Seizure prediction for therapeutic devices: A review

Journal of Neuroscience Methods

Volumn 260, Issue , 2016, Pages 270-282

  Gadhoumi, Kais ^a,d   Lina, Jean Marc ^b,c,d,e   Mormann, Florian ^f   Gotman, Jean ^a,d  

^a MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b ÉCOLE DE TECHNOLOGIE SUPÉRIEURE   (Canada)

^c UNIVERSITÉ DE MONTRÉAL   (Canada)

^d MCGILL UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^e INSERM   (France)

^f UNIVERSITY OF BONN   (Germany)

Author keywords

Algorithms; Focal epilepsy; Intracerebral EEG; Seizure prediction; Statistical validation; Therapeutic devices

Indexed keywords

DRUG RESISTANT EPILEPSY; ELECTRODE; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAM; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY PHASE SYNCHRONIZATION; FOCAL EPILEPSY; FREQUENCY; HIPPOCAMPUS; HISTOGRAM; HUMAN; MESIAL TEMPORAL LOBE EPILEPSY; NEOCORTEX; NEUROLOGICAL THERAPEUTIC DEVICE; PATTERN RECOGNITION; PRACTICE GUIDELINE; PREDICTION; PRIORITY JOURNAL; RECEIVER OPERATING CHARACTERISTIC; REVIEW; SEIZURE; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY; SIGNAL PROCESSING; SPIKE; SUPPORT VECTOR MACHINE; ALGORITHM; ANIMAL; AUTOMATED PATTERN RECOGNITION; COMPUTER ASSISTED DIAGNOSIS; DEVICE FAILURE ANALYSIS; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EQUIPMENT DESIGN; PROCEDURES; PROGNOSIS; REPRODUCIBILITY; SEIZURES;

ALGORITHMS; ANIMALS; DIAGNOSIS, COMPUTER-ASSISTED; ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY; EQUIPMENT DESIGN; EQUIPMENT FAILURE ANALYSIS; HUMANS; PATTERN RECOGNITION, AUTOMATED; PROGNOSIS; REPRODUCIBILITY OF RESULTS; SEIZURES; SENSITIVITY AND SPECIFICITY;

EID: 84957442740     PISSN: 01650270     EISSN: 1872678X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2015.06.010     Document Type: Review

References (90)

1. Aarabi A., He B. A rule-based seizure prediction method for focal neocortical epilepsy. Clin Neurophysiol 2012, 123:1111-1122.
2. Aarabi A., He B. Seizure prediction in hippocampal and neocortical epilepsy using a model-based approach. Clin Neurophysiol 2014, 125:930-940.
3. Aarabi A., He B. Seizure prediction in intracranial EEG: a patient-specific rule-based approach. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2011 2011, 2566-2569.
4. Andrzejak R.G., Chicharro D., Elger C.E., Mormann F. Seizure prediction: any better than chance?. Clin Neurophysiol 2009, 120:1465-1478.
5. Andrzejak R.G., Mormann F., Kreuz T., Rieke C., Kraskov A., Elger C.E., et al. Testing the null hypothesis of the nonexistence of a preseizure state. Phys Rev E: Stat Nonlinear Soft Matter Phys 2003, 67. 010901(R).
6. Arnhold J., Grassberger P., Lehnertz K., Elger C.E. A robust method for detecting interdependences: application to intracranially recorded EEG. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenom 1999, 134:419-430.
7. Aschenbrenner-Scheibe R., Maiwald T., Winterhalder M., Voss H.U., Timmer J., Schulze-Bonhage A. How well can epileptic seizures be predicted? An evaluation of a nonlinear method. Brain 2003, 126:2616-2626.
8. Bandarabadi M., Teixeira C.A., Rasekhi J., Dourado A. Epileptic seizure prediction using relative spectral power features. Clin Neurophysiol 2015, 126(2):237-248.
9. Banerjee S., Pedersen T. The design, implementation, and use of the Ngram statistics package. Computational linguistics and intelligent text processing 2003, 370-381. Springer Berlin, Heidelberg. A. Gelbukh (Ed.).
10. Bengio Y., Ducharme j, Vincent P., Janvin C. A neural probabilistic language model. J Mach Learn Res 2003, 3:1137-1155.
11. Bennewitz M.F., Saltzman W.M. Nanotechnology for delivery of drugs to the brain for epilepsy. Neurotherapeutics 2009, 6:323-336.
12. Bower M.R., Stead M., Meyer F.B., Marsh W.R., Worrell G.A. Spatiotemporal neuronal correlates of seizure generation in focal epilepsy. Epilepsia 2012, 53:807-816.
13. Chaovalitwongse W., Iasemidis L.D., Pardalos P.M., Carney P.R., Shiau D.S., Sackellares J.C. Performance of a seizure warning algorithm based on the dynamics of intracranial EEG. Epilepsy Res 2005, 64:93-113.
14. Cook M.J., O'Brien T.J., Berkovic S.F., Murphy M., Morokoff A., Fabinyi G., et al. Prediction of seizure likelihood with a long-term, implanted seizure advisory system in patients with drug-resistant epilepsy: a first-in-man study. Lancet Neurol 2013, 12:563-571.
15. Costa R.P., Oliveira P., Rodrigues G., Leitao B., Dourado A. Epileptic seizure classification using neural networks with 14 features. Lect Notes Artif Int 2008, 5178:281-288.
16. Deckers C.L., Genton P., Sills G.J., Schmidt D. Current limitations of antiepileptic drug therapy: a conference review. Epilepsy Res 2003, 53:1-17.
17. DeGiorgio C.M., Soss J., Cook I.A., Markovic D., Gornbein J., Murray D., et al. Randomized controlled trial of trigeminal nerve stimulation for drug-resistant epilepsy. Neurology 2013, 80:786-791.
18. Eftekhar A., Juffali W., El-Imad J., Constandinou T.G., Toumazou C. Ngram-derived pattern recognition for the detection and prediction of epileptic seizures. PLoS ONE 2014, 9:e96235.
19. Elger C.E., Mormann F. Seizure prediction and documentation-two important problems. Lancet Neurol 2013, 12:531-532.
20. Feldwisch-Drentrup H., Schulze-Bonhage A., Timmer J., Schelter B. Statistical validation of event predictors: a comparative study based on the field of seizure prediction. Phys Rev E: Stat Nonlin Soft Matter Phys 2011, 83:066704.
21. Fisher R., Salanova V., Witt T., Worth R., Henry T., Gross R., et al. Electrical stimulation of the anterior nucleus of thalamus for treatment of refractory epilepsy. Epilepsia 2010, 51:899-908.
22. Fisher R.S. Therapeutic devices for epilepsy. Ann Neurol 2012, 71:157-168.
23. Fisher R.S., Ho J. Potential new methods for antiepileptic drug delivery. CNS Drugs 2002, 16:579-593.
24. Fountas K.N., Smith J.R., Murro A.M., Politsky J., Park Y.D., Jenkins P.D. Implantation of a closed-loop stimulation in the management of medically refractory focal epilepsy: a technical note. Stereotact Funct Neurosurg 2005, 83:153-158.
25. Fregni F., Otachi P.T., Do Valle A., Boggio P.S., Thut G., Rigonatti S.P., et al. A randomized clinical trial of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation in patients with refractory epilepsy. Ann Neurol 2006, 60:447-455.
26. Fujii M., Fujioka H., Oku T., Tanaka N., Imoto H., Maruta Y., et al. Application of focal cerebral cooling for the treatment of intractable epilepsy. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo) 2010, 50:839-844.
27. Gadhoumi K., Lina J.M., Gotman J. Discriminating preictal and interictal states in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy using wavelet analysis of intracerebral EEG. Clin Neurophysiol 2012, 123:1906-1916.
28. Gadhoumi K., Lina J.M., Gotman J. Seizure prediction in patients with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy using EEG measures of state similarity. Clin Neurophysiol 2013, 124:1745-1754.
29. Haut S.R., Swick C., Freeman K., Spencer S. Seizure clustering during epilepsy monitoring. Epilepsia 2002, 43:711-715.
30. Heck C.N., King-Stephens D., Massey A.D., Nair D.R., Jobst B.C., Barkley G.L., et al. Two-year seizure reduction in adults with medically intractable partial onset epilepsy treated with responsive neurostimulation: final results of the RNS System Pivotal trial. Epilepsia 2014, 55:432-441.
31. Huang N.E., Shen Z., Long S.R., Wu M.C., Shih H.H., Zheng Q., et al. The empirical mode decomposition and the Hilbert spectrum for nonlinear and non-stationary time series analysis. Proc R Soc London, Ser A: Math Phys Eng Sci 1998, 454:903-995.
32. Iasemidis L.D., Pardalos P.M., Shiau D.-S., Chaovalitwongse W., Narayanan K., Kumar S., et al. Prediction of human epileptic seizures based on optimization and phase changes of brain electrical activity. Optim Meth Softw 2003, 18:81-104.
33. Iasemidis L.D., Sackellares J.C. Chaos theory and epilepsy. Neuroscientist 1996, 2:118-126.
34. Iasemidis L.D., Shiau D.S., Chaovalitwongse W., Sackellares J.C., Pardalos P.M., Principe J.C., et al. Adaptive epileptic seizure prediction system. IEEE Trans Biomed Eng 2003, 50:616-627.
35. Iasemidis L.D., Shiau D.S., Pardalos P.M., Chaovalitwongse W., Narayanan K., Prasad A., et al. Long-term prospective on-line real-time seizure prediction. Clin Neurophysiol 2005, 116:532-544.
36. Ihle M., Feldwisch-Drentrup H., Teixeira C.A., Witon A., Schelter B., Timmer J., et al. EPILEPSIAE-a European epilepsy database. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 2012, 106:127-138.
37. Jansen B.H., Rit V.G. Electroencephalogram and visual evoked potential generation in a mathematical model of coupled cortical columns. Biol Cybern 1995, 73:357-366.
38. Klatt J., Feldwisch-Drentrup H., Ihle M., Navarro V., Neufang M., Teixeira C., et al. The EPILEPSIAE database: an extensive electroencephalography database of epilepsy patients. Epilepsia 2012, 53:1669-1676.
39. Kossoff E.H., Ritzl E.K., Politsky J.M., Murro A.M., Smith J.R., Duckrow R.B., et al. Effect of an external responsive neurostimulator on seizures and electrographic discharges during subdural electrode monitoring. Epilepsia 2004, 45:1560-1567.
40. Kreuz T., Andrzejak R.G., Mormann F., Kraskov A., Stogbauer H., Elger C.E., et al. Measure profile surrogates: a method to validate the performance of epileptic seizure prediction algorithms. Phys Rev E: Stat Nonlinear Soft Matter Phys 2004, 69(6 Pt 1).
41. Krieger D., Litt B. Seizure prediction: its evolution and therapeutic potential. Blue book of neurology: the epilepsies 3 2008, Saunders, Philadelphia, PA. S. Shorvon, T. Pedely (Eds.).
42. Kuhlmann L., Freestone D., Lai A., Burkitt A.N., Fuller K., Grayden D.B., et al. Patient-specific bivariate-synchrony-based seizure prediction for short prediction horizons. Epilepsy Res 2010, 91:214-231.
43. Lange H.H., Lieb J.P., Engel J., Crandall P.H. Temporo-spatial patterns of pre-ictal spike activity in human temporal lobe epilepsy. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1983, 56:543-555.
44. Le Van Quyen M., Foucher J., Lachaux J., Rodriguez E., Lutz A., Martinerie J., et al. Comparison of Hilbert transform and wavelet methods for the analysis of neuronal synchrony. J Neurosci Methods 2001, 111:83-98.
45. Le Van Quyen M., Soss J., Navarro V., Robertson R., Chavez M., Baulac M., et al. Preictal state identification by synchronization changes in long-term intracranial EEG recordings. Clin Neurophysiol 2005, 116:559-568.
46. Lehnertz K. Seizure anticipation techniques: state of the art and future requirements. Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, 2001. Proceedings of the 23rd Annual International Conference of the IEEE 2001, 4121-4123. 4.
47. Lehnertz K., Elger C.E. Neuronal complexity loss in temporal lobe epilepsy: effects of carbamazepine on the dynamics of the epileptogenic focus. Electroencephalogr Clin Neurophysiol 1997, 103:376-380.
48. Lehnertz K., Mormann F., Osterhage H., Muller A., Prusseit J., Chernihovskyi A., et al. State-of-the-art of seizure prediction. J Clin Neurophysiol 2007, 24:147-153. (Official Publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society).
49. Li S., Zhou W., Yuan Q., Liu Y. Seizure prediction using spike rate of intracranial EEG. IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng 2013, 21:880-886.
50. Lopes da Silva F.H., Hoeks A., Smits H., Zetterberg L.H. Model of brain rhythmic activity. The alpha-rhythm of the thalamus. Kybernetik 1974, 15:27-37.
51. Maiwald T., Winterhalder M., Aschenbrenner-Scheibe R., Voss H.U., Schulze-Bonhage A., Timmer J. Comparison of three nonlinear seizure prediction methods by means of the seizure prediction characteristic. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenom 2004, 194:357-368.
52. Mirowski P., Madhavan D., Lecun Y., Kuzniecky R. Classification of patterns of EEG synchronization for seizure prediction. Clin Neurophysiol 2009, 120:1927-1940.
53. Moghim N., Corne D.W. Predicting epileptic seizures in advance. PLoS ONE 2014, 9:e99334.
54. Moran R.J., Stephan K.E., Kiebel S.J., Rombach N., O'Connor W.T., Murphy K.J., et al. Bayesian estimation of synaptic physiology from the spectral responses of neural masses. NeuroImage 2008, 42:272-284.
55. Mormann F. Seizure prediction. Scholarpedia 2008, 3:5770.
56. Mormann F., Andrzejak R.G., Elger C.E., Lehnertz K. Seizure prediction: the long and winding road. Brain 2007, 130:314-333.
57. Mormann F., Andrzejak R.G., Kreuz T., Rieke C., David P., Elger C.E., et al. Automated detection of a preseizure state based on a decrease in synchronization in intracranial electroencephalogram recordings from epilepsy patients. Phys Rev E: Stat Nonlinear Soft Matter Phys 2003, 67:021912.
58. Mormann F., Elger C.E., Lehnertz K. Performance of a seizure warning algorithm based on the dynamics of intracranial EEG. Epilepsy Res 2006, 71:241-242.
59. Mormann F., Elger C.E., Lehnertz K. Seizure anticipation: from algorithms to clinical practice. Curr Opin Neurol 2006, 19:187-193.
60. Mormann F., Jefferys J.G. Neuronal firing in human epileptic cortex: the ins and outs of synchrony during seizures. Epilepsy Curr 2013, 13:100-102.
61. Mormann F., Kreuz T., Andrzejak R.G., David P., Lehnertz K., Elger C.E. Epileptic seizures are preceded by a decrease in synchronization. Epilepsy Res 2003, 53:173-185.
62. Mormann F., Kreuz T., Rieke C., Andrzejak R.G., Kraskov A., David P., et al. On the predictability of epileptic seizures. Clin Neurophysiol 2005, 116:569-587.
63. Mormann F., Lehnertz K., David P., Elger C.E. Mean phase coherence as a measure for phase synchronization and its application to the EEG of epilepsy patients. Physica D: Nonlinear Phenom 2000, 144:358-369.
64. Morrell M.J. Responsive cortical stimulation for the treatment of medically intractable partial epilepsy. Neurology 2011, 77:1295-1304. on behalf of the RNS System in Epilepsy Study Group.
65. Motamedi G.K., Lesser R.P., Miglioretti D.L., Mizuno-Matsumoto Y., Gordon B., Webber W.R., et al. Optimizing parameters for terminating cortical afterdischarges with pulse stimulation. Epilepsia 2002, 43:836-846.
66. Murro A., Park Y., Bergey G., Kossoff E., Ritzl E., Karceski S., et al. Multicenter study of acute responsive stimulation in patients with intractable epilepsy. Epilepsia 2003, 44(Suppl. 9):326.
67. Osorio I., Frei M.G., Sunderam S., Giftakis J., Bhavaraju N.C., Schaffner S.F., et al. Automated seizure abatement in humans using electrical stimulation. Ann Neurol 2005, 57:258-268.
68. Pardalos P.M., Wanpracha C., Iasemidis L.D., Chris Sackellares J., Shiau D.-S., Carney P.R., et al. Seizure warning algorithm based on optimization and nonlinear dynamics. Math Program, Ser A 2004, 101:365-385.
69. Park Y., Luo L., Parhi K.K., Netoff T. Seizure prediction with spectral power of EEG using cost-sensitive support vector machines. Epilepsia 2011, 52:1761-1770.
70. Rong P., Liu A., Zhang J., Wang Y., He W., Yang A., et al. Transcutaneous vagus nerve stimulation for refractory epilepsy: a randomized controlled trial. Clin Sci (Lond) 2014, 10.1042/CS20130518.
71. Rothman S.M. The therapeutic potential of focal cooling for neocortical epilepsy. Neurotherapeutics 2009, 6:251-257.
72. Sackellares J.C., Shiau D.S., Principe J.C., Yang M.C., Dance L.K., Suharitdamrong W., et al. Predictability analysis for an automated seizure prediction algorithm. J Clin Neurophysiol 2006, 23:509-520.
73. Schad A., Schindler K., Schelter B., Maiwald T., Brandt A., Timmer J., et al. Application of a multivariate seizure detection and prediction method to non-invasive and intracranial long-term EEG recordings. Clin Neurophysiol 2008, 119:197-211.
74. Schelter B., Feldwisch-Drentrup H., Ihle M., Schulze-Bonhage A., Timmer J. Seizure prediction in epilepsy: from circadian concepts via probabilistic forecasting to statistical evaluation. Conf Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc, 2011 2011, 1624-1627.
75. Schelter B., Winterhalder M., Maiwald T., Brandt A., Schad A., Schulze-Bonhage A., et al. Testing statistical significance of multivariate time series analysis techniques for epileptic seizure prediction. Chaos 2006, 16:013108.
76. Schevon C.A., Weiss S.A., McKhann G., Goodman R.R., Yuste R., Emerson R.G., et al. Evidence of an inhibitory restraint of seizure activity in humans. Nat Commun 2012, 3:1060.
77. Schindler K., Wiest R., Kollar M., Donati F. EEG analysis with simulated neuronal cell models helps to detect pre-seizure changes. Clin Neurophysiol 2002, 113:604-614.
78. Schulze-Bonhage A., Sales F., Wagner K., Teotonio R., Carius A., Schelle A., et al. Views of patients with epilepsy on seizure prediction devices. Epilepsy Behav: E&B 2010, 18:388-396.
79. Snyder D.E., Echauz J., Grimes D.B., Litt B. The statistics of a practical seizure warning system. J Neural Eng 2008, 5:392-401.
80. Springer U.S., Bowers D., Goodman W.K., Shapira N.A., Foote K.D., Okun M.S. Long-term habituation of the smile response with deep brain stimulation. Neurocase 2006, 12:191-196.
81. Stein A.G., Eder H.G., Blum D.E., Drachev A., Fisher R.S. An automated drug delivery system for focal epilepsy. Epilepsy Res 2000, 39:103-114.
82. Teixeira C.A., Direito B., Feldwisch-Drentrup H., Valderrama M., Costa R.P., Alvarado-Rojas C., et al. EPILAB: a software package for studies on the prediction of epileptic seizures. J Neurosci Methods 2011, 200:257-271.
83. Truccolo W., Donoghue J.A., Hochberg L.R., Eskandar E.N., Madsen J.R., Anderson W.S., et al. Single-neuron dynamics in human focal epilepsy. Nat Neurosci 2011, 14:635-641.
84. van Putten M.J., Zandt B.J. Neural mass modeling for predicting seizures. Clin Neurophysiol 2014, 125:867-868.
85. Williamson J.R., Bliss D.W., Browne D.W., Narayanan J.T. Seizure prediction using EEG spatiotemporal correlation structure. Epilepsy Behav 2012, 25:230-238.
86. Winterhalder M., Maiwald T., Voss H.U., Aschenbrenner-Scheibe R., Timmer J., Schulze-Bonhage A. The seizure prediction characteristic: a general framework to assess and compare seizure prediction methods. Epilepsy Behav 2003, 4:318-325.
87. Winterhalder M., Schelter B., Maiwald T., Brandt A., Schad A., Schulze-Bonhage A., et al. Spatio-temporal patient-individual assessment of synchronization changes for epileptic seizure prediction. Clin Neurophysiol 2006, 117:2399-2413.
88. Winterhalder M., Schelter B., Schulze-Bonhage A., Timmer J. Comment on: "Performance of a seizure warning algorithm based on the dynamics of intracranial EEG". Epilepsy Res 2006, 72:80-81. (Discussion 2-4).
89. Wong S., Gardner A.B., Krieger A.M., Litt B. A stochastic framework for evaluating seizure prediction algorithms using hidden Markov models. J Neurophysiol 2007, 97:2525-2532.
90. Zheng Y., Wang G., Li K., Bao G., Wang J. Epileptic seizure prediction using phase synchronization based on bivariate empirical mode decomposition. Clin Neurophysiol 2014, 125:1104-1111.