Marine mammal culling programs: Review of effects on predator and prey populations

Mammal Review

Volumn 43, Issue 3, 2013, Pages 207-220

  Bowen, W D ^a   Lidgard, Damian ^b  

^a BEDFORD INSTITUTE OF OCEANOGRAPHY   (Canada)

^b DALHOUSIE UNIVERSITY   (Canada)

Author keywords

Cetaceans; Pinnipeds; Predator control; Seals

Indexed keywords

ABUNDANCE; CETACEAN; CULLING; DOLPHIN; FISHERY MANAGEMENT; PINNIPED; POPULATION DENSITY; POPULATION DISTRIBUTION; POPULATION SIZE; PREDATOR CONTROL;

AVES; CETACEA; MAMMALIA; PINNIPEDIA;

EID: 84878778383     PISSN: 03051838     EISSN: 13652907     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1365-2907.2012.00217.x     Document Type: Review

References (107)

1. Andrewartha HG, Birch LC (1954) The Distribution and Abundance of Animals. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, USA.
2. Anonymous (1997) Wolves, Bears and Their Prey in Alaska. National Academy Press, Washington DC, USA.
3. Anonymous (1999) Protocol for the Scientific Evaluation of Proposals to Cull Marine Mammals. Report of the Scientific Advisory Committee of the Marine Mammals Action Plan. United Nations Enironmental Program, Rome, Italy.
4. Anonymous (2008) Report of the ICES Advisory Committee, 2008. ICES Advice, Copenhagen, Denmark.
5. Anonymous (2010) The State of the World Fisheries and Aquaculture. Fisheries and Aquaculture Department, The Food and Agriculture Oranization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy.
6. Anonymous (2011) Towards Recovered and Sustainable Groundfish Fisheries in Eastern Canada (FRCC.2011.R1). Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada, Ottawa, Canada.
7. Bax NJ (1991) A comparison of the fish biomass flow to fish, fisheries, and mammals in six marine ecosystems. ICES Marine Science Symposia 193: 217-224.
8. Bearzi G, Holcer D, Notarbartolo di Sciara G (2004) The role of historical dolphin takes and habitat degradation in shaping the present status of northern Adriatic cetaceans. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 14: 363-379.
9. Berger J, Stacey PB, Bellis L, Johnson MP (2001) A mammalian predator-prey imbalance: grizzly bear and wolf extinction affect avian neotropical migrants. Ecological Applications 11: 947-960.
10. Berger KM (2006) Carnivore-livestock conflicts: effects of subsidized predator control and economic correlates on the sheep industry. Conservation Biology 20: 751-761.
11. Bigg MA (1969) The Harbour Seal in British Columbia. Fisheries Research Board of Canada Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
12. Bigg MA (1984) Sighting and kill data of Steller sea lions (Eumetopia jubatus) and California sea lions (Zalophus californianus) from British Columbia during 1892-1982, with some records from Washington and southeastern Alaska. Canadian Data Report of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 460: 1-191.
13. Bigg MA (1985) Status of the Steller sea lion (Eumetopias jubatus) and California sea lion (Zalophus californianus) in British Columbia. Canadian Special Publication of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 77: 1-20.
14. Birkun AJ (2002) Interactions between cetaceans and fisheries in the Black Sea. In: Notarbartolo di Sciara G (ed.) Cetaceans of the Mediterranean and Black Seas: State of Knowledge and Conservation Strategies, Section 10, 1-11. Report to the ACCOBAMS Secretariat, Monaco.
15. Bonner WN (1989) Seals and man - a changing relationship. Biological Journal of the Linnean Society 38: 53-60.
16. Boulva J (1973) The harbor seal, Phoca vitulina concolor, in Eastern Canada. PhD thesis, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Canada.
17. Boulva J, McLaren IA (1979) Biology of the harbour seal, Phoca vitulina, in eastern Canada. Bulletin of the Fisheries Research Board of Canada 200: 1-24.
18. Burnett JAD, Ringler NH, Lantry BF, Johnson JH (2002) Impact of double-crested cormorant (Phalacrocorax auritus) piscivory on the yellow perch (Perca flavescens) populations in the eastern basin of Lake Ontario. Journal of Great Lakes Research 28: 202-211.
19. Butler JRA, Middlemas SJ, McKelvey SA, McMyn I, Leyshon B, Walker I etal. (2008) The Moray Firth Seal Management Plan: an adaptive framework for balancing the conservation of seals, salmon, fisheries and wildlife tourism in the UK. Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems 18: 1025-1038.
20. Butler JRA, Middlemas SJ, Graham IM, Harris RN (2011) Perceptions and costs of seal impacts on Atlantic salmon fisheries in the Moray Firth, Scotland: implications for the adaptive co-management of seal-fishery conflict. Marine Policy 35: 317-323.
21. Butterworth DS, Harwood J (1991) Report on the Benguela Ecology Programme workshop on seal-fishery biological interactions. Report of the Benguela Ecology Progamme of South Africa 22: 1-65.
22. Cote IM, Sutherland WJ (1997) The effectiveness of removing predators to protect bird populations. Conservation Biology 11: 395-405.
23. Crooks KR, Soule ME (1999) Mesopredator release and avifaunal extinctions in a fragmented landscape. Nature 400: 563-566.
24. David JHM, Cury P, Crawford RJM, Randall RM, Underhill LG, Meyer MA (2003) Assessing conservation priorities in the Benguela ecosystem, South Africa: analysing predation by seals on threatened seabirds. Biological Conservation 114: 289-292.
25. DeMaster DP, Sisson JE (1992) Pros and cons of pinniped management along the North American coast to abet fish stocks. In: McCullough DR, Barrett RH (eds) Wildlife 2001: Populations, 321-330. Elsevier Applied Science, London, UK and New York, USA.
26. Dorr BS, Aderman T, Butchko PH, Barras SC (2010) Management effects on breeding and foraging numbers and movements of double-crested cormorants in the Les Cheneaux Islands, Lake Huron, Michigan. Journal of Great Lakes Research 36: 224-231.
27. Dragesund O, Johannessen A, Ulltang O (1997) Variation in migration and abundance of Norwegian spring spawning herring (Clupea harengus L.). Sarsia 82: 97-105.
28. Errington PL (1946) Predtion and vertebrate populations. The Quarterly Review of Biology 21: 221-245.
29. Estes JA, Riedman ML, Staedler MM, Tinker MT, Lyon BE (2003) Individual variation in prey selection by sea otters: patterns, causes and implications. The Journal of Animal Ecology 72: 144-155.
30. Farquhar JF, Mazzocchi IM, McCullough RD (2004) Management of Double-Crested Cormorants in the Eastern Basin of Lake Ontario, 1999-2003: a Summary and Recommendations. New York State, Department of Environmental Conservation Special Report, Albany, New York, USA.
31. Fielder DG (2010) Response of yellow perch in Les Cheneaux Islands, Lake Huron to declining numbers of double-crested cormorants stemming from control activities. Journal of Great Lakes Research 36: 207-214.
32. Fiscus CH (1979) Interactions of marine mammals and Pacific hake. Marine Fisheries Review 10: 1-9.
33. Fletcher K, Aebischer NJ, Baines D, Foster R, Hoodless AN (2010) Changes in breeding success and abundance of ground-nesting moorland birds in relation to the experimental deployment of legal predator control. The Journal of Applied Ecology 47: 263-272.
34. Gerber LR, Morissette L, Kaschner K, Pauly D (2009) Should whales be culled to increase fishery yield? Science 323: 880-881.
35. Graham K, Beckerman AP, Thirgood S (2005) Human-predator-prey conflicts: ecological correlates, prey losses and patterns of management. Biological Conservation 122: 159-171.
36. Guillemette M, Brousseau P (2001) Does culling predatory gulls enhance the productivity of breeding common terns? The Journal of Applied Ecology 38: 1-8.
37. Gulland JA (1987) Seals and fisheries: a case for predator control? Trends in Ecology & Evolution 2: 102-103.
38. Hansson S, Rudstam LG (1990) Eutrophication and Baltic fish communities. Ambio 19: 123-125.
39. Hansson S, Hjerne O, Harvey C, Kitchell JF, Cox SP, Essington TE (2007) Managing Baltic Sea fisheries under contrasting production and predation regimes: ecosystem model analyses. Ambio 36: 265-271.
40. Harding KC, Harkonen TJ (1999) Development in the Baltic grey seal (Halichoerus grypus) and ringed seal (Phoca hispida) populations during the 20th century. Ambio 28: 619-627.
41. Harwood J, Greenwood JD (1985) Competition between British grey seals and fisheries. In: Beddington JR, Beverton RJH, Lavigne DM (eds) Marine Mammals and Fisheries, 153-169. George Allen & Unwin, London, UK.
42. Harwood J, Prime JH (1978) Some factors affecting the size of British grey seal populations. The Journal of Applied Ecology 15: 401-411.
43. Hauksson E (2007) Abundance of grey seals in Icelandic waters, based on trends of pup-counts from aerial surveys. NAMMCO Scientific Publications 6: 85-98.
44. Hauksson E, Bogason V (1997) Comparative feeding of grey (Halichoerus grypus) and common seals (Phoca vitulina) in coastal waters of Iceland, with a note on the diet of hooded (Cystophora cristata) and harp seals (Phoca groenlandica). Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science 22: 125-135.
45. Holt AR, Davies ZG, Tyler C, Staddon S (2008) Meta-analysis of the effects of predation on animal prey abundance: evidence from UK vertebrates. PLoS ONE 3: e2400.
46. Jackson JBC, Kirby MX, Berger WH, Bjorndal KA, Botsford LW, Bourque BJ etal. (2001) Historical overfishing and the recent collapse of coastal ecosystems. Science 293: 629-637.
47. Jenkins D, Watson A, Miller GR (1963) Population sudies on red grouse, Lagopus lagopus scoticus (Lath) in Northeast Scotland. The Journal of Animal Ecology 32: 317-376.
48. Johnson CN, Isaac JL, Fisher DO (2007) Rarity of a top predator triggers continent-wide collapse of mammal prey: dingoes and marsupials in Australia. Proceedings of The Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 274: 341-346.
49. Johnson JH, McCullough RD, Farquhar JF (2010) Double-Crested Cormorant Studies at Little Galloo Island, Lake Ontario in 2009: Diet Composition, Fish Consumption and the Efficacy of Management Activities in Reducing Fish Predation. Annual Report, Bureau of Fisheries Lake Ontario Unit and St. Lawrence River Unit, to the Great Lakes Fishery Commission's Lake Ontario Committee, Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA.
50. Kasuya T (1985) Fishery dolphin conflict in the Iki Island area of Japan. In: Beddington JR, Beverton RJH, Lavigne DM (eds) Marine Mammals and Fisheries, 253-275. Allen & Unwin, London, UK.
51. Kokko H, Helle E, Lindström J, Ranta E, Sipila T, Courchamp F (1999) Backcasting population sizes of ringed and grey seals in the Baltic and Lake Saimaa during the 20th century. Annales Zoologici Fennici 36: 65-73.
52. Komatsu M, Misaki S (2001) The Truth Behind the Whaling Dispute. Institute of Cetacean Research, Tokyo, Japan.
53. Königson S, Lunneryd S-G, Stridh H, Sundqvist F (2009) Grey seal predation in cod gillnet fisheries in the central Baltic Sea. Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fishery Science 42: 41-47.
54. Lantry BF, Eckert TH, Schneider CP, Chrisman JR (2002) The relationship between the abundance of smallmouth bass and double-crested cormorants in the eastern basin of Lake Ontario. Journal of Great Lakes Research 28: 193-201.
55. Lavigne DM (2003) Marine mammals and fisheries: the role of science in the culling debate. In: Gales N, Hindell M, Kirkwood R (eds) Marine Mammals: Fisheries, Tourism, and Management Issues, 31-47. CSIRO, Collingwood, Australia.
56. Lavigueur L, Hammill MO (1993) Distribution and seasonal movements of grey seals, Halichoerus grypus, born in the Gulf of St. Lawrence and Eastern Nova Scotia. The Canadian Field-Naturalist 107: 329-340.
57. Lelli B, Harris DE (2006) Seal bounty and seal protection laws in Maine, 1872 to 1972: historic perspectives on a current controversy. Natural Resources Journal 46: 881-924.
58. Lelli B, Harris DE, Aboueissa A-M (2009) Seal bounties in Maine and Massachusetts, 1888 to 1962. Northeastern Naturalist 16: 239-254.
59. Lensink CJ (1958) Predator Investigation and Control. Alaska Department of Fish and Game Annual Report No. 10. Juneau, Alaska. pp. 91-104. (unpublished). Available from Alaska Department of Fish and Game, Division of Wildlife Conservation, 525W.67th Avenue, Anchorage, Alaska 99518, USA.
60. Lessard RB, Martell S, Walters CJ, Essington TE, Kitchell JFK (2005) Should ecosystem management involve active control of species abundances? Ecology and Society 10: 1. online: http://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol10/iss2/art1
61. Letnic M, Koch F (2010) Are dingoes a trophic regulator in arid Australia? A comparison of mammal communities on either side of the dingo fence. Austral Ecology 35: 167-175.
62. Ling JK (1999) Exploitation of fur seals and sea lions from Australian, New Zealand and adjacent subantarctic islands during the eighteenth, nineteenth and twentieth centuries. The Australian Zoologist 31: 323-350.
63. Lotze HK, Worm B (2009) Historical baselines for large marine animals. Trends in Ecology & Evolution 24: 254-262.
64. Makhado AB, Meÿer MA, Crawford RJM, Underhill LG, Wilke C (2009) The efficacy of culling seals seen preying on seabirds as a means of reducing seabird mortality. African Journal of Ecology 47: 335-340.
65. Mansfield AW, Beck B (1977) The grey seal in eastern Canada. Fisheries and Marine Service Technical Report 704: 1-81.
66. McKinnell SM, Wood CC, Rutherford DT, Hyatt KD, Welch DW (2001) The demise of Owikeno Lake sockeye salmon. North American Journal of Fisheries Management 21: 774-791.
67. Merriam CH (1901) Food of sea lions. Science 13: 777-779.
68. Mitchell E (1975) Porpoise, Dolphin and Small Whale Fisheries of the World. Status and Problems. IUCN Monograph No 3., International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources, Gland, Switzerland and Cambridge, UK.
69. Nicholson AJ (1933) The balance of animal populations. The Journal of Animal Ecology 2: 132-178.
70. Nilssen KT, Haug T (2007) Status of grey seals (Halichoerus grypus) in Norway. NAMMCO Scientific Publications 6: 23-32.
71. Oien N (1988) The distribution of killer whales (Orcinus orca) in the North Atlantic based on Norwegian catches, 1938-1981, and incidental sightings, 1967-1987. Rit Fiskideildar 11: 65-78.
72. Olesiuk PF (2009) An Assessment of Population Trends and Abundance of Harbour Seals (Phoca vitulina) in British Columbia. Research Document 105. Canadian Science Advisory Secretariat, Ottawa, Canada.
73. Oro D, de León A, Minguez E, Furness RW (2005) Estimating predation on breeding European storm-petrels (Hydrobates pelagicus) by yellow-legged gulls (Larus michahellis). Journal of Zoology 265: 421-429.
74. Paine RT, Tegner MJ, Johnson EA (1998) Compounded perturbations yield ecological surprises. Ecosystems 1: 535-545.
75. Pearson JP, Verts BJ (1970) Abundance and distribution of harbor seals and northern fur seals in Oregon. Murrelet 51: 1-5.
76. Punt AE, Butterworth DS (1995) The effects of future consumption by the cape fur seal on catches and catch rates of the cape hakes. 4. Modellng the biological interaction between Cape fur seals Arctocephalus pusillus pusillus and the Cape hakes Merluccius capensis and M.paradoxus. South African Journal of Marine Science 16: 255-285.
77. Rae BB (1960) Seals and Scottish fisheries. Marine Research 2: 1-39.
78. Reynolds JC, Tapper SC (1996) Control of mammalian predators in game management and conservation. Mammal Review 26: 127-155.
79. Roberts C (2007) The Unnatural History of the Sea. Island Press, Washington DC, USA.
80. Sanz-Aguilar A, Martinez-Abrain A, Tavecchia G, Minguez E, Oro D (2009) Evidence-based culling of a facultative predator: efficacy and efficiency components. Biological Conservation 142: 424-431.
81. Scheffer M, Carpenter S, Foley JA, Folke C, Walker B (2001) Catastrophic shifts in ecosystems. Nature 413: 591-596.
82. Schnieder CP, Schiavone A Jr, Eckert TH, McCullough RD, Lantry BF, Einhouse DW, Chrisman JR, Adams CM, Johnson JH, Ross RM (1999) Double-Crested Cormorant Predation on Smallmouth Bass and Other Fishes of the Eastern Basin of Lake Ontario: Overview, Summary and Recommendations. Section 1 in Final Report to Assess the Impact of Double-Crested Cormorant Predation on the Smallmouth Bass and Other Fishes of the Eastern Basin of Lake Ontario. Special Report, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Albany, New York, USA.
83. Scott F (1968) The seals of Nova Scotian waters. Journal of Education 149: 16-24.
84. Seip DR (1992) Wolf predation, wolf control and the management of ungulate populations. In: McCullough DR, Barrett RH (eds) Wildlife 2001: Populations, 331-340. Elsevier Applied Science, London, UK.
85. Sinclair ARE, Pech RP (1996) Density dependence, stochasticity, compensation and predator regulation. Oikos 75: 164-173.
86. Sinclair ARE, Pech R, Dickman CR, Hik D, Mahon P, Newsome AE (1998) Predicting effects of predation on conservation of endangered prey. Conservation Biology 12: 564-575.
87. Smith RK, Pullin AS, Stewart GB, Sutherland WJ (2010) Effectiveness of predator removal for enhancing bird populations. Conservation Biology 24: 820-829.
88. Smith TD (1995) Interactions between marine mammals and fisheries: an unresolved problem for fisheries research. In: Blix AS, Walløe L, Ulltang Ø (eds) Whales, Seals, Fish and Man, 527-536. Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
89. Stansell RJ, Gibbons KM, Nagy WT (2010) Evaluation of Pinniped Predation on Adult Salmonids and Other Fish in the Bonneville Dam Tailrace, 2008-2010. US Army Corps of Engineers Report, Portland District, Cascade Locks, Oregon, USA.
90. Summers CF, Harwood J (1979) The grey seal 'problem' in the Outer Hebrides. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. Section B: Biology 77: 495-503.
91. Svanbäck R, Persson L (2004) Individual diet specialization, niche width and population dynamics: implications for trophic polymorphisms. The Journal of Animal Ecology 73: 973-982.
92. Tapper SC, Green RE, Rands MRW (1982) Effects of mammalian predators on partridge populations. Mammal Review 12: 159-167.
93. Terborgh J (1992) Why American songbirds are vanishing. Scientific American 266: 98-104.
94. Terborgh J, Estes JA, Paquet P, Ralls K, Boyd D, Miller B, Noss R (1999) Role of top carnivores in regulating terrestrial ecosystems. In: Soule ME, Terborgh J (eds) Continental Strategies for Conservation, 39-64. Island Press, Washington DC, USA.
95. Terborgh J, Lopez L, Nunez P, Rao M, Shahabuddin G, Orihuela G etal. (2001) Ecological meltdown in predator-free forest fragments. Science 294: 1923-1926.
96. Thompson PM, Mackey B, Barton TR, Duck C, Butler RRA (2007) Assessing the potential impact of salmon fisheries management on the conservation of harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) in north-east Scotland. Animal Conservation 10: 48-56.
97. Tjelmelan S, Lindstrøm U (2005) An ecosystem element added to the assessment of Norwegian spring-spawning herring: implementing predation by minke whales. ICES Journal of Marine Science 62: 285-294.
98. Treves A, Karanth KU (2003) Human-carnivore conflict and perspectives on carnivore management worldwide. Conservation Biology 17: 1491-1499.
99. Trites AW, Christensen V, Pauly D (1997) Competition between fisheries and marine mammals for prey and primary production in the Pacific Ocean. Journal of Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Science 22: 173-187.
100. Valkama J, Korpimaki E, Arroyo B, Beja P, Bretagnolle V, Bro E etal. (2005) Birds of prey as limiting factors of gamebird populations in Europe: a review. Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 80: 171-203.
101. Woodroffe R, MacDonald DW (1995) Cost of breeding status in the European badger, Meles meles. Journal of Zoology, London 235: 237-245.
102. Worm B, Myers RA (2003) Meta-analysis of cod-shrimp interactions reveals top-down control in oceanic food webs. Ecology 84: 162-173.
103. Worthington EB (1964) Grey seals and fisheries. Nature 203: 116-118.
104. Yodzis P (1988) The indeterminacy of ecological interactions as perceived through perturbation experiments. Ecology 69: 508-515.
105. Yodzis P (1998) Local trophodynamics and the interaction of marine mammals and fisheries in the Benguela ecosystem. The Journal of Animal Ecology 67: 635-658.
106. Yodzis P (2001) Must top predators be culled for the sake of fisheries? Trends in Ecology & Evolution 16: 78-84.
107. Zwanenburg K, Bowen WD, Sergeant DE (1985) Assessment of Northwest Atlantic Grey Seal (Halichoerus grypus) Pup Production for 1977 to 1984. Research document 67. Canadian Atlantic Fisheries Scientific Advisory Committee, Ottawa, Canada.