Is there an ideal outcome scoring system for facial reanimation surgery? A review of current methods and suggestions for future publications

Journal of Plastic, Reconstructive and Aesthetic Surgery

Volumn 68, Issue 4, 2015, Pages 447-456

  Niziol, Rafal ^a   Henry, Francis P ^a   Leckenby, Jonathan I ^a   Grobbelaar, Adriaan O ^a  

^a ROYAL FREE HOSPITAL   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Facial palsy scoring system; Facial paralysis; Facial reanimation; Outcome

Indexed keywords

CONTRACTURE; FACE ASYMMETRY; FACIAL EXPRESSION; FACIAL NERVE PARALYSIS; FACIAL REANIMATION SURGERY; FACIES; HUMAN; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLICATION; REVIEW; SCORING SYSTEM; SYNKINESIS; FACIAL NERVE; FACIAL PARALYSIS; NERVE REGENERATION; PHOTOGRAPHY; PHYSIOLOGY; PLASTIC SURGERY; PROCEDURES;

FACIAL EXPRESSION; FACIAL NERVE; FACIAL PARALYSIS; HUMANS; NERVE REGENERATION; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT (HEALTH CARE); PHOTOGRAPHY; SURGERY, PLASTIC;

EID: 84926255837     PISSN: 17486815     EISSN: 18780539     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.bjps.2014.12.015     Document Type: Review

References (57)

1. D.E. Brackmann, M.F.M. Barbara, M. Frey, J. Terzis, M. Cheney, and T. Hadlock Panel: lessons learned at FN Symposium 2013, and thoughts on where to go next 12th International Facial Nerve Symposium, Boston 2013
2. J.W. House Facial nerve grading systems Laryngoscope 93 8 1983 1056 1069
3. F. Janssen Over de postoperatieve facialis-verlamming [Dissertation] 1963 University of Amsterdam Amsterdam
4. K.K. Adour, and P.J. Swanson Jr. Facial paralysis in 403 consecutive patients: emphasis on treatment response in patients with Bell's palsy Trans Am Acad Ophthalmol Otolaryngol 75 6 1971 1284 1301
5. N. Yanagihara, and M. Kishimoto Electrodiagnosis in facial palsy Arch Otolaryngol 95 4 1972 376 382
6. E. Stennert, C.H. Limberg, and K.P. Frentrup An index for paresis and defective healing-an easily applied method for objectively determining therapeutic results in facial paresis (author's transl) HNO 25 7 1977 238 245
7. J.W. Botman, and L.B. Jongkees The result of intratemporal treatment of facial palsy Pract Otorhinolaryngol (Basel) 17 2 1955 80 100
8. M. May Facial paralysis, peripheral type: a proposed method of reporting. (Emphasis on diagnosis and prognosis, as well as electrical and chorda tympani nerve testing) Laryngoscope 80 3 1970 331 390
9. E. Peitersen The natural history of Bell's palsy Am J Otol 4 2 1982 107 111
10. J.W. House, and D.E. Brackmann Facial nerve grading system Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 93 2 1985 146 147
11. S.D. Reitzen, J.S. Babb, and A.K. Lalwani Significance and reliability of the House-Brackmann grading system for regional facial nerve function Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 140 2 2009 154 158
12. L.N. Lee, S.M. Susarla, M. Hohman, D.K. Henstrom, M.L. Cheney, and T.A. Hadlock A comparison of facial nerve grading systems Ann Plast Surg 70 3 2013 313 316
13. J. Rickenmann, C. Jaquenod, D. Cerenko, and U. Fisch Comparative value of facial nerve grading systems Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 117 4 1997 322 325
14. S.E. Coulson, G.R. Croxson, R.D. Adams, and N.J. O'Dwyer Reliability of the "Sydney," "Sunnybrook," and "House Brackmann" facial grading systems to assess voluntary movement and synkinesis after facial nerve paralysis Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 132 4 2005 543 549
15. R.A. Evans, M.L. Harries, D.M. Baguley, and D.A. Moffat Reliability of the House and Brackmann grading system for facial palsy J Laryngol Otol 103 11 1989 1045 1046
16. T.S. Kang, J.T. Vrabec, N. Giddings, and D.J. Terris Facial nerve grading systems (1985-2002): beyond the House-Brackmann scale Otol Neurotol 23 5 2002 767 771
17. T.L. Yen, C.L. Driscoll, and A.K. Lalwani Significance of House-Brackmann facial nerve grading global score in the setting of differential facial nerve function Otol Neurotol 24 1 2003 118 122
18. J.T. Vrabec, D.D. Backous, and H.R. Djalilian Facial nerve grading system 2.0 Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 140 4 2009 445 450
19. H.Y. Lee, M.S. Park, J.Y. Byun, J.H. Chung, S.Y. Na, and S.G. Yeo Agreement between the facial nerve grading system 2.0 and the House-Brackmann grading system in patients with Bell palsy Clin Exp Otorhinolaryngol 6 3 2013 135 139
20. N. Yanagihara Grading of facial palsy Proceedings of the Third International Symposium on Facial Nerve Surgery 1977 Kugler Medical Publications Zurich 533 535
21. T. Berg, L. Jonsson, and M. Engstrom Agreement between the Sunnybrook, House-Brackmann, and Yanagihara facial nerve grading systems in Bell's palsy Otol Neurotol 25 6 2004 1020 1026
22. Y. Satoh, J. Kanzaki, and S. Yoshihara A comparison and conversion table of 'the House-Brackmann facial nerve grading system' and 'the Yanagihara grading system' Auris Nasus Larynx 27 3 2000 207 212
23. G.G. Hay Psychiatric aspects of cosmetic nasal operations Br J Psychiatry 116 530 1970 85 97
24. S.T. Tan, G. Ashworth, S. Czypionka, M.D. Poole, and M. Briggs Vertical orbital dystopia Plast Reconstr Surg 97 7 1996 1349 1361
25. M.M. Cohen Jr., B.R. Rollnick, and C.I. Kaye Oculoauriculovertebral spectrum: an updated critique Cleft Palate J 26 4 1989 276 286
26. D.H. Harrison, and A.O. Grobbelaar Pectoralis minor muscle transfer for unilateral facial palsy reanimation: an experience of 35 years and 637 cases J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg 65 7 2012 845 850
27. J.A. de Ru, W.W. Braunius, P.P. van Benthem, W.B. Busschers, and G.J. Hordijk Grading facial nerve function: why a new grading system, the MoReSS, should be proposed Otol Neurotol 27 7 2006 1030 1036
28. S. Burres, and U. Fisch The comparison of facial grading systems Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 112 7 1986 755 758
29. G. Croxson, M. May, and S.J. Mester Grading facial nerve function: House-Brackmann versus Burres-Fisch methods Am J Otol 11 4 1990 240 246
30. G.E. Murty, J.P. Diver, P.J. Kelly, G.M. O'Donoghue, and P.J. Bradley The Nottingham System: objective assessment of facial nerve function in the clinic Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 110 2 1994 156 161
31. G.H. Chee, and J.M. Nedzelski Facial nerve grading systems Facial Plast Surg 16 4 2000 315 324
32. B.G. Ross, G. Fradet, and J.M. Nedzelski Development of a sensitive clinical facial grading system Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 114 3 1996 380 386
33. W.L. Hu, B. Ross, and J. Nedzelski Reliability of the Sunnybrook facial grading system by novice users J Otolaryngol 30 4 2001 208 211
34. F.T. Kayhan, D. Zurakowski, and S.D. Rauch Toronto facial grading system: interobserver reliability Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 122 2 2000 212 215
35. S.A. Burres Facial biomechanics: the standards of normal Laryngoscope 95 6 1985 708 714
36. R.T. Manktelow, R.M. Zuker, and L.R. Tomat Facial paralysis measurement with a handheld ruler Plast Reconstr Surg 121 2 2008 435 442
37. M. Frey, A. Jenny, P. Giovanoli, and E. Stussi Development of a new documentation system for facial movements as a basis for the international registry for neuromuscular reconstruction in the face Plast Reconstr Surg 93 7 1994 1334 1349
38. P.C. Johnson, H. Brown, W.M. Kurzon Jr., R. Balliet, J.L. Garrison, and J. Campbell Simultaneous quantitation of facial movements: the maximal static response assay of facial nerve function Ann Plast Surg 32 2 1994 171 179
39. M. Isono, K. Murata, H. Tanaka, M. Kawamoto, and H. Azuma An objective evaluation method for facial mimic motion Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 114 1 1996 27 31
40. E.W. Sargent, O.A. Fadhli, and R.S. Cohen Measurement of facial movement with computer software Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 124 3 1998 313 318
41. M.M. Gross, C.A. Trotman, and K.S. Moffatt A comparison of three-dimensional and two-dimensional analyses of facial motion Angle Orthod 66 3 1996 189 194
42. M. Heckmann, and G. Schon-Hupka Quantification of the efficacy of botulinum toxin type A by digital image analysis J Am Acad Dermatol 45 4 2001 508 514
43. G.S. Wachtman, J.F. Cohn, J.M. VanSwearingen, and E.K. Manders Automated tracking of facial features in patients with facial neuromuscular dysfunction Plast Reconstr Surg 107 5 2001 1124 1133
44. M. Frey, P. Giovanoli, H. Gerber, M. Slameczka, and E. Stussi Three-dimensional video analysis of facial movements: a new method to assess the quantity and quality of the smile Plast Reconstr Surg 104 7 1999 2032 2039
45. C.H. Tzou, I. Pona, and E. Placheta Evolution of the 3-dimensional video system for facial motion analysis: ten years' experiences and recent developments Ann Plast Surg 69 2 2012 173 185
46. L.R. Tomat, and R.T. Manktelow Evaluation of a new measurement tool for facial paralysis reconstruction Plast Reconstr Surg 115 3 2005 696 704
47. A.S. Zigmond, and R.P. Snaith The hospital anxiety and depression scale Acta Psychiatr Scand 67 6 1983 361 370
48. J.E. Ware Jr., and C.D. Sherbourne The MOS 36-item short-form health survey (SF-36). I. Conceptual framework and item selection Med Care 30 6 1992 473 483
49. J.M. VanSwearingen, and J.S. Brach The facial disability index: reliability and validity of a disability assessment instrument for disorders of the facial neuromuscular system Phys Ther 76 12 1996 1288 1298 discussion 1298-300
50. J.B. Kahn, R.E. Gliklich, K.P. Boyev, M.G. Stewart, R.B. Metson, and M.J. McKenna Validation of a patient-graded instrument for facial nerve paralysis: the FaCE scale Laryngoscope 111 3 2001 387 398
51. J.H. Ng, and R.Y. Ngo The use of the facial clinimetric evaluation scale as a patient-based grading system in Bell's palsy Laryngoscope 123 5 2013 1256 1260
52. D.H. Harrison The pectoralis minor vascularized muscle graft for the treatment of unilateral facial palsy Plast Reconstr Surg 75 2 1985 206 216
53. J.K. Terzis, and M.E. Noah Analysis of 100 cases of free-muscle transplantation for facial paralysis Plast Reconstr Surg 99 7 1997 1905 1921
54. F. Biglioli, A. Frigerio, D. Rabbiosi, and R. Brusati Single-stage facial reanimation in the surgical treatment of unilateral established facial paralysis Plast Reconstr Surg 124 1 2009 124 133
55. B.F. O'Reilly, J.J. Soraghan, S. McGrenary, and S. He Objective method of assessing and presenting the House-Brackmann and regional grades of facial palsy by production of a facogram Otol Neurotol 31 3 2010 486 491
56. M. Romeo, B. O'Reilly, B.F. Robertson, and S. Morley Validation of the glasgow facial palsy scale for the assessment of smile reanimation surgery in facial paralysis Clin Otolaryngol 37 3 2012 181 187
57. M. Michaelidou, M. Herceg, and O. Schuhfried Correlation of functional recovery with the course of electrophysiological parameters after free muscle transfer for reconstruction of the smile in irreversible facial palsy Muscle Nerve 44 5 2011 741 748