Why are policy innovations rare and so often negative? Blame avoidance and problem denial in climate change policy-making

Global Environmental Change

Volumn 29, Issue , 2014, Pages 395-403

  Howlett, Michael ^a,b  

^a SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^b NATIONAL UNIVERSITY OF SINGAPORE   (Singapore)

Author keywords

Blame avoidance; Climate change; Policy failure; Policy innovation

Indexed keywords

EID: 84923458529     PISSN: 09593780     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.12.009     Document Type: Article

References (131)

1. Adelle C., Russel D. Climate policy integration: a case of Déjà Vu?. Environmental Policy and Governance 2013, 23(1):1-12.
2. Adapting to Climate Change: Thresholds, Values, Governance 2010, Cambridge University Press, Reissue. W.N. Adger, I. Lorenzoni, K.L. O'Brien (Eds.).
3. Anheier H.K. When Things Go Wrong: Organizational Failures and Breakdowns 1999, Sage Publications, Inc., Beverly Hills. 1st ed.
4. Balla S.J., Lawrence E.D., Maltzman F., Sigelman L. Partisanship, blame avoidance, and the distribution of legislative pork. American Journal of Political Science 2002, 46(July (3)):515-525.
5. Bassett T.J., Fogelman C. Déjà Vu or something new? The adaptation concept in the climate change literature. Geoforum August 2013, 48:42-53. 10.1016/j.geoforum.2013.04.010.
6. Baumgartner F.R., Jones B.D. Policy Dynamics 2002, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
7. Berman S. Ideational theorizing in the social sciences since 'policy paradigms, social learning, and the state'. Governance 2013, 26(2):217-237. 10.1111/gove.12008.
8. Biesbroek G.R., Swart R.J., Carter T.R., Cowan C., Henrichs T., Mela H., Morecroft M.D., Rey D. Europe adapts to climate change: comparing national adaptation strategies. Global Environmental Change 2010, 20(August (3)):440-450.
9. Birkland T.A. After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy and Focusing Events 1997, Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC.
10. Birkland T.A. Focusing events, mobilization, and agenda setting. Journal of Public Policy 1998, 18(1):53-74.
11. Bovens M., t'Hart P. Frame multiplicity and policy fiascos: limits to explanation. Knowledge and Policy 1995, 8(4):61-83.
12. Bovens M., t'Hart P. Understanding Policy Fiascos 1996, Transaction Press, New Brunswick, NJ.
13. Brandstrom A., Kuipers S. From 'normal incidents' to political crises: understanding the selective politicization of policy failures. Government and Opposition 2003, 38(3):279-305.
14. Bryner G. Failure and opportunity: environmental groups in US climate change policy. Environmental Politics 2008, 17(2):319-336.
15. Burns T.R., Ueberhorst R. Creative Democracy: Systematic Conflict Resolution and Policymaking in a World of High Science and Technology 1988, Praeger, New York.
16. Butzengeiger-Geyer S., Michaelowa A., Köhler M., Stadelmann M. Policy instruments for climate change adaptation - lessons from mitigation and preconditions for introduction of market mechanisms for adaptation. Colorado Conference on Earth System Governance 2011.
17. Capano G. Understanding policy change as an epistemological and theoretical problem. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice 2009, 11(March (1)):7-31.
18. European and North American Policy Change: Drivers and Dynamics 2009, Routledge, New York. G. Capano, M. Howlett (Eds.).
19. Cashore B., Howlett M. Punctuating which equilibrium? Understanding thermostatic policy dynamics in pacific northwest forestry. American Journal of Political Science 2007, 51(3):532-551.
20. Clayton S. Will people act to mitigate climate change?. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 2012, 12(1):221-224.
21. Clemens E.S., Cook J.M. Politics and institutionalism: explaining durability and change. Annual Review of Sociology 1999, 25:441-466.
22. Cobb R.W., Primo D.M. The Plane Truth: Airline Crashes, the Media, and Transportation Policy 2003, Brookings Institute, Washington, DC.
23. Cultural Strategies of Agenda Denial; Avoidance, Attack and Redefinition 1997, University Press of Kansas, Lawrence. R.W. Cobb, M.H. Ross (Eds.).
24. Compston H., Bailey I. Climate Clever: How Governments Can Tackle Climate Change (and Still Win Elections 2012, Routledge, London.
25. Connor L.H., Higginbotham N. Natural cycles' in lay understandings of climate change. Global Environmental Change 2013, 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.07.002.
26. Considine M. Thinking outside the box? Applying design theory to public policy. Politics and Policy 2012, 40(4):704-724.
27. Considine M., Lewis J.M. Innovation and innovators inside government: from institutions to networks. Governance 2007, 20(4):581-607.
28. Corner A., Randall A. Selling climate change? The limitations of social marketing as a strategy for climate change public engagement. Global Environmental Change 2013, (corrected Proof (n.d.)).
29. Craft J., Howlett M. The dual dynamics of policy advisory systems: the impact of externalization and politicization on policy advice. Policy and Society 2013, 32(September (3)):187-197.
30. de Vries M.S. The Importance of Neglect in Policy-Making 2010, Palgrave Macmillan, London.
31. Downs A. Up and down with ecology - the 'issue-attention cycle'. Public Interest 1972, 28:38-50.
32. Dunleavy P. Policy disasters: explaining the UK's record. Public Policy and Administration 1995, 10(2):52-70.
33. Dür A., Mateo G. Gaining access or going public? Interest group strategies in five European countries. European Journal of Political Research 2013, 52(5):660-686.
34. Edelman M.J. Constructing the Political Spectacle 1988, University of Chicago Press, Chicago.
35. Engels A., Hüther O., Schäfer M., Held H. Public climate-change skepticism, energy preferences and political participation. Global Environmental Change 2013, 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.05.008.
36. Europæiske Miljøagentur Adaptation in Europe: Addressing Risks and Opportunities from Climate Change in the Context of Socio-economic Developments 2013, European Environment Agency, Copenhagen.
37. García de Jalón S., Iglesias A., Quiroga S., Bardají I. Exploring public support for climate change adaptation policies in the Mediterranean region: a case study in Southern Spain. Environmental Science and Policy May 2013, 29:1-11. 10.1016/j.envsci.2013.01.010.
38. Giest S., Howlett M. Multi-level governance and place-based policy making for climate change adaptation: the European experience and lessons for British Columbia. BC Studies 2012, 176(Winter 2012/2013):145-166.
39. Goodin R.E. Manipulatory Politics 1980, Yale University Press, New Haven.
40. Grant W. Intractable policy failure: the case of bovine TB and badgers. British Journal of Politics and International Relations 2009, 11:557-573.
41. Griffin R. Auction designs for allocating wind energy leases on the U.S. outer continental shelf. Energy Policy 2013, (accessed 13.02.13). 10.1016/j.enpol.2013.01.023.
42. Hahn R.W. Primer on Environmental Policy Design 1989, Routledge Chapman & Hall, New York.
43. Hall P.A. Policy paradigms, social learning and the state: the case of economic policy making in Britain. Comparative Politics 1993, 25(3):275-296.
44. Hansen L., Gregg R.M., Arroyo V., Ellsworth S., Jackson L., Snover A. The State of Adaptation in the United States: An Overview. A report for John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation 2013, EcoAdapt.
45. Harris P.G. Collective action on climate change: the logic of regime failure. Natural Resources Journal 2007, 47(1):195-224.
46. Global Commons, Domestic Decisions: The Comparative Politics of Climate Change 2010, The MIT Press, Boston. K. Harrison, L.M. Sundstrom (Eds.).
47. Hayes M.T. The Limits of Policy Change: Incrementalism, Worldview and the Rule of Law 2001, Georgetown University Press, Washington, DC.
48. Hegger D., Lamers M., Van Zeijl-Rozema A., Dieperink C. Conceptualising joint knowledge production in regional climate change adaptation projects: success conditions and levers for action. Environmental Science and Policy April 2012, 18:52-65.
49. Hisschemoller M., Hoppe R. Coping with intractable controversies: the case for problem structuring in policy design and analysis. Knowledge and Policy 1995, 8(4):40-61.
50. Hobson K., Niemeyer S. Public responses to climate change: the role of deliberation in building capacity for adaptive action. Global Environmental Change 2011, 21(August (3)):957-971.
51. Hoffman M.J. Climate Governance at the Crossroads: Experimenting with a Global Response After Kyoto 2011, Oxford University Press, New York.
52. Holt D., Barkemeyer R. Media coverage of sustainable development issues - attention cycles or punctuated equilibrium?. Sustainable Development 2012, 20(January (1)):1-17. 10.1002/sd.460.
53. Hood C. The Tools of Government 1986, Chatham House Publishers, Chatham.
54. Hood C. The risk game and the blame game. Government and Opposition 2002, 37(1):15-54.
55. Hood C. The Blame Game: Spin, Bureaucracy, and Self-Preservation in Government 2010, Princeton University Press, Princeton.
56. Hood C. Can we? Administrative limits revisited. Public Administration Review 2010, 70(4):527-534.
57. Hood C., Baldwin R., Rothstein H. Assessing the dangerous dogs act: when does a regulatory law fail?. Public Law 2000, (Summer):282-305.
58. Hoppe R. The Governance of Problems: Puzzling, Powering and Participation 2010, Policy Press, Bristol.
59. Howlett M. Managing the 'hollow state': procedural policy instruments and modern governance. Canadian Public Administration 2000, 43(4):412-431.
60. Howlett M. Policy analytical capacity and evidence-based policy-making: lessons from Canada. Canadian Public Administration 2009, 52(2):153-175.
61. Howlett M. Designing Public Policies: Principles and Instruments 2011, Routledge, New York.
62. Howlett M. The lessons of failure: learning and blame avoidance in public policy-making. International Political Science Review 2012, 33(5):1-17.
63. Howlett M., Cashore B. The dependent variable problem in the study of policy change: understanding policy change as a methodological problem. Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice 2009, 11(1):33-46.
64. Howlett M., Migone A. Charles Lindblom is alive and well and living in punctuated equilibrium land. Policy and Society 2011, 30(February (1)):53-62.
65. Howlett M., Ramesh M., Perl A. Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems 2009, Oxford University Press, Toronto.
66. Huitema D., Meijerink S. Realizing water transitions. The role of policy entrepreneurs in water policy change. Ecology and Society 2010, 15(2):26.
67. Igielska B. Climate change mitigation: overview of the environmental policy instruments. International Journal of Green Economics 2008, 2(2):210-225.
68. Ingram H.M., Mann D.E. Policy Failure: An Issue Deserving Analysis. Why Policies Succeed or Fail 1980, 11-32. Sage Publications, Beverly Hills.
69. Jones B.D., Baumgartner F.R. From there to here: punctuated equilibrium to the general punctuation thesis to a theory of government information processing. Policy Studies Journal 2012, 40(February (1)):1-20.
70. Jordan A., Huitema D. Policy innovation in a changing climate: sources, pattern and effects. Global Environmental Change 2014, (in this issue).
71. Jordan A., Huitema D., van Asselt H., Rayner T., Berkhout F. Climate Change Policy in the European Union: Confronting the Dilemmas of Mitigation and Adaptation? 2010, Cambridge University Press, London.
72. Kay A. Tense layering and synthetic policy paradigms: the politics of health insurance in Australia. Australian Journal of Political Science 2007, 42(4):579-591.
73. Kingdon J.W. Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies 1984, Little Brown and Company, Boston.
74. Latin H.A. Climate Change Policy Failures: Why Conventional Mitigation Approaches Cannot Succeed 2012, World Scientific Publishing Company, London. 1st ed.
75. Lidskog R., Elander I. Addressing climate change democratically. Multi-level governance, transnational networks and governmental structures. Sustainable Development 2010, 18(1):32-41.
76. Lindblom C.E. The science of muddling through. Public Administration Review 1959, 19(2):79-88.
77. Lockwood M. The political sustainability of climate policy: the case of the UK climate change act. Global Environmental Change 2013, (accessed 14.08.13). 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.07.001.
78. Lorenzoni I., Pidgeon N.F. Public views on climate change: European and USA perspectives. Climatic Change 2006, 77(August (1-2)):73-95.
79. Maor M. Policy overreaction. Journal of Public Policy 2012, 32(3):231-259.
80. Maor M. Policy Bubbles: Policy Overreaction and Positive Feedback. SSRN Scholarly Paper 2013, Social Science Research Network, Rochester, NY, (accessed 25.05.13.). http://www.papers.ssrn.com/abstract=2219077.
81. Martin S., Sanderson I. Evaluating public policy experiments measuring outcomes, monitoring processes or managing pilots?. Evaluation 1999, 5(July (3)):245-258.
82. Massey E., Huitema D. The emergence of climate change adaptation as a policy field: the case of England. Regional Environmental Change 2012, 1-12.
83. McConnell A. Policy success, policy failure and grey areas in-between. Journal of Public Policy 2010, 30(3):345-362.
84. McConnell A. Understanding Policy Success: Rethinking Public Policy 2010, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke.
85. McGraw K.M. Avoiding blame: an experimental investigation of political excuses and justifications. British Journal of Political Science 1990, 20(January (1)):119-131.
86. McGraw K.M. Managing blame: an experimental test of the effects of political accounts. The American Political Science Review 1991, 85(December (4)):1133-1157.
87. Meadowcroft J. What about the politics? Sustainable development, transition management, and long term energy transitions. Policy Sciences 2009, 42(November (4)):323-340.
88. Merton R.K. The unanticipated consequences of purposive social action. American Sociological Review 1936, 6:1894-1904.
89. Moran M. Not steering but drowning: policy catastrophes and the regulatory state. The Political Quarterly 2001, 72:414-427.
90. Mortensen P.B. 'It's the Central government's fault': elected regional officials' use of blame-shifting rhetoric. Governance 2012, 25(3):439-461.
91. Mulder K.F. Innovation for sustainable development: from environmental design to transition management. Sustainability Science 2007, 2(September (2)):253-263.
92. Murray F. The changing winds of atmospheric environment policy. Environmental Science and Policy May 2013, 29:115-123.
93. Parenti M. Inventing Reality: The Politics of the Mass Media 1986, St. Martin's Press, New York.
94. Patchen M. What shapes public reactions to climate change? Overview of research and policy implications. Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy 2010, 10(1):47-68.
95. Peters B.G., Hogwood B.W. The Pathology of Public Policy 1985, Oxford University Press, New York.
96. Pielke R. The Climate Fix: What Scientists and Politicians Won't Tell You About Global Warming 2010, Basic Books, New York.
97. Polsby N.W. Political Innovation in America: The Politics of Policy Initiation 1984, Yale University Press, New Haven.
98. Poortinga W., Spence A., Whitmarsh L., Capstick S., Pidgeon N.F. Uncertain climate: an investigation into public scepticism about anthropogenic climate change. Global Environmental Change 2011, 21(August (3)):1015-1024.
99. Rabe B., Borick C., Lachapelle E. Climate Compared: Public Opinion on Climate Change in the United States and Canada 2011, The Brookings Institution. http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2011/04/climate-change-opinion.
100. Roots R.I. When laws backfire: unintended consequences of public policy. American Bahavioural Scientist 2004, 47(11):1376-1394.
101. Rotmans J., Kemp R., van Asselt M. More evolution then revolution: transition management in public policy. Foresight 2001, 3(1):15-31.
102. Sabatier P.A. An advocacy coalition framework of policy change and the role of policy-oriented learning therein. Policy Sciences 1988, 21(2/3):129-168.
103. Saward M. Co-Optive Politics and State Legitimacy 1992, Dartmouth, Aldershot.
104. Schmidt A., Ivanova A., Schäfer Mike S. Media attention for climate change around the world: a comparative analysis of newspaper coverage in 27 countries. Global Environmental Change 2013, 23(October (5)):1233-1248. 10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.07.020.
105. Schneider A.L. Patterns of change in the use of imprisonment in the American states: an integration of path dependence, punctuated equilibrium and policy design approaches. Political Research Quarterly 2006, 59(September (3)):457-470.
106. Deserving and Entitled: Social Constructions and Public Policy. SUNY Series in Public Policy 2005, State University of New York, Albany. A.L. Schneider, H.M. Ingram (Eds.).
107. Schudson M. The trouble with experts - and why democracies need them. Theory and Society 2006, 35:491-506.
108. Scruggs L., Benegal S. Declining public concern about climate change: can we blame the great recession?. Global Environmental Change 2012, 22(May (2)):505-515.
109. Simon H.A. A behavioural model of rational choice. Quarterly Journal of Economics 1955, 69(1):99-118.
110. Skogstad G. Policy failure, policy learning and policy development in a context of internationalization. Paper Presented to the Annual Meeting of the Canadian Political Science Association 2007.
111. Sovacool B.K. The policy challenges of tradable credits: a critical review of eight markets. Energy Policy 2011, 39(February (2)):575-585.
112. Stoker G., John P. Design experiments: engaging policy makers in the search for evidence about what works. Political Studies 2009, 57:336-373.
113. Stone D.A. Policy Paradox and Political Reason 1988, Scott, Foresman, Glenview, IL.
114. Toke D. Trading schemes, risks, and costs: the cases of the European Union emissions trading scheme and the renewables obligation. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 2008, 26:938-953.
115. Tversky A., Kahneman D., Slovic P. Judgement Under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases 1982, 3-20. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
116. Twight C. From claiming credit to avoiding blame: the evolution of congressional strategy for asbestos management. Journal of Public Policy 1991, 11(2):153-186.
117. van Beers C., de Moor A. Public Subsidies and Policy Failures: How Subsidies Distort the Natural Environment, Equity and Trade and How to Reform Them 2001, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.
118. van Buuren A., Loorbach D. Policy innovation in isolation? Conditions for policy renewal by transition arenas and pilot projects. Public Management Review 2009, 11(3):375-392.
119. Vining A.R., Weimer D.L. Government supply and government production failure: a framework based on contestability. Journal of Public Policy 1990, 10(1):1-22.
120. Voß J.-P., Bornemann B. The politics of reflexive governance: challenges for designing adaptive management and transition management. Ecology and Society 2011, 16(2):9-32.
121. Vreugdenhil H., Taljaard S., Slinger J.H. Pilot projects and their diffusion: a case study of integrated coastal management in South Africa. International Journal of Sustainable Development 2012, 15(1/2):148.
122. Walsh J.I. Policy failure and policy change. Comparative Political Studies 2006, 39(May (4)):490-518.
123. Weaver R.K. The politics of blame avoidance. Journal of Public Policy 1986, 6(4):371-398.
124. Weaver R.K. The politics of blame. The Brookings Review 1987, 5(April (2)):43-47.
125. Weaver R.K. Automatic Government: The Politics of Indexation 1988, Brookings Institution, Washington, DC.
126. Weaver K. Setting and firing policy triggers. Journal of Public Policy 1989, 9(July (3)):307-336.
127. Wellstead A., Howlett M., Rayner J. The neglect of governance in forest sector vulnerability assessments: structural-functionalism and 'Black Box' problems in climate change adaptation planning. Ecology and Society 2013, 18(3):23.
128. Wellstead A., Rayner J., Howlett M. Beyond the black box: forest sector vulnerability assessments and adaptation to climate change in North America. Environmental Science and Policy 2014, 35:109-116. 10.1016/j.envsci.2013.04.002.
129. Whitmarsh L. What's in a name? Commonalities and differences in public understanding of 'climate change' and 'global warming'. Public Understanding of Science 2009, 18(July (4)):401-420.
130. Wolf C. Markets and non-market failures: comparison and assessment. Journal of Public Policy 1987, 7(1):43-70.
131. Wolman H. The determinants of program success and failure. Journal of Public Policy 1981, 1(October (4)):433-464.