Remembering what could have happened: Neural correlates of episodic counterfactual thinking

Neuropsychologia

Volumn 51, Issue 12, 2013, Pages 2401-2414

  De Brigard, F ^a,b   Addis, D R ^c   Ford, J H ^a   Schacter, D L ^b   Giovanello, K S ^a,d  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA   (United States)

^b HARVARD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF AUCKLAND   (New Zealand)

^d UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

Author keywords

Counterfactual thinking; Episodic memory; FMRI; Imagination; Mental time travel; Partial least squares

Indexed keywords

ADULT; ARTICLE; BRAIN FUNCTION; BRAIN MAPPING; CONTROLLED STUDY; CORRELATION ANALYSIS; EPISODIC COUNTERFACTUAL THINKING; EPISODIC MEMORY; FEMALE; FUNCTIONAL MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; HIPPOCAMPUS; HUMAN; HUMAN EXPERIMENT; IMAGINATION; LITERATURE; MALE; MEMORY CONSOLIDATION; MENTAL CAPACITY; NEUROMODULATION; NORMAL HUMAN; PARAHIPPOCAMPAL GYRUS; PARTIAL LEAST SQUARES REGRESSION; SEMANTIC MEMORY; SPATIOTEMPORAL ANALYSIS; THINKING; VISUAL MEMORY;

COUNTERFACTUAL THINKING; EPISODIC MEMORY; FMRI; IMAGINATION; MENTAL TIME TRAVEL; PARTIAL LEAST SQUARES;

ADOLESCENT; ADULT; BRAIN; BRAIN MAPPING; FEMALE; HIPPOCAMPUS; HUMANS; IMAGINATION; MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING; MALE; MEMORY, EPISODIC; MENTAL RECALL; PARAHIPPOCAMPAL GYRUS; THINKING; YOUNG ADULT;

EID: 84886095160     PISSN: 00283932     EISSN: 18733514     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2013.01.015     Document Type: Article

References (81)

1. Addis D.R., Cheng T., Roberts R., Schacter D.L. Hippocampal contributions to the episodic simulation of specific and general future events. Hippocampus 2011, 21:1045-1052.
2. Addis D.R., Knapp K., Roberts R.P., Schacter D.L. Routes to the past: neural substrates of direct and generative autobiographical memory retrieval. NeuroImage 2012, 59:2908-2922.
3. Addis D.R., Moscovitch M., Crawley A.P., McAndrews M.P. Recollective qualities modulate hippocampal activation during autobiographical memory retrieval. Hippocampus 2004, 14:752-762.
4. Addis D.R., Musicaro R., Pan L., Schacter D.L. Episodic simulation of past and future events in older adults: evidence from an experimental recombination task. Psychology and Aging 2010, 25:369-376.
5. Addis D.R., Pan L., Vu M., Laiser N., Schacter D.L. Constructive episodic simulation of the future and the past: distinct subsystems of a core brain network mediate imagining and remembering. Neuropsychologia 2009, 47:2222-2238.
6. Addis D.R., Roberts R.P., Schacter D.L. Age-related neural changes in autobiographical remembering and imagining. Neuropsychologia 2011, 49:3656-3669.
7. Addis D.R., Sacchetti D.C., Ally B.A., Budson A.E., Schacter D.L. Episodic simulation of future events is impaired in mild Alzheimer's disease. Neuropsychologia 2009, 47:2660-2671.
8. Addis D.R., Schacter D.L. Effects of detail and temporal distance of past and future events on the engagements of a common neural network. Hippocampus 2008, 18:227-237.
9. Addis D.R., Wong A.T., Schacter D.L. Remembering the past and imagining the future: common and distinct neural substrates during event construction and elaboration. Neuropsychologia 2007, 45:1363-1377.
10. Addis D.R., Wong A.T., Schacter D.L. Age-related changes in episodic simulation of future events. Psychological Science 2008, 19:33-41.
11. Addis D.R., Schacter D.L. The hippocampus and imagining the future: where do we stand?. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 2012, 5:173. doi: 10.3389/fnhum. 2011.00173.
12. Atance C.M., O'Neill D.K. Episodic future thinking. Trends in Cognitive Science 2001, 5:533-539.
13. Barbey A.K., Krueger F., Grafman J. Structured event complexes in the medial prefrontal cortex support counterfactual representations for future planning. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B: Biological Sciences 2009, 364:1291-1300.
14. Beldarrain M., Garcia-Monco J., Astigarraga E., Gonzalez A., Grafman J. Only spontaneous counterfactual thinking is impaired in patients with prefrontal cortex lesions. Cognition and Brain Research 2005, 24:723-726.
15. Berntson G.G., Norman G.J., Bechara A., Bruss J., Tranel D., Cacioppo J.T. The insula and evaluative processes. Psychological Science 2011, 22:80-86.
16. Bower G.H. Mood and memory. American Psychologist 1981, 36:129-148.
17. Buckner R.L., Andrews-Hanna J.R., Schacter D.L. The brain's default network: anatomy, function, and relevance to disease. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 2008, 1124:1-38.
18. Buckner R.L., Carroll D.C. Self-projection and the brain. Trends in Cognitive Science 2007, 11:49-57.
19. Burianova H., Grady C.L. Common and unique neural activations in autobiographical, episodic, and semantic retrieval. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2007, 19:1520-1534.
20. Byrne R.M.J. Mental models and counterfactual thoughts about what might have been. Trends in Cognitive Science 2002, 6:426-431.
21. Camille N., Coricelli G., Sallet J., Pradat-Diehl P., Duhamel J., Sirigu A. The involvement of the orbitofrontal cortex in the experience of regret. Science 2004, 304:1167-1170.
22. Chua E., Rand-Giovennetti E., Schacter D.L., Albert M.S., Sperling R.A. Dissociating confidence and accuracy: functional magnetic resonance imaging shows origins of subjective memory experience. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2004, 16:1131-1142.
23. Clark J.M., Paivio A. Extensions of the Paivio, Yuille, and Madigan (1968) norms. Behavioral and Research Methods 2004, 36:371-383.
24. Conway M.A., Pleydell-Pearce C.W. The search of autobiographical memories in the self-memory system. Psychological Review 2000, 107:261-288.
25. Coricelli G., Critchley H.D., Joffily M., O'Doherty J.P., Sirigu A., Dolan R.J. Regret and its avoidance: a neuroimaging study of choice behavior. Nature Neuroscience 2005, 8:1255-1262.
26. Coricelli G., Dolan R.J., Sirigu A. Brain, emotion, and decision making: the paradigmatic example of regret. Trends in Cognitive Science 2007, 11:258-265.
27. D'Argembeau A.D., Stawarczyk D., Majerus S., Collette F., Van der Linden M., Feyers D., Maquet P., Salmon E. The neural basis of personal goal processing when envisioning future events. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2009, 22:1701-1713.
28. De Brigard, F., Szpunar, K. K., Schacter, D. Coming to grips with the past: effects of repeated simulation on the perceived plausibility of episodic counterfactual thoughts. Psychological Science, in press.
29. De Brigard F., Giovanello K. Influence of outcome valence in the subjective experience of episodic past, future, and counterfactual thinking. Consciousness and Cognition 2012, 21:1085-1096.
30. Dickson J.M., Bates G.W. Influence of repression on autobiographical memories and expectations of the future. Australian Journal of Psychology 2005, 57:20-27.
31. D'Argembeau A., Raffard S., Van der Linden M. Remembering the past and imagining the future in schizophrenia. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 2008, 117:247-251.
32. D'Argembeau A., Van der Linden M. Phenomenal characteristics associated with projecting oneself back into the past and forward into the future: influence of valence and temporal distance. Consciousness and Cognition 2004, 13:844-858.
33. D'Argembeau A., Van der Linden M. Individual differences in the phenomenology of mental time travel: the effects of vivid visual imagery and emotion regulation strategies. Consciousness and Cognition 2006, 15:342-350.
34. D'Argembeau A., Xue G., Lu Z.L., Van der Linden M., Bechara A. Neural correlates of envisioning emotional events in the near and far future. NeuroImage 2008, 40:398-407.
35. Eichenbaum H. The hippocampus and declarative memory: cognitive mechanisms and neural codes. Behavioral Brain Research 2001, 127:199-207.
36. Elliott R., Dolan R.J., Frith C.D. Dissociable functions in the medial and lateral orbitofrontal cortex: evidence from human neuroimaging studies. Cerebral Cortex 2000, 10:308-317.
37. Epstude K., Roese N.J. The functional theory of counterfactual thinking personal. Social Psychological Review 2008, 12:168-192.
38. Gaesser B., Sacchetti D.C., Addis D.R., Schacter D.L. Characterizing age-related changes in remembering the past and imagining the future. Psychology and Aging 2011, 26:80-84.
39. Gamboz N., De Vito S., Brandimonte M.A., Pappalardo S., Galone F., Iavarone A., Della Sala S. Episodic future thinking in amnesic mild cognitive impairment. Neuropsychologia 2010, 48:2091-2097.
40. Giovanello K.S., Schnyer D., Verfaellie M. A critical role for the anterior hippocampus in relational memory: evidence from an fMRI study comparing associative and item recognition. Hippocampus 2004, 14:5-8.
41. Hassabis D., Kumaran D., Maguire E.A. Using imagination to understand the neural basis of episodic memory. Journal of Neuroscience 2007, 27:14365-14374.
42. Hassabis D., Kumaran D., Vann S.D., Maguire E.A. Patients with hippocampal amnesia cannot imagine new experiences. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science U.S.A 2007, 104:1726-1731.
43. Hassabis D., Maguire E.A. Deconstructing episodic memory with construction. Trends in Cognitive Science 2007, 11:299-306.
44. Hassabis D., Maguire E.A. The construction system of the brain. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B: Biological Sciences 2009, 1521:1263-1271.
45. Hoch S. Counterfactual reasoning and accuracy in predicting personal events. Journal of Experimental Psychology 1984, 11:719-731.
46. Holmes D.S. Differential change in affective intensity and the forgetting of unpleasant personal experiences. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1970, 3:234-239.
47. Klein S.B., Loftus J., Kihlstrom J.F. Memory and temporal experience: the effects of episodic memory loss on an amnesic patient's ability to remember the past and imagine the future. Social Cognition 2002, 20:353-379.
48. Kurczek, J. C., Duff, M. C., Jensen, U., Adolphs, R., Cohen, N. J., Tranel, D. (2010). Hippocampal amnesia impairs the generation of mental representations across all time periods. In: SfN Annual Meeting, November 13-17, San Diego, CA. Abstr 600.8.
49. Martin V.C., Schacter D.L., Corballis M., Addis D.R. A role for the hippocampus in encoding simulations of future events. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science U.S.A 2011, 108:13858-13863.
50. Meltzer H. Individual differences in forgetting pleasant and unpleasant experiences. Journal of Educational Psychology 1930, 21:399.
51. Okuda J., Fujii T., Ohtake H., Tsukiura T., Tanji K., Suzuki K., Kawashima R., Fukuda H., Itoh M., Yamadori A. Thinking of the future and the past: the roles of the frontal pole and the medial temporal lobes. NeuroImage 2003, 19:1369-1380.
52. Race E., Keane M., Verfaellie M. Medial temporal lobe damage causes deficits in episodic memory and episodic future thinking not attributable to deficits in narrative construction. Journal of Neuroscience 2011, 31:10262-10269.
53. Roese N. Counterfactual thinking. Psychological Bulletin. 1997, 121:133-148.
54. Rombouts S.A.R.B., Scheltens P., Machielsen C.M., Barkhof F., Hoogenraad F.G.C., Veltmen D.J., Valk J., Witter M.P. Parametric fMRI analysis of visual encoding in the human medial temporal lobe. Hippocampus 1999, 9:637-643.
55. Schacter D.L., Addis D.R. The ghosts of past and future. Nature 2007, 445:27.
56. Schacter D.L., Addis D.R. The cognitive neuroscience of constructive memory: remembering the past and imagining the future. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, B: Biological Sciences 2007, 362:773-786.
57. Schacter D.L., Addis D.R., Buckner R.L. The prospective brain: remembering the past to imagine the future. Nature Reviews Neuroscience 2007, 8:657-661.
58. Schacter D.L., Addis D.R., Buckner R.L. Episodic simulation of future events: concepts, data, and applications. Annals of the New York Academy of Science 2008, 1124:39-60.
59. Schacter D.L., Addis D.R., Hassabis D., Martin β, Spreng R.N., Szpunar K.K. The future of memory: remembering, imagining, and the brain. Neuron 2012, 76:677-694.
60. Schacter D.L., Wagner A.D. Medial temporal lobe activations in fMRI and PET studies of episodic encoding and retrieval. Hippocampus 1999, 9:7-24.
61. Sharot T., Riccardi A.M., Raio C.M., Phelps E.A. Neural mechanisms mediating optimism bias. Nature 2007, 450:102-105.
62. Spreng N., Levine B. The temporal distribution of past and future autobiographical events across the lifespan. Memory and Cognition 2006, 34:1644-1651.
63. Spreng R.N., Mar R.A., Kim A.S. The common neural basis of autobiographical memory, prospection, navigation, theory of mind, and the default mode: a quantitative meta-analysis. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 2009, 21:489-510.
64. Squire L.R., van der Horst A., McDuff S.G.R., Frascino J.C., Hopkins R.O., Mauldin K.N. Role of the hippocampus in remembering the past and imagining the future. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science U.S.A 2010, 107:19044-19048.
65. Suddendorf T., Busby J. Making decisions with the future in mind: developmental and comparative identification of mental time travel. Learning and Motivation 2005, 36:110-125.
66. Szpunar K.K. Episodic future thought: an emerging concept. Perspectives in Psychological Science 2010, 5:142-162.
67. Szpunar K.K., Addis D.R., Schacter D.L. Memory for emotional simulations: remembering a rosy future. Psychological Science. 2012, 23:24-29.
68. Szpunar K.K., Chan J.K.C., McDermott K.B. Contextual processing in episodic future thought. Cerebral Cortex 2009, 19:1539-1548.
69. Szpunar K.K., McDermott K.B. Episodic future thought and its relation to remembering: evidence from ratings of subjective experience. Consciousness and Cognition 2008, 17:330-334.
70. Szpunar K.K., Watson J.M., McDermott K.B. Neural substrates of envisioning the future. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science U.S.A 2007, 104:642-647.
71. Tulving E. Memory and consciousness. Canadian Psychologist 1985, 25:1-12.
72. Tulving E. Episodic memory: from mind to brain. Annual Review of Psychology 2002, 53:1-25.
73. Van Hoeck, N., Ma, N., Ampe, L., Baetens, K., Vandekerckhove, M., Van Overwalle, F. Counterfactual thinking: an fMRI study on changing the past for a better future. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, doi: 10.1093/scan/nss031, in press.
74. Van Hoeck N., Ma N., Van Overwalle F., Vandekerckhove M. Counterfactual thinking and the episodic system. Behavioral Neurology 2010, 23:225-227.
75. Waldfogel S. The frequency and affective character of childhood memories. Psychological Monographs 1948, 62:291.
76. Walker W.R., Skowronski J.J. The fading affect bias. ... but what the hell is it for?. Applied Cognitive Psychology 2009, 23:1122-1136.
77. Weiler J.A., Suchan B., Daum I. Foreseeing the future: occurrence probability of imagined future events modulates hippocampal activation. Hippocampus 2010, 20:685-690.
78. Weinstein N.D. Unrealistic optimism about future life events. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 1980, 39:806-820.
79. Wilbur W.R., Skowronski J.J., Thompson C.P. Life is pleasant-and memory helps to keep it that way!. Review General Psychology 2003, 7:203-210.
80. Williams J.M., Ellis N.C., Tyers C., Healy H., Rose G., MacLeod A.K. The specificity of autobiographical memory and imageability of the future. Memory and Cognition 1996, 24:116-125.
81. Xue G., Lu Z., Levin I.P., Bechara A. The impact of prior risk experiences on subsequent risky decision-making: the role of the insula. NeuroImage 2010, 50:709-716.