Wildlife camera trapping: A review and recommendations for linking surveys to ecological processes

Journal of Applied Ecology

Volumn 52, Issue 3, 2015, Pages 675-685

  Burton, A Cole ^a,b   Neilson, Eric ^c   Moreira, Dario ^c   Ladle, Andrew ^c   Steenweg, Robin ^d   Fisher, Jason T ^a,b   Bayne, Erin ^c   Boutin, Stan ^c  

^a Alberta Innovates Technology Future   (Canada)

^b UNIVERSITY OF VICTORIA   (Canada)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA   (Canada)

^d UNIVERSITY OF MONTANA   (United States)

Author keywords

Animal movement; Camera trap; Capture recapture; Density estimation; Imperfect detection; Mammal monitoring; Occupancy model; Relative abundance; Sampling error; Wildlife survey methodology

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; BIODIVERSITY; CAPTURE METHOD; LITERATURE REVIEW; MOVEMENT; RELATIVE ABUNDANCE; SAMPLING; WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT;

ANIMALIA; MAMMALIA;

EID: 84929656572     PISSN: 00218901     EISSN: 13652664     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/1365-2664.12432     Document Type: Review

References (60)

1. Ahumada, J.A., Hurtado, J. & Lizcano, D. (2013) Monitoring the status and trends of tropical forest terrestrial vertebrate communities from camera trap data: a tool for conservation. PLoS ONE, 8, e73707.
2. Anderson, D.R. (2001) The need to get the basics right in wildlife field studies. Wildlife Society Bulletin, 29, 1294-1297.
3. Bailey, L.L., MacKenzie, D.I. & Nichols, J.D. (2014) Advances and applications of occupancy models. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 5, 1269-1279.
4. Bailey, L.L., Hines, J.E., Nichols, J.D. & MacKenzie, D.I. (2007) Sampling design trade-offs in occupancy studies with imperfect detection: examples and software. Ecological Applications, 17, 281-290.
5. Bengsen, A.J., Leung, L.K., Lapidge, S.J. & Gordon, I.J. (2011) Using a general index approach to analyze camera-trap abundance indices. Journal of Wildlife Management, 75, 1222-1227.
6. Blanc, L., Marboutin, E., Gatti, S. & Gimenez, O. (2013) Abundance of rare and elusive species: empirical investigation of closed versus spatially explicit capture-recapture models with lynx as a case study. Journal of Wildlife Management, 77, 372-378.
7. Brodie, J.F. & Giordano, A. (2013) Lack of trophic release with large mammal predators and prey in Borneo. Biological Conservation, 163, 58-67.
8. Burton, A.C., Sam, M.K., Balangtaa, C. & Brashares, J.S. (2012) Hierarchical multi-species modeling of carnivore responses to hunting, habitat and prey in a West African protected area. PLoS ONE, 7, e38007.
9. Carbone, C., Christie, S., Conforti, K., Coulson, T., Franklin, N., Ginsberg, J.R. et al. (2001) The use of photographic rates to estimate densities of tigers and other cryptic mammals. Animal Conservation, 4, 75-79.
10. Caughley, G. (1977) Analysis of Vertebrate Populations. John Wiley and Sons, New York city, New York, USA.
11. Chandler, R.B. & Royle, J.A. (2013) Spatially-explicit models for inference about density in unmarked populations. Annals of Applied Statistics, 7, 936-954.
12. Claridge, A.W. & Paull, D.J. (2014) How long is a piece of string? Camera trapping methodology is question dependent. Camera Trapping: Wildlife Management and Research (eds P. Meek, P. Fleming, G. Ballard, P. Banks, A. Claridge, J. Sanderson & D. Swann ), pp. 206-214. CSIRO Publishing, Collingwood.
13. Efford, M.G. & Dawson, D.K. (2012) Occupancy in continuous habitat. Ecosphere, 3, art32.
14. Fisher, J.T., Wheatley, M. & Mackenzie, D. (2014) Spatial patterns of breeding success of grizzly bears derived from hierarchical multistate models. Conservation Biology, 28, 1249-1259.
15. Foster, R.J. & Harmsen, B.J. (2012) A critique of density estimation from camera-trap data. Journal of Wildlife Management, 76, 224-236.
16. Glen, A.S., Cockburn, S., Nichols, M., Ekanayake, J. & Warburton, B. (2013) Optimising camera traps for monitoring small mammals. PLoS ONE, 8, e67940.
17. Harmsen, B.J., Foster, R.J., Silver, S., Ostro, L. & Doncaster, C.P. (2010) Differential use of trails by forest mammals and the implications for camera-trap studies: a case study from Belize. Biotropica, 42, 126-133.
18. Hebblewhite, M. & Haydon, D.T. (2010) Distinguishing technology from biology: a critical review of the use of GPS telemetry data in ecology. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, 365, 2303-2312.
19. Jennelle, C.S., Runge, M.C. & MacKenzie, D.I. (2002) The use of photographic rates to estimate densities of tigers and other cryptic mammals: a comment on misleading conclusions. Animal Conservation, 5, 119-120.
20. Johnson, D.H. (2008) In defense of indices: the case of bird surveys. Journal of Wildlife Management, 72, 857-868.
21. Karanth, K.U. & Nichols, J.D. (1998) Estimation of tiger densities in India using photographic captures and recaptures. Ecology, 79, 2852-2862.
22. Kjellander, P., Hewison, A.J.M., Liberg, O., Angibault, J., Bideau, E. & Cargnelutti, B. (2004) Experimental evidence for density-dependence of home-range size in roe deer (Capreolus capreolus L.): a comparison of two long-term studies. Oecologia, 139, 478-485.
23. Krebs, C.J. (1999) Ecological Methodology, 2nd edn. Addison Wesley Longman, Menlo Park.
24. Kucera, T.E. & Barrett, R.H. (2011) A history of camera trapping. Camera Traps in Animal Ecology (eds A.F. O'Connell, J.D. Nichols & K.U. Karanth ), pp. 9-26. Springer, New York city, New York, USA.
25. Kuprewicz, E.K. (2013) Mammal abundances and seed traits control the seed dispersal and predation roles of terrestrial mammals in a Costa Rican forest. Biotropica, 45, 333-342.
26. Linkie, M., Guillera-Arroita, G., Smith, J., Ario, A., Bertagnolio, G., Cheong, F. et al. (2013) Cryptic mammals caught on camera: assessing the utility of range wide camera trap data for conserving the endangered Asian tapir. Biological Conservation, 162, 107-115.
27. Long, R.A., MacKay, P., Zielinski, W.J. & Ray, J.C. (eds.) (2008) Noninvasive Survey Methods for Carnivores. Island Press, Washington, District of Columbia, USA.
28. MacKenzie, D.I. & Bailey, L.L. (2004) Assessing the fit of site-occupancy models. Journal of Agricultural Biological and Environmental Statistics, 9, 300-318.
29. MacKenzie, D.I., Nichols, J.D., Lachman, G.B., Droege, S., Royle, J.A. & Langtimm, C.A. (2002) Estimating site occupancy rates when detection probabilities are less than one. Ecology, 83, 2248-2255.
30. MacKenzie, D.I., Nichols, J.D., Royle, J.A., Pollock, K.H., Bailey, L.L. & Hines, J.E. (2006) Occupancy Estimation and Modeling: Inferring Patterns and Dynamics of Species Occurrence. Elsevier Academic Press, London.
31. Magoun, A.J., Long, C.D., Schwartz, M.K., Pilgrim, K.L., Lowell, R.E. & Valkenburg, P. (2011) Integrating motion-detection cameras and hair snags for wolverine identification. Journal of Wildlife Management, 75, 731-739.
32. Meek, P.D., Ballard, G.A. & Fleming, P.J.S. (2015) The pitfalls of wildlife camera trapping as a survey tool in Australia. Australian Mammalogy, 37, 13-22.
33. Meek, P.D., Ballard, G., Claridge, A., Kays, R., Moseby, K., O'Brien, T. et al. (2014a) Recommended guiding principles for reporting on camera trapping research. Biodiversity and Conservation, 23, 2321-2343.
34. Meek, P., Fleming, P., Ballard, G., Banks, P., Claridge, A., Sanderson, J. & Swann, D. (2014b) Camera Trapping: Wildlife Management and Research. CSIRO Publishing, Collingwood.
35. O'Brien, T.G. (2011) Abundance, density and relative abundance: a conceptual framework. Camera Traps in Animal Ecology (eds A.F. O'Connell, J.D. Nichols & K.U. Karanth ), pp. 71-96. Springer, New York city, New York, USA.
36. O'Brien, T.G., Kinnaird, M.F. & Wibisono, H.T. (2003) Crouching tigers, hidden prey: sumatran tiger and prey populations in a tropical forest landscape. Animal Conservation, 6, 131-139.
37. O'Brien, T.G., Baillie, J.E.M., Krueger, L. & Cuke, M. (2010) The wildlife picture index: monitoring top trophic levels. Animal Conservation, 13, 335-343.
38. O'Connell, A.F. & Bailey, L.L. (2011) Inference for occupancy and occupancy dynamics. Camera Traps in Animal Ecology (eds A.F. O'Connell, J.D. Nichols & K.U. Karanth ), pp. 191-204. Springer, New York city, New York, USA.
39. O'Connell, A.F., Nichols, J.D. & Karanth, K.U. (eds.) (2011) Camera Traps in Animal Ecology: Methods and Analyses. Springer, New York city, New York, USA.
40. O'Connell, A., Talancy, N., Bailey, L., Sauer, J., Cook, R. & Gilbert, A. (2006) Estimating site occupancy and detection probability parameters for meso-and large mammals in a coastal ecosystem. Journal of Wildlife Management, 70, 1625-1633.
41. du Preez, B.D., Loveridge, A.J. & Macdonald, D.W. (2014) To bait or not to bait: a comparison of camera-trapping methods for estimating leopard Panthera pardus density. Biological Conservation, 176, 153-161.
42. Rota, C.T., Fletcher, R.J., Dorazio, R.M. & Betts, M.G. (2009) Occupancy estimation and the closure assumption. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 1173-1181.
43. Rovero, F. & Marshall, A.R. (2009) Camera trapping photographic rate as an index of density in forest ungulates. Journal of Applied Ecology, 46, 1011-1017.
44. Rovero, F., Zimmermann, F., Berzi, D. & Meek, P. (2013) "Which camera trap type and how many do I need?" A review of camera features and study designs for a range of wildlife research applications. Hystrix, 24, 148-156.
45. Rowcliffe, J.M., Field, J., Turvey, S.T. & Carbone, C. (2008) Estimating animal density using camera traps without the need for individual recognition. Journal of Applied Ecology, 45, 1228-1236.
46. Rowcliffe, J.M., Carbone, C., Jansen, P.A., Kays, R. & Kranstauber, B. (2011) Quantifying the sensitivity of camera traps: an adapted distance sampling approach. Methods in Ecology and Evolution, 2, 464-476.
47. Royle, J.A., Chandler, R.B., Sollmann, R. & Gardner, B. (2014) Spatial Capture-Recapture. Academic Press, Waltham.
48. Sarmento, P., Cruz, J., Eira, C. & Fonseca, C. (2009) Evaluation of camera trapping for estimating red fox abundance. Journal of Wildlife Management, 73, 1207-1212.
49. Sollmann, R., Mohamed, A., Samejima, H. & Wilting, A. (2013a) Risky business or simple solution - relative abundance indices from camera-trapping. Biological Conservation, 159, 405-412.
50. Sollmann, R., Gardner, B., Chandler, R.B., Shindle, D.B., Onorato, D.P., Royle, J.A. & O'Connell, A.F. (2013b) Using multiple data sources provides density estimates for endangered Florida panther. Journal of Applied Ecology, 50, 961-968.
51. Srbek-Araujo, A.C. & Chiarello, A.G. (2013) Influence of camera-trap sampling design on mammal species capture rates and community structures in southeastern Brazil. Biota Neotropica, 13, 51-62.
52. Steinmetz, R., Seuaturien, N. & Chutipong, W. (2013) Tigers, leopards, and dholes in a half-empty forest: assessing species interactions in a guild of threatened carnivores. Biological Conservation, 163, 68-78.
53. Switalski, T.A. & Nelson, C.R. (2011) Efficacy of road removal for restoring wildlife habitat: black bear in the northern Rocky Mountains, USA. Biological Conservation, 144, 2666-2673.
54. Tobler, M.W., Carrillo-Percastegui, S.E., Leite Pitman, R., Mares, R. & Powell, G. (2008) An evaluation of camera traps for inventorying large- and medium-sized terrestrial rainforest mammals. Animal Conservation, 11, 169-178.
55. Wang, Y. & Fisher, D.O. (2012) Dingoes affect activity of feral cats, but do not exclude them from the habitat of an endangered macropod. Wildlife Research, 39, 611-620.
56. Watts, D.E., Parker, I.D., Lopez, R.R., Silvy, N.J. & Davis, D.S. (2008) Distribution and abundance of endangered Florida key deer on outer islands. Journal of Wildlife Management, 72, 360-366.
57. Wearn, O.R., Rowcliffe, J.M., Carbone, C., Bernard, H. & Ewers, R.M. (2013) Assessing the status of wild felids in a highly-disturbed commercial forest reserve in Borneo and the implications for camera trap survey design. PLoS ONE, 8, e77598.
58. Wellington, K., Bottom, C., Merrill, C. & Litvaitis, J.A. (2014) Identifying performance differences among trail cameras used to monitor forest mammals. Wildlife Society Bulletin, 38, 634-638.
59. Williams, B.K., Nichols, J.D. & Conroy, M.J. (2002) Analysis and Management of Animal Populations. Academic Press, San Diego, California, USA.
60. Zero, V.H., Sundaresan, S.R., O'Brien, T.G. & Kinnaird, M.F. (2013) Monitoring an endangered savannah ungulate, Grevy's zebra Equus grevyi: choosing a method for estimating population densities. Oryx, 47, 410-419.