Cost-effectiveness of nitrogen mitigation by alternative household wastewater management technologies

Journal of Environmental Management

Volumn 150, Issue , 2015, Pages 344-354

  Wood, Alison ^a   Blackhurst, Michael ^b   Hawkins, Troy ^c   Xue, Xiaobo ^c   Ashbolt, Nicholas ^d   Garland, Jay ^d  

^a The University of Texas at Austin   (United States)

^b UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN   (United States)

^c U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

^d U S ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY   (United States)

Author keywords

Advanced septic; Blackwater digestion; Compost toilet; Cost effectiveness; Diversion toilet; Household wastewater; Nitrogen

Indexed keywords

NITROGEN; WATER; WASTE WATER;

COMPOST; COMPOSTING; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; DOMESTIC WASTE; LIFE CYCLE ANALYSIS; NITROGEN; RECYCLING; SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS; SEWAGE TREATMENT; URINE;

ARTICLE; COMPOSTING; COST EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS; EUTROPHICATION; HOUSEHOLD; LIFE CYCLE; SEPTIC TANK; URINE DIVERSION; WASTE COMPONENT REMOVAL; WASTE WATER MANAGEMENT; WASTE WATER RECYCLING; WATERSHED; WATERSHED MANAGEMENT; CHEMISTRY; COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS; ECONOMICS; FAMILY SIZE; HUMAN; PROCEDURES; SEWAGE; UNITED STATES; WASTE WATER;

FALMOUTH [MASSACHUSETTS]; MASSACHUSETTS; UNITED STATES;

COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; FAMILY CHARACTERISTICS; HUMANS; NITROGEN; UNITED STATES; WASTE DISPOSAL, FLUID; WASTE WATER;

EID: 84920913820     PISSN: 03014797     EISSN: 10958630     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2014.10.002     Document Type: Article

References (88)

1. AquaPoint City Chooses Distributed Wastewater over Central Sewer 2008, AquaPoint Performance Based Wastewater Treatment Solutions, Aug. 1, 2014. http://www.aquapoint.com/images/Piperton%20Case%20Study_pdfs.pdf.
2. Baek S.H., Pagilla K.R. "Aerobic and anaerobic membrane bioreactors for municipal wastewater treatment.". Water Environ. Res. 2006, 78(2):133-140.
3. Baker L.A., Hartzheim P.M., Hobbie S.E., King J.Y., Nelson K.C. "Effect of consumption choices on fluxes of carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus through households.". Urban Ecosyst. 2007, 10(2):97-117.
4. Barnstable County Department of Health and Environment Data and Statistics 2014, Barnstable County Septic Database, Aug. 1, 2014. http://https://septic.barnstablecountyhealth.org/posts/data-and-statistics.
5. Barnstable County Wastewater Cost Task Force Comparison of Costs for Wastewater Management Systems Applicable to Cape Cod: Guidance to Cape Cod Towns Undertaking Comprehensive Wastewater Management Planning 2010, Cape Cod Water Protection Collaborative.
6. Buchanan J.R., Deal N.E., Lindbo D.L., Hanson A.T., Gustafson D.G., Miles R.J. Collection Series: Gravity Sewer Systems 2010, Water Environment Research Foundation.
7. Cape Cod Commission Regional Wastewater Management Plan: Overview 2013, Barnstable County, MA.
8. Cape Cod Eco-Toilet Center. (n.d.). "UD Flush Toilets." Cape Cod Eco-Toilet Center, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://capecodecotoiletcenter.com/types-of-eco-toilets/urine-diverting-toilets/ud-flush-toilets/.
9. Cape Cod Winwater Work Co Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
10. Capewide Enterprises Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
11. Charles K., Ashbolt N., Ferguson C., Roser D., McGuinness R., Deere D. Centralised versus decentralised sewage systems: a comparison of pathogen and nutrient loads released into Sydney's drinking water catchments. Water Sci. Technol. 2003, 48(11-12):53-60.
12. Chesapeake Bay Commission Cost-effective Strategies for the Bay 2004, Chesapeake Bay Commission.
13. Chesapeake Bay Program Chesapeake Bay Nutrient Reduction Progress and Future Directions 1997, Chesapeake Bay Program.
14. Clivus Multrum 2013 Residential Price List 2013.
15. Clivus Multrum Personal Communication with Customer Service 2013.
16. Commonwealth of Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs, Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection, and West Falmouth Harbor Embayment System Total Maximum Daily Loads for Total Nitrogen 2007.
17. Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan Review Committee Town of Falmouth Comprehensive Wastewater Management Planning Project for the South Coast Watersheds to Little Pond, Great Pond, Green Pond, Bournes Pond, Eel Pond and Waquoit Bay. Town of Falmouth 2010.
18. David J.Burnie Septic Services Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
19. Dodds W.K., Bouska W.W., Eitzmann J.L., Pilger T.J., Pitts K.L., Riley A.J., Schloesser J.T., Thornbrugh D.J. "Eutrophication of U.S. freshwaters: analysis of potential economic damages.". Environ. Sci. Technol. 2009, 43(1):12-19.
20. "EAGO TB326 Ultra Low Flush Eco-Friendly Toilet." (n.d.). Amazon, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.amazon.com/EAGO-TB326-Eco-Friendly-Toilet-1-Piece/dp/B003YA0GCU#.
21. Ecovita. (n.d.). "Ecovita Products and Tools." (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.ecovita.net/products.html.
22. Gallagher N.T., Sharvelle S.E. Decentralized anaerobic blackwater management: a sustainable development technology concept for urban water management. World Environ. Water Resour. Congr. 2010: Challenges Change 2010, 16-20.
23. Gerardi M.H. Nitrification and Denitrification in the Activated Sludge Process 2002, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, NY.
24. Gottschall N., Edwards M., Topp E., Bolton P., Payne M., Curnoe W.E., Coelho B.B., Lapen D.R. Nitrogen, phosphorus, and bacteria tile and groundwater quality following direct injection of dewatered municipal biosolids into soil. J.Environ. Qual. 2009, 38(3):1066.
25. Guérineau H., Dorner S., Carrière A., McQuaid N., Sauvé S., Aboulfadl K., Hajj-Mohamad M., Prévost M. Source tracking of leaky sewers: a novel approach combining fecal indicators in water and sediments. Water Res. 2014, 58:50-61.
26. Hardisty P.E., Sivapalan M., Humphries R. Determining a sustainable and economically optimal wastewater treatment and discharge strategy. J.Environ. Manag. 2013, 114:285-292.
27. Hawn C. Bilfinger Airvac Water Technologies Vacuum Toilet Information 2014.
28. Hernández-Sancho F., Molinos-Senante M., Sala-Garrido R. Economic valuation of environmental benefits from wastewater treatment processes: an empirical approach for Spain. Sci. Total Environ. 2010, 408(4):953-957.
29. Hill G.B., Baldwin S.A. Vermicomposting toilets, an alternative to latrine style microbial composting toilets, prove far superior in mass reduction, pathogen destruction, compost quality, and operational cost. Waste Manag. 2012, 32(10):1811-1820.
30. Holt P., James E. Wastewater Reuse in the Urban Environment: Selection of Technologies 2006, Landcom.
31. Hong B., Swaney D.P., Howarth R.W. Estimating net anthropogenic nitrogen inputs to U.S. watersheds: comparison of methodologies. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47(10):5199-5207.
32. Howarth R.W. Coastal nitrogen pollution: a review of sources and trends globally and regionally. Harmful Algae 2008, 8(1):14-20.
33. Industrial Economics, Inc, Millenium Institute, and Applied Science Associates, Inc Narragansett Bay Sustainability Pilot: Phase I Report 2012, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
34. Jaffe A. Personal Communication with Eco-toilet Expert 2014.
35. Kampschreur M.J., Temmink H., Kleerebezem R., Jetten M.S.M., van Loosdrecht M.C.M. Nitrous oxide emission during wastewater treatment. Water Res. 2009, 43(17):4093-4103.
36. Kelsay J.L., Behall K.M., Prather E.S. Effect of fiber from fruits and vegetables on metabolic responses of human subjects: I. Bowel transit time, number of defecations, fecal weight, urinary excretions of energy and nitrogen and apparent digestibilities of energy, nitrogen, and fat. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. 1978, 31:1149-1153.
37. Kinstedt K. Optimization of the Collection and Transport of Blackwater in Source-separated Wastewater Systems 2012, Technical University Hamburg-Harburg, Hamburg, Germany.
38. Leal L.H., Temmink H., Zeeman G., Buisman C.J.N. Characterization and anaerobic biodegradability of grey water. Desalination 2011, 270(1-3):111-115.
39. Lin H., Peng W., Zhang M., Chen J., Hong H., Zhang Y. Areview on anaerobic membrane bioreactors: applications, membrane fouling and future perspectives. Desalination 2013, 314:169-188.
40. Liptzin D., Dahlgren R. ACalifornia Nitrogen Mass Balance for 2005 2014, California Nitrogen Assessment, (in review).
41. Liu C., Zou C., Wang Q., Hayashi Y., Yasunari T. Impact assessment of human diet changes with rapid urbanization on regional nitrogen and phosphorus flows-a case study of the megacity Shanghai. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Res. 2014, 21(3):1905-1914.
42. Meinzinger F. Resource Efficiency of Urban Sanitation Systems: a Comparative Assessment Using Material and Energy Flow Analysis 2010, Technical University Hamburg-Harburg, Hamburg, Germany.
43. Merck "Urination, Excessive or Frequent." the Merck Manual Home Health Handbook 2013, Aug. 1, 2014. http://www.merckmanuals.com/home/kidney_and_urinary_tract_disorders/symptoms_of_kidney_and_urinary_tract_disorders/urination_excessive_or_frequent.html.
44. Miller R. Personal Communication with Orenco Customer Service 2014.
45. National Center for Environmental Economics Guidelines for Preparing Economic Analyses 2010, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Policy.
46. Noe-Hays A. Personal Communication with Eco-toilet Expert 2014.
47. Nutrient Reduction Technology Cost Task Force Nutrient Reduction Technology Cost Estimations for Point Sources in the Chesapeake Bay Watershed 2002, Chesapeake Bay Program.
48. Oceanside Septic Services Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
49. Pelletier N., Leip A. Quantifying anthropogenic mobilization, flows (in product systems) and emissions of fixed nitrogen in process-based environmental life cycle assessment: rationale, methods and application to a life cycle inventory. Int. J. Life Cycle Assess. 2014, 19(1):166-173.
50. Potamis G. Personal Communication with Falmouth, MA Wastewater Engineer 2014.
51. Pretty J.N., Mason C.F., Nedwell D.B., Hine R.E., Leaf S., Dils R. Environmental costs of freshwater eutrophication in England and Wales. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2003, 37(2):201-208.
52. Rehan R., Knight M.A., Haas C.T., Unger A.J.A. Application of system dynamics for developing financially self-sustaining management policies for water and wastewater systems. Water Res. 2011, 45(16):4737-4750.
53. Rehan R., Knight M.A., Unger A.J.A., Haas C.T. Development of a system dynamics model for financially sustainable management of municipal watermain networks. Water Res. 2013, 47(20):7184-7205.
54. Rehan R., Knight M.A., Unger A.J.A., Haas C.T. Financially sustainable management strategies for urban wastewater collection infrastructure - development of a system dynamics model. Tunn. Undergr. Space Technol. 2014, 39:116-129.
55. Rehan R., Unger A.J.A., Knight M.A., Haas C.T. Financially sustainable management strategies for urban wastewater collection infrastructure - implementation of a system dynamics model. Tunn. Undergr. Space Technol. 2014, 39:102-115.
56. Remy C., Jekel M. Energy analysis of conventional and source-separation systems for urban wastewater management using life cycle assessment. Water Sci. Technol. 2011, 65(1):22.
57. Rosie's Natural Way. (n.d.). "Dubbletten." Rosie's Natural Way, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.rosiesnaturalway.com/dubbletten/.
58. Rowland J. Personal Communication with I/A Septic Expert 2014.
59. RS Means RS Means Online 2013, Oct. 4, 2013. http://www.rsmeansonline.com/.
60. Schoen M.E., Xue X., Hawkins T.R., Ashbolt N.J. Comparative human health risk analysis of coastal community water and waste service options. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2014, 48(16):9728-9736.
61. "Separett Waterless Toilets." (n.d.). (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.separett-usa.com/.
62. "Septic Systems and Their Maintenance." (n.d.). Soil Facts, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.soil.ncsu.edu/publications/Soilfacts/AG-439-13/.
63. "Septic Tank Pumping Cost - The Ultimate Guide to Pumping Cost" SepticHelp.org, Aug. 1, 2014. http://www.septichelp.org/septic-tank-pumping-cost/.
64. Shea Concrete Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
65. Short J. Personal Communication with I/A Septic Expert 2014.
66. Short M.D., Daikeler A., Peters G.M., Mann K., Ashbolt N.J., Stuetz R.M., Peirson W.L. Municipal gravity sewers: an unrecognised source of nitrous oxide. Sci. Total Environ. 2014, 468-469:211-218.
67. Siegmund Environmental Personal Communication with Massachusetts Septic Company 2014.
68. "Sun-Mar Sealand 510 Plus Ultra Low Flush Toilet." (n.d.). Bass Pro Shops, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.basspro.com/SunMar-Sealand-510-Plus-Ultra-Low-Flush-Toilet/product/89011/.
69. Sunmar Personal Communication with Customer Service 2013.
70. Tarnopolsky M.A., MacDougall J.D., Atkinson S.A. Influence of protein intake and training status on nitrogen balance and lean body mass. J.Appl. Physiol. 1988, 64(1):187-193.
71. TenBrink M. Falmouth water bill 2013.
72. Termes-Rifé M., Molinos-Senante M., Hernández-Sancho F., Sala-Garrido R. Life cycle costing: a tool to manage the urban water cycle. J.Water Supply: Res. Technol.-AQUA 2013, 62(7):468.
73. Town of Falmouth Annual Town Meeting 2013.
74. Town of Falmouth Wastewater Department 2013, Town of Falmouth, Jul. 30, 2014. http://www.falmouthmass.us/depart.php?depkey=wastewater.
75. U.S. Department of Commerce. (n.d.). "American Fact Finder: Community Facts, Falmouth Town, Barnstable County, Massachusetts." United States Census Bureau, (Jul. 30, 2014). http://factfinder2.census.gov/faces/nav/jsf/pages/community_facts.xhtml.
76. U.S.Environmental Protection Agency Onsite Wastewater Treatment Systems Manual 2002, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
77. U.S.Environmental Protection Agency National Rivers and Streams Assessment 2008-2009: a Collaborative Survey 2013.
78. U.S.Environmental Protection Agency Indoor Water Use in the United States 2014, Water Sense, Jul. 31, 2014. http://www.epa.gov/WaterSense/pubs/indoor.html.
79. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (n.d.). "Striving for Balance in the Narragansett Bay Watershed: EPA's Triple Value Simulation (3VS) Model." U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Office of Research and Development.
80. Vacuum Toilets Australia. (n.d.). "Vacuum Toilet System Operation." Vacuum Toilets Australia Pty Ltd, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.vacuumtoiletsaustralia.com.au/operation.html.
81. Van Grinsven H.J.M., Holland M., Jacobsen B.H., Klimont Z., Sutton M.a., Jaap Willems W. Costs and benefits of nitrogen for Europe and implications for mitigation. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2013, 47(8):3571-3579.
82. "Villeroy & Boch Toilet Element for Omnia Architectura GreenGain Toilet." (n.d.). reuter-shop.com, (Aug. 1, 2014). http://www.reuter-shop.com/villeroy-boch-toilet-element-for-omnia-architectura-greengain-toilet-5638-p46980.php.
83. Vinnerås B. Possibilities for Sustainable Nutrient Recycling by Faecal Separation Combined with Urine Diversion 2002, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, Uppasala, Sweden.
84. Wang S. Values of decentralized systems that avoid investments in idle capacity within the wastewater sector: a theoretical justification. J.Environ. Manag. 2014, 136:68-75.
85. Whitman D., Terry R. Fundamentals of Engineering Economics and Decision Analysis 2012, Morgan & Claypool Publishers.
86. Wood C. Personal Communication with Rhode Island Contractor 2014.
87. Xue, X., Hawkins, T., Schoen, M., and Ashbolt, N., (Under revision). "Comparative assessment of life cycle energy consumption and global warming potential of options for providing household water and waste services." Environ. Sci. Technol.
88. Xue X., Landis A.E. Eutrophication potential of food consumption patterns. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2010, 44(16):6450-6456.