Ultrasound versus 'clinical touch' for catheter guidance during embryo transfer in women

Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews

Volumn 2016, Issue 3, 2016, Pages

  Brown, Julie ^a   Buckingham, Karen ^b   Buckett, William ^c   Abou Setta, Ahmed M ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND   (New Zealand)

^b Repromed Auckland   (New Zealand)

^c MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MANITOBA   (Canada)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ADVERSE OUTCOME; CATHETER; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CLINICAL TOUCH; COCHRANE LIBRARY; COMPARATIVE EFFECTIVENESS; ECTOPIC PREGNANCY; EMBASE; EMBRYO TRANSFER; FEMALE INFERTILITY; HUMAN; LIVE BIRTH; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); METHODOLOGY; MULTIPLE PREGNANCY; PREGNANCY; PREGNANCY OUTCOME; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SAMPLE SIZE; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS; SPONTANEOUS ABORTION; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (TOPIC); TOUCH; ULTRASOUND; ULTRASOUND GUIDED EMBRYO TRANSFER; ADVERSE EFFECTS; FEMALE; INTERVENTIONAL ULTRASONOGRAPHY; META ANALYSIS; PALPATION; PROCEDURES; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EMBRYO TRANSFER; FEMALE; HUMANS; PALPATION; PREGNANCY; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC; TREATMENT OUTCOME; ULTRASONOGRAPHY, INTERVENTIONAL;

EID: 84961864536     PISSN: None     EISSN: 1469493X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD006107.pub4     Document Type: Review

References (82)

1. Ammar AR, Mousa KS, Rabei NH, Galal A. Effect of ultrasound guided embryo transfer on pregnancy rates. New York Science Journal 2013;6(12):79-83.
2. Al-Shemi M. Ultrasound Guided Versus Blind Touch Embryo Transfer Among Patients Undergoing Intra Cytoplasm Sperm Injection [Protocol for Thesis]. Faculty of Medicine, Ain Shams University, Egypt, 2008.
3. Azmy O, Taha T, Bibars M, Refaat M. Ultrasound guided versus blind touch embryo transfer: the Egyptian experience. Proceedings of the 15th World Conference of IVF and 4th Congress of IVM. 2009:9-12.
4. Bar-Hava I, Meltzer S, Rabinson J, Ayash I, Sega S, Tur-Kaspa I. Ultrasound guided versus blind tactile embryo transfer: a prospective randomised study. Human Reproduction 2003;18 (suppl 1)(7):xviii7.
5. Chen S-C, Lai T-H, Lee F-K. The influence of abdominal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer on pregnancy rate: a preliminary report. Fertility and Sterility 2007;87(5):1235-7.
6. Coroleu B, Carreras O, Veiga A, Martell A, Martinez F, Belil I, et al. Embryo transfer under ultrasound guidance improves pregnancy rates after in-vitro fertilization. Human Reproduction 2000;15(3):616-20.
7. Coroleu B, Barri P, Carreras O, Martinez F, Veiga A, Balasch J. The usefulness of ultrasound guidance in frozen-thawed embryo transfer: a prospective randomised clinical trial. Human Reproduction 2002;17(11):2885-90.
8. Davar R, Ghandi S, Tayebi N. Does transabdominal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer improve pregnancy rates in ART cycles?. Iranian Journal of Reproductive Medicine 2007;5(3):95-8.
9. Drakeley A, Jorgensen A, Sklavounos J, Aust T, Gazvani R, Williamson P, et al. A randomized controlled clinical trial of 2295 ultrasound-guided embryo transfers. Human Reproduction 2008;23(5):1101-6.
10. Drakeley AJ, Lunt R, Aust T, Williamson P, Gazvani R, Sklavounos J, et al. A randomized trial of 2250 women having ultrasound guided embryo transfer. Human Reproduction 2006;21((suppl 1)):i82.
11. Eskandar M, Abou-Setta A, Almushait M, El-Amin M, Mohamad S. Ultrasound guidance during embryo transfer: a prospective, single-operator, randomized controlled trial. Fertility and Sterility 2008;90(4):1187-90.
12. Garcia-Velasco J, Isaza V, Martinez-Salazar J, Landazabal A, Requena A, Remohi J, et al. Transabdominal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer does not increase pregnancy rates in oocyte recipients. Fertility and Sterility 2002;78(3):534-9.
13. Kosmas IP, Janssens R, De Munck L, Al Turki HF, Tournaye H, Van Steirteghem AC, et al. Ultrasound guidance during embryo transfer does not offer any benefit in clinical outcome: a randomized controlled trial. Human Reproduction 2007;22(5):1327-34.
14. Li R, Lu L, Hao G, Zhong K, Cai Z, Wang W. Abdominal ultrasound guided embryo transfer improves clinical pregnancy rates after in vitro fertilization: experiences from 330 clinical investigations. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 2005;22(1):3-8.
15. Maldonado LG, Ajzen Sa, Busato WC, Iaconelli A Jr, Bibancos M, Borges E Jr. Impact of previous hysterosonometry on embryo transfer. Fertility and Sterility 2005;84:S364.
16. Marconi G, Young E Jr, Vilela M, Bello A, Young E Sr, Sueldo C. Prospective randomized comparison of an ultrasound-guided embryo transfer versus a blind catheter placement. Fertility and Sterility 2003;80(suppl 3):S130.
17. Martins A, Baruffi R, Mauri A, Petersen C, Oliveira J, Contart P, et al. Ultrasound guidance is not necessary during easy embryo transfers. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 2004;21(12):421-5.
18. Matorras R, Urquijo E, Mendoza R, Corcostegui B, Exposito A, Rodriguez-Escudero F. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer improves pregnancy rates and increases the frequency of easy transfers. Human Reproduction 2002;17(7):1762-6.
19. Moraga-Sanchez M, Llata E, Resendiz V, Haliscak R, Galache-Vega P, Ayup S, et al. Ultrasound influence and 30 second wait in embryo transfer. Human Reproduction 2004;19:i127.
20. Tang O, Ng E, So W, Ho P. Ultrasound guided embryo transfer: a prospective randomized controlled trial. Human Reproduction 2001;16(11):2310-5.
21. Weissman A, Farhi J, Steinfeld Z, Mustafi R, Nahum H, Levran D. A prospective randomized study of ultrasound-guided embryo transfer. Fertility and Sterility 2003;80 (Suppl 1):S122.
22. Wisanto A, Janssens R, Desacht J, Camus M, Devroey P, Van Steirtegham AC. Performance of different embryo transfer catheters in a human in vitro fertilization program. Fertility and Sterility 1989;52(1):79-84.
23. Zakova J, Crha L, Ventruba P, Lobsova E, Huser M. Does ultrasound-guided embryo transfer improve pregnancy rate in in vitro fertilization?. Human Reproduction 2008;23 (Supplement 1):i135.
24. Al-Shawaf T, Yang D, Al-Magid Y, Seaton A, Iketubosin F, Craft I. Ultrasonic monitoring during replacement of frozen/thawed embryos in natural and hormone replacement cycles. Human Reproduction 1993;8(12):2068-74.
25. Al-Shawaf T, Dave R, Harper J, Linehan D, Riley P, Craft I. Transfer of embryos into the uterus: How much do technical factors affect pregnancy rates?. Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics 1993;10(1):31-6.
26. Anderson RE, Nugent NL, Gregg AT, Nunn SL, Behr BR. Transvaginal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer improves outcome in patients with previous failed in vitro fertilization cycles. Fertility and Sterility 2002;77(4):769-74.
27. Baba K, Ishihara O, Hayashi N, Saioh M, Taya J, Kinoshita K. Three dimensional ultrasound in embryo transfer. Ultrasound in Obsterics and Gynecology 2000;16:372-3.
28. Blake . Unpublished. Personal communicaton 1998.
29. Bodri D, Colodron M, Garcia D, Obradors Am Vernaeve V, Coll O. Transvaginal versus transabdominal ultrasound guidance for embryo transfer in donor oocyte recipients: a randomized clinical trial. Fertility and Sterility 2011;95(7):2263-8.
30. Broussin B, Jayot S, Subtil D, Parneix I, Audebert A, Dubecq F, et al. Difficult embryo transfer: the ultrasonography contribution. Fertilite Contraception Sexualite 1998;26(7-8):492-7.
31. Coroleu B, Barri PN, Carreras O, Martinez F, Parriego M, Hereter L, Parera N, Veiga A, Balasch J. The influence of the depth of embryo placement into the uterine cavity on implantation rates after IVF: a controlled, ultrasound-guided study. Human Reproduction 2002;17(2):341-6.
32. Cruickshank B, Fasciani A, Di Berardino A, Hannam TG, Casper RF, Greenblatt E. The ultrasound guided embryo transfer significantly increases the ongoing pregnancy rates when a 'laminar flow' pattern is observed. Human Reproduction 2003;18((Suppl 1) Issue 6):Xviii6.
33. Deep JP, Li Y, Liu H. The effect of embryo transfer on IVF treatment: Comparing the trans-vaginal versus transabdominal ultrasound approach. Journal of Minimally Invasive Gynecology 2013;1:S42-3.
34. Englert Y, Puissant F, Camus M, Van Hoeck J, Leroy F. Clinical study on embryo transfer after human in vitro fertilisation. Journal of In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer 1986;3(4):243-6.
35. Eskander M, Abou-Setta A. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer is superior to clinical touch alone: A single operator randomized controlled trial. Fertility and Sterility 2007;88 (suppl 1):S326-7.
36. Faure JM, Dechaud H, Deschamps F, Arnal F, Humeau C, Hedon B. Ultrasound guided embryo transfer. Effects on implantation and pregnancy rates. Fertility and Sterility 1998:S26.
37. Flisser E, Grifo JA, Krey L, Noyes N. Transabdominal ultrasound-assisted embryo transfer and pregnancy outcome. Fertility and Sterility 2006;85(2):353-7.
38. Garcia-Velasco J, Martinez-Salazar J, Isaza A, Landazabal A, Requena A, Simon C. Does ultrasound guidance at embryo transfers improve pregnancy rates in oocyte recipients?. Fertility and Sterility 2001;76:75-6.
39. Garzo G. Embryo transfer technique. Clinical Obstetrics and Gynecology 2006;49(1):117-22.
40. Gergely R, DeUgarte C, Danzer H, Surrey M, Hill D, DeCherney A. Three dimensional/four dimensional ultrasound-guided embryo transfer using the maximal implantation potential point. Fertility and Sterility 2005;84(2):500-3.
41. Ghazzawi I, Hassani S, Karaki R, Souso S. Transfer technique and catheter choice influence the incidence of transcervical embryo expulsion and the outcome of IVF. Human Reproduction 1999;14(3):677-82.
42. Hauzman E, Kohls G, Barrio A, Martinez Salazar J, Iglesias C, Garcia-Velasco JA. Comparison of embryo transfer in egg donation recipients with transvaginal and transabdominal ultrasound: A randomized pilot study. Human Reproduction 2013;28:i241.
43. Hurley V, Osborn J, Leoni M, Leeton J. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer: a controlled trial. Fertility and Sterility 1991;55(3):559-62.
44. Kan AKS, Abdalla HI, Gafar AH, Nappi L, Ogunyemi BO, Thomas A, Ola-ojo OO. Embryo transfer: ultrasound-guided versus clinical touch. Human Reproduction 1999;14(5):1259-61.
45. Karande V, Hazlett D, Vietzke M, Cleicher N. A prospective randomized comparison of the Wallace catheter and the Cook Echo-Tip catheter for ultrasound guided embryo transfer. Fertility and Sterility 2002;77(4):826-30.
46. Kojima K, Nomiyama M, Kumamoto T, Matsmoto Y, Iwasaka T. Transvaginal ultrasound guided embryo transfer improves pregnancy and implantation rates after IVF. Human Reproduction 2001;16(12):2578-82.
47. Kolankaya A, Enginsu ME, Camlibel TF, Sarikamis B, Kurt E, Yildiz K, Hunerli C. Ultrasound guided embryo transfer improves pregnancy rates. Human Reproduction 2001;16((Suppl 1)):155.
48. Kosmas IP, Janssens R, De Munck L, Al Turki HF, Tournaye H, Van Steirteghem AC, et al. Ultrasound guidance during embryo transfer does not offer any benefit in clinical outcome: a randomized controlled trial. Human Reproduction 2006;21(6):i101.
49. Kreiner D, Moschella J, Carlson N, Jelicks J, Bolkas M, Moodie G, et al. Pregnancy rates of a two step ultrasound guided embryo transfer 1-112 cm from the top of the uterine cavity. Fertility and Sterility 2000;74(3 (suppl 1)):S206.
50. Lenz S, Leeton J, Rogers P, Trouson A. Transfundal transfer of embryos using ultrasound. Journal of In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer 1987;4(1):13-7.
51. Lenz S, Leeton J. Evaluating the possibility of uterine transfer by ultrasonically guided transabdominal puncture. Journal of In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer 1987;4(1):18-22.
52. Leong M, Leung C, Tucker M, Wong C, Chan H. Ultrasound assisted embryo transfer. Journal of In Vitro Fertilization and Embryo Transfer 1986;3(6):383-5.
53. Lesny P, Killick SR, Tetlow RL, Robinson J, Maguiness SD. Embryo transfer - can we learn anything new from the observation of junctional zone contractions?. Human Reproduction 1998;13(6):1540-6.
54. Letterie GS. Three-dimensional ultrasound-guided embryo transfer: A preliminary study. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 2005;192:1983-8.
55. Lindheim SR, Cohen MA, Sauer MV. Ultrasound guided embryo transfer significantly improves pregnancy rates in women undergoing oocyte donation. International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 1999;66:281-4.
56. Lorusso F, Depalo R, Bettocchi S, Vacca M, Vimercati A, Selvaggi L. Outcome of in vitro fertilization after transabdominal ultrasound-assisted embryo transfer with a full or empty bladder. Fertility and Sterility 2005;84(4):1046-8.
57. Martinez F, Coroleu B, Parriego M, Carreras O, Belil I, Parera N, Hereter L, Buxaderas R, Barri PN. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer: immediate withdrawal of the catheter versus a 30 second wait. Human Reproduction 2001;16(5):871-4.
58. Parsons JH, Bolton VN, Wilson L, Campbell S. Pregnancies following in vitro fertilization and ultrasound-directed surgical embryo transfer by perurethral and transvaginal techniques. Fertility and Sterility 1987;48(4):691-3.
59. Porat N, Boehnlein LM, Schouweiler CM, Kang J, Lindheim SR. Interim analysis of a randomized clinical trial comparing abdominal versus transvaginal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer. The Journal of Obstetrics and Gynaecology Research 2010;36(2):384-92.
60. Prapas Y, Prapas N, Hatziparasidou A, Prapa S, Nijs M, Vanderzwalmen P, et al. The echoguide embryo transfer maximises the IVF results. Acta Europaea Fertilitatis 1995;26(3):113-5.
61. Prapas Y, Prapas N, Hatziparasidou A, Vanderzwalmen P, Nijs M, Prapa S, et al. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer maximizes the IVF results on day 3 and day 4 embryo transfer but has no impact on day 5. Human Reproduction 2001;16(9):1904-8.
62. Saharkhiz N, Nikbakht R, Salehpour S. Comparison between conventional blind embryo transfer and embryo transfer based on previously measured uterine length. International Journal of Fertility and Sterility 2014;8(3):249-54.
63. Sallam H, Agameya A, Rahman A, Ezzeldin F, Sallam A. Ultrasound measurement of the uterocervical angle before embryo transfer: a prospective controlled study. Human Reproduction. 2001; Vol. 16, issue abstract book 1:126.
64. Sallam HN, Agameya AF, Rahman AF, Ezzeldin F, Sallam AN. Ultrasound measurement of the uterocervical angle before embryo transfer: a prospective controlled study. Human Reproduction 2002;17(7):1767-772.
65. Sasy M, Salem W, Fattah A, Ashraf M, Abozaid T, Khan I, et al. Comparison between ultrasound-guided embryo transfer and tubal embryo transfer after intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Middle East Fertility Society Journal 2003;8(3):223-8.
66. Scholtes M, Roozenburg B, Verhoeff, Zeilmaker G. A randomised trial of transcervical intrafallopian transfer of pronucleate embryos controlled by ultrasound versus intrauterine transfer of four to eight cell embryos. Fertility and Sterility 1994;61(1):102-4.
67. Shamonki MI, Spandorfer SD, Rosenwaks Z. Ultrasound-guided embryo transfer and the accuracy of trial embryo transfer. Human Reproduction 2005;20(3):709-16.
68. Silberstein T, Trimarchi JR, Shackelton R, Weitzen S, Frankfurter D, Plosker S. Ultrasound guided mid-uterine cavity embryo transfer is associated with a decreased incidence of retained embryos in the transfer catheter. Fertility and Sterility 2005;84(5):1510-2.
69. Strickler RC, Christianson C, Crane JP, Curato A, Knight AB, Yang V. Ultrasound guidance for human embryo transfer. Fertility and Sterility 1985;43(1):54-61.
70. Wood EG, Batzer F, Go KJ, Gutmann JN, Corson SL. Ultrasound-guided soft catheter embryo transfers will improve pregnancy rates in in-vitro fertilization. Human Reproduction 2000;15(1):107-12.
71. Woolcott R, Stanger J. Potentially important variables identified by transvaginal ultrasound-guided embryo transfer. Human Reproduction 1997;12(5):963-6.
72. Yovich J, Turner S, Murphy A. Embryo transfer technique as a cause of ectopic pregnancies in in-vitro fertilization. Fertility and Sterility 1985;44(3):318-21.
73. Abou-Setta AM, Mansour RT, Al-Inany HG, Aboulghar MM, Aboulghar MA, Serour GI. Among women undergoing embryo transfer is the probability of pregnancy and live birth improved with ultrasound guidance over clinical touch alone? A systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective randomised controlled trials. Fertility and Sterility 2007;88(2):333-41.
74. Fanchin R, Righini C, Olivennes F, Taylor S, de Ziegler D, Frydman R. Uterine contractions at the time of embryo transfer alter pregnancy rates after in vitro fertilization. Human Reproduction 1998;13:1968-74.
75. McMaster University (developed by Evidence Prime Inc). Available from gradepro.org. GRADEpro GDT: GRADEpro Guideline Development Tool. McMaster University (developed by Evidence Prime Inc). Available from gradepro.org, 2015.
76. Higgins J, Green S (editors). Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions Version 5.1.0 [updated March 2011]. The Cochrane Collaboration, 2011. Available from www.cochrane-handbook.org.
77. Kovacs GT. What factors are important for successful embryo transfer after in-vitro fertilization?. Human Reproduction 1999;14:590-2.
78. The Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration. Review Manager (RevMan). Version 5.3. Copenhagen: The Nordic Cochrane Centre, The Cochrane Collaboration, 2014.
79. Sallam HN, Saad-el-Din S. Performing embryo transfer under ultrasound guidance - A meta analysis of randomized trials. Fertility and Sterility 2002;78(3 (Suppl 1)):S46.
80. Steptoe PC, Edwards RG. Birth after the reimplantation of a human embryo. The Lancet 1978;2:366.
81. Teixeira DM, Dassuncao LA, Vieira CV, Barbosa MA, Coelho Neto MA, Nastri CO, et al. Ultrasound guidance during embryo transfer: a systemtic review and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology 2015;45(2):139-48.
82. Brown J, Buckingham K, Abou-Setta AM, Buckett W. Ultrasound versus 'clinical touch' for catheter guidance during embryo transfer in women. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2010, Issue 1.