Methods of estimating marine mammal diets: A review of validation experiments and sources of bias and uncertainty

Marine Mammal Science

Volumn 29, Issue 4, 2013, Pages 719-754

  Bowen, W D ^a   Iverson, S J ^b  

^a BEDFORD INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGRAPHY   (Canada)

^b DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

DNA; Fatty acids; Feces; Otoliths; Stable isotopes

Indexed keywords

DIET; DIGESTION; DNA; FATTY ACID; FECES; MARINE MAMMAL; OTOLITH; PREDATOR; STABLE ISOTOPE;

MAMMALIA;

EID: 84885835308     PISSN: 08240469     EISSN: 17487692     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-7692.2012.00604.x     Document Type: Article

References (94)

1. Austin, D., W. D. Bowen, J. I. McMillan and S. J. Iverson 2006. Linking movement, diving, and habitat to foraging success in a large marine predator. Ecology 87:3095-3108.
2. Beck, C. A., W. D. Bowen and S. J. Iverson 2000. Effect of seasonal changes in buoyancy on diving behaviour in grey seals. Journal of Experimental Biology 203:2323-2330.
3. Beck, C. A., W. D. Bowen, J. I. McMillan and S. J. Iverson 2003. Sex differences in diving at multiple temporal scales in a size-dimorphic capital breeder. Journal of Animal Ecology 72:979-993.
4. Ben-David, M., R. W. Flynn and D. M. Schell 1997. Annual and seasonal changes in diets of martens: Evidence from stable isotope analysis. Oecologia 111:280-291.
5. Ben-David, M., and D. M. Schell 2001. Mixing models in analyses of diet using multiple stable isotopes: A response. Oecologia 127:180-184.
6. Berg, I., T. Haug and K. T. Nilssen 2002. Harbour seal (Phoca vitulina) diet in Vesteralen, north Norway. Sarsia 87:451-461.
7. Bigg, M. A., and I. F. Fawcett 1985. Two biases in diet determination of northern fur seals (Callorhinus ursinus). Pages 284-291 in J. R. Beddington, R. J. H. Beverton and D. M. Lavigne, eds. Maine mammals and fisheries. George Allen & Unwin, London, U.K.
8. Bowen, W. D. 1997. Role of marine mammals in aquatic ecosystems. Marine Ecology Progress Series 158:267-274.
9. Bowen, W. D. 2000. Reconstruction of pinniped diets: Accounting for complete digestion of otoliths and cephalopod beaks. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 57:898-905.
10. Bowen, W. D., and D. B. Siniff 1999. Distribution, population biology, and feeding ecology of marine mammals. Pages 423-484 in J. E. Reynolds III and S. A. Rommel, eds. Biology of Marine Mammals. Smithsonian Press, Washington, DC.
11. Bowen, W. D., J. W. Lawson and B. Beck 1993. Seasonal and geographic variation in the species composition and size of prey consumed by grey seals (Halichoerus grypus) on the Scotian shelf. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 50:1768-1778.
12. Bowen, W. D., D. Tully, D. J. Boness, B. Bulheier and G. Marshall 2002. Prey-dependent foraging tactics and prey profitability in a marine mammal. Marine Ecology Progress Series 244:235-245.
13. Bowles, E. 2009. Determining the relative amounts of prey in Steller sea lion (Eumetopias jubatus) diet using real-time PCR. M.Sc. thesis, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada. 47 pp.
14. Breed, G. A., W. D. Bowen, J. I. McMillan and M. L. Leonard 2006. Sex segregation of seasonal foraging habitats in a non-migratory marine mammal. Proceedings of Royal Society, B. 273:2319-2326.
15. Breed, G. A., I. D. Jonsen, R. A. Myers, W. D. Bowen and M. L. Leonard 2009. Sex-specific, seasonal foraging tactics of adult grey seals (Halichoerus grypus) revealed by state-space analysis. Ecology 90:3209-3221.
16. Browne, P., J. L. Laake and R. L. DeLong 2002. Improving pinniped diet analyses through identification of multiple skeletal structures in fecal samples. Fishery Bulletin 100:423-433.
17. Budge, S. M., S. J. Iverson, W. D. Bowen and R. G. Ackman 2002. Among and within species variability in fatty acid signatures of marine fish and invertebrates on the Scotian Shelf, Georges Bank, and southern Gulf of St. Lawrence. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 59:886-898.
18. Budge, S. M., S. J. Iverson and H. N. Koopman 2006. Studying trophic ecology in marine ecosystems using fatty acids: A primer on analysis and interpretation. Marine Mammal Science 22:759-801.
19. Carss, D. N., and D. A. Elston 1996. Errors associated with otter Lutra lutra faecal analysis. 2. Estimating prey size distribution from bones recovered in spraints. Journal of Zoology 238:319-332.
20. Carss, D. N., and S. G. Parkinson 1996. Errors associated with otter Lutra lutra faecal analysis. 1. Assessing general diet from spraints. Journal of Zoology 238:301-317.
21. Carss, D. N., D. A. Elston and H. S. Morley 1998. The effects of otter (Lutra lutra) activity on spraint production and composition: Implications for models which estimate prey-size distribution. Journal of Zoology, London 244:295-302.
22. Casper, R. M., N. J. Gales, M. A. Hindell and S. M. Robinson 2006. Diet estimation based on an integrated mixed prey feeding experiment using Arctocephalus seals. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 328:228-239.
23. Casper, R. M., S. N. Jarrnan, B. E. Deagle, N. J. Gales and M. A. Hindell 2007. Detecting prey from DNA in predator scats: A comparison with morphological analysis, using Arctocephalus seals fed a known diet. Journal of Experimental Marine Biology and Ecology 347:144-154.
24. Cooper, M. H. 2004. Fatty acid metabolism in marine carnivores: implications for quantitative estimation of predator diets. Ph.D. thesis, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Canada. 228 pp.
25. Cottrell, P. E., A. W. Trites and T. E. Miller 1996. Assessing the use of hard parts in faeces to identify harbour seal prey: results of captive-feeding trials. Canadian Journal of Zoology 74:875-880.
26. da Silva, J., and J. D. Neilson 1985. Limitation of using otoliths recovered in scats to estimate prey consumption in seals. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 42:1439-1442.
27. Deagle, B. E., and D. J. Tollit 2007. Quantitative analysis of prey DNA in pinniped faeces: Potential to estimate diet composition. Conservation Genetics 8:743-747.
28. Deagle, B. E., D. J. Tollit, S. N. Jarman, M. A. Hindell, A. W. Trites and N. J. Gales 2005. Molecular scatology as a tool to study diet: Analysis of prey DNA in scats from captive Steller sea lions. Molecular Ecology 14:1831-1842.
29. Deagle, B. E., R. Kirkwood and S. N. Jarman 2009. Analysis of Australian fur seal diet by pyrosequencing prey DNA in faeces. Molecular Ecology 18:2022-2038.
30. Deagle, B. E., A. Chiaradia, J. McInnes and S. N. Jarman 2010. Pyrosequencing faecal DNA to determine diet of little penguins: Is what goes in what comes out? Conservation Genetics 11:2039-2048.
31. Dellinger, T., and F. Trillmich 1988. Estimating diet composition from scat analysis in otariid seals (Otariidae): Is it reliable? Canadian Journal of Zoology 66:1865-1870.
32. Estes, J. A., R. J. Jameson and E. B. Rhode 1982. Activity and prey selection in the sea otter: Influence of population status on community structure. American Naturalist 120:242-258.
33. Fea, N., and R. Harcourt 1997. Assessing the use of faecal and regurgitate analysis as a means of determining the diet of New Zealand fur seals. Pages 143-150 in M. A. Hindell and C. Kemper, eds. Marine mammal research in the southern hemisphere. Volume I. Ecology and medicine. Surrey Beatty and Sons, Blaukham Hills, Australia.
34. Fitch, J. E., and R. L. Brownell 1968. Fish otoliths in cetacean stomachs and their importance in interpreting feeding habits. Journal of Fisheries Research Board of Canada 25:2561-2575.
35. Gales, N. J., and A. J. Cheal 1992. Estimating diet composition of the Australian sea lion (Neophoca cinerea) from scat analysis: An unreliable technique. Wildlife Research 19:447-456.
36. Gales, R., and D. Pemberton 1994. Diet of the Australian fur seal in Tasmania. Australian Journal of Marine And Freshwater Research 45:653-664.
37. Grellier, K., and P. S. Hammond 2005. Feeding method affects otolith digestion in captive gray seals: Implications for diet composition estimation. Marine Mammal Science 21:296-306.
38. Grellier, K., and P. S. Hammond 2006. Robust digestion and passage rate estimates for hard parts of grey seal (Halichoerus grypus) prey. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 63:1982-1998.
39. Hammond, P. S., and P. Rothery 1996. Application of computer sampling in the estimation of seal diet. Journal of Applied Statistics 23:525-533.
40. Harvey, J. T. 1989. Assessment of errors associated with harbour seal (Phoca vitulina) feacal sampling. Journal of Zoology, London 219:101-111.
41. Harvey, J. T., and G. A. Antonelis 1994. Biases associated with non-lethal methods of determining the diet of northern elephant seals. Marine Mammal Science 10:178-187.
42. Hoberecht, L. K. 2006. Investigating the use of blubber fatty acids to detect Steller sea lion (Eumetopias jubatus) foraging on ephemeral high-quality prey. Ph.D. thesis, University of Washington, Seattle, WA. 245 pp.
43. Hobson, K. A., J. F. Piatt and J. Pitocechelli 1994. Using stable isotopes to determine seabird trophic relationships. Journal of Animal Ecology 63:768-798.
44. Hobson, K. A., J. L. Sease, R. L. Merrick and J. F. Piatt 1997. Investigating trophic relationships of pinnipeds in Alaska and Washington using stable isotope ratios of nitrogen and carbon. Marine Mammal Science 13:114-132.
45. Iverson, S. J. 2009. Tracing aquatic food webs using fatty acids: From qualitative indicators to quantitative determination. Pages 281-307 in M. T. Arts, M. T. Brett and M. J. Kainz, eds. Lipids in aquatic ecosystems. Springer, New York, NY.
46. Iverson, S. J., C. Field, W. D. Bowen and W. Blanchard 2004. Quantitative fatty acid signature analysis: A new method of estimating predator diets. Ecological Monographs 74:211-235.
47. Iverson, S. J., I. Stirling and S. L. C. Lang 2006. Spatial and temporal variation in the diets of polar bears across the Canadian Arctic: Indicators of changes in prey populations and environment. Pages 98-117 in I. L. Boyd, S. Wanless and C. J. Camphuysen, eds. Top predators in marine ecosystems: Their role in monitoring and management. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, U.K.
48. Iverson, S. J., A. M. Springer and A. S. Kitaysky 2007. Seabirds as indicators of food web structure and ecosystem variability: Qualitative and quantitative diet analyses using fatty acids. Marine Ecology Progress Series 352:235-244.
49. Iverson, S. J., B. S. Stewart and P. K. Yochem 2010. Report of validation and calibration of fatty acid signatures in blubber as indicators of prey in Hawaiian monk seal diet. A report submitted under Contract No. AB133F-03-SE-1195 September 2003. Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, Administrative Report H-10-05, Pacific Islands Fisheries Science Center, National Marine Fishery Service, NOAA, Honolulu, HI. 20 pp.
50. Jarman, S. N., B. E. Deagle and N. J. Gales 2004. Group-specific polymerase chain reaction for DNA-based analysis of species diversity and identity in dietary samples. Molecular Ecology 13:1313-1322.
51. Jobling, M. 1987. Marine mammal faecal samples as indicators of prey importance-a source of error in bioenergetics studies. Sarsia 72:255-260.
52. Jobling, M., and A. Breiby 1986. The use and abuse of fish otoliths in studies of feeding habits of marine piscivores. Sarsia 71:265-274.
53. Johnstone, I. G., M. P. Harris, S. Wanless and J. A. Graves 1990. The usefulness of pellets for assessing the diet of adult shags Phalacrocorax aristotelis. Bird Study 37:5-11.
54. Kelly, J. F. 2000. Stable isotopes of carbon and nitrogen in the study of avian and mammalian trophic ecology. Canadian Journal of Zoology 78:1-27.
55. King, R. A., D. S. Read, M. Traugott and W. O. C. Symondson 2008. Molecular analysis of predation: A review of best practice for DNA-based approaches. Molecular Ecology 17:947-963.
56. Koch, P. L., and D. L. Phillips 2002. Incorporating concentration dependence in stable isotope mixing models: A reply to Robbins, Hilderbrand and Farley (2002). Oecologia 133:14-18.
57. Lawson, J. W., E. H. Miller and E. Noseworthy 1997. Variation in assimilation efficiency and digestive efficiency of captive harp seals (Phoca groenlandica) on different diets. Canadian Journal of Zoology 75:1285-1291.
58. Longenecker, K. 2010. Fishes in the Hawaiian monk seal diet, based on regurgitate samples collected in the Northwestern Hawaiian Islands. Marine Mammal Science 26:420-429.
59. Madden, K. M., L. A. Fuiman, T. M. William and R. W. Davis 2008. Identification of foraging dives in free-ranging Weddell seals Leptonychotes weddellii: Confirmation using video records. Marine Ecology Progres Series 365:263-275.
60. Marcus, J., W. D. Bowen and J. D. Eddington 1998. Effects of meal size on otolith recovery from fecal samples of gray and harbor seal pups. Marine Mammal Science 14:789-802.
61. Matejusova, I., F. Doig, S. J. Middlemas, et al. 2008. Using quantitative real-time PCR to detect salmonid prey in scats of grey Halichoerus grypus and harbour Phoca vitulina seals in Scotland-an experimental and field study. Journal of Applied Ecology 45:632-640.
62. Murie, D. J., and D. M. Lavigne 1986. Interpretation of otoliths in stomach content analyses of phocid seals: Quantifying fish consumption. Canadian Journal of Zoology 64:1152-1157.
63. Nordstrom, C. A., L. J. Wilson, S. J. Iverson and D. J. Tollit 2008. Evaluating quantitative fatty acid signature analysis (QFASA) using harbour seals Phoca vitulina richardsi in captive feeding studies. Marine Ecology-Progress Series 360:245-263.
64. Ochoa Acuña, H., and J. M. Francis 1995. Spring and summer prey of the Juan Fernández fur seal, Artcocephalus philippii. Canadian Journal of Zoology 73:1444-1452.
65. Orr, A. J., and J. T. Harvey 2001. Quantifying errors associated with using fecal samples to determine the diet of the California sea lion (Zalophus californianus). Canadian Journal of Zoology 79:1080-1087.
66. Parrish, F. A., K. Abernathy, G. J. Marshall and B. M. Buhleier 2002. Hawaiian monk seals (Monachus schauinslandi) foraging in deep-water coral beds. Marine Mammal Science 18:244-258.
67. Phillips, D. L., and J. W. Gregg 2001. Uncertainty in source partitioning using stable isotopes. Oecologia 127:171-179.
68. Phillips, D. L., and J. W. Gregg 2003. Source partitioning using stable isotopes: Coping with too many sources. Oecologia 136:261-269.
69. Phillips, E. M., and J. T. Harvey 2009. A captive feeding study with the Pacific harbor seal (Phoca vitulina richardii): Implications for scat analysis. Marine Mammal Science 25:373-391.
70. Pierce, G. J., and P. R. Boyle 1991. A review of methods for diet analysis in piscivorous marine mammals. Oceanography and Marine Biology 29:409-486.
71. Pierce, G. J., P. R. Boyle, J. Watt and M. Grisley 1993. Recent advances in diet analysis of marine mammals. Symposium of Zoological Society of London 66:241-261.
72. Pierce, G. J., M. B. Santos and S. Cervino 2007. Assessing sources of variation underlying estimates of cetacean diet composition: A simulation study on analysis of harbour porpoise diet in Scottish (UK) waters. Journal Of The Marine Biological Association Of The United Kingdom 87:213-221.
73. Pitcher, K. W. 1981. Stomach contents and faeces as indicators of harbor seal, Phoca vitulina, foods in the Gulf of Alaska. Fishery Bulletin 78:797-798.
74. Prime, J. H. 1979. Observations on the digestion of some gadoid fish otoliths by a young common seal. ICES Marine Mammals Committee:CM 1979/N:1914.
75. Prime, J. H., and P. S. Hammond 1987. Quantitative assessment of gray seal diet from fecal analysis. Pages 165-181 in A. C. Huntley, D. P. Costa, G. A. J. Worthy and M. A. Castellini, eds. Approaches to marine mammal energetics. Special Publication Number 1, The Society for Marine Mammalogy.
76. Robbins, C. T. 1983. Wildlife feeding and nutrition. Academic Press, Inc., Orlando, FL.
77. Santos, M. B., M. R. Clarke and G. J. Pierce 2001. Assessing the importance of cephalopods in the diets of marine mammals and other top predators: Problems and solutions. Fisheries Research 52:121-139.
78. Scott, T. 1903. Some further observations on the food of fishes, with an note on the food observed in the stomach of a common porpoise. Annual Report Fisheries Board of Scotland, Scientific Investigations 21:218-227.
79. Scharf, F. S., R. M. Yetter, A. P. Summers and F. Juanes 1998. Enhancing diet analyses of piscivorous fishes in the Northwest Atlantic through identification and reconstruction of original prey sizes from ingested remains. Fishery Bulletin 96:575-588.
80. Sheffield, G., and J. M. Grebmeier 2009. Pacific walrus (Odobenus rosmarus divergens): Differential prey digestion and diet. Marine Mammal Science 25:761-777.
81. Sheffield, G., F. H. Fay, H. Feder and B. P. Kelly 2001. Laboratory digestion of prey and interpretation of walrus stomach contents. Marine Mammal Science 17:310-330.
82. Tarkan, A. S., C. G. Gaygusuz, O. Gaygusuz and H. Acipinar 2007. Use of bone and otolith measures for size-estimation of fish in predator-prey studies. Folia Zoologica 56:328-336.
83. Thiemann, G. W., S. J. Iverson and I. Stirling 2008. Polar bear diets and arctic marine food webs: Insights from fatty acid analysis. Ecological Monographs 78:591-613.
84. Tollit, D. J., M. J. Steward, P. M. Thompson, G. J. Pierce, M. B. Santos and S. Hughes 1997. Species and size difference in the digestion of otoliths and beaks: Implications for estimates of pinniped diet composition. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 54:105-119.
85. Tollit, D. J., M. Wong, A. J. Winship, D. A. S. Rosen and A. W. Trites 2003. Quantifying errors associated with using prey skeletal structures from fecal samples to determine the diet of Steller's sea lion (Eumetopias jubatus). Marine Mammal Science 19:724-744.
86. Tollit, D. J., S. G. Heaslip, B. E. Deagle, S. I. Iverson, R. Joy, D. A. S. Rosen and A. W. Trites 2006. Estimating diet composition in sea lions: Which technigue to choose? Pages 293-308 in A. W. Trites, S. K. Atkinson, D. P. DeMaster, L. W. Fritz, T. S. Gelatt, L. D. Rea and K. M. Wynne, eds. Sea lions of the world. Alaska Sea Grant College Program AK-SG-06-01, Fairbanks, AK.
87. Tollit, D. J., S. G. Heaslip, R. L. Barrick and A. W. Trites 2007. Impact of diet-index selection and the digestion of prey hard remains on determining the diet of the Steller sea lion (Eumetopias jubatus). Canadian Journal of Zoology 85:1-15.
88. Tollit, D. J., A. D. Schulze, A. W. Trites, et al. 2009. Development and application of DNA techniques for validating and improving pinniped diet estimates. Ecological Applications 19:889-905.
89. Tollit, D., G. J. Pierce, K. A. Hobson, W. D. Bowen and S. J. Iverson 2010. Diet. Pages 165-190 in I. L. Boyd, W. D. Bowen and S. J. Iverson, eds. Marine mammal ecology and conservation: A handbook of techniques. Oxford University Press., Oxford, U.K.
90. Trumble, S. J., and M. A. Castellini 2005. Diet mixing in an aquatic carnivore, the harbour seal. Canadian Journal of Zoology 83:851-859.
91. Trzcinski, K. M., R. Mohn and D. W. Bowen 2006. Continued decline of an Atlantic cod population: How important is grey seal predation. Ecological Applications 16:2276-2292.
92. Tucker, S., D. W. Bowen and S. J. Iverson 2008. Convergence of diet estimates from fatty acids and stable isotopes, support for long-term integration of natural diets within individual grey seals. Marine Ecology Progress Series 354:267-276.
93. Wang, S. W., T. E. Hollmen and S. J. Iverson 2010. Validating quantitative fatty acid signature analysis to estimate diets of spectacled and Steller's eiders (Somateria fischeri and Polysticta stelleri). Journal of Comparative Physiology B-Biochemical Systemic and Environmental Physiology 180:125-139.
94. Zijlstra, M., and M. R. Vaneerden 1995. Pellet production and the use of otoliths in determining the diet of cormorants Phalacrocorax carbo sinensis: Trials with captive birds. Ardea 83:123-131.