A practice-oriented review of woodchip bioreactors for subsurface agricultural drainage

Applied Engineering in Agriculture

Volumn 28, Issue 6, 2012, Pages 861-874

  Christianson, L E ^a   Bhandari, A ^b   Helmers, M J ^a  

^a Iowa State University   (United States)

^b Kansas State University   (United States)

Author keywords

Agricultural drainage; Denitrification bioreactor; Nitrate; Woodchip

Indexed keywords

AGRICULTURAL DRAINAGE; DRAINAGE WATER; NITRATE REMOVAL; QUALITY CONCERNS; WOOD CHIP;

AGRICULTURE; BIOREACTORS; DENITRIFICATION; DRAINAGE; INNOVATION; NITRATES; WASTEWATER DISPOSAL; WATER QUALITY;

BIOCONVERSION;

EID: 84874330752     PISSN: 08838542     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: None     Document Type: Review

References (94)

1. Andrus, J. M. 2011. Microbial community analysis for denitrifying biofilters. PhD diss. Urbana-Champaign, Illinois: Univ. of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Agr. & Bio. Eng.
2. Appleford, J. M., L. F. Rodriguez, R. A. C. Cooke, Y. Zhang, A. D. Kent, and J. L. Zilles. 2008. Characterization of microorganisms contributing to denitrification in tile drain biofilters in Illinois. ASABE Paper No. 084583. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE.
3. Blowes, D. W., W. D. Robertson, C. J. Ptacek, and C. Merkley. 1994. Removal of agricultural nitrate from tile-drainage effluent water using in-line bioreactors. J. Contaminant Hydrol. 15(3): 207-221.
4. Cameron, S. G., and L. A. Schipper. 2010. Nitrate removal and hydraulic performance of organic carbon for use in denitrification beds. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1588-1595.
5. Cameron, S. G., and L. A. Schipper. 2011. Evaluation of passive solar heating and alternative flow regimes on nitrate removal in denitrification beds. Ecol. Eng. 37(8): 1195-1204.
6. Caspers-Simmet, J. 2010. Nashua research farm studying bioreactor. Agri News: Serving Minnesota and Northern Iowa. Available at: www.agrinews.com/ nashua/research/farm/studying/bioreactor/story-2733.html. Accessed 1 December 2011.
7. Chapin III, F. S., P. A. Matson, and H. A. Mooney 2002. Principles of Terrestrial Ecosystem Ecology. New York, N.Y.: Springer Publication.
8. Christianson L. 2011. Design and performance of denitrification bioreactors for agricultural drainage. PhD diss. Ames, Iowa: Iowa State Univ, Agricultural and Biosystems Engineering.
9. Christianson, L., A. Bhandari, and M. Helmers. 2009. Emerging technology: Denitrification bioreactors for nitrate reduction in agricultural waters. J. Soil Water Cons. 64(5): 139A-141A.
10. Christianson, L., A. Castelló, R. Christianson, M. Helmers, and A. Bhandari. 2010a. Technical note: Hydraulic property determination of denitrifying bioreactor fill media. Applied Eng. in Agric. 26(5): 849-854.
11. Christianson, L., M. Helmers, and A. Bhandari. 2010b. Bioreactor design geometry effects on nitrate removal. ASABE Paper No. IDS-CSBE100073. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE.
12. Christianson, L., and M. Helmers. 2011. Woodchip bioreactors for nitrate in agricultural drainage. Iowa State University Extension Publication PMR 1008. Available at: store.extension.iastate.edu/ItemDetail.aspx?ProductID=13691. Accessed 30 November 2011.
13. Christianson, L., and J. Tyndall. 2011. Seeking a dialog: A targeted technology for sustainable agricultural systems in the U.S. Corn Belt. Sustainability: Sci., Practice, & Policy 7(2): 70-77.
14. Christianson, L., A. Bhandari, and M. Helmers. 2011a. Potential design methodology for agricultural drainage denitrification bioreactors. In Proc. 2011 EWRI Congress. Reston, Va.: American Society of Civil Engineers' Environmental & Water Resources Institute.
15. Christianson, L. E., A. Bhandari, and M. J. Helmers. 2011b. Pilotscale evaluation of denitrification drainage bioreactors: Reactor geometry and performance. J. Environ. Eng. 137(4): 213-220.
16. Christianson, L. E., J. Hanly, and M. Hedley. 2011c. Optimized denitrification bioreactor treatment through simulated drainage containment. Agric. Water Mgmt. 99(1): 85-92.
17. Christianson, L., A. Bhandari, M. Helmers, K. Kult, T. Sutphin, and R. Wolf. 2012a. Performance evaluation of four field-scale agricultural drainage denitrification bioreactors in Iowa. Trans. ASABE 55(6): In press.
18. Christianson, L., N. Hoover, A. Bhandari, and M. Helmers. 2012b. The potential of municipal yard waste to be denitrification bioreactor fill. Applied Eng. in Agric. 28(6): 853-859.
19. Christianson, L., M. Helmers, A. Bhandari, and T. Moorman. 2012c. Internal hydraulics of an agricultural drainage denitrification bioreactor. Ecol. Eng. (in press) http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoleng.2012.11.001.
20. Chun, J. A., and R. A. Cooke. 2008. Technical note: Calibrating Agridrain water level control structures using generalized weir and orifice equations. Applied Eng. in Agric. 24(5): 595-602.
21. Chun, J. A., R. A. Cooke, J. W. Eheart, and M. S. Kang. 2009. Estimation of flow and transport parameters for woodchipbased bioreactors: I. Laboratory-scale bioreactor. Biosystems Eng. 104(3): 384-395.
22. Chun, J. A., R. A. Cooke, J. W. Eheart, and J. Cho. 2010. Estimation of flow and transport parameters for woodchipbased bioreactors: II. field-scale bioreactor. Biosystems Eng. 105(1): 95-102.
23. Cooke, R. A., A. M. Doheny, and M. C. Hirschi. 2001. Bioreactors for edge of field treatment of tile outflow. ASAE Paper No. 01-20182001. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASAE.
24. David, M. B., L. E. Drinkwater, and G. F. McIsaac. 2010. Sources of nitrate yields in the Mississippi River Basin. J. Environ. Qual. 39(5): 1657-1667.
25. Diaz, R., J. Garcia, R. Mujeriego, and M. Lucas. 2003. A quick, low-cost treatment method for secondary effluent nitrate removal through denitrification. Environ. Eng. Sci. 20(6): 693-702.
26. Dinnes, D. L., D. L. Karlen, D. B. Jaynes, T. C. Kaspar, J. L. Hatfield, T. S. Colvin, and C. A. Cambardella. 2002. Nitrogen management strategies to reduce nitrate leaching in tiledrained midwestern soils. Agron. J. 94(1): 153-171.
27. Doheny, A. 2002. Amerlioration of tile nitrate and atrazing using inline biofilters. MS thesis. Urbana-Champaign, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Agricultural & Biological Engineering.
28. Elgood, Z., W. D. Robertson, S. L. Schiff, and R. Elgood. 2010. Nitrate removal and greenhouse gas production in a streambed denitrifying bioreactor. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1575-1580.
29. Gibert, O., S. Pomierny, I. Rowe, and R. M. Kalin. 2008. Selection of organic substrates as potential reactive materials for use in a denitrification permeable reactive barrier (PRB). Biores. Tech. 99(16): 7587-7596.
30. Greenan, C. M., T. B. Moorman, T. C. Kaspar, T. B. Parkin, and D. B. Jaynes. 2006. Comparing carbon substrates for denitrification of subsurface drainage water. J. Environ. Qual. 35(3): 824-829.
31. Greenan, C. M., T. B. Moorman, T. B. Parkin, T. C. Kaspar, and D. B. Jaynes. 2009. Denitrification in wood chip bioreactors at different water flows. J. Environ. Qual. 38(4): 1664-1671.
32. Hashemi, S. E., M. Heidarpour, B. Mostafazadeh-Fard, A. Madani, S-F. Mousavi, M. Gheysari, and S. Mehran. 2010. Nitrate removal of drainage water with barley straw as a bioreactor filter. ASABE Paper No. IDS-CSBE100171. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE.
33. Hoover, N. L. 2012. Denitrification woodchip bioreactor twophase column study: Evaluation of nitrate removal at various hydraulic retention times and effect of temperature on denitrification rates. MS thesis. Ames, Iowa: Iowa State Univ, Environmental Science and Sustainable Agriculture.
34. Healy, M. G., T. G. Ibrahim, G. J. Lanigan, A. J. Serrenho, and O. Fenton. 2012. Nitrate removal rate, efficiency and pollution swapping potential of different organic carbon media in laboratory denitrification bioreactors. Ecol. Eng. 40: 198-209.
35. Hunt, P. G., T. A. Matheny, K. S. Ro, K. C. Stone, and M. B. Vanotti. 2008. Denitrification of agricultural drainage line water via immobilized denitrification sludge. J. Environ. Sci. and Health, Part A 43(9): 1077-1084.
36. IDNR. 2006. Total Maximum Daily Load for nitrate Cedar River Linn County, Iowa. Iowa Department of Natural Resources. Available at: www.epa.gov/waters/ tmdldocs/32009-IACedarRiverTMDL.pdf. Accessed 3 September 2011.
37. Ima, C. S., and D. D. Mann. 2007. Physical properties of woodchip: Compost mixtures used as biofilter media. Agricultural Engineering International: the CIGR Ejournal Manuscript BC 07 005. Vol. IX.
38. Iowa NRCS. 2010. Iowa Environmental Quality Incentives Program (EQIP) list of eligible practices and payment schedule FY2011. United States Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service. Available at: www.ia.nrcs.usda.gov/programs/stateeqip.html. Accessed 29 November 2011.
39. ISA. 2010. Environmental programs: Bioreactor basics. Iowa Soybean Association. Available at www.iasoybeans.com/environment/programs-initiatives/ programs/bioreactors/basics. Accessed 1 December 2011.
40. ISU Extension. 2006. Denitrification of agricultural sub-surface drainage; Kenneth Pint Farm, Independence, Iowa; Demonstration sponsored by: Lime Creek Watershed Council and Iowa Corn Growers Association. Available at: www.heartlandwq.iastate.edu/NR/rdonlyres/3FB71A4D-7B21-4549-943E-C9B42DA3DCBF/0/ 061122LCbiofilter1.pdf. Accessed 23 July 2011.
41. Jaynes, D. B., T. C. Kaspar, T. B. Moorman, and T. B. Parkin. 2008. In situ bioreactors and deep drain-pipe installation to reduce nitrate losses in artificially drained fields. J. Environ. Qual. 37(2): 429-436.
42. Kellman, L. M. 2005. A study of tile drain nitrate -15N values as a tool for assessing nitrate sources in an agricultural region. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems 71(2): 131-137.
43. Korom, S. F. 1992. Natural denitrification in the saturated zone: A review. Water Resources Res. 28(6): 1657-1668.
44. Leverenz, H. L., K. Haunschild, G. Hopes, G. Tchobanoglous, and J. L. Darby. 2010. Anoxic treatment wetlands for denitrification. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1544-1551.
45. Long, L. M., L. A. Schipper, and D. A. Bruesewitz. 2011. Longterm nitrate removal in a denitrification wall. Agric., Ecosystems and Environ. 140(3-4): 514-520.
46. McLaughlan, R. G., and O. Al-Mashaqbeh. 2009. Effect of media type and particle size on dissolved organic carbon release from woody filtration media. Biores. Tech. 100(2): 1020-1023.
47. Metcalf and Eddy. 2003. Wastewater Engineering Treatment and Reuse. 4th ed. New York, N.Y.: McGraw-Hill.
48. Mirek, S. T. 2001. Effect of nitrogen fertilizer management and seasonality of tile flow on nitrate leaching through tile drains. MS thesis. Urbana-Champaign, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Agricultural & Biological Engineering.
49. Moorman, T. B., T. B. Parkin, T. C. Kaspar, and D. B. Jaynes. 2010. Denitrification activity, wood loss, and N2O emissions over 9 years from a wood chip bioreactor. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1567-1574.
50. NOAA. 2009. Smaller than expected, but severe, dead zone in Gulf of Mexico. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Available at: www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2009/20090727-deadzone.html. Accessed 14 Oct. 2009.
51. Ohio NRCS. 2012. January 26, 2012 Meeting Agenda (mentions CIG entitled Implementation of Bioreactors for Drainage Water Quality). Ohio Natural Resources Conservation Service. Available at: www.oh.nrcs.usda.gov/partnerships/ 01-12-12-agenda.html. Accessed 6 March 2012.
52. Rabalais, N. N., W. J. Wiseman, R. E. Turner, B. K. Sen Gupta, and Q. Dortch. 1996. Nutrient changes in the Mississippi River and system responses on the adjacent continental shelf. Estuaries 19(2): 386-407.
53. Ranaivoson, A., J. Moncrief, R.Venterea, M. Dittrich, Y. Chander, and P. Rice. 2010. Bioreactor performance in Minnesota. Minnesota/ Iowa Drainage Research Forum. Available at: www.extension.umn.edu/AgDrainage/components/ Ranaivoson.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2011.
54. Randall, G. W., and M. J. Goss. 2001. Chapt. 5: Nitrate losses to surface water through subsurface, tile drainage. In Nitrogen in the Environment: Sources, Problems, and Management. R. F. Follett and J. L. Hatfield, eds. Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier Science.
55. Robertson, W. D. 2010. Nitrate removal rates in woodchip media of varying age. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1581-1587.
56. Robertson, W. D., and J. A. Cherry. 1995. In situ denitrification of septic-system nitrate using reactive porous media barriers: Field trials. Ground Water 33(1): 99-111.
57. Robertson, W. D., and L. C. Merkley. 2009. In-stream bioreactor for agricultural nitrate treatment. J. Environ. Qual. 38(1): 230-237.
58. Robertson, W. D., D. W. Blowes, C. J. Ptacek, and J. A. Cherry. 2000. Long-term performance of in situ reactive barriers for nitrate remediation. Ground Water 38(5): 689-695.
59. Robertson, W. D., G. I. Ford, and P. S. Lombardo. 2005a. Woodbased filter for nitrate removal in septic systems. Trans. ASABE 48(1): 121-128.
60. Robertson, W. D., N. Yeung, P. W. van Driel, and P. S. Lombardo. 2005b. High-permeability layers for remediation of ground water; go wide, not deep. Ground Water 43(4): 574-581.
61. Robertson, W., J. Vogan, and P. Lombardo. 2008. Nitrate removal rates in a 15-year-old permeable reactive barrier treating septic system nitrate. Ground Water Monitoring & Remediation 28(3): 65-72.
62. Rodrigue, A. L. 2004. Effects of sampling frequencies in the evaluation of nitrate-N transport from drainage -related BMPs. MS thesis. Urbana-Champaign, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Agricultural & Biological Engineering.
63. Schipper, L., and M. Vojvodic-Vukovic. 1998. Nitrate removal from groundwater using a denitrification wall amended with sawdust: Field trial. J. Environ. Qual. 27(3): 664-668.
64. Schipper, L. A., G. F. Barkle, J. C. Hadfield, M. Vojvodic-Vukovic, and C. P. Burgess. 2004. Hydraulic constraints on the performance of a groundwater denitrification wall for nitrate removal from shallow groundwater. J. Contaminant Hydrol. 69(3-4): 263-279.
65. Schipper, L. A., G. F. Barkle, and M. Vojvodic-Vukovic. 2005. Maximum rates of nitrate removal in a denitrification wall. J. Environ. Qual. 34(4): 1270-1276.
66. Schipper, L. A., W. D. Robertson, A. J. Gold, D. B. Jaynes, and S. C. Cameron. 2010a. Denitrifying bioreactors: An approach for reducing nitrate loads to receiving waters. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1532-1543.
67. Schipper, L. A., S. C. Cameron, and S. Warneke. 2010b. Nitrate removal from three different effluents using large-scale denitrification beds. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1552-1557.
68. Shih, R., W. D. Robertson, S. L. Schiff, and D. L. Rudolph. 2011. Nitrate controls methyl mercury production in a streambed bioreactor. J. Environ. Qual. 40(5): 1586-1592.
69. Skaggs, R. W., and J. van Schilfgaarde. 1999. Drainage for Agriculture, Monograph No. 38. Madison, Wis.: American Society of Agronomy.
70. Soares, M. I. M., and A. Abeliovich. 1998. Wheat straw as substrate for water denitrification. Water Res. 32(12): 3790-3794.
71. South Dakota NRCS. 2011. News for immediate release: South Dakota NRCS announces recipients of state-level Conservation Innovation Grants. South Dakota Natural Resources Conservation Service. Available at: www.sd.nrcs.usda.gov/ news/. Accessed 6 March 2012.
72. Sutphin, T., and K. Kult. 2010. Iowa bioreactor demonstration project. Minnesota/ Iowa Drainage Research Forum. Available at: www.extension.umn.edu/ AgDrainage/components/Sutphin-Kult.pdf . Accessed 1 December 2011.
73. Tiedje, J. M. 1994. Denitrifiers. Part 2: Microbiological and biochemical properties. In Methods of Soil Analysis, 245-267. R. W. Weaver, ed. Madison, Wis.: Soil Science Society of America.
74. Turner, R. E., and N. N. Rabalais. 1994. Coastal eutrophication near the Mississippi river delta. Nature 368(6472): 619-621.
75. UMN Extension and MN Department of Ag. 2011. Woodchip bioreactors. University of Minnesota Extension and Minnesota Department of Agriculture. Available at: www.ellingsoncompanies.com/services/documents/WoodchipBioreactors. pdf. Accessed 17 July 2012.
76. University of Illinois. 2011. Designing and constructing bioreactors to reduce nitrate loss from subsurface drains. University of Illinois Department of Agricultural and Biological Engineering. Available at: www.wq.illinois.edu/dg/ Equations/trifold-Bioreactor.pdf. Accessed 30 November 2011.
77. USDA NIFA. 2011. Integrated research, education, and extension competitive grants program: National integrated water quality program fy 2011 request for applications: Nitrogen cycling in agricultural watersheds program area 110.D. U.S. Department of Agriculture National Institute of Food and Agriculture. Available at: www.nifa.usda.gov/funding/rfas/pdfs/11-water-quality. pdf. Accessed 17 July 2012.
78. USDA NRCS. 2009. Natural Resources Conservation Service (Iowa) Conservation Practice Standard Denitrifying Bioreactor (Ac.) Interim Code 747. United States Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service. Available at: www.ia.nrcs.usda.gov/technical/ia-standards.html. Accessed 29 November 2011.
79. USDA NRCS. 2011. Conservation Innovation Grants - Awardees: Fiscal Year 2011. United State Department of Agriculture Natural Resources Conservation Service. Available at: www.nrcs.usda.gov/wps/portal/nrcs/detail/national/ programs/financial/cig/?&cid=stelprdb1044889. Accessed 6 March 2012.
80. USEPA. 2007. Hypoxia in the Northern Gulf of Mexico: An update by the EPA Science Advisory Board. Washington, D.C.: United States Environmental Protection Agency Science Advisory Board.
81. USEPA. 2011. Hypoxia in the news. United States Environmental Protection Agency Office of Wetlands, Oceans, and Watersheds. Available at: water.epa.gov/type/watersheds/named/msbasin/gulfnews.cfm. Accessed 11 July 2012.
82. USGS. 2000. Nitrogen in the Mississippi Basin: Estimating sources and predicting flux to the Gulf of Mexico. United States Geological Survey. Available at: ks.water.usgs.gov/pubs/fact-sheets/fs.135-00.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2011.
83. Van Driel, P. W., W. D. Robertson, and L. C. Merkley. 2006a. Denitrification of agricultural drainage using wood-based reactors. Trans. ASABE 49(2): 565-573.
84. Van Driel, P. W., W. D. Robertson, and L. C. Merkley. 2006b. Upflow reactors for riparian zone denitrification. J. Environ. Qual. 35(2): 412-420.
85. Verma, S., R. Bhattarai, G. Goodwin, R. Cooke, and J. A. Chun. 2010. Evaluation of conservation drainage systems in Illinois: Bioreactors. ASABE Paper No. 10098942010. St. Joseph, Mich.: ASABE.
86. Volokita, M., S. Belkin, A. Abeliovich, and M. I. M. Soares. 1996. Biological denitrification of drinking water using newspaper. Water Res. 30(4): 965-971.
87. Wang, X., J. R. Frankenberger, and E. J. Kladivko. 2003. Estimating nitrate-N losses from subsurface drains using variable water sampling frequencies. Trans. ASAE 46(4): 1033-1040.
88. Warneke, S., L. A. Schipper, D. A. Bruesewitz, I. McDonald, and S. Cameron. 2011a. Rates, controls and potential adverse effects of nitrate removal in a denitrification bed. Ecol. Eng. 37(3): 511-522.
89. Warneke, S., L. A. Schipper, M. G. Matiasek, K. M. Scow, S. Cameron, D. A. Bruesewitz, and I. McDonald. 2011b. Nitrate removal, communities of denitrifiers and adverse effects in different carbon substrates for use in denitrification beds. Water Res. 45(17): 5463-5475.
90. Wildman, T. A. 2001. Design of field-scale bioreactors for bioremediation of nitrate in tile drainage effluent. MS thesis. Urbana-Champaign, Ill.: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Agricultural & Biological Engineering.
91. Willette, J. 2010. Bioreactor field day proves to be a learning day. Agri News: Serving Minnesota and Northern Iowa. Available at: www.agrinews.com/ bioreactor/field/day/proves/to/be/a/learning/day/story-2887.html. Accessed 1 December 2011.
92. Woli, K. P., M. B. David, R. A. Cooke, G. F. McIsaac, and C. A. Mitchell. 2010. Nitrogen balance in and export from agricultural fields associated with controlled drainage systems and denitrifying bioreactors. Ecol. Eng. 36(11): 1558-1566.
93. YSI Environmental. 2001. Measuring ORP on YSI 6-Series sondes: Tips, cautions and limitations. Available at: www.ysi.com/media/pdfs/T608-Measuring- ORP-on-YSI-6-Series-Sondes-Tips-Cautions-and-Limitations.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2011.
94. YSI Environmental. 2008. ORP Management in wastewater as an indicator of process efficiency. Available at: www.ysi.com/media/pdfs/A567-ORP-Management-in- Wastewater-as-an-Indicator-of-Process-Efficiency.pdf. Accessed 1 December 2011.