What can we learn from twin studies? A comprehensive evaluation of the equal environments assumption

Social Science Research

Volumn 43, Issue , 2014, Pages 184-199

  Felson, Jacob ^a  

^a WILLIAM PATERSON UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

Behavior genetics; Equal environments assumption; Twin studies

Indexed keywords

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; CHILD; ENVIRONMENT; EVALUATION STUDY; FEMALE; GENETICS; HUMAN; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROTIC DISORDERS; SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT; STANDARDS; STATISTICAL BIAS; TWIN STUDY; TWINS; UNITED STATES;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; AGED; BIAS (EPIDEMIOLOGY); CHILD; DISEASES IN TWINS; ENVIRONMENT; FEMALE; HUMANS; MALE; MIDDLE AGED; NEUROTIC DISORDERS; SOCIAL ENVIRONMENT; TWIN STUDIES AS TOPIC; TWINS; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84887347012     PISSN: 0049089X     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2013.10.004     Document Type: Article

References (73)

1. Adkins D.E., Vaisey S. Toward a unified stratification theory: structure, genome, and status across human societies. Sociological Theory 2009, 27:99-121.
2. Alford J.R., Funk C.L., Hibbing J.R. Are political orientations genetically transmitted?. American Political Science Review 2005, 99:153-167.
3. Allison D.B., Kaprio J., Korkeila M., Koskenvuo M., Neale M.C., Hayakawa K. The heritability of body mass index among an international sample of monozygotic twins reared apart. International Journal of Obesity 1996, 20:501-506.
4. Alwin D.F. Margins of Error: A Study of Reliability in Survey Measurement 2007, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ.
5. Baker L.A., Cesa I.L., Gatz M., Mellins C. Genetic and environmental influences on positive and negative affect: support for a two-factor theory. Psychology and Aging 1992, 7:158-163.
6. Benjamin D.J., Cesarini D., van der Loos M.J.H.M., Dawes C.T., Koellinger P.D., Magnusson P.K.E., Chabris C.F., Conley D., Laibson D., Johannesson M., Visscher P.M. The genetic architecture of economic and political preferences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2012, 109:8026-8031.
7. Borkenau P., Riemann R., Angleitner A., Spinath F. Similarity of childhood experiences and personality resemblance in monozygostic and dizygotic twins: a test of the equal environments assumption. Personality and Individual Differences 2002, 33:261-269.
8. Bouchard T., Lykken D., McGue M., Segal N., Tellegen A. Sources of human psychological differences: the minnesota study of twins reared apart. Science 1990, 250:223.
9. Bradshaw M., Ellison C. Do genetic factors influence religious life? Findings from a behavior genetic analysis of twin siblings. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 2008, 47:529-544.
10. Branigan, A.R., McCallum, K.J., Freese, J., 2013. Variation in the heritability of educational attainment: An international meta-analysis. Northwestern University Institute for Policy Research Working Paper 13.
11. Bulik C. Heritability of binge-eating and broadly defined bulimia nervosa. Biological Psychiatry 1998, 44:1210-1218.
12. Chabris C.F., Hebert B.M., Benjamin D.J., Beauchamp J., Cesarini D., van der Loos M., Johannesson M., Magnusson P.K., Lichtenstein P., Atwood C.S. Most reported genetic associations with general intelligence are probably false positives. Psychological Science 2012, 23:1314-1323.
13. Charney E. Behavior genetics and postgenomics. Behavioral and Brain Sciences 2012, 35:331-358.
14. Conley D., Rauscher E., Dawes C., Magnusson P.K., Siegal M.L. Heritability and the equal environments assumption: evidence from multiple samples of misclassified twins. Behavior Genetics 2013, 1-12.
15. Cronk N.J., Slutske W.S., Madden P.A.F., Bucholz K., Reich W., Heath A. Emotional and behavioral problems among female twins: an evaluation of the equal environments assumption. Journal of the American Academy of Child Adolescent Psychiatry 2002, 41:829-837.
16. Davies G., Tenesa A., Payton A., Yang J., Harris S.E., Liewald D., Ke X., Le Hellard S., Christoforou A., Luciano M., McGhee K., Lopez L., Gow A.J., Corley J., Redmond P., Fox H.C., Haggarty P., Whalley L.J., McNeill G., Goddard M.E., Espeseth T., Lundervold A.J., Reinvang I., Pickles A., Steen V.M., Ollier W., Porteous D.J., Horan M., Starr J.M., Pendleton N., Visscher P.M., Deary I.J. Genome-wide association studies establish that human intelligence is highly heritable and polygenic. Molecular Psychiatry 2011, 16:996-1005.
17. Derks E.M., Dolan C.V., Boomsma D.I. A test of the equal environment assumption (EEA) in multivariate twin studies. Twin Research and Human Genetics 2005, 9:403-411.
18. Eaves L., Hatemi P., Prom-Womley E. Social and genetic influences on adolescent religious attitudes and practices. Social Forces 2008, 86:1621-1646.
19. Eriksson M., Rasmussen F., Tynelius P. Genetic factors in physical activity and the equal environment assumption - the Swedish young male twins study. Behavior Genetics 2006, 36:238-247.
20. Freese J. Genetics and the social science explanation of individual outcomes. American Journal of Sociology 2008, 114:S1-S35.
21. Gunderson E., Ai-Lin T., Selby J., Caan B., Mayer-Davis E., Risch N. Twins of mistaken zygosity (TOMZ): evidence for genetic contributions to dietary patterns and physiologic traits. Twin Research and Human Genetics 2006, 9:540-549.
22. Guo G., Roettger M.E., Shih J.C. Contributions of the DAT1 and DRD2 genes to serious and violent delinquency among adolescents and young adults. Human Genetics 2007, 121:125-136.
23. Guo G., Stearns E. The social influences on the realization of genetic potential for intellectual development. Social Forces 2002, 80:881-910.
24. Harris J.R. The Nurture Assumption: Why Children Turn Out the Way They Do 1999, Free Press, New York.
25. Hettema J.M., Neale M.C., Kendler K.S. Physical similarity and the equal environments assumption in twin studies of psychiatric disorders. Behavior Genetics 1995, 25:327-335.
26. Holmes S.J. Nature vs. nurture in the development of the mind. The Scientific Monthly 1930, 31:245-252.
27. Horwitz A., Videon T., Schmitz M., Davis D. Rethinking twins and environments: Possible social sources for presumed genetic influences in twin research. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 2003, 44:111-129.
28. Jang K.L., Livesley W.J., Vemon P.A. Heritability of the big five personality dimensions and their facets: a twin study. Journal of Personality 1996, 64:577-592.
29. Jencks C. Heredity, environment, and public policy reconsidered. American Sociological Review 1980, 723-736.
30. Johnson W., Krueger R.F. Higher perceived life control decreases genetic variance in physical health: evidence from a national twin study. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 2005, 88:165.
31. Joseph J. The genetics of political attitudes and behavior: claims and refutations. Ethical Human Psychology and Psychiatry 2010, 12:200-217.
32. Kaprio J., Koskenvuo M., Rose R.J. Change in cohabitation and intrapair similarity of monozygotic (MZ) cotwins for alcohol use, extraversion, and neuroticism. Behavior Genetics 1990, 20:265-276.
33. Kasriel J., Eaves L., et al. The zygosity of twins: further evidence on the agreement between diagnosis by blood groups and written questionnaires. Journal of Biosocial Science 1976, 8:263-266.
34. Kendler K.S., Gardner C.O. Twin studies of adult psychiatric and substance dependence disorders: are they biased by differences in the environmental experiences of monozygotic and dizygotic twins in childhood and adolescence?. Psychological Medicine 1998, 28:625-633.
35. Kendler K.S., Myers J.M., Maes H.H., Keyes C.L. The relationship between the genetic and environmental influences on common internalizing psychiatric disorders and mental well-being. Behavior Genetics 2011, 41:641-650.
36. Kendler K.S., Neale M.C., Heath A., Eaves L. Parental treatment and the equal environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illness. Psychological Medicine 1994, 24:579-590.
37. Kendler K.S., Neale M.C., Kessler R., Heath A. A test of the equal-environment assumption in twin studies of psychiatric illness. Behavior Genetics 1993, 23:21-27.
38. Klump K.L., Holly A., Iacono W.G., Mcgue M., Willson L.E. Physical similarity and twin resemblance for eating attitudes and behaviors: a test of the equal environments assumption. Behavior Genetics 2000, 30:51-58.
39. Kohler H.P., Rodgers J.L. DF-like analyses of binary, ordered, and censored variables using probit and tobit approaches. Behavior Genetics 1999, 29:221-232.
40. LaBuda M., Svikis D., Pickens R. Twin closeness and co-twin risk for substance use disorders: assessing the impact of the equal environment assumption. Psychiatry Research 1997, 70:155-164.
41. Levene, H., 1960. Robust tests for equality of variances. In: Contributions to Probability and Statistics: Essays in Honor of Harold Hotelling, vol. 2, p. 278.
42. Lewis G.J., Bates T.C. A common heritable factor influences prosocial obligations across multiple domains. Biology Letters 2011, 7:567-570.
43. Littvay L., Weith P.T., Dawes C.T. Sense of control and voting: a genetically-driven relationship. Social Science Quarterly 2011, 92:1236-1252.
44. Loehlin J., Nichols R. Heredity. Environment and Personality: A Study of 850 Sets of Twins 1976, University of Texas Press, Austin.
45. Manolio T., Collins F., Cox N., Goldstein D., Hindorff L., Hunter D., McCarthy M., Ramos E., Cardon L., Chakravarti A., et al. Finding the missing heritability of complex diseases. Nature 2009, 461:747-753.
46. Matheny A.P., Wilson R.S., Dolan A.B. Relations between twins' similarity of appearance and behavioral similarity: testing an assumption. Behavior Genetics 1976, 6:343-351.
47. Morris-Yates A., Andrews G., Howie P., Henderson S. Twins: a test of the equal environments assumption. Acta Psychiatry Scandinavia 1990, 81:322-326.
48. Mowrer E. Some factors in the affectional adjustment of twins. American Sociological Review 1954, 19:468-471.
49. Nelson T.L., Vogler G.P., Pedersen N.L., Miles T.P. Genetic and environmental influences on waist-to-hip ratio and waist circumference in an older swedish twin population. International Journal of Obesity 1999, 23:449-455.
50. Nicolaou N., Shane S. Entrepreneurship and occupational choice: genetic and environmental influences. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 2010, 76:3-14.
51. Nielsen F. Achievement and ascription in educational attainment: genetic and environmental influences on adolescent schooling. Social Forces 2006, 85:193-216.
52. Nielsen, F., Roos, J., 2011. Genetics of educational attainment and the persistence of privilege at the turn of the 21st century [unpublished manuscript].
53. Pam A., Kemker S., Ross C., Golder R. The equal environments assumption in mz-dz twin comparisons: an untenable premise of psychiatric genetics?. Acta Geneticae Medicae Et Gemellologiae 1996, 45:349-360.
54. Penninkilampi-Kerola V., Moilanen I. Co-twin dependence, social interactions, and academic achievement: a population-based study. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 2005, 22:519-541.
55. Plomin R., Willerman L., Loehlin J.C. Resemblance in appearance and the equal environments assumption in twin studies of personality traits. Behavior Genetics 1976, 6:43-52.
56. Richardson K., Norgate S. The equal environments assumption of classical twin studies may not hold. British Journal of Educational Psychology 2005, 75:339-350.
57. Rodgers J.L., Kohler H.P., Kyvik K.O., Christensen K. Behavior genetic modeling of human fertility: findings from a contemporary danish twin study. Demography 2001, 38:29-42.
58. Rose R.J., Koskenvuo M., Kaprio J., Seppo S., Langinvainio H. Shared genes, shared experiences, and similarity of personality: data from 14,288 adult Finnish co-twins. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1988, 54:161-171.
59. Rowe D. The Limits of Family Influence: Genes Experience and Behavior 1995, Guilford Press. 1st ed.
60. Ryff, C., Almeida, D.M., Ayanian, J.S., Carr, D.S., Cleary, P.D., Coe, C., Davidson, R., Krueger, R.F., Lachman, M.E., Marks, N.F., Mroczek, D.K., Seeman, T., Seltzer, M.M., Singer, B.H., Sloan, R.P., Tun, P.A., Weinstein, M., Williams, D., 2011. National survey of midlife development in the united states (MIDUS II), 2004-2006.
61. Scarr S. Environmental bias in twin studies. Eugenics Quarterly 1968, 15:34-50.
62. Scarr S., Carter-Saltzman L. Twin method: defense of a critical assumption. Behavior Genetics 1979, 9:527-542.
63. Schnittker J. Happiness and success: genes, families, and the psychological effects of socioeconomic position and social support. American Journal of Sociology 2008, 114:233-259.
64. Schnittker J. Gene-environment correlations in the stress-depression relationship. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 2010, 51:229-243.
65. Silventoinen K., Sammalisto S., Perola M., Boomsma D.I., Cornes B.K., Davis C., Dunkel L., De Lange M., Harris J.R., Hjelmborg J.V. Heritability of adult body height: a comparative study of twin cohorts in eight countries. Twin Research 2003, 6:399-408.
66. Smith K.B., Hatemi P.K. OLS is AOK for ACE: a regression-based approach to synthesizing political science and behavioral genetics models. Political Behavior 2012, 35:383-408.
67. Smith R.T. A comparison of socioenvironmental factors in monozygotic and dizygotic twins testing an assumption. Methods and Goals in Human Behavior Genetics 1965, Academic Press, New York. S.G. Vandenberg (Ed.).
68. Towne B., Czerwinski S.A., Demerath E.W., Blangero J., Roche A.F., Siervogel R.M. Heritability of age at menarche in girls from the fels longitudinal study. American Journal of Physical Anthropology 2005, 128:210-219.
69. Truett K.R., Eaves L.J., Meyer J.M., Heath A.C., Martin N.G. Religion and education as mediators of attitudes: a multivariate analysis. Behavior Genetics 1992, 22:43-62.
70. Turkheimer E. Three laws of behavior genetics and what they mean. Current Directions in Psychological Science 2000, 9:160.
71. Vinkhuyzen A.A.E., Pedersen N.L., Yang J., Lee S.H., Magnusson P.K.E., Iacono W.G., McGue M., Madden P.A.F., Heath A.C., Luciano M., Payton A., Horan M., Ollier W., Pendleton N., Deary I.J., Montgomery G.W., Martin N.G., Visscher P.M., Wray N.R. Common SNPs explain some of the variation in the personality dimensions of neuroticism and extraversion. Translational Psychiatry 2012, 2:e102.
72. Wilson P. A study of twins with special reference to heredity as a factor determining differences in environment. Human Biology 1934, 61:629.
73. Xian H., Scherrer J.F., Eisen S.A., True W.R., Heath A.C., Goldberg J., Lyons M.J., Tsuang M.T. Self-reported zygosity and the equal-environments assumption for psychiatric disorders in the vietnam era twin registry. Behavior Genetics 2000, 30:303-9690.