The effectiveness of evidence-based treatments for personality disorders when comparing treatment-as-usual and bona fide treatments

Clinical Psychology Review

Volumn 33, Issue 8, 2013, Pages 1057-1066

  Budge, Stephanie L ^a   Moore, Jonathan T ^a   Del Re, A C ^b   Wampold, Bruce E ^c,d   Baardseth, Timothy P ^e   Nienhuis, Jacob B ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF LOUISVILLE   (United States)

^b STANFORD UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN MADISON   (United States)

^d MODUM BAD PSYCHIATRIC CENTER   (Norway)

^e HINES VA HOSPITAL   (United States)

Author keywords

Bona fide treatments; Evidence based treatments; Meta analysis; Personality disorders; Treatment as usual

Indexed keywords

CLINICAL RESEARCH; CODING; EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE; HOSPITAL PATIENT; HUMAN; INFORMATION RETRIEVAL; MEDICAL EDUCATION; OUTPATIENT; PERSONALITY DISORDER; PSYCHOLOGIC ASSESSMENT; PSYCHOTHERAPY; REVIEW;

BONA FIDE TREATMENTS; EVIDENCE-BASED TREATMENTS; META-ANALYSIS; PERSONALITY DISORDERS; TREATMENT-AS-USUAL;

COGNITIVE THERAPY; EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE; HUMANS; PERSONALITY DISORDERS; PSYCHOTHERAPY; TREATMENT OUTCOME;

EID: 84884385304     PISSN: 02727358     EISSN: 18737811     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1016/j.cpr.2013.08.003     Document Type: Review

References (67)

1. American Psychiatric Association Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed. revised) 2000, Author, Washington, DC.
2. Baardseth T.P., Goldberg S.B., Pace B.T., Minami T., Wislocki A.P., Frost N.D., Wampold B.E. Cognitive-Behavioral Therapy versus Other Therapies: Redux. Clinical psychology review. 2013, 33:395-405.
3. Bateman A.W., Fonagy P. Effectiveness of psychotherapeutic treatment of personality disorder. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2000, 177:138-143. 10.1192/bjp.177.2.138.
4. Bateman A., Fonagy P. Randomized controlled trial of outpatient mentalization-based treatment versus structured clinical management for borderline personality disorder. Focus 2010, 8(1):55-65.
5. Bender D.S. Treatment for borderline personality disorder: Perils of the randomized controlled trial paradigm. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 2011, 123(5):323-324.
6. Benish S.G., Imel Z.E., Wampold B.E. he relative efficacy of bona fide psychotherapies for treating post-traumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons. Clinical Psychology Review 2008, 28:746-758. 10.1016/j.cpr.2007.10.005.
7. Binks C.A., Fenton M., McCarthy L., Lee T., Adams C.E., Duggan C. Psychological therapies for people with borderline personality disorder. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 2006, 1. (CD005652).
8. Binks C.A., Fenton M., McCarthy L., Lee T., Adams C.E., Duggan C. Pharmacological interventions for people with borderline personality disorder. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 2006, 1:CD005653.
9. Chambless D.L., Hollon S. Defining empirically supported therapies. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1998, 66:7-18. 10.1037/0022-006X.66.1.7.
10. Clum G.A., Clum G.A., Surls R. A meta-analysis of treatments for panic disorder. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1993, 61:317-326. 10.1037/0022-006X.61.2.317.
11. Cohen J. Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences 1977, Academic Press, New York, NY.
12. Crits-Cristoph P., Barber J.P. Psychological treatments for personality disorders. A guide to treatments that work 2002, Oxford University Press, New York, NY. 2nd ed.
13. Davidson K., Norrie J., Tyrer P., Gumley A., Tata P., Murray H., et al. The effectiveness of cognitive behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder: Results from the borderline personality disorder study of cognitive therapy (BOSCOT) trial. Journal of Personality Disorders 2006, 20(5):450-465. 10.1521/pedi.2006.20.5.450.
14. Davidson K.M., Tyrer P., Tata P., Cooke D., Gumley A., Crawford M.J. Cognitive behaviour therapy for violent men with antisocial personality disorder in the community: An exploratory randomized controlled trial. Psychological Medicine 2009, 39:569-577. 10.1017/S0033291708004066.
15. Davidson P.R., Parker K.C. Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR): A meta-analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2001, 69:305-316. 10.1037/0022-006X.69.2.305.
16. Del Re A.C., Hoyt W.T. MAc: Meta-analysis with correlations. R package (version 1.0.6.) Retrieved from. http://CRAN.R-project.org/package=MAc.
17. Duggan C., Huband N., Smailagic N., Ferriter M., Adams C. The use of pharmacological treatments for people with personality disorder: A systematic review of randomized controlled trials. Personality and Mental Health 2008, 2:119-170. 10.1002/pmh.41.
18. Falkai P., Möller H.J. Emotional status: Diagnosis and treatment for severe psychiatric disorders. European Archives of Psychiatry and Clinical Neuroscience 2012, 1-2.
19. Gabbard G.O. Psychotherapy of personality disorders. Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research 2000, 9:1-6.
20. Gibbon S., Völlm B.A., Duggan C., Khalifa N., Stoffers J., Huband N., et al. Pharmacological and psychological interventions for antisocial personality disorder-Results of two Cochrane reviews. European Psychiatric Review 2011, 2011(4):52-58.
21. †Giesen-Bloo J., van Dyck R., Spinhoven P., van Tilburg W., Dirksen C., van Asselt T., et al. Outpatient psychotherapy for borderline personality disorder: Randomized trial of schema-focused therapy vs. transference-focused psychotherapy. Archives of General Psychiatry 2006, 63:649-659. 10.1001/archpsyc.63.6.649.
22. Gude T., Hoffart A. Change in interpersonal problems after cognitive agoraphobia and schema-focused therapy versus psychodynamic treatment as usual of inpatients with agoraphobia with Cluster C personality disorders. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology 2008, 49:195-199. 10.1111/j.1467-9450.2008.00629.x.
23. Hadjipavlou G., Ogrodniczuk J.S. Promising psychotherapies for personality disorders. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 2010, 55:202-210.
24. Hedges L.V., Olkin I. Statistical methods for meta-analysis 1985, Academic Press, New York, NY.
25. Henderson A.R. A substantive theory of recovery from the effects of severe persistent mental illness. The International Journal of Social Psychiatry 2011, 57(6):564-573.
26. Høglend P., Hersoug A.G., Bøgwald K.P., Amlo S., Marble A., Sørbye Ø., et al. Effects of transference work in the context of therapeutic alliance and quality of object relations. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2011, 79(5):697-706.
27. Imel Z.E., Wampold B.E., Miller S.D., Fleming R.R. Distinctions without a difference: Direct comparisons of psychotherapies of for alcohol use disorders. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors 2008, 22:533-543. 10.1037/a0013171.
28. Kopta S.M., Howard K.I., Lowry J.L., Beutler L.E. Patterns of symptomatic recovery in psychotherapy. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 1994, 62(5):1009-1016.
29. Leichsenring F., Leibing E., Kruse J., New A.S., Leweke F. Borderline personality disorder. Lancet 2011, 377(9759):74-84.
30. Leischsenring F., Leibing E. The effectiveness of psychodynamic therapy and cognitive behavior therapy in the treatment of personality disorders: A meta-analysis. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2003, 160:1223-1232. 10.1176/appi.ajp.160.7.1223.
31. Leichsenring F., Rabung S. Long-term psychodynamic psychotherapy in complex mental disorders: Update of a meta-analysis. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2011, 199(1):15-22.
32. Lenzenweger M.F. Epidemiology of personality disorders. Psychiatric Clinics of North America 2008, 31:395-403. 10.1016/j.psc.2008.03.003.
33. Linehan M. Skills training manual for treating borderline personality disorder 1993, Guilford Press, New York.
34. Linehan M.M., Comtois K.A., Murray A.M., Brown M.Z., Gallop R.J., Heard H.L., et al. Two-year randomized controlled trial and follow-up of dialectical behavior therapy vs. therapy by experts for suicidal behaviors and borderline personality disorder. Archives of General Psychiatry 2006, 63:757-766. 10.1001/archpsyc.63.7.757.
35. Linehan M.M., Schmidt H., Dimeff L.A., Craft J.C., Kanter J., Comtois K.A. Dialectical behavior therapy for patients with borderline personality disorder and drug-dependence. The American Journal on Addictions 1999, 8:279-292. 10.1080/105504999305686.
36. Linehan M.M., Tutek D.A., Heard H.L., Armstrong H.E. Interpersonal outcome of cognitive behavioral treatment for chronically suicidal borderline patients. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1994, 151:1771-1776.
37. McMain S. Effectiveness of psychosocial treatments on suicidality in personality disorders. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 2007, 52:103-114.
38. Miller S., Wampold B., Varhely K. Direct comparisons of treatment modalities for youth disorders: A meta-analysis. Psychotherapy Research 2008, 18:5-14. 10.1080/10503300701472131.
39. Moher D., Liberati A., Tetzlaff J., Altman D.G., The PRISMA Group Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Medicine 2009, 6(7):e1000097. 10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097.
40. Minami T., Wampold B.E., Serlin R.C., Hamilton E.G., Brown G.S.J., Kircher J.C. Benchmarking the effectiveness of psychotherapy treatment for adult depression in a managed care environment: A preliminary study. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 2008, 76(1):116.
41. Ogrodniczuk J.S., Piper W.E. Day treatment for personality disorders: A review of research findings. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 2001, 9:105-117. 10.1080/10673220127889.
42. Paris J. Pharmacological treatments for personality disorders. International Review of Psychiatry 2011, 23:303-309. 10.3109/09540261.2011.586993.
43. Perry J.C., Bond M. Empirical studies of psychotherapy for personality disorders. Psychotherapy for personality disorders 2000, 1-31. American Psychiatric Publishing, Washington, D.C. J.G. Gunderson, G.O. Gabbard (Eds.).
44. Perry J.C., Banon E., Ianni F. Effectiveness of psychotherapy for personality disorders. The American Journal of Psychiatry 1999, 156:1312-1321.
45. Persons J.B., Gross J.J., Etkin M.S., Madan S.K. Psychodynamic therapists' reservations about cognitive-behavioral therapy: Implications for training and practice. Journal of Psychotherapy Practice and Research 1996, 5(3):202-212.
46. Project MATCH Research Group Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Project MATCH post-treatment drinking outcomes. Journal of Studies on Alcohol 1997, 58:7-29.
47. Raudenbush S.W., Bryk A.S. Hierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis methods 2002, Sage, Newbury Park, CA. 2nd ed.
48. Rosenzweig S. Some implicit common factors in diverse methods in psychotherapy. The American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 1936, 6:412-415. 10.1111/j.1939-0025.1936.tb05248.x.
49. Ruegg R., Frances A. New research on personality disorders. Journal of Personality Disorders 1995, 9:1-48. 10.1521/pedi.1995.9.1.1.
50. Samuels J. Personality disorders: Epidemiology and public health issues. International Review of Psychiatry 2011, 23:223-233. 10.3109/09540261.2011.588200.
51. Sanislow C.A., McGlashan T.H. Treatment outcome of personality disorders. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 1998, 43:237-250.
52. Shea M.T. Psychosocial treatment of personality disorders. Journal of Personality Disorders 1993, 7:167-180.
53. Siedler G.H., Wagner F.E. Comparing the efficacy of EMDR and trauma focused cognitive behavioral therapy in the treatment of PTSD: A meta-analytic study. Psychological Medicine 2006, 36:1515-1522. 10.1017/S0033291706007963.
54. Skodol A.E., Gunderson J.G., McGlashan T.H., Dyck I.R., Stout R.L., Bender D.S., et al. Functional impairment in patients with schizotypal, borderline, avoidant, and obsessive-compulsive personality disorder. The American Journal of Psychiatry 2002, 159(2):276-283.
55. Soeteman D.I., Verhuel R., Meerman A.M., Ziegler U., Rossum B.V., Delimon J., et al. Cost-effectiveness of psychotherapy for cluster C personality disorders: A decision-analytic model in the Netherlands. The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 2011, 72:51-59. 10.4088/JCP.09m05228blu.
56. Soeteman D.I., Verhuel R., Delimon J., Meerman A.M., van den Eijnden E., Rossum B.V., et al. Cost-effetiveness of psychotherapy for cluster B personality disorders. The British Journal of Psychiatry 2010, 196:396-403. 10.1192/bjp.bp.109.070482.
57. Spielmans G., Gatlin E., McFall J. The efficacy of evidence-based psychotherapies versus usual care for youths: Controlling confounds in a meta-reanalysis. Psychotherapy Research 2010, 20:234-246. 10.1080/10503300903311293.
58. Spielmens G.I., Pasek L.F., McFall J.P. What are the active ingredients in cognitive and behavioral psychotherapy for anxious and depressed children? A meta-analytic review. Clinical Psychology Review 2007, 27:642-654. 10.1016/j.cpr.2006.06.001.
59. Stoffers J., Völlm B.A., Rücker G., Timmer A., Huband N., Lieb K. Pharmacological interventions for borderline personality disorder. Cochrane Database Systematic Review 2010, 6:CD005653.
60. Trijsburg R.W., Semeniuk T., Perry J.C. An empirical study of the differences in interventions between psychodynamic and cognitive-behavioural therapy for recurrent depression. Canadian Journal of Psychoanalysis 2004, 12:325-345.
61. Verheul R., Herbrink M. The efficacy of various modalities of psychotherapy for personality disorders: A systematic review of the evidence and clinical recommendations. International Review of Psychiatry 2007, 19:25-38. 10.1080/09540260601095399.
62. Viechtbauer W. Bias and efficiency of meta-analytic variance estimators in the random-effects model. Journal of Educational and Behavioral Statistics 2005, 30:261-293. 10.3102/10769986030003261.
63. Wampold B.E., Budge S.L., Laska K.M., Del Re A.C., Baardseth T.P., Flückiger, et al. Evidence-based treatments for depression and anxiety versus treatment-as-usual: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons. Clinical Psychology Review 2011, 31:1304-1312. 10.1016/j.cpr.2011.07.012.
64. Wampold B.E., Mondin G.W., Moody M., Stich F., Benson K., Ahn H. A meta-analysis of outcome studies comparing bona fide psychotherapies: Empirically, "all must have prizes". Psychological Bulletin 1997, 122:203-215. 10.1037/0033-2909.122.3.203.
65. Wampold B.E., Serlin R.C. Meta-analytic methods to test relative efficacy. Quality and Quantity 2013, 1-11. 10.1007/s11135-012-9800-6.
66. Weisz J.R., Jensen-Doss A., Hawley K.M. Evidence-based youth psychotherapies versus usual clinical care: A meta-analysis of direct comparisons. American Psychologist 2006, 61:671-689.
67. Westen D., Novotny C.M., Thompson-Brenner H. The empirical status of empirically supported psychotherapies: Assumptions, findings, and reporting in controlled clinical trials. Psychological Bulletin 2004, 130:631-663. 10.1037/0033-2909.130.4.631.