The challenge of sustainable building renovation: Assessment of current criteria and future outlook

Journal of Cleaner Production

Volumn 123, Issue , 2016, Pages 88-100

  Pombo, Olatz ^a   Rivela, Beatriz ^b   Neila, Javier ^a  

^a UNIVERSIDAD POLITÉCNICA DE MADRID   (Spain)

^b National Institute for Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energies   (Ecuador)

Author keywords

Housing renovation; Life cycle assessment; Life cycle cost; Retrofitting; Sustainability

Indexed keywords

COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ENERGY EFFICIENCY; ENERGY UTILIZATION; GAS EMISSIONS; GREENHOUSE GASES; HOUSING; INTELLIGENT BUILDINGS; RETROFITTING; SEALING (CLOSING); SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS; SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT;

ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGIES; HOUSING RENOVATIONS; LIFE CYCLE ASSESSMENT (LCA); LIFE CYCLE COST METHODOLOGY; LIFECYCLE COSTS; REDUCING ENERGY CONSUMPTION; STATE-OF-THE ART REVIEWS; SUSTAINABLE BUILDING;

LIFE CYCLE;

EID: 84963542755     PISSN: 09596526     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2015.06.137     Document Type: Review

References (135)

1. W. Abrahamse, L. Steg, C. Vlek, and T. Rothengatter A review of intervention studies aimed at household energy conservation J. Environ. Psychol. 3 2005 273 291
2. C. Ahern, P. Griffiths, and M. O'Flaherty State of the Irish housing stock - modelling the heat losses of Ireland's existing detached rural housing stock & estimating the benefit of thermal retrofit measures on this stock Energy Policy 0 2013 139 151
3. C.B. Aktas, and M.M. Bilec Impact of lifetime on US residential building LCA results Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 3 2012 337 349
4. K. Alanne Selection of renovation actions using multi-criteria "knapsack" model Autom. Constr. 3 2004 377 391
5. K. Allacker Environmental and economic optimisation of the floor on grade in residential buildings Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 6 2012 813 827
6. K. Allacker, and F. De Troyer Moving towards a more sustainable Belgian dwelling stock: the passive standard as the next step? J. Green Build. 2 2013 112 132
7. F. Al-Ragom Retrofitting residential buildings in hot and arid climates Energy Convers. Manag. 14 2003 2309 2319
8. R.W. Amstalden, M. Kost, C. Nathani, and D.M. Imboden Economic potential of energy-efficient retrofitting in the Swiss residential building sector: the effects of policy instruments and energy price expectations Energy Policy 3 2007 1819 1829
9. E. Antipova, D. Boer, G. Guillén-Gosálbez, L.F. Cabeza, and L. Jiménez Multi-objective optimization coupled with life cycle assessment for retrofitting buildings Energy Build. 0 2014 92 99
10. F. Ardente, M. Beccali, M. Cellura, and M. Mistretta Energy and environmental benefits in public buildings as a result of retrofit actions Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 1 2011 460 470
11. E. Asadi, M.G. da Silva, C.H. Antunes, and L. Dias Multi-objective optimization for building retrofit strategies: a model and an application Energy Build. 0 2012 81 87
12. M. Asif, T. Muneer, and R. Kelley Life cycle assessment: a case study of a dwelling home in Scotland Build. Environ. 3 2007 1391 1394
13. R. Assiego de Larriva, G. Calleja Rodriguez, J.M. Cejudo Lopez, M. Raugei, and P. Fullana i Palmer A decision-making LCA for energy refurbishment of buildings: conditions of comfort Energy Build. 333 2014 333 342 342
14. A. Audenaert, S.H. De Cleyn, and M. Buyle LCA of low-energy flats using the Eco-indicator 99 method: impact of insulation materials Energy Build. 0 2012 68 73
15. N. Baker, and K. Steemers Energy and Environment in Architecture: a Technical Design Guide 2000 Taylor & Francis London
16. C.A. Balaras, A.G. Gaglia, E. Georgopoulou, S. Mirasgedis, Y. Sarafidis, and D.P. Lalas European residential buildings and empirical assessment of the Hellenic building stock, energy consumption, emissions and potential energy savings Build. Environ. 3 2007 1298 1314
17. S. Barlow, and D. Fiala Occupant comfort in UK offices-How adaptive comfort theories might influence future low energy office refurbishment strategies Energy Build. 7 2007 837 846
18. M. Beccali, M. Cellura, M. Fontana, S. Longo, and M. Mistretta Energy retrofit of a single-family house: life cycle net energy saving and environmental benefits Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 0 2013 283 293
19. R.M.J. Benders, R. Kok, H.C. Moll, G. Wiersma, and K.J. Noorman New approaches for household energy conservation - In search of personal household energy budgets and energy reduction options Energy Policy 18 2006 3612 3622
20. J. Bennett, and G. Norman Life Cycle Costing. Construction Management and Economics 1987 (Special Issue)
21. A. Bierer, U. Götze, L. Meynerts, and R. Sygulla Integrating life cycle costing and life cycle assessment using extended material flow cost accounting J. Clean. Prod. 108 Part B 2015 1289 1301
22. G. Bin, and P. Parker Measuring buildings for sustainability: comparing the initial and retrofit ecological footprint of a century home - the REEP house Appl. Energy 0 2012 24 32
23. D. Bleviss, and A. Gravitz Energy conservation in rental housing Energy Conserv. Coalit. 1984
24. M. Bojić, S. Djordjević, A. Stefanović, M. Miletić, and D. Cvetković Decreasing energy consumption in thermally non-insulated old house via refurbishment Energy Build. 0 2012 503 510
25. C.A. Bolin, and S. Smith Life cycle assessment of ACQ-treated lumber with comparison to wood plastic composite decking J. Clean. Prod. 6-7 2011 620 629
26. Boverket Sa mar Vara Hus. Redovisning av Regeringsuppdrag Beträffande Byggnaders Tekniska Utformning m.m in Swedish 2009 (Karlskrona, Sweden)
27. BRE Private Communication 1994 Building Research Establishment Garston, Watford, UK
28. N.W.O. Brown, T. Malmqvist, W. Bai, and M. Molinari Sustainability assessment of renovation packages for increased energy efficiency for multi-family buildings in Sweden Build. Environ. 0 2013 140 148
29. A. Bühring, and K. Kiefer Monitoringbericht 2001 zum Förderprogramm Wär- meerzeugung im Passivhaus der EnBW 2002 Energie Baden-Württemberg AG
30. C. Buratti, E. Belloni, and D. Palladino Evolutive housing system: refurbishment with new technologies and unsteady simulations of energy performance Energy Build. 0 2014 173 181
31. K. Byman, and S. Jernelius The Economics of Renovation Projects with Energy- Related Investments 2012 February, 1-61
32. C.J. Campbell Forecasting Global Oil Supply 2000-2050 2002 Hubbert Center Newsletter 2002/3, Colorado School of Mines Golden
33. M. Cellura, A. Di Gangi, S. Longo, and A. Orioli An Italian input-output model for the assessment of energy and environmental benefits arising from retrofit actions of buildings Energy Build. 0 2013 97 106
34. M. Cellura, F. Guarino, S. Longo, and M. Mistretta Energy life-cycle approach in net zero energy buildings balance: operation and embodied energy of an Italian case study Energy Build. 0 2014 371 381
35. M. Cellura, F. Guarino, S. Longo, M. Mistretta, and A. Orioli The role of the building sector for reducing energy consumption and greenhouse gases: an Italian case study Renew. Energy 0 2013 586 597
36. CEN EN 15804 Sustainability of Construction Works - Environmental Product Declaration - Core Rules for the Product Category of Construction Products 2012
37. CEN EN 15978 Sustainability Assessment of Construction Works - Assessment of Environmental Performance of Buildings - Calculation Method 2011
38. I. Cetiner, and E. Edis An environmental and economic sustainability assessment method for the retrofitting of residential buildings Energy Build. 2014 132 140
39. F.P. Chantrelle, H. Lahmidi, W. Keilholz, M.E. Mankibi, and P. Michel Development of a multicriteria tool for optimizing the renovation of buildings Appl. Energy 4 2011 1386 1394
40. T.Y. Chen, J. Burnett, and C.K. Chau Analysis of embodied energy use in the residential building of Hong Kong Energy 4 2001 323 340
41. S. Cohen, C. Goldman, and J. Harris Energy savings and economics of retrofitting single-family buildings Energy Build. 4 1991 297 311
42. R.M. Cuéllar-Franca, and A. Azapagic Life cycle cost analysis of the UK housing stock Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2013 1 20
43. G. Dall'O, A. Galante, and G. Pasetti A methodology for evaluating the potential energy savings of retrofitting residential building stocks Sustain. Cities Soc. 0 2012 12 21
44. E. De Angelis, G. Dotelli, F. Pittau, A. La Torre, C. Porcino, G. Pansa, and N. Villa LCA and LCC Based Energy Optimization of Building Renovation Strategies 2013 77 86
45. G. Desogus, L. Di Pilla, S. Mura, G.L. Pisano, and R. Ricciu Economic efficiency of social housing thermal upgrade in Mediterranean climate Energy Build. 0 2013 354 360
46. B.S. Dhillon Life cycle costing: techniques, models and applications 1989 Gordon and Breach New York
47. C. Diakaki, E. Grigoroudis, N. Kabelis, D. Kolokotsa, K. Kalaitzakis, and G. Stavrakakis A multi-objective decision model for the improvement of energy efficiency in buildings Energy 12 2010 5483 5496
48. C. Diakaki, E. Grigoroudis, and D. Kolokotsa Towards a multi-objective optimization approach for improving energy efficiency in buildings Energy Build. 9 2008 1747 1754
49. A. Dodoo, L. Gustavsson, and R. Sathre Life cycle primary energy implication of retrofitting a wood-framed apartment building to passive house standard Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 12 2010 1152 1160
50. L. Dreyer, M. Hauschild, and J. Schierbeck A framework for social life cycle impact assessment Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2 2006 88 97
51. M.J. Epstein Measuring Corporate Environmental Performance 1996 Irwin Professional Publishing Chicago
52. European Commission Guidelines accompanying commission delegated regulation (EU) no 244/2012 of 16 January 2012 supplementing directive 2010/31/EU of the European parliament and of the council on the energy performance of buildings by establishing a comparative methodology framework for calculating cost-optimal levels of minimum energy performance requirements for buildings and building elements Off. J. Eur. Union. C 115 2012 1 28
53. European Parliament, Council Directive 2012/27/EU of the European parliament and of the council of 25 october 2012 on energy efficiency, amending directives 2009/125/EC and 2010/30/EU and repealing directives 2004/8/EC and 2006/32/EC Off. J. Eur. Union. L 315 2012 1 56
54. R. Galvin, and M. Sunikka-Blank Economic viability in thermal retrofit policies: learning from ten years of experience in Germany Energy Policy 0 2013 343 351
55. M.R. Gaterell, and M.E. McEvoy The impact of climate change uncertainties on the performance of energy efficiency measures applied to dwellings Energy Build. 9 2005 982 995
56. M.R. Gaterell, and M.E. McEvoy The impact of energy externalities on the cost effectiveness of energy efficiency measures applied to dwellings Energy Build. 10 2005 1017 1027
57. J.S. Gero, D.C. Neville, and A.D. Radford Energy in context: a multi-criteria model for building design Build. Environ. 1983 99 107
58. H. Gervásio, P. Santos, R. Martins, and L. Simões da Silva A macro-component approach for the assessment of building sustainability in early stages of design Build. Environ. 0 2014 256 270
59. C.A. Goldman, K.M. Greely, and J.P. Harris Retrofit experience in U.S. multifamily buildings: energy savings, costs, and economics Energy 11 1988 797 811
60. M.J. González, and J. García Navarro Assessment of the decrease of CO2 emissions in the construction field through the selection of materials: practical case study of three houses of low environmental impact Build. Environ. 7 2006 902 909
61. C. Goodacre, S. Sharples, and P. Smith Integrating energy efficiency with the social agenda in sustainability Energy Build. 1 2002 53 61
62. M. Gorgolewski Optimising renovation strategies for energy conservation in housing Build. Environ. 4 1995 583 589
63. D.L. Greene, J.L. Hopson, and J. Li Have we run out of oil yet? Oil peaking analysis from an optimist's perspective Energy Policy 5 2006 515 531
64. O. Guerra Santin, L. Itard, and H. Visscher The effect of occupancy and building characteristics on energy use for space and water heating in Dutch residential stock Energy Build. 11 2009 1223 1232
65. O. Guerra-Santin, and L. Itard Occupants' behaviour: determinants and effects on residential heating consumption Build. Res. Inf. 3 2010 318 338
66. G. Gustavsson WP 4.1.2 two models for life cycle cost in Växjö, Sweden North Sea Sustain. Energy Plan. 2012 1 8
67. L. Gustavsson, and A. Joelsson Life cycle primary energy analysis of residential buildings Energy Build. 2 2010 210 220
68. R. Haas, and P. Biermayr The rebound effect for space heating empirical evidence from Austria Energy Policy 6-7 2000 403 410
69. T. Häkkinen Systematic method for the sustainability analysis of refurbishment concepts of exterior walls Constr. Build. Mater. 0 2012 783 790
70. A. Hasan, M. Vuolle, and K. Sirén Minimisation of life cycle cost of a detached house using combined simulation and optimisation Build. Environ. 12 2008 2022 2034
71. O. Hohmeyer The Social Costs of Energy Consumption 2002 Rio 02 World Climate & Energy Event Copacabana Palace
72. IEA Energy in Buildings and Communities Programme Annex 57: Evaluation of Embodied Energy and CO2eq for Building Construction 2014
73. IEA World Energy Outlook 2004 2004 OECD/IEA Paris
74. IEA Experience Curves for Energy Technology Policy 2000 OECD/IEA Paris
75. ISO 14040 Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment - Principles and Framework 2006
76. ISO 14044 Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment - Requirements and Guidelines 2006
77. ISO 15686-5 Buildings and Constructed Assets - Service-life Planning - Part 5: Life-cycle Costing 2008
78. M. Jaggs, and J. Palmer Energy performance indoor environmental quality retrofit - a European diagnosis and decision making method for building refurbishment Energy Build. 2 2000 97 101
79. M. Jakob, E. Jochem, and K. Christen Grenzkosten bei forcierten Energie-Effizienzmassnahmen in Wohngebäuden 2002
80. M. Jakob, and R. Madlener Riding down the experience curve for energy-efficient building envelopes: the Swiss case for 1970-2020 Int. J. Energy Technol. Policy 1/2 2004 153 178
81. Y. Juan, J.H. Kim, K. Roper, and D. Castro-Lacouture GA-based decision support system for housing condition assessment and refurbishment strategies Autom. Constr. 4 2009 394 401
82. E. Kaatz, D.S. Root, P.A. Bowen, and R.C. Hill Advancing key outcomes of sustainability building assessment Build. Res. Inf. 4 2006 308 320
83. G.A. Keoleian, S. Blanchard, and P. Reppe Life-cycle energy, costs, and strategies for improving a single-family house J. Ind. Ecol. 2 2000 135 156
84. S.J. Kirk, and A.J. Dell'Isola Life Cycle Costing for Design Professionals 1995 McGraw-Hill New York
85. W. Kloepffer, and I. Renner Life-cycle based sustainability assessment of products S. Schaltegger, M. Bennett, R.L. Burrit, C. Jasch, Environmental Management Accounting for Cleaner Production 2008 Springer Dordrecht 91 102
86. N. Kohler Analyse énergétique de la construction de l'utilisation et de la démolition de bâtiments 1986
87. N. Kohler, and S. Moffatt Life-cycle analysis of the built environment UNEP Ind. Environ. 2003 17 21
88. M. Krarti Energy Audit of Building Systems: an Engineering Approach second ed. 2011 CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group Boca Raton, Florida, USA
89. E. Kreith, and D.Y. Goswami Energy Management and Conservation Handbook 2008 CRC Press, Taylor and Francis Group Boca Raton, Florida, USA
90. L. Magnier, and F. Haghighat Multiobjective optimization of building design using TRNSYS simulations, genetic algorithm, and artificial neural network Build. Environ. 3 2010 739 746
91. T.M.I. Mahlia, M.F.M. Said, H.H. Masjuki, and M.R. Tamjis Cost-benefit analysis and emission reduction of lighting retrofits in residential sector Energy Build. 6 2005 573 578
92. T. Malmqvist, M. Glaumann, Å. Svenfelt, P. Carlson, M. Erlandsson, J. Andersson, H. Wintzell, G. Finnveden, T. Lindholm, and T. Malmström A Swedish environmental rating tool for buildings Energy 4 2011 1893 1899
93. R. Marler, and J. Arora Survey of multi-objective optimization methods for engineering Struct. Multidiscip. Optim. 6 2004 369 395
94. V. Martinaitis, E. Kazakevičius, and A. Vitkauskas A two-factor method for appraising building renovation and energy efficiency improvement projects Energy Policy 1 2007 192 201
95. É. Mata, A.S. Kalagasidis, and F. Johnsson A modelling strategy for energy, carbon, and cost assessments of building stocks Energy Build. 0 2013 100 108
96. É. Mata, A. Sasic Kalagasidis, and F. Johnsson Energy usage and technical potential for energy saving measures in the Swedish residential building stock Energy Policy 0 2013 404 414
97. M. Mequignon, L. Adolphe, F. Thellier, and H. Ait Haddou Impact of the lifespan of building external walls on greenhouse gas index Build. Environ. 0 2013 654 661
98. M. Mequignon, H. Ait Haddou, F. Thellier, and M. Bonhomme Greenhouse gases and building lifetimes Build. Environ. 0 2013 77 86
99. T. Moore, and J. Morrissey Lifecycle costing sensitivities for zero energy housing in Melbourne, Australia Energy Build. 2014 1 11
100. J. Morrissey, and R.E. Horne Life cycle cost implications of energy efficiency measures in new residential buildings Energy Build. 4 2011 915 924
101. C. Mullaly Home energy use behaviour: a necessary component of successful local government home energy conservation (LGHEC) programs Energy Policy 14 1998 1041 1052
102. G. Munda Multiple criteria decision analysis and sustainable development J. Figueira, S. Greco, M. Ehrgott, Multiple Criteria Decision Analysis: State of the Art Surveys 2005 Springer New York 953 986
103. F. Nemry, A. Uihlein, C. Makishi Colodel, C. Wetzel, A. Braune, B. Wittstock, I. Hasan, J. Kreissig, N. Gallon, S. Niemeier, and Y. Frech Options to reduce the environmental impacts of residential buildings in the European Union-potential and costs Energy Build. 7 2010 976 984
104. G.M. Nicoletti, B. Notarnicola, and G. Tassielli Comparative life cycle assessment of flooring materials: ceramic versus marble tiles J. Clean. Prod. 3 2002 283 296
105. M. Optis, and P. Wild Inadequate documentation in published life cycle energy reports on buildings Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 7 2010 644 651
106. Y. Ostermeyer, H. Wallbaum, and F. Reuter Multidimensional pareto optimization as an approach for site-specific building refurbishment solutions applicable for life cycle sustainability assessment Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 9 2013 1762 1779
107. OTA Energy Efficiency of Buildings in Cities 1982 Office of Technology Assessment, U. S. Congress
108. W. Ott, R. Bolliger, V. Ritter, S. Citherlet, B. Perriset, M. De Almeida, and M. Ferreira IEA EBC annex 56: methodology for cost-effective energy and carbon emissions optimization in building renovation Methodol. Assess. Renov. Meas. Parametr. Calc. 2014
109. J. Ouyang, M. Lu, B. Li, C. Wang, and K. Hokao Economic analysis of upgrading aging residential buildings in China based on dynamic energy consumption and energy price in a market economy Energy Policy 9 2011 4902 4910
110. J. Ouyang, C. Wang, H. Li, and K. Hokao A methodology for energy-efficient renovation of existing residential buildings in China and case study Energy Build. 9 2011 2203 2210
111. J. Owens, and H. Wilhite Household energy behavior in Nordic countries - an unrealized energy saving potential Energy 12 1988 853 859
112. S. Paiho, Å. Hedman, R. Abdurafikov, H. Hoang, M. Sepponen, I. Kouhia, and M. Meinander Energy saving potentials of Moscow apartment buildings in residential districts Energy Build. 2013 706 713
113. A.M. Papadopoulos, T.G. Theodosiou, and K.D. Karatzas Feasibility of energy saving renovation measures in urban buildings: the impact of energy prices and the acceptable pay back time criterion Energy Build. 5 2002 455 466
114. F. Perkins Practical Cost Benefit Analysis. Basic Concepts and Applications 1994 MacMillan South Melbourne, Australia
115. B. Peuportier, S. Thiers, and A. Guiavarch Eco-design of buildings using thermal simulation and life cycle assessment J. Clean. Prod. 0 2013 73 78
116. R. Pike, and R. Dobbins Investment Decisions and Financial Strategy 1986 Philip Allan Hemel Hempstead, UK
117. C. Reitinger, M. Dumke, M. Barosevcic, and R. Hillerbrand A conceptual framework for impact assessment within SLCA Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 4 2011 380 388
118. D.S. Remer, and A.P. Nieto A compendium and comparison of 25 project evaluation techniques. Part 1: net present value and rate of return methods Int. J. Prod. Econ. 1 1995 79 96
119. E. Rey Office building retrofitting strategies: multicriteria approach of an architectural and technical issue Energy Build. 4 2004 367 372
120. B. Risholt, B. Time, and A.G. Hestnes Sustainability assessment of nearly zero energy renovation of dwellings based on energy, economy and home quality indicators Energy Build. 2013 217 224
121. S. Roberts Altering existing buildings in the UK Energy Policy 12 2008 4482 4486
122. S.V. Russell-Smith, M.D. Lepech, R. Fruchter, and Y.B. Meyer Sustainable target value design: integrating life cycle assessment and target value design to improve building energy and environmental performance J. Clean. Prod. 0 2015 43 51
123. R. Saidur, H.H. Masjuki, and M.Y. Jamaluddin An application of energy and exergy analysis in residential sector of Malaysia Energy Policy 2 2007 1050 1063
124. I. Sartori, and A.G. Hestnes Energy use in the life cycle of conventional and low-energy buildings: a review article Energy Build. 3 2007 249 257
125. C. Seligman, J.M. Darley, and L.J. Becker Behavioral approaches to residential energy conservation Energy Build. 3 1978 325 337
126. K. Steemers, and G.Y. Yun Household energy consumption: a study of the role of occupants Build. Res. Inf. 5-6 2009 625 637
127. L. Steg Promoting household energy conservation Energy Policy 12 2008 4449 4453
128. T. Stovall, T. Petrie, J. Kosny, P. Childs, J. Atchley, and K. Sissom An exploration of wall retrofit best practices. Thermal performance of the exterior envelopes of buildings X Proceedings of ASHRAE THERM X 2007
129. M. Sunikka-Blank, and R. Galvin Introducing the prebound effect: the gap between performance and actual energy consumption Build. Res. Inf. 3 2012 260 273
130. UNEP Guidelines for Social Life Cycle Assessment of Products (France) 2009
131. US Department of Energy The Official Building Simulation Program of the United States Department of Energy 2015
132. G. Verbeeck, and H. Hens Energy savings in retrofitted dwellings: economically viable? Energy Build. 7 2005 747 754
133. J. Vrijders, and L. Wastiels Nearly Zero Energy Renovation of Houses: Life Cycle Costs and Environmental Impact 2013 87 94
134. B. Wittstock, J. Gantner, K. Lenz, T. Saunders, J. Anderson, C. Carter, Z. Gyetvai, J. Kreißig, A. Braune, S. Lasvaux, B. Bosdevigie, M. Bazzana, N. Schiopu, E. Jayr, S. Nibel, J. Chevalier, J. Hans, P. Fullana-i-Palmer, C. Gazulla, J. Mundy, T. Barrow-Williams, and C. Sjöström EeB Guide Guidance Document, Part B: Buildings, Operational Guidance for Life Cycle Assessment Studies of the Energy-efficienct Buildings Initiative 2012 1-360
135. I. Zabalza Bribián, A. Valero Capilla, and A. Aranda Usón Life cycle assessment of building materials: comparative analysis of energy and environmental impacts and evaluation of the eco-efficiency improvement potential Build. Environ. 5 2011 1133 1140