Quantitative review finds no evidence of cognitive effects in healthy populations from single-session transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS)

Brain Stimulation

Volumn 8, Issue 3, 2015, Pages 535-550

  Horvath, Jared Cooney ^a   Forte, Jason D ^a   Carter, Olivia ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE   (Australia)

Author keywords

Executive function; Language; Memory; Quantitative review; Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS); Working memory

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; COGNITION; DORSOLATERAL PREFRONTAL CORTEX; EPISODIC MEMORY; EXECUTIVE FUNCTION; EXECUTIVE FUNCTION TEST; HIGH RISK BEHAVIOR; HUMAN; LANGUAGE; MEMORY; MENTAL ARITHMETIC; PRIORITY JOURNAL; QUANTITATIVE ANALYSIS; RESPONSE TIME; RUMINATION; SECONDARY ANALYSIS; STROOP TEST; TRANSCRANIAL DIRECT CURRENT STIMULATION; WORKING MEMORY; ADULT; FEMALE; MALE; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TEST; PHYSIOLOGY; SHORT TERM MEMORY;

ADULT; COGNITION; EXECUTIVE FUNCTION; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MEMORY, SHORT-TERM; NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL TESTS; TRANSCRANIAL DIRECT CURRENT STIMULATION;

EID: 84925324149     PISSN: 1935861X     EISSN: 18764754     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.brs.2015.01.400     Document Type: Article

References (110)

1. Horvath JC, Forte JD, Carter O. Evidence that transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) generates little-to-no reliable neurophysiologic effect beyond MEP amplitude modulation in healthy human subjects: a systematic review. Neuropsychologia 2015;66:213e36.
2. Nitsche MA, Paulus W. Excitability changes induced in the human motor cortex by weak transcranial direct current stimulation. J Physiol 2000;527(Pt 3):633e9.
3. Stagg CJ, Nitsche MA. Physiological basis of transcranial direct current stimulation. Neuroscientist 2011;17(1):37e53.
4. Elliott R. Executive functions and their disorders. Br Med Bull 2003;65:49e59.
5. Kiesel A, Steinhauser M, Wendt M, et al. Control and interference in task switchingda review. Psychol Bull 2010;136(5):849e74.
6. Verbruggen F, Logan GD. Response inhibition in the stop-signal paradigm. Trends Cogn Sci 2008;12(11):418e24.
7. Macleod CM. Half a Century of research on the Stroop effect e an integrative review. Psychol Bull 1991;109(2):163e203.
8. Evans V, Green M. Cognitive linguistics: an introduction. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press; 2006.
9. Breitenstein C, Knecht S. Development and validation of a language learning model for behavioral and functional-imaging studies. J Neurosci Methods 2002;114(2):173e9.
10. Johnson CJ, Paivio A, Clark JM. Cognitive components of picture naming. Psychol Bull 1996;120(1):113e39.
11. Costafreda SG, Fu CH, Lee L, Everitt B, Brammer MJ, David AS. A systematic review and quantitative appraisal of fMRI studies of verbal fluency: role of the left inferior frontal gyrus. Hum Brain Mapp 2006;27(10):799e810.
12. Anderson JR. Learning and memory. New Jersey: John Wiley & Sons, Inc; 2000.
13. Conway AR, Kane MJ, Bunting MF, Hambrick DZ, Wilhelm O, Engle RW. Working memory span tasks: a methodological review and user's guide. Psychon Bull Rev 2005;12(5):769e86.
14. Tulving E. Episodic memory: from mind to brain. Annu Rev Psychol 2002;53:1e25.
15. Sternberg S. Memory-scanning: mental processes revealed by reaction-time experiments. Am Sci 1969;57(4):421e57.
16. Kane MJ, Conway AR, Miura TK, Colflesh GJ. Working memory, attention control, and the N-back task: a question of construct validity. J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn 2007;33(3):615e22.
17. Ashcraft MH. Cognitive arithmetic: a review of data and theory. Cognition 1992;44(1e2):75e106.
18. Olofsson JK, Nordin S, Sequeira H, Polich J. Affective picture processing: an integrative review of ERP findings. Biol Psychol 2008;77(3):247e65.
19. Buelow MT, Suhr JA. Construct validity of the Iowa gambling task. Neuropsychol Rev 2009;19(1):102e14.
20. Lejuez CW, Read JP, Kahler CW, et al. Evaluation of a behavioral measure of risk taking: the Balloon Analogue Risk Task (BART). J Exp Psychol Appl 2002;8(2):75e84.
21. Smith JM, Alloy LB. A roadmap to rumination: a review of the definition, assessment, and conceptualization of this multifaceted construct. Clin Psychol Rev 2009;29(2):116e28.
22. Gieryn TF. The ballad of Pons and Fleischmann: experiment and narrative in the (un)making of cold fusion. In: McMullin E, editor. The social dimensions of science. Indiana: University of Notre Dame Press; 1992.
23. Mobley A, Linder SK, Braeuer R, Ellis LM, Zwelling L. A survey on data reproducibility in cancer research provides insights into our limited ability to translate findings from the laboratory to the clinic. PLoS One 2013;8(5):e63221.
24. Osherovich L. Doubts about tragretin in AD. SciBX 2013;6(21).
25. Leite J, Carvalho S, Fregni F, Gonalves OF. Task-specific effects of tDCSinduced cortical excitability changes on cognitive and motor sequence set shifting performance. PLoS One 2011;6(9):e24140.
26. Plewnia C, Zwissler B, Lngst I, Maurer B, Giel K, Krger R. Effects of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) on executive functions: influence of COMT Val/Met polymorphism. Cortex 2013;49(7):1801e7.
27. Jacobson L, Javitt DC, Lavidor M. Activation of inhibition: diminishing impulsive behavior by direct current stimulation over the inferior frontal gyrus. J Cogn Neurosci 2011;23(11):3380e7.
28. Ditye T, Jacobson L, Walsh V, Lavidor M. Modulating behavioral inhibition by tDCS combined with cognitive training. Exp Brain Res 2012;219(3):363e8.
29. Leite J, Carvalho S, Fregni F, Boggio PS, Gonalves F. The effects of crosshemispheric dorsolateral prefrontal cortex transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) on task switching. Brain Stimul 2013;6(4):660e7.
30. Kwon JW, Nam SH, Lee NK, Son SM, Choi YW, Kim CS. The effect of transcranial direct current stimulation on the motor suppression in stop-signal task. NeuroRehabilitation 2013;32(1):191e6.
31. Reinhart RM, Woodman GF. Causal control of medial-frontal cortex governs electrophysiological and behavioral indices of performance monitoring and learning. J Neurosci 2014;34(12):4214e27.
32. Hsu TY, Tseng LY, Yu JX, Kuo WJ. Modulating inhibitory control with direct current stimulation of the superior medial frontal cortex. Neuroimage 2011;56(4):2249e57.
33. Kwon YH, Kwon JW. Response inhibition induced in the stop-signal task by transcranial direct current stimulation of the pre-supplementary motor area and primary sensoriomotor cortex. J Phys Ther Sci 2013;25(9):1083e6.
34. Liang WK, Lo MT, Yang AC, et al. Revealing the brain's adaptability and the transcranial direct current stimulation facilitating effect in inhibitory control by multiscale entropy. Neuroimage 2014;90:218e34.
35. Fecteau S, Pascual-Leone A, Zald DH, et al. Activation of prefrontal cortex by transcranial direct current stimulation reduces appetite for risk during ambiguous decision making. J Neurosci 2007;27(23):6212e8.
36. Fecteau S, Boggio P, Fregni, Pascual-Leone A. Modulation of untruthful responses with non-invasive brain stimulation. Front Psychiatry 2013;3:97.
37. Jeon SY, Han SJ. Improvement of the working memory and naming by transcranial direct current stimulation. Ann Rehabil Med 2012;36(5):585e95.
38. Kadosh RC, Soskic S, Iuculano T, Kanai R, Walsh V. Modulating neuronal activity produces specific and long-lasting changes in numerical competence. Curr Biol 2010;20(22):2016e20.
39. Richmond L, Wolk D, Chein J, Olson IR. Transcranial direct current stimulation enhances verbal working memory training performance over time and near-transfer outcomes. J Cogn Neurosci 2014;26(11):2443e54.
40. Floel A, Rösser N, Michka O, Knecht S, Breitenstein C. Noninvasive brain stimulation improves language learning. J Cogn Neurosci 2008;20(8):1415e22.
41. Fiori V, Coccia M, Marinelli CV, et al. Transcranial direct current stimulation improves word retrieval in healthy and nonfluent aphasic subjects. J Cogn Neurosci 2011;23(9):2309e23.
42. Fertonani A, Rosini S, Cotelli M, Rossini PM, Miniussi C. Naming facilitation induced by transcranial direct current stimulation. Behav Brain Res 2010;208(2):311e8.
43. Wirth M, Rahman RA, Kuenecke J, et al. Effects of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) on behaviour and electrophysiology of language production. Neuropsychologia 2011;49(14):3989e98.
44. Cerruti C, Schlaug G. Anodal transcranial direct current stimulation of the prefrontal cortex enhances complex verbal associative thought. J Cogn Neurosci 2009;21(10):1980e7.
45. Cattaneo Z, Pisoni A, Papagno C. Transcranial direct current stimulation over Broca's region improves phonemic and semantic fluency in healthy individuals. Neuroscience 2011;183:64e70.
46. Penolazzi B, Pastore M, Mondini S. Electrode montage dependent effects of transcranial direct current stimulation on semantic fluency. Behav Brain Res 2013;248:129e35.
47. Meinzer M, Lindenberg R, Antonenko D, Flaisch T, Flöel A. Anodal transcranial direct current stimulation temporarily reverses age-associated cognitive decline and functional brain activity changes. J Neurosci 2013;33(30):12470e8.
48. Vannorsdall TD, Schretlen DJ, Andrejczuk M, et al. Altering automatic verbal processes with transcranial direct current stimulation. Front Psychiatry 2012;3:73.
49. Sparing R, Dafotakis M, Meister IG, Thirugnanasambandam N, Fink GR. Enhancing language performance with non-invasive brain stimulationea transcranial direct current stimulation study in healthy humans. Neuropsychologia 2008;46(1):261e8.
50. Ross LA, McCoy D, Wolk DA, Coslett HB, Olson IR. Improved proper name recall by electrical stimulation of the anterior temporal lobes. Neuropsychologia 2010;48(12):3671e4.
51. Meinzer M, Antonenko D, Lindenberg R, et al. Electrical brain stimulation improves cognitive performance by modulating functional connectivity and task-specific activation. J Neurosci 2012;32(5):1859e66.
52. Andrews SC, Hoy KE, Enticott PG, Daskalakis ZJ, Fitzgerald PB. Improving working memory: the effect of combining cognitive activity and anodal transcranial direct current stimulation to the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Brain Stimul 2011;4(2):84e9.
53. Mulquiney PG, Hoy KE, Daskalakis ZJ, Fitzgerald PB. Improving working memory: exploring the effect of transcranial random noise stimulation and transcranial direct current stimulation on the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Clin Neurophysiol 2011;122(12):2384e9.
54. Gladwin TE, den Uyl TE, Wiers RW. Anodal tDCS of dorsolateral prefontal cortex during an implicit association test. Neurosci Lett 2012;517(2):82e6.
55. Berryhill ME, Wencil EB, Coslett HB, Olson IR. A selective working memory impairment after transcranial direct current stimulation to the right parietal lobe. Neurosci Lett 2010;479(3):312e6.
56. Jones KT, Berryhill ME. Parietal contributions to visual working memory depend on task difficulty. Front Psychiatry 2012;3:81.
57. Tseng P, Hsu TY, Chang CF, et al. Unleashing potential: transcranial direct current stimulation over the right posterior parietal cortex improves change detection in low-performing individuals. J Neurosci 2012;32(31):10554e61.
58. Hsu TY, Tseng P, Liang WK, Cheng SK, Juan CH. Transcranial direct current stimulation over right posterior parietal cortex changes prestimulus alpha oscillation in visual short-term memory task. Neuroimage 2014;98:306e13.
59. Tanoue RT, Jones KT, Peterson DJ, BerryhillME. Differential frontal involvement in shifts of internal and perceptual attention. Brain Stimul 2013;6(4):675e82.
60. Hoy KE, Emonson MR, Arnold SL, Thomson RH, Daskalakis ZJ, Fitzgerald PB. Testing the limits: investigating the effect of tDCS dose on working memory enhancement in healthy controls. Neuropsychologia 2013;51(9):1777e84.
61. Keeser D, Padberg F, Reisinger E, et al. Prefrontal direct current stimulation modulates resting EEG and event-related potentials in healthy subjects: a standardized low resolution tomography (sLORETA) study. Neuroimage 2011;55(2):644e57.
62. Fregni F, Boggio PS, Nitsche M, et al. Anodal transcranial direct current stimulation of prefrontal cortex enhances working memory. Exp Brain Res 2005;166(1):23e30.
63. Teo F, Hoy KE, Daskalakis ZJ, Fitzgerald PB. Investigating the role of current strength in tDCS modulation of working memory performance in healthy controls. Front Psychiatry 2011;2:45.
64. Ohn SH, Park CI, Yoo WK, et al. Time-dependent effect of transcranial direct current stimulation on the enhancement of working memory. Neuroreport 2008;19(1):43e7.
65. Martin DM, Liu R, Alonzo A, et al. Can transcranial direct current stimulation enhance outcomes from cognitive training? A randomized controlled trial in healthy participants. Int J Neuropsychopharmacol 2013;16(9):1927e36.
66. Ferrucci R, Marceglia S, Vergari M, et al. Cerebellar transcranial direct current stimulation impairs the practice-dependent proficiency increase in working memory. J Cogn Neurosci 2008;20(9):1687e97.
67. Macher K, Böhringer A, Villringer A, Pleger B. Cerebellar-parietal connections underpin phonological storage. J Neurosci 2014;34(14):5029e37.
68. Hammer A, Mohammadi B, Schmicker M, Saliger S, Mnte TF. Errorless and errorful learning modulated by transcranial direct current stimulation. BMC Neurosci 2011;12:72.
69. Javadi AH, Walsh V. Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) of the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex modulates declarative memory. Brain Stimul 2012;5(3):231e41.
70. Bona S, Silvanto J. Accuracy and confidence of visual short-term memory do not go hand-in-hand: behavioral and neural dissociations. PLoS One 2014;9(3):e90808.
71. Zwissler B, Sperber C, Aigeldinger S, Schindler S, Kissler J, Plewnia C. Shaping memory accuracy by left prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation. J Neurosci 2014;34(11):4022e6.
72. Chi RP, Fregni F, Snyder AW. Visual memory improved by non-invasive brain stimulation. Brain Res 2010;1353:168e75.
73. Schaal NK, Krause V, Lange K, Banissy MJ, VJWilliamson. Pitch memory in nonmusicians and musicians: revealing functional differences using transcranial direct current stimulation. Cereb Cortex 2014.
74. Heimrath K, Sandmann P, Becke A, Mller NG, Zaehle T. Behavioral and electrophysiological effects of transcranial direct current stimulation of the parietal cortex in a visuo-spatial working memory task. Front Psychiatry 2012;3:56.
75. Moos K, Vossel S, Weidner R, Sparing R, Fink GR. Modulation of top-down control of visual attention by cathodal tDCS over right IPS. J Neurosci 2012;32(46):16360e8.
76. Zaehle T, Sandmann P, Thorne JD, Jncke L, Herrmann CS. Transcranial direct current stimulation of the prefrontal cortex modulates working memory performance: combined behavioural and electrophysiological evidence. BMC Neurosci 2011;12:2.
77. Lally N, Nord CL, Walsh V, Roiser JP. Does excitatory fronto-extracerebral tDCS lead to improved working memory performance? F1000Res 2013;2:219.
78. Javadi AH, Cheng P, Walsh V. Short duration transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) modulates verbal memory. Brain Stimul 2012;5(4):468e74.
79. Gomes-Osman J, Field-Fote EC. Bihemispheric anodal corticomotor stimulation using transcranial direct current stimulation improves bimanual typing task performance. J Mot Behav 2013;45(4):361e7.
80. Motohashi N, Yamaguchi M, Fujii T, Kitahara Y. Mood and cognitive function following repeated transcranial direct current stimulation in healthy volunteers: a preliminary report. Neurosci Res 2013;77(1e2):64e9.
81. Bolognini N, Fregni F, Casati C, Olgiati E, Vallar G. Brain polarization of parietal cortex augments training-induced improvement of visual exploratory and attentional skills. Brain Res 2010;1349:76e89.
82. Manenti R, Brambilla M, Petesi M, Ferrari C, Cotelli M. Enhancing verbal episodic memory in older and young subjects after non-invasive brain stimulation. Front Aging Neurosci 2013;5:49.
83. Clemens B, Jung S, Zvyagintsev M, Domahs F, Willmes K. Modulating arithmetic fact retrieval: a single-blind, sham-controlled tDCS study with repeated fMRI measurements. Neuropsychologia 2013;51(7):1279e86.
84. Hauser TU, Rotzer S, Grabner RH, Mérillat S, Jncke L. Enhancing performance in numerical magnitude processing and mental arithmetic using transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Front Hum Neurosci 2013;7:244.
85. Boggio PS, Zaghi S, Fregni F. Modulation of emotions associated with images of human pain using anodal transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS). Neuropsychologia 2009;47(1):212e7.
86. Pena-Gomez C, Vidal-Piñeiro D, Clemente IC, Pascual-Leone Á., Bartrés-Faz D. Down-regulation of negative emotional processing by transcranial direct current stimulation: effects of personality characteristics. PLoS One 2011;6(7):e22812.
87. Brunoni AR, Vanderhasselt MA, Boggio PS, et al. Polarity- and valence-dependent effects of prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation on heart rate variability and salivary cortisol. Psychoneuroendocrinology 2013;38(1):58e66.
88. Feeser M, Prehn K, Kazzer P, Mungee A, Bajbouj M. Transcranial direct current stimulation enhances cognitive control during emotion regulation. Brain Stimul 2014;7(1):105e12.
89. Fecteau S, Knoch D, Fregni F, Sultani N, Boggio P, Pascual-Leone A. Diminishing risk-taking behavior by modulating activity in the prefrontal cortex: a direct current stimulation study. J Neurosci 2007;27(46):12500e5.
90. Minati L, Campanha C, Critchley HD, Boggio PS. Effects of transcranial directcurrent stimulation (tDCS) of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) during a mixed-gambling risky decision-making task. Cogn Neurosci 2012;3(2):80e8.
91. Kelley NJ, Hortensius R, Harmon-Jones E. When anger leads to rumination: induction of relative right frontal cortical activity with transcranial direct current stimulation increases anger-related rumination. Psychol Sci 2013;24(4):475e81.
92. Vanderhasselt MA, Brunoni AR, Loeys T, Boggio PS, De Raedt R. Nosce te ipsumeSocrates revisited? Controlling momentary ruminative self-referent thoughts by neuromodulation of emotional working memory. Neuropsychologia 2013;51(13):2581e9.
93. Kasahara K, Tanaka S, Hanakawa T, Senoo A, Honda M. Lateralization of activity in the parietal cortex predicts the effectiveness of bilateral transcranial direct current stimulation on performance of a mental calculation task. Neurosci Lett 2013;545:86e90.
94. Maeoka H, Matsuo A, Hiyamizu M, Morioka S, Ando H. Influence of transcranial direct current stimulation of the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex on pain related emotions: a study using electroencephalographic power spectrum analysis. Neurosci Lett 2012;512(1):12e6.
95. Weber MJ, Messing SB, Rao H, Detre JA, Thompson-Schill SL. Prefrontal transcranial direct current stimulation alters activation and connectivity in cortical and subcortical reward systems: a tDCS-fMRI study. Hum Brain Mapp 2014;35(8):3673e86.
96. Walker E, Hernandez AV, Kattan MW. Meta-analysis: Its strengths and limitations. Cleve Clin J Med 2008;75(6):431e9.
97. Silvanto J, Muggleton N, Walsh V. State-dependency in brain stimulation studies of perception and cognition. Trends Cogn Sci 2008;12(12):447e54.
98. Silvanto J, Pascual-Leone A. State-dependency of transcranial magnetic stimulation. Brain Topogr 2008;21(1):1e10.
99. Quartarone A, Morgante F, Bagnato S, et al. Long lasting effects of transcranial direct current stimulation on motor imagery. Neuroreport 2004;15(8):1287e91.
100. Antal A, Terney D, Poreisz C, Paulus W. Towards unravelling task-related modulations of neuroplastic changes induced in the human motor cortex. Eur J Neurosci 2007;26(9):2687e91.
101. Lang N, Siebner HR, Ernst D, et al. Preconditioning with transcranial direct current stimulation sensitizes the motor cortex to rapid-rate transcranial magnetic stimulation and controls the direction of after-effects. Biol Psychiatry 2004;56(9):634e9.
102. Batsikadze G, Moliadze V, Paulus W, et al. Partially non-linear stimulation intensity-dependent effects of direct current stimulation on motor cortex excitability in humans. J Physiol 2013;591(Pt 7):1987e2000.
103. Rosenberg O, Shoenfeld N, Kotler M, Dannon PN. Mood disorders in elderly population: neurostimulative treatment possibilities. Recent Pat CNS Drug Discov 2009;4(2):149e59.
104. Berryhill ME, Jones KT. tDCS selectively improves working memory in older adults with more education. Neurosci Lett 2012;521(2):148e51.
105. Kalu UG, Sexton CE, Loo CK, Ebmeier KP. Transcranial direct current stimulation in the treatment of major depression: a meta-analysis. Psychol Med 2012;42(9):1791e800.
106. Lima MC, Fregni F. Motor cortex stimulation for chronic pain: systematic review and meta-analysis of the literature. Neurology 2008;70(24):2329e37.
107. Butler AJ, Shuster M, O'Hara E, Hurley K, Middlebrooks D, Guilkey K. A metaanalysis of the efficacy of anodal transcranial direct current stimulation for upper limbmotor recovery in stroke survivors. J Hand Ther 2013;26(2):162e70. quiz 171.
108. Schambra HM, Abe M, Luckenbaugh DA, Reis J, Krakauer JW, Cohen LG. Probing for hemispheric specialization for motor skill learning: a transcranial direct current stimulation study. J Neurophysiol 2011;106(2):652e61.
109. Marshall L, Kirov R, Brade J, Mölle M, Born J. Transcranial electrical currents to probe EEG brain rhythms and memory consolidation during sleep in humans. PLoS One 2011;6(2):e16905.
110. Reis J, Schambra HM, Cohen LG, et al. Noninvasive cortical stimulation enhances motor skill acquisition over multiple days through an effect on consolidation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 2009;106(5):1590e5.