Practice Does Not Make Perfect: No Causal Effect of Music Practice on Music Ability

Psychological Science

Volumn 25, Issue 9, 2014, Pages 1795-1803

  Mosing, Miriam A ^a   Madison, Guy ^b   Pedersen, Nancy L ^a   Kuja Halkola, Ralf ^a   Ullén, Fredrik ^a  

^a KAROLINSKA INSTITUTE   (Sweden)

^b UMEÅ UNIVERSITY   (Sweden)

Author keywords

causality; expertise; heritability; music ability; practice; training; twin

Indexed keywords

ADULT; APTITUDE; DIZYGOTIC TWINS; EPIDEMIOLOGY; FEMALE; HUMAN; LEARNING; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MONOZYGOTIC TWINS; MUSIC; TWINS;

ADULT; APTITUDE; CAUSALITY; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; MUSIC; PRACTICE (PSYCHOLOGY); TWINS, DIZYGOTIC; TWINS, MONOZYGOTIC;

EID: 84908115845     PISSN: 09567976     EISSN: 14679280     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1177/0956797614541990     Document Type: Article

References (39)

1. Bengtsson S. L.,Nagy Z.,Forsman L.,Forssberg H.,Skare S.,Ullén F.Extensive piano practicing has regionally specific effects on white matter development.Nature Neuroscience. 2005;8:1148-1150
2. BokerS. M.NealeM. C.MaesH. H.WildeM. J.SpiegelM.BrickT. R.. BrandmaierA. (2012). OpenMx user guide: Release 1.2.0-1919. Retrieved from http://openmx.psyc.virginia.edu/docs/OpenMx/latest/OpenMxUserGuide.pdf
3. Boker S. M.,Neale M.,Maes H.,Wilde M.,Spiegel M.,Brick T.,.. Fox J.OpenMx: An open source extended structural equation modeling framework.Psychometrika. 2011;76:306-317
4. Charness N.,Feltovich P. J.,Hoffman R. R.,Ericsson K. A.The Cambridge handbook of expertise and expert performance. Cambridge, England: Cambridge University Press; 2006:
5. Coon H.,Carey G.Genetic and environmental determinants of musical ability in twins.Behavior Genetics. 1989;19:183-193
6. CorrigallK. A.SchellenbergE. G.MisuraN. M. (2013). Music training, cognition, and personality. Frontiers in Psychology, 4, Article 222. Retrieved from http://journal.frontiersin.org/Journal/10.3389/fpsyg.2013.00222/full
7. de Bruin A. B.,Smits N.,Rikers R. M.,Schmidt H. G.Deliberate practice predicts performance over time in adolescent chess players and drop-outs: A linear mixed models analysis.British Journal of Psychology. 2008;99:473-497
8. de Geus E. J. C.,de Moor M. H. M.A genetic perspective on the association between exercise and mental health.Mental Health and Physical Activity. 2008;1:53-61
9. Detterman D. K.,Ruthsatz J. M.Toward a more comprehensive theory of exceptional abilities.Journal for the Education of the Gifted. 1999;22:148-158
10. Drayna D.,Manichaikul A.,de Lange M.,Snieder H.,Spector T.Genetic correlates of musical pitch recognition in humans.Science. 2001;291:1969-1972
11. DuboisL.Ohm KyvikK.GirardM.Tatone-TokudaF.PerusseD.HjelmborgJ.. MartinM. G. (2012). Genetic and environmental contributions to weight, height, and BMI from birth to 19 years of age: An international study of over 12,000 twin pairs. PLoS ONE, 7(2), Article e30153. Retrieved from http://www.plosone.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0030153
12. Duffy D. L.,Martin N. G.Inferring the direction of causation in cross-sectional twin data: Theoretical and empirical considerations.Genetic Epidemiology. 1994;11:483-502
13. Ericsson K. A.The pursuit of excellence through education. Ferrari M., ed. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum; 2002:21-55.
14. Ericsson K. A.Training history, deliberate practice and elite sports performance: An analysis in response to Tucker and Collins review—What makes champions?.British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2013;47:533-535
15. Ericsson K. A.Why expert performance is special and cannot be extrapolated from studies of performance in the general population: A response to criticisms.Intelligence. 2014;45:81-103
16. Ericsson K. A.,Chase W. G.,Faloon S.Acquisition of a memory skill.Science. 1980;208:1181-1182
17. Ericsson K. A.,Krampe R. T.,Heizmann S.Can we create gifted people? [Target article and commentaries].Ciba Foundation Symposium; 1993; 1993. 222.
18. Ericsson K. A.,Krampe R. T.,Tesch-Römer C.The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance.Psychological Review. 1993;100:363-406
19. Ericsson K. A.,Lehmann A. C.Expert and exceptional performance: Evidence of maximal adaptation to task constraints.Annual Review of Psychology. 1996;47:273-305
20. Ericsson K. A.,Nandagopal K.,Roring R. W.Giftedness viewed from the expert performance perspective.Journal for the Education of the Gifted. 2005;28:287-311
21. Gladwell M.Outliers: The story of success. New York, NY: Little, Brown; 2008:
22. Hambrick D. Z.,Oswald F. L.,Altmann E. M.,Meinz E. J.,Gobet F.,Campitelli G.Deliberate practice: Is that all it takes to become an expert?.Intelligence. 2014;45:34-45
23. Howe M. J. A.,Davidson J. W.,Sloboda J. A.Innate talents: Reality or myth?.Behavioral & Brain Sciences. 1998;21:399-442
24. Hyde K. L.,Lerch J.,Norton A.,Forgeard M.,Winner E.,Evans A. C.,Schlaug G.Musical training shapes structural brain development.Journal of Neuroscience. 2009;29:3019-3025
25. Jang K. L.,Livesley W. J.,Vernon P. A.Heritability of the Big Five personality dimensions and their facets: A twin study.Journal of Personality. 1996;64:577-591
26. Krampe R. T.,Ericsson K. A.Maintaining excellence: Deliberate practice and elite performance in young and older pianists.Journal of Experimental Psychology: General. 1996;125:331-359
27. Lichtenstein P.,De Faire U.,Floderus B.,Svartengren M.,Svedberg P.,Pedersen N. L.The Swedish Twin Registry: A unique resource for clinical, epidemiological and genetic studies.Journal of Internal Medicine. 2002;252:184-205
28. Lichtenstein P.,Sullivan P. F.,Cnattingius S.,Gatz M.,Johansson S.,Carlström E.,.. Pedersen N. L.The Swedish Twin Registry in the third millennium: An update.Twin Research and Human Genetics. 2006;9:875-882
29. Neale M. C.,Boker S. M.,Xie G.,Maes H. H.Mx: Statistical modeling. (2006). Mx: Statistical modeling (7th ed.). Richmond: Virginia Commonwealth University, Department of Psychiatry.Richmond: Virginia Commonwealth University, Department of Psychiatry; 2006:
30. Neale M. C.,Maes H. H. M.Methodology for genetic studies of twins and families. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic; 2004:
31. Plomin R.,DeFries J. C.,Loehlin J. C.Genotype-environment interaction and correlation in the analysis of human behavior.Psychological Bulletin. 1977;84:309-322
32. Plomin R.,Shakeshaft N. G.,McMillan A.,Trzaskowski M.Nature, nurture, and expertise.Intelligence. 2014;45:46-59
33. Posthuma D.,de Geus E. J. C.,Deary I. J.The genetics of cognitive neuroscience. Goldberg T. E.Weinberger D. R., ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2009:97-122.
34. Ruthsatz J.,Detterman D.,Griscom W. S.,Cirullo B. A.Becoming an expert in the musical domain: It takes more than just practice.Intelligence. 2008;36:330-338
35. Schellenberg E. G.,Weiss M. W.The psychology of music. (2013). Music and cognitive abilities. In DeutschD. (Ed.), The psychology of music (3rd ed., pp. 499–550). Waltham, MA: Elsevier.Deutsch D., ed. Waltham, MA: Elsevier; 2013:499-550.
36. Seashore C. E.Manual of instructions and interpretations for Measures of Musical Talent. New York, NY: Psychological Corp; 1960:
37. Tucker R.,Collins M.What makes champions? A review of the relative contribution of genes and training to sporting success.British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2012;46:555-561
38. Ullén F.,Mosing M. A.,Holm L.,Eriksson H.,Madison G.Psychometric properties and heritability of a new online test for musicality, the Swedish Musical Discrimination Test.Personality and Individual Differences. 2014;63:87-93
39. Vinkhuyzen A. A.,van der Sluis S.,Posthuma D.,Boomsma D. I.The heritability of aptitude and exceptional talent across different domains in adolescents and young adults.Behavior Genetics. 2009;39:380-392