Crystalloids versus colloids: Exploring differences in fluid requirements by systematic review and meta-regression

Anesthesia and Analgesia

Volumn 120, Issue 2, 2015, Pages 389-402

  Orbegozo Cortés, Diego ^a   Gamarano Barros, Teresa ^a   Njimi, Hassane ^a   Vincent, Jean Louis ^a  

^a ERASME HOSPITAL   (Belgium)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ALBUMIN; INFUSION FLUID; ALBUMINOID; COLLOID; CRYSTALLOID; ISOTONIC SOLUTION; PLASMA SUBSTITUTE;

COLLOID; COMPARATIVE STUDY; CRYSTALLOID; HEMODYNAMICS; HUMAN; META ANALYSIS; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PUBLICATION; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REGRESSION ANALYSIS; REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; FLUID THERAPY; PROCEDURES; THERAPEUTIC USE;

ALBUMINS; COLLOIDS; FLUID THERAPY; HUMANS; ISOTONIC SOLUTIONS; PLASMA SUBSTITUTES; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC;

EID: 84922067358     PISSN: 00032999     EISSN: 15267598     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000000564     Document Type: Review

References (56)

1. Bansch P, Statkevicius S, Bentzer P. Plasma volume expansion with 5% albumin compared to Ringer's acetate during normal and increased microvascular permeability in the rat. Anesthesiology 2014; 121: 817-24
2. McIlroy DR, Kharasch ED. Acute intravascular volume expansion with rapidly administered crystalloid or colloid in the setting of moderate hypovolemia. Anesth Analg 2003; 96: 1572-7
3. Brunkhorst FM, Engel C, Bloos F, Meier-Hellmann A, Ragaller M, Weiler N, Moerer O, Gruendling M, Oppert M, Grond S, Olthoff D, Jaschinski U, John S, Rossaint R, Welte T, Schaefer M, Kern P, Kuhnt E, Kiehntopf M, Hartog C, Natanson C, Loeffler M, Reinhart K; German Competence Network Sepsis (SepNet). Intensive insulin therapy and pentastarch resuscitation in severe sepsis. N Engl J Med 2008; 358: 125-39
4. Guidet B, Martinet O, Boulain T, Philippart F, Poussel JF, Maizel J, Forceville X, Feissel M, Hasselmann M, Heininger A, Van Aken H. Assessment of hemodynamic efficacy and safety of 6% hydroxyethylstarch 130/0. 4 vs. 0. 9% NaCl fluid replacement in patients with severe sepsis: the CRYSTMAS study. Crit Care 2012; 16: R94
5. Lee JS, Ahn SW, Song JW, Shim JK, Yoo KJ, Kwak YL. Effect of hydroxyethyl starch 130/0. 4 on blood loss and coagulation in patients with recent exposure to dual antiplatelet therapy undergoing off-pump coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Circ J 2011; 75: 2397-402
6. Bayer O, Reinhart K, Sakr Y, Kabisch B, Kohl M, Riedemann NC, Bauer M, Settmacher U, Hekmat K, Hartog CS. Renal effects of synthetic colloids and crystalloids in patients with severe sepsis: A prospective sequential comparison. Crit Care Med 2011; 39: 1335-42
7. Magder S, Potter BJ, Varennes BD, Doucette S, Fergusson D; Canadian Critical Care Trials Group. Fluids after cardiac surgery: A pilot study of the use of colloids versus crystalloids. Crit Care Med 2010; 38: 2117-24
8. Perner A, Haase N, Guttormsen AB, Tenhunen J, Klemenzson G, Åneman A, Madsen KR, Møller MH, Elkjar JM, Poulsen LM, Bendtsen A, Winding R, Steensen M, Berezowicz P, Søe-Jensen P, Bestle M, Strand K, Wiis J, White JO, Thornberg KJ, Quist L, Nielsen J, Andersen LH, Holst LB, Thormar K, Kjaldgaard AL, Fabritius ML, Mondrup F, Pott FC, Møller TP, Winkel P, Wetterslev J; 6S Trial Group; Scandinavian Critical Care Trials Group. Hydroxyethyl starch 130/0. 42 versus Ringer's acetate in severe sepsis. N Engl J Med 2012; 367: 124-34
9. Finfer S, Bellomo R, Boyce N, French J, Myburgh J, Norton R; SAFE Study Investigators. A comparison of albumin and saline for fluid resuscitation in the intensive care unit. N Engl J Med 2004; 350: 2247-56
10. Payen D, de Pont AC, Sakr Y, Spies C, Reinhart K, Vincent JL; Sepsis Occurrence in Acutely Ill Patients (SOAP) Investigators. A positive fluid balance is associated with a worse outcome in patients with acute renal failure. Crit Care 2008; 12: R74
11. Lee J, de Louw E, Niemi M, Nelson R, Mark RG, Celi LA, Mukamal KJ, Danziger J. Association between fluid balance and survival in critically ill patients. J Intern Med 2014 [Epub ahead of print]
12. Metildi LA, Shackford SR, Virgilio RW, Peters RM. Crystalloid versus colloid in fluid resuscitation of patients with severe pulmonary insufficiency. Surg Gynecol Obstet 1984; 158: 207-12
13. Hankeln K, Siebert-Spelmeyer C, Böhmert F, Beez M, Laniewski P. Effect of colloid volume replacement substances and Ringer's lactate on hemodynamics and oxygen consumption of intensive care patients [in German]. Infusionstherapie 1988; 15: 33-8
14. Tølløfsrud S, Svennevig JL, Breivik H, Kongsgaard U, Ozer M, Hysing E, Mohr B, Seem E, Geiran O, Abdelnour M. Fluid balance and pulmonary functions during and after coronary artery bypass surgery: Ringer's acetate compared with dextran, polygeline, or albumin. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1995; 39: 671-7
15. Ernest D, Belzberg AS, Dodek PM. Distribution of normal saline and 5% albumin infusions in septic patients. Crit Care Med 1999; 27: 46-50
16. Dubin A, Pozo MO, Casabella CA, Murias G, Pálizas F Jr, Moseinco MC, Kanoore Edul VS, Pálizas F, Estenssoro E, Ince C. Comparison of 6% hydroxyethyl starch 130/0. 4 and saline solution for resuscitation of the microcirculation during the early goal-directed therapy of septic patients. J Crit Care 2010; 25: 659. e1-8
17. Lv J, Zhao HY, Liu F, An YZ. The influence of lactate Ringer solution versus hydroxyethyl starch on coagulation and fibrinolytic system in patients with septic shock [in Chinese]. Zhongguo Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue 2012; 24: 38-41
18. Virgilio RW, Rice CL, Smith DE, James DR, Zarins CK, Hobelmann CF, Peters RM. Crystalloid vs. colloid resuscitation: is one better. A randomized clinical study. Surgery 1979; 85: 129-39
19. Shires GT 3rd, Peitzman AB, Albert SA, Illner H, Silane MF, Perry MO, Shires GT. Response of extravascular lung water to intraoperative fluids. Ann Surg 1983; 197: 515-9
20. Weisel RD, Charlesworth DC, Mickleborough LL, Fremes SE, Ivanov J, Mickle DA, Teasdale SJ, Glynn MF, Scully HE, Goldman BS. Limitations of blood conservation. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 1984; 88: 26-38
21. Gallagher JD, Moore RA, Kerns D, Jose AB, Botros SB, Flicker S, Naidech H, Clark DL. Effects of colloid or crystalloid administration on pulmonary extravascular water in the postoperative period after coronary artery bypass grafting. Anesth Analg 1985; 64: 753-8
22. McNulty SE, Sharkey SJ, Asam B, Lee JH. Evaluation of STATCRIT hematocrit determination in comparison to Coulter and centrifuge: the effects of isotonic hemodilution and albumin administration. Anesth Analg 1993; 76: 830-4
23. Marik PE, Iglesias J, Maini B. Gastric intramucosal pH changes after volume replacement with hydroxyethyl starch or crystalloid in patients undergoing elective abdominal aortic aneurysm repair. J Crit Care 1997; 12: 51-5
24. Ernest D, Belzberg AS, Dodek PM. Distribution of normal saline and 5% albumin infusions in cardiac surgical patients. Crit Care Med 2001; 29: 2299-302
25. Verheij J, van Lingen A, Beishuizen A, Christiaans HM, de Jong JR, Girbes AR, Wisselink W, Rauwerda JA, Huybregts MA, Groeneveld AB. Cardiac response is greater for colloid than saline fluid loading after cardiac or vascular surgery. Intensive Care Med 2006; 32: 1030-8
26. Soares RR, Ferber L, Lorentz MN, Soldati MT. Intraoperative volume replacement: crystalloids versus colloids in surgical myocardial revascularization without cardiopulmonary bypass [in Portuguese]. Rev Bras Anestesiol 2009; 59: 439-51
27. Lowe RJ, Moss GS, Jilek J, Levine HD. Crystalloid vs colloid in the etiology of pulmonary failure after trauma: A randomized trial in man. Surgery 1977; 81: 676-83
28. Shah DM, Browner BD, Dutton RE, Newell JC, Powers SR Jr. Cardiac output and pulmonary wedge pressure. Use for evaluation of fluid replacement in trauma patients. Arch Surg 1977; 112: 1161-8
29. Moss GS, Lowe RJ, Jilek J, Levine HD. Colloid or crystalloid in the resuscitation of hemorrhagic shock: A controlled clinical trial. Surgery 1981; 89: 434-8
30. Macintyre E, Mackie IJ, Ho D, Tinker J, Bullen C, Machin SJ. The haemostatic effects of hydroxyethyl starch (HES) used as a volume expander. Intensive Care Med 1985; 11: 300-3
31. Rackow EC, Falk JL, Fein IA, Siegel JS, Packman MI, Haupt MT, Kaufman BS, Putnam D. Fluid resuscitation in circulatory shock: A comparison of the cardiorespiratory effects of albumin, hetastarch, and saline solutions in patients with hypovolemic and septic shock. Crit Care Med 1983; 11: 839-50
32. Hankeln K, Rädel C, Beez M, Laniewski P, Bohmert F. Comparison of hydroxyethyl starch and lactated Ringer's solution on hemodynamics and oxygen transport of critically ill patients in prospective crossover studies. Crit Care Med 1989; 17: 133-5
33. Prien T, Backhaus N, Pelster F, Pircher W, Bünte H, Lawin P. Effect of intraoperative fluid administration and colloid osmotic pressure on the formation of intestinal edema during gastrointestinal surgery. J Clin Anesth 1990; 2: 317-23
34. Pockaj BA, Yang JC, Lotze MT, Lange JR, Spencer WF, Steinberg SM, Topalian SL, Schwartzentruber DJ, White DE, Rosenberg SA. A prospective randomized trial evaluating colloid versus crystalloid resuscitation in the treatment of the vascular leak syndrome associated with interleukin-2 therapy. J Immunother Emphasis Tumor Immunol 1994; 15: 22-8
35. Evans PA, Garnett M, Boffard K, Kirkman E, Jacobson BF. Evaluation of the effect of colloid (Haemaccel) on the bleeding time in the trauma patient. J R Soc Med 1996; 89: 101P-4P
36. Younes RN, Yin KC, Amino CJ, Itinoshe M, Rocha e Silva M, Birolini D. Use of pentastarch solution in the treatment of patients with hemorrhagic hypovolemia: randomized phase II study in the emergency room. World J Surg 1998; 22: 2-5
37. Bothner U, Georgieff M, Vogt NH. Assessment of the safety and tolerance of 6% hydroxyethyl starch (200/0. 5) solution: A randomized, controlled epidemiology study. Anesth Analg 1998; 86: 850-5
38. Moretti EW, Robertson KM, El-Moalem H, Gan TJ. Intraoperative colloid administration reduces postoperative nausea and vomiting and improves postoperative outcomes compared with crystalloid administration. Anesth Analg 2003; 96: 611-7
39. Yorozu T, Morisaki H, Kondoh M, Zenfuku M, Shigematsu T. Comparative effect of 6% hydroxyethyl starch (containing 1% dextrose) and lactated Ringer's solution for cesarean section under spinal anesthesia. J Anesth 2002; 16: 203-6
40. Mittermayr M, Streif W, Haas T, Fries D, Velik-Salchner C, Klingler A, Innerhofer P. Effects of colloid and crystalloid solutions on endogenous activation of fibrinolysis and resistance of polymerized fibrin to recombinant tissue plasminogen activator added ex vivo. Br J Anaesth 2008; 100: 307-14
41. Schortgen F, Girou E, Deye N, Brochard L; CRYCO Study Group. The risk associated with hyperoncotic colloids in patients with shock. Intensive Care Med 2008; 34: 2157-68
42. Trof RJ, Sukul SP, Twisk JW, Girbes AR, Groeneveld AB. Greater cardiac response of colloid than saline fluid loading in septic and non-septic critically ill patients with clinical hypovolaemia. Intensive Care Med 2010; 36: 697-701
43. Myburgh JA, Finfer S, Bellomo R, Billot L, Cass A, Gattas D, Glass P, Lipman J, Liu B, McArthur C, McGuinness S, Rajbhandari D, Taylor CB, Webb SA; CHEST Investigators; Australian and New Zealand Intensive Care Society Clinical Trials Group. Hydroxyethyl starch or saline for fluid resuscitation in intensive care. N Engl J Med 2012; 367: 1901-11
44. Feldheiser A, Pavlova V, Bonomo T, Jones A, Fotopoulou C, Sehouli J, Wernecke KD, Spies C. Balanced crystalloid compared with balanced colloid solution using a goal-directed haemodynamic algorithm. Br J Anaesth 2013; 110: 231-40
45. Topçu I, Civi M, Oztürk T, Keleş GT, Coban S, Yentür EA, Okçu G. Evaluation of hemostatic changes using n thromboelastography after crystalloid or colloid fluid administration during major orthopedic surgery. Braz J Med Biol Res 2012; 45: 869-74
46. Alavi SM, Ahmadi BB, Baharestani B, Babaei T. Comparison of the effects of gelatin, Ringer's solution and a modern hydroxyl ethyl starch solution after coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Cardiovasc J Afr 2012; 23: 428-31
47. Haase N, Perner A, Hennings LI, Siegemund M, Lauridsen B, Wetterslev M, Wetterslev J. Hydroxyethyl starch 130/0. 38-0. 45 versus crystalloid or albumin in patients with sepsis: systematic review with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis. BMJ 2013; 346: f839
48. Bayer O, Reinhart K, Kohl M, Kabisch B, Marshall J, Sakr Y, Bauer M, Hartog C, Schwarzkopf D, Riedemann N. Effects of fluid resuscitation with synthetic colloids or crystalloids alone on shock reversal, fluid balance, and patient outcomes in patients with severe sepsis: A prospective sequential analysis. Crit Care Med 2012; 40: 2543-51
49. Ando Y, Terao Y, Fukusaki M, Yamashita K, Takada M, Tanabe T, Sumikawa K. Influence of low-molecular-weight hydroxyethyl starch on microvascular permeability in patients undergoing abdominal surgery: comparison with crystalloid. J Anesth 2008; 22: 391-6
50. Zhu GC, Quan ZY, Shao YS, Zhao JG, Zhang YT. The study of hypertonic saline and hydroxyethyl starch treating severe sepsis [in Chinese]. Zhongguo Wei Zhong Bing Ji Jiu Yi Xue 2011; 23: 150-3
51. Lindroos AC, Niiya T, Silvasti-Lundell M, Randell T, Hernesniemi J, Niemi TT. Stroke volume-directed administration of hydroxyethyl starch or Ringer's acetate in sitting position during craniotomy. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 2013; 57: 729-36
52. Annane D, Siami S, Jaber S, Martin C, Elatrous S, Declere AD, Preiser JC, Outin H, Troche G, Charpentier C, Trouillet JL, Kimmoun A, Forceville X, Darmon M, Lesur O, Regnier J, Abroug F, Berger P, Clec'h C, Cousson J, Thibault L, Chevret S. Effects of fluid resuscitation with colloids vs crystalloids on mortality in critically ill patients presenting with hypovolemic shock: the CRISTAL randomized trial. JAMA 2013; 310: 1809-17
53. Svensén C, Hahn RG. Volume kinetics of Ringer solution, dextran 70, and hypertonic saline in male volunteers. Anesthesiology 1997; 87: 204-12
54. James MF, Latoo MY, Mythen MG, Mutch M, Michaelis C, Roche AM, Burdett E. Plasma volume changes associated with two hydroxyethyl starch colloids following acute hypovolaemia in volunteers. Anaesthesia 2004; 59: 738-42
55. Payen JF, Vuillez JP, Geoffray B, Lafond JL, Comet M, Stieglitz P, Jacquot C. Effects of preoperative intentional hemodilution on the extravasation rate of albumin and fluid. Crit Care Med 1997; 25: 243-8
56. Dubois MJ, Orellana-Jimenez C, Melot C, De Backer D, Berre J, Leeman M, Brimioulle S, Appoloni O, Creteur J, Vincent JL. Albumin administration improves organ function in critically ill hypoalbuminemic patients: A prospective, randomized, controlled, pilot study. Crit Care Med 2006; 34: 2536-40