What Constitutes “Good” Evidence for Public Health and Social Policy-making? From Hierarchies to Appropriateness

Social Epistemology

Volumn 30, Issue 5-6, 2016, Pages 665-679

  Parkhurst, Justin O ^a   Abeysinghe, Sudeepa ^b  

^a LONDON SCHOOL OF HYGIENE AND TROPICAL MEDICINE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Appropriate Evidence; Evidence; Health Policy; Hierarchy of Evidence

Indexed keywords

EID: 84965025876     PISSN: 02691728     EISSN: 14645297     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/02691728.2016.1172365     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. J.D.Auerbach, J.O.Parkhurst, and C.Cáceres. 2011. “Addressing Social Drivers of HIV/AIDS for the Long-term Response:Conceptual and Methodological Considerations.” Global Public Health 6:S293–S309.10.1080/17441692.2011.594451
2. C.L.Bacchi, 2009. Analysing Policy:What’s the Problem Represented to Be? Frenchs Forest:Pearson Australia.
3. A.Barnes, and J.O.Parkhurst. 2014. “Can Global Health Policy Be Depoliticised? A Critique of Global Calls for Evidence-based Policy.” In Handbook of Global Health Policy, edited by G.Yamey and G.Brown, 157–73. Chichester:Wiley-Blackwell.
4. V.Berridge, and J.Stanton. 1999. “Science and Policy:Historical Insights.” Social Science & Medicine 49:1133–1138.
5. V.Berridge, and B.Thom. 1996. “Research and Policy:What Determines the Relationship?” Policy Studies 17:23–34.10.1080/01442879608423691
6. N.Black, 2001. “Evidence Based Policy:Proceed with Care Commentary:Research Must Be Taken Seriously.” BMJ 323:275–279.10.1136/bmj.323.7307.275
7. M.Blaxter, 1978. “Diagnosis as Category and Process:The Case of Alcoholism.” Social Science & Medicine Part A:Medical Psychology & Medical Sociology 12:9–17.
8. D.Bloor, 1976. Knowledge and Social Imagery. London:Routledge & Keagan Paul.
9. A.Boaz, and D.Ashby. 2003. Fit for Purpose? Assessing Research Quality for Evidence Based Policy and Practice. London:ESRC UK Centre for Evidence Based Policy and Practice.
10. A.Booth, 2010. “On Hierarchies, Malarkeys and Anarchies of Evidence.” Health Information & Libraries Journal 27:84–88.
11. K.Borgerson, 2009. “Valuing Evidence:Bias and the Evidence Hierarchy of Evidence-based Medicine.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 52:218–233.10.1353/pbm.0.0086
12. P.Cairney, 2015. The Politics of Evidece-based Policymaking. London:Palgrave Pivot.
13. Canadian Taskforce on the Periodic Health Examination. 1994. “The Canadian Guide to Clinical Preventative Medicine.” Ottawa:Minister of Supply and Services Canada.
14. N.Cartwright, 2011. “A Philosopher’s View of the Long Road from RCTs to Effectiveness.” The Lancet 377:1400–1401.10.1016/S0140-6736(11)60563-1
15. N.Cartwright, and J.Hardie. 2012. “Evidence-based Policy:A Practical Guide to Doing It Better.” Oxford:Oxford University Press.10.1093/acprof:osobl/9780199841608.001.0001
16. T.C.Chalmers, H.SmithJr, B.Blackburn, B.Silverman, B.Schroeder, D.Reitman, and A.Ambroz. 1981. “A Method for Assessing the Quality of a Randomized Control Trial.” Controlled Clinical Trials 2:31–49.10.1016/0197-2456(81)90056-8
17. S.Clark, and A.Weale. 2012. “Social Values in Health Priority Setting:A Conceptual Framework.” Journal of Health Organization and Management 26:293–316.
18. C.A.Collins, and D.R.Williams. 1999. “Segregation and Mortality:The Deadly Effects of Racism?” In Sociological Forum 14 (3):495–23.
19. R.Cookson, 2005. “Evidence-based Policy Making in Health Care:What it is and What it Isn’t.” Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 10:118–121.10.1258/1355819053559083
20. W.H.Courtenay, 2000. “Constructions of Masculinity and Their Influence on Men’s Well-being:A Theory of Gender and Health.” Social Science and Medicine 50:1385–1401.10.1016/S0277-9536(99)00390-1
21. C.A.Davies, 2008. Reflexive Ethnography:A Guide to Researching Selves and Others. London:Routledge.
22. H.T.O.Davies, S.M.Nutley, and P.C.Smith. 2000. What Works? Evidence-based Policy and Practice in Public Services. Bristol:Polity Press.10.1332/policypress/9781861341914.001.0001
23. M.J.Dobrow, V.Goel, and R.Upshur. 2004. “Evidence-based Health Policy:Context and Utilisation.” Social Science and Medicine 58:207–217.10.1016/S0277-9536(03)00166-7
24. L.Doyal, 2000. “Gender Equity in Health:Debates and Dilemmas.” Social Science and Medicine 51:931–939.10.1016/S0277-9536(00)00072-1
25. D.Easton, ([1971] 1953). “The Political System:An Inquiry into the State of Political Science.” New York, NY:Alfred A. Knopf.
26. M.H.Ebell, J.Siwek, B.D.Weiss, S.H.Woolf, J.Susman, B.Ewigman, and M.Bowman. 2004. “Strength of Recommendation Taxonomy (SORT):A Patient-centred Approach to Grading Evidence in the Medical Literature.” American Family Physician 69:548–556.
27. Evidence-based Medicine Working Group. 1992. “Evidence-based Medicine. A New Approach to Teaching the Practice of Medicine.” JAMA 268:2420–2425.
28. A.C.Gatrell, and S.J.Elliott. 2009. Geographies of Health:An Introduction. Chichester:John Wiley & Sons.
29. P.Glasziou, J.Vandenbroucke, and I.Chalmers. 2004. “Assessing the Quality of Research.” BMJ 328:39–41.10.1136/bmj.328.7430.39
30. M.J.Goldenberg, 2006. “On Evidence and Evidence-based Medicine:Lessons from the Philosophy of Science.” Social Science & Medicine 62:2621–2632.
31. M.Hammersley, 2013. The Myth of Research-based Policy & Practice. London:Sage.10.4135/9781473957626
32. M.Hammersley, and P.Atkinson. 2007. Ethnography:Principles in Practice. London:Routledge.
33. A.B.Hill, 1965. “The Environment and Disease:Association or Causation?” Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine 58:295–300.
34. R.Hoppe, 2010. “From “Knowledge Use” towards “Boundary Work”:Sketch of an Emerging New Agenda for Inquiry into Science–policy Interaction.” In Knowledge Democracy Consequences for Science, Politics and Media, edited by R.In ‘t Veld, 169–186. Heidelberg:Springer.
35. R.Imrie, 2004. “Demystifying Disability:A Review of the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health.” Sociology of Health & Illness 26:287–305.
36. S.S.Jasanoff, 1987. “Contested Boundaries in Policy-relevant Science.” Social Studies of Science 17:195–230.10.1177/030631287017002001
37. S.Jasanoff, ed. 2004. States of Knowledge:The Co-production of Science and the Social Order. London:Routledge.
38. S.Jasanoff, 2011. “Constitutional Moments in Governing Science and Technology.” Science & Engineering Ethics 17:621–638.
39. S.V.Katikireddi, 2015. “Reply to What Constitutes “Good” Evidence for Public Health and Social Policy Making? From Hierarchies to Appropriateness.” Social Epistemology Review and Reply Collective 4:51–55.
40. N.Krieger, 1992. “The Making of Public Health Data:Paradigms, Politics, and Policy.” Journal of Public Health Policy 13:412–27.
41. N.Krieger, J.T.Chen, P.D.Waterman, D.H.Rehkopf, and S.Subramanian. 2003. “Race/Ethnicity, Gender, and Monitoring Socioeconomic Gradients in Health:A Comparison of Area-based Socioeconomic Measures—The Public Health Disparities Geocoding Project.” Journal Information 93:341–78.
42. N.Krieger, D.R.Williams, and N.E.Moss. 1997. “Measuring Social Class in US Public Health Research:Concepts, Methodologies, and Guidelines.” Annual Review of Public Health 18:341–378.10.1146/annurev.publhealth.18.1.341
43. T.S.Kuhn, 1970. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago Press.
44. H.D.Lasswell, ([1990] 1936). Politics; Who Gets What, When, How. Gloucester, MA:Peter Smith.
45. J.N.Lavis, D.Robertson, J.M.Woodside, C.B.Mcleod, and J.Abelson. 2003. “How Can Research Organizations More Effectively Transfer Research Knowledge to Decision Makers?” Milbank Quarterly 81:221–248.10.1111/milq.2003.81.issue-2
46. J.M.Lewis, 2003. “Evidence-based Policy:A Technocratic Wish in a Political World.” In Evidence-based Health Policy:Problems & Possibilities, edited by V.Lin and B.Gibson, 250–259. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
47. D.L.MacKenzie, 2000. “Evidence-based Corrections:Identifying What Works.” Crime & Delinquency 46:457–471.
48. M.Marmot, and S.Friel. 2008. “Global Health Equity:Evidence for Action on the Social Determinants of Health.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 62:1095–1097.10.1136/jech.2008.081695
49. M.Marmot, and R.Wilkinson. 2009. Social Determinants of Health. Oxford:Oxford University Press.
50. R.K.Merton, 1973. The Sociology of Science:Theoretical and Empirical Investigations. Chicago, IL:University of Chicago press.
51. C.Mitton, C.E.Adair, E.Mckenzie, S.B.Patten, and B.W.Perry. 2007. “Knowledge Transfer and Exchange:Review and Synthesis of the Literature.” Milbank Quarterly 85:729–768.10.1111/milq.2007.85.issue-4
52. M.Morrissey, 2005. “Ethnicity and Race in Drug and Alcohol Research.” Health Sociology Review 14:111–120.10.5172/hesr.14.2.111
53. C.A.Moser, and G.Kalton. 1971. “Survey Methods in Social Investigation.” London:Routledge.
54. NICE. 2005. Guideline Development Methods 11—Creating Guideline Recommendations. http://www.nice.org.uk/niceMedia/pdf/GDM_Chapter11_0305.pdf
55. S.Nutley, A.Powell, and H.Davies. 2013. “What Counts as Good Evidence?”. London: Alliance for Useful evidence.
56. OCEBM Levels of Evidence Working Group. n.d. "The Oxford Levels of Evidence 2". Oxford Centre for Evidence-Based Medicine. http://www.cebm.net/index.aspx?o=5653
57. A.D.Oxman, and G.W.Group. 2004. “Grading Quality of Evidence and Strength of Recommendations.” BMJ 328:1490–1494.
58. J.O.Parkhurst, 2010. “Understanding the Correlations between Wealth, Poverty and Human Immunodeficiency Virus Infection in African Countries.” Bulletin of the World Health Organization 88:519–526.10.2471/BLT.09.070185
59. R.Pawson, T.Greenhalgh, G.Harvey, and K.Walshe. 2005. “Realist Review—A New Method of Systematic Review Designed for Complex Policy Interventions.” Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 10:21–34.
60. R.Pawson, and N.Tilley. 1997. Realistic Evaluation. London:Sage.
61. M.Petticrew, 2013. “Public Health Evaluation:Epistemological Challenges to Evidence Production and Use.” Evidence & Policy:A Journal of Research, Debate and Practice 9:87–95.
62. M.Petticrew, and H.Roberts. 2003. “Evidence, Hierarchies, and Typologies:Horses for Courses.” Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 57:527–529.10.1136/jech.57.7.527
63. J.Russell, T.Greenhalgh, E.Byrne, and J.McDonnell. 2008. “Recognizing Rhetoric in Health Care Policy Analysis.” Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 13:40–46.
64. D.A.Schön, and M.Rein. 1994. Frame Reflection:Toward the Resolution of Intractable Policy Controversies. New York:Basic Books.
65. R.E.Slavin, 2008. “Perspectives on Evidence-based Research in Education—What Works? Issues in Synthesizing Educational Program Evaluations.” Educational Researcher 37:5–14.10.3102/0013189X08314117
66. K.Smith, 2013a. “Understanding the Influence of Evidence in Public Health Policy:What Can We Learn from the “Tobacco Wars”?” Social Policy & Administration 47:382–398.
67. K.Smith, 2013b. Beyond Evidence Based Policy in Public Health. Basingstoke:Palgrave Macmillan.10.1057/9781137026583
68. D.Stone, 2002. Policy Paradox:The Art of Political Decision-making. London:W.W. Norton.
69. M.R.Trusheim, E.R.Berndt, and F.L.Douglas. 2007. “Stratified Medicine:Strategic and Economic Implications of Combining Drugs and Clinical Biomarkers.” Nature Reviews Drug Discovery 6:287–293.10.1038/nrd2251
70. UK Government. 2013. “What Works:Evidence Centres for Social Policy.” London:UK Cabinet Office.
71. C.G.Victora, J.-P.Habicht, and J.Bryce. 2004. “Evidence-based Public Health:Moving beyond Randomized Trials.” American Journal of Public Health 94:400–405.10.2105/AJPH.94.3.400
72. C.H.Weiss, 1977. “Research for Policy’s Sake:The Enlightenment Function of Social Research.” Policy Analysis 3 (4):531–545.
73. C.H.Weiss, 1979. “The Many Meanings of Research Utilization.” Public Administration Review 39:426–431.10.2307/3109916
74. R.G.Wilkinson, 2002. Unhealthy Societies:The Afflictions of Inequality. London:Routledge.
75. G.H.Williams, 2003. “The Determinants of Health:Structure, Context and Agency.” Sociology of Health & Illness 25:131–154.
76. J.Worrall, 2010. “Evidence:Philosophy of Science Meets Medicine.” Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 16:356–362.10.1111/j.1365-2753.2010.01400.x