Explaining sectoral discrepancies between national and provincial statistics in China

China Economic Review

Volumn 30, Issue , 2014, Pages 353-369

  Ma, Ben ^a   Song, Guojun ^a   Zhang, Lei ^a   Sonnenfeld, David A ^b  

^a RENMIN UNIVERSITY OF CHINA   (China)

^b STATE UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK   (United States)

Author keywords

C43; C82; Data discrepancy; Energy consumption; Gross domestic product (GDP); Index decomposition; Institutional arrangements; O43; O53; Q43; R58

Indexed keywords

EID: 84908376556     PISSN: 1043951X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.chieco.2014.07.004     Document Type: Article

References (50)

1. Bhattacharyya S.C. Energy economics: Concepts, issues, markets and governance 2011, Springer-Verlag London Limited, New York.
2. British Petroleum BP statistical review of world energy June 2011 2011, British Petroleum, London.
3. Cai Y. Between state and peasant: Local cadres and statistical reporting in rural China. The China Quarterly 2000, 783-805.
4. Central Office of the State Council Notice of proposal on improvements of provincial GDP calculation. Guobanfa [2004] No. 82 2004.
5. Central Office of the State Council Notice of reform plan on management system of survey teams directly under the NBS issued by Central Office of the State Council. Guobanfa [2005] No. 14 2005.
6. Chen Y., Li H., Zhou L.-A. Relative performance evaluation and the turnover of provincial leaders in China. Economics Letters 2005, 88:421-425.
7. Chow G. Are Chinese official statistics reliable?. CESifo Economic Studies 2006, 52:396-414.
8. Feng Y., Wu C. Is economic performance important for Chinese official promotion?. Journal of Management Sciences in China 2013, 16:55-68. (in Chinese).
9. Holz C.A. "Fast, clear and accurate": How reliable are Chinese output and economic growth statistics?. The China Quarterly 2003, 122-163.
10. Holz C.A. Deconstructing China's GDP statistics. China Economic Review 2004, 15:164-202.
11. Holz C.A. China's statistical system in transition: Challenges, data problems, and institutional innovations. Review of Income and Wealth 2004, 50:381-409.
12. Holz C.A. OECD-China governance project: the institutional arrangements for the production of statistics. OECD Statistics Working Papers 2005/1 2005, OECD Publishing, Paris.
13. Holz C.A. China's 2004 economic census and 2006 benchmark revision of GDP statistics: More questions than answers?. The China Quarterly 2008, 193:150-163.
14. Holz C.A. Chinese statistics: Classification systems and data sources. Munich Personal RePEc Archive (MPRA) Working Paper. No. 43869 2013.
15. Holz C.A. Monthly industrial output in China 1980-2012. China Economic Review 2014, 28:1-16.
16. IEA Energy statistics manual 2004, International Energy Agency, Paris, (Available at: (accessed Jan., 2014)).
17. 2 emission from fuel combustion: Highlights 2012, International Energy Agency, Paris. 2012 ed.
18. Koch-Weser I.N. The reliability of China's economic data: An analysis of national output 2013, The U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission, New York.
19. Li H., Zhou L.-A. Political turnover and economic performance: The incentive role of personnel control in China. Journal of Public Economics 2005, 89:1743-1762.
20. Mehrotra A., Pääkkönen J. Comparing China's GDP statistics with coincident indicators. Journal of Comparative Economics 2011, 39:406-411.
21. NBS Answer reporters' questions on raising the cut off level of industrial and investment statistics by responsible person from the NBS 2011, Statistical News. National Bureau of Statistics, Beijing.
22. NBS China energy statistical yearbook 2012 2012, China Statistics Press, Beijing.
23. NBS About energy statistics (No. 6), Answers to frequently asked questions 2013, National Bureau of Statistics, Beijing.
24. NBS Industrial value added, statistical indicators by your side. National Bureau of Statistics Available at:, (accessed Nov., 2013). http://www.stats.gov.cn/tjzs/tjbk/nsbzb/201402/P020140226559332052330.pdf.
25. NBS About industrial statistics (No. 5), Answers to frequently asked questions 2013, National Bureau of Statistics, Beijing.
26. NBS National Economic Accounting Division China's gross domestic product calculation methods for census years 2007, China Statistics Press, Beijing, (in Chinese).
27. NBS National Economic Accounting Division China's gross domestic product calculation methods for non-census years 2008, China Statistics Press, Beijing, (in Chinese).
28. NBS National Economic Accounting Division China's gross domestic product calculation methods for non-census years (revised version on May 7, 2010) 2010, National Bureau of Statistics, (in Chinese).
29. OECD Environment and governance in China, in Governance in China 2005, OECD Publishing, Paris.
30. Pan Z., An Y. Where is the one-trillion difference from? Some thoughts on the difference between national and provincial accounts data 2003, 10-11. China Statistics, (in Chinese).
31. Qiao S. A reexamination of the mechanism of official promotion tournament in China: Evidence from provincial and municipal governments. Journal of Finance and Economics 2013, 39:123-133. (in Chinese).
32. Rawski T.G. What is happening to China's GDP statistics?. China Economic Review 2001, 12:347-354.
33. Sinton J.E. Accuracy and reliability of China's energy statistics. China Economic Review 2001, 12:373-383.
34. Sinton J.E., Fridley D. A guide to China's energy statistics 2001, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Berkeley.
35. Song G., Ma B. Evaluation on the energy efficiency to cities in China 2013, Chemical Industry Press, Beijing, (in Chinese).
36. Wang Q. New compendium on statistical work (Xinbian tongji gongzuo shiwu quanshu) 2000, China Statistics Press, Beijing, (in Chinese).
37. Wang Y., Chandler W. Understanding energy intensity data in China 2011, Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.
38. Wang X., Meng L. A reevaluation of China's economic growth. China Economic Review 2001, 12:338-346.
39. Wang X., Xu X. Promotion competition of local officials and economic growth. Economic Science 2010, 42-58. (in Chinese).
40. Xu X. A study on the measurement of service industry and related issues in China. Economic Research Journal 2004, 20-27. (in Chinese).
41. Xu X. China's gross domestic product estimation. China Economic Review 2004, 15:302-322.
42. Xu X. On the changes in the GDP estimation in the economic census year. Economic Research Journal 2006, 16-20. (in Chinese).
43. Xu X. The establishment, reform and development of China's national economic accounting system. Social Sciences in China 2009, 41-59. (205 (in Chinese)).
44. Xu C. The fundamental institutions of China's reforms and development. Journal of Economic Literature 2011, 49:1076-1151.
45. Xue S. China's statistical system and resources. Journal of Government Information 2004, 30:87-109.
46. Yang M., Patiño-Echeverri D., Yang F. Wind power generation in China: Understanding the mismatch between capacity and generation. Renewable Energy 2012, 41:145-151.
47. Yang Q., Zheng N. Which competition mode works among local leaders for promotion, the yardstick competition, tournament or qualifying competition?. The Journal of World Economy 2013, 130-156. (in Chinese).
48. Zhang Z. Copenhagen and beyond: Reflections on China's stance and responses. East-West Center working papers No. 111 2010.
49. Zhou L.-A. Governing China's local officials: An analysis of promotion tournament model. Economic Research Journal 2007, 36-50. (in Chinese).
50. Zhou L.-A., Li H., Chen Y. Relative performance evaluation: An empirical analysis of turnover of the Chinese local officials. China Journal of Economics 2005, 1:83-96. (in Chinese).