Efficacy of psychological treatment for headaches: An overview of systematic reviews and analysis of potential modifiers of treatment efficacy

Clinical Journal of Pain

Volumn 30, Issue 4, 2014, Pages 353-369

  Huguet, Anna ^a   McGrath, Patrick J ^a,b   Stinson, Jennifer ^d   Tougas, Michelle E ^a,b   Doucette, Steve ^c  

^a IWK HEALTH CENTRE   (Canada)

^b DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

^c Research Methods Unit Capital Health   (United States)

^d HOSPITAL FOR SICK CHILDREN   (Canada)

Author keywords

efficacy; headache; psychological treatment; quality assessment; systematic review of meta analysis

Indexed keywords

AUTOGENIC TRAINING; CLINICAL EFFECTIVENESS; CLINICAL PRACTICE; COCHRANE LIBRARY; COGNITIVE THERAPY; EMBASE; FEEDBACK SYSTEM; HEADACHE; HOME CARE; HUMAN; MEDLINE; META ANALYSIS (TOPIC); MIGRAINE; MUSCLE RELAXATION; PHARMACEUTICAL CARE; PHYSIOTHERAPY; PRIORITY JOURNAL; PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENT; PSYCHOTHERAPY; PSYCINFO; QUALITY CONTROL; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED TRIAL (TOPIC); REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW; SYSTEMATIC REVIEW (TOPIC); TENSION HEADACHE; THERAPY EFFECT; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

DATABASES, FACTUAL; HEADACHE; HUMANS; PSYCHOTHERAPY;

EID: 84896394966     PISSN: 07498047     EISSN: 15365409     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1097/AJP.0b013e318298dd8b     Document Type: Review

References (107)

1. Stovner LJ, Hagen K, Jensen R, et al. The global burden of headache: a documentation of headache prevalence and disability worldwide. Cephalalgia. 2007;27:193-210.
2. Edmeads J, Findlay H, Tugwell P, et al. Impact of migraine and tension-type headache on life-style, consulting behaviour, and medication use: a Canadian population survey. Can J Neurol Sci. 1993;20:131-137.
3. Powers SW, Gilman DK, Hershey AD. Headache and psychological functioning in children and adolescents. Headache. 2006;46:1404-1415.
4. World Health Organization. The World Health Report 2001. Geneva: WHO; 2001.
5. Mennini FS, Gitto L, Martelletti P. Improving care through health economics analyses: cost of illness and headache. J Headache Pain. 2008;9:199-206.
6. Munakata J, Hazard E, Serrano D, et al. Economic burden of transformed migraine: results from the American Migraine Prevalence and Prevention (AMPP) Study. Headache. 2009;49:498-508.
7. Jensen R, Olesen J. Tension-type headache: an update on mechanisms and treatment. Curr Opin Neurol. 2000;13: 285-289.
8. Appelbaum KA, Blanchard EB, Nicholson NL, et al. Controlled evaluation of the addition of cognitive strategies to a home-based relaxation protocol for tension headache. Behav Ther. 1990;21:293-303.
9. Fichtel A, Larsson B. Does relaxation treatment have differential effects on migraine and tension-type headache in adolescents? Headache. 2001;41:290-296.
10. Labbe EE. Treatment of childhood migraine with autogenic training and skin temperature biofeedback: a component analysis. Headache. 1995;35:10-13.
11. Chambless DL, Ollendick TH. Empirically supported psychological interventions: controversies and evidence. Annu Rev Psychol. 2001;52:685-716.
12. Nestoriuc Y, Martin A. Efficacy of biofeedback of migraine: a meta-analysis. Pain. 2007;128:111-127.
13. Nestoriuc Y, Martin A, Rief W, et al. Biofeedback treatment for headache disorders: a comprehensive efficacy review. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2008;33:125-140.
14. Trautmann E, Lackschewitz H, Kroner-Herwig B. Psychological treatment of recurrent headache in children and adolescents-a meta-analysis. Cephalalgia. 2006;26: 1411-1426.
15. Boynton J, Glanville J, McDaid D, et al. Identifying systematic reviews in MEDLINE: developing an objective approach to search strategy. J Inf Sci. 1998;24:137-157.
16. White VJ, Glanville JM, Lefebvre C, et al. A statistical approach to designing search filters to find systematic reviews: objectivity enhances accuracy. J Inf Sci. 2001;27: 357-370.
17. Kung J, Chiappelli F, Cajulis OO, et al. From systematic reviews to clinical recommendations for evidence-based health care: validation of Revised Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews (R-AMSTAR) for grading of clinical relevance. Open Dent J. 2010;4:84-91.
18. Ramchandani M, Siddiqui M, Kanwar R, et al. Proteomic signature of periodontal disease in pregnancy: predictive validity for adverse outcomes. Bioinformation. 2011;5:300-303.
19. Shea BJ, Hamel C, Wells GA, et al. AMSTAR is a reliable and valid measurement tool to assess the methodological quality of systematic reviews. J Clin Epidemiol. 2009;62: 1013-1020.
20. Liberati A, Altman DG, Tetzlaff J, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions: explanation and elaboration. J Clin Epidemiol. 2009;62:e1-e34.
21. Weir CR, Staggers N, Laukert T. Reviewing the impact of computerized provider order entry on clinical outcomes: the quality of systematic reviews. Int J Med inform. 2012;81: 219-231.
22. Matheson SL, Shepherd AM, Laurens KR, et al. A systematic meta-review grading the evidence for non-genetic risk factors and putative antecedents of schizophrenia. Schizophr Res. 2011;133:133-142
23. Headache Classification Committee of the International Headache Society. Classification and diagnostic criteria for headache disorders, cranial neuralgias and facial pain. Cephalalgia. 1988;8:1-96
24. Ad hoc committee on Classification of Headache. Classification of headache. JAMA. 1962;179:717-718.
25. Damen L, Bruijn J, Koes BW, et al. Prophylactic treatment of migraine in children. Part 1. A systematic review non-pharmacological trials. Cephalalgia. 2006;26:373-383.
26. Eccleston C, Palermo TM, Williams ACDC, et al. Psychological therapies for the management of chronic and recurrent pain in children and adolescents (Review). Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2009;2CD003968.
27. Haddock CK, Rowan AB, Andrasik F, et al. Home-based behavioral treatments for chronic benign headache: a meta-analysis trials. Cephalalgia. 1997;17:113-118.
28. Stetter F, Kupper S. Autogenic training: a meta-analysis of clinical outcome studies. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2002;27:45-98.
29. Nestoriuc Y, Rief W, Martin A. Meta-analysis of biofeed-back for tension-type headache: efficacy, specificity, and treatment moderators. J Consult Clin Psychol. 2008;76: 379-396.
30. Hermann C, Kim M, Blanchard EB. Behavioral and prophylactic pharmacological intervention studies of pedia-tric migraine: an exploratory meta-analysis. Pain. 1995;60: 239-256.
31. Hyman RB, Feldman HR, Harris RB, et al. The effects of relaxation training on clinical symptoms: a meta-analysis. Nurs Res. 1989;38:216-220.
32. Linden W. Autogenic training: a narrative and quantitative review of clinical outcome. Biofeedback Self Regul. 1994;119: 227-264.
33. Stetter F, Kupper S. Autogenic training-qualitiative meta-analysis of controlled clinical studies an relation to naturo-pathy. Forsch Komplementmed. 1998;5:211-223.
34. Miller RC, Berman JS. The efficacy of cognitive behavior therapies: a quantitative review of the research evidence. Psychol Bull. 1983;94:34-53.
35. Olivares Rodriguez J, Alcazar AIR, Sanchez Meca J, et al. Treatment of headaches: a meta-analytic review of behavioral interventions in Spain. Psicologia Conductual. 1999;7:85-105.
36. Jakle C, Basler HD. Change of cognition in psychological pain therapy: a meta-analysis of the cognitive-behavioral model. Z Klin Psychol Psychother. 2000;29:127-139.
37. Palermo TM, Eccleston C, Lewandowski AS, et al. Randomized controlled trials of psychological therapies for management of chronic pain in children and adolescents: an updated meta-analytic review. Pain. 2010;148:387-397.
38. Weisz JR, Weiss B, Han SS. Effects of psychotherapy with children and adolescents revisited-a meta-analysis of treatment outcome studies. Psychol Bull. 1995;117:450-468.
39. Gould RA, Clum GA. A meta-analysis of self-help treatment approaches. Clin Psychol Rev. 1993;13:169-186.
40. Moher D, Schulz KR, Altman DG. The CONSORT statement: revised recommendations for improving the quality of reports of parallel-group randomized trials. Ann Intern Med. 2001;134:637-662.
41. Moher D, Hopewell S, Schulz KT, et al. CONSORT 2010 explanation and elaboration: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomized trials. J Clin Epidemiol. 2010; 63:e1-e37.
42. Stewart-Williams S, Podd J. The placebo effect: dissolving the expectancy versus conditioning debate. Psychol Bull. 2004; 130:324-340.
43. Cox DJ, Freundlich A, Meyer R. Differential effectiveness of electromyography feedback, verbal relaxation instructions, and medication placebo with tension headaches. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1975;43:892-898.
44. Williamson DA, Monguillot JE, Jarell MP, et al. Relaxation for the treatment of headache: controlled evaluation of two group programs. Behav Modif. 1984;8:407-424.
45. Larsson B, Daleflod B, Hakansson L, et al. Therapist-assisted versus self-help relaxation treatment of chronic headaches in adolescents: a school-based intervention. J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 1987;28:127-136.
46. Larsson B, Melin L, Lamminen M, et al. A school-based treatment of chronic headaches in adolescents. J Pediatr Psychol. 1987;12:553-566.
47. Engel JM, Rapoff MA. A component analysis of relaxation training for children with vascular, muscle contraction, and mixed-headache disorders. In: Tyler DC, Krane EJ, eds. Advances in Pain Research and Therapy: Paediatric Pain. New York: Raven Press; 1990:273-290.
48. Kroner-Herwig B, Mohn U, Pothmann R. Comparison of biofeedback and relaxation in the treatment of pediatric headache and the influence of parent involvement on outcome. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 1998;23: 143-157.
49. Trautmann E, Kroner-Herwig B. A randomized controlled trial of Internet-based self-help training for recurrent headache in childhood and adolescence. Behav Res Ther. 2010;48: 28-37.
50. Bromberg J, Wood ME, Black RA, et al. randomized trial of a web-based intervention to improve migraine self-management and coping. Headache. 2012;52:244-261.
51. Nicholson R, Nash J, Andrasik F. A self-administered behavioral intervention using tailored messages for migraine. Headache. 2005;45:1124-1139.
52. Larsson B, Melin L, Doberl A. Recurrent tension headache in adolescents treated with self-help relaxation training and a muscle relaxant drug. Headache. 1990;30:665-671.
53. Macea DD, Gajos K, Daglia Calil YA, et al. The efficacy of web-based cognitive behavioral interventions for chronic pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Pain. 2010;11: 917-929.
54. Hedborg K, Muhr C. Multimodal behavioral treatment of migraine: an internet-administered, randomized, controlled trial. Ups J Med Sci. 2011;116:169-186.
55. Hedborg K, Muhr C. The influence of multimodal behavioral treatment on the consumption of acute migraine drugs: a randomized, controlled study. Cephalalgia. 2012;32:297-307.
56. Penzien DB, Andrasik F, Freidenberg BM, et al. American Headache Society Behavioral Clinical Trials Workgroup. Guidelines for trials of behavioral treatments for recurrent headache, first edition: American Headache Society Behavioral Clinical Trials Workgroup. Headache. 2005;45(suppl 2):S110-S132.
57. McCrory DC, Gray RN, Tfelt-Hansen P, et al. Methodological issues in systematic reviews of headache trials: adapting historical diagnostic classifications and outcome measures to present-day standards. Headache. 2005;45:459-465.
58. Coyne JC, Thombs BD, Hagedoorn M. Ain't necessarily so: review and critique of recent meta-analyses of behavioral medicine interventions in health psychology. Health Psychol. 2010;29:107-116.
59. Nicolucci A, Togoni G. Should we trust results of meta-analyses? Lancet. 2004;9443:1401.
60. Schulz KF, Altman DG, Moher D, For the CONSORT Group. CONSORT 2010 statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomized trials. Ann Intern Med. 2010;152:726-732.
61. Guyatt G, Oxman AD, Akl EA, et al. GRADE guidelines: 1. Introduction-GRADE evidence profiles and summary of findings tables. J Clin Epidemiol. 2011;64:383-394.
62. Biondi-Zoccai GG, Lotrionte M, Abbate A, et al. Compliance with QUOROM and quality of reporting of overlapping meta-analyses on the role of acetylcysteine in the prevention of contrast associated nephropathy: case study. BMJ. 2006;332:202-209.
63. Shea B, Boers M, Grimshaw JM, et al. Does updating improve the methodological and reporting quality of systematic reviews? BMC Med Res Methodol. 2006;6:27.
64. Olivo SA, Macedo LG, Gadotti IC, et al. Scales to assess the quality of randomized controlled trials: a systematic review. Phys Ther. 2008;88:156-175.
65. Allen KD, Shriver MD. Role of parent-mediated pain behavior management strategies in biofeedback treatment of childhood migraines. Behav Ther. 1998;29:477-490.
66. Guarnieri P, Blanchard EB. Evaluation of home-based thermal biofeedback treatment of pediatric migraine headache. Biofeedback Self Regul. 1990;15:179-184.
67. Scharff L, Marcus DA, Masek BJ. A controlled study of minimal-contact thermal biofeedback treatment in children with migraine. J Pediatr Psychol. 2002;27:109-119.
68. Labbe EE, Williamson DA. Treatment of childhood migraine using autogenic feedback training. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1984;52:968-976.
69. Fentress DW, Masek BJ, Mehegan JE, et al. Biofeedback and relaxation response training in the treatment of pediatric migraine. Dev Med Child Neuroi. 1986;8:139-146.
70. Osterhaus SO, Passchier J, van der Helm-Hylkema H, et al. Effects of behavioral psychophysiological treatment on schoolchildren with migraine in a nonclinical setting: predictors and process variables. J Pediatr Psychol. 1993;18:697-715.
71. McGrath PJ, Humphreys P, Keene D, et al. The efficacy and efficiency of a self-administered treatment for adolescent migraine. Pain. 1992;49:321-324.
72. Hicks CL, von Baeyer CL, McGrath PJ. Online psychological treatment for pediatric recurrent pain: a randomized evaluation. J Pediatr Psychol. 2006;31:724-736.
73. Barry J, von Baeyer CL. Brief cognitive-behavioral group treatment for children's headache. Clin J Pain. 1997;13: 215-220.
74. Connelly M, Rapoff MA, Thompson N, et al. Headstrong: a pilot study of a CD-ROM intervention for recurrent pediatric headache. J Pediatr Psychol. 2006;31:737-747.
75. Griffiths JD, Martin PR. Clinical versus home-based treatment formats for children with chronic headache. Br J Health Psychol. 1996;1:151-166.
76. Kroener-Herwig B, Denecke H. Cognitive-behavioral therapy of pediatric headache: are there differences in efficacy between a therapist-administered group training and a self-help format? J Psychosom Res. 2002;53:1107-1114.
77. Larsson B, Carlsson J. A school-based, nurse-administered relaxation training for children with chronic tension-type headache. J Pediatr Psychol. 1996;21:603-614.
78. Larsson B, Melin L, Doberl A. Recurrent tension headache in adolescents treated with self-help relaxation training and a muscle relaxant drug. Headache. 1990;30:665-671.
79. Osterhaus SOL, Lange A, WHJP Linssen, et al. A behavioral treatment of young migrainous and nonmigrainous headache patients: prediction of treatment success. Int J Behav Med. 1997;4:378-396.
80. Sartory G, Muller B, Metsch J, et al. A comparison of psychological and pharmacological treatment of pediatric migraine. Behav Res Ther. 1998;36:1155-1170.
81. Bussone G, Grazzi L, D'Amico D, et al. Biofeedback-assisted relaxation training for young adolescents with tension-type headache: a controlled study. Cephalalgia. 1988;18:463-467.
82. Blanchard EB, Appelbaum KA, Nicholson NL, et al. A controlled evaluation of the addition of cognitive therapy to a home-based biofeedback and relaxation treatment of vascular headache. Headache. 1990;30:371-376.
83. Kohlenberg RJ, Cahn T. Self-help treatment for migraine headaches: a controlled outcome study. Headache. 1981;21: 196-200.
84. Larsson B, Melin L. The psychological treatment of recurrent headache in adolescents-short-term outcome and its prediction. Headache. 1988;28:187-195.
85. McGrath PJ, Humphreys P, Goodman JT, et al. Relaxation prophylaxis for childhood migraine: a randomized placebo-controlled trial. Dev Med Child Neurol. 1988;30:626-631.
86. Richter IL, McGrath PJ, Humphreys PJ, et al. Cognitive and relaxation treatment of paediatric migraine. Pain. 1986;25: 195-203.
87. Wisniewski JJ, Genshaft JL, Mulick JA, et al. Relaxation therapy and compliance in the treatment of adolescent headache. Headache. 1988;28:612-617.
88. Basler HD, JakIe C, Kroner-Herwig B. Cognitive-behavioral therapy for chronic headache at German pain centers. Psychiatr Rehabil J. 1996;2:235-252.
89. Holroyd KA, Nash JM, Pingel JD, et al. A comparison of pharmacological (amitriptyline HCL) and nonpharmacolog-ical (cognitive behavioral) therapies for chronic tension headaches. J Consult Clin Psychol. 1991;59:387-393.
90. James LD, Thorn BE, Williams DA. Goal specification in cognitive-behavioral therapy for chronic headache pain. Behav Ther. 1993;24:305-320.
91. Newton CR, Barbaree HE. Cognitive changes accompanying headache treatment: the use of a thought sampling procedure. Cognit Ther Res. 1987;11:635-651.
92. Janssen K, Neutgens J. Autogenic training and progressive relaxation in the treatment of three kinds of headache. Behav Res Ther. 1986;24:199-208.
93. Sargent J, Solbach P, Coyne L, et al. Results of a controlled, experimental, outcome study of nondrug treatments for the control of migraine headaches. J Behav Med. 1986;9: 291-323.
94. Spinhoven P, Linssen ACG, van Dyck R, et al. Autogenic training and self-hypnosis in the control of tension headache. Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 1992;14:408-415.
95. Zitman FG, van Dyc R, Spinhoven P, et al. Hypnosis and autogenic training in the treatment of tension headaches: a two-phase constructive design study with follow-up. J Psychosom Res. 1992;36:219-228.
96. Holroyd KA, Andrasik F, Westbrook T. Cognitive control of tension headache. Cognit Ther Res. 1977;1:121-133.
97. Lake A, Rainez J, Papsdorf JD. Biofeedback and rational-emotive therapy in the management of migraine headache. J Appl Behav Anal. 1979;12:127-140.
98. Cott A, Parkinson W, Fabich M, et al. Long-term efficacy of combined relaxation: biofeedback treatments for chronic headache. Pain. 1992;51:49-56.
99. Hutchings OF, Reinking RH. Tension headaches: what form of therapy is most effective? Biofeedback Self Regul. 1976;1:183-190.
100. Kroner B, HeiB M. Der Einsatz von Entspannungsverfahren bei chronischen Kopfschmerzen-Eine Studie'uber die M'oglichkeiten nichtmedikament oser Therapie [Effectiveness of relaxation techniques in the treatment of headaches- possibilities of non-medication therapy]. In: Huber MP, ed. Migr'ane [Migraine]. M'unchen: Urban & Schwarzenberg; 1982:154-175.
101. Reich BA. Non-invasive treatment of vascular and muscle contraction headache: a comparative longitudinal study. Headache. 1999;29:34-41.
102. Van Dyck R, Zitman FG, Linssen ACG, et al. Autogenic training and future oriented hypnotic imagery in the treatment of tension headache: outcome and process. Int J Clin Ex Hypn. 1991;39:6-23.
103. Ter Kuile MM, Spinhoven P, Linssen AC. Responders and nonresponders to autogenic training and cognitive self-hypnosis: prediction of short-and long-term success in tension-type headache patients. Headache. 1995;35: 630-636.
104. Collet L, Cottraux J, Juenet C. GSR feedback and Schultz's relaxation in tension headaches: a comparative study. Pain. 1986;25:205-213.
105. Kroner-Herwig B, Mohn U, Pothmann R. Comparison of biofeedback and relaxation in the treatment of paediatric headache and the influence of parent involvement on outcome. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 1998;23:143-157.
106. Siniatchkin M, Hierundar A, Kropp P, et al. Self-regulation of slow cortical potentials in children with migraine: an exploratory study. Appl Psychophysiol Biofeedback. 2000;25:13-32.
107. Larsson B, Melin L. Chronic headaches in adolescents: treatment in a school setting with relaxation training as compared with information-contact and self-registration. Pain. 1984;25:325-335.