Spatial and temporal characteristics of error-related activity in the human brain

Journal of Neuroscience

Volumn 35, Issue 1, 2015, Pages 253-266

  Neta, Maital ^a   Miezin, Xfrancis M ^b,c,d   Nelson, Steven M ^f   Dubis, Joseph W ^b   Dosenbach, Nico U F ^b   Schlaggar, Bradley L ^b,c,d   Petersen, Steven E ^b,c,d,e  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA LINCOLN   (United States)

^b WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^c WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^d WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^e WASHINGTON UNIVERSITY IN ST LOUIS   (United States)

^f VISN 17 Center of Excellence for Research on Returning War Veterans   (United States)

Author keywords

Error; Functional networks; Meta analysis; Resting state; Task control

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ANTERIOR CINGULATE; ARTICLE; AUDITORY STIMULATION; BOLD SIGNAL; BRAIN FUNCTION; CINGULO OPERCULAR NETWORK; CLUSTER ANALYSIS; COGNITION; ERROR RELATED NEGATIVITY; EVENT RELATED POTENTIAL; FEMALE; FRONTAL OPERCULUM; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HEMISPHERE; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; IMAGE PROCESSING; INFERIOR FRONTAL GYRUS; INFERIOR PARIETAL LOBULE; MALE; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); MIDDLE TEMPORAL GYRUS; NERVE CONDUCTION; PREFRONTAL CORTEX; PUTAMEN; RESTING STATE NETWORK; SPATIAL DISCRIMINATION; STIMULUS RESPONSE; SUPERIOR PARIETAL LOBULE; TASK PERFORMANCE; TEMPORAL CORTEX; VISUAL STIMULATION; ADOLESCENT; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY; META ANALYSIS; NERVE CELL NETWORK; PHOTOSTIMULATION; PHYSIOLOGY; PROCEDURES; PSYCHOMOTOR PERFORMANCE; TIME; YOUNG ADULT;

ACOUSTIC STIMULATION; ADOLESCENT; ADULT; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDIES; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; NERVE NET; PHOTIC STIMULATION; PSYCHOMOTOR PERFORMANCE; TIME FACTORS; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84920520029     PISSN: 02706474     EISSN: 15292401     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.1313-14.2015     Document Type: Article

References (72)

1. Bender-deMoll S, McFarland DA (2006) The art and science of dynamic network visualization. J Soc Struct 7.
2. Biswal B, Yetkin FZ, Haughton VM, Hyde JS (1995) Functional connectivity in the motor cortex of resting human brain using echo-planar MRI. Magn Reson Med 34:537–541.
3. Bush G, Luu P, Posner MI (2000) Cognitive and emotional influences in anterior cingulate cortex. Trends Cogn Sci 4:215–222.
4. Cannestra AF, Bookheimer SY, Pouratian N, O’Farrell A, Sicotte N, Martin NA, Becker D, Rubino G, Toga AW (2000) Temporal and topographical characterization of language cortices using intraoperative optical intrinsic signals. Neuroimage 12:41–54.
5. Carp J, Kim K, Taylor SF, Fitzgerald KD, Weissman DH (2010) Conditional differences in mean reaction time explain effects of response congruency, but not accuracy, on posterior medial frontal cortex activity. Front Hum Neurosci 4:231.
6. Cassidy B, Solo V (2012) fMRI model diagnostics for the double gamma and temporal derivative. Biomedical Imaging (ISBI), 2012 9th IEEE International Symposium 30–33.
7. Chein JM, Fissell K, Jacobs S, Fiez JA (2002) Functional heterogeneity within Broca’s area during verbal working memory. Physiol Behav 77: 635–639.
8. Church JA, Wenger KK, Dosenbach NU, Miezin FM, Petersen SE, Schlaggar BL (2009) Task control signals in pediatric Tourette syndrome show evidence of immature and anomalous functional activity. Front Hum Neurosci 3:38.
9. Cordes D, Haughton V, Carew JD, Arfanakis K, Maravilla K (2002) Hierarchical clustering tomeasure connectivityin fMRI resting-state data. Magn Reson Imaging 20:305–317.
10. Danielmeier C, Ullsperger M (2011) Post-error adjustments. Front Psychol 2:233.
11. Danielmeier C, Eichele T, Forstmann BU, Tittgemeyer M, Ullsperger M (2011) Posterior medial frontal cortex activity predicts post-error adap-tations in task-related visual and motor areas. J Neurosci 31:1780–1789.
12. Dehaene S, Posner MI, Tucker DM (1994) Localization of a neural system for error detection and compensation. Psychol Sci 5:303–305.
13. Donaldson DI, Wheeler ME, Petersen SE (2010) Remember the source: dissociating frontal and parietal contributions to episodic memory. J Cogn Neurosci 22:377–391.
14. Dosenbach NU, Visscher KM, Palmer ED, Miezin FM, Wenger KK, Kang HC, Burgund ED, Grimes AL, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2006) A core system for the implementation of task sets. Neuron 50:799–812.
15. Dosenbach NU, Fair DA, Miezin FM, Cohen AL, Wenger KK, Dosenbach RA, Fox MD, Snyder AZ, Vincent JL, Raichle ME, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2007) Distinct brain networks for adaptive and stable task control in humans. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:11073–11078.
16. Dosenbach NU, Fair DA, Cohen AL, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2008) A dual-networks architecture of top-down control. Trends Cogn Sci 12:99–105.
17. Dubis JW, Siegel JS, Neta M, Visscher KM, Petersen SE (2014) Tasks driven by perceptual information do not recruit sustained BOLD activity in cingulo-opercular regions. Cereb Cortex. Advance online publication. doi:10/1093/cercor/bhu187.
18. Fox MD, Snyder AZ, Barch DM, Gusnard DA, Raichle ME (2005) Transient BOLD responses at block transitions. Neuroimage 28:956–966.
19. Gonzalez-Castillo J, Saad ZS, Handwerker DA, Inati SJ, Brenowitz N, Ban-dettini PA (2012) Whole-brain, time-locked activation with simple tasks revealed using massive averaging and model-free analysis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 109:5487–5492.
20. Greicius MD, Supekar K, Menon V, Dougherty RF (2009) Resting-state functional connectivity reflects structural connectivity in the default mode network. Cereb Cortex 19:72–78.
21. Handl J, Knowles J, Kell DB (2005) Computational cluster validation in post-genomic data analysis. Bioinformatics 21:3201–3212.
22. Hester R, Fassbender C, Garavan H (2004) Individual differences in error processing: a review and reanalysis of three event-related fMRI studies using the GO/NOGO task. Cereb Cortex 14:986–994.
23. Hester R, Nandam LS, O’Connell RG, Wagner J, Strudwick M, Nathan PJ, Mattingley JB, Bellgrove MA (2012) Neurochemical enhancement of conscious error awareness. J Neurosci 32:2619–2627.
24. Holroyd CB, Coles MG (2002) The neural basis of human error processing: reinforcement learning, dopamine, and the error-related negativity. Psy-chol Rev 109:679–709.
25. Holroyd CB, Dien J, Coles MG (1998) Error-related scalp potentials elicited by hand and foot movements: evidence for an output-independent error-processing system in humans. Neurosci Lett 242:65–68.
26. Holroyd CB, Nieuwenhuis S, Yeung N, Nystrom L, Mars RB, Coles MG, Cohen JD (2004) Dorsal anterior cingulate cortex shows fMRI response to internal and external error signals. Nat Neurosci 7:497–498.
27. Kiehl KA, Liddle PF, Hopfinger JB (2000) Error processing and the rostral anterior cingulate: an event-related fMRI study. Psychophysiology 37: 216–223.
28. King JA, Korb FM, von Cramon DY, Ullsperger M (2010) Post-error behavioral adjustments are facilitated by activation and suppression of task-relevant and task-irrelevant information processing. J Neurosci 30: 12759–12769.
29. Lancaster JL, Glass TG, Lankipalli BR, Downs H, Mayberg H, Fox PT (1995) A modality-independent approach to spatial normalization of tomo-graphic images of the human brain. Hum Brain Mapp 3:209–223.
30. Logan GD, Gordon RD (2001) Executive control of visual attentionin dual-task situations. Psychol Rev 108:393–434.
31. Mars RB, Coles MG, Grol MJ, Holroyd CB, Nieuwenhuis S, Hulstijn W, Toni I (2005) Neural dynamics of error processing in medial frontal cortex. Neuroimage 28:1007–1013.
32. Martin TA, Keating JG, Goodkin HP, Bastian AJ, Thach WT (1996a) Throwing while looking through prisms: I. Focal olivocerebellar lesions impair adaptation. Brain 119:1183–1198.
33. Martin TA, Keating JG, Goodkin HP, Bastian AJ, Thach WT (1996b)Throwing while looking through prisms: II. Specificity and storage of multiple gaze-throw calibrations. Brain 119:1199–1211.
34. Mathalon DH, Whitfield SL, Ford JM (2003) Anatomy of an error: ERP and fMRI. Biol Psychol 64:119–141.
35. Michelon P, Snyder AZ, Buckner RL, McAvoy M, Zacks JM (2003) Neural correlates of incongruous visual information: an event-related fMRI study. Neuroimage 19:1612–1626.
36. Miezin FM, Maccotta L, Ollinger JM, Petersen SE, Buckner RL (2000) Characterizing the hemodynamic response: effects of presentation rate, sampling procedure, and the possibility of ordering brain activity based on relative timing. Neuroimage 11:735–759.
37. Mugler JP 3rd, Brookeman JR (1990) Three-dimensional magnetization-prepared rapid gradient-echo imaging (3D MPRAGE). Magn Reson Med 15:152–157.
38. Nachev P, Rees G, Parton A, Kennard C, Husain M (2005) Volition and conflict in human medial frontal cortex. Curr Biol 15:122–128.
39. Nelson SM, Dosenbach NU, Cohen AL, Wheeler ME, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2010) Role of the anterior insula in task-level control and focal attention. Brain Struct Funct 214:669–680.
40. Neta M, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2014) Separable responses to error, ambiguity, and reaction timeincingulo-opercular task control regions. Neu-roimage 99:59–68.
41. Newman ME (2006) Modularity and community structure in networks. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 103:8577–8582.
42. Norris SA, Hathaway EN, Taylor JA, Thach WT (2011) Cerebellar inactiva-tion impairs memory of learned prism gaze-reach calibrations. J Neuro-physiol 105:2248–2259.
43. Ojemann JG, Akbudak E, Snyder AZ, McKinstry RC, Raichle ME, Conturo TE (1997) Anatomic localization and quantitative analysis of gradient refocused echo-planar fMRI susceptibility artifacts. Neuroimage 6:156–167.
44. Orr JM, Weissman DH (2009) Anterior cingulate cortex makes 2 contributions to minimizing distraction. Cereb Cortex 19:703–711.
45. Paulesu E, Goldacre B, Scifo P, Cappa SF, Gilardi MC, Castiglioni I, Perani D, Fazio F (1997) Functional heterogeneity of left inferior frontal cortex as revealed by fMRI. Neuroreport 8:2011–2017.
46. Petersen SE, Posner MI (2012) The attention system of the human brain: 20 years after. Annu Rev Neurosci 35:73–89.
47. Picard N, Strick PL (2001) Imaging the premotor areas. Curr Opin Neuro-biol 11:663–672.
48. Posner MI, Petersen SE (1990) The attention system of the human brain. Annu Rev Neurosci 13:25–42.
49. Power JD, Petersen SE (2013) Control-related systems in the human brain. Curr Opin Neurobiol 23:223–228.
50. Power JD, Cohen AL, Nelson SM, Vogel AC, Church JA, Barnes KA, Wig GS, Laumann TO, Miezin FM, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2011) Functional network organization in the human brain. Neuron 72:665–678.
51. Power JD, Barnes KA, Snyder AZ, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2012) Spurious but systematic correlations in functional connectivity MRI networks arise from subject motion. Neuroimage 59:2142–2154.
52. Power JD, Barnes KA, Snyder AZ, Schlaggar BL, Petersen SE (2013) Steps toward optimizing motion artifact removal in functional connectivity MRI; a reply to carp. Neuroimage 76:439–441.
53. Rabbitt PM (1966) Errors and error correction in choice-response tasks. J Exp Psychol 71:264–272.
54. Ridderinkhof KR, Ullsperger M, Crone EA, Nieuwenhuis S (2004) The role of the medial frontal cortex in cognitive control. Science 306:443–447.
55. Rushworth MF, Walton ME, Kennerley SW, Bannerman DM (2004) Action sets and decisions in the medial frontal cortex. Trends Cogn Sci 8:410–417.
56. Salvador R, Suckling J, Coleman MR, Pickard JD, Menon D, Bullmore E (2005) Neurophysiological architecture of functional magnetic reso nance images of human brain. Cereb Cortex 15:1332–1342.
57. Seeley WW, Menon V, Schatzberg AF, Keller J, Glover GH, Kenna H, Reiss AL, Greicius MD (2007) Dissociable intrinsic connectivity networks for salience processing and executive control. J Neurosci 27:2349–2356.
58. Shmuel A, Leopold DA (2008) Neuronal correlates of spontaneous fluctuations in fMRI signals in monkey visual cortex: implications for functional connectivity at rest. Hum Brain Mapp 29:751–761.
59. Snyder AZ (1996) Difference image vs ratio image error function forms in PET-PET realignment. In: Quantification of brain function using PET-(Myer R, et al., eds), pp 131–137. San Diego: Academic.
60. Stuss DT (2011) Functions of the frontal lobes: relation to executive functions. J Int Neuropsychol Soc 17:759–765.
61. Swick D, Turken AU (2002) Dissociation between conflict detection and error monitoring in the human anterior cingulate cortex. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 99:16354–16359.
62. Talairach J, Tournoux P (1988) Co-planar stereotaxic atlas of the human brain. New York: Thieme Medical.
63. Tunik E, Frey SH, Grafton ST (2005) Virtual lesions of the anterior intrapa-rietal area disrupt goal-dependent on-line adjustments ofgrasp. Nat Neu-rosci 8:505–511.
64. Ullsperger M, von Cramon DY (2001) Subprocesses of performance monitoring: a dissociation of error processing and response competition revealed by event-related fMRI and ERPs. Neuroimage 14:1387–1401.
65. Ullsperger M, von Cramon DY, Müller NG (2002) Interactions of focal cortical lesions with error processing: evidence from event-related brain potentials. Neuropsychology 16:548–561.
66. Ullsperger M, Harsay HA, Wessel JR, Ridderinkhof KR (2010) Conscious perception of errors and its relation to the anterior insula. Brain Struct Funct 214:629–643.
67. van Driel J, Ridderinkhof KR, Cohen MX (2012) Not all errors are alike: theta and alpha EEG dynamics relate to differences in error-processing dynamics. J Neurosci 32:16795–16806.
68. Van Essen DC (2005) A population-average, landmark- and surface-based (PALS) atlas of human cerebral cortex. Neuroimage 28:635–662.
69. Van Essen DC, Drury HA, Dickson J, Harwell J, Hanlon D, Anderson CH (2001) An integrated software suite for surface-based analyses ofcerebral cortex. J Am Med Inform Assoc 8:443–459.
70. Wessel JR, Danielmeier C, Morton JB, Ullsperger M (2012) Surprise and error: common neuronal architecture for the processing of errors and novelty. J Neurosci 32:7528–7537.
71. Wheeler ME, Shulman GL, Buckner RL, Miezin FM, Velanova K, Petersen SE (2006) Evidence for separate perceptual reactivation and search pro cesses during remembering. Cereb Cortex 16:949–959.
72. Yeo BT, Krienen FM, Sepulcre J, Sabuncu MR, Lashkari D, Hollinshead M, Roffman JL, Smoller JW, Zöllei L, Polimeni JR, Fischl B, Liu H, Buckner RL (2011) The organization of the human cerebral cortex estimated by intrinsic functional connectivity. J Neurophysiol 106:1125–1165.