The economic costs of avoided deforestation in the developing world: A meta-analysis

Journal of Forest Economics

Volumn 20, Issue 1, 2014, Pages 1-16

  Dang Phan, Thu Ha ^a,b   Brouwer, Roy ^b   Davidson, Marc ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF AMSTERDAM   (Netherlands)

^b VU UNIVERSITY AMSTERDAM   (Netherlands)

Author keywords

Avoided deforestation; Carbon storage; Climate change mitigation; Meta analysis; Opportunity costs; RED

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL ROBOTS; CLIMATE CHANGE; COSTS; DEFORESTATION; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; DIGITAL STORAGE; ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; LAND USE;

CARBON ACCOUNTING; CARBON STORAGE; CLIMATE CHANGE MITIGATION; DEVELOPING WORLD; ESTIMATION METHODOLOGIES; FOREST PROTECTION; META ANALYSIS; OPPORTUNITY COSTS;

COST BENEFIT ANALYSIS;

CARBON SEQUESTRATION; CLIMATE CHANGE; COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS; DEFORESTATION; DEVELOPING WORLD; META-ANALYSIS; MITIGATION;

CARBON; COSTS; DEFORESTATION; DEVELOPING COUNTRIES; ECONOMIC ANALYSIS; SEASONAL VARIATION; STORAGE;

EID: 84893751865     PISSN: 11046899     EISSN: 16181530     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.jfe.2013.06.004     Document Type: Article

References (59)

1. Bellassen V., Gitz V. Reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation in Cameroon - assessing costs and benefits. Ecological Economics 2008, 68(1-2):336-344.
2. Blaser J., Robledo C. Initial analysis on the mitigation potential in the forestry sector. Prepared for the UNFCCC Secretariat 2007, At, (accessed 10.04.2012). https://unfccc.int/files/cooperation_and_support/financial_mechanism/application/pdf/blaser.pdf.
3. Boer R. Economic assessment of mitigation options for enhancing and maintaining carbon sink capacity in Indonesia. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 2001, 6(3):257-290.
4. Börner J., Wunder S. Paying for avoided deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon: from cost assessment to scheme design. International Forestry Review 2008, 10(3):496-511.
5. Boucher D. Out of the Woods: A Realistic Role for Tropical Forests in Curbing Global Warming. Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) 2008, UCS Publications, Cambridge, MA, At:, (accessed 10.04.2012). http://www.eanth.org/Policy/UCS-REDD-Boucherreport.pdf.
6. Brown D., Seymour F., Peskett L. Chapter 11 How do we achieve REDD co-benefits and avoid doing harmα. Moving Ahead with REDD: Issues, Options and Implications. 2008, CIFOR Bogor, Indonesia. A. Angelsen (Ed.).
7. Butler R.A., Koh L.P., Ghazoul J. REDD in the red: palm oil could undermine carbon payment schemes. Conservation Letters 2009, 2(2):67-73.
8. Chomitz K.M., Kumari K. The domestic benefits of tropical forests: a critical review. The World Bank Research Observer 1998, 13(1):13-35.
9. Coomes O., Grimardb F., Potvinc C., Simad P. The fate of the tropical forest: carbon or cattleα. Ecological Economics 2008, 65(2):207-212.
10. Diaz M.D.C., Schwartzman S. Carbon offsets and land use in the Brazilian Amazon. Tropical Deforestation and Climate Change. IPAM: Belem 2005, 13-21. Brazil and Environmental Defense, Washington, DC. P. Moutinho, S. Schwartzman (Eds.).
11. Ebeling J., Yasué M. Generating carbon finance through avoided deforestation and its potential to create climatic, conservation and human development benefits. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 2008, 363:1917-1924.
12. Eliasch J. Part I: The Challenge of Deforestation. Climate Change: Financing Global Forests 2008, The Eliasch Review, Earthscan, London.
13. FAO Global Forest Resources Assessment 2005 2005, FAO, Rome.
14. FAO Global Forest Resources Assessment 2010 2010, FAO, Rome.
15. Fisher B., Lewis S.L., Burgess N.D., Malimbwi R.E., Munishi P.K., Swetnam R.D., Turner R.K., Willcock S., Balmford A. Implementation and opportunity costs of reducing deforestation and forest degradation in Tanzania. Nature Climate Change 2011, 1(3):161-164.
16. Fisher B., Edwards D.P., Giam X., Wilcove D.S. The high costs of conserving Southeast Asia's lowland rainforests. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2011, 9(6):329-334.
17. Glass G.V., McGaw B., Smith M.L. Meta-Analysis in Social Research 1981, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills.
18. Grieg-Gran M. The cost of avoided deforestation as a climate change mitigation option. Avoided Deforestation. Prospects for Mitigating Climate Change 2009, 11-38. Routledge Explorations in Environmental Economics Series. C. Palmer, S. Engel (Eds.).
19. Hope C., Castilla-Rubio J.C. A First Cost Benefit Analysis of Action to Reduce Deforestation 2008, Judge Business School, University of Cambridge, New work Commissioned for the Eliasch Review.
20. Houghton R.A. Tropical deforestation as a source of greenhouse gas emissions. Tropical Deforestation and Climate Change 2005, 13-21. IPAM: Belem, Brazil and Environmental Defense, Washington, DC. P. Mountinho, S. Schwartzman (Eds.).
21. IPCC Land Use, Land-Use Change and Forestry 2000, 375. Cambridge University Press, UK. R.T. Watson, I.R. Noble, B. Bolin, N.H. Ravindranath, D.J. Verardo, D.J. Dokken (Eds.).
22. Irawan S., Tacconi L., Ring I. Stakeholders' Incentives for Land-use Change and REDD+: The Case of Indonesia. Working Paper #2, Asia Pacific Network for Environmental Governance 2011, The Australian National University.
23. Johnston R.J., Rosenberger R.S. Methods, trends and controversies in contemporary benefit transfer. Journal of Economic Surveys 2010, 24:479-510.
24. Kindermann G.E., Obersteiner M., Sohngen B., Sathaye J., Andrasko K., Rametsteiner E., Schlamadinger B., Wunder S., Beach R. Global cost estimates of reducing carbon emissions through avoided deforestation. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2008, 105:10302-10307.
25. Kirby K. Land-use change in the Neotropics: regional-scale predictors of deforestation and local effects on carbon storage and tree-species diversity. MSc thesis 2005, Department of Biology, Neotropical Environments Option, McGill University, Montreal.
26. Kremen C., Niles J.O., Dalton M.G., Daily G.C., Ehrlich P.R., Fay J.P., Grewal D., Guillery R.P. Economic Incentives for Rain Forest Conservation Across Scales. Science 2000, 288(5472):1828-1832.
27. Lasco R.D., Pulhin F.B. Climate change mitigation activities in the Philippine forestry sector: application of the COMAP Model. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 2001, 6(3):313-334.
28. Makundi W.R., Okiting'ati A. Carbon flows and economic evaluation of mitigation options in Tanzania's forest sector. Biomass and Bioenergy 1995, 8(5):381-393.
29. McCann L., Colby B., Easter K.W., Kasterine A., Kuperan K.V. Transaction cost measurement for evaluating environmental policies. Ecological Economics 2005, 52(4):527-542.
30. Nabuurs G.J., Masera O., Andrasko K., Benitez-Ponce P., Boer R., Dutschke M., Elsiddig E., Ford-Robertson J., Frumhoff P., Karjalainen T., Krankina O., Kurz W.A., Matsumoto M., Oyhantcabal W., Ravindranath N.H., Sanz Sanchez M.J., Zhang X. Forestry. Climate Change 2007: Mitigation. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change 2007, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York, NY, USA, (Chapter 9). B. Metz, O.R. Davidson, P.R. Bosch, R. Dave, L.A. Meyer (Eds.).
31. Nelson J., Kennedy P. The use (and abuse) of meta-analysis in environmental and natural resource economics: an assessment. Environmental and Resource Economics 2009, 42:345-377.
32. Nepstad D., Merry F., Rodrigues H.O., Schwartzman S., Almeida O. The Costs and Benefits of Reducing Carbon Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation in the Brazilian Amazon 2007, Woods Hole Research Center, Falmouth, MA, At, (accessed 10.04.12). http://www.whrc.org/policy/pdf/cop13/WHRC_Amazon_REDD.pdf.
33. Nepstad D., Soares-Filho B.S., Merry F., Lima A., Moutinho P., Carter J., Bowman M., Cattaneo A., Rodrigues H., Schwartzman S., McGrath D.G., Stickler C.M., Lubowski R., Piris-Cabezas P., Rivero S., Alencar A., Almeida O., Stella O. The end of deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon. Science 2009, 326(5958):1350-1351.
34. Osafo Y.B. Reducing emissions from tropical forest deforestation: applying compensated reduction in Ghana. Tropical Deforestation and Climate Change. IPAM: Belem 2005, 13-21. Brazil and Environmental Defense, Washington, DC. P. Moutinho, S. Schwartzman (Eds.).
35. Osborne T., Kiker C. Carbon offsets as an economic alternative to large-scale logging: a case study in Guyana. Ecological Economics 2005, 52(4):481-496.
36. Potvin C., Guay B., Pedroni L. Is reducing emissions from deforestation financially feasibleα A Panamanian case study. Climate Policy 2008, 8(1):23-40.
37. Ravindranath N.H., Sudha P., Rao S. Forestry for sustainable biomass production and carbon sequesteration in India. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global Change 2001, 6(3):233-256.
38. Richards K.R., Stokes C. A review of forest carbon sequestration cost studies: a dozen years of research. Climatic Change 2004, 63(1):1-48.
39. Ruslandi, Venter O., Putz F.E. Overestimating conservation costs in Southeast Asia. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 2011, 9(10):542-544.
40. Sathaye J., Andrasko K., Chan P. Emissions scenarios, costs, and implementation considerations of REDD-plus programs. Environment and Development Economics 2011, 16(special issue 04):361-380.
41. Sedjo R.A., Wisniewski J., Sample A.V., Kinsman J.D. The economics of managing carbon via forestry: assessment of existing studies. Environmental and Resource Economics 1995, 6(2):139-165.
42. Silva-Chávez G.A. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions from tropical deforestation by applying compensated reduction to Bolivia. Tropical Deforestation and Climate Change 2005, 13-21. IPAM: Belem, Brazil and Environmental Defense, Washington, DC. P. Moutinho, S. Schwartzman (Eds.).
43. Smith V.K., Pattanayak S. Is meta-analysis a noah's ark for non-market valuationα. Environmental and Resource Economics 2002, 22:271-296.
44. Sohngen B., Beach R.H., Andrasko K. Avoided deforestation as a greenhouse gas mitigation tool: economic issues. Journal of Environmental Quality 2008, 37(4):1368-1375.
45. Sohngen B. An analysis of forestry carbon sequestration as a response to climate change. Copenhagen Consensus on Climate 2009.
46. Stanley T.D. Wheat from chaff: meta-analysis as quantitative literature review. Journal of Economic Perspectives 2001, 15:131-150.
47. Stern N. Part VI: International Collective Action. The Economics of Climate Change 2006, The Stern Review Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
48. Stickler C., Nepstad D., Coe M., Macgrath D., Rodrigues H., Davidson E., Soares-Filho B. The potential ecological costs and co-benefits of REDD: a critical review and case study from the Amazon region. Global Change Biology 2009, 15:2803-2824.
49. Strassburg B., Turner R.K., Fisher B., Schaeffer R., Lovett A. Reducing emissions from deforestation - the combined incentives mechanism and empirical simulations. Global Environmental Change 2009, 19(2):265-278.
50. Strassburg B.B.N., Rodrigues A.S.L., Gusti M., Balmford A., Fritz S., Obersteiner M., Turner R.K., Brooks T.M. Impacts of incentives to reduce emissions from deforestation on global species extinctions. Nature Climate Change 2012, 2:350-355.
51. Tomich T.P., de Foresta H., Dennis R., Ketterings Q., Murdiyarso D., Palm C., Stolle F., Suyanto, van Noordwijk M. Carbon offsets for conservation and development in Indonesiaα. American Journal of Alternative Agriculture 2002, 17(03):125-137.
52. van Kooten G.C., Eagle A.J., Manley J., Smolak T. How costly are carbon offsetsα A meta-analysis of carbon forest sinks. Environmental Science & Policy 2004, 7(4):239-251.
53. van Kooten G.C., Laaksonen-Craig S., Wang Y. A meta-regression analysis of forest carbon offset costs. Canadian Journal of Forest Research 2009, 39(11):2153-2167.
54. Venter O., Meijaard E., Possingham H., Dennis R., Sheil D., Wich S., Hovani L., Wilson K. Carbon payments as a safeguard for threatened tropical mammals. Conservation Letters 2009, 2(3):123-129.
55. 2 response options in the forestry sector: the case of Thailand. Biomass and Bioenergy 1995, 8(5):293-307.
56. Wertz-Kanounnikoff S. Estimating the costs of reducing forest emissions: a review of methods, working paper No. 42 2008, CIFOR Bogor, Indonesia.
57. Wolf F.M. Meta-analysis 1986, Sage Publications, Beverly Hills, CA.
58. World Bank Estimating the Opportunity Costs of REDD+ A training manual 2011, At, (accessed 10.04.2012). http://www.theredddesk.org/sites/default/files/resources/pdf/2011/oppcostsreddmanual.pdf.
59. Yamamoto Y., Takeuchi K. Estimating the break-even price for forest protection in Central Kalimantan. Environmental Economics and Policy Studies 2012, 14:289-301.