Ethics and geoengineering: Reviewing the moral issues raised by solar radiation management and carbon dioxide removal

Wiley Interdisciplinary Reviews: Climate Change

Volumn 4, Issue 1, 2013, Pages 23-37

  Preston, Christopher J ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF MONTANA   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

CARBON; CARBON DIOXIDE; PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECTS;

CARBON DIOXIDE REMOVAL; ETHICAL CONCERNS; ETHICAL ISSUES; GEOENGINEERING; GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGES; INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITY; RADIATION MANAGEMENT; SOCIAL SCIENTISTS;

CLIMATE CHANGE;

CARBON DIOXIDE; CLIMATE CHANGE; ETHICS; GLOBAL CLIMATE; IMPLEMENTATION PROCESS; MORALITY; SOLAR RADIATION;

EID: 84871435133     PISSN: 17577780     EISSN: 17577799     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1002/wcc.198     Document Type: Review

References (97)

1. Shepherd J, Caldeira K, Cox P, Haigh J, Keith D, Launder B, Mace G, MacKerron G, Pyle J, Rayner S, et al. Geoengineering the climate: science, governance, and uncertainty 2009. Available at: http://royalsociety.org/policy/publications/2009/geoengineering-climate. (Accessed June 26, 2012).
2. Blackstock J. Researchers can't regulate climate engineering alone. Nature 2012, 486:13.
3. Crutzen P. Albedo enhancement by stratospheric sulfur injections: a contribution to resolve a policy dilemma? Climatic Change 2006, 77:211-219.
4. Lawrence M. The geoengineering dilemma: to speak or not to speak. Climatic Change 2006, 77:245-248.
5. Elliot K. Geoengineering and the precautionary principle. International Journal of Applied Philosophy 2010, 24:237-252.
6. Launder M, Thompson J. Geoscale engineering to avert dangerous climate change. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 2008, 366.
7. Solar Radiation Management Governance Initiative (SRMGI). Solar radiation management: the governance of research. Available at: http://www.srmgi.org/files/2012/01/DES2391_SRMGI-report_web_11112.pdf. (Accessed June 27, 2012).
8. Bracmort K, Lattanzio R, Barbour E. Geoengineering: Governance and Technology Policy (US Congressional Research Service Report). Available at: www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R41371.pdf. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
9. Goodell J. How to Cool the Planet. New York: Houghton Mifflin; 2010.
10. Kintisch E. Hack the Planet: Science's Best Hope-or Worst Nightmare-for Averting Climate Catastrophe. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley Publishing; 2010.
11. Gardiner S. Some early ethics of geoengineering the climate: a commentary on the values of the royal society report. Environmental Values 2011, 20:163-188.
12. Ipsos Mori Experiment earth?: Report on a public dialogue on geoengineering 2010. Available at: http://www.nerc.ac.uk/about/consult/geoengineering-dialogue-final-report.pdf. (Accessed June 26, 2012).
13. Keith D, Parson E, Morgan M. Research on global sun block needed now. Nature 2010, 463:426-427.
14. Barrett S. The incredible economics of geoengineering. Environmental & Resource Economics 2008, 39:45-54.
15. Schneider S. Geoengineering: could-or should-we do it? Climatic Change 1996, 31:291-302.
16. Hale B. The world that would have been: Moral hazard arguments against geoengineering. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 113-131.
17. Keith D. David Keith's unusual idea on climate change. Available at: www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/david_keith_s_surprising_ideas_on_climate_change.html. (Accessed June 27, 2012).
18. Bunzl M. An ethical assessment of geoengineering. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists 2008, 64:18.
19. Smith P. Domination and the ethics of solar radiation management. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 113-131.
20. Hourdequin, M. Geoengineering, solidarity, and moral risk. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 15-32.
21. Ott K. Might solar radiation management constitute a dilemma. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 113-131.
22. Scott D. Insurance policy or technological fix: the ethical implications of framing solar radiation management. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 113-131.
23. Lin A. Does geoengineering present a moral hazard? Ecology Law Quarterly 2012. In press.
24. Gardiner S. A Perfect Moral Storm: The Ethical Tragedy of Climate Change. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2011.
25. Gardiner S. Is "arming the future" with geoengineering really the lesser evil? In: Gardiner S, Caney S, Jamieson D, Shue H, eds. Climate Ethics: Essential Readings. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2010, 284-312.
26. White L. The historical roots of our ecological crisis. Science 1967, 155:1203-1207.
27. Merchant C. The Death of Nature: Women, Ecology, and the Scientific Revolution. New York: Harper Collins; 1980.
28. Berman M. The Re-Enchantment of the World. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press; 1981.
29. Leopold A. A Sand County Almanac: And Sketches Here and There. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 1949.
30. Hill T. Ideals of human excellence and preserving natural environments. Environmental Ethics 1983, 5:211-224.
31. Jamieson D. Ethics and intentional climate change. Climatic Change 1996, 33:323-336.
32. Rolston H III. Environmental Ethics: Duties to and Values in the Natural World. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press; 1988.
33. Preston C. Re-thinking the unthinkable: environmental ethics and the presumptive argument against geoengineering. Environmental Values 2011, 20:457-479.
34. Weinberg A. Reflections on Big Science. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 1967.
35. Borgmann A. The setting of the scene: technological fixes and the design of the good life. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 189-200.
36. Scott D. Insurance policy or technological fix? The ethical implications of framing solar radiation management. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 151-168.
37. LeCain T. When everybody wins does the environment lose? The environmental techno-fix in twentieth-century mining. In: Rosner L, ed. The Technological Fix: How People Use Technology to Create and Solve Social Problems. New York: Routledge; 2004; 137-153.
38. Katz E. The call of the wild: the struggle for domination and the technological fix of nature. Environmental Ethics 1992, 14:265-273.
39. Hamilton C. Ethical anxieties about geoengineering: moral hazard, slippery slope, and playing God, 2011. Available at: http://www.clivehamilton.net.au/cms/media/ethical_anxieties_about_geoengineering.pdf. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
40. Corner A, Pidgeon N. Geoengineering the climate: the social and ethical implications. Environment 2010, 52:24-37.
41. Hale B. Getting the bad out: remediation technologies and respect for others. In: Kabasenche WP, O'Rourke M, Slater M, eds. The Environment: Philosophy, Science, and Ethics. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press; 2012, 223-244.
42. Alfred Wegner Institute, Lohafex provides new insights on plankton ecology-Only small amounts of atmospheric carbon dioxide fixed 23 March 2009. Available at: http://www.awi.de/en/news/press_releases/detail/item/lohafex_provides_new_insights_on_plankton_ecology_only_small_amounts_of_atmospheric_carbon_dioxide/?cHash=1eb5f2e233. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
43. Izrael Y, Zakharov V, Petrov N, Ryaboshapko A, Ivanov V, Savchenko A, Andreev Y, Puzov Y, Danelyan B, Kulyapin V. Field experiment on studying solar radiation passing through aerosol layers. Russian Meteorology and Hydrology 2009, 34:265-373.
44. Oxford Geoengineering Programme. Stratospheric Particle Injection for Climate Engineering (S.P.I.C.E.) Available at: http://www.geoengineering.ox.ac.uk/research/oxford-university-research/spice/. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
45. ETC Group. Open letter about S.P.I.C.E. geogengineering test, 2011, 26 September. Available at: http://www.etcgroup.org/sites/www.etcgroup.org/files/publication/pdf_file/SPICE-Opposition%20Letter.pdf. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
46. Watson M. Testbed news 2012, 16 May. Available at: http://thereluctantgeoengineer.blogspot.de/2012/05/testbed-news.html. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
47. Rayner S, Redgwell C, Savulescu J, Pidgeon N, Kruger T. Oxford memorandum submitted to the House of Commons Select Committee on Science and Technology, 2009. Available at: http://www.geoengineering.ox.ac.uk/oxford-principles/history/. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
48. Morrow D, Kopp R, Oppenheimer M. Toward ethical norms and institutions for climate engineering research. Environment Research Letters 2009, 4:1-8.
49. Kant I. Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals (trans. Ellington J). 3rd ed. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing; 1993.
50. Aristotle. Nichomachean Ethics (trans. Irwin T). 2nd ed. Indianapolis, IN: Hackett Publishing; 1999.
51. Lohmann L. Carbon trading: a critical conversation on climate change, privatisation and power. Development Dialogue 2006, 48. Available at: http://www.dhf.uu.se/pdffiler/DD2006_48_carbon_trading/carbon_trading_web.pdf. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
52. Buck, H. Climate remediation to address social development challenges: going beyond cost-benefit and risk approaches to assessing solar radiation management. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 133-148.
53. Pongratz J, Lobell D, Cao L, Caldeira K. Crop yields in a geoengineered climate. Nature Climate Change 2012, 2:1-5.
54. Olson R. Geoengineering for decision makers. Woodrow Wilson Center Report November 2011. Available at: http://www.wilsoncenter.org/sites/default/files/Geoengineering_for_Decision_Makers_0.pdf. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
55. Svoboda T, Keller K, Goes M, Tuana T. Sulfate aerosol geoengineering: the question of justice. Public Affairs Quarterly 2011, 25:157-180.
56. Shue H. The unavoidability of justice. In: Hurrell A, Kingsbury B, eds. The International Politics of the Environment. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press; 1992, 373-397.
57. Stirling A. 'Opening up' and 'closing down': power, participation, and pluralism in the social appraisal of technology. Science, Technology, & Human Values 2008, 33:262-294.
58. Wilsdon J, Willis R. See-Through Science: Why Public Engagement Needs to Move Upstream. London: Demos; 2004.
59. Leach M, Scoones I, Wynne B, eds. Science and Citizens: Globalization and the Challenge of Engagement. London, UK: Zed Books; 2005.
60. Leiserowitz A. Climate change and geoengineering in the public mind. Presentation at Asilomar International Conference on Climate Intervention Technologies (slide 12). Available at: http://www.climateresponsefund.org/images/Conference/leiserowitz-4-24-10-red.pdf. (Accessed July 7, 2012).
61. Whyte K. Indigenous peoples, solar radiation management, and consent. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 65-76.
62. Preston C. Solar radiation management and vulnerable populations: the moral deficit and its prospects. In: Preston C., ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 77-94.
63. Intemann K. Putting feminist research principles into practice: objectivity and social justice in climate change studies. In: Hesse-Biber S, ed. The Handbook of Feminist Research: Theory and Praxis, 2nd ed. London: Sage Publications; 2011, 495-510.
64. Beatty J. Masking disagreement among experts. Episteme: A Journal of Social Epistemology 2006, 3:52-67.
65. Biddle J, Winsberg E. Value judgments and the estimation of uncertainty in climate modeling. In: Magnus PD, Busch J, eds. New Waves in Philosophy of Science. Hampshire, UK: Palgrave Macmillan; 2011, 172-197.
66. Rawls J. A Theory of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1999.
67. Grasso M. A normative ethical framework in climate change. Climatic Change 2007, 81:223-246.
68. Ricke K, Morgan G, Allen M. Regional climate response to solar-radiation management. Nature Geoscience 2010, 3:537-541.
69. Keith D. Just how many knobs, bells and whistles do you want on that there climate control box? Presentation at Ethics of SRM Workshop, University of Montana, October 18th, 2010.
70. Sandler R. Solar radiation management and non-human species. In: Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 95-109.
71. Bipartisan Policy Center. Task Force on Climate Remediation Research. Available at: http://bipartisanpolicy.org/library/report/task-force-climate-remediation-research. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
72. Matthews H, Caldeira, K. Transient climate--carbon simulations of planetary geoengineering. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2007, 104:9949-9954.
73. Bala G, Duffy P, Taylor K. Impact of geoengineering schemes on the global hydrological cycle. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 2008, 105:7664-7669.
74. Keith D, Parson E, Morgan M. Research on global sunblock needed now. Nature 2010, 463:426-427.
75. Kellogg W, Schneider S. Climate stabilization: for better or for worse? Science 1974, 186:1163-1172.
76. Bunzl M. Geoengineering harms and compensation. Stanford Journal of Law, Science, and Policy 2011, 4:69-75.
77. Robock A. Will geoengineering with solar radiation management ever be used? Ethics, Policy, Environment 2012, 15:202-205.
78. Dworkin R. What is equality? Philosophy and Public Affairs 1981, 10:185-246.
79. Sen A. Choice, Welfare and Measurement. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press; 1982.
80. Robock A. Twenty reasons why geoengineering might be a bad idea. Bulletin of the Atomic Sciences 2008, 64:14-18.
81. Mercado L, Bellouin N, Sitch S, Boucher O, Huntingford C, Wild M, Cox P. Impact of changes in diffuse radiation on the global land carbon sink. Nature 2009: 458, 1014-1017.
82. 2 from air requires largest industry ever. New Scientist Available at: http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg21428593.800-stripping-co2-from-air-requires-largest-industry-ever.html. (Accessed July 4, 2012).
83. Latham J, Rasch P, Chen C, Kettles L, Gadian A, Gettelman A, Morrison H, Bower K, Choularton T. Global temperature stabilization via controlled albedo enhancement of low-level maritime clouds. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A 2008, 366:3969-3987.
84. Burns W. Climate geoengineering: solar radiation management and its implications for intergenerational equity. Stanford Journal of Law, Science & Policy 2011, 4:39-55.
85. Robock A, Bunzl M, Kravitz B, Stenchikov L. Atmospheric science: a test for geoengineering? Science 2010, 327:530-531.
86. Chen I, Hill J, Ohlemüller R, Roy D, Thomas C. Rapid range shifts of species associated with high levels of climate warming. Science 2011, 333:1024-1026.
87. Geo-engineering the climate: buying time to decarbonize the world. Strategic Direction 2010, 26:35-38.
88. Institute of Physics, Geoengineering: Challenges and global impacts, 2009. Available at: http://www.iop.org/publications/iop/2009/file_44080.pdf. (Accessed July 9, 2012).
89. Solomon S, Qin D, Manning M, Chen Z, Marquis M, Averyt K, Tignor M, Miller H, eds. Contribution of Working Group I to the Fourth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge, United Kingdom and New York: Cambridge University Press; 2007.
90. Siegenthaler U, Sarmiento J. Atmospheric carbon dioxide and the ocean. Nature 1993, 356:119-125.
91. 2 sink due to recent climate change. Science 2007, 316:1735-1738.
92. Fleming J. Fixing the Sky: The Checkered History of Weather and Climate Control. New York; 2010.
93. Erle E. The planet of no return. Breakthrough Journal 2011, 2. Available at: http://breakthroughjournal.org/content/authors/erle-ellis/the-planet-of-no-return.shtml. (Accessed July 7, 2012).
94. Galarraga M, Szerszynski B. Making climates: solar radiation management and the ethics of fabrication. In Preston C, ed. Engineering the Climate: The Ethics of Solar Radiation Management. Lanham, MD: Lexington Press; 2012, 221-236.
95. Moreno-Cruz J, Ricke K, Keith D. A simple model to account for regional inequalities in the effectiveness of solar radiation management. Climatic Change 2012, 110:649-668.
96. Bracmort K, Lattanzio R, Barbour E. Geoengineering: Governance and Technology Policy (US Congressional Research Service Report). Available at: www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/R41371.pdf.
97. Renforth P. The potential of enhanced weathering in the UK. International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control 2012, 10:229-243.