A critique of density estimation from camera-trap data

Journal of Wildlife Management

Volumn 76, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 224-236

  Foster, Rebecca J ^a,b,c   Harmsen, Bart J ^a,b,c  

^a PANTHERA   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF SOUTHAMPTON   (United Kingdom)

^c UNIVERSITY OF BELIZE   (Belize)

Author keywords

abundance estimation; camera trap; capture recapture; closed population model; density estimation

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE ESTIMATION; DATA SET; ESTIMATION METHOD; MARK-RECAPTURE METHOD; POPULATION MODELING; SAMPLING; TRAP (EQUIPMENT); TRAPPING; WILDLIFE MANAGEMENT;

MAMMALIA;

EID: 84856104525     PISSN: 0022541X     EISSN: 19372817     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/jwmg.275     Document Type: Review

References (103)

1. Arispe, R., C. Venegas, and, D. Rumiz,. 2008. Abundancia y patrones de actividad del mapache (Procyon cancrivorus) en un bosque chiquitano de Bolivia. Mastozoología Neotropical 15: 323-333. [In Spanish.]
2. Arnason, A. N., C. J. Schwarz, and, J. M. Gerrard,. 1991. Estimating closed population size and number of marked animals from sighting data. Journal of Wildlife Management 55: 718-730.
3. Balme, G. A., L. T. B. Hunter, and, R. Slotow,. 2009. Evaluating methods for counting cryptic carnivores. Journal of Wildlife Management 73: 433-441.
4. Bartmann, R. M., G. C. White, L. H. Carpenter, and, R. A. Garrott,. 1987. Aerial mark-recapture estimates of confined mule deer in Pinyon-Juniper woodland. Journal of Wildlife Management 51: 41-46.
5. Bondrup-Nielsen, S., 1983. Density estimation as a function of live-trapping grid and home range size. Canadian Journal of Zoology 61: 2361-2365. (Pubitemid 15274001)
6. Borchers, D. L., and, M. G. Efford,. 2008. Spatially explicit maximum likelihood methods for capture-recapture studies. Biometrics 64: 377-385. (Pubitemid 351691934)
7. Bowden, D. C., and, R. C. Kufeld,. 1995. Generalized mark-resight population size estimation applied to Colorado moose. Journal of Wildlife Management 59 (4): 840-851. (Pubitemid 26469998)
8. Burnham, K. P., and, W. S. Overton,. 1978. Estimation of the size of a closed population when capture probabilities vary among animals. Biometrika 65: 625-633. (Pubitemid 9071195)
9. Carbone, C., S. Christie, K. Conforti, T. Coulson, N. Franklin, J. R. Ginsberg, M. Griffiths, J. Holden, K. Kawanishi, M. Kinnaird, R. Laidlaw, A. Lynam, D. W. Macdonald, D. Martyr, C. McDougal, L. Nath, T. O'Brien, J. Seidensticker, D. J. L. Smith, M. Sunquist, R. Tilso, and, W. N. W. Shahruddin,. 2001. The use of photographic rates to estimate densities of tigers and other cryptic mammals. Animal Conservation 4: 75-79. (Pubitemid 33668701)
10. Chao, A., and, R. M. Huggins,. 2005. Modern closed-population capture-recapture models. Pages 58-87 in, C. Amstrup, T. L. McDonald, and, B. F. J. Manly, editors. Handbook of capture-recapture analysis. Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, USA.
11. Cuellar, E., L. Maffei, R. Arispe, and, A. Noss,. 2006. Geoffroy's cats at the northern limit of their range: activity patterns and density estimates from camera trapping in Bolivian dry forests. Studies on Neotropical Fauna and Environment 41: 169-177. (Pubitemid 44627542)
12. Cullen, L. Jr., K. C. Abreu, D. Sana, and, A. F. D. Nava,. 2005. Jaguars as landscape detectives for the upper Paraná River corridor, Brazil. Natureza and Conservação 3: 43-58.
13. Di Bitetti, M. S., A. Paviolo, and, C. De Angelo,. 2006. Density, habitat use and activity patterns of ocelots (Leopardus pardalis) in the Atlantic Forest of Misiones, Argentina. Journal of Zoology 270: 153-163.
14. Di Bitetti, M. S., A. Paviolo, and, C. De Angelo,. 2008. Local and continental correlates of the abundance of a neotropical cat, the ocelot (Leopardus pardalis). Journal of Tropical Ecology 24: 189-200. (Pubitemid 351682572)
15. Dice, L. R., 1938. Some census methods for mammals. Journal of Wildlife Management 2: 119-130.
16. Dillon, A., 2005. Ocelot density and home range in Belize, Central America: camera-trapping and radio-telemetry. Thesis, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, USA.
17. Dillon, A., and, M. J. Kelly,. 2007. Ocelot (Leopardus pardalis) in Belize: the impact of trap spacing and distance moved on density estimates. Oryx 41: 469-477. (Pubitemid 350211154)
18. Dillon, A., and, M. J. Kelly,. 2008. Ocelot home range, overlap and density: comparing radio telemetry with camera trapping. Journal of Zoology 275: 391-398.
19. Efford, M., 2004. Density estimation in live-trapping studies. Oikos 106: 598-610. (Pubitemid 39059091)
20. Efford, M. G., 2010. Package 'secr'. Accessed 4 Dec 2010.
21. Efford, M. G., D. L. Borchers, and, A. E. Byrom,. 2009a. Density estimation by spatially explicit capture-recapture: likelihood-based methods. Pages 255-269 in, D. L. Thomson, E. G. Cooch, and, M. J. Conroy, editors. Modelling demographic processes in marked populations. Springer, New York, New York, USA.
22. Efford, M. G., D. K. Dawson, and, D. L. Borchers,. 2009b. Population density estimated from locations of individuals on a passive detector array. Ecology 90: 2676-2682.
23. Efford, M. G., B. Warburton, M. C. Coleman, and, R. J. Barker,. 2005. A field test of two methods for density estimation. Wildlife Society Bulletin 33: 731-738. (Pubitemid 41494876)
24. Foster, R. J., 2008. The ecology of jaguars in a human-influenced landscape. Thesis, University of Southampton, England, United Kingdom.
25. Foster, R. J., B. J. Harmsen, and, C. P. Doncaster,. 2010. Habitat use by sympatric jaguars and pumas across a gradient of human disturbance in Belize. Biotropica 42: 724-731.
26. Fuller, T. K., E. C. York, M. S. Powell, T. A. Decker, and, R. M. DeGraaf,. 2001. An evaluation of territory mapping to estimate fisher density. Canadian Journal of Zoology 79: 1691-1696. (Pubitemid 33017141)
27. Gardner, B., J. Reppucci, M. Lucherini, and, J. A. Royle,. 2010. Spatially explicit inference for open populations: estimating demographic parameters from camera-trap studies. Ecology 91: 3376-3383.
28. Giman, B., R. Stuebing, N. Megum, W. J. Mcshea, and, C. M. Stewart,. 2007. A camera trapping inventory for mammals in a mixed use planted forest in Sarawak. Raffles Bulletin of Zoology 55: 209-215.
29. Griffiths, M., and, C. P. van Schaik,. 1993. The impact of human traffic on the abundance and activity periods of Sumatran rain forest wildlife. Conservation Biology 7: 623-626.
30. Grogan, R. G., and, F. G. Lindzey,. 1999. Estimating population size of a low-density black bear population using capture-resight. Ursus 11: 117-122.
31. Haines, A. M., J. E. Janecka, M. E. Tewes, L. I. Grassman, Jr., and, P. Morton,. 2006. The importance of private lands for ocelot (Leopardus pardalis) conservation in the United States. Oryx 40: 1-5.
32. Harihar, A., B. Pandav, and, S. P. Goyal,. 2009. Subsampling photographic capture-recapture data of tigers (Panthera tigris) to minimize closure violation and improve estimate precision: as case study. Population Ecology 51: 471-479.
33. Harihar, A., M. Ghosh, M. Fernandes, B. Pandav, and, S. P. Goyal,. 2010. Use of photographic capture-recapture sampling to estimate density of Striped Hyena (Hyaena hyaena): implications for conservation. Mammalia 74: 83-87.
34. Harmsen, B. J., 2006. The use of camera traps for estimating abundance and studying the ecology of jaguars (Panthera onca). Thesis, University of Southampton, England, United Kingdom.
35. Harmsen, B. J., R. J. Foster, and, C. P. Doncaster,. 2010a. Heterogeneous capture rates in low density populations and consequences for capture-recapture analysis of camera-trap data. Population Ecology 53: 253-259.
36. Harmsen, B. J., R. J. Foster, S. C. Silver, L. E. T. Ostro, and, C. P. Doncaster,. 2009. Spatial and temporal interactions of sympatric jaguars (Panthera onca) and pumas (Puma concolor) in a neotropical forest. Journal of Mammalogy 90: 612-620.
37. Harmsen, B. J., R. J. Foster, S. Silver, L. Ostro, and, C. P. Doncaster,. 2010b. Differential use of trails by forest mammals and the implications for camera-trap studies: a case study from Belize. Biotropica 42: 126-133.
38. Heilbrun, R. D., L. J. Silvy, M. J. Peterson, and, M. E. Tewes,. 2006. Estimating bobcat abundance using automatically triggered cameras. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34: 69-73.
39. Ivan, J. S., 2011. Density, demography and seasonal movements of snowshoe hares in central Colorado. Thesis, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, USA.
40. Jackson, R. M., J. D. Roe, R. Wangchuk, and, D. O. Hunter,. 2006. Estimating snow leopard population abundance using photography and capture-recapture techniques. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34: 772-781. (Pubitemid 44784513)
41. Jenelle, C. S., M. C. Runge, and, D. I. MacKenzie,. 2002. The use of photographic rates to estimate densities of tigers and other cryptic mammals: a comment on misleading conclusions. Animal Conservation 5: 119-120. (Pubitemid 40281216)
42. Jett, D. A., and, J. D. Nichols,. 1987. A field comparison of nested grid and trapping web density estimators. Journal of Mammalogy 68: 888-892.
43. Johnson, A., C. Vongkhamheng, M. Hedemark, and, T. Saithongdam,. 2006. Effects of human-carnivore conflict on tiger (Panthera tigris) and prey populations in Lao PDR. Animal Conservation 9: 421-430. (Pubitemid 44596944)
44. Jordan, M. J., R. H. Barrett, and, K. L. Purcell,. 2011. Camera trapping estimates of density and survival of fishers (Martes pennanti). Wildlife Biology 17: 266-276.
45. Karanth, K. U., 1995. Estimating tiger (Panthera tigris) populations from camera-trap data using capture recapture models. Biological Conservation 71: 333-338.
46. Karanth, K. U., R. S. Chundawat, J. D. Nichols, and, N. S. Kumar,. 2004a. Estimation of tiger densities in the tropical dry forests of Panna, Central India, using photographic capture-recapture sampling. Animal Conservation 7: 285-290. (Pubitemid 40281136)
47. Karanth, K. U., and, J. D. Nichols,. 1998. Estimation of tiger densities in India using photographic captures and recaptures. Ecology 79: 2852-2862. (Pubitemid 29000644)
48. Karanth, K. U., J. D. Nichols, N. S. Kumar, W. A. Link, and, J. E. Hines,. 2004b. Tigers and their prey: predicting carnivore densities from prey abundance. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 101: 4854-4858. (Pubitemid 38469167)
49. Kawanishi, K., and, M. E. Sunquist,. 2004. Conservation status of tigers in a primary rainforest of Peninsular Malaysia. Biological Conservation 120: 329-344.
50. Kelly, M. J., A. J. Noss, M. S. Di Bitetti, L. Maffei, R. L. Arispe, A. Paviolo, C. D. De Angelo, and, Y. E. Di Blanco,. 2008. Estimating puma densities from camera trapping across three study sites: Bolivia, Argentina, and Belize. Journal of Mammalogy 89: 408-418. (Pubitemid 351631409)
51. Krebs, C. J., 1999. Ecological methodology. Benjamin/Cummings, Menlo Park, Canada.
52. Larrucea, E. S., P. F. Brussard, M. M. Jaeger, and, R. H. Barrett,. 2007. Cameras, coyotes, and the assumption of equal detectability. Journal of Wildlife Management 71: 1682-1689.
53. Linkie, M., I. A. Haidir, A. Nugroho, and, Y. Dinata,. 2008. Conserving tigers Panthera tigris in selectively logged Sumatran forests. Biological Conservation 141: 2410-2415.
54. Lynam, A. J., R. Laidlaw, W. S. W. Noordin, S. Elagupillay, and, E. L. Bennett,. 2007. Assessing the conservation status of the tiger Panthera tigris at priority sites in Peninsular Malaysia. Oryx 41: 454-462. (Pubitemid 350211156)
55. Lynam, A. J., A. Rabinowitz, T. Myint, M. Maung, K. T. Latt, and, S. H. T. Po,. 2009. Estimating abundance with sparse data: tigers in northern Myanmar. Population Ecology 51: 115-121.
56. Mace, R. D., S. C. Minta, T. L. Manley, and, K. E. Aune,. 1994. Estimating grizzly bear population size using camera sightings. Wildlife Society Bulleting 22: 74-83.
57. Maffei, L., E. Cuéllar, and, A. Noss,. 2004. One thousand jaguars (Panthera onca) in Bolivia's Chaco? Camera trapping in the Kaa-Iya National Park. Journal of Zoology 262: 295-304. (Pubitemid 38319248)
58. Maffei, L., and, A. J. Noss,. 2008. How small is too small? Camera trap survey areas and density estimates for ocelots in the Bolivian Chaco. Biotropica 40: 71-75.
59. Maffei, L., A. J. Noss, E. Cuéllar, and, D. I. Rumiz,. 2005. Ocelot (Felis pardalis) population densities, activity, and ranging behavior in the dry forests of eastern Bolivia: data from camera trapping. Journal of Tropical Ecology 21: 1-6.
60. Matthews, S. M., R. T. Golightly, and, J. M. Higley,. 2008. Mark-resight density estimation form American black bears in Hoopa, California. Ursus 19: 13-21. (Pubitemid 351834263)
61. Mazzolli, M., 2010. Mosaics of exotic forest plantations and native forests as habitat of pumas. Environmental Management 46: 237-253.
62. McCarthy, K. P., T. K. Fuller, M. Ming, T. M. McCarthy, L. Waits, and, K. Jumabaev,. 2008. Assessing estimators of snow leopard abundance. Journal of Wildlife Management 72: 1826-1833.
63. McClintock, B., 2011. Mark-resight models. Pages 1-34 in, E. G. Cooch, and, G. C. White, editors. A gentle introduction to program MARK. Ithaca, New York, USA. Accessed 23 Apr 2011.
64. McClintock, B. T., and, G. C. White,. In press. From NOREMARK to MARK: software for estimating demographic parameters using mark-resight methodology. Journal of Ornithology.
65. McClintock, B. T., G. C. White, M. F. Antolin, and, D. W. Tripp,. 2009. Estimating abundance using mark-resight when sampling is with replacement or the number of marked individuals is unknown. Biometrics 65: 237-246.
66. Minta, S., and, M. Mangel,. 1989. A simple population estimate based on simulation for capture-recapture and capture-resight data. Ecology 70: 1738-1751. (Pubitemid 20424806)
67. Negrões, N., P. Sarmento, J. Cruz, C. Eira, E. Revilla, C. Fonseca, R. Sollmann, N. M. Tõrres, M. M. Furtado, A. T. A. Jácomo, and, L. Silveira,. 2010. Use of camera-trapping to estimate puma density and influencing factors in Central Brazil. Journal of Wildlife Management 74: 1195-1203.
68. Noss, A. J., R. L. Cuéllar, J. Barrientos, L. Maffei, E. Cuéllar, R. Arispe, D. Rúmiz, and, K. Rivero,. 2003. A camera trapping and radio telemetry study of lowland tapir (Tapirus terrestris) in Bolivian dry forests. Tapir Conservation 12: 24-32.
69. Noss, A. J., and, D. I. Rumiz,. 2004. Camera trapping Priodontes maximus in the dry forests of Santa Cruz, Bolivia. Endangered Species Update 21: 43-52.
70. O'Brien, T. G., M. F. Kinnaird, and, H. T. Wibisono,. 2003. Crouching tigers, hidden prey: Sumatran tiger and prey populations in a tropical forest landscape. Animal Conservation 6: 131-139. (Pubitemid 40281180)
71. Oliveira-Santos, L. G. R., C. A. Zucco, P. C. Antunes, and, P. G. Crawshaw, Jr., 2010. Is it possible to individually identify mammals with no natural markings using camera-traps. A controlled case-study with lowland tapirs. Mammalian Biology 75: 375-378.
72. Otis, D. L., K. P. Burnham, G. C. White, and, D. R. Anderson,. 1978. Statistical inference from capture data on closed animal populations. Wildlife Monographs 62: 1-135.
73. Parmenter, R. R., T. L. Yates, D. R. Anderson, K. P. Burnham, J. L. Dunnum, A. B. Franklin, M. T. Friggens, B. C. Lubow, M. Miller, G. S. Olson, C. A. Parmenter, J. Pollard, E. Rexstad, T. M. Shenk, T. R. Stanley, and, G. C. White,. 2003. Small-mammal density estimation: a field comparison of grid-based vs. web-based density estimators. Ecological Monographs 73: 1-26. (Pubitemid 36247190)
74. Paviolo, A., C. D. De Angelo, Y. E. Di Blanco, and, M. S. Di Bitetti,. 2008. Jaguar (Panthera onca) population decline in the Upper Paraná Atlantic Forest of Argentina and Brazil. Oryx 42: 554-561.
75. Paviolo, A., Y. E. Di Blanco, C. D. De Angelo, and, M. S. Di Bitetti,. 2009. Protection affects the abundance and activity patterns of pumas in the Atlantic forest. Journal of Mammalogy 90: 926-934.
76. Rabinowitz, A. R., and, B. G. Nottingham,. 1986. Ecology and behavior of the jaguar (Panthera onca) in Belize, Central America. Journal of Zoology 210: 149-159.
77. Rayan, D. M., and, S. W. Mohamad,. 2009. The importance of selectively logged forests for tiger (Panthera tigris) conservation: a population density estimate in Peninsular Malaysia. Oryx 43: 48-51.
78. Ríos-Uzeda, B., H. Gõmez, and, R. B. Wallace,. 2007. A preliminary density estimate for Andean bear using camera-trapping methods. Ursus 18: 124-128. (Pubitemid 46996543)
79. Rowcliffe, J. M., J. Field, S. T. Turvey, and, C. Carbone,. 2008. Estimating animal density using camera traps without the need for individual recognition. Journal of Applied Ecology 45: 1228-1236. (Pubitemid 351951822)
80. Royle, J. A., and, B. Gardner,. 2011. Hierarchical spatial capture-recapture models for estimating density from trapping arrays. Pages 163-190 in, A. F. O'Connell, K. U. Karanth, and, J. D. Nichols, editors. Camera traps in animal ecology: methods and analyses. Springer, Tokyo, Dordrecht, Heidelberg, London, New York.
81. Royle, J. A., J. D. Nichols, K. U. Karanth, and, A. M. Gopalaswamy,. 2009a. A hierarchical model for estimating density in camera-trap studies. Journal of Applied Ecology 46: 118-127.
82. Royle, J. A., K. U. Karanth, A. M. Gopalaswamy, and, N. S. Kumar,. 2009b. Bayesian inference in camera trapping studies for a class of spatial capture-recapture models. Ecology 90: 3233-3244.
83. Salom-Pérez, R., E. Carrillo, J. C. Sáenz, and, J. M. Mora,. 2007. Critical condition of the jaguar (Panthera onca) population in Cocovado National Park, Costa Rica. Oryx 41: 51-56. (Pubitemid 46364651)
84. Sarmento, P., J. Cruz, C. Eira, and, C. Fonseca,. 2009. Evaluation of camera trapping for estimating red fox abundance. Journal of Wildlife Management 73: 1207-1212.
85. Silver, S. C., L. E. T. Ostro, L. K. Marsh, L. Maffei, A. J. Noss, M. J. Kelly, R. B. Wallace, H. Gomez, and, G. Ayala,. 2004. The use of camera traps for estimating jaguar (Panthera onca) abundance and density using capture/recapture analysis. Oryx 38: 1-7.
86. Simcharoen, S., A. Pattanavibool, K. U. Karanth, J. D. Nichols, and, N. S. Kumar,. 2007. How many tigers (Panthera tigris) are there in Huai Kha Khaeng Wildlife Sanctuary, Thailand? An estimate using photographic capture-recapture sampling. Oryx 41: 447-453. (Pubitemid 350211168)
87. Smith, J. L. D., C. McDougal, and, D. Miquelle,. 1989. Scent marking in free-ranging tigers, Panthera tigris. Animal Behavior 37: 1-10. (Pubitemid 19325438)
88. Soisalo, M. K., and, S. M. C. Cavalcanti,. 2006. Estimating the density of a jaguar population in the Brazilian Pantanal using camera-traps and capture-recapture sampling in combination with GPS radio-telemetry. Biological Conservation 129: 487-496. (Pubitemid 43384167)
89. Sunquist, M., and, F. Sunquist,. 2002. Wild cats of the world. The University of Chicago Press, London, United Kingdom.
90. Sweitzer, R. A., D. Van Vuren, I. A. Gardner, W. M. Boyce, and, J. D. Waithman,. 2000. Estimating sizes of wild pig populations in the north and central coast regions of California. Journal of Wildlife Management 64: 531-543. (Pubitemid 30221447)
91. Thorn, M., D. M. Scott, M. Green, P. W. Bateman, and, E. Z. Cameron,. 2009. Estimating brown hyaena occupancy using baited camera traps. South African Journal of Wildlife Research 39: 1-10.
92. Trolle, M., and, M. Kéry,. 2003. Estimation of ocelot density in the Pantanal using capture-recapture analysis of camera-trapping data. Journal of Mammalogy 84: 607-614. (Pubitemid 36689371)
93. Trolle, M., and, M. Kéry,. 2005. Camera-trap study of ocelot and other secretive mammals in the northern Pantanal. Mammalia 69: 405-412.
94. Trolle, M., A. J. Noss, E. De S. Lima, and, J. C. Dalponte,. 2007. Camera-traps studies of maned wolf density in the Cerrado and the Pantanal of Brazil. Biodiversity Conservation 16: 1197-1204. (Pubitemid 46712778)
95. Trolle, M., A. J. Noss, and, J. L. P. Cordeiro,. 2008. Brazilian Tapir density in the Pantanal: a comparison of systematic camera-trapping and line-transect surveys. Biotropica 40: 211-217. (Pubitemid 351463893)
96. Wallace, R. B., H. Gomez, G. Ayala, and, F. Espinoza,. 2003. Camera trapping for jaguar (Panthera onca) in the Tuichu Valley, Bolivia. Journal of Neotropical Mammalogy 10: 133-139.
97. Wang, S. W., and, D. W. Macdonald,. 2009. The use of camera traps for estimating tiger and leopard populations in the high altitude mountains of Bhutan. Biological Conservation 142: 606-613.
98. Watts, D. E., I. D. Parker, R. R. Lopez, N. J. Silvy, and, D. S. Davis,. 2008. Distribution and abundance of endangered Florida Key Deer on outer islands. Journal of Wildlife Management 72: 360-366. (Pubitemid 351273006)
99. Wegge, P., C. P. Pokheral, and, S. R. Jnawali,. 2004. Effects of trapping effort and trap shyness on estimates of tiger abundance from camera trap studies. Animal Conservation 7: 251-256. (Pubitemid 40281132)
100. White, G. C., D. R. Anderson, K. P. Burnham, and, D. L. Otis,. 1982. Capture-recapture and removal methods for sampling closed populations. Los Alamos National Laboratory, LA-8787-NERP, Los Alamos, New Mexico.
101. White, G. C., and, K. P. Burnham,. 1999. Program MARK: survival estimation from populations of marked animals. Bird Study 46 (Supplement): 120-138.
102. Wilson, K. R., and, D. R. Anderson,. 1985. Evaluation of two density estimators of small mammal population size. Journal of Mammalogy 66: 13-21.
103. Yoshizaki, J., K. H. Pollock, C. Brownie, and, R. A. Webster,. 2009. Modeling misidentification errors in capture-recapture studies using photographic identification of evolving marks. Ecology 90: 3-9.