Virtual nature, violent accumulation: The 'spectacular failure' of carbon offsetting at a Ugandan National Park

Geoforum

Volumn 56, Issue , 2014, Pages 55-65

  Cavanagh, Connor ^a   Benjaminsen, Tor A ^a  

^a NORWEGIAN UNIVERSITY OF LIFE SCIENCES   (Norway)

Author keywords

Accumulation by dispossession; Carbon offsets; Green grabbing; Spectacle; Virtualism; Voluntary carbon markets

Indexed keywords

ACCUMULATION; CARBON EMISSION; CARBON SEQUESTRATION; CLIMATE CHANGE; CONSERVATION MANAGEMENT; EMISSIONS TRADING; ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION; MITIGATION; NATURE CONSERVATION; NONGOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION; CARBON DIOXIDE; PROTECTED AREA; REFORESTATION;

MOUNT ELGON NATIONAL PARK; UGANDA;

EID: 84904321868     PISSN: 00167185     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.geoforum.2014.06.013     Document Type: Article

References (113)

1. Adams W.M., Hutton J. People, parks and poverty: political ecology and biodiversity conservation. Conserv. Soc. 2007, 5(2):147-183.
2. Agarwal A., Narain S. Global Warming in an Unequal World 1991, Centre for Science and Environment, New Delhi.
3. Arsel M., Büscher B. Nature™, Inc.: changes and continuities in neoliberal conservation and market-based environmental policy. Dev. Change 2012, 43(1):53-78.
4. Ascui F., Lovell H. As frames collide: making sense of carbon accounting. Account., Audit. Account. 2011, 24(8):978-999.
5. Bachram H. Climate fraud and carbon colonialism: the new trade in greenhouse gases. Capital. Nat. Social. 2004, 15(4):5-20.
6. Benjaminsen T.A., Bryceson I. Conservation, green/blue grabbing and accumulation by dispossession in Tanzania. J. Peasant Stud. 2012, 39(2):335-355.
7. Benjaminsen T.A., Svarstad H. The death of an elephant: conservation discourses versus practices in Africa. Forum Dev. Stud. 2010, 37(3):385-408.
8. Benjaminsen T.A., Goldman M.J., Minwary M.Y., Maganga F.P. Wildlife management in Tanzania: state control, rent seeking and community resistance. Dev. Change 2013, 44(5):1087-1109.
9. Beymer-Farris B.A., Bassett T.J. The REDD menace: resurgent protectionism in Tanzania's mangrove forests. Global Environ. Change 2012, 22(2):332-341.
10. Borras S.M., Hall R., Scoones I., White B., Wolford W. Towards a better understanding of global land grabbing: an editorial introduction. J. Peasant Stud. 2011, 38(2):209-216.
11. Brockington D. Fortress Conservation: The Preservation of the Mkomazi Game Reserve, Tanzania 2002, James Currey, Oxford.
12. Bumpus, A.G., 2004. CPR for Climate Change? Understanding the Effective Recipiency of a Carbon Sequestration Project as a Common Pool or Privately Owned Resource in Highland Ecuador. Unpublished Master's Thesis. King's College, London.
13. 2e in carbon offsets. Antipode 2011, 43(3):612-638.
14. Bumpus A.G., Liverman D.M. Accumulation by decarbonization and the governance of carbon offsets. Econ. Geogr. 2008, 84(2):127-155.
15. Bumpus A.G., Liverman D.M. Carbon colonialism? Offsets, greenhouse gas reductions, and sustainable development. Global Political Ecology 2011, 203-224. Routledge, London. R. Peet, P. Robbins, M. Watts (Eds.).
16. Bunker S. Peasants against the State: The Politics of Market Control in Bugisu, Uganda, 1900-1983 1991, University of Chicago Press, Chicago. second ed.
17. Büscher B. Nature 2.0. Geoforum 2013, 44:1-3.
18. Büscher B., Arsel M. Introduction: neoliberal conservation, uneven geographical development and the dynamics of contemporary capitalism. Tijdschr. Econ. Soc. Geogr. 2012, 103(2):129-135.
19. Büscher B., Sullivan S., Neves K., Igoe J., Brockington D. Towards a synthesized critique of neoliberal biodiversity conservation. Capital. Nat. Social. 2012, 23(2):4-30.
20. Büscher, B., Dressler, W., Fletcher, R. (Eds.). 2014. Nature™ Inc.: Environmental Conservation in the Neoliberal Age. University of Arizona Press, Tucson, AZ.
21. Byakola, T., Lang, C., 2006. Uprooted. New Internationalist 391. (accessed 14.06.14). http://newint.org/features/2006/07/01/uganda/.
22. Carrere R. Carbon sink plantation in Uganda: evicting people for making space for trees. Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets 2009, 98-101. Mayfly Books, London. S. Böhm, S. Dahbi (Eds.).
23. Castree N. Environmental issues: relational ontologies and hybrid politics. Prog. Human Geogr. 2003, 27(2):203-211.
24. Castree N. Commodifying what nature?. Prog. Human Geogr. 2003, 27(3):273-297.
25. Castree N. Neoliberalizing nature: processes, effects, and evaluations. Environ. Plan. A 2008, 40(1):153-178.
26. Cavanagh, C., 2012. Unready for REDD+? Lessons from Corruption in Ugandan Conservation Areas. Policy brief for the U4 Anti-Corruption Resource Centre, Chr. Michelsen Institute. U4/CMI, Bergen, Norway.
27. Checker M. Double jeopardy: pursuing the path of carbon offsets and human rights abuses. Upsetting the Offset: The Political Economy of Carbon Markets 2009, 41-56. Mayfly Books, London. S. Böhm, S. Dahbi (Eds.).
28. Corson C., MacDonald K.I. Enclosing the global commons: the convention on biological diversity and green grabbing. J. Peasant Stud. 2012, 39(2):263-283.
29. Corson C., MacDonald K.I., Neimark B. Grabbing 'green': markets, environmental governance, and the materialization of natural capital. Human Geogr.: New Radical J. 2013, 6(1):1-15.
30. Cultural Survival, 2005. Momentous Ruling Recognizes Land Rights of Indigenous Community. (accessed 14.06.14). http://www.culturalsurvival.org/news/katie-meyer/momentous-ruling-recognizes-land-rights-indigenous-community.
31. Debord G. The Society of the Spectacle 1967, Zone Books, New York.
32. 2 Offset 1992, FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
33. FACE Foundation Annual Report 2000 2000, FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
34. FACE Foundation Annual Report 2001 2001, FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
35. FACE Foundation UWA-FACE Contract 2001, FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
36. FACE Foundation, n.d.-a. UWA-Face - Uganda. Undated Project Brochure. FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
37. FACE Foundation, n.d.-b. Let the Earth Remain Green. Undated Project Brochure. FACE Foundation, Rotterdam, Netherlands.
38. Fairhead J., Leach M., Scoones I. Green grabbing: a new appropriation of nature?. J. Peasant Stud. 2012, 39(2):237-261.
39. Faris, S. 2007. The Other Side of Carbon Trading. Fortune (30 August 2007). (accessed 10.04.12). http://money.cnn.com/2007/08/27/news/international/uganda_carbon_trading.fortune/.
40. Fletcher R. Using the master's tools? Neoliberal conservation and the evasion of inequality. Dev. Change 2012, 43(1):295-317.
41. Friends of the Earth International Life, Land, and Justice: How Land Grabbing in Uganda is affecting the Environment, Livelihoods, and Food Sovereignty of Communities 2012, Friends of the Earth International, Amsterdam.
42. Galik C.S., Jackson J.B. Risks to forest carbon offset projects in a changing climate. Forest Ecol. Manage. 2009, 257(11):2209-2216.
43. Gardner B. Tourism and the politics of the global land grab in Tanzania: markets, appropriation and recognition. J. Peasant Stud. 2012, 39(2):377-402.
44. Gibson C.C. Politicians and Poachers: The Political Economy of Wildlife Policy in Africa 1999, Cambridge UP, Cambridge.
45. Gosalamang, D., Vedeld, P., Gombya-Ssembajjwe, W., 2008. From Forest Reserve to National Park: Change in Legal Status and Impacts on Livelihoods and Biodiversity Resources, Mt. Elgon, Uganda. Noragric Working Paper No. 44. Norwegian University of Life Sciences, Ås, Norway.
46. Government of Uganda Constitution of the Republic of Uganda 1995, Uganda Law Reform Commission, Kampala.
47. GreenSeat, 2012. GreenSeat Homepage. (accessed 10.04.12). http://greenseat.nl/en/.
48. Harvey D. The New Imperialism 2003, Oxford UP, Oxford.
49. Himmelfarb, D., 2006. Moving People, Moving Boundaries: The Socio-Economic Effects of Protectionist Conservation, Involuntary Resettlement and Tenure Insecurity on the Edge of Mt. Elgon National Park, Uganda. Agroforestry in Landscape Mosaics Working Paper Series. World Agroforestry Centre, Tropical Resources Institute of Yale University, and The University of Georgia.
50. Himmelfarb, D., 2012. In the Aftermath of Displacement: A Political Ecology of Dispossession, Transformation, and Conflict on Mt. Elgon, Uganda. PhD Dissertation. University of Georgia, Athens.
51. Honigsbaum, M., 2007. Is carbon offsetting the solution? (Or part of the problem?) The Guardian (10 June 2007). (accessed 15.06.14). http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2007/jun/10/ethicalliving.carbonemissions.
52. Human Rights Network (Hurinet) Uganda, 2011. Resource Based Conflicts and Human Rights Violations in Uganda. A Case Study of Selected Protected Areas. Hurinet-Uganda/Diakonia-Sweden, Kampala.
53. Hunt D. Unintended consequences of the land rights reform: the case of the 1998 Uganda land act. Dev. Policy Rev. 2004, 22(2):173-191.
54. Igoe J. The spectacle of nature in the global economy of appearances: anthropological engagements with the spectacular mediations of transnational conservation. Critique Anthropol. 2010, 30(4):375-397.
55. Igoe J. Consume, connect, conserve: consumer spectacle and the technical mediation of neoliberal conservation's aesthetic of redemption and repair. Human Geogr.: New Radical J. 2013, 6(1):16-28.
56. Igoe J., Croucher B. Conservation, commerce, and communities: the story of community-based wildlife management areas in Tanzania's northern tourist circuit. Conserv. Soc. 2007, 5(4):534-561.
57. International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN), 2012. IUCN Invests in Rainforest Rehabilitation to Offset Congress Footprint. (accessed 28.11.13). http://www.iucn.org/about/union/secretariat/offices/esaro/_news/?10606/IUCN-investsin-rainforest-rehabilitation-to-offset-Congress-footprint.
58. Kelly A.B. Conservation practice as primitive accumulation. J. Peasant Stud. 2011, 38(4):683-701.
59. Kosoy N., Corbera E. Payments for ecosystem services as commodity fetishism. Ecol. Econ. 2010, 69:1228-1236.
60. Lang, C., Byakola, T., 2006. A Funny Place to Store Carbon: UWA-FACE Foundation's Tree Planting Project in Mount Elgon National Park, Uganda. World Rainforest Movement, Frankfurt. (accessed 10.04.12). http://www.wrm.org.uy/countries/Uganda/Place_Store_Carbon.pdf.
61. Latour B. We Have Never Been Modern 1993, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, MA.
62. Lovell H., Liverman D. Understanding carbon offset technologies. New Polit. Econ. 2010, 15(2):255-273.
63. Lovell H., MacKenzie D. Accounting for carbon: the role of accounting professional organizations in governing climate change. Antipode 2011, 43(3):704-730.
64. MacDonald K.I. Grabbing green: cynical reason, instrumental ethics, and the production of the green economy. Human Geogr.: New Radical J. 2013, 6(1):46-63.
65. MacDonald K.I., Corson C. TEEB begins now: a virtual moment in the production of natural capital. Dev. Change 2012, 43(1):159-184.
66. Mamdani M. Politics and Class Formation in Uganda 1976, Heinemann, London.
67. Marino E., Ribot J. Adding insult to injury: climate change and the inequities of climate intervention. Global Environ. Change 2012, 22(2):323-328.
68. Marx, K., 1995 (1867). In: Engels, F. (Ed.), Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, vol. 1 (S. Moore, E. Aveling, Trans.). Progress Publishers, Moscow. http://marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/index.htm.
69. McAfee K. The contradictory logic of global ecosystem services markets. Dev. Change 2012, 43(1):105-131.
70. McCarthy J., Prudham S. Neoliberal nature and the nature of neoliberalism. Geoforum 2004, 35(3):275-284.
71. Mosse D. Cultivating Development: An Ethnography of Aid Policy and Practice 2005, Pluto Press, London.
72. Mugambwa J. A comparative analysis of land tenure law reform in Uganda and Papua New Guinea. J. South Pacific Law 2007, 11(1):39-55.
73. National Forestry Authority (NFA) Assessment of Trends of Evictions from Protected Areas During the Period 2005-2010 and their Implications for REDD+ 2011, NFA, Kampala.
74. Nel A., Hill D. Constructing walls of carbon: the complexities of community, carbon sequestration and protected areas in Uganda. J. Contemp. Afr. Stud. 2013, 31(3):421-440.
75. Nel A., Sharife K. East African trees and the green resource curse. The CDM in Africa Cannot Deliver the Money: Why the Carbon Trading Gamble and 'Clean Development Mechanism' Won't Save the Planet from Climate Change, and How African Civil Society is Resisting 2012, Centre for Civil Society, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa. P. Bond (Ed.).
76. Neumann R. Imposing Wilderness: Struggles over Livelihood and Nature Conservation in Africa 1998, University of California Press, Berkeley.
77. Norgrove, L., 2002. Parking Resistance and Resisting the Park: The Theory and Practice of National Park Management, A Case Study of Mount Elgon National Park, Uganda. Unpublished PhD Dissertation. University of Manchester, Manchester.
78. Norgrove L., Hulme D. Confronting conservation at Mount Elgon, Uganda. Dev. Change 2006, 37(5):1093-1116.
79. O'Connor J. Capitalism, nature, socialism: a theoretical introduction. Capital. Nat. Social. 1988, 1(1):11-38.
80. Okuku J.A. The Land Act (1998) and land tenure reform in Uganda. Africa Dev. 2006, 31(1):1-26.
81. Okwaare S., Hargreaves S. Mountains of Trouble: The Benet Community of Uganda. ActionAid Critical Stories of Change Series 2009, ActionAid, Kampala.
82. Oxfam International The New Forests Company and its Uganda Plantations 2011, Oxfam, Oxford.
83. Peet R., Robbins P., Watts M. Global nature. Global Political Ecology 2011, 1-48. Routledge, London. R. Peet, P. Robbins, M. Watts (Eds.).
84. Peluso N. What's nature got to do with it? A situated historical perspective on socio-natural commodities. Dev. Change 2012, 43(1):70-104.
85. Peluso N.L., Lund C. New frontiers of land control: introduction. J. Peasant Stud. 2011, 38(4):667-681.
86. Petracco, C.K., Pender, J., 2009. Evaluating the Impact of Land Tenure and Titling on Access to Credit in Uganda. IFPRI Discussion Paper 00853. IFPRI, Washington, DC.
87. Petursson J.G., Vedeld P., Kaboggoza J. Transboundary biodiversity management: institutions, local stakeholders, and protected areas: a case study from Mt. Elgon, Uganda and Kenya. Soc. Nat. Resour. 2011, 24(12):1304-1321.
88. Petursson J.G., Vedeld P., Sassen M. An institutional analysis of deforestation processes in protected areas: the case of the transboundary Mt. Elgon, Uganda and Kenya. Forest Policy Econ. 2013, 26:22-33.
89. Petursson J.G., Vedeld P., Vatn A. Going transboundary? An institutional analysis of transboundary protected area management challenges at Mt Elgon, East Africa. Ecol. Soc. 2013, 18(4):28.
90. Robertson M. Measurement and alienation: producing a world of ecosystem services. Trans. Inst. Br. Geogr. 2012, 37:386-401.
91. Roth R.J., Dressler W. Market-oriented conservation governance: the particularities of place. Geoforum 2012, 43(3):363-366.
92. Sassen M., Sheil D. Human impacts on forest structure and species richness on the edges of a protected mountain forest in Uganda. Forest Ecol. Manage. 2013, 307:206-218.
93. Sassen M., Sheil D., Giller K.E., ter Braak C.J. Complex contexts and dynamic drivers: understanding four decades of forest loss and recovery in an East African protected area. Biol. Conserv. 2013, 159:257-268.
94. Smith N. Nature as an accumulation strategy. Soc. Reg. 2007, 16:19-41.
95. Société Générale de Surveillance (SGS) Agrocontrol Uganda Wildlife Authority-Face Foundation Natural High Forest Rehabilitation Project, Mt Elgon National Park, Uganda: GHG Project Validation and Verification Main Assessment Report 2001, SGS Agrocontrol, Spijkenisse, Netherlands.
96. Springer S. Illegal evictions? Overwriting possession and orality with law's violence in Cambodia. J. Agrarian Change 2013, 14(4):520-546.
97. Sullivan S. Conservation is sexy! What makes this so, and what does this make? An engagement with Celebrity and the Environment. Conserv. Soc. 2011, 9(4):334-345.
98. Sullivan S. Banking nature? The spectacular financialization of environmental conservation. Antipode 2013, 45(1):198-217.
99. Tsing A. Inside the economy of appearances. Public Cult. 2000, 12(1):115-144.
100. Tsing A. Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection 2005, Princeton University Press, Princeton and Oxford.
101. Turyahabwe N., Banana A. An overview of history and development of forest policy and legislation in Uganda. Int. Forestry Rev. 2008, 10(4):641-656.
102. Uganda Communications Commission (UCC), 2010. Rural Communications Development Fund (RCDF): UCC Support through the RCDF Programme. Uganda Communications Commission, Kampala.
103. Uganda Wildlife Authority (UWA) Mt. Elgon National Park General Management Plan (MENP GMP), 2000-2010 2000, Uganda Wildlife Authority, Kampala.
104. Uganda Wildlife Authority (UWA) Mount Elgon National Park General Management Plan, 2009-2019 2009, Uganda Wildlife Authority, Kampala.
105. Uganda Wildlife Authority (UWA) Memorandum of Understanding between Uganda Wildlife Authority and Bududa District Local Government for and on behalf of the Relevant Communities of Bududa District for Collaborative Park Restoration 2009, Uganda Wildlife Authority, Kampala.
106. Uganda Wildlife Authority (UWA), 2011. UWA-FACE Progressive Forest Restoration Report, January 1994-October 2010. Uganda Wildlife Authority, Kampala.
107. United States Agency for International Development (USAID) Project Grant Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Uganda and the United States of America for the Action Program for the Environment 1991, USAID, Washington, DC.
108. Vangen, C., 2009. Evicted in the Name of Nature: The Process of Eviction and its Impact on Local Rural Livelihoods in Mount Elgon, Uganda. M.Sc. Thesis. University of Life Sciences, Ås, Norway.
109. Webster G. Working Plan for Mount Elgon Forest Reserve 1954, Government Printer, Entebbe.
110. West P., Igoe J., Brockington D. Parks and peoples: the social impact of protected areas. Annu. Rev. Anthropol. 2006, 35:251-277.
111. White, S., 2002. People-park Conflicts in Mt. Elgon: The Role of Collaborative Management in Conflict Resolution. Paper Presented to the National Conference on Mountains and Highlands in Uganda, 3-4 October 2002, Makerere University, Kampala.
112. White S., Hinchley D. Managing Mount Elgon. Arborvitae 2001, 18:13.
113. Wunder, S., 2008. How do we deal with leakage? In: Angelsen, A. (Ed.), Moving Ahead with REDD: Issues, Options, and Implications. Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), Bangor, Indonesia.