Clinically meaningful nocebo effect occurs in acupuncture treatment: A systematic review

Journal of Clinical Epidemiology

Volumn 67, Issue 8, 2014, Pages 858-869

  Koog, Yun Hyung ^a   Lee, Jin Su ^a   Wi, Hyungsun ^a  

^a Medifarm Hospital   (South Korea)

Author keywords

Acupuncture; Adverse event; Dropout; Nocebo effect; Randomized trial; Systematic review

Indexed keywords

ACUPUNCTURE; ATTRIBUTABLE RISK; CONFIDENCE INTERVAL; DATA BASE; HUMAN; KNEE OSTEOARTHRITIS; LOW BACK PAIN; META ANALYSIS; MUSCULOSKELETAL DISEASE; NOCEBO EFFECT; OUTCOME ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECT; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; RISK ASSESSMENT; SHAM PROCEDURE; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

ACUPUNCTURE; ADVERSE EVENT; DROPOUT; NOCEBO EFFECT; RANDOMIZED TRIAL; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW;

ACUPUNCTURE THERAPY; HUMANS; NOCEBO EFFECT; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIALS AS TOPIC;

EID: 84902850819     PISSN: 08954356     EISSN: 18785921     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jclinepi.2014.02.021     Document Type: Review

References (92)

1. P.C. Gøtzsche Is there logic in the placebo? Lancet 344 1994 925 926
2. A. Hróbjartsson, and P.C. Gøtzsche Placebo interventions for all clinical conditions Cochrane Database Syst Rev 1 2010 CD003974
3. H.K. Beecher The powerful placebo JAMA 159 1955 1602 1606
4. E. Loder, R. Goldstein, and D. Biondi Placebo effects in oral triptan trials: the scientific and ethical rationale for continued use of placebo controls Cephalalgia 25 2005 124 131
5. W. Zhang, J. Robertson, A.C. Jones, P.A. Dieppe, and M. Doherty The placebo effect and its determinants in osteoarthritis: meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials Ann Rheum Dis 67 2008 1716 1723
6. M.V. Madsen, P.C. Gøtzsche, and A. Hróbjartsson Acupuncture treatment for pain: systematic review of randomised clinical trials with acupuncture, placebo acupuncture, and no acupuncture groups BMJ 338 2009 a3115
7. K. Linde, K. Niemann, A. Schneider, and K. Meissner How large are the nonspecific effects of acupuncture? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials BMC Med 8 2010 75
8. Y.H. Koog, S.R. We, and B.I. Min Three-armed trials including placebo and no-treatment groups may be subject to publication bias: systematic review PLoS One 6 2011 e20679
9. S.R. We, Y.H. Koog, M.S. Park, and B.I. Min Placebo effect was influenced by publication year in three-armed acupuncture trials Complement Ther Med 20 2012 83 92
10. Y.H. Koog, and W.Y. Jung Time course of placebo effect of acupuncture on pain: a systematic review ISRN Pain 2013 2013 204108
11. D.G. Finniss, T.J. Kaptchuk, F. Miller, and F. Benedetti Biological, clinical, and ethical advances of placebo effects Lancet 375 2010 686 695
12. W. Häuser, E. Hansen, and P. Enck Nocebo phenomena in medicine: their relevance in everyday clinical practice Dtsch Arztebl Int 109 2012 459 465
13. J.R. Nebeker, P. Barach, and M.H. Samore Clarifying adverse drug events: a clinician's guide to terminology, documentation, and reporting Ann Intern Med 140 2004 795 801
14. R. DerSimonian, and N. Laird Meta-analysis in clinical trials Control Clin Trials 7 1986 177 188
15. J.P. Higgins, S.G. Thompson, J.J. Deeks, and D.G. Altman Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses BMJ 327 2003 557 560
16. M. Egger, G. Davey Smith, M. Schneider, and C. Minder Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test BMJ 315 1997 629 634
17. R.M. Harbord, and J.P. Higgins Meta-regression in Stata Stata J 8 2008 493 529
18. L. Vase, S. Baram, N. Takakura, H. Yajima, M. Takayama, and T.J. Kaptchuk et al. Specifying the nonspecific components of acupuncture analgesia Pain 154 2013 1659 1667
19. S. Bokmand, and H. Flyger Acupuncture relieves menopausal discomfort in breast cancer patients: a prospective, double blinded, randomized study Breast 22 2013 320 323
20. G. Li, S. Li, L. An, and B. Wang Electroacupuncture alleviates intraoperative immunosuppression in patients undergoing supratentorial craniotomy Acupunct Med 31 2013 51 56
21. S.M. Choi, J.E. Park, S.S. Li, H. Jung, M. Zi, and T.H. Kim et al. A multicenter, randomized, controlled trial testing the effects of acupuncture on allergic rhinitis Allergy 68 2013 365 374
22. B. Brinkhaus, M. Ortiz, C.M. Witt, S. Roll, K. Linde, and F. Pfab et al. Acupuncture in patients with seasonal allergic rhinitis: a randomized trial Ann Intern Med 158 2013 225 234
23. J. Vas, J.M. Aranda, M. Modesto, N. Benítez-Parejo, A. Herrera, and D.M. Martínez-Barquín et al. Acupuncture in patients with acute low back pain: a multicentre randomised controlled clinical trial Pain 153 2012 1883 1889
24. C.I. Mavrommatis, E. Argyra, A. Vadalouka, and D.G. Vasilakos Acupuncture as an adjunctive therapy to pharmacological treatment in patients with chronic pain due to osteoarthritis of the knee: a 3-armed, randomized, placebo-controlled trial Pain 153 2012 1720 1726
25. J.M. Painovich, C.L. Shufelt, R. Azziz, Y. Yang, M.O. Goodarzi, and G.D. Braunstein et al. A pilot randomized, single-blind, placebo-controlled trial of traditional acupuncture for vasomotor symptoms and mechanistic pathways of menopause Menopause 19 2012 54 61
26. Y.L. Liu, and Z.G. Jin Clinical observation of the impacts and safety of electroacupuncture at Sanyinjiao (SP 6) on labor Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 32 2012 409 412
27. F. Pfab, M.T. Kirchner, J. Huss-Marp, T. Schuster, P.C. Schalock, and J. Fuqin et al. Acupuncture compared with oral antihistamine for type I hypersensitivity itch and skin response in adults with atopic dermatitis: a patient- and examiner-blinded, randomized, placebo-controlled, crossover trial Allergy 67 2012 566 573
28. I.Z. Mackenzie, J. Xu, C. Cusick, H. Midwinter-Morten, H. Meacher, and J. Mollison et al. Acupuncture for pain relief during induced labour in nulliparae: a randomized controlled study BJOG 118 2011 440 447
29. W. Ma, W. Bai, C. Lin, P. Zhou, L. Xia, and C. Zhao et al. Effects of Sanyinjiao (SP6) with electroacupuncture on labour pain in women during labour Complement Ther Med 19 Suppl 1 2011 S13 S18
30. A. Lomuscio, S. Belletti, P.M. Battezzati, and F. Lombardi Efficacy of acupuncture in preventing atrial fibrillation recurrences after electrical cardioversion J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol 22 2011 241 247
31. C.Z. Liu, J.P. Xie, L.P. Wang, Y.Y. Zheng, Z.B. Ma, and H. Yang et al. Immediate analgesia effect of single point acupuncture in primary dysmenorrhea: a randomized controlled trial Pain Med 12 2011 300 307
32. M.E. Suarez-Almazor, C. Looney, Y. Liu, V. Cox, K. Pietz, and D.M. Marcus et al. A randomized controlled trial of acupuncture for osteoarthritis of the knee: effects of patient-provider communication Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken) 62 2010 1229 1236
33. J.P. Mu, L. Liu, W. Fang, J.M. Cheng, and L. Zhao Effect of electroacupuncture at Jiaji (EX-B 2) on drug craving of heroin addicts and beta-EP and Dyn-A in plasma Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 30 2010 881 885
34. J.Y. Choi, H.J. Jung, J.I. Kim, M.S. Lee, K.W. Kang, and Y.L. Roh et al. A randomized pilot study of acupuncture as an adjunct therapy in adult asthmatic patients J Asthma 47 2010 774 780
35. D.C. Cherkin, K.J. Sherman, A.L. Avins, J.H. Erro, L. Ichikawa, and W.E. Barlow et al. A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain Arch Intern Med 169 2009 858 866
36. S.H. Lee, and B.C. Lee Electroacupuncture relieves pain in men with chronic prostatitis/chronic pelvic pain syndrome: three-arm randomized trial Urology 73 2009 1036 1041
37. S. Sertel, S. Herrmann, H.J. Greten, V. Haxsen, S. El-Bitar, and C.H. Simon et al. Additional use of acupuncture to NSAID effectively reduces post-tonsillectomy pain Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol 266 2009 919 925
38. C.M. Grecco, A.H. Kao, K. Maksimowicz-McKinnon, R.M. Glick, M. Houze, and S.M. Sereika et al. Acupuncture for systemic lupus erythematosus: a pilot RCT feasibility and safety study Lupus 17 2008 1108 1116
39. N.E. Avis, C. Legault, R.R. Coeytaux, M. Pian-Smith, J.L. Shifren, and W. Chen et al. A randomized, controlled pilot study of acupuncture treatment for menopausal hot flashes Menopause 15 2008 1070 1078
40. E. Facco, A. Liguori, F. Petti, G. Zanette, F. Coluzzi, and M. De Nardin et al. Traditional acupuncture in migraine: a controlled randomized study Headache 48 2008 398 407
41. A.O. Freire, G.C. Sugai, F.S. Chrispin, S.M. Togeiro, Y. Yamamura, and L.E. Mello et al. Treatment of moderate obstructive sleep apnea syndrome with acupuncture: a randomised, placebo-controlled pilot trial Sleep Med 8 2007 43 50
42. N.E. Foster, E. Thomas, P. Barlas, J.C. Hill, J. Young, and E. Mason et al. Acupuncture as an adjunct to exercise based physiotherapy for osteoarthritis of the knee: randomised controlled trial BMJ 1335 2007 436
43. J.J. Allen, R.N. Schnyer, A.S. Chambers, S.K. Hitt, F.A. Moreno, and R. Manber Acupuncture for depression: a randomized controlled trial J Clin Psychiatry 67 2006 1665 1673
44. L. Gioia, L. Cabrini, M. Gemma, R. Fiori, F. Fasce, and G. Bolognesi et al. Sedative effect of acupuncture during cataract surgery: prospective randomized double-blind study J Cataract Refract Surg 32 2006 1951 1954
45. L. Cabrini, L. Gioia, M. Gemma, G. Melloni, A. Carretta, and P. Ciriaco et al. Acupuncture for diagnostic fiberoptic bronchoscopy: a prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled study Am J Chin Med 34 2006 409 415
46. H.P. Scharf, U. Mansmann, K. Streitberger, S. Witte, J. Krämer, and C. Maier et al. Acupuncture and knee osteoarthritis: a three-armed randomized trial Ann Intern Med 145 2006 12 20
47. S. Ziaei, and L. Hajipour Effect of acupuncture on labor Int J Gynaecol Obstet 92 2006 71 72
48. B. Brinkhaus, C.M. Witt, S. Jena, K. Linde, A. Streng, and S. Wagenpfeil et al. Acupuncture in patients with chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial Arch Intern Med 166 2006 450 457
49. D. Melchart, A. Streng, A. Hoppe, B. Brinkhaus, C. Witt, and S. Wagenpfeil et al. Acupuncture in patients with tension-type headache: randomised controlled trial BMJ 331 2005 376 382
50. C. Witt, B. Brinkhaus, S. Jena, K. Linde, A. Streng, and S. Wagenpfeil et al. Acupuncture in patients with osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomised trial Lancet 366 2005 136 143
51. K. Linde, A. Streng, S. Jürgens, A. Hoppe, B. Brinkhaus, and C. Witt et al. Acupuncture for patients with migraine: a randomized controlled trial JAMA 293 2005 2118 2125
52. M.S. Schuler, C. Durdak, N.M. Hosl, A. Klink, K.A. Hauer, and P. Oster et al. Acupuncture treatment of geriatric patients with ischemic stroke: a randomized, double-controlled, single-blind study J Am Geriatr Soc 53 2005 549 550
53. P.A. Johnstone, T.L. Bloom, R.C. Niemtzow, D. Crain, R.H. Riffenburgh, and C.L. Amling A prospective, randomized pilot trial of acupuncture of the kidney-bladder distinct meridian for lower urinary tract symptoms J Urol 169 2003 1037 1039
54. A. Rösler, B. Otto, D. Schreiber-Dietrich, H. Steinmetz, and K.R. Kessler Single-needle acupuncture alleviates gag reflex during transesophageal echocardiography: a blinded, randomized, controlled pilot trial J Altern Complement Med 9 2003 847 849
55. A.F. Molsberger, J. Mau, D.B. Pawelec, and J. Winkler Does acupuncture improve the orthopedic management of chronic low back pain-a randomized, blinded, controlled trial with 3 months follow up Pain 99 2002 579 587
56. E. Leibing, U. Leonhardt, G. Köster, A. Goerlitz, J.A. Rosenfeldt, and R. Hilgers et al. Acupuncture treatment of chronic low-back pain-a randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled trial with 9-month follow-up Pain 96 2002 189 196
57. J.G. Lin, M.W. Lo, Y.R. Wen, C.L. Hsieh, S.K. Tsai, and W.Z. Sun The effect of high and low frequency electroacupuncture in pain after lower abdominal surgery Pain 99 2002 509 514
58. T.C. Medici, E. Grebski, J. Wu, G. Hinz, and B. Wüthrich Acupuncture and bronchial asthma: a long-term randomized study of the effects of real versus sham acupuncture compared to controls in patients with bronchial asthma J Altern Complement Med 8 2002 737 750 discussion 751-754
59. C. Smith, C. Crowther, and J. Beilby Acupuncture to treat nausea and vomiting in early pregnancy: a randomized controlled trial Birth 29 2002 1 9
60. N. Kotani, T. Kushikata, A. Suzuki, H. Hashimoto, M. Muraoka, and A. Matsuki Insertion of intradermal needles into painful points provides analgesia for intractable abdominal scar pain Reg Anesth Pain Med 26 2001 532 538
61. J. Shen, N. Wenger, J. Glaspy, R.D. Hays, P.S. Albert, and C. Choi et al. Electroacupuncture for control of myeloablative chemotherapy-induced emesis: a randomized controlled trial JAMA 284 2000 2755 2761
62. J. Röschke, C. Wolf, M.J. Müller, P. Wagner, K. Mann, and M. Grözinger et al. The benefit from whole body acupuncture in major depression J Affect Disord 57 2000 73 81
63. G. Gosman-Hedström, L. Claesson, U. Klingenstierna, J. Carlsson, B. Olausson, and M. Frizell et al. Effects of acupuncture treatment on daily life activities and quality of life: a controlled, prospective, and randomized study of acute stroke patients Stroke 29 1998 2100 2108
64. J.J.B. Allen, R.N. Schyner, and S.K. Hitt The efficacy of acupuncture in the treatment of major depression in women Psychol Sci 9 1998 397 401
65. H. Sprott Efficiency of acupuncture in patients with fibromyalgia Clin Bull Myofascial Ther 3 1998 37 43
66. S. Birch, and R.N. Jamison Controlled trial of Japanese acupuncture for chronic myofascial neck pain: assessment of specific and nonspecific effects of treatment Clin J Pain 14 1998 248 255
67. M.L. Tremeau, P. Fontanie-Ravier, F. Teurnier, and J. Demouzon Protocol of cervical maturation by acupuncture J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris) 21 1992 375 380
68. J.M. Helms Acupuncture for the management of primary dysmenorrhea Obstet Gynecol 69 1987 51 56
69. L. Fanti, M. Gemma, S. Passaretti, M. Guslandi, P.A. Testoni, and A. Casati et al. Electroacupuncture analgesia for colonoscopy: a prospective, randomized, placebo-controlled study Am J Gastroenterol 98 2003 312 316
70. L.M. Rusy, G.M. Hoffman, and S.J. Weisman Electroacupuncture prophylaxis of postoperative nausea and vomiting following pediatric tonsillectomy with or without adenoidectomy Anesthesiology 96 2002 300 305
71. A. Aune, T. Alraek, H. LiHua, and A. Baerheim Acupuncture in the prophylaxis of recurrent lower urinary tract infection in adult women Scand J Prim Health Care 16 1998 37 39
72. J.W. Dundee, W.N. Chestnutt, R.G. Ghaly, and A.G. Lynas Traditional Chinese acupuncture: a potentially useful antiemetic? Br Med J (Clin Res Ed) 293 1986 583 584
73. G.X. Shi, C.Z. Liu, J. Zhu, L.P. Guan, D.J. Wang, and M.M. Wu Effects of acupuncture at Sanyinjiao (SP6) on prostaglandin levels in primary dysmenorrhea patients Clin J Pain 27 2011 258 261
74. C.Y. Gu, L.R. Shen, Y.H. Ding, Y. Lou, H.G. Wu, and Z. Shi et al. Influence of acupuncture at acupoints and non-acupoints on the perioperative analgesic effect in patients with laparoscopic cholecystectomy Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 30 2010 675 678
75. Y.X. Ma, L.X. Ma, X.L. Liu, Y.X. Ma, K. Lv, and D. Wang et al. A comparative study on the immediate effects of electroacupuncture at Sanyinjiao (SP6), Xuanzhong (GB39) and a non-meridian point, on menstrual pain and uterine arterial blood flow, in primary dysmenorrhea patients Pain Med 11 2010 1564 1575
76. D.D. Mitsikostas, L. Mantonakis, and N. Chalarakis Nocebo in clinical trials for depression: a meta-analysis Psychiatry Res 215 2014 82 86 pii: S0165-1781(13)00670-7
77. P. Stathis, M. Smpiliris, S. Konitsiotis, and D.D. Mitsikostas Nocebo as a potential confounding factor in clinical trials for Parkinson's disease treatment: a meta-analysis Eur J Neurol 20 2013 527 533
78. D. Papadopoulos, and D.D. Mitsikostas A meta-analytic approach to estimating nocebo effects in neuropathic pain trials J Neurol 259 2012 436 447
79. W. Häuser, C. Bartram, E. Bartram-Wunn, and T. Tölle Systematic review: adverse events attributable to nocebo in randomised controlled drug trials in fibromyalgia syndrome and painful diabetic peripheral neuropathy Clin J Pain 28 2012 437 451
80. D.D. Mitsikostas, N.G. Chalarakis, L.I. Mantonakis, E.M. Delicha, and P.P. Sfikakis Nocebo in fibromyalgia: meta-analysis of placebo-controlled clinical trials and implications for practice Eur J Neurol 19 2012 672 680
81. D.D. Mitsikostas, L.I. Mantonakis, and N.G. Chalarakis Nocebo is the enemy, not placebo. A meta-analysis of reported side effects after placebo treatment in headaches Cephalalgia 31 2011 550 561
82. D. Papadopoulos, and D.D. Mitsikostas Nocebo effects in multiple sclerosis trials: a meta-analysis Mult Scler 16 2010 816 828
83. W. Rief, Y. Nestoriuc, A. von Lilienfeld-Toal, I. Dogan, F. Schreiber, and S.G. Hofmann et al. Differences in adverse effect reporting in placebo groups in SSRI and tricyclic antidepressant trials: a systematic review and meta-analysis Drug Saf 32 2009 1041 1056
84. M. Amanzio, L.L. Corazzini, L. Vase, and F. Benedetti A systematic review of adverse events in placebo groups of anti-migraine clinical trials Pain 146 2009 261 269
85. W. Rief, J. Avorn, and A.J. Barsky Medication-attributed adverse effects in placebo groups: implications for assessment of adverse effects Arch Intern Med 166 2006 155 160
86. A. Hróbjartsson What are the main methodological problems in the estimation of placebo effects? J Clin Epidemiol 55 2002 430 435
87. T.J. Kaptchuk, W.B. Stason, R.B. Davis, A.R. Legedza, R.N. Schnyer, and C.E. Kerr et al. Sham device v inert pill: randomised controlled trial of two placebo treatments BMJ 332 2006 391 397
88. T. Lundeberg, I. Lund, A. Sing, and J. Naslund Is placebo acupuncture what it is intended to be? Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2011 2011 932407
89. H.H. Moffet Sham acupuncture may be as efficacious as true acupuncture: a systematic review of clinical trials J Altern Complement Med 15 2009 213 216
90. Y.H. Koog, M. Gil, S.R. We, H. Wi, and B.I. Min Barriers to participant retention in knee osteoarthritis clinical trials: a systematic review Semin Arthritis Rheum 42 2013 346 354
91. T. Lundeberg, and I. Lund Are reviews based on sham acupuncture procedures in fibromyalgia syndrome (FMS) valid? Acupunct Med 25 2007 100 106
92. F.D. Sheftell, M. Feleppa, S.J. Tepper, A.M. Rapoport, L. Ciannella, and M.E. Bigal Assessment of adverse events associated with triptans-methods of assessment influence the results Headache 44 2004 978 982