Effectiveness of chemical amendments for stabilisation of lead and antimony in risk-based land management of soils of shooting ranges

Environmental Science and Pollution Research

Volumn 22, Issue 12, 2015, Pages 8942-8956

  Sanderson, Peter ^a   Naidu, Ravi ^a   Bolan, Nanthi ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA   (Australia)

Author keywords

Chemical stabilisation; Pb; Sb; Shooting range

Indexed keywords

ANTIMONY; CALCIUM COMPOUNDS; LEAD; LIME; METALS, HEAVY; OXIDES; SOIL; SOIL POLLUTANTS;

CHEMISTRY; HUMANS; SOIL; SOIL POLLUTANTS;

ANTIMONY; CALCIUM COMPOUNDS; HUMANS; LEAD; METALS, HEAVY; OXIDES; SOIL; SOIL POLLUTANTS;

EID: 84931562750     PISSN: 09441344     EISSN: 16147499     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1007/s11356-013-1918-0     Document Type: Article

References (96)

1. Altin O, Ozbelge OH, Dogu T (1999) Effect of pH, flow rate and concentration on the sorption of Pb and Cd on montmorillonite: I. Experimental. J Chem Technol Biotechnol 74:1131–1138
2. Astrup T, Boddum JK, Christensen TH (1999) Lead distribution and mobility in a soil embankment used as a bullet stop at a shooting range. J Soil Contam 8:653–665
3. Bannon DI, Drexler JW, Fent GM, Casteel SW, Hunter PJ, Brattin WJ, Ma M (2009) Evaluation of small arms range soils for metal contamination and lead bioavailability. Environ Sci Technol 43:9071–9076
4. Berti WR, Cunningham SD (1997) In-place inactivation of Pb in Pb-contaminated soils. Environ Sci Technol 31:1359–1364
5. Bertocchi AF, Ghiani M, Peretti R, Zucca A (2006) Red mud and fly ash for remediation of mine sites contaminated with As, Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn. J Hazard Mater 134:112–119
6. Blay K (2000) Sorption wässriger Antimon-Spezies an bodenbildende Festphasen und Remobilisierung durch natürliche Komplexbildner. Ph.D. Thesis, Technical University of Munich
7. Bolan NS, Duraisamy VP (2003) Role of inorganic and organic soil amendments on immobilisation and phytoavailability of heavy metals: a review involving specific case studies. Aust J Soil Res 41:533–555
8. Bolan NS et al (1999) Surface charge and solute interactions in soils. Advances in Agronomy. Academic, New York, pp 87–140
9. Bordas FO, Bourg A (2001) Effect of solid/liquid ratio on the remobilization of Cu, Pb, Cd and Zn from polluted river sediment. Water Air Soil Pollut 128:391–400
10. Brown S, Chaney RL, Hallfrisch JG, Xue Q (2003) Effect of biosolids processing on lead bioavailability in an urban soil. J Environ Qual 32:100–108
11. Brown S, Chaney R, Hallfrisch J, Ryan JA, Berti WR (2004) In situ soil treatments to reduce the phyto- and bioavailability of lead, zinc, and cadmium. J Environ Qual 33:522–531
12. Bruell R, Nikolaidis NP, Long RP (1999) Evaluation of remedial alternatives of lead from shooting range soil. Environ Eng Sci 16:403–414
13. Cao X, Ma LQ, Chen M, Hardison DW, Harris WG (2003) Lead transformation and distribution in the soils of shooting ranges in Florida, USA. Sci Total Environ 307:179–189
14. Cao X, Dermatas D, Xu X, Shen G (2008) Immobilization of lead in shooting range soils by means of cement, quicklime, and phosphate amendments. Environ Sci Pollut Res 15:120–127
15. Chen M, Daroub SH, Ma LQ, Harris WG, Cao X (2002) Characterization of lead in soils of a rifle/pistol shooting range in central Florida, USA. Soil Sediment Contam 11:1–17
16. Conesa HM, Wieser M, Gasser M, Hockmann K, Evangelou MWH, Studer B, Schulin R (2010) Effects of three amendments on extractability and fractionation of Pb, Cu, Ni and Sb in two shooting range soils. J Hazard Mater 181:845–850
17. Cortina J-L, Lagreca I, De Pablo J, Cama J, Ayora C (2003) Passive in situ remediation of metal-polluted water with caustic magnesia: evidence from column experiments. Environ Sci Technol 37:1971–1977
18. Debela F, Arocena JM, Thring RW, Whitcombe T (2010) Organic acid-induced release of lead from pyromorphite and its relevance to reclamation of Pb-contaminated soils. Chemosphere 80:450–456
19. Dermatas D, Cao X, Tsaneva V, Shen G, Grubb D (2006a) Fate and behavior of metal(loid) contaminants in an organic matter-rich shooting range soil: implications for remediation. Water, Air, Soil Pollut Focus 6:143–155
20. Dermatas D, Shen G, Chrysochoou M, Grubb DG, Menounou N, Dutko P (2006b) Pb speciation versus TCLP release in army firing range soils. J Hazard Mater 136:34–46, Selected proceedings of the seventh biennial protection and restoration of the environment international conference
21. Dermatas D, Chrysochoou M, Grubb DG, Xu X (2008) Phosphate treatment of firing range soils: lead fixation or phosphorus release? J Environ Qual 37:47–56
22. Dermont G, Bergeron M, Mercier G, Richer-Laflèche M (2008) Soil washing for metal removal: a review of physical/chemical technologies and field applications. J Hazard Mater 152:1–31
23. Drexler JW, Brattin WJ (2007) An in vitro procedure for estimation of lead relative bioavailability: with validation. Hum Ecol Risk Assess Int J 13:383–401
24. Gougar MLD, Scheetz BE, Roy DM (1996) Ettringite and C-S-H Portland cement phases for waste ion immobilization: a review. Waste Manage 16:295–303
25. Griggs CS, Martin WA, Larson SL, O’Connnor G, Fabian G, Zynda G, Mackie D (2011) The effect of phosphate application on the mobility of antimony in firing range soils. Sci Total Environ 409:2397–2403
26. Hashimoto Y, Matsufuru H, Sato T (2008) Attenuation of lead leachability in shooting range soils using poultry waste amendments in combination with indigenous plant species. Chemosphere 73:643–649
27. Hashimoto Y, Matsufuru H, Takaoka M, Tanida H, Sato T (2009a) Impacts of chemical amendment and plant growth on lead speciation and enzyme activities in a shooting range soil: an X-ray absorption fine structure investigation. J Environ Qual 38:1420
28. Hashimoto Y, Takaoka M, Oshita K, Tanida H (2009b) Incomplete transformations of Pb to pyromorphite by phosphate-induced immobilization investigated by X-ray absorption fine structure (XAFS) spectroscopy. Chemosphere 76:616–622
29. Hashimoto Y, Taki T, Sato T (2009c) Sorption of dissolved lead from shooting range soils using hydroxyapatite amendments synthesized from industrial byproducts as affected by varying pH conditions. J Environ Manage 90:1782–1789
30. Hashimoto Y, Taki T, Sato T (2009d) Extractability and leachability of Pb in a shooting range soil amended with poultry litter ash: investigations for immobilization potentials. J Environ Sci Health A Toxicol/Hazard Subst Environ Eng 44:583–590
31. Heier LS, Lien IB, Strømseng AE, Ljønes M, Rosseland BO, Tollefsen K-E, Salbu B (2009) Speciation of lead, copper, zinc and antimony in water draining a shooting range—time dependant metal accumulation and biomarker responses in brown trout (Salmo trutta L.). Sci Total Environ 407:4047–4055
32. Hettiarachchi GM, Pierzynski GM, Ransom MD (2001) In situ stabilization of soil lead using phosphorus. J Environ Qual 30:1214–1221
33. Hui CA (2002) Lead distribution throughout soil, flora, and an invertebrate at a wetland skeet range. J Toxicol Environ Health A 65:1093–1107
34. Johnson DW, Cole DW (1980) Anion mobility in soils: relevance to nutrient transport from forest ecosystems. Environ Int 3:79–90
35. Johnson CA, Moench H, Wersin P, Kugler P, Wenger C (2005) Solubility of antimony and other elements in samples taken from shooting ranges. J Environ Qual 34:248–254
36. Jorgensen SS, Willems M (1987) The fate of lead in soils: the transformation of lead pellets in shooting range soils. Ambio 16:11–15
37. Kilgour DW, Moseley RB, Barnett MO, Savage KS, Jardine PM (2008) Potential negative consequences of adding phosphorus-based fertilizers to immobilize lead in soil. J Environ Qual 37:1733–1740
38. Klitzke S, Lang F (2009) Mobilization of soluble and dispersible lead, arsenic, and antimony in a polluted, organic-rich soil—effects of pH increase and counterion valency. J Environ Qual 38:933–939
39. Klitzke S, Lang F, Kaupenjohann M (2008) Increasing pH releases colloidal lead in a highly contaminated forest soil. Eur J Soil Sci 59:265–273
40. Knechtenhofer LA, Xifra IO, Scheinost AC, Fluhler H, Kretzschmar R (2003) Fate of heavy metals in a strongly acidic shooting-range soil: small-scale metal distribution and its relation to preferential water flow. J Plant Nutr Soil Sci 166:84–92
41. Krupka KM, Serne RJ (2002) Geochemical factors affecting the behavior of antimony, cobalt, europium, technetium, and uranium in vadose sediments. Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, PNNL-14126
42. Lang F, Kaupenjohann M (2003) Effect of dissolved organic matter on the precipitation and mobility of the lead compound chloropyromorphite in solution. Eur J Soil Sci 54:139–148
43. Laporte-Saumure M, Martel R, Mercier G (2010) Evaluation of physicochemical methods for treatment of Cu, Pb, Sb, and Zn in Canadian small arm firing ranges backstop soils. Water, Air, & Soil Pollution 213:171–189
44. Levonmäki M, Hartikainen H (2007) Efficiency of liming in controlling the mobility of lead in shooting range soils as assessed by different experimental approaches. Sci Total Environ 388:1–7
45. Lin Z (1996) Secondary mineral phases of metallic lead in soils of shooting ranges from Örebro County, Sweden. Environ Geol 27:370–375
46. Lin Z, Comet B, Qvarfort U, Herbert R (1995) The chemical and mineralogical behaviour of Pb in shooting range soils from central Sweden. Environ Pollut 89:303–309
47. Lombi E, Zhao F-J, Zhang G, Sun B, Fitz W, Zhang H, McGrath SP (2002) In situ fixation of metals in soils using bauxite residue: chemical assessment. Environ Pollut 118:435–443
48. Ma QY, Traina SJ, Logan TJ, Ryan JA (1993) In situ lead immobilization by apatite. Environ Sci Technol 27:1803–1810
49. Ma QY, Traina SJ, Logan TJ, Ryan JA (1994a) Effects of aqueous Al, Cd, Cu, Fe(II), Ni, and Zn on Pb immobilization by hydroxyapatite. Environ Sci Technol 28:1219–1228
50. Ma QY, Logan TJ, Traina SJ, Ryan JA (1994b) Effects of NO3−, Cl−, F−, SO4 2−, and CO3 2− on Pb2+ immobilization by hydroxyapatite. Environ Sci Technol 28:408–418
51. Ma L, Hardison D, Harris W, Cao X, Zhou Q (2007) Effects of soil property and soil amendment on weathering of abraded metallic Pb in shooting ranges. Water Air Soil Pollut 178:297–307
52. Martinez CE, Jacobson A, McBride MB (2001) Thermally induced changes in metal solubility of contaminated soils is linked to mineral recrystallization and organic matter transformations. Environ Sci Technol 35:908–916
53. McKenzie R (1980) The adsorption of lead and other heavy metals on oxides of manganese and iron. Aust J Soil Res 18:61–73
54. McLaren RG, Rooney CP, Condron LM (2009) Control of lead solubility in soil contaminated with lead shot: effect of soil moisture and temperature. Aust J Soil Res 47:296–304
55. Medlin EA (1997) An in vitro method for estimating the relative bioavailability of lead in humans. Masters thesis. Department of Geological Sciences, University of Colorado, Boulder.
56. Migliorini M, Pigino G, Bianchi N, Bernini F, Leonzio C (2004) The effects of heavy metal contamination on the soil arthropod community of a shooting range. Environ Pollut 129:331–340
57. Moreno AM, Quintana JR, Pérez L, Parra JG (2006) Factors influencing lead sorption–desorption at variable added metal concentrations in Rhodoxeralfs. Chemosphere 64:758–763
58. Moseley RA, Barnett MO, Stewart MA, Mehlhorn TL, Jardine PM, Ginder-Vogel M, Fendorf S (2008) Decreasing lead bioaccessibility in industrial and firing range soils with phosphate-based amendments. J Environ Qual 37:2116–2124
59. Mukherjee AB (1994) Fluxes of lead, cadmium and mercury in the Finnish environment and the use of biomonitors in checking trace metals. Environmentalica Fenn 18:1–59
60. Naidu R, Mcclure S, Mckenzie N, Fitzpatrick R (1996) Soil solution composition and aggregate stability changes caused by long-term farming at four contrasting sites in South Australia. Aust J Soil Res 34:511–527
61. Naidu R, Bolan NS, Megharaj M, Juhasz AL, Gupta S, Clothier B, Schulin R (2008) Chemical bioavailability in terrestrial environments. In: Naidu et al. (eds) Chemical bioavailability in terrestrial environment. Elsevier, Amsterdam, pp 1–6. ISBN 978-0-444-52
62. Nriagu JO (1974) Lead orthophosphates—IV formation and stability in the environment. Geochim Cosmochim Acta 38:887–898
63. Okazaki M, Kimura SD, Kikuchi T, Igura M, Hattori T, Abe T (2008) Suppressive effects of magnesium oxide materials on cadmium uptake and accumulation into rice grains: I: characteristics of magnesium oxide materials for cadmium sorption. J Hazard Mater 154:287–293
64. Ono H, Wada SI (2006) Reactions of lead ion in mixtures of silica and magnesia. J Fac Agric Kyushu Univ 51(2):437–440
65. Park JH, Bolan NS, Chung JW, Naidu R, Megharaj M (2011a) Environmental monitoring of the role of phosphate compounds in enhancing immobilization and reducing bioavailability of lead in contaminated soils. J Environ Monit 13:2234–2242
66. Park JH, Lamb D, Paneerselvam P, Choppala G, Bolan N, Chung J-W (2011b) Role of organic amendments on enhanced bioremediation of heavy metal(loid) contaminated soils. J Hazard Mater 185:549–574
67. Peddicord RK, LaKind JS (2000) Ecological and human health risks at an outdoor firing range. Environ Toxicol Chem 19:2602–2613
68. Puls R et al (1991) Effects of pH, solid/solution ratio, ionic strength, and organic acids on Pb and Cd sorption on kaolinite. Water Air Soil Pollut 57–58:423–430
69. Rooney CP, McLaren RG, Condron LM (2007) Control of lead solubility in soil contaminated with lead shot: effect of soil pH. Environ Pollut 149:149–157
70. Ruby MV, Davis A, Schoof R, Eberle S, Sellstone CM (1996) Estimation of lead and arsenic bioavailability using a physiologically based extraction test. Environ Sci Technol 30:422LP–430LP
71. Ryan JA, Zhang P, Hesterberg D, Chou J, Sayers DE (2001) Formation of chloropyromorphite in a lead-contaminated soil amended with hydroxyapatite. Environ Sci Technol 35:3798–3803
72. Ryan JA, Scheckel KG, Berti WR, Brown SL, Casteel SW, Chaney RL, Hallfrisch J, Doolan M, Grevatt P, Maddaloni M, Mosby D (2004) Peer reviewed: reducing Children’s risk from lead in soil. Environ Sci Technol 38:18A–24A
73. Sanderson P, Naidu R, Bolan N, Bowman M, McLure S (2012) Effect of soil type on distribution and bioaccessibility of metal contaminants in shooting range soils. Sci Total Environ 438:452–462
74. Sauve S, McBride M, Hendershot W (1998) Soil solution speciation of lead(II): effects of organic matter and pH. Soil Sci Soc Am J 62:618–621
75. Scheckel KG, Ryan JA, Allen D, Lescano NV (2005) Determining speciation of Pb in phosphate-amended soils: method limitations. Sci Total Environ 350:261–272
76. Scheidegger AM, Lamble GM, Sparks DL (1997) Spectroscopic evidence for the formation of mixed-cation hydroxide phases upon metal sorption on clays and aluminum oxides. J Colloid Interface Sci 186:118–128
77. Scheuhammer AM, Norris SL (1995) A review of the environmental impacts of lead shotshell ammunition and lead fishing weights in Canada, rep. no. 88. Minister of Environment Canadian Wildlife Service, Ottawa, pp 3–23
78. Shao L, Zhou Y, Chen JF, Wu W, Lu SC (2005) Buffer behavior of brucite in removing copper from acidic solution. Miner Eng 18:639–641
79. Sorvari J (2007) Jerome, ON, shooting ranges: environmental contamination. Encyclopedia of environmental health. Elsevier, Burlington, pp 41–50
80. Sorvari J, Antikainen R, Pyy O (2006) Environmental contamination at Finnish shooting ranges—the scope of the problem and management options. Sci Total Environ 366:21–31
81. Spuller C, Weigand H, Marb C (2007) Trace metal stabilisation in a shooting range soil: mobility and phytotoxicity. J Hazard Mater 141:378–387
82. Stanforth RR (2003) Reducing lead bioavailability. US patent no: 6590133B2
83. Stanforth R, Qiu J (2001) Effect of phosphate treatment on the solubility of lead in contaminated soil. Environ Geol 41:1–10
84. Stanforth R, Yap C-F, Nayar R (2005) Effects of weathering on treatment of lead contaminated soils. J Environ Eng 131:38–48
85. Stromseng AE, Ljones M, Bakka L, Mariussen E (2009) Episodic discharge of lead, copper and antimony from a Norwegian small arm shooting range. J Environ Monit 11:1259–1267
86. Turpeinen R, Salminen J, Kairesalo T (2000) Mobility and bioavailability of lead in contaminated boreal forest soil. Environ Sci Technol 34:5152–5156
87. USEPA (1986) Method 9081 cation-exchange capacity of soils (sodium acetate). USEPA, Washington, DC
88. USEPA (1992) USEPA method 1311 toxicity characteristic leaching procedure. USEPA, Washington, DC
89. USEPA (2001): Best management practices for lead at outdoor shooting ranges, EPA-902-B-01-001. USEPA, Washington, DC
90. Wilde EW, Brigmon RL, Dunn DL, Heitkamp MA, Dagnan DC (2005) Phytoextraction of lead from firing range soil by Vetiver grass. Chemosphere 61:1451–1457
91. Wildt C, Gibert O, Cortina J, Coscera G (2004) On-site remediation of chromium-contaminated sediments by combination of sediment washing and stabilization with magnesium oxide/limestone mixtures. J Soils Sediments 4:184
92. Wilson SC, Lockwood PV, Ashley PM, Tighe M (2010) The chemistry and behaviour of antimony in the soil environment with comparisons to arsenic: a critical review. Environ Pollut 158:1169–1181
93. Wright J, Rice KR, Murphy B, Conca JL (2004) PIMS using apatite II: remediation of Pb-contaminated range soil at Camp Stanley storage activity, TX. Proceedings of the conference on sustainable range management. New Orleans
94. Wu WX, Shao L, Chen JF, Lu SC (2007) Investigation on mechanisms of Cu super(2+) immobilization by brucite. Fresenius Environ Bull 16(1):29–33
95. Yang J, Mosby D (2006) Field assessment of treatment efficacy by three methods of phosphoric acid application in lead-contaminated urban soil. Sci Total Environ 366:136–142
96. Yin X, Gao B, Ma LQ, Saha UK, Sun H, Wang G (2010) Colloid-facilitated Pb transport in two shooting-range soils in Florida. J Hazard Mater 177:620–625