Functional network architecture predicts psychologically mediated analgesia related to treatment in chronic knee pain patients

Journal of Neuroscience

Volumn 34, Issue 11, 2014, Pages 3924-3936

  Hashmi, Javeria Ali ^a,b   Kong, Jian ^a,b   Spaeth, Rosa ^a   Khan, Sheraz ^a,b,c   Kaptchuk, Ted J ^b   Gollub, Randy L ^a  

^a MASSACHUSETTS GENERAL HOSPITAL   (United States)

^b HARVARD MEDICAL SCHOOL   (United States)

^c MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY   (United States)

Author keywords

Brain network; Chronic pain; Placebo; Predictive analysis; Resting state; Synchronization

Indexed keywords

ACUPUNCTURE ANALGESIA; ADULT; ARTICLE; BRAIN REGION; CHRONIC PAIN; CLINICAL ARTICLE; CONTROLLED STUDY; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HUMAN; KNEE PAIN; MALE; MEMORY; MOTIVATION; PAIN ASSESSMENT; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHOLOGICAL ASPECT; QUESTIONNAIRE; RESTING STATE NETWORK;

BRAIN NETWORK; CHRONIC PAIN; PLACEBO; PREDICTIVE ANALYSIS; RESTING STATE; SYNCHRONIZATION;

ACUPUNCTURE ANALGESIA; ADAPTATION, PSYCHOLOGICAL; ARTHRALGIA; CHRONIC PAIN; CONDITIONING (PSYCHOLOGY); CONNECTOME; CORTICAL SYNCHRONIZATION; CUES; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; OSTEOARTHRITIS, KNEE; PLACEBO EFFECT; PREDICTIVE VALUE OF TESTS; REST;

EID: 84896801130     PISSN: 02706474     EISSN: 15292401     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1523/JNEUROSCI.3155-13.2014     Document Type: Article

References (76)

1. Baliki MN, Geha PY, Fields HL, Apkarian AV (2010) Predicting value of pain and analgesia: nucleus accumbens response to noxious stimuli changes in the presence of chronic pain. Neuron 66:149-160. CrossRef Medline
2. Bassett DS, Bullmore ET (2009) Human brain networks in health and disease. Curr Opin Neurol 22:340-347. CrossRef Medline
3. Beattie KA, Duryea J, Pui M, O'Neill J, Boulos P, Webber CE, Eckstein F, Adachi JD (2008) Minimum joint space width and tibial cartilage morphology in the knees of healthy individuals: a cross-sectional study. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 9:119. CrossRef Medline
4. Beckmann M, Johansen-Berg H, Rushworth MF (2009) Connectivity-based parcellation of human cingulate cortex and its relation to functional specialization. J Neurosci 29:1175-1190. CrossRef Medline
5. Benedetti F (2008) Mechanisms of placebo and placebo-related effects across diseases and treatments. Annu Rev Pharmacol Toxicol 48:33-60. CrossRef Medline
6. Benedetti F, Mayberg HS, Wager TD, Stohler CS, Zubieta JK (2005) Neurobiological mechanisms of the placebo effect. J Neurosci 25:10390-10402. CrossRef Medline
7. Biswal BB, Mennes M, Zuo XN, Gohel S, Kelly C, Smith SM, Beckmann CF, Adelstein JS, Buckner RL, Colcombe S, Dogonowski AM, Ernst M, Fair D, Hampson M, Hoptman MJ, Hyde JS, Kiviniemi VJ, Kötter R, Li SJ, Lin CP, et al. (2010) Toward discovery science of human brain function. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 107:4734-4739. CrossRef Medline
8. Brown MW, Aggleton JP (2001) Recognition memory: what are the roles of the perirhinal cortex and hippocampus? Nat Rev Neurosci 2:51-61. CrossRef Medline
9. Bullmore E, Sporns O (2009) Complex brain networks: graph theoretical analysis of structural and functional systems. Nat Rev Neurosci 10:186-198. CrossRef Medline
10. Bullmore E, Barnes A, Bassett DS, Fornito A, Kitzbichler M, Meunier D, Suckling J (2009) Generic aspects of complexity in brain imaging data and other biological systems. Neuroimage 47:1125-1134. CrossRef Medline
11. Colloca L, Benedetti F (2006) How prior experience shapes placebo analgesia. Pain 124:126-133. CrossRef Medline
12. Colloca L, Petrovic P, Wager TD, Ingvar M, Benedetti F (2010) How the number of learning trials affects placebo and nocebo responses. Pain 151: 430-439. CrossRef Medline
13. Colloca L, Klinger R, Flor H, Bingel U (2013) Placebo analgesia: psychological and neurobiological mechanisms. Pain 154:511-514. CrossRef Medline
14. Craggs JG, Price DD, Verne GN, Perlstein WM, Robinson MM (2007) Functional brain interactions that serve cognitive-affective processing during pain and placebo analgesia. Neuroimage 38:720-729. CrossRef Medline
15. Craggs JG, Price DD, Perlstein WM, Verne GN, Robinson ME (2008) The dynamic mechanisms of placebo induced analgesia: evidence of sustained and transient regional involvement. Pain 139:660-669. CrossRef Medline
16. Damasio AR (1996) The somatic marker hypothesis and the possible functions of the prefrontal cortex. Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 351: 1413-1420. CrossRef Medline
17. Douw L, Schoonheim MM, Landi D, van der Meer ML, Geurts JJ, Reijneveld JC, Klein M, Stam CJ (2011) Cognition is related to resting-state smallworld network topology: an magnetoencephalographic study. Neuroscience 175:169-177. CrossRef Medline
18. Egúiluz VM, Chialvo DR, Cecchi GA, Baliki M, Apkarian AV (2005) Scalefree brain functional networks. Phys Rev Lett 94:018102. CrossRef Medline
19. Eippert F, Bingel U, Schoell ED, Yacubian J, Klinger R, Lorenz J, Büchel C (2009) Activation of the opioidergic descending pain control system underlies placebo analgesia. Neuron 63:533-543. CrossRef Medline
20. Enck P, Bingel U, Schedlowski M, Rief W (2013) The placebo response in medicine: minimize, maximize or personalize? Nat Rev Drug Discov 12: 191-204. CrossRef Medline
21. Ginestet CE, Nichols TE, Bullmore ET, Simmons A (2011) Brain network analysis: separating cost from topology using cost-integration. PLoS One 6:e21570. CrossRef Medline
22. Glahn DC, Bearden CE, Caetano S, Fonseca M, Najt P, Hunter K, Pliszka SR, Olvera RL, Soares JC (2005) Declarative memory impairment in pediatric bipolar disorder. Bipolar Disord 7:546-554. CrossRef Medline
23. Gossec L, Hawker G, Davis AM, Maillefert JF, Lohmander LS, Altman R, Cibere J, Conaghan PG, Hochberg MC, Jordan JM, Katz JN, March L, Mahomed N, Pavelka K, Roos EM, Suarez-Almazor ME, Zanoli G, Dougados M (2007) OMERACT/OARSI initiative to define states of severity and indication for joint replacement in hip and knee osteoarthritis. J Rheumatol 34:1432-1435. Medline
24. Gracely RH, Dubner R (1987) Reliability and validity of verbal descriptor scales of painfulness. Pain 29:175-185. CrossRef Medline
25. Gracely RH, KwiloszDM (1988) The Descriptor Differential Scale: applying psychophysical principles to clinical pain assessment. Pain 35:279-288. CrossRef Medline
26. Hashmi JA, Davis KD (2008) Effect of static and dynamic heat pain stimulus profiles on the temporal dynamics and interdependence of pain qualities, intensity, and affect. J Neurophysiol 100:1706-1715. CrossRef Medline
27. Hashmi JA, Davis KD (2014) Deconstructing sex differences in pain sensitivity. Pain 155:10-13. CrossRef Medline
28. Hashmi JA, Baria AT, Baliki MN, Huang L, Schnitzer TJ, Apkarian AV (2012) Brain networks predicting placebo analgesia in a clinical trial for chronic back pain. Pain 153:2393-2402. CrossRef Medline
29. Hashmi JA, Baliki MN, Huang L, Baria AT, Torbey S, Hermann KM, Schnitzer TJ, Apkarian AV (2013) Shape shifting pain: chronification of back pain shifts brain representation from nociceptive to emotional circuits. Brain 136:2751-2768. CrossRef Medline
30. Hilz MJ, Devinsky O, Szczepanska H, Borod JC, Marthol H, Tutaj M (2006) Right ventromedial prefrontal lesions result in paradoxical cardiovascular activation with emotional stimuli. Brain 129:3343-3355. CrossRef Medline
31. Hipp JF, Engel AK, Siegel M (2011) Oscillatory synchronization in largescale cortical networks predicts perception. Neuron 69:387-396. CrossRef Medline
32. Hipp JF, Hawellek DJ, Corbetta M, Siegel M, Engel AK (2012) Large-scale cortical correlation structure of spontaneous oscillatory activity. Nat Neurosci 15:884-890. CrossRef Medline
33. Holtzheimer PE 3rd, Mayberg HS (2010) Deep brain stimulation for treatment-resistant depression. Am J Psychiatry 167:1437-1444. CrossRef Medline
34. Kelley JM, Lembo AJ, Ablon JS, Villanueva JJ, Conboy LA, Levy R, Marci CD, Kerr CE, Kirsch I, Jacobson EE, Riess H, Kaptchuk TJ (2009) Patient and practitioner influences on the placebo effect in irritable bowel syndrome. Psychosom Med 71:789-797. CrossRef Medline
35. Kellgren JH, Lawrence JS (1957) Radiological assessment of rheumatoid arthritis. Ann Rheum Dis 16:485-493. CrossRef Medline
36. Kong J, Fufa DT, Gerber AJ, Rosman IS, Vangel MG, Gracely RH, Gollub RL (2005) Psychophysical outcomes from a randomized pilot study of manual, electro, and sham acupuncture treatment on experimentally induced thermal pain. J Pain 6:55-64. CrossRef Medline
37. Kong J, Gollub RL, Rosman IS, Webb JM, Vangel MG, Kirsch I, Kaptchuk TJ (2006a) Brain activity associated with expectancy-enhanced placebo analgesia as measured by functional magnetic resonance imaging. J Neurosci 26:381-388. CrossRef Medline
38. Kong J, White NS, Kwong KK, Vangel MG, Rosman IS, Gracely RH, Gollub RL (2006b) Using fMRI to dissociate sensory encoding from cognitive evaluation of heat pain intensity. HumBrain Mapp 27:715-721. CrossRef Medline
39. Kong J, Gollub RL, Polich G, Kirsch I, Laviolette P, Vangel M, Rosen B, Kaptchuk TJ (2008) A functional magnetic resonance imaging study on the neural mechanisms of hyperalgesic nocebo effect. J Neurosci 28: 13354-13362. CrossRef Medline
40. Kong J, Kaptchuk TJ, Polich G, Kirsch I, Vangel M, Zyloney C, Rosen B, Gollub R (2009a) Expectancy and treatment interactions: a dissociation between acupuncture analgesia and expectancy evoked placebo analgesia. Neuroimage 45:940-949. CrossRef Medline
41. Kong J, Kaptchuk TJ, Polich G, Kirsch I, Vangel M, Zyloney C, Rosen B, Gollub RL (2009b) An fMRI study on the interaction and dissociation between expectation of pain relief and acupuncture treatment. Neuroimage 47:1066-1076. CrossRef Medline
42. Kong J, Jensen K, Loiotile R, Cheetham A, Wey HY, Tan Y, Rosen B, Smoller JW, Kaptchuk TJ, Gollub RL (2013) Functional connectivity of the frontoparietal network predicts cognitive modulation of pain. Pain 154:459-467. CrossRef Medline
43. Langer N, von Bastian CC, Wirz H, Oberauer K, Jäncke L (2013) The effects of working memory training on functional brain network efficiency. Cortex 49:2424-2438. CrossRef Medline
44. Latora V, Marchiori M (2001) Efficient behavior of small-world networks. Phys Rev Lett 87:198701. CrossRef Medline
45. Li A, Kaptchuk TJ (2011) The case of acupuncture for chronic low back pain: when efficacy and comparative effectiveness conflict. Spine 36:181-182. CrossRef Medline
46. Lim SL, O'Doherty JP, Rangel A (2013) Stimulus value signals in ventromedial PFC reflect the integration of attribute value signals computed in fusiform gyrus and posterior superior temporal gyrus. J Neurosci 33: 8729-8741. CrossRef Medline
47. Meissner K, Bingel U, Colloca L, Wager TD, Watson A, Flaten MA (2011) The placebo effect: advances from different methodological approaches. J Neurosci 31:16117-16124. CrossRef Medline
48. Miller EK, Buschman TJ (2013) Cortical circuits for the control of attention. Curr Opin Neurobiol 23:216-222. CrossRef Medline
49. Miller FG, Colloca L, Kaptchuk TJ (2009) The placebo effect: illness and interpersonal healing. Perspect Biol Med 52:518-539. CrossRef Medline
50. Peat G, McCarney R, Croft P (2001) Knee pain and osteoarthritis in older adults: a review of community burden and current use of primary health care. Ann Rheum Dis 60:91-97. CrossRef Medline
51. Petrovic P, Dietrich T, Fransson P, Andersson J, Carlsson K, Ingvar M (2005) Placebo in emotional processing-induced expectations of anxiety relief activate a generalized modulatory network. Neuron 46:957-969. CrossRef Medline
52. Petrovic P, Kalso E, Petersson KM, Andersson J, Fransson P, Ingvar M (2010) Aprefrontal nonopioid mechanism in placebo analgesia. Pain 150:59-65. CrossRef Medline
53. Price DD, Craggs J, Verne GN, Perlstein WM, RobinsonME (2007) Placebo analgesia is accompanied by large reductions in pain-related brain activity in irritable bowel syndrome patients. Pain 127:63-72. CrossRef Medline
54. Price DD, Finniss DG, Benedetti F (2008) A comprehensive review of the placebo effect: recent advances and current thought. Annu Rev Psychol 59:565-590. CrossRef Medline
55. Roy M, Shohamy D, WagerTD (2012) Ventromedial prefrontal-subcortical systems and the generation of affective meaning. Trends Cogn Sci 16:147-156. CrossRef Medline
56. Rubinov M, Sporns O (2010) Complex network measures of brain connectivity: uses and interpretations. Neuroimage 52:1059-1069. CrossRef Medline
57. Scott DJ, Stohler CS, Egnatuk CM, Wang H, Koeppe RA, Zubieta JK (2007) Individual differences in reward responding explain placebo-induced expectations and effects. Neuron 55:325-336. CrossRef Medline
58. Scott DJ, Stohler CS, Egnatuk CM, Wang H, Koeppe RA, Zubieta JK (2008) Placebo and nocebo effects are defined by opposite opioid and dopaminergic responses. Arch Gen Psychiatry 65:220-231. CrossRef Medline
59. Sporns O, Tononi G, Edelman GM (2000a) Connectivity and complexity: the relationship between neuroanatomy and brain dynamics. Neural Netw 13:909-922. CrossRef Medline
60. Sporns O, Tononi G, Edelman GM (2000b) Theoretical neuroanatomy: relating anatomical and functional connectivity in graphs and cortical connection matrices. Cereb Cortex 10:127-141. CrossRef Medline
61. Stam CJ, Reijneveld JC (2007) Graph theoretical analysis of complex networks in the brain. Nonlinear Biomed Phys 1:3. CrossRef Medline
62. Stevens AA, Tappon SC, Garg A, Fair DA (2012) Functional brain network modularity captures inter-and intra-individual variation in working memory capacity. PLoS One 7:e30468. CrossRef Medline
63. Streitberger K, Kleinhenz J (1998) Introducing a placebo needle into acupuncture research. Lancet 352:364-365. CrossRef Medline
64. Tian L, Wang J, Yan C, He Y (2011) Hemisphere-and gender-related differences in small-world brain networks: a resting-state functional MRI study. Neuroimage 54:191-202. CrossRef Medline
65. van den Heuvel MP, Stam CJ, Kahn RS, Hulshoff Pol HE (2009) Efficiency of functional brain networks and intellectual performance. J Neurosci 29:7619-7624. CrossRef Medline
66. van der Kouwe AJ, Benner T, Salat DH, Fischl B (2008) Brain morphometry with multiecho MPRAGE. Neuroimage 40:559-569. CrossRef Medline
67. van Wijk BC, Stam CJ, Daffertshofer A (2010) Comparing brain networks of different size and connectivity density using graph theory. PLoS One 5:e13701. CrossRef Medline
68. Wager TD, Rilling JK, Smith EE, Sokolik A, Casey KL, Davidson RJ, Kosslyn SM, Rose RM, Cohen JD (2004) Placebo-induced changes in FMRI in the anticipation and experience of pain. Science 303:1162-1167. CrossRef Medline
69. Wager TD, Atlas LY, Leotti LA, Rilling JK (2011) Predicting individual differences in placebo analgesia: contributions of brain activity during anticipation and pain experience. J Neurosci 31:439-452. CrossRef Medline
70. Watson A, El-Deredy W, Iannetti GD, Lloyd D, Tracey I, Vogt BA, Nadeau V, Jones AK (2009) Placebo conditioning and placebo analgesia modulate a common brain network during pain anticipation and perception. Pain 145:24-30. CrossRef Medline
71. Watts DJ, Strogatz SH (1998) Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks. Nature 393:440-442. CrossRef Medline
72. Winecoff A, Clithero JA, Carter RM, Bergman SR, Wang L, Huettel SA (2013) Ventromedial prefrontal cortex encodes emotional value. J Neurosci 33:11032-11039. CrossRef Medline
73. Xia M, Wang J, He Y (2013) BrainNet Viewer: a network visualization tool for human brain connectomics. PLoS One 8:e68910. CrossRef Medline
74. Zhu D, Gao Y, Chang J, Kong J (2013) Placebo acupuncture devices: considerations for acupuncture research. Evid Based Complement Alternat Med 2013:628907. CrossRef Medline
75. Zubieta JK, Bueller JA, Jackson LR, Scott DJ, Xu Y, Koeppe RA, Nichols TE, Stohler CS (2005) Placebo effects mediated by endogenous opioid activity on mu-opioid receptors. J Neurosci 25:7754-7762. CrossRef Medline
76. Zubieta JK, Yau WY, Scott DJ, Stohler CS (2006) Belief or Need? Accounting for individual variations in the neurochemistry of the placebo effect. Brain Behav Immun 20:15-26. CrossRef Medline