Lichenometric dating: Science or pseudo-science?

Quaternary Research (United States)

Volumn 83, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 1-12

  Osborn, Gerald ^a   McCarthy, Daniel ^b   LaBrie, Aline ^c   Burke, Randall ^d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY   (Canada)

^b BROCK UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^c Canadian Natural Resources Limited   (Canada)

^d NONE   (Canada)

Author keywords

Geochronology; Glacial chronology; Growth curves; Lichenometric dating; Lichenometry; Rhizocarpon geographicum

Indexed keywords

DATA HANDLING; DEPOSITS; GEOCHRONOLOGY;

GLACIAL CHRONOLOGY; GROWTH CURVES; LICHENOMETRIC DATING; LICHENOMETRY; RHIZOCARPON GEOGRAPHICUM;

FUNGI;

GEOCHRONOLOGY; GROWTH CURVE; LICHEN; LICHENOMETRY; MORTALITY; QUATERNARY;

RHIZOCARPON GEOGRAPHICUM;

EID: 84920859727     PISSN: 00335894     EISSN: 10960287     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.yqres.2014.09.006     Document Type: Article

References (117)

1. Allen S.M., Smith D.J. Late Holocene glacial activity of Bridge Glacier, British Columbia Coast Mountains. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 2007, 44(12):1753-1773.
2. Andrews J.T., Barnett D.M. Holocene (Neoglacial) moraine and proglacial lake chronology, Barnes Ice Cap, Canada. Boreas 1979, 8:341-358.
3. Andrews J.T., Webber P.J. Lichenometry to evaluate changes in glacial mass budgets: as illustrated from north-central Baffin Island, N.W.T. Arctic and Alpine Research 1969, 1(3):181-194.
4. Angiel P.J., Dabski M. Lichenometric ages of the Little Ice Age moraines on King George Island and of the last volcanic activity on Penguin Island (West Antarctica). Geografiska Annaler Series A Physical Geography 2012, 94:395-412.
5. Armstrong R.A. Growth curves for four crustose lichens. Symbiosis 2005, 38:47-57.
6. Armstrong R.A. The biology of the crustose lichen Rhizocarpon geographicum. Symbiosis 2011, 55(2):53-67.
7. Armstrong R., Bradwell T. Growth of crustose lichens: a review. Geografiska Annaler 2010, 92(1):3-17.
8. Asta J., Letrouit-Galinou M.A. Observations on the early growth of Rhizocarpon geographicum thalli. Herzogia 1995, 11:239-252.
9. Bacon C.R., Lanphere M.A. Eruptive history and geochronology of Mount Mazama and the Crater Lake region, Oregon. Geological Society of America Bulletin 2006, 118:1331-1359.
10. 10Be ages of late Pleistocene deglaciation and neoglaciation in the north-central Brooks Range, Arctic Alaska. Journal of Quaternary Science 2013, 28(1):95-102.
11. Beget J.E. Tephrochronology, lichenometry and radiocarbon dating at Gulkana Glacier, central Alaska Range, USA. The Holocene 1994, 4:307-331.
12. Benedict J.B. Recent glacial history of an alpine area in the Colorado Front Range, U.S.A. 1. Establishing a lichen-growth curve. Journal of Glaciology 1967, 6:817-832.
13. Benedict J.B. A review of lichenometric dating and its applications to archaeology. American Antiquity 2009, 74:143-173.
14. Beschel R.E. Flechten als Altersmaßstab rezenter Moränen. Zeitschrift für Gletscherkunde und Geologie 1950, 1:152-162. (Translated by Barr, W., 1973. Lichens as a measure of the age of recent moraines. Arctic and Alpine Research 5, 303-309.).
15. Beschel R.E. Dating rock surfaces by lichen growth and its application to glaciology and physiography (lichenometry). Geology of the Arctic: Proceedings of the First International Symposium on Arctic Geology 1961, 1044-1062. University of Toronto Press, Toronto. G.O. Raasch (Ed.).
16. Bickerton R.W., Matthews J.A. On the accuracy of lichenometric dates: an assessment based on the 'Little Ice Age' moraine sequence of Nigardsbreen, southern Norway. The Holocene 1992, 2(3):227-237.
17. Bowerman N.D., Clark D.H. Holocene glaciation of the central Sierra Nevada, California. Quaternary Science Reviews 2011, 30:1067-1085.
18. Bradwell T. Lichenometric dating in southeast Iceland: the size-frequency approach. Geografiska Annaler 2004, 86:31-41.
19. Bradwell T. Lichenometric dating: a commentary, in the light of some recent statistical studies. Geografiska Annaler 2009, 91(2):61-69.
20. Bradwell T. Studies on the growth of Rhizocarpon geographicum in NW Scotland, and some implications for lichenometry. Geografiska Annaler 2010, 92(1):41-52.
21. Bradwell T., Armstrong R.A. Growth rates of Rhizocarpon geographicum lichens: a review with new data from Iceland. Journal of Quaternary Science 2007, 22:311-320.
22. Brock F., Lee S., Housley R.A., Ramsey C.B. Variation in the radiocarbon age of different fractions of peat: a case study from Ahrenshöft, northern Germany. Quaternary Geochronology 2011, 6:550-555.
23. Bull W.B. Dating San Andreas fault earthquakes with lichenometry. Geology 1996, 24(2):111-114.
24. Bull W.B. Lichenometry: a new way of dating and locating prehistorical earthquakes. American Geophysical Union Reference Shelf Series 4, Washington DC 2000, 521-526. J. Stratton, J.M. Sowers, W.R. Lettis (Eds.).
25. Bull W.B., Brandon M.T. Lichen dating of earthquake-generated regional rockfall events, Southern Alps, New Zealand. Geological Society America Bulletin 1998, 110:60-84.
26. Calkin P.E., Ellis J.M. A lichenometric dating curve and its application to Holocene glacier studies in the central Brooks Range, Alaska. Arctic and Alpine Research 1980, 12:245-264.
27. Calkin P.E., Ellis J.M. Development and application of a lichenometric dating curve, Brooks Range, Alaska. Quaternary Dating Methods 1984, 7:227-246.
28. Calkin P.E., Kaufman D.S., Przbyl B.J., Whitford W.B., Peck B.J. Glacier regimes, periglacial landforms, and Holocene climate change in the Kigluaik Mountains, Seward Peninsula, Alaska, U.S.A. Arctic and Alpine Research 1998, 30(2):154-165.
29. Caseldine C. Neoglacial glacier variations in northern Iceland: examples from the Eyjafjordur area. Arctic and Alpine Research 1987, 19:296-304.
30. Caseldine C. Lichenometric dating, lichen population studies and Holocene glacial history in Tröllaskagi, northern Iceland. Environmental Change in Iceland: Past and Present (2) 1991, 219-233. Springer, Netherlands. J.K. Maizels, C. Caseldine (Eds.).
31. Chenet M., Roussel E., Jomelli V., Grancher D. Asynchronous Little Ice Age glacial maximum extent in southeast Iceland. Geomorphology 2010, 114:253-260.
32. Clark D.H., Gillespie A.R. Timing and significance of late-glacial and Holocene cirque glaciation in the Sierra Nevada, California. Quaternary International 1997, 39(39):21-38.
33. Clayden S.R. Thallus initiation and development in the lichen Rhizocarpon lecanorinum. New Phytologist 1998, 139:685-695.
34. Clayden S.R., Pentecost A., Dawson R.J.M. Growth of the lichen Rhizocarpon lecanorinum, with comments on Aplin-Hill and lichenometric curves. Symbiosis 2004, 37(1-3):379-393.
35. Curry R.R. Holocene climatic and glacial history of the central Sierra Nevada, California. GSA Special Paper 1969, 123:1-48.
36. Dabski M. A commentary to 'Asynchronous Little Ice Age glacial maximum extent in southeast Iceland' by Chenet et al. (Geomorphology 114 (2010) 253-260); a case of Fláajökull. Geomorphology 2010, 120:365-367.
37. Dabski M., Angiel P. Geomorphic implications of the retreat of Breidamerkurjökull in the southern part of the Skálabjörg ridge, Esjufjöll, Iceland. Jökull 2010, 60:185-197.
38. Dahms D.E. Glacial stratigraphy of Stough Creek Basin, Wind River Range, Wyoming. Geomorphology 2001, 42:59-83.
39. Denton G.H., Karlén W. Lichenometry: its application to Holocene moraine studies in southern Alaska and Swedish Lapland. Arctic and Alpine Research 1973, 5:347-373.
40. Ellis J.M., Calkin P.E. Chronology of Holocene glaciation, central Brooks Range, Alaska. Bulletin of the Geological Society of America 1984, 95:897-912.
41. Erikstad L., Sollid J.L. Neoglaciation in South Norway using lichenometric methods. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 1986, 40(2):85-105.
42. Evans D.J.A., Archer S., Wilson D.J.H. A comparison of the lichenometric and Schmidt hammer dating techniques based on data from the proglacial areas of some Icelandic glaciers. Quaternary Science Reviews 1999, 18(1):13-41.
43. 14C to investigate the growth and carbon turnover rates of a crustose lichen. Geografiska Annaler Series A Physical Geography 2010, 92(1):53-63.
44. Gellatly A.F. Lichenometry as a relative-age dating method in Mount Cook National Park, New Zealand. New Zealand Journal of Botany 1982, 20:343-353.
45. Gordon J.E., Sharp M. Lichenometry in dating recent glacial landforms and deposits, southeast Iceland. Boreas 1983, 12:191-200.
46. Gouze P., Argollo J., Saliège J., Servant M. Interprétation paléoclimatique des oscillations des glaciers au cours des 20 derniers millénaires dans les régions tropicales; exemple des Andes boliviennes. Comptes Rendus de l'Académie des Sciences (Paris) 1986, 303:219-224.
47. Hallet B., Putkonen J. Surface dating of dynamic landforms: young boulders on aging moraines. Science 1994, 265(5174):937-940.
48. Hansen E.S. The application of lichenometry in dating of glacier deposits. Geografisk Tidsskrift - Danish Journal of Geography 2008, 108(1):143-151.
49. Harrison S., Winchester V., Glasser N. The timing and nature of recession of outlet glaciers of Hielo Patagónico Norte, Chile, from their Neoglacial IV (Little Ice Age) maximum positions. Global and Planetary Change 2007, 59:67-78.
50. Haworth L.A., Calkin P.E., Ellis J.M. Direct measurement of lichen growth in the central Brooks Range, Alaska, USA, and its application to lichenometric dating. Arctic and Alpine Research 1986, 18(3):289-296.
51. Hestmark G., Skogesal O., Skullerud Ø. Growth, reproduction, and population structure in four alpine lichens during 240years of primary colonization. Canadian Journal of Botany 2004, 82:1356-1362.
52. Hurlbert S.H. Pseudoreplication and the design of ecological field experiments. Ecological Monographs 1984, 52(2):187-211.
53. Innes J.L. 'A manual for lichenometry' - comment. Area 1981, 13:237-241.
54. Innes J.L. Development of lichenometric dating curves for Highland Scotland. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences 1983, 74:23-32.
55. Innes J.L. Use of an aggregated Rhizocarpon 'species' in lichenometry: an evaluation. Boreas 1983, 12:183-190.
56. Innes J.L. The optimal sample size in lichenometric studies. Arctic and Alpine Research 1984, 16(2):233-244.
57. Innes J.L. Lichenometry. Progress in Physical Geography 1985, 9:187-254.
58. Jettestuen E., Nermoen A., Hestmark G., Timdal E., Mathiesen J. Competition on the rocks: community growth and tessellation. PLoS ONE 2010, 5(9):1-5.
59. Jochimsen M. Does the size of lichen thalli really constitute a valid measure for dating glacial deposits. Arctic and Alpine Research 1973, 5:417-424.
60. John E.A. Note on the sizes of largest thalli of three species of Rhizocarpon (subgenus Rhizocarpon) at a rockslide in the Canadian Rocky Mountains. Arctic and Alpine Research 1989, 21:185-187.
61. Jomelli V., Grancher D., Naveau P., Cooley D., Brunstein D. Assessment study of lichenometric methods for dating surfaces. Geomorphology 2007, 86(1-2):131-143.
62. Jomelli V., Naveau P., Cooley D., Grancher D., Brunstein D., Rabatel A. A response to Bradwell's commentary on recent statistical studies in lichenometry. Geografiska Annaler 2010, 92:487-489.
63. Karlen W., Black J.L. Estimates of lichen growth-rate in northern Sweden. Geografiska Annaler 2002, 84(3-4):225-232.
64. Kirkbride M.P., Dugmore A.J. Can lichenometry be used to date the "Little Ice Age" glacial maximum in Iceland?. The Iceberg in the Mist: Northern Research in Pursuit of a "Little Ice Age" (2) 2001, 151-167. Springer, Netherlands. A.E.J. Ogilvie, T. Jonsson (Eds.).
65. Kirkbride M.P., Dugmore A.J. Two millennia of glacier advances from southern Iceland dated by tephrochronology. Quaternary Research 2008, 70:398-411.
66. Larocque S.J., Smith D.J. Calibrated Rhizocarpon spp. growth curve for the Mount Waddington area, British Columbia Coast Mountains, Canada. Arctic Antarctic and Alpine Research 2004, 36(4):407-418.
67. Lewis D., Smith D.J. Little Ice Age glacial activity in Strathcona Provincial Park, Vancouver Island, British Columbia, Canada. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 2004, 41:285-297.
68. Locke W.W. Discussion of "size frequency distributions as a lichenometric technique: an assessment". Arctic and Alpine Research 1983, 15(3):419.
69. Locke W.W., Andrews J.T., Webber P.J. A manual for lichenometry. British Geomorphological Research Group Technical Bulletin 1979, 26:47.
70. Loso M.G., Doak D.F. The biology behind lichenometric dating curves. Oecologia 2006, 147:223-229.
71. Loso M.G., Doak D.F., Anderson R.S. Lichenometric dating of Little Ice Age glacier moraines using explicit demographic models of lichen colonization, growth, and survival. Geografiska Annaler Series A Physical Geography 2014, 96(1):21-41.
72. Luckman B.H. Lichenometric dating of Holocene moraines at Mount Edith Cavell, Jasper, Alberta. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 1977, 14(8):1809-1822.
73. Luckman B., Osborn G. Holocene glacier fluctuations in the middle Canadian Rocky Mountains. Quaternary Research 1979, 11:52-77.
74. Matthews J.A. Families of lichenometric dating curves from the Storbreen Gletschervorfeld, Jotunheimen, Norway. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 1974, 28(4):215-235.
75. Matthews J.A. Experiments on the reproducibility and reliability of lichenometric dates, Storbreen gletschervorfeld, Jotunheimen, Norway. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 1975, 29(3):97-109.
76. Matthews J.A. A lichenometric test of the 1750 end-moraine hypothesis: Storbreen gletscervorfeld, southern Norway. Norsk Geografisk Tidsskrift - Norwegian Journal of Geography 1977, 31(3):129-136.
77. Matthews J.A. Lichenometric dating: a review with particular reference to 'Little Ice Age' moraines in southern Norway. Dating in Exposed and Surface Contexts 1994, 185-212. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque. C. Beck (Ed.).
78. Matthews J.A., Trenbirth H.E. Growth rate of a very large crustose lichen (Rhizocarpon subgenus) and its implications for lichenometry. Geografiska Annaler 2011, 93:27-39.
79. McCarthy D.P. A biological basis for lichenometry?. Journal of Biogeography 1999, 26:379-386.
80. McCarthy D.P. Lichenometry. Monitoring with Lichens-Monitoring Lichens 2002, 379-383. Springer, Netherlands. P.L. Nimis, C. Scheidegger, P.A. Wolsley (Eds.).
81. McCarthy D.P. Estimating lichenometric ages by direct and indirect measurement: a case study of Rhizocarpon agg. at the Illecillewaet Glacier, British Columbia. Arctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research 2003, 35:203-213.
82. McCarthy D.P. Lichenometry. Encyclopedia of Quaternary Science 2007, 1399-1405. Elsevier, Amsterdam. S.A. Elias (Ed.).
83. McCarthy D.P. Lichenometry. Encyclopedia of Quaternary Science 2013, 565-572. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Second edition, 10.1016/B978-0-444-53643-3.00055-8. S.A. Elias, C.J. Mock (Eds.).
84. McCarthy D.P., Henry N. Measurement of growth in the lichen Rhizocarpon geographicum using a new photographic technique. The Lichenologist 2012, 44:679-693. 10.1017/S0024282912000175.
85. McCarthy D.P., Smith D.J. Growth curves for calcium-tolerant lichens in the Canadian Rocky Mountains. Arctic and Alpine Research 1995, 27(3):290-297.
86. McKinzey K.M., Orwin J.F., Bradwell T. Re-dating the moraines at Skálafellsjökull and Heinabergsjökull using different lichenometric methods: implications for the timing of the Icelandic Little Ice Age maximum. Geografiska Annaler 2004, 86(4):319-335.
87. Menounos B., Osborn G., Clague J.J., Luckman B.H. Latest Pleistocene and Holocene glacier fluctuations in western Canada. Quaternary Science Reviews 2009, 28(21-22):2049-2074.
88. Menounos B., Goehring B., Osborn G., Clarke G., Ward B., Margold M., Bond J., Clague J., Lakeman T., Schaefer J., Koch J., Gosse J., Stroeven A., Seguinot J., Heyman J., Fulton R. The complex behavior of the Cordilleran Ice Sheet and mountain glaciers to abrupt climate change during the latest Pleistocene. Abstract EGU2014-15013, European Geosciences Union General Assembly 2014, Vienna 2014.
89. Miller G.H., Andrews J.T. Quaternary history of northern Cumberland Peninsula, east Baffin Island, N.W.T., Canada. Part VI: preliminary lichen growth curve. Geological Society of America Bulletin 1972, 83:1133-1138.
90. Mullineaux D.R. Pumice and other pyroclastic deposits in Mount Rainier National Park Washington. U.S. Geological Survey Bulletin 1974, 1326:83.
91. Naveau P., Jomelli V., Cooley D., Delphine G., Rabatel A. Modeling uncertanties in lichenometry studies. Arctic Antarctic and Alpine Research 2007, 39(2):277-285.
92. Nicholas J.W., Butler D.R. Application of relative-age dating techniques on rock glaciers of the La Sal Mountains, Utah: an interpretation of Holocene paleoclimates. Geografiska Annaler 1996, 78:1-18.
93. Noller J.S., Locke W.W. Lichenometry. American Geophysical Union Reference Shelf Series 4, Washington DC 2000, 261-272. J. Stratton, J.M. Sowers, W.R. Lettis (Eds.).
94. O'Neal M.A. The effects of slope degradation on lichenometric dating of Little Ice Age moraines. Quaternary Geology 2006, 1(2):121-128.
95. O'Neal M.A. Identifying lichenometrically datable, glacerized terrains: a case study in the cascade range of western North America. Geocarto International 2009, 25(4):315-325.
96. O'Neal M.A., Schoenenberger K.R. A Rhizocarpon geographicum growth curve for the Cascade Range of Washington and northern Oregon, USA. Quaternary Research 2003, 60:233-241.
97. Osborn G.D. Holocene tephrostratigraphy and glacial fluctuations in Waterton Lakes and Glacier National Parks, Alberta and Montana. Canadian Journal of Earth Sciences 1985, 22:1093-1101.
98. Osborn G. Lichenometry. Geology 1988, 396-399. C.W. Finkl (Ed.).
99. Osborn G., Taylor J. Lichenometry on calcareous substrates in the Canadian Rockies. Quaternary Research 1975, 8:111-120.
100. Pentecost A. Aspects of competition in saxicolous lichen communities. The Lichenologist 1980, 12:135-144.
101. Porter S.C. Lichenometric studies in the Cascade Range, Washington: establishment of Rhizocarpon geographicum growth curves at Mount Rainier. Arctic and Alpine Research 1981, 13:11-23.
102. Refsnider K.A., Brugger K.A. Rock glaciers in central Colorado as indicators of late-Holocene climate change: a lichenometric study using Rhizocarpon subgenus Rhizocarpon. Arctic, Antarctic and Alpine Research 2007, 39:127-136.
103. Runemark H. Studies in Rhizocarpon. I. Taxonomy of the yellow species in Europe. Opera Botanica 1956, 2(1):1-152.
104. 14C evidence for the Late Holocene glacier variations in the Oigaing River Basin, Western Tian Shan, Central Asia. Zeitschrift für Gletscherkunde und Glazialgeologie 1997, 33:111-124.
105. Scuderi L.A., Fawcett P.J. Holocene environmental change resets lichen surface dates on Recess Peak glacial deposits in the Sierra Nevada, California. Quaternary Research 2013, 80(2):180-188.
106. Sikorski J.J., Kaufman D.S., Manley W.F., Nolan M. Glacial-geologic evidence for decreased precipitation during the Little Ice Age in the Brooks Range, Alaska. Arctic Antarctic and Alpine Research 2009, 41:138-150.
107. Solomina O., Calkin P. Lichenometry as applied to moraines in Alaska, U.S.A., and Kamchatka, Russia. Arctic Antarctic and Alpine Research 2003, 35:129-143.
108. 14C age calibration program. Radiocarbon 1993, 35:215-230.
109. Trenbirth H.E., Matthews J.A. Lichen growth rates on glacier forelands in southern Norway: preliminary results from a 25-year monitoring programme. Geografiska Annaler 2010, 92:19-39.
110. Webber P.J., Andrews J.T. Lichenometry: a commentary. Arctic and Alpine Research 1973, 5:295-302.
111. Wilcox W.D. The dam at Moraine Lake. American Alpine Journal 1930, 1:189.
112. Wiles G.C., Jacoby G.C., Davi N.K., McAllister R.P. Late Holocene glacier fluctuations in the Wrangell Mountains, Alaska. Geological Society of America Bulletin 2002, 114:896-908.
113. Wiles G.C., Barclay D.J., Young N. A review of lichenometric dating of glacial moraines in Alaska. Geografiska Annaler 2010, 92:101-109.
114. Worsley P. Lichenometry. Geomorphological Techniques 1981, 302-305. George Allen and Unwin Ltd., London. A. Goudie (Ed.).
115. 14C dating on inorganic carbon. Quaternary International 2004, 121:99-107.
116. Yi C., Zhu Z., Wei L., Cui Z., Zheng B., Shi Y. Advances in numerical dating of Quaternary glaciations in China. Zeitschrift für Geomorphologie 2007, 51(Suppl. 2):153-175.
117. Young N.E., Briner J.P., Kaufman D.S. Late Pleistocene and Holocene glaciation of the Fish Lake valley, northeastern Alaska Range, Alaska. Journal of Quaternary Science 2009, 24:677-689.