, remaining in care, or adopted. Children and Youth Services Review, 33, 1383–1391.
63. H.*Maroufi (2003). The development of prenatally drug-exposed children: A comparison between those living with their mothers and those placed in foster care. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 64, 1–128.
64. C.*McAuley (1996). Children in long term foster care: Emotional and social development. Vermont: Ashgate.
65. H.MeltzerR.GatwardT.CorbinR.GoodmanT.Ford (2003). The mental health of young people looked after by local authorities in England. London, England: Office for National Statistics.
66. F.E.*MennenM.BrensilverP.K.Trickett (2010). Do maltreated children who remain at home function better than those who are placed?Children and Youth Services Review, 32, 1675–1682.
67. M.O.*MinS.MinnesS.YoonE.J.ShortL.T.Singer (2014). Self-reported adolescent behavioral adjustment: Effects of prenatal cocaine exposure. The Journal of Adolescent Health: Official Publication of the Society for Adolescent Medicine, 55, 167–174.
68. B.Minty (1999). Annotation: Outcomes in long-term foster family care. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 40, 991–999.
69. P.Moayyedi (2004). Meta-analysis: Can we mix apples and oranges?The American Journal of Gastroenterology, 99, 2297–2301.
70. D.MoherA.LiberatiJ.TetzlaffD.G.Altman (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Annals of Internal Medicine, 151, 264–269.
71. D.S.MooreG.P.McCabe (2006). Introduction to the practice of statistics. 5th ed. New York: W.H. Freeman.
72. B.Mullen (2013). Advanced Basic Meta-analysis: Version 1.10. Hillsdale, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
73. J.M.MurphyS.J.BishopM.S.JellinekS.D.QuinnJ.F.Poitrast (1992). What happens after the care and protection petition? Reabuse in a court sample. Child Abuse & Neglect, 16, 485–493.
74. R.R.NewtonA.J.LitrownikJ.A.Landsverk (2000). Children and youth in foster care: Disentangling the relationship between problem behaviors and number of placements. Child Abuse & Neglect, 24, 1363–1374.
75. R.OsmoR.Benbenishty (2004). Children at risk: Rationales for risk assessments and interventions. Children and Youth Services Review, 26, 1155–1173.
76. K.*PearsP.A.Fisher (2005). Developmental, cognitive, and neuropsychological functioning in preschool-aged foster children: Associations with prior maltreatment and placement history. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 26, 112–122.
77. K.J.PottickL.A.WarnerK.A.Yoder (2005). Youths living away from families in the US mental health system. The Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 32, 264–281.
78. J.M.PriceP.ChamberlainJ.LandsverkJ.B.ReidL.D.LeveH.Laurent (2008). Effects of a foster parent training intervention on placement changes of children in foster care. Child Maltreatment, 13, 64–75.
79. H.RingeisenC.CasanuevaT.P.CrossM.Urato (2009). Mental health and special education services at school entry for children who were involved with the child welfare system as infants. Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 17, 177–192.
80. L.Roberts (2015). Using part-time fostering as a family support service: Advantages, challenges and contradictions. British Journal of Social Work. doi:10.1093/bjsw/bcv075
81. K.E.*Rork (2007). An examination of parenting strategies, attitudes, and stress in foster and biological parents of young children. Morgantown, West Virginia: West Virginia University.
82. H.R.RothsteinA.J.SuttonM.Borenstein (2006). Publication bias in meta-analysis: Prevention, assessment and adjustments. Chichester, West Sussex: John Wiley & Sons.
83. P.*RoyM.RutterA.Pickles (2000). Institutional care: risk from family background or pattern of rearing?Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 41, 139–149.
84. D.K.RunyanC.L.Gould (1985). Foster care for child maltreatment: Impact on delinquent behavior. Pediatrics, 75, 562–568.
85. J.RussellS.Macgill (2015). Demographics, policy, and foster care rates; a predictive analytics approach. Children and Youth Services Review, 58, 118–126.
86. S.*SaloK.KivistoR.KorjaZ.BiringenS.TupolaH.KahilaS.Kivitie-Kallio (2009). Emotional availability, parental self-efficacy beliefs, and child development in caregiver-child relationships with buprenorphine-exposed 3-year-olds. Parenting: Science and Practice, 9, 244–259.
87. S.SandersonI.D.TattJ.P.Higgins (2007). Tools for assessing quality and susceptibility to bias in observational studies in epidemiology: A systematic review and annotated bibliography. International Journal of Epidemiology, 36, 666–676.
88. T.G.Scherr (2007). Educational experiences of children in foster care. Meta-analyses of special education, retention and discipline rates. School Psychology International, 28, 419–436.
89. R.*Schiefer (1994). A comparison of foster children, the biological children of foster parents and children from non-foster homes with respect to: Behavior, self-esteem, attachment, coping, and family perceptions. Buffalo: University of New York.
90. E.M.Scholte (1997). Exploration of criteria for residential and foster care. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 38, 657–666.
91. B.J.SheaC.HamelG.A.WellsL.M.BouterE.KristjanssonJ.Grimshaw…M.Boers (2009). AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews. Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, 62, 1013–1020.
92. L.T.*Shepherd (2009). Does hope moderate the relationship between attachment and behavioral outcomes in foster children?Seattle, WA: Seattle Pacific University.
93. A.Stang (2010). Critical evaluation of the Newcastle-Ottawa scale for the assessment of the quality of nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses. European journal of epidemiology, 25, 603–605.
94. J.StrijkerS.Van OijenJ.Knot-Dickscheit (2011). Assessment of problem behaviour by foster parents and their foster children. Child & Family Social Work, 16, 93–100.
95. M.Tarren-Sweeney (2007). The Assessment Checklist for Children—ACC: A behavioral rating scale for children in foster, kinship and residential care. Children and Youth Services Review, 29, 672–691.
96. J.R.*TininenkoP.A.FisherJ.BruceK.C.Pears (2010). Associations between sleep and inattentive/hyperactive problem behavior among foster and community children. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics, 31, 668–674.
97. B.*TizardJ.Hodges (1978). The effect of early institutional rearing on the development of eight year old children. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 19, 99–118.
98. United Nations General Assembly. (1989). Convention on the rights of the child, United Nations, treaty series (vol. 1577, p.3). Retrieved fromhttp://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b38f0.html
99. S.*ÜstünerN.ErolZ.Simsek (2005). Koruyucu aile bakimi altindaki çocuklarin davranis ve duygusal sorunlari. Coçuk ve Gençlik Ruh Sagligi Dergisi, 12, 130–140.
100. E.Van Santen (2010). Predictors of exit type and length of stay in non-kinship family foster care - The German experience. Children and Youth Services Review, 32, 1211–1222.
101. A.*VictorJ.R.WozniakP.N.Chang (2008). Environmental correlates of cognition and behavior in children with fetal alcohol spectrum disorders. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment, 18, 288–300.
102. M.S.*WaldJ.M.CarlsmithP.H.Leiderman (1988). Protecting abused and neglected children. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
103. T.A.Washington (2004). The combined effects of maltreatment and subsequent foster care placement in early childhood. Dissertation Abstracts International: Section B: The Sciences and Engineering, 65, 1–124.
104. G.A.WellsB.SheaD.O’ConnellJ.E.A.PetersonV.WelchM.LososP.Tugwell (2000). The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality of nonrandomised studies in meta-analyses. Retrieved fromhttp://www.medicine.mcgill.ca/rtamblyn/Readings/The%20Newcastle%20-%20Scale%20for%20assessing%20the%20quality%20of%20nonrandomised%20studies%20in%20meta-analyses.pdf
105. K.WhettenJ.OstermannB.W.PenceR.A.WhettenL.C.MesserS.Ariely…D.Itemba (2014). Three-year change in the wellbeing of orphaned and separated children in institutional and family-based care settings in five low-and middle-income countries. PLoS One, 9, 1–10.
106. M.WinokurA.HoltanK.E.Batchelder (2014). Kinship care for the safety, permanency, and well-being of maltreated children. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2014, Issue 1. Art. No.: CD006546. DOI: 10. 1002/14651858. CD006546. pub3.
107. F.Wulczyn (2004). Family reunification. Children, Families, and Foster Care, 14, 95–113.
108. X.ZengY.ZhangJ.S.KwongC.ZhangS.LiF.Sun…L.Du (2015). The methodological quality assessment tools for preclinical and clinical studies, systematic review and meta-analysis, and clinical practice guideline: A systematic review. Journal of Evidence-Based Medicine, 8, 2–10.
109. S.J.ZuravinJ.G.OrmeR.L.Hegar (1995). Disposition of child physical abuse reports: Review of the literature and test of a predictive model. Children and Youth Services Review, 17, 547–566.