R.I.P. sidaway: Patientoriented disclosure-A standard worth waiting for?

Medical Law Review

Volumn 23, Issue 3, 2015, Pages 455-466

  Heywood, Rob ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF EAST ANGLIA   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

GREAT BRITAIN; HUMAN; INTERPERSONAL COMMUNICATION; LEGAL ASPECT; LEGISLATION AND JURISPRUDENCE; MALPRACTICE; PREOPERATIVE PERIOD; RISK;

DISCLOSURE; GREAT BRITAIN; HUMANS; MALPRACTICE; PREOPERATIVE PERIOD; RISK;

EID: 84943424847     PISSN: 09670742     EISSN: 14643790     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/medlaw/fwv024     Document Type: Note

References (54)

1. Sarah Devaney, 'Autonomy Rules OK' (2005) 13 Med L Rev 102.
2. Tamsyn Clark and Donal Nolan, 'A Critique of Chester v Afshar' (2014) 34 Oxford J Legal Stud 659.
3. Jane Stapleton, 'Occam's Razor Reveals an Orthodox Basis for Chester v Afshar' (2006). Law Q Rev 426.
4. Montgomery, n 5 at 87-88.
5. Sidaway, n 1.
6. Montgomery, n 5 at [94].
7. Ian Kennedy, 'The Patient on the Clapham Omnibus' (1984) 47 Med L Rev 454.
8. Michael A Jones, 'Informed Consent and Other Fairy Stories' (1999) 7 Med L Rev 103.
9. Margaret Brazier, 'Patient Autonomy and Consent to Treatment: The Role of the Law?' (1987) 7 LS 169.
10. Harvey Teff, 'Consent to Medical Procedures: Paternalism, Self-Determination or Therapeutic Alliance?' (1985) 101 LQR 432.
11. Montgomery, n 5 at [107].
12. Margaret Brazier and Jose Miola, 'Bye-Bye Bolam: A Medical Litigation Revolution?' (2000) 8 Med L Rev 85.
13. Jones, n 12.
14. Rob Heywood, 'Negligent Antenatal Disclosure and Management of Labour' (2011) 19 Med L Rev 140.
15. Brazier and Miola, n 14.
16. Rob Heywood, 'Medical Disclosure of Alternative Treatments' (2009) 68 Cambridge LJ 30.
17. Heywood, n 15.
18. Montgomery, n 5 at [30]-[31].
19. Alasdair MacLean, 'From Sidaway to Pearce and Beyond: Is the Legal Regulation of Consent Any Better Following a Quarter of a Century of Judicial Scrutiny?' (2012) 20 Med L Rev 108 at 125.
20. Alasdair MacLean, 'The Doctrine of Informed Consent: Does It Exist and Has It Crossed the Atlantic?' (2004) 24 Legal Stud 386.
21. Lord Kerr and Lord Reed in Montgomery, n 5 at [68].
22. Montgomery, n 5 at [13].
23. Harvey Teff, Reasonable Care: Legal Perspectives on the Doctor-Patient Relationship (Clarendon: Oxford, 1994)
24. Raymond Tallis, Hippocratic Oaths: Medicine and Its Discontents (Atlantic: London, 2004).
25. Montgomery, n 5 at [46].
26. Montgomery, n 5 at [69].
27. Rob Heywood, 'Subjectivity in Risk Disclosure: Considering the Position of the Particular Patient' (2009) 25 JPN 3.
28. Montgomery, n 5 at [87].
29. Montgomery, n 5 at [46].
30. Jose Miola, 'On the Materiality of Risk: Paper Tigers and Panaceas' (2009) 17 Med L Rev 76.
31. Montgomery, n 5 at [12].
32. Pearce, n 15 at [24].
33. Montgomery, n 5 at [89].
34. Montgomery, n 5 at [93].
35. Karen Tickner, 'Rogers v Whitaker-Giving Patients a Meaningful Choice' (1995) 15 Oxford J Legal Stud 109.
36. Kevin Williams, 'Pre-Operative Consent and Medical Negligence' (1985) 14 Anglo-American Law Rew. at 172.
37. Montgomery, n 5 at [73].
38. Montgomery, n 5 at [75].
39. Montgomery, n 5 at [68] and [93].
40. Montgomery, n 5 at [108].
41. Montgomery, n 5 at [83].
42. Rob Heywood, 'Litigating Labour: Condoning Unreasonable Risk Taking in Childbirth?' (2015) 44 Common Law World Rev 28. Doi:10.1177/1473779514564559.
43. Montgomery, n 5 at [87].
44. Heywood, n 16.
45. Montgomery, n 5 at [90].
46. Jose Miola, 'Autonomy Rued OK?' (2006) 14 Med L Rev 108.
47. Kevin Williams, 'Comprehending Disclosure: Must Patients Understand the Risks They Run?' (2000) 4 Med L Intl 97.
48. Montgomery, n 5 at [88].
49. Montgomery, n 5 at [85].
50. Rob Heywood and others, 'Informed Consent in Hospital Practice: Health Professionals' Perspectives and Legal Reflections' (2010) 18 Med L Rev 152.
51. Rob Heywood and others, 'Patient Perceptions of the Consent Process: Qualitative Inquiry and Legal Reflection (2008) 24 J PN 104.
52. Alasdair MacLean, 'Giving the Reasonable Patient a Voice: Information Disclosure and the Relevance of Empirical Evidence' (2005) 7 Med Law Intl 1.
53. Montgomery, n 5 at [69].
54. Montgomery, n 5 at [77-79].