The “yellow rain” controversy: Lessons for arms control compliance

Nonproliferation Review

Volumn 8, Issue 1, 2001, Pages 25-42

  Tucker, Jonathan B ^a  

^a MONTEREY INSTITUTE OF INTERNATIONAL STUDIES   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84947223610     PISSN: 10736700     EISSN: 17461766     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/10736700108436836     Document Type: Article

References (133)

1. Alexander M. Haig, Jr., “A Certain Idea of Man: The Democratic Revolution and Its Future,” Current Policy, No. 311 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Department of State, Bureau of Public Affairs, September 13,1981).
2. Peter Pringle, “Political Science: How the Rush to Scientific Judgement on Yellow Rain Embarrassed Both U.S. Science and the U.S. Government,” Atlantic Monthly 256 (October 1985), p. 67.
3. Robert L. Bartley and William P. Kucewicz, “‘Yellow Rain’ and the Future of Arms Agreements,” Foreign Affairs 61 (1983), pp. 805-826.
4. Nicholas Wade, “Toxin Warfare Charges May Be Premature,” Science 214 (October 2,1981), p. 34.
5. Philip M. Boffey, “The Yellow Rain Debate: Scientists Take Sides as Battle Intensifies,” New York Times, June 21,1983, p. Cl.
6. Lois R. Ember, “Yellow Rain,” Chemical and Engineering News 62 (January 9, 1984), pp. 8-34.
7. Stanley Kamow, “U.S. Giving Little Attention to Meos, Once Allies, Now Genocide Target” Washington Post, August 20, 1979.
8. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, Volume II-Supporting Analysis, February 2,1982, DocumentNo. 11/50/37-82 [approved for release with extensive redactions in November 1987], p. 20.
9. U.S. House, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Subcommittee on Asian and Pacific Affairs, Hearing, Use of Chemical Agents in Southeast Asia Since the Vietnam War, 96th Congress, 1st session, December 12, 1979 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1980), p. 4.
10. Erik Guyot, “The Case Is Not Proved,” The Nation 239, p. 465.
11. U.S. House, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Hearing, Use of Chemical Agents in Southeast Asia, p. 4.
12. Robert W. Wannemacher and Stanley L. Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” in Frederick R. Sidell, Ernest T. Takafuji, and David R. Franz, Medical Aspects of Chemical and Biological Warfare (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Army, 1997), p. 659.
13. Gary B. Crocker, “Yellow Rain Dampens Treaty Hopes,” NBC Defense and Technology International 1 (September 1986), p. 7.
14. U.S. House, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Hearing, Use of Chemical Agents in Southeast Asia, p. 73.
15. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, Volume II- Supporting Analysis, p. El.
16. Defense Intelligence Agency, Toxic Chemical Warfare Agents and Weapon Systems—USSR, Report No. DST-162OS-041-83, January31,1983 [declassified May 1, 1998], pp. 16-17.
17. U.S. House, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Hearing, Use of Chemical Agents in Southeast Asia, p. 4.
18. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia, Volume 2, p. El.
19. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Memorandum to Holders, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, March 2, 1983, p. B-l.
20. “Laos: Sowing Death on Phou Bia,” Asiaweek, December 1, 1978.
21. U.S. House, Committee on Foreign Affairs, Hearing, Use of Chemical Agents in Southeast Asia, p. 21.
22. Graham Hovey, “Refugees from Laos Tell of Gas Attack,” New York Times, November 4, 1979.
23. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, Volume 2, pp. E-3, E-4.
24. U.S. Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, Subcommittee on Arms Control, Oceans, International Operations and Environment, Hearing, “Yellow Rain” and Other Forms of Chemical and Biological Warfare in Asia, 97th Congress, 1st session, November 10, 1981 (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1982), p. 11.
25. UPI, “Cambodian Guerillas Maintain that Vietnam is Using Poison Gas,” Washington Star, February 18, 1980, p. 1.
26. Gary B. Crocker, “The ‘Yellow Rain’ Issue: Evidence of Chemical and Toxin Weapons Use in Laos, Cambodia, and Afghanistan,” Comments on Toxicology 2 (Special Issue on “Yellow Rain”) (1988), p. 7.
27. Alexander M. Haig, Jr., March 22,1982, Special Report No. 98, p. 11.
28. William Beecher, “Toxic Weapon Used on Chinese?” Boston Globe, July 30, 1982, p. 16.
29. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, Volume 2, p. E-2.
30. Julian Robinson, Jeanne Guillemin, and Matthew Meselson, “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia: The Story Collapses,” Foreign Policy, No. 68 (Fall 1987), reprinted in Susan Wright, ed., Preventing a Biological Arms Race (Cambridge: MIT Press, 1990), p. 221.
31. Pringle, “Political Science.”
32. H. Bruno Schiefer, “The Differential Diagnosis: Are There Natural Explanations for What is Called ‘Yellow Rain’ and its Alleged Effects?” Comments on Toxicology 2 (1988), p. 53.
33. Crocker, “The ‘Yellow Rain’ Issue,” p. 11.
34. U.S. Senate, Committee on Foreign Relations, Subcommittee on Arms Control, Oceans, International Operations and Environment, Hearing, “Yellow Rain” (Chemical and Toxin Weapons Use): The Arms Control Implications, 98th Cong., 1st session, February 24, 1983 (Washington, D.C., U.S. Government Printing Office, 1983), p. 79.
35. Henry S. Bradsher, “Viets Suspected of Using Gas on Lao Tribes,” Washington Star, August 9,1979.
36. Edward M. Spiers, Chemical Warfare (Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1986), p. 107.
37. Sterling Seagrave, Yellow Rain: A Journey Through the Terror of Chemical Warfare (New York: M. Evans and Co., 1981), p. 34.
38. ABC News Closeup, “Rain of Terror,” broadcast on December 21,1981, 8:00-9:00 p.m. EST, produced by Steve Singer, written by Steve Singer and Bill Redeker.
39. Jane Hamilton-Merritt, “Gas Warfare in Laos: Communism’s Drive to Annihilate a People,” Reader’s Digest, October 1980.
40. David C. Stark, James F. Hertzog, and Maria B. Filinska, “Appendix G: Assessment of Investigations of Alleged CW Use in Laos and Kampuchea,” in Chemical Weapons Convention Verification Technology Research and Development: Assessments of Investigations of Alleged Use of CW (19701993) (Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD: Edgewood Research, Development and Engineering Center, ERDEC-CR-151, May 1994), p. G-2.
41. Victor A. Utgoff, The Challenge of Chemical Weapons: An American Perspective (New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1991), p. 77.
42. U.N. General Assembly Resolution 35/144 C, dated December 12, 1980; Spiers, Chemical Warfare, p. 105.
43. Bartley and Kucewicz, ‘“Yellow Rain’ and the Future of Arms Agreements,” pp. 809-810; Sharon Watson, personal communication with author, December 2000.
44. Wannemacher and Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” p. 660.
45. M. Peraica, B. Radic, A. Lucic, and M. Pavlovic, “Toxic Effects of Mycotoxins in Humans,” Bulletin of the World Health Organization 77 (1999), p.759.
46. M. Yamazaki, “Chemistry of Mycotoxins,” in K. Uraguchi and M. Yamazaki, eds., Toxicology, Biochemistry, and Pathology of Mycotoxins (New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1978), pp. 65-106.
47. Peraica, Radic, Lucic, and Pavlovic, “Toxic Effects of Mycotoxins in Humans,” pp. 754-766.
48. Wannemacher and Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” p. 660.
49. Sharon Watson, in U.S. Department of State, “On-the-Record Briefing on Chemical Warfare in Afghanistan, Laos, and Kampuchea,” Washington, D.C., November 29, 1982 [transcript], p. 26.
50. William S. Augerson, A Review of the Scientific Literature as it Pertains to Gulf War Illnesses, Vol. 5: Chemical and Biological Warfare Agents, Report No. MR-1018/5-OSD (Santa Monica, Calif.: RAND Corp., 2000), p. 70.
51. H.B. Schiefer, “Dynamics of Experimental Trichothecene Mycotoxico- sis,” in John Lacey, ed., Trichothecenes and Other Mycotoxins (New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1985), p. 433.
52. Judith Perera, “Yellow Rain Evidence Does Not Stand Up,” New Scientist, March 22, 1984, p. 4.
53. Schiefer, “The Differential Diagnosis,” pp. 51-62.
54. Wannemacher and Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” p. 666.
55. Kenneth S.K. Chinn, Trichothecenes: Are They Potential Threat Agents? (Dugway, UT: U.S. Army Dugway Proving Ground, Document No. DSG- S-83-502, June 1983, declassified version), p. 2.
56. H.B. Schiefer, “The Possible Use of Chemical Warfare Agents in Southeast Asia,” Conflict Quarterly 3 (1983), p. 38.
57. Alex Ciegler, “Mycotoxins: A New Class of Chemical Weapons,” NBC Defense and Technology International 1 (April 1986), pp. 52-57
58. Colin G. Rousseaux, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins: Real or Imaginary Toxins?” Comments on Toxicology 2 (1988), p. 47;
59. H. B. Schiefer, “Dynamics of Experimental Trichothecene Mycotoxicosis,” p. 434;
60. David L. Bunner, Robert W. Wannemacher, Harold A. Neufield, et al., “Pathophysiology of Acute T-2 Intoxication in the Cynomolgus Monkey and Rat Models,” in Lacey, ed., Trichothecenes and Other Mycotoxins, p. 418.
61. Wannemacher and Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” p. 659.
62. Spiers, Chemical Warfare, p. 106.
63. Joseph D. Rosen, “Yellow Rain” [letter], Science 221 (August 19, 1983), p. 698;
64. Robert T. Rosen and Joseph D. Rosen, “Presence of Four Fusarium Mycotoxins and Synthetic Material in ‘Yellow Rain’,” Biomedical Mass Spectrometry 9 (1982), pp. 443-450.
65. Thomas D. Seeley, Joan W. Nowicke, Matthew Meselson, Jeanne Guillemin, and Prongthep Akratanakul, “Yellow Rain,” Scientific American 253 (September 1985), p. 131.
66. U.S. Department of State, “On-the-Record Briefing,” November 29,1982, p. 15.
67. U.S. Department of State, “On-the-Record Briefing,”., p. 20.
68. U.S. Department of State, “On-the-Record Briefing,”., p. 3.
69. U.S. Department of State, Chemical Warfare in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan: Report to the Congress from Secretary of State Alexander M. Haig, Jr., Special Report No. 98, March 22, 1982.
70. U.S. Department of State, Chemical Warfare in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan: An Update, Reportfrom Secretary of State George Schultz, Special Report No. 104, November 1982.
71. Final Report of the U.N. Group of Experts, U.N. Document No. A/37/ 259, December 1, 1982.
72. Eliot Marshall, “The Soviet Elephant Grass Theory,” Science 217 (July 2, p. 32.
73. Barry Erlick, Defense Intelligence Agency, Washington, D.C., interview with author, April 29,1996.
74. Utgoff, The Challenge of Chemical Weapons, p. 77.
75. Thomas Whiteside, “Annals of the Cold War: The Yellow Rain Com- plex-I,” New Yorker, February 11, 1991, pp. 38-67.
76. Paul Gigot, “Is the United States Crying Wolf on Yellow Rain, or Is Everyone Else Ignoring Evidence?” Wall Street Journal, December 14,1982.
77. U.S. Department of State, “On-the-Record Briefing,” November 29,1982, pp. 19-20.
78. U.S. Information Agency, “Briefing: Robert Dean and Gary Crocker on ‘Yellow Rain’,” Washington, D.C., November 30,1982 [transcript], pp. 1213.
79. Matthew Meselson, personal communication to author, December 11,2000.
80. Joan W. Nowicke and Matthew Meselson, “Yellow Rain-A Palynologi- cal Analysis,” Nature 309 (May 17, 1984), pp. 205-206.
81. Eliot Marshall, “Bugs in the Yellow Rain Theory,” Science 220 (June 24, pp. 1356-1358.
82. Seeley, Nowicke., Meselson, Guillemin, and Akratanakul, A “Yellow Rain,” p. 132.
83. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 224.
84. Zhang Zhongying, Chen Yu-Ming, Chow Shu, and Li Min, “A Study of the Origin and Pollen Analysis of ‘Yellow Rains’ in Northern Jiangsu,” Kexue Tongbao [in Chinese] 22 (1977), pp. 409-412
85. Zhang Zhongying, “Yellow Rain: A Major International Debate of the 1980’s,” Ziran Zazhi [in Chinese] 9 (February 1986), pp. 122-125.
86. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 225.
87. Seeley, Nowicke., Meselson, Guillemin, and Akratanakul, A “Yellow Rain,” pp. 135-137.
88. Seeley, Nowicke., Meselson, Guillemin, and Akratanakul, A “Yellow Rain,”., pp. 129-130.
89. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 234.
90. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,”., pp. 232-233.
91. Grant Evans, The Yellow Rainmakers: Are Chemical Weapons Being Used in S.E. Asia? (London: Verso Editions, 1983).
92. Matthew Meselson, e-mail message to the author, December 13,2000.
93. Elisa D. Harris, “Sverdlovsk and Yellow Rain: Two Cases of Soviet Noncompliance,” International Security 11 (Spring 1987), p. 78.
94. Spiers, Chemical Warfare, p. 114.
95. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 228.
96. Eliot Marshall, “Yellow Rain Evidence Slowly Whittled Away,” Science 233 (July 4,1986), p. 18;
97. “Yellow Rain: British Analyses Find No Toxin,” Nature 321 (May 29, 1986), p. 459.
98. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 229.
99. Thomas D. Seeley, Joan W. Nowicke, Matthew Meselson, and Jeanne Guillemin, “Letter to the Editor,” Scientific American 254 (January 1986), p. 10.
100. Matthew Meselson, e-mail message to the author, December 13, 2000.
101. Sharon Watson, Ph.D., director, Chemical/Biological Warfare Defense, SRS Technologies, Huntsville, Alabama, letter to the author, November 15, 2000.
102. M.E. May, P.J. Hannan, and H.W. Carhart, Yellow Rain (.Trichothecene Mycotoxins): A Synopsis and Recommendations, NRL Memorandum Report 5522 (Washington, D.C.: Naval Research Laboratory, March 27,1985) [Partially declassified under FOIA on April 1,1999], p. 16.
103. G.R. Humphreys and J. Dow, “An Epidemiological Investigation of Alleged CW/BW Incidents in SE Asia” (Ottawa, Canada: Directorate of Preventative Medicine, Surgeon General Branch, National Defence Headquarters, August 11, 1982).
104. Sharon Watson, letter to author, November 15,2000.
105. Schiefer, “The Possible Use of Chemical Warfare Agents,” p. 34.
106. William Kucewicz, “Bee-Feces Theory Still Has No Sting,” Wall Street Journal, September 17,1987.
107. Matthew Meselson, e-mail message to the author, December 13,2000.
108. Sharon Watson, telephone interview with author, December 14,2000.
109. Sharon Watson, letter to the author, November 15,2000.
110. Wannemacher and Wiener, “Trichothecene Mycotoxins,” p. 666.
111. Peter Barss, “Epidemic Field Investigation as Applied to Allegations of Chemical, Biological, or Toxin Warfare,” Politics and the Life Sciences 11 (February 1992), p. 15.
112. Charles Piller and Keith R. Yamamoto, Gene Wars: Military Control Over the New Genetic Technologies (New York: Beech Tree Books/William Morrow, 1988), p. 75.
113. Howard Hu, Robert Cook-Deegan, and Asfandiar Shukri, “The Use of Chemical Weapons: Conducting an Investigation Using Survey Epidemiology,” Journal of the American Medical Association 262 (August 4, 1989), p. 641.
114. Stark, Hertzog, and Filinska, F “Appendix G: Assessment of Investigations of Alleged CW Use,” p. G-16.
115. Stark, Hertzog, and Filinska, F “Appendix G: Assessment of Investigations of Alleged CW Use,”., p. G-20.
116. World Armaments and Disarmament: SIPRI Yearbook 1986 (New York: Oxford University Press, 1986), p. 164.
117. Eliot Marshall, “Yellow Rain and the Cloud of Chemical War,” Science 214 (1981), p. 1008.
118. U.S. Senate, Select Committee on Intelligence, 102nd Congress, 1st session, Hearing, Nomination of Robert M. Gates to be Director of Central Intelligence, Volume 2, September 24, October 1,2,1991 [S.Hrg. 102-799, Vol. 2] (Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1992), p. 144.
119. “Excerpts from Gates’s Testimony on His Record at the C.I.A.,” New York Times, October 4, 1991, p. A12.
120. Author interviews with Gary Crocker (1996), Barry Erlick (1996), and Sharon Watson (2000).
121. Barbara Seiders, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, interview with author, June 25,1996.
122. U.S. Information Agency, “Briefing: Robert Dean and Gary Crocker on ‘Yellow Rain’,” p. 15.
123. Anthony Rimmington, “Invisible Weapons of Mass Destruction: The Soviet Union’s BW Programme and its Implications for Contemporary Arms Control,” Journal of Slavic Military Studies 13 (September 2000), pp. 1-46.
124. Ken Alibek and Stephen Handelman, Biohazard: The Chilling True Story of the Largest Covert Biological Weapons Program in the World—Told from the Inside by the Man Who Ran It (New York: Random House, 1999).
125. Dr. Ken Alibek, Battelle Memorial Institute, Arlington, VA, interview with author, July 2,1998.
126. Special National Intelligence Estimate, Use of Toxins and Other Lethal Chemicals in Southeast Asia and Afghanistan, Volume 1, p. 20.
127. Ernest Blazar, “Inside the Ring: Long Lost Secrets,” Washington Times, June 29, 1998, p. 9.
128. Howard Hu, Jonathan Fine, Paul Epstein, et al., “Tear Gas—Harassing Agent or Toxic Chemical Weapon?” Journal of the American Medical Association 262 (August 4, 1989), pp. 660-663.
129. United States Arms Control and Disarmament Agency (ACDA), “Verification Annex, Part XI: Investigation in Cases of Alleged Use of Chemical Weapons,” Convention on the Prohibition of the Development, Production, Stockpiling and Use of Chemical Weapons and on Their Destruction (W ash- ington, D.C.: ACDA, October 1993), pp. 164-165.
130. Michael Barletta, “Chemical Weapons in the Sudan: Allegations and Evidence,” The Nonproliferation Review 6 (Fall 1998), p. 124.
131. Utgoff, The Challenge of Chemical Weapons, p. 80.
132. Douglas Feith, law firm of Feith and Zell, Washington, D.C., interview with author, April 30, 1996.
133. Robinson, Guillemin, and Meselson, M “Yellow Rain in Southeast Asia,” p. 235.