Variation in the heritability of educational attainment: An international meta-analysis

Social Forces

Volumn 92, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 109-140

  Branigan, Amelia R ^a   Mccallum, Kenneth J ^a   Freese, Jeremy ^a  

^a NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84882606510     PISSN: 00377732     EISSN: 15347605     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1093/sf/sot076     Document Type: Article

References (92)

1. Alexander, Karl L., and Bruce K. Eckland. 1974. "Sex Differences in the Educational Attainment Process." American Sociological Review 39:668-82.
2. Alford, John R., Carolyn L. Funk, and John R. Hibbing. 2005. "Are Political Orientations Genetically Transmitted?" American Political Science Review 99:153-67.
3. Ashenfelter, Orley, and Alan Krueger. 1994. "Estimates of the Economic Return to Schooling from a New Sample of Twins." American Economic Review 84:1157-73.
4. Bailey, J. Michael, Richard C. Pillard, Michael C. Neale, and Yvonne Agyei. 1993. "Heritable Factors Influence Sexual Orientation in Women." Archives of General Psychiatry 50:217-23.
5. Baker, Laura A., Susan A. Treloar, Chandra A. Reynolds, Andrew C. Heath, and Nicholas G. Martin. 1996. "Genetics of Educational Attainment in Australian Twins: Sex Differences and Secular Changes." Behavior Genetics 26(2):13.
6. Behrman, Jere R., and Paul Taubman. 1989. "Is Schooling 'Mostly in the Genes'? Nature-Nurture Decomposition Using Data on Relatives." Journal of Political Economy 97:1425.
7. Behrman, Jere R., Paul Taubman, and Terence Wales. 1977. "Controlling for and Measuring the Effects of Genetics and Family Environment in Equations for Schooling and Labor Market Success." In Kinometrics: Determinants of Socioeconomic Success Within and Between Families. New York: North- Holland Publishing Company.
8. Benjamin, Daniel J., David Cesarini, Matthijs J. H. M. van der Loos, Christopher T. Dawes, Philipp D. Koellinger, Patrik K. E. Magnusson, Christopher F. Chabris, Dalton Conley, David Laibson, Magnus, Johannesson, and Peter M. Visscher. 2012. "The Genetic Architecture of Economic and Political Preferences." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
9. Bingley, Paul, Kaare Christensen, and Ian Walker. 2005. "Twin-Based Estimates of the Returns to Education: Evidence from the Population of Danish Twins." Aarhus, Denmark: Aarhus Business School.
10. Björklund, Anders, Markus Jäntti, and Gary Solon. 2003. "Influences of Nature and Nurture on Earnings Variation: A Report on a Study of Various Sibling Types in Sweden." In Unequal Chances: Family Background and Economic Success, edited by S. Bowles, H. Gintis, and M. Osborne. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
11. Boardman, Jason D. 2009. "State-Level Moderation of Genetic Tendencies to Smoke." American Journal of Public Health 99:480-86.
12. Boardman, Jason D., Jonathan Daw, and Jeremy Freese. Forthcoming. "Defining the Environment in Gene- Environment Research: Lessons from Social Epidemiology." American Journal of Public Health.
13. Boardman, Jason D., Jarron M. Saint Onge, Brett C. Haberstick, David S. Timberlake, and John K. Hewitt. 2008. "Do Schools Moderate the Genetic Determinants of Smoking?" Behavior Genetics 38:13.
14. Boomsma, Dorret, Gonneke Willemsen, Conor V. Dolan, Louise C. Hawkley, and John T. Cacioppo. 2005. "Genetic and Environmental Contributions to Loneliness in Adults: The Netherlands Twin Register Study." Behavior Genetics 35:745-52.
15. Booth, Alison, and Hiau Joo Kee. 2009. "The University Gender Gap in Australia: A Long-run Perspective." Paper presented at the Conference Australian Economic History in the Long Run, Canberra, Australia, March 26-27.
16. Borgers, N., J. Dronkers, L. Rollenberg, M. D. R. Evans, and J. Kelley. 1995. "The Decline of the Family and Educational Resemblance Between Australian Siblings: Birth Cohorts, Migration, Divorce, and Working Mothers." Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Sociological Association, Washington, D.C.
17. Bouchard, Thomas J., and Matt McGue. 1981. "Familial Studies of Intelligence: A Review." Science 212:1055-59.
18. Breen, Richard, Ruud Luijkx, Walter Müller, and Reinhard Pollak. 2010. "Long-term Trends in Educational Inequality in Europe: Class Inequalities and Gender Differences." European Sociological Review 26:31-48.
19. Clausson, Britt, Paul Lichtenstein, and Sven Cnattingius. 2000. "Genetic Influence on Birthweight and Gestational Length Determined by Studies in Offspring of Twins." BJOG: An International Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology 107:375-81.
20. Cochran, William G. 1954. "The Combination of Estimates from Different Experiments." Biometrics 10:101-29.
21. Cooper, Harris, Larry V. Hedges, and Jeffrey C. Valentine. 1994. The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.
22. De Graaf, Paul M., and Johannes J. Huinink. 1992. "Trends in Measured and Unmeasured Effects of Family Background on Educational Attainment and Occupational Status in the Federal Republic of Germany." Social Science Research 21:28.
23. Dempster, A. P., N. M. Laird, and D. B. Rubin. 1977. "Maximum Likelihood from Incomplete Data via the EM Algorithm." Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B (Methodological) 39:1-38.
24. Devlin, B., Michael Daniels, and Kathryn Roeder. 1997. "The Heritability of IQ." Nature 388:468-71.
25. Diewald, Martin. 2010. "On Genetic Variation and Social Inequality." Zeitschrift für Soziologie 39:4-21.
26. Dronkers, J. 1993a. "Is the Importance of Family Decreasing? Evidence Regarding Dutch Sibling Data and Educational Attainment." Pp. 267-78 in Adolescence, Careers, and Cultures, edited by W. Meeus, M. de Goede, W. Kox, and K. Hurrelman. Berlin/New York: DeGruyter.
27. Dronkers, J. 1993b. "Educational Reform in the Netherlands: Did It Change the Impact of Parental Occupation and Education?" Sociology of Education 6(4):262-77.
28. Duncan, L. E., and M. C. Keller. 2011. "A Critical Review of the First 10 Years of Candidate Gene-by- Environment Interaction Research in Psychiatry." American Journal of Psychiatry 168(10):1041-49.
29. Dunne, M. P., N. G. Martin, D. J. Statham, W. S. Slutske, S. H. Dinwiddie, K. K. Bucholz, P. A. F. Madden, and A. C. Heath. 1997. "Genetic and Environmental Contributions to Variance in Age at First Sexual Intercourse." Psychological Science 8:211-16.
30. Durbin, Nancy E., and Lori Kent. 1989. "Postsecondary Education of White Women in 1900." Sociology of Education 62(1):1-13.
31. Eckland, Bruce K. 1967. "Genetics and Sociology: A Reconsideration." American Sociological Review 32:173-94.
32. Esping-Andersen, Gøsta. 1990. The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
33. Everett, Bethany G., Richard G. Rogers, Patrick M. Krueger, and Robert A. Hummer. 2007. "Trends in Educational Attainment by Sex, Race/Ethnicity, and Nativity in the United States, 1989-2005." Working paper, Population Program, Institute of Behavioral Science, University of Colorado at Boulder, Boulder, CO. http://www.colorado.edu/ibs/pubs/pop/pop2007-0007.pdf.
34. Feldman, M. W., and R. C. Lewontin. 1975. "The Heritability Hang-Up." Science 190:1163-68.
35. Fowler, James H., Laura A. Baker, and Christopher T. Dawes. 2008. "Genetic Variation in Political Participation." American Political Science Review 102:233-48.
36. Freese, Jeremy. 2008. "Genetics and the Social Science Explanation of Individual Outcomes." American Journal of Sociology 114:35.
37. Goldberger, Arthur S. 1979. "Heritability." Economica 46:327-47.
38. Guo, Guang, Michael E. Roettger, and Tianji Cai. 2008. "The Integration of Genetic Propensities into Social- Control Models of Delinquency and Violence among Male Youths." American Sociological Review 73:543-68.
39. Guo, Guang, and Elizabeth Stearns. 2002. "The Social Influences on the Realization of Genetic Potential for Intellectual Development." Social Forces 80:881-910.
40. Hatemi, Peter K., John R. Hibbing, Sarah E. Medland, Matthew C. Keller, John R. Alford, Kevin B. Smith, Nicholas G. Martin, and Lindon J. Eaves. 2010. "Not by Twins Alone: Using the Extended Family Design to Investigate Genetic Influence on Political Beliefs." American Journal of Political Science 54:798-814.
41. Hauser, Robert M., and David L. Featherman. 1974. "Socioeconomic Achievements of U.S. Men, 1962 to 1972." Science 185:325-31.
42. Hauser, Robert M., and Peter A. Mossel. 1985. "Fraternal Resemblance in Educational Attainment and Occupational Status." American Journal of Sociology 91:650-73.
43. Hauser, Robert M., and Raymond Sin-Kwok Wong. 1989. "Sibling Resemblance and Intersibling Effects in Educational Attainment." Sociology of Education 62:149-71.
44. Heath, A. C., K. Berg, L. J. Eaves, M. H. Salaas, L. A. Corey, J. Sundet, P. Magnus, and W. E. Nance. 1985. "Education Policy and the Heritability of Educational Attainment." Nature 314:734-6.
45. Heath, A. C., K. K. Bucholz, P. A. F. Madden, S. H. Dinwiddie, W. S. Slutske, L. J. Bierut, D. J. Statham, M. P. Dunne, J. B. Whitfield, and N. G. Martin. 1997. "Genetic and Environmental Contributions to Alcohol Dependence Risk in a National Twin Sample: Consistency of Findings in Women and Men." Psychological Medicine 27:1381-96.
46. Higgins, Julian P. T., and Simon G. Thompson. 2002. "Quantifying Heterogeneity in a Meta-Analysis." Statistics in Medicine 21:1539-58.
47. Higgins, Julian P. T., Simon G. Thompson, Jonathan J. Deeks, and Douglas G. Altman. 2003. "Measuring Inconsistency in Meta-Analyses." BMJ 327:557-60.
48. Hill, William G., Michael E. Goddard, and Peter M. Visscher, 2008. "Data and Theory Point to Mainly Additive Genetic Variance for Complex Traits." PloS Genetics 4:10.
49. Huedo-Medina, Tania B., Julio Sánchez-Meca, Juan Botella, and Fulgencio Marín-Martínez. 2006. "Assessing Heterogeneity in Meta-Analysis: Q Statistic or I2 Index?" Psychological Methods 11:14.
50. Isacsson, Gunnar. 1999. "Estimates of the return to schooling in Sweden from a large sample of twins." Labour Economics 6(4):471-89.
51. Jencks, C. 1980. "Heredity, Environment, and Public Policy Reconsidered." American Sociological Review 45:723-36.
52. Jencks, Christopher, and Laura Tach. 2006. "Would Equal Opportunity Mean More Mobility?" Pp. 23-58 in S. Morgan, D. Grusky, and G. Fields, eds., Mobility and Inequality: Frontiers of Research from Sociology and Economics. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.
53. Kato, Kenji, and Nancy Pedersen. 2005. "Personality and Coping: A Study of Twins Reared Apart and Twins Reared Together." Behavior Genetics 35:147-58.
54. Kendler, Kenneth S., Margaret Gatz, Charles O. Gardner, and Nancy L. Pedersen. 2006. "A Swedish National Twin Study of Lifetime Major Depression." American Journal of Psychiatry 163:6.
55. Kuo, Hsiang-Hui Daphne, and Robert M. Hauser. 1995. "Trends in Family Effects on the Education of Black and White Brothers." Sociology of Education 68:136-60.
56. Kuo, Hsiang-Hui Daphne, and Robert M. Hauser. 1997. "How Does Size of Sibship Matter? Family Configuration and Family Effects on Educational Attainment." Social Science Research 26:25.
57. Li, Ming D., Rong Cheng, Jennie Z. Ma, and Gary E. Swan. 2003. "A Meta-Analysis of Estimated Genetic and Environmental Effects on Smoking Behavior in Male and Female Adult Twins." Addiction 98:23-31.
58. Lowe, Roy, ed. 2012. Education & the Second World War: Studies in Schooling & Social Change. New York: Routledge.
59. Lykken, D. T., T. J. Bouchard, M. McGue, and A. Tellegen. 1990. "The Minnesota Twin Family Registry: Some Initial Findings." Acta geneticae medicae et gemellologiae 39:35.
60. Manski, Charles F. 2011. "Genes, Eyeglasses, and Social Policy." Journal of Economic Perspectives 25(4):9.
61. Martin, Nicolas W., Sarah E. Medland, Karin J. H. Verweij, S. Hong Lee, Dale R. Nyholt, Pamela A. Madden, Andrew C. Heath, Grant W. Montgomery, Margaret J. Wright, and Nicholas G. Martin. 2011. "Educational Attainment: A Genome-Wide Association Study in 9538 Australians." PLoS ONE 6(6):8.
62. McGue, Matt, and David T. Lykken. 1992. "Genetic Influence on Risk of Divorce." Psychological Science 3:6.
63. McGuire, Shirley, Jenae M. Neiderhiser, David Reiss, E. Mavis Hetherington, and Robert Plomin. 1994. "Genetic and Environmental Influences on Perceptions of Self-Worth and Competence in Adolescence: A Study of Twins, Full Siblings, and Step-Siblings." Child Development 65:785-99.
64. Miller, Paul, Charles Mulvey, and Nick Martin. 1997. "Family Characteristics and the Returns to Schooling: Evidence on Gender Differences from a Sample of Australian Twins." Economica 64:137-54.
65. Moayyeri A., C. J. Hammond, A. M. Valdes, T. D. Spector. 2012. "Cohort Profile: TwinsUK and Healthy Ageing Twin Study." International Journal of Epidemiology.
66. Murray, Sheila E., William N. Evans, and Robert M. Schwab. 1998. "Education-Finance Reform and the Distribution of Education Resources." American Economic Review 88:789-812.
67. Neale, Michael C., and Hermine H. M. Maes. 2004. Methodology for Genetic Studies of Twins and Families. Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers B.V.
68. Nielsen, François. 2006. "Achievement and Ascription in Educational Attainment: Genetic and Environmental Influences on Adolescent Schooling." Social Forces 85:193-216.
69. Nielsen, François. 2008. "The Nature of Social Reproduction: Two Paradigms of Social Mobility." Sociologica 3. doi: 10.2383/28771.
70. Núñez, Clara Eugenia. 2003. "Within the European Periphery: Education and Labor Mobility in Twentieth- Century Spain." Paedagogica Historica 39:621-49.
71. Olson, James M., Philip A. Vernon, Julie Aitken Harris, and Kerry L. Jang. 2001. "The Heritability of Attitudes: A Study of Twins." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 80:845-60.
72. Pedersen, Nancy L., Robert Plomin, Gerald E. McClearn, and Lars Friberg. 1988. "Neuroticism, Extraversion, and Related Traits in Adult Twins Reared Apart and Reared Together." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 55:950-57.
73. Plomin, Robert, John C. DeFries, Gerald E. McClearn, and Peter McGuffin. 2008. Behavioral Genetics, 5th Edition. New York: Worth Publishers.
74. Robinson, JoAnn L., Jerome Kagan, J. Steven Reznick, and Robin Corley. 1992. "The Heritability of Inhibited and Uninhibited Behavior: A Twin Study." Developmental Psychology 28:1030-37.
75. Rowe, David C. 1994. "The Limits of Family In?uence: Genes, Experience, and Behavior." New York: Guilford Press.
76. Rowe, David C., Kristen C. Jacobson, and Edwin J. C. G. van den Oord. 1999. "Genetic and Environmental Influences on Vocabulary IQ: Parental Education Level as Moderator." Child Development 70:1151-62.
77. Rushton, J. Philippe, David W. Fulker, Michael C. Neale, David K. B. Nias, and Hans J. Eysenck. 1986. "Altruism and Aggression: The Heritability of Individual Differences." Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 50:1192-98.
78. Scourfield, J., N. Martin, G. Lewis, and P. McGuffin. 1999. "Heritability of Social Cognitive Skills in Children and Adolescents." British Journal of Psychiatry 175:559-64.
79. Sieben, Inge, and Paul M. de Graaf. 2003. "The Total Impact of the Family on Educational Attainment." European Societies 5:35.
80. Silventoinen, Karri, Robert F. Krueger, Thomas J. Bouchard, Jaakko Kaprio, and Matt McGue. 2004. "Heritability of Body Height and Educational Attainment in an International Context: Comparison of Adult Twins in Minnesota and Finland." American Journal of Human Biology 16:544-55.
81. Smith, Herbert L., and Paul P. L. Cheung. 1986. "Trends in the Effects of Family Background on Educational Attainment in the Philippines." American Journal of Sociology 91:1387-408.
82. Sung, Joohon, Sung-Il Cho, Yun-Mi Song, Kayoung Lee, Eun-Young Choi, Mina Ha, Jihae Kim, H. O. Kim, Yeonju Kim, Eun-Kyung Shin, Yoon-Hee Kim, Keun-Young Yoo, Chan Park, and Kuchan Kimm. 2006. "Do We Need More Twin Studies? The Healthy Twin Study, Korea." International Journal of Epidemiology 35:488-90.
83. Taubman, Paul. 1976. "The Determinants of Earnings: Genetics, Family, and Other Environments: A Study of White Male Twins." American Economic Review 66:858-70.
84. Thompson, Lee, Douglas Detterman, and Robert Plomin. 1993. "Differences in Heritability across Groups Differing in Ability, Revisited." Behavior Genetics 23:331-36.
85. Toka, Gabor, and Jaap Dronkers. 1996. "Sibling Resemblance in Educational Attainment, Occupational Prestige, and Wealth in Hungary during the Communist Regime." European Sociological Review 12:251-69.
86. Tozzi, Federica, Steven H. Aggen, Benjamin M. Neale, Charles B. Anderson, Suzanne E. Mazzeo, Michael C. Neale, and Cynthia M. Bulik. 2004. "The Structure of Perfectionism: A Twin Study." Behavior Genetics 34:483-94.
87. Turkheimer, Eric. 2000. "Three Laws of Behavior Genetics and What They Mean." Current Directions in Psychological Science 9:5.
88. Turkheimer, Eric. 2004. "Spinach and Ice Cream: Why Social Science Is So Difficult." Pp. 161-89 in Behavior Genetics Principles: Perspectives in Development, Personality, and Psychopathology, edited by L. DiLalla. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
89. Turkheimer, Eric, Andreana Haley, Mary Waldron, Brian D'Onofrio, and Irving I. Gottesman. 2003. "Socioeconomic Status Modifies Heritability of IQ in Young Children." Psychological Science 14:623-8.
90. Turkheimer, Eric, and Mary Waldron. 2000. "Nonshared Environment: A Theoretical, Methodological, and Quantitative Review." Psychological Bulletin 126:31.
91. Visscher, Peter M., Matthew A. Brown, Mark I. McCarthy, and Jian Yang. 2012. "Five Years of GWAS Discovery." American Journal of Human Genetics 90:7-24.
92. Winerman, Lea. 2004. "A Second Look at Twin Studies." Monitor on Psychology 35:46.