Advance Directives in Some Western European Countries: A Legal and Ethical Comparison between Spain, France, England, and Germany

European Journal of Health Law

Volumn 22, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 321-345

  Veshi, Denard ^a,b   Neitzke, Gerald ^a,b  

^a Ethics and Philosophy of Medicine   (Germany)

^b HANNOVER MEDICAL SCHOOL   (Germany)

Author keywords

advance directives; English speaking countries; German speaking countries; legal proxy; living will; Romance speaking countries

Indexed keywords

COMPARATIVE STUDY; ETHICS; FRANCE; GERMANY; HUMAN; LEGISLATION AND JURISPRUDENCE; LIVING WILL; SPAIN; UNITED KINGDOM;

ADVANCE DIRECTIVES; FRANCE; GERMANY; GREAT BRITAIN; HUMANS; SPAIN;

EID: 84941028316     PISSN: 09290273     EISSN: 15718093     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1163/15718093-12341368     Document Type: Review

References (74)

1. C. Gabl and R.J. Jox, 'Paternalism and autonomy - no contradiction', Wiener Medizinische Wochenschrift 158(23-24) (2008) 642-649.
2. The Ethicus group analysed questionnaires from patients in intensive care units (ICUs) in seventeen European countries (Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Israel, the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey and the United Kingdom) in 1999-2000.
3. The results were published in these papers: C.L. Sprung, D. Ledoux, H.H. Bulow, A. Lippert, E. Wennberg, M. Baras, B. Ricou, P. Sjokvist, C. Wallis, P. Maia, L.G. Thijs and J. Solsona Duran; Ethicus Study Group, 'Relieving suffering or intentionally hastening death: where do you draw the line?', Critical Care Medicine 36(1) (2008) 8-13;
4. C.L. Sprung, T. Woodcock, P. Sjokvist, B. Ricou, H.H. Bulow, A. Lippert, P. Maia, S. Cohen, M. Baras, S. Hovilehto, D. Ledoux, D. Phelan, E. Wennberg and W. Schobersberger, 'Reasons, considerations, difficulties and documentation of end-of-life decisions in European intensive care units: the Ethicus Study', Intensive Care Medicine 24(2) (2008) 271-277;
5. C.L. Sprung, P. Maia, H.H. Bulow, B. Ricou, A. Armaganidis, M. Baras, E. Wennberg, K. Reinhart, S.L. Cohen, D.R. Fries, G. Nakos and L.G. Thijs; Ethicus Study Group, 'The importance of religious affiliation and culture on end-of-life decisions in European intensive care units', Intensive Care Medicine 33(10) (2007) 1732-1739;
6. J. Benbenishty, F.D. Ganz, A. Lippert, H.H. Bulow, E. Wennberg, B. Henderson, M. Svantesson, M. Baras, D. Phelan, P. Maia and C.L. Sprung, 'Nurse involvement in end-of-life decision making: the Ethicus Study', Intensive Care Medicine 32(1) (2006) 129-132.
7. The results were published in these papers: J. Cohen, J. van Delden, F. Mortier, R. Löfmark, M. Norup, C. Cartwright, K. Faisst, C. Canova, B. Onwuteaka-Philipsen and J. Bilsen; Eureld Consortium, 'Influence of physicians' life stances on attitudes to end-of-life decisions and actual end-of-life decision-making in six countries', Journal of Medical Ethics 34(4) (2008) 247-253;
8. R. Löfmark, T. Nilstun, C. Cartwright, S. Fischer, A. van der Heide, F. Mortier, M. Norup, L. Simonato and B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen; Eureld Consortium, 'Physicians' experiences with end-of-life decision-making: survey in 6 European countries and Australia', BMC Medicine 12(6) (2008) 4;
9. H.M. Buiting, J.J. van Delden, J.A. Rietjens B.D. Onwuteaka-Philipsen, J. Bilsen, S. Fischer, R. Löfmark, G. Miccinesi, M. Norup and A. van der Heide; Eureld-Consortium, 'Forgoing artificial nutrition or hydration in patients nearing death in six European countries', Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 34(3) (2007) 305-314;
10. J.J. van Delden, R. Lfmark, L. Deliens, G. Bosshard, M. Norup, R. Cecioni and A. van der Heide; Eureld Consortium, 'Do-not-resuscitate decisions in six European countries', Critical Care Medicine 34(6) (2006) 1686-1690;
11. J. Bilsen, M. Norup, L. Deliens, G. Miccinesi, G. van der Wal, R. Lfmark, K. Faisst and A. van der Heide; Eureld Consortium, 'Drugs used to alleviate symptoms with life shortening as a possible side effect: end-of-life care in six European countries', Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 31(2) (2006) 111-121.
12. The Ethicatt group examined questionnaires from physicians and nurses working in ICUs, patients who survived ICU, and their families in six European countries (Czech Republic, Israel, The Netherlands, Portugal, Sweden, and the United Kingdom) in 2004.
13. H.H. Bü low, Ch. L. Sprung, M. Baras, S. Carmel, M. Svantesson, J. Benbenishty, P.A. Maia, A. Beishuizen, S. Cohen and D. Nalos, 'Are religion and religiosity important to end-of-life decisions and patient autonomy in the ICU? The Ethicatt study', Intensive Care Medicine 38(7) (2012) 1126-1133;
14. Ch. L. Sprung, S. Carmel, P. Sjokvist, M. Baras, S.L. Cohen, P. Maia, A. Beishuizen, D. Nalos, I. Novak, M. Svantesson, J. Benbenishty and B. Henderson; Ethicatt Study Group, 'Attitudes of European physicians, nurses, patients, and families regarding end-of-life decisions: the Ethicatt study', Intensive Care Medicine 33(1) (2007) 104-110
15. its comment A.M. Vrakking, E.J. Kompanje and J. Bakker, 'Comment on "Attitudes of European physicians, nurses, patients, and families regarding end-of-life decisions: the Ethicatt study" by Sprung et al.', Intensive Care Medicine 33(4) (2007) 747.
16. The results are published in B.A. Daveson, C. Bausewein, F.E. Murtagh, N. Calanzani, I.J. Higginson, R. Harding, J. Cohen, S.T. Simon, L. Deliens, D. Bechinger-English, S. Hall, J. Koffman, P.L. Ferreira, F. Toscani, M. Gysels, L. Ceulemans, D.F. Haugen, B. Gomes; Prisma, 'To be involved or not to be involved: a survey of public preferences for self-involvement in decision-making involving mental capacity (competency) within Europe', Palliative Medicine 27(5) 418-427.
17. Withholding and Withdrawing Life-prolonging Medical Treatment Guidance for Decision Making (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2007) 74.
18. President's Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research, 1982, 'Making Health Care Decisions'. Retrieved 18 March 2015,http://kie.georgetown.edu/nrcbl/documents/pcemr/makingdecisions.pdf;
19. Bundesärztekammer, Zentrale Ethikkommission bei der Bundesärztekammer, 2013, 'Empfehlungen der Bundesärztekammer und der Zentralen Ethikkommission bei der Bundesärztekammer zum Umgang mit Vorsorgevollmacht und Patientenverfügung in der ärztlichen Praxis'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/downloads/Empfehlungen-BAeKZEKO-Vorsorgevollmacht-Patientenverfuegung-19082013l.pdf.
20. As in France, the Italian bill no. 2350 - approved with modification in 2011 and still not passed - was the result of a case-law, that of Eluana Englaro. D. Veshi, 'Withdrawing Treatment from Incompetent Patients in Italy: The Case of Eluana Englaro', Asian Bioethics Review 6(4) (2014) 402-408.
21. A.E. Buchanan and D.W. Brock, Deciding for Others: The Ethics of Surrogate Decision Making (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990) 99, 116.
22. In England: Joint Committee on the Draft Mental Incapacity Bill, 2003, 'Draft Mental Incapacity Bill (1st Report, Session 2002-03, HL 189-I)'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/jt/jtdmi.htm;
23. in Ireland: Minister of State at the Department of Health (Deputy Kathleen Lynch), 2013, 'Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Bill 2013: Second Stage'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://oireachtasdebates.oireachtas.ie/debates%20authoring/debateswebpack.nsf/takes/dail2013120300037?opendocument#KK00700;
24. in Scotland: Scottish Law Commission, 1995, 'Report on Incapable Adults (Part 1)', (Scot Law Com No 151), retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.scotlawcom.gov.uk/publications/reports/1990-1999/.
25. In Austria: Judiciary Committee, 2006, 'Report of the law 2006 - SWRÄG 2006'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/VHG/XXII/I/I-01511/fname-063771.pdf;
26. in Germany: Legal Committee, 2009, 'Recommendation of the legal Committee'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://dipbt.bundestag.de/dip21/btd/16/133/1613314.pdf;
27. and in Switzerland: Swiss National Advisory Commission on Biomedical Ethics, 2011, 'Opinion 17/2011'.Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.nek-cne.ch/fileadmin/nek-cne-dateien/Themen/Stellungnahmen/en/NEK-CNE-Advance-Directives.pdf.
28. In France: National Assembly, 2008, 'Mission d'évaluation de la loi no 2005-370 du 22 avril 2005 relative aux droits des malades et àla fin de vie no 1287'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/13/dossiers/mission-fin-vie.asp;
29. in Italy: National Committee of Bioethics, 2003, 'Dichiarazioni anticipate di trattamento'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.governo.it/bioetica/testi/Dichiarazioni-anticipate-trattamento.pdf.
30. In the Iberian countries risks arising from the implementation of ADs are highlighted through a strict bureaucratic model. In particular, in Spain most Autonomous Communities' regulations establish several formal requirements: M. Navarro-Michel, 'Advance Directives: the Spanish Perspective', Medical Law Review 13(2) (2005) 137-169.
31. A.D. Pereira, 'Living will and health care proxy - the Portuguese legal situation', Medicine and Law 32(4) (2013) 497-502.
32. In Austria, the Federal Minister of Justice is responsible for the implementation of the Sachwalterrechts-Änderungsgesetz 2006 - SWRÄG 2006, law 23 June 2006, governing the role of surrogate
33. and the Federal Minister of Health and Women in agreement with the Federal Minister of Justice is responsible for the implementation of the Patientenverfügungs-Gesetz - PatVG, law of 8 May 2006, governing 'living wills'.
34. D. Parfit, Reasons and Persons (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984).
35. J.H. Lingler, D. Rubin and J.A. Saxton, 'Temporal stability of receptiveness to clinical research on Alzheimer disease in Alzheimer disease', Alzheimer Disease and Associated Disorders 24 (2010) S30-S34;
36. M.N. Witting, K.H. Morales, L.A. Meoni, D.E. Ford, N.Y. Wang, M.J. Klag and J.J. Gallo, 'Stability of preferences for end-of-life treatment after 3 years of follow-up: the Johns Hopkins Precursors Study', Schistosomiasis 168(19) (2008) 2125-2130;
37. P.H. Ditto, W.D. Smucker, J.H. Danks, J.A. Jacobson, R.M. Houts, A. Fagerlin, K.M. Coppola and R.M. Gready, 'Stability of older adults' preferences for life-sustaining medical treatment', Health Psychology: Official Journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association 22(6) (2003) 605-615.
38. M. Costantini, G. Morasso, M. Montella, P. Borgia, R. Cecioni, M. Beccaro, E. Sguazzotti and P. Bruzzi; Isdoc Study Group, 'Diagnosis and prognosis disclosure among cancer patients. Results from an Italian mortality follow-back survey', Annals of Oncology: Official Journal of the European Society for Medical Oncology / ESMO 17(5) (2006) 853-859;
39. R.L. Fainsinger, J.M. Nunez-Olarte and D.M. Demoissac, 'The cultural differences in perceived value of disclosure and cognition: Spain and Canada', Journal of Palliative Care 19(1) (2003) 43-48.
40. M. Costantini, M. Beccaro and I.J. Higginson, 'Cancer trajectories at the end of life: is there an effect of age and gender?', BMC Cancer 2(8) (2008) 127;
41. P.G. Rossi, M. Beccaro, G. Miccinesi, P. Borgia, M. Costantini, F. Chini, D. Baiocchi, G. de Giocomi, M. Grimaldi and M. Montella; The Isdoc Working Group, 'Dying of cancer in Italy: impact on family and caregiver. The Italian Survey of Dying of Cancer', Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 61(6) (2007) 547-554;
42. L. Blanco Toro, S. Librada Flores, J. Rocafort Gil, R. Cabo Dominguez, T. Calea Marin, M.E. Alonso Prado, 'Perfil del cuidador principal del enfermo en situación terminal y análisis del riesgo de desarrollar duelo patológico', Medicina Paliativa 14(3) (2007) 1-5.
43. Eurostat, 2015, 'Crude marriage rate, selected years, 1960-2012' demonstrates that in 2011 the rate of divorce in UK is 2.1 and in Italy is 0.9. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php/Marriage-and-divorce-statistics.
44. R. Pereira, 'Human handicap and self-determination: compassion and insensibility in the Vincent Humbert case', História, ciências, saúde - Manguinhos 14(1) (2007) 119-34;
45. B.M. Dupont, 'Refuse a "Vincent Humbert law', Médecine palliative 4(6) (2005) 309-311.
46. D. Rodríguez-Arias, G. Moutel, M.P. Aulisio, A. Salfati, J. C Coffin, J.L. Rodríguez-Arias, L. Calvo and C Hervé 'Advance directives and the family: French and American perspectives', Clinical Ethics 2(3) (2007) 139-145.
47. A. Steinbock, The Oxford Handbook of Bioethics (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009).
48. R.J. Devettere, Practical Decision Making in Health Care Ethics: Cases and Concepts (Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 2010) 50-52.
49. D. Veshi and G. Neitzke, 'Living wills in Italy: ethical and comparative law approaches', European Journal of Health Law 22(1) (2015) 38-60.
50. J.L. Holley, 'Palliative care in end-stage renal disease: focus on advance care planning, hospice referral, and bereavement', Seminars in Dialysis 18(2) (2005) 154-156.
51. A. Fagerlin, P.H. Ditto, N.A. Hawkins, C.E. Schneider and W.D. Smucker, 'The use of advance directives in end-of-life decision making', American Behavioural Scientist 46(2) (2002) 268-283.
52. R.S. Olick, 'On the Scope and Limits of Advance Directives and Prospective Autonomy' in: P. Lack, N. Biller-Andorno and S. Brauer (eds.), Advance Directives (New York: Springer, 2014) 54.
53. British Medical Association, Advanced Statements about Medical Treatment (London: BMJ Publishing Group, 1995).
54. R. Horn, " 'I don't need my patients' opinion to withdraw treatment": patient preferences at the end-of-life and physician attitudes towards advance directives in England and France', Medicine, Health Care, and Philosophy 17(3) (2014) 425-35.
55. J.J. Rousseau, Du contrat social (Paris, Flammarion, 2001) [original work published 1762].
56. French National Medical Council, 2000, 'Avis sur Fin de vie, arrê de vie, euthanasie'.Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.ccne-ethique.fr/sites/default/files/publications/avis063.pdf.
57. J.V. Zerwekh, Nursing Care at the End of Life Palliative Care for Patients and Families (Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company, 2005).
58. S. Pennec, A. Monnier, S. Pontone and R. Aubry, 'End-of-life medical decisions in France: a death certificate follow-up survey 5 years after the 2005 act of parliament on patients' rights and end of life', BMC Palliative Care 3(11) (2012) 25.
59. J. Locke, The Two Treatises of Government (London: Everyman Paperback, 1993) [original work published 1690].
60. J.S. Mill, On Liberty (New York: Simon & Brown, 2012) [original work published 1865].
61. D.L. Dickenson, 'Cross-cultural issues in European bioethics', Bioethics 13 (3-4) (1999) 249-255.
62. General Medical Council, 2008, 'Consent: Patients and doctors making decisions together', 2008. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.gmc-uk.org/static/documents/content/Consent-English-0914.pdf;
63. General Medical Council, 2010, 'Treatment and care towards the end of life: Good practices in decision making'. Retrieved 18 March 2015, http://www.gmc-uk.org/End-of-life.pdf-32486688.pdf.
64. Airedale NHS Trust v. Bland [1993] 2 WLR 816;
65. G. Neitzke, R. Charbonnier, W. Diemer, A.T. May and T. Wernstedt, 'Göttinger Thesen zur gesetzlichen Regelung des Umgangs mit Patientenverfügung und Vorsorgevollmacht', Ethik in der Medizin 18(2) (2006) 192-194.
66. T.M. Pope, 'The best interest standard: both guide and limit to medical decision making on behalf of incapacitated patients', The Journal of Clinical Ethics 22(2) (2011) 134-138.
67. Simms v. Simms and Another [2003] 1 All E.R. 669.
68. These rulings included in the concept of 'best interest' emotional and other welfare issues. Beforehand, 'best interest' was limited to objective medical criteria F. v. West Berkshire Health Authority [1989] 2 All ER 545.
69. D. Shickle, 'The Mental Capacity Act 2005', Clinical Medicine 6(2) (2006) 169-173.
70. U. Wiesing, R.J. Jox, H.J. Heßler and G.D. Borasio, 'A new law on advance directives in Germany', Journal of Medical Ethics 36(12) (2010) 779-783.
71. N. Evans, C. Bausewein, A. Meñaca, E.V. Andrew, I.J. Higginson, R. Harding, R. Pool and M. Gysels; project PRISMA, 'A critical review of advance directives in Germany: attitudes, use and healthcare professionals' compliance', Patient Education and Counseling 87(3) (2012) 277-288.
72. C. Schroder, G. Schmutzer and E. Brahler, 'Representative survey of German people concerning enlightenment and patient directive in a case of terminal illness', Psychotherapie, Psychosomatik, Medizinische Psychologie 52(5) (2002) 236-243.
73. F.R. Lang and G.G. Wagner, 'Patient living wills in Germany: conditions for their increase and reasons for refusal', Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift 132 (48) (2007) 2558-2562;
74. F. Lang, P. Baltes and G. Wagner, 'Desired lifetime and end-of-life desires across adulthood from 20 to 90: a dual-source information model', The Journals of Gerontology. Series B, Psychological Sciences and Social Sciences 62(5) (2007) 268-278.