Multi-modal demands of a smartphone used to place calls and enter addresses during highway driving relative to two embedded systems

Ergonomics

Volumn 59, Issue 12, 2016, Pages 1565-1585

  Reimer, Bryan ^a   Mehler, Bruce ^a   Reagan, Ian ^b   Kidd, David ^b   Dobres, Jonathan ^a  

^a MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

^b Insurance Institute for Highway Safety ^*  (United States)

Author keywords

distraction; human machine interface; visual demand; Voice interface; workload

Indexed keywords

AUTOMOBILE DRIVERS; ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL EFFECTS; OFF ROAD VEHICLES; ROADS AND STREETS; SIGNAL ENCODING; SMARTPHONES; SYSTEMS ANALYSIS; TRANSPORTATION;

DISTRACTION; HUMAN MACHINE INTERFACE; VISUAL DEMAND; VOICE INTERFACES; WORKLOAD;

EMBEDDED SYSTEMS;

DRIVER; ERROR; EYE; HIGHWAY; HUMAN; MACHINE; PHYSICIAN; SMARTPHONE; VOICE; WORKLOAD; ADULT; AGED; ATTENTION; CAR DRIVING; COMPUTER INTERFACE; FEMALE; GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEM; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; TASK PERFORMANCE; YOUNG ADULT;

ADULT; AGED; ATTENTION; AUTOMOBILE DRIVING; FEMALE; GEOGRAPHIC INFORMATION SYSTEMS; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; SMARTPHONE; TASK PERFORMANCE AND ANALYSIS; USER-COMPUTER INTERFACE; VOICE; WORKLOAD; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84966642032     PISSN: 00140139     EISSN: 13665847     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/00140139.2016.1154189     Document Type: Article

References (61)

1. Angell, L., J., Auflick, P. A., Austria, D., Kochhar, L., Tijerina, W., Biever, T. Diptiman, J. Hogsett, and S. Kiger. 2006. Driver Workload Metrics Task 2 Final Report. Washington, DC:U.S. Department of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.10.1037/e729342011-001
2. Atchley, P., and M., Chan. 2011. “Potential Benefits and Costs of Concurrent Task Engagement to Maintain Vigilance:A Driving Simulator Investigation.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 53 (1):3–12.10.1177/0018720810391215
3. Beckers, N., S., Schreiner, P., Bertrand, B., Reimer, B., Mehler, D., Munger, and J. Dobres. 2014. “Comparing the Demands of Destination Entry Using Google Glass and the Samsung Galaxy S4.” Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Chicago, IL, 2156–2160.
4. Brookhuis, K. A., and D., de Waard. 2001. “Assessment of Drivers’ Workload:Performance and Subjective and Physiological Indexes.” In Stress, Workload, and Fatigue, edited by P. A., Hancock and P. A., Desmond, 321–333. Mahwah, NJ:Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
5. Caird, J. K., C. R., Willness, P., Steel, and C., Scialfa. 2008. “A Meta-analysis of the Effects of Cell Phones on Driver Performance.” Accident Analysis & Prevention 40 (4):1282–1293.
6. Chiang, D. P., A. M., Brooks, and D. H., Weir. 2005. Comparison of Visual-Manual and Voice Interaction with Contemporary Navigation System HMIs. SAE 2005 World Congress & Exhibition. Warrendale, PA:SAE International SAE Technical Paper 2005-01-0433.
7. Collet, C., A., Guillot, and C., Petit. 2010. “Phoning While Driving II:A Review of Driving Conditions Influence.” Ergonomics 53 (5):602–616.10.1080/00140131003769092
8. Collet, C., E., Salvia, and C., Petit-Boulanger. 2014. “Measuring Workload with Electrodermal Activity during Common Braking Actions.” Ergonomics 57 (6):886–896.10.1080/00140139.2014.899627
9. Conover, W. J., and R. L., Iman. 1981. “Rank Transformations as a Bridge between Parametric and Nonparametric Statistics.” American Statistician 35 (3):124–129.
10. Cooper, J. M., H., Ingebretsen, and D. L., Strayer. 2014. Title Mental Workload of Common Voice-based Vehicle Interactions across Six Different Vehicle Systems. Washington, DC:AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.
11. Dingus, T. A., S. G., Klauer, V. L., Neale, A., Petersen, S. E., Lee, J. D. Sudweeks, M. A. Perez, J. Hankey, D. J.Ramsey, S. Gupta, C. Bucher, Z.R. Doerzaph, J. Jermeland, and R.R. Knipling. (2006). The 100-Car Naturalistic Driving Study, Phase II–Results of the 100-Car Field Experiment:U.S. Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
12. Driver Focus-Telematics Working Group. 2006. Statement of Principles, Criteria and Verification Procedures on Driver Interactions with Advanced in-Vehicle Information and Communication Systems, Version 2.0:Alliance of Automotive Manufacturers.
13. Farmer, C. M., S. G., Klauer, J. A., McClafferty, and F., Guo. 2014. Relationship of near-Crash/Crash Risk to Time Spent on a Cell Phone While Driving. Arlington, VA:Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.
14. Fitch, G. A., S. A., Soccolich, F., Guo, J., McClafferty, Y., Fang, R. L., Olson, M. A., Perez, R. J. Hanowski, J. M. Hankey, and T. A. Dingus. 2013. The Impact of Hand-Held and Hands-Free Cell Phone Use on Driving Performance and Safety-Critical Event Risk (Report No. DOT HS 811 757). Washington, DC:National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
15. Friedman, M., 1937. “The Use of Ranks to Avoid the Assumption of Normality Implicit in the Analysis of Variance.” Journal of the American Statistical Association 32 (200):675–701.10.1080/01621459.1937.10503522
16. Gershon, P., D., Shinar, T., Oron-Gilad, Y., Parmet, and A., Ronen. 2011. “Usage and Perceived Effectiveness of Fatigue Countermeasures for Professional and Nonprofessional Drivers.” Accident Analysis & Prevention 43 (3):797–803.
17. Hart, S. G., 2006. “Nasa-Task Load Index (NASA-TLX); 20 Years Later.” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, 904–908.10.1177/154193120605000909
18. Horrey, W. J., and C. D., Wickens. 2006. “Examining the Impact of Cell Phone Conversations on Driving Using Meta-analytic Techniques.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 48 (1):196–205.10.1518/001872006776412135
19. ISO 15007-1. 2002. Road Vehicles–Measurement of Driver Visual Behaviour with Respect to Transport Information and Control Systems–Part 1:Definitions and Parameters. Geneva:International Standards Organization.
20. ISO 15007-2. 2001. Road Vehicles–Measurement of Driver Visual Behaviour with Respect to Transport Information and Control Systems–Part 2:Equipment and Procedures. Geneva:International Standards Organization.
21. Klauer, S. G., T. A., Dingus, V. L., Neale, J. D., Sudweeks, and D. J., Ramsey. 2006. The Impact of Driver Inattention on near-Crash/Crash Risk:An Analysis Using the 100-Car Naturalistic Driving Study Data (Report No. DOT HS 810 594). Washington, DC:United States Department of Transportation, National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.
22. Klauer, S. G., F., Guo, B. G., Simons-Morton, M. C., Ouimet, S. E., Lee, and T. A., Dingus. 2014. “Distracted Driving and Risk of Road Crashes among Novice and Experienced Drivers.” New England Journal of Medicine 370 (1):54–59.10.1056/NEJMsa1204142
23. Mccartt, A. T., L. A., Hellinga, and K. A., Bratiman. 2006. “Cell Phones and Driving:Review of Research.” Traffic Injury Prevention 7 (2):89–106.10.1080/15389580600651103
24. McCartt, A. T., D. G., Kidd, and E. R., Teoh. 2014. “Driver Cellphone and Texting Bans in the United States:Evidence of Effectiveness.” Annals of Advances in Automotive Medicine 58:99–114.
25. McKnight, A. J., and A. S., McKnight. 1993. “The Effect of Cellular Phone Use upon Driver Attention.” Accident Analysis and Prevention 25 (3):259–265.10.1016/0001-4575(93)90020-W
26. McWilliams, T., B., Reimer, B., Mehler, J., Dobres, and H., McAnulty. 2015. “Secondary Assessment of the Impact of Voice Interface Turn Delays on Driver Attention and Arousal in Field Conditions:A Consideration of 4 Vehicle Systems and a Smartphone.” Proceedings of the 8th International Driving Symposium on Human Factors in Driver Assessment, Training, and Vehicle Design, Snowbird, UT, 414–420.
27. Mehler, B., D., Kidd, B., Reimer, I., Reagan, J., Dobres, and A., McCartt. 2015. “Multi-Modal Assessment of on-Road Demand of Voice and Manual Phone Calling and Voice Navigation Entry across Two Embedded Vehicle Systems.” Ergonomics. doi:10.1080/00140139.2015.1081412.
28. Mehler, B., B., Reimer, and J. F., Coughlin. 2012. “Sensitivity of Physiological Measures for Detecting Systematic Variations in Cognitive Demand from a Working Memory Task:An on-Road Study across Three Age Groups.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 54 (3):396–412. doi:10.1177/0018720812442086.
29. Mehler, B., B., Reimer, J. F., Coughlin, and J. A., Dusek. 2009. “The Impact of Incremental Increases in Cognitive Workload on Physiological Arousal and Performance in Young Adult Drivers.” Proceedings of the Transportation Research Board of The National Academies, Washington, DC.
30. Mehler, B., B., Reimer, J., Dobres, H., McAnulty, A., Mehler, D., Munger, et al. 2014. Further Evaluation of the Effects of a Production Level “Voice-Command” Interface on Driver Behavior:Replication and a Consideration of the Significance of Training Method (Technical Report 2014-2). Cambridge, MA:MIT AgeLab.
31. Munger, D., B., Mehler, B., Reimer, J., Dobres, A., Pettinato, B., Pugh, et al. 2014. “A Simulation Study Examining Smartphone Destination Entry While Driving.” Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Automotive User Interfaces and Interactive Vehicle Applications, Seattle,WA.10.1145/2667317
32. Muñoz, M., B., Reimer, and B., Mehler. 2015. “Exploring New Qualitative Methods to Support a Quantitative Analysis of Glance Behavior.” Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on Automotive User Interfaces and Interactive Vehicle Applications (AutomotiveUI ‘15), Nottingham, UK.
33. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. 2013. Visual-Manual NHTSA Driver Distraction Guidelines for in-Vehicle Electronic Devices (Docket No. NHTSA-2010-0053). Washington, DC:U.S. Department of Transportation National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).
34. Nurullah, A. S., J., Thomas, and F., Vakilian. 2013. “The Prevalence of Cell Phone Use While Driving in a Canadian Province.” Transportation Research Part F:Traffic Psychology and Behaviour 19:52–62.10.1016/j.trf.2013.03.006
35. Owens, J. M., McLaughlin, S. B., and Sudweeks, J., (2010). “On-Road Comparison of Driving Performance Measures When Using Handheld and Voice-Control Interfaces for Mobile Phones and Portable Music Players.” SAE International Journal of Passenger Cars–Mechanical Systems 3 (1):734–743.10.4271/2010-01-1036
36. Owens, J. M., S. B., McLaughlin, and J., Sudweeks. 2011. “Driver Performance While Text Messaging Using Handheld and in-Vehicle Systems.” Accident Analysis & Prevention 43 (3):939–947.
37. R Core Team. (2014). R:A Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. Vienna:R Foundation for Statistical Computing. http://www.R-project.org/.
38. Reagan, I. J., and D. G., Kidd. 2013. “Using Heirarchical Task Analysis to Compare Four Vehicle Manufacturers’ Infotainment Systems.” Proceedings of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society Annual Meeting, San Diego, CA, 1495–2599.
39. Redelmeier, D. A., and R. J., Tibshirani. 1997. “Association between Cellular-Telephone Calls and Motor Vehicle Collisions.” New England Journal of Medicine 336 (7):453–458.10.1056/NEJM199702133360701
40. Reimer, B., P., Gruevski, and J. F., Coughlin. 2014. MIT AgeLab Video Annotator. Cambridge, MA. Retrieved from TBD posting of open sourced code is in progress.
41. Reimer, B., and B., Mehler. 2011. “The Impact of Cognitive Workload on Physiological Arousal in Young Adult Drivers:A Field Study and Simulation Validation.” Ergonomics 54 (10):932–942.10.1080/00140139.2011.604431
42. Reimer, B., B., Mehler, J., Dobres, and J. F., Coughlin. 2013. The Effects of a Production Level “Voice-Command” Interface on Driver Behavior:Reported Workload, Physiology, Visual Attention, and Driving Performance (Technical Report 2013-17a). Cambridge, MA:MIT AgeLab.
43. Reimer, B., B., Mehler, J., Dobres, H., McAnulty, A., Mehler, D., Munger, and A. Rumpold. 2014. “Effects of an ‘Expert Mode’ Voice Command System on Task Performance, Glance Behavior & Driver Physiology.” Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Automotive User Interfaces and Interactive Vehicle Applications, Seattle, WA.
44. Reimer, B., B., Mehler, H., McAnulty, D., Munger, A., Mehler, E. A. G., Perez, T. Manhardt, and J. F. Coughlin. 2013. “A Preliminary Assessment of Perceived and Objectively Scaled Workload of a Voice-Based Driver Interface.” Proceedings of the Proceedings of the 7th International Driving Symposium on Human Factors in Driver Assessment, Training, and Vehicle Design, Bolton Landing, NY, 537–543.
45. Reimer, B., B., Mehler, Y., Wang, and J. F., Coughlin. 2010. “The Impact of Systematic Variation of Cognitive Demand on Drivers’ Visual Attention across Multiple Age Groups.” Proceedings of the 54th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, San Francisco, CA, 2052–2056.
46. Reimer, B., B., Mehler, Y., Wang, and J. F., Coughlin. 2012. “A Field Study on the Impact of Variations in Short-Term Memory Demands on Drivers' Visual Attention and Driving Performance across Three Age Groups.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 54 (3):454–468. doi:10.1177/0018720812437274.
47. Samost, A., D., Perlman, A. G., Domel, B., Reimer, B., Mehler, A., Mehler, J. Dobres, and T. McWilliams. 2015. “Comparing the Relative Impact of Smartwatch and Smartphone Use While Driving on Workload, Attention, and Driving Performance.” Proceedings of the 59th Annual Meeting of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society, Los Angeles, CA, 1602–1606.
48. Shutko, J., K., Mayer, E., Laansoo, and L., Tijerina. 2009. Driver Workload Effects of Cell Phone, Music Player, and Text Messaging Tasks with the Ford SYNC Voice Interface versus Handheld Visual-Manual Interfaces. Warrendale, PA:SAE International SAE Technical Paper 2009-01-0786. doi:10.4271/2009-01-0786.
49. Smith, D. L., J., Chang, R., Glassco, J., Foley, and D., Cohen. 2005. “Methodology for Capturing Driver Eye Glance Behavior during in-Vehicle Secondary Tasks.” Transportation Research Record:Journal of the Transportation Research Board 1937 (1):61–65.10.3141/1937-09
50. Strayer, D. L., J. M., Cooper, J., Turrill, J., Coleman, N., Medeiros-Ward, and F., Biondi. 2013. Measuring Cognitive Distraction in the Automobile. Washington, DC:AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.
51. Strayer, D. L., J. M., Cooper, J., Turrill, J. R., Coleman, and R. J., Hopman. 2015a. Measuring Cognitive Distraction in the Automobile III:A Comparison of Ten 2015 in-Vehicle Information Systems. Washington, DC:AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.
52. Strayer, D. L., J. M., Cooper, J., Turrill, J. R., Coleman, and R. J., Hopman. 2015b. The Smartphone and the Driver’s Cognitive Workload:A Comparison of Apple, Google, and Microsoft’s Intelligent Personal Assistants. Washington, DC:AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.
53. Strayer, D. L., and F. A., Drews. 2004. “Profiles in Driver Distraction:Effects of Cell Phone Conversations on Younger and Older Drivers.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 46 (4):640–649.10.1518/hfes.46.4.640.56806
54. Strayer, D. L., F. A., Drews, and D. J., Crouch. 2006. “A Comparison of the Cell Phone Driver and the Drunk Driver.” Human Factors:The Journal of the Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 48 (2):381–391.10.1518/001872006777724471
55. Strayer, D. L., F. A., Drews, and W. A., Johnston. 2003. “Cell Phone-Induced Failures of Visual Attention during Simulated Driving.” Journal of Experimental Psychology:Applied 9 (1):23–32.
56. Strayer, D. L., J., Turrill, J. R., Coleman, E. V., Ortiz, and J. M., Cooper. 2014. Measuring Cognitive Distraction in the Automobile II:Assessing in-Vehicle Voice-Based Interactive Technologies. Washington, DC:AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety.
57. Task Force of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. 1996. “Heart Rate Variability:Standards of Measurement, Physiological Interpretation, and Clinical Use.” European Heart Journal 17:354–381.
58. Tison, J., N., Chaudhary, and L., Cosgrove. 2011. National Phone Survey on Distracted Driving Attitudes and Behaviors (Report No. DOT HS 811 555). Washington, DC:National Highway Traffic Safety Administration.10.1037/e562822012-001
59. Victor, T., J., Bärgman, C., Boda, M., Dozza, J., Engstroem, C., Flannagan, J. D., Lee, G., Markkula. 2014. Analysis of Naturalistic Driving Study Data:Safer Glances, Driver Inattention, and Crash Risk:Safer.
60. Yang, Y., B., Reimer, B., Mehler, and J., Dobres 2013. “A Field Study Assessing Driving Performance, Visual Attention, Heart Rate and Subjective Ratings in Response to Two Types of Cogntive Workload.” Proceedings of the 7th International Driving Symposium on Human Factors in Driver Assessment, Training, and Vehicle Design, Bolton Landing, NY, 397–403.
61. Young, R. A., and C., Schreiner. 2009. “Real-World Personal Conversations Using a Hands-Free Embedded Wireless Device While Driving:Effect on Airbag-Deployment Crash Rates.” Risk Analysis 29 (2):187–204.10.1111/risk.2009.29.issue-2