Ideology of the Commons and Property Rights: Who Owns Plant Genetic Resources and the Associated Traditional Knowledge?

International Library of Environmental, Agricultural and Food Ethics

Volumn 11, Issue , 2007, Pages 21-48

  Onwuekwe, Chika B ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CALGARY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Indigenous Knowledge; Intellectual Property; Patent Protection; Plant Genetic Resource; Traditional Knowledge

Indexed keywords

EID: 84900173256     PISSN: 15703010     EISSN: 22151737     Source Type: Book Series    
DOI: 10.1007/978-1-4020-5822-6_2     Document Type: Chapter

References (86)

1. Antarctic Treaty, concluded in Washington DC, on 1 December 1959, entered into force on 23 June 1961, reprinted in 40 UNTS 71
2. Aoki K (1998) Nationalism, anticommons property, and Biopiracy in the (Not-So-Brave) new world order of international intellectual property Protection 6 Ind. J. Global Leg. Stud. 11. Retrieved from: http://www.law.uoregon.edu/faculty/kaoki/site/articles/notsobrave.pdf
3. Charter of Economic Rights and Duties of States (1974) Article 3
4. Battiste M, Henderson JY (2000) Protecting indigenous knowledge and heritage: a global challenge. Purich, Saskatoon
5. Becker DC, Elinor O (1995) Human ecology and resource sustainability: the importance of institutional diversity. Annual review of ecology and systematics, vol 26. pp 113–133
6. Blakeney M (2001) Intellectual property aspects of traditional agricultural knowledge. In: Drahos P, Blakeney M (eds) IP Biodiversity and agriculture: regulating the biosphere. Sweet and Maxwell, London
7. Brownlie I (1998) Principles of public international law, 5th edn. Oxford University Press, Oxford
8. Busch L, Lacy WB, Burkhardt J, Lacy LR (1991) Plants, power and profit: social, economic, and ethical consequences of the new Biotechnologies. Basil Blackwell, Cambridge MA and Oxford
9. Carr CL (ed) (1994) The political writings of Samuel Pufendorf. trans. by Seidler MJ. Oxford University Press Oxford
10. Convention on Biological Diversity. Article 2(2). available online: http://www.biodiv.org/convention/articles.asp checked 1993
11. Crucible II Group (2000) Seedling solutions: policy options for genetic resources (people, plants, and patents revisited), vol 1. IDRC & IPGRI, online version, Ottawa & Rome
12. Dietz T, Elinor O, Stern PC (2003) The struggle to govern the commons, Science,12/12/2003, vol 302 Issue 5652. pp 1907–1912
13. Drahos P (1996) A philosophy of intellectual property. Dartmouth, Aldershot
14. Dutfield G (1999) Protecting and revitalising traditional ecological knowledge: intellectual property rights and community knowledge databases in India. In: Blakeney M (ed) Intellectual property aspects of Ethnobiology. Sweet & Maxwell, London
15. Dutfield G (2001a) Indigenous peoples, Bioprospecting, and the TRIPS Agreement: threats and opportunities. In: Drahos P, Blakeney M (eds) IP in biodiversity and agriculture: regulating the biosphere. Sweet and Maxwell, London
16. Dutfield G (2001b) TRIPS-related aspects of traditional knowledge. Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law 33(2) JIL 233-275
17. Engle E (2004) Economic theory of Law and the public domain: when is piracy economically desirable. available online: http://lexnet.bravepages.com/media1.html
18. Epstein RA (1994) On the optimal mix of private and common property 11 social philosophy and policy 17. reprinted in Epstein RA (ed) Private and common property. Garland, New York & London
19. Epstein RA (2000) Possession as the root of title. In: Epstein RA (ed) Private and common property.Garland, New York & London
20. Evenson RE (1999) Intellectual property rights, access to plant germplasm, and crop production scenarios in 2020” (1999) 39 Crop Science 1630
21. Eyzaguirre P, Evan D (2003) The impacts of collective action and property rights on plant genetic resources – being a paper prepared for the CAPRi-IPGRI workshop on Property rights, collective action and local conservation of genetic resources (in Rome), available online: http://www.capri.cgiar.org/pdf/GReyzaguirre.pdf
22. Federal Court Trial (FCT) 256 (2001) available online: http://decisions.fct-cf.gc.ca/fct/2001/2001fct256.html The Supreme Court of Canada’s judgment on this landmark case is reported in Monsanto Canadav. Schmeiser[2004] 1 S.C.R. 902.
23. Food and Agriculture Organization, International Undertaking on Plant Genetic Resources. 1983 Available online: http://www.fao.org/ag/cgrfa/IU.htm
24. Fowler C, Smale M, Gaiji S (2001) Unequal exchange? Recent transfers of the agricultural resources and their implications for developing countries. Development Policy Review 19(2):181–204
25. GATT/WTO (1995) Agreement on Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs), which came into effect on January 1, 1995.
26. Gertler ME (1998) Biotechnology and social issues in rural agricultural communities: identifying the issues. In: Hardy RWF, Segelken JB, Voionmaa M (eds) Resource management in challenged environment. NABC, New York
27. Ghijsen H (1998) Plant variety protection in a developing and demanding world. Biotechnology and Development Monitor 36:2–5
28. Gibbs CJN, Bromley DW (1989) Institutional arrangements for management of rural resources: common property regimes. In: Berkes F (ed) Common property resources: ecology and community-based sustainable development. Belhaven Press, London
29. Goldstein D (1988) Molecular biology and the protection of germplasm: a matter of national security. In: Kloppenburg JR (ed) Seeds and sovereignty: the use and control of plant genetic resources. Duke University Press, Durham
30. Gray K (1991) Property in thin air. Cambridge L J 50:253–256
31. Greenpeace Canada (2002) New report exposes multiple threats if GE wheat approved available online: http://www.greenpeace.ca/e/index.php
32. Grotius H (1925) De Jure Belli Ac Pacis Libre Tres, trans. by Kelsey FW (1964). Wildy, New York & Oceania
33. Hardin G (1993) The tragedy of the commons. In: Daly HE, Townsend KN (eds) Valuing the earth: economics, ecology, and ethics. The MIT Press, Cambridge, MA
34. Harris JW (2001) Property and justice. Oxford University Press, Oxford & New York
35. Heller M (1998) Tragedy of the anticommons: property in the transition from Marx to markets. Harv L Rev 11:621
36. Higgott R (1994) International political economy. In: Groom AJR, Light M (eds) Contemporary international relations: a guide to theory. Pinter Publishers, London & New York
37. Hughes J (1988) The philosophy of intellectual property. Geo L J 77:287
38. International Convention for the Protection of New Varieties of Plants (UPOV Convention) (1978) as amended in March 1991, and 1996, respectively. Online at: http://www/upov.int
39. Kelly D, Michelman F (1980) Are property and contract efficient? Hofstra L Rev 8:711
40. Kloppenburg JR, Kleinman DL (1988) Seeds of controversy: National property versus common heritage. In: Kloppenburg JR (ed) Seeds and sovereignty: the use and control of genetic resources. Duke University Press, Durham & London
41. KloppenburgJR (1988) First the seed: the political economy of plant biotechnology, 1492–2000. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge & New York
42. Kloppenburg J, Kleinman DL (1987) The plant germplasm controversy. BioScience 37(3):190–198
43. Knorr K (1973) Power and wealth: the political economy of international power. Basic Books, New York
44. Krasner SD (2000) State power and the structure of international trade. In: Friedman JA, Lake DA (eds) International political economy: perspectives on global power and wealth. Bedford/St. Martin’s, Boston & New York
45. Laslett P (ed) (1960) Two treatises of government: a critical edition. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
46. Lesser W (2000) Intellectual property rights under the convention on biological diversity. In: Santiello V, Evenson RE, Zilberman D, Carlson GA (eds) Agriculture and intellectual property rights: economic, institutional and implementation issues in Biotechnology. CABI, London
47. Locke J (2001) Two treatises of government. In: Pecora VP (ed) Nations and identities: classic readings. Blackwell, Malden, MA
48. Low A (2001) The third revolution: plant genetic resources in developing countries and China: global village or global pillage? In: Kinsler J et al (eds) International trade and business law annual. Cavendish, Newport, New South Wales
49. Mgbeoji I (2002) Patents and plant resources-related knowledge: towards a regime of communal patents for plant resources-related knowledge. In: Islam N et al. (eds) Environmental law in developing countries: selected issues. IUCN, Bonn, Germany
50. Mgbeoji I (2001) Patents and traditional knowledge of the uses of plants: Is a communal patent regime part of the solution to the scourge of bio piracy? Ind J Global Legal Stud 9:163–186
51. Morck R, Yeung B (2001) The economic determinants of innovation, Industry Canada Research Publications No.25
52. Moschini G (2003) Intellectual property rights and the World Trade Organization: retrospect and prospects. Working Paper 03-WP 334, also available online: CARD website: www.card.iastate.edu
53. Mossoff A (2003) What is property? Putting the pieces back together. Ariz L Rev 45:371
54. Murphy SD (2001) Biotechnology and international Law. Harv Int’l L J 42:47
55. Onwuekwe CB (2004) The commons concept and intellectual property rights regime: Whither plant genetic resources and traditional knowledge? Pierce 2(1) Law Review 65–90
56. Ostrom, E.(2004) Understanding Collective Action. In Ruth N. Meinzen-Dick and Monica Di Gregorio, Collective Action and Property Rights for Sustainable Development. brief 2.2020 Four service, No.11, Washington, D.C.: International Food Policy Research Institute.
57. Ostrom, E.(1999) Coping with Tragedies of the commons. Annual Review of Political Science 2,pp. 493–535
58. Peters PE (1987) Embedded systems and rooted models: the grazing lands of botswana and the commons Debate. In: MaCay BJ, Acheson JM (eds) The Question of the Commons: the Culture and Ecology of Communal Resources. The University of Arizona Press, Tucson, AZ
59. Phillips P (2001) Will biotechnology feed the sorld’s hungry? Int’l J 56(4):665–677
60. Phillips PWB, Khachatourians GG (2001) Approaches to and measurement of innovation. In: Phillips PWB, Khachatourians GG (eds) The Biotechnology revolution in global agriculture: invention, innovation and investment in the Canola sector. CABI, Oxon & New York
61. Pistorius R, van Wijk J (1999) The exploitation of plant genetic information: political strategies in crop development. CABI, Oxon & New York
62. Posey DA, Dutfield G (1996) Beyond intellectual property: toward traditional resource rights for indigenous peoples and local communities. IDRC, Ottawa
63. P.L. (Public Law) 91-577. 1970. Plant Variety Protection Act, 84 Stat. 1542–1559
64. RAFI (1996) Enclosures of the mind: intellectual monopolies. IDRC, Ottawa
65. Rhoades RE, Nazarea VD (1999) Local management of biodiversity in traditional agroecosystems. In: Collins WW, Qualset CO (eds) Biodiversity in agroecosystems. CRS Press, London & New York
66. Rose CM (1986) The comedy of the commons: customs, commerce, and inherently public property. U Chi L Rev 53:711
67. Scotchmer S (1991) Standing on the shoulders of giants: cumulative research and the patent law. J Econ Perspect 5:29
68. Sedjo RA (1988) Property rights and the protection of plant genetic resources. In: Kloppenburg JR (ed) Seeds and sovereignty: the use and control of plant genetic resources. Duke University Press, Durham & London
69. Shavell S, van Ypersele T (1998) Rewards versus intellectual property rights available online: http://www.law.harvard.edu/programs/olin_center/papers/pdf/246.pdf
70. Shaw MN (1997) International Law, 4th edn. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge & New York
71. Shiva V (1993) Monocultures of the mind: perspectives on biodiversity and Biotechnology. Zed Books, New Jersey
72. Shiva V (1997) Biopiracy: the plunder of nature and knowledge. Between the Lines, Toronto
73. Stenson AA, Gray TS (1999) The politics of genetic resource control. St. Martins Press, New York
74. Strange S (1994) States and markets, 2nd edn. Pinter, London & New York
75. Townsend R, Wilson J (1987) An economic view of the tragedy of the commons. In: McCay B, Acheson J (eds) The questions of the commons–the culture and ecology of communal resources. University of Arizona Press, USA
76. Trade Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPs). TRIPS Article 27.1 of the Agreement. Available online: http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/trips_e/t_agm0_e.htm
77. Tully J (1980) A discourse on property: John Locke and his adversaries. Cambridge University Press Cambridge & New York
78. UN General Assembly, Twenty-Eighth Session, Resolution 3129 XXVIII (1973) Cooperation in the field of the environment concerning natural resources shared by two or more States. Available online: http://www.un.org/documents/ga/res/28/ares28.htm
79. UNCLOS (with Annex V), Art. 137, concluded at Montego Bay, 10 December 1982, and entered into force on 16 November 1994. UN Doc. A/CONF.62/122; reprinted in (1982) 21 I.L.M. 1261
80. United Nations Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED) (1992) Rio de Janeiro
81. Utuama AA (1991) Customary Law and land use act. In: Osinbajo Y, Kalu AU (eds) Towards a restatement of Nigerian customary Laws. Federal Ministry of Justice, Lagos
82. Wallerstein I (1991) Geopolitics and geoculture: essays on the changing world–system. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge & New York
83. Wallerstein I (2000) The modern world–system. In: Garner R (ed) Social theory: continuity and confrontation –A reader. Broadview Press, Ontario
84. Wallerstein I (2001) The end of the world as we know it: social science for the twenty-first century. University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis
85. World Intellectual Property Office (WIPO) (1999) Report on fact-finding missions on intellectual property and traditional knowledge. available online: http://www.wipo.int/tk/en/tk/ffm/report/final/index.html
86. Zilberman D, Yarkin C, Heiman A (1998) Institutional change and Biotechnology in agriculture: implications for developing countries. In: Smale M (ed) Farmers, gene banks and crop breeding: economic analysis of diversity in wheat, maize, and rice. Kluwer Academic, Boston & London