Epistemological problems in cognitive archaeology: An anti-relativistic proposal towards methodological uniformity

Journal of Anthropological Sciences

Volumn 92, Issue , 2014, Pages 7-14

  Garofoli, Duilio ^a   Haidle, Miriam Noël ^a,b  

^a UNIVERSITY OF TÜBINGEN   (Germany)

^b HEIDELBERG ACADEMY OF SCIENCES AND HUMANITIES   (Germany)

Author keywords

Cognitive archaeology; Epistemology; Incommensurability; Theoretical mapping

Indexed keywords

ARCHEOLOGY; BEHAVIOR; BIOLOGICAL MODEL; EVOLUTION; HUMAN; HUMAN CHARACTERISTIC; KNOWLEDGE; PSYCHOLOGY;

ARCHAEOLOGY; BEHAVIOR; BIOLOGICAL EVOLUTION; COGNITIVE SCIENCE; HUMAN CHARACTERISTICS; HUMANS; KNOWLEDGE; MODELS, BIOLOGICAL;

EID: 84895087829     PISSN: 18274765     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.4436/JASS.91003     Document Type: Article

References (138)

1. Baddeley A.D. & Hitch G.J. 1974. Working memory. In G.A. Bower (eds): Recent Advances in Learning and Motivation, pp. 47-90. Academic Press, New York.
2. Baddeley A.D. & Logie R.H. 1999. Working memory: the multiple-component model. In A. Miyake & P. Shah (eds): Models of Working Memory: Mechanisms of Active Maintenance and Executive Control, pp. 28-61. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
3. Baddeley A.D. 2000. The episodic buffer: a new component of working memory? Trends Cog. Sci., 4: 417-423.
4. Baddeley A.D. 2001. Is working memory still working? Am. Psychol., 11: 851-864.
5. Baddeley A. 2003. Working memory: looking back and looking forward. Nat. Rev. Neurosci., 4: 829-839.
6. Barnard P., May J., Duke D. & Duce D. 2000. Systems, interactions and Macro-theory. ACM T. Comput. Hum. Int., 7: 222-262.
7. Barnard P., Duke D., Byrne R. & Davidson I. 2007. Differentiation in cognitive and emotional meanings: an evolutionary analysis. Cognition Emotion, 21: 1155-1183.
8. Barnard P.J. 2010a. From Executive Mechanisms Underlying Perception and Action to the Parallel Processing of Meaning. Curr. Anthropol., 51: S39-53.
9. Barnard P.J. 2010b. Current developments in inferring cognitive capabilities from the archaeological traces left by stone tools. In A. Nowell & I. Davidson (eds): Stone Tools and the Evolution of Human Cognition, pp. 207-226. University Press of Colorado.
10. Barkow J., Cosmides L. & Tooby J. 1992 (eds). The Adapted Mind: Evolutionary Psychology and the Generation of Culture. Oxford University Press, Oxford & New York.
11. Bar-Yosef Mayer D., Vandermeersch B. & Bar-Yosef O. 2009. Shells and ochre in Middle Paleolithic Qafzeh Cave, Israel: indications for modern behavior. J. Hum. Evol., 56: 307-314.
12. Bell J.A. 1987. Reason vs. relativism: review of I. Hodder's Reading the past. Archaeological Review from Cambridge. 6: 75-86.
13. Bell J.A. 1991. Anarchy and archaeology. In R. W. Preucel (ed): Processual and postprocessual archaeologies: multiple ways of knowing the past, pp. 71-80. Southern Illinois University Press, Carbondale.
14. Bell J.A. 1994a. Interpretation and testability in theories about prehistoric thinking. In C. Renfrew (ed): The Ancient Mind: elements of cognitive archaeology, pp. 15-21. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
15. Bell J.A. 1994b. Reconstructing prehistory: scientific method and archaeology. Temple University Press, Philadelphia.
16. Bell J.A. 1998. Overcoming dogma in epistemology. Issues in integrative Studies, 16: 99-119.
17. Binford L. 1965. Archaeological systematics and the study of culture process. Am. Antiquity., 31: 203-210.
18. Binford L. 1987. Data, relativism and archaeological science. Man, 22: 391-404.
19. Bouzouggar A., Barton N., Vanhaeren M., d'Errico F., Collcutt S., Higham T., Hodge E., Parfitt S., Rhodes E., Schwenninger J.L., Stringer C., Turner E., Ward S., Moutmir A. & Stambouli A. 2007. 82,000-year-old shell beads from North Africa and implications for the origins of modern human behavior. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 104: 9964-9969.
20. Bruner E., Manzi G. & Arsuaga J.L. 2003. Encephalization and allometric trajectories in the genus Homo: Evidence from the Neandertal and modern lineages. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 100: 15335-15340.
21. Bruner E. 2004. Geometric morphometrics and paleoneurology: brain shape evolution in the genus Homo. J. Hum. Evol., 47: 279-303.
22. Bruner E. 2008. Comparing endocranial form and shape differences in modern humans and Neandertal: a geometric approach. PaleoAnthropology, 2008: 93-106.
23. Bruner E. 2010. Morphological Differences in the Parietal Lobes within the Human Genus: a Neurofunctional perspective. Curr. Anthropol., 51: S77-78.
24. Bruner E. 2011. The evolution of the parietal cortical areas in the human genus: between structure and cognition. In D. Broadfield, M. Yuan, K. Schick, & N. Toth (eds): The human brain evolving. Stone Age Institute, Bloomington, Indiana.
25. Bruner E., Martin-Loeches M., Burgualeta M. & Colom R. 2011. Midsagittal brain shape correlation with intelligence and cognitive performance. Intelligence, 39: 141-147.
26. Buss D.M. 2005. The Handbook of Evolutionary Psychology. Wiley Press, Hoboken, New Jersey.
27. Chalmers D.J. 1995. Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness. Journal of Consciousness Studies, 2: 200-219.
28. Chalmers D.J. 1996. The Conscious Mind: in search of a fundamental theory. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
29. Chase P.G. 1999. Symbolism as reference and symbolism as culture. In R.I.M. Dunbar, C. Knight & C. Power (eds): The Evolution of Culture: An Interdisciplinary View, pp. 34-99. Edinburgh University Press, Edinburgh.
30. Chase P.G. 2003. Comment on C.S. Henshilwood & C. Marean: The origin of modern behavior: a review and critique of models and test implications. Curr. Anthropol., 44: 637.
31. Chase P.G. 2006. The Emergence of Culture: The Evolution of a Uniquely Human Way of Life. Springer, New York.
32. Clark A. 2008. Supersizing the mind: Embodiment, action and cognitive extension. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
33. Conard N. 2008. A critical view of the evidence for a Southern African origin of behavioral modernity. S. Afr. Arch. Soc., 10: 175-179.
34. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2001. Executive functions of the frontal lobes and the evolutionary ascendancy of Homo sapiens. Camb. Archaeol. J., 11: 255-60.
35. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2004. A cognitive and neuropsychological perspective on the Chatelperronian. J. Anthropol. Res., 60: 55-70.
36. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2005. Working memory, its executive functions, and the emergence of modern thinking. Camb. Archaeol. J., 15: 5-26.
37. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2008. The role of episodic memory and autonoetic thought in the Upper Palaeolithic Life. PaleoAnthropology, 2008:212-217.
38. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2009. The rise of Homo sapiens. Wiley Blackwell, New Jersey.
39. Coolidge F.L. & Wynn T. 2011. Comment to C.S. Henshilwood & B. Dubreuil: The Still Bay and Howiesons Poort, 77-59 ka Symbolic Material Culture and the Evolution of the Mind during the African Middle Stone Age. Curr. Anthropol., 52: 361-400.
40. Davidson I. & Noble W. 1989. The archaeology of perception: traces of depiction and language. Curr. Anthropol., 30: 125-156.
41. Davidson I. & Noble W. 1993. Tools and Language in Human Evolution. In K. Gibson & T. Ingold (eds): Tools, Language and Cognition, pp: 363-388. Cambridge University Press, New York.
42. Davidson I. 2010. The archaeology of cognitive evolution. WIREs Cog. Sci., 1: 214-229.
43. Deacon T. 1997. The symbolic species. Norton & Company Inc., New York.
44. Deregowski J.B. 2002. Is symmetry of stone tools merely an epiphenomenon of similarity? Comment to T. Wynn.: Archaeology and cognitive evolution. Behav. Brain Sci., 25: 389-438.
45. d'Errico F., Zilhao J., Julien M., Baffier D. & Pelegrin J. 1998. Neanderthal acculturation in Western Europe? A critical review of the evidence and its interpretation. Curr. Anthropol., 39: 1-44.
46. d'Errico F. 2003. The invisible frontier. A multiple species model for the origin of behavioral modernity. Evol. Anthropol., 12: 188-202.
47. d'Errico F., Henshilwood C., Vanhaeren M., van Niekerke K. 2005. Nassarius kraussianus shell beads from Blombos Cave: evidence for symbolic behaviour in the Middle Stone Age. J. Hum. Evol., 48: 3-24.
48. d'Errico F. & Vanhaeren M. 2007. Evolution or revolution? New evidence for the origins of symbolic behavior in and out of Africa. In P. Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef & C. Stringer (eds): Rethinking the Human Revolution., pp. 275-286. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, Cambridge.
49. d'Errico F., Vanhaeren M. & Wadley L. 2008. Possible shell beads from the Middle Stone Age layers of Sibudu Cave, South Africa. J. Archaeol. Sci., 35: 2675-2685.
50. d' Errico F., Vanhaeren M., Barton N., Bouzouggar A. & Mienis H. et al. 2009. Additional evidence on the use of personal ornaments in the Middle Paleolithic of North Africa. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 106: 16051-16056.
51. d'Errico F. & Stringer C.B. 2011. Evolution, revolution or saltation scenario for the emergence of modern cultures? Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. B., 366: 1060-9.
52. Dubreuil B. 2011. The other middle-range theories: Mapping behaviour and the evolution of the mind. In C.S. Henshilwood & F. d'Errico (eds): Homo Symbolicus: The dawn of language, imagination and spirituality, xi, 237, pp. 185-204. John Benjamins Publishing Company, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
53. Fodor J.A. 1983. The Modularity of Mind: An Essay in Faculty Psychology. The MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
54. Gamble C. 1999. Paleolithic Societies of Europe. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge.
55. Gardner H. 1983. Frames of Mind: the theories of multiple intelligences. Basic books, New York.
56. Gärdenfors P. 2011. Comment to C.S. Henshilwood & B. Dubreuil: The Still Bay and Howiesons Poort, 77-59 ka Symbolic Material Culture and the Evolution of the Mind during the African Middle Stone Age. Curr. Anthropol., 52: 361-400.
57. Godfrey-Smith P. 2003. Theory and Reality: An Introduction to the Philosophy of Science. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois.
58. Gunz P., Neubauer S., Maureille B. & Hublin J.J. 2010. Brain development after birth differs between Neanderthals and modern humans. Curr. Biol., 20: R921-R922.
59. Haidle M.N. 2009. How to think a simple spear? In S. de Beaune, F.L. Coolidge & T. Wynn (eds): Cognitive archaeology and human evolution, pp. 57-73. Cambridge University Press, New York.
60. Haidle M.N. 2010. Working memory capacity and the evolution of modern cognitive capacities - implications from animal and early human tool use. Curr. Anthropol., 51: S149-S166.
61. Haidle M.N. 2012. How to think tools? A comparison of cognitive aspects in tool behavior of animals and during human evolution. Cognitive perspectives in tool behaviour Vol. 1. http://tobias-lib.uni-tuebingen.de/frontdoor.php?source_opus=6014.
62. Halford G.S., Cowan N. & Andrews G. 2007. Separating cognitive capacity from knowledge: a new hypothesis. Trends Cog. Sci., 11: 236-242.
63. Harrold F. 2009. Historical perspectives on the European transition from Middle to Upper Paleolithic. In M. Camps & P. Chauhan (eds): Sourcebook of Paleolithic Transitions, pp. 283-299. Springer, New York.
64. Henshilwood C.S. & Marean C. 2003. The origin of modern human behavior. Curr. Anthropol., 44: 627-651.
65. Henshilwood C.S. & Dubreuil B. 2011. The Still Bay and Howiesons Poort, 77-59 ka Symbolic Material Culture and the Evolution of the Mind during the African Middle Stone Age. Curr. Anthropol., 52: 361-400.
66. Hodder I. 1984. History vs science: no contest. Review of L.R. Binford (1983): In pursuit of the past (Thames and Hudson) and J.G.D Clark (1983): The identity of man (Methuen). Scot. Archaeol. Rev., 3: 66-68.
67. Hodder I. 1986. Reading the past. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
68. Hodder, I. 1987. Reply to Bell, J.A.: Reason vs. relativism: review of Ian Hodder's "Reading the past". Archaeological Review from Cambridge, 6: 75-86.
69. Holloway R.L. 1969. Culture: a human domain. Curr. Anthropol., 10: 395-412.
70. Hoopes J. 1991. Peirce on Signs. Writing on semiotics by Charles Sanders Peirce. The University of North Carolina Press, Chapel Hills, North Carolina.
71. Hovers E., Ilani S., Bar-Yosef O. & Vandermeersch B. 2003. An Early Case of Color Symbolism. Curr. Anthropol., 44: 491-522.
72. Hovers E. & Belfer-Cohen A. 2006. Now you see it, now you don't-modern human behavior in the Middle Paleolithic. In E. Hovers & S.L. Kuhn (eds): Transitions Before The Transition: Evolution and Stability in the Middle Paleolithic and Middle Stone Age, pp 205-304. Springer, New York.
73. Hume D. [1739] 1978. A Treatise of Human Nature. In L.A. Selby-Bigge & P.H. Nidditch. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
74. Johnson M. 1999. Archaeological Theory: An Introduction. Blackwell, Oxford.
75. Jung R.E. & Haier R.J. 2007. The parieto-frontal integration theory (P-FIT) of intelligence: converging neuroimaging evidence. Behav. Brain Sci., 30: 135-187.
76. Klein R.G. 1995. Anatomy, behavior, and modern human origins. J. World Prehist., 9: 167-198.
77. Klein R.G. 2000. Archaeology and the evolution of human behavior. Evol. Anthropol., 9: 17-36.
78. Klein R.G. 2001. Southern Africa and modern human origins. J. Anthropol. Res., 57: 1-16.
79. Klein R.G. 2003. Comment to E. Hovers, S. Ilani, O. Bar-Yosef & B. Vandermeersch: An Early Case of Color Symbolism. Curr. Anthropol., 44: 491-522.
80. Klein R.G. 2008. Out of Africa and the evolution of human behavior. Evol. Anthropol., 17: 267-281.
81. Kline M.A. & Boyd R. 2010. Population size predicts technological complexity in Oceania. Philos. Trans R. Soc. Lond. B, 277: 2559-2564.
82. Kohn M. & Mithen S. 1999. Handaxes: products of sexual selection? Antiquity, 73: 518-526.
83. Kuhn S. & Stiner M. 2007. Paleolithic ornaments: implications for cognition, demography and identity. Diogenes, 54: 40-48.
84. Lakoff G. & Johnson M. 1999. Philosophy in the flesh: the embodied mind and its challenge to western thought. Basic Books, New York.
85. Latour B. 1993. We Have Never Been Modern. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
86. Lieberman D.E., McBratney B.M & Krovitz G. 2002. The evolution and development of cranial form in Homo sapiens. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 99: 1134-1139.
87. Lombard M. & Haidle M.N. 2012. Thinking a bow-and-arrow: cognitive implications of Middle Stone Age bow and stone-tipped arrow technology. Camb. Archaeol. J., 22: 237-264.
88. Malafouris L. 2007. Before and beyond representation: towards an enactive conception of the Palaeolithic image. In C. Renfrew & I. Morley (eds): Image and Imagination: a Global History of Figurative Representation, pp. 289-302. McDonald Institute Monographs, Cambridge.
89. Malafouris L. 2008a. Between brains, bodies and things: tectonoetic awareness and the extended self. Philos. Trans R. Soc. Lond. B, 363: 1993-2002.
90. Malafouris L. 2008b. Beads for a Plastic Mind: The 'Blind Man's Stick' (BMS) hypothesis and the active nature of material culture. Camb. Archaeol. J., 18: 401-414.
91. Malafouris L. 2008c. At the Potter wheel. In C. Knappet & L. Malafouris (eds): Material agency, pp. 19-36. Springer editions, New York.
92. Malafouris L. 2010a. The brain-artefact interface (BAI): a challenge for archaeology and cultural neuroscience. Soc. Cogn. Affect. Neurosci., doi: 10.1093/scan/nsp057
93. Malafouris L. 2010b. Metaplasticity and the human becoming. Principles of Neuroarchaeology. J. Anthropol. Sci., 88: 49-72.
94. Marean C.W. 2007. Heading north: an Africanist perspective on the replacement of Neanderthals by modern humans. In P. Mellars, K. Boyle, O. Bar-Yosef & C. Stringer (eds): Rethinking the Human Revolution. pp. 367-79. McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research, Cambridge.
95. Marean C.W., Bar-Matthews M., Bernatchez J., Fisher E., Goldberg P., Herries A.I.R., Jacobs Z., Jerardino A., Karkanas P., Minichillo T., Nilssen P.J., Thompson E., Watts I. & Williams H.M. 2007. Early human use of marine resources and pigment in South Africa during the Middle Pleistocene. Nature, 449: 905-908.
96. Mitchell J.C. 1995. Studying biface butchery at Boxgrove: roe deer butchery with replica handaxes. Lithics, 16: 64-69.
97. Mithen S.J. 1996. The prehistory of the mind: a search for the origins of art, religion, and science. Thames and Hudson, London.
98. Mithen S.J. & Parsons L. 2008. The brain as a cultural artifact. Camb. Archaeol. J., 18: 415-422.
99. Neubauer S., Gunz P. & Hublin J.J. 2010. Endocranial shape changes during growth in chimpanzees and humans: a morphometric analysis of unique and shared aspects. J. Hum. Evol., 59: 555-56.
100. Newell, A. 1990. Unified theories of Cognition. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
101. Noble, W. & Davidson, I. 1991. The evolutionary emergence of modern human behavior: language and its archaeology. Man, 26: 223-53.
102. Nowell A. 2010. Defining Behavioral Modernity in the Context of Neandertal and Anatomically Modern Human Populations. Ann. Rev. Anthropol., 39: 437-452.
103. Nowell A. & Davidson I. 2010. Stone Tools and the evolution of human cognition. University Press of Colorado.
104. Peikoff L. 1981. May be you are wrong. The Objectivist Forum, 2: 8-12.
105. Pinker S. 1997. How the Mind Works. Norton, New York.
106. Platt J.R. 1964. Strong Inference. Science, 146: 347-353.
107. Plotkin H. 1997. Evolution in Mind. Alan Lane, London.
108. Powell A., Shennan S. & Thomas M.G. 2009. Late Pleistocene demography and the appearance of modern human behavior. Science, 324: 1298-1301
109. Preucel R. 2007. Archaeological Semiotics. Blackwell publishing, Malden, Massachusetts.
110. Rand A. 1964. The virtue of selfishness: a new concept of egoism, pp. 13-35. Signet, New York.
111. Rand A. 1967. Introduction to objectivist epistemology. The Objectivist, New York.
112. Read D. 2012. Population size does not predict artifact complexity: analysis of data from Tasmania, Arctic hunter-gatherers, and Oceania fishing groups. Retrieved from: http://www.escholarship.org/uc/item/61n4303q
113. Renfrew C. 1982. Towards an archaeology of mind, pp. 16-19. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
114. Renfrew C. 1989. Comments on archaeology into the 1990s. Nor. Archaeol. Rev., 22: 33-41.
115. Renfrew C. 1994. Towards a cognitive archaeology. In C. Renfrew (eds): The Ancient Mind: elements of cognitive archaeology, pp 3-12. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
116. Rilling J.K. & Seligman R. 2002. A quantitative morphometric comparative analysis of the primate temporal lobe. J. Hum. Evol., 42: 505-534.
117. Rossano M. 2010. Making Friends, making Tools and making Symbols. Curr. Anthropol., 51: S89-98.
118. Rossano M. 2011. Comment to Henshilwood, C.S. & Dubreuil, B.: The Still Bay and Howiesons Poort, 77-59 ka Symbolic Material Culture and the Evolution of the Mind during the African Middle Stone Age. Curr. Anthropol., 52: 361-400.
119. Samson R. 2006. Stones of contention: the Acheleuan handaxe lethal projectile controversy. Lithic Technol., 31: 127-135.
120. Searle J. 1997. The Mistery of Consciousness. New York review books, New York.
121. Searle J. 2004. Mind: a brief introduction. Oxford University Press, New York.
122. Semendeferi K. & Damasio H. 2000. The brain and its main anatomical subdivisions in living hominoids using magnetic resonance imaging. J. Hum. Evol., 38: 317-332.
123. Shanks M. & Tilley C. 1987a. Re-constructing archaeology. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
124. Shanks M. & Tilley C. 1987b. Social theory and archaeology. Cambridge Polity Press, Cambridge.
125. Shennan S. 2001. Demography and cultural innovation: a model and its implications for the emergence of modern human culture. Cambr. Archaeol. J., 11: 5-16.
126. Soffer O. 2009. Defining modernity, establishing rubicons, imagining the other-and the Neanderthal enigma. In M. Camps & P. Chauhan (eds): Sourcebook of Paleolithic Transitions, pp. 43-64. Springer, New York.
127. Trigger B.G. 2007. A History of Archaeological Thought (Second Edition). Cambridge University Press, New York.
128. Vanhaeren M., d'Errico F., Stringer C., James S.L., Todd J.A. & Mienis H.K. 2006. Middle Paleolithic shell beads in Israel and Algeria. Science, 12: 1785-1788.
129. Vanhaeren M. & d'Errico F. 2006. Aurignacian ethno-linguistic geography of Europe revealed by personal ornaments. J. Archaeol. Sci., 33: 1105-1128.
130. Wadley L. 2001. What is cultural modernity? A general view and a South African perspective from Rose Cottage Cave. Cambr. Archaeol. J., 11: 201-21.
131. Wadley L. 2010. Were snares and traps used in the Middle Stone Age and does it matter? A review and a case study from Sibudu, South Africa. J. Hum. Evol., 58: 179-192.
132. Walton D.N. 2001. Abductive, presumptive and plausible arguments. Informal Logic., 21: 141-169.
133. Wynn, T. 2002. Archaeology and cognitive evolution. Behav. Brain Sci., 25: 389-438.
134. Wynn T. & Coolidge F. 2004. The expert Neandertal mind. J. Hum. Evol., 46, 467-487.
135. Wynn T., Coolidge F. & Bright M. 2009. Hohlenstein-Stadel and the Evolution of Human Conceptual Thought. Camb. Archaeol. J., 19: 73-83.
136. Wynn T. & Coolidge F.L. 2011. The Implications of the Working Memory Model for the Evolution of Modern Cognition International. J. Evolution. Biol, Article ID. 741357.
137. Zilhao J. 2007. The emergence of ornaments and art: an archaeological perspective on the origins of behavioral modernity. J. Archaeol. Res., 15: 1-54.
138. Zilhão J., Angelucci D.E., Badal-García E., d'Errico F., Daniel F., Dayet L., Douka K., Higham T.F.G., Martínez-Sánchez M.J., Montes-Bernárdez R., Murcia-Mascarós S., Pérez-Sirvent C., Roldán-García C., Vanhaeren M., Villaverde V., Wood R. & Zapata J. 2010. Symbolic use of marine shells and mineral pigments by Iberian Neandertals. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 107: 1023-1028.