Are agrofuels a conservation threat or opportunity for grassland birds in the United States?

Condor

Volumn 114, Issue 4, 2012, Pages 679-688

  Robertson, Bruce A ^a,b,c   Rice, Robert A ^a   Scott Sillett, T ^a   Ribic, Christine A ^d   Babcock, Bruce A ^e   Landis, Douglas A ^b   Herkert, James R ^f   Fletcher, Robert J ^g   Fontaine, Joseph J ^h   Doran, Patrick J ⁱ   Schemske, Douglas W ^b  

^a SMITHSONIAN CONSERVATION BIOLOGY INSTITUTE   (United States)

^b MICHIGAN STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c BARD COLLEGE   (United States)

^d UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN MADISON   (United States)

^e IOWA STATE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^f UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS   (United States)

^g UNIVERSITY OF FLORIDA   (United States)

^h UNIVERSITY OF NEBRASKA LINCOLN   (United States)

ⁱ THE NATURE CONSERVANCY   (United States)

Author keywords

Biodiversity; Biofuels; Cellulosic ethanol; Conservation reserve program; Prairie; Switchgrass

Indexed keywords

EID: 84870497954     PISSN: 00105422     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1525/cond.2012.110136     Document Type: Review

References (78)

1. BAKKER, K. K., AND K. F. HIGGINS. 2009. Planted grasslands and native sod prairie: equivalent habitat for grassland birds? Western North American Naturalist 69:35-242.
2. BAKKER, K. K., D. E. NAUGLE, AND K. F. HIGGINS. 2002. Incorporating landscape attributes into models for migratory grassland bird conservation. Conservation Biology 16:1638-1646.
3. BEECHER, N. A., R. J. JOHNSON, R. J., BRANDLE, R. M., CASE, AND L. J. YOUNG. 2002. Agroecology of birds in organic and nonorganic farmland. Conservation Biology 16:1620-1631.
4. BELLAMY, P. E., R. J. CROXTON, M. S. HEARD, S. A. HINSLEY, L. HULMES, S. HULMES, R. NUTTALL, R. F. PYWELL, AND P. ROTHERY. 2009. The impact of growing miscanthus for biomass on farmland bird populations. Biomass and Bioenergy 33:191-199.
5. BENTON, T. G., J. A. VICKERY, AND J. D. WILSON. 2003. Farmland biodiversity: is habitat heterogeneity the key? Trends in Ecology and Evolution 18:182-188.
6. BEST, L. B. 1986. Conservation tillage: ecological traps for nesting birds? Wildlife Society Bulletin 14:308-317.
7. BEST, L. B., K. E. FREEMARK, J. J. DINSMORE, AND M. CAMP. 1995. A review and synthesis of habitat use by breeding birds in agricultural landscapes of Iowa. American Midland Naturalist 134:1-29.
8. BOLLINGER, E. K., P. B. BOLLINGER, AND T. A. GAVIN. 1990. Effects of hay-cropping on eastern populations of the Bobolink. Wildlife Society Bulletin 18:142-150.
9. BOWYER, C. 2010. Anticipated indirect land use change associated with expanded use of biofuels and bioliquids in the EU'an analysis of the national renewable energy action plans. Institute for European Environmental Policy, London.
10. BRADBURY, R. B., S. J. BROWNE, D. K. STEVENS, AND N. J. AEBISCHER. 2004. Five-year evaluation of the impact of the Arable Stewardship Pilot Scheme on birds. Ibis 146:171-180.
11. BRENNAN, L. A., AND W. P. KUVLESKY JR. 2005. North American grassland birds: an unfolding conservation crisis. Journal of Wildlife Management 69:1-13.
12. CARTER, M. F., W. C. HUNTER, D. N. PASHLEY, AND K. V. ROSENBERG. 2000. Setting conservation priorities for landbirds in the United States: the Partners in Flight approach. Auk 117:541-48.
13. COPPEDGE, B. R., D. M. ENGLE, R. E. MASTERS, AND M. S. GREGORY. 2001. Avian response to landscape change in fragmented southern Great Plains grasslands. Ecological Applications 11:47-59.
14. DALE, V. H., K. L. KLINE, L. L. WRIGHT, R. D. PERLACK, M. DOWNING, AND R. L. GRAHAM. 2011. Interactions among bioenergy feedstock choices, landscape dynamics, and land use. Ecological Applications 21:1039-1054.
15. DAUBER, J. S., M. B. JONES, AND J. C. STOUT. 2010. The impact of biomass crop cultivation on temperate biodiversity. Global Change Biology Bioenergy 2:289-309.
16. DECHANT, J. A., M. F. DINKINS, D. H. JOHNSON, L. D. IGL, C. M. GOLDADE, AND B. R. EULISS. 2002. Effects of management practices on grassland birds: Vesper Sparrow (revised). Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center, Jamestown, ND.
17. DINKINS, M. E, A. L. ZIMMERMAN, J. A. DECHANT, B. D. PARKIN, D. H. JOHNSON, L. D. IGL, C. M. GOLDADE, AND B. R. EULISS. 2002. Effects of management practices on grassland birds: Horned Lark (revised). Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center, Jamestown, ND.
18. EGGERS, J., K. TROLTZSCH, A. FALCUCCI, L. MAIORANO, P. H. VERBURG, E. FRAMSTAND, G. LOUETTE, D. MAES, S. NAGY, W. OZINGA, AND B. DELBAERE, 2009. Is biofuel policy harming biodiversity in Europe? Global Change Biology Bioenergy 1:18-34.
19. EUROPEAN COMMISSION ENVIRONMENT [ONLINE]. 2009. Fuel Quality Directive amendment, Directive 2009/30/EC. (20 January 2011).
20. EVANS, J. M., R. J. FLETCHER JR., AND J. I. ALAVALAPATI. 2010. Using species distribution models to identify suitable areas for biofuel feedstock production. Global Change Biology Bioenergy 2:63-78.
21. FARGIONE, J. E., T. R. COOPER, D. J. FLASPOHLER, J. HILL, C. LEHMAN, T. MCCOY, S. MCLEOD, E. J. NELSON, K. S. OBERHAUSER, AND D. TILMAN, 2009. Bioenergy and wildlife: threats and opportunities for grassland conservation. BioScience 59:767-777.
22. FIELD, C. B., J. E. CAMPBELL, AND D. B. LOBELL. 2008. Biomass energy: the scale of the potential resource. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 23:65-72.
23. FILIPPI-CODACCIONI, O., V. DEVICTOR, Y. BAS, AND R. JULLIARD. 2010. Toward more concern for specialization and less for species diversity in conserving farmland biodiversity. Biological Conservation 143:1493-1500.
24. FIRBANK, L. G., S. PETIT, S. SMART, A. BLAIN, AND R. J. FULLER. 2008. Assessing the impacts of agricultural intensification on biodiversity: a British perspective. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 363:777-787.
25. FLETCHER, R. J. JR., AND R. R. KOFORD. 2002. Habitat and landscape associations of breeding birds in native and restored grasslands. Journal of Wildlife Management 66:1011-1022.
26. FLETCHER, R. J., B. A. ROBERTSON, J. EVANS, P. J. DORAN, J. R. R. ALAVALAPATI, AND D. SCHEMSKE. 2011. Biodiversity conservation in the era of bio fuels: risks and opportunities. Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment 9:161-168.
27. FUENTES, R. G., AND C. M. TALIAFERRO. 2002. Biomass yield stability of switchgrass cultivars, p. 276-282. In J. Janick, and A. Whipkey [eds.], Trends in new crops and new uses. ASHS Press, Alexandria, VA.
28. GARDINER, M., J. TUELL, R. ISAACS, J. GIBBS, J. ASCHER, AND D. A. LANDIS. 2010. Implications of three model biofuel crops for beneficial arthropods in agricultural landscapes. Bioenergy Research 3:6-19.
29. ™ pretreated biomass from unmanaged fields in comparison to corn stover. Biomass and Bioenergy 37:49-59.
30. GREEN, R. E., S. J. CORNELL, J. P. W. SCHARLEMANN, AND A. BALMFORD. 2005. Farming and the fate of wild nature. Science 307:550-555.
31. GROOM, M. J., E. M. GRAY, AND P. A. TOWNSEND. 2008. Biofuels and biodiversity: principles for creating better policies for biofuel production. Conservation Biology 22:602-609.
32. HAGEN, C. A., G. C. SALTER, J. C. PITMAN, R. J. ROBEL, AND R. D. APPLEGATE. 2005. Lesser Prairie-Chicken brood habitat in sand sagebrush: invertebrate biomass and vegetation. Wildlife Society Bulletin 33:1080-1091.
33. HEDGES, L. V., J. GUREVITCH, AND P. S. CURTIS. 1999. The metaanalysis of response ratios in experimental ecology. Ecology 80:1150-1156.
34. HENNENBERG, K. J., C. DRAGISIC, S. HAYE, J. HEWSON, B. SEMROC, C. SAVY, K. WIEGMANN, H. FEHERENBACH, AND U. R. FRITSCHE. 2009. The power of bioenergy-related standards to protect biodiversity. Conservation Biology 24:412-423.
35. HERKERT, J. R. 2009. Response of bird populations to farmland setaside programs. Conservation Biology 24:1036-1040.
36. HERKERT, J. R., D. W. SAMPLE, AND R. E. WARNER. 1996. Management of midwestern grassland landscapes for the conservation of migratory birds, p. 89-116. In F. R. Thompson [ed.], Management of midwestern landscapes for the conservation of neotropical migratory birds. USDA Forest Service General Technical Report NC-187. USDA Forest Service North Central Forest Experiment Station, St. Paul, MN.
37. HOLE, D. G., A. J. PERKINS, J. D. WILSON, P. V. ALEXANDER, AND A. D. EVANS. 2005. Does organic farming benefit biodiversity? Biological Conservation 122:113-130.
38. HOOGWIJK, M., A. FAAIJ, B. EICKHOUT, B. DE VRIES, AND W. TURKENBURG. 2005. Potential of biomass energy out to 2100, for four IPCC-SRES land-use scenarios. Biomass and Bioenergy 29:225-257.
39. H. R. 6'110TH CONGRESS [ONLINE]. 2007. Energy Independence and Security Act of 2007. (1 October 2011).
40. H. R. 2419'110TH CONGRESS [ONLINE]. 2008. Food, Conservation and Energy Act of 2008. (1 October 2011).
41. JOHNSON, R. G., AND S. A. TEMPLE. 1990. Nest predation and brood parasitism of tall-grass prairie birds. Journal of Wildlife Management 54:106-111.
42. KING, J., AND J. SAVIDGE. 1995. Effects of the Conservation Reserve Program on selected wildlife in southeast Nebraska. Wildlife Society Bulletin 23:377-385.
43. KIRSCH, E. M., B. R. GRAY, T. J. FOX, AND W. E. THOGMARTIN. 2007. Breeding bird territory placement in riparian wet meadows in relation to invasive reed canary grass, Phalaris arundinacea. Wetlands 27:644-655.
44. LEWANDOWSKI, I., J. C. CLIFTON-BROWN, J. M. O. SCURLOCK, AND W. HUISMAN. 2000. Miscanthus: European experience with a novel energy crop. Biomass and Bioenergy 19:209-227.
45. MCCOY, T. D., M. R. RYAN, L. W. BURGER JR., AND E. W. KURZEJESKI. 2001. Grassland bird conservation: CPI vs. CP2 plantings in Conservation Reserve Program fields in Missouri. American Midland Naturalist 145:1-17.
46. MCDONALD, R. I., J. FARGIONE, J. KIESECKER, W. M. MILLER, AND J. POWELL [ONLINE]. 2009. Energy sprawl or energy efficiency: climate policy impacts on natural habitat for the United States of America. PLoS One 4:e6802.
47. MCLAUGHLIN, S. B., AND WALSH M. E. 1998. Evaluating environmental consequences of producing herbaceous crops for bioenergy. Biomass and Bioenergy 14:317-324.
48. MEEHAN, T. D., A. H. HURLBERT, AND C. GRATTON. 2010. Bird communities in future bioenergy landscapes of the Upper Midwest. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA 107:18533-18538.
49. MILLENBAH, K. E, S. R. WINTERSTEIN, H. CAMPAIN, L. T. FURROW, AND R. B. MINNIS. 1996. Effects of Conservation Reserve Program field age on avian relative abundance, diversity, and productivity. Wilson Bulletin 108:760-770.
50. MURRAY, L. D., AND L. B. BEST. 2003. Short-term bird response to harvesting switchgrass for biomass in Iowa. Journal of Wildlife Management 67:611-621.
51. MURRAY, L. D., L. B. BEST, T. J. JACOBSEN, AND M. L. BRASTER. 2003. Potential effects on grassland birds of converting marginal cropland to switchgrass biomass production. Biomass and Bioenergy 25:167-175.
52. PEACH, W. J., L. J., LOVETT, S. R. WOTTON, AND C. JEFFS. 2001. Countryside stewardship delivers Cirl Buntings (Emberiza cirltis) in Devon, UK. Biological Conservation 101:361-373.
53. RAHMIG, C. J., W. E., JENSE, AND K. A. WITH. 2008. Grassland bird responses to land management in the largest remaining tallgrass prairie. Conservation Biology 23:420-432.
54. RASHFORD, B. S., J. A. WALKER, AND C. T. BASTIAN. 2011. Economics of grassland conversion to cropland in the prairie pothole region. Conservation Biology 25:276-284.
55. RENFREW, R. B., AND C. A. RIBIC. 2008. Multi-scale models of grassland passerine abundance in a fragmented system in Wisconsin. Landscape Ecology 23:181-193.
56. RIBIC, C. A. R., R. KOFORD, J. R. HERKERT, D. H. JOHNSON, N. D. NIEMUTH, D. E. NAUGLE, K. K. BAKKER, D. W. SAMPLE, AND R. B. RENFREW, 2009. Area sensitivity in North American grassland birds: patterns and processes. Auk 126:233-244.
57. RICH, T. D., C. J. BEARDMORE, H. BERLANGA, P. J. BLANCHER, M. S. W. BRADSTREET, G. S. BUTCHER, D. W. DEMAREST, E. H. DUNN, W. C. HUNTER, E. E. INIGO-ELIAS, J. A. KENNEDY, A. M. MARTELL, A. O. PANJABI, D. N. PASHLEY, K. V. ROSENBERG, C. M. RUSTAY, J. S. WENDT, AND T. C. WILL [online]. 2004. Partners in Flight North American landbird conservation plan. Partners in Flight, Ithaca, NY. .
58. ROBERTSON, B. A., P. J. DORAN, E. R. LOOMIS, J. R. ROBERTSON, AND D. W. SCHEMSKE. 2011a. Perennial biomass crops enhance avian biodiversity. Global Change Biology Bioenergy 3:235-246.
59. ROBERTSON, B. A., P. J. DORAN, E. R. LOOMIS, J. R. ROBERTSON, AND D. W. SCHEMSKE [online]. 2011b. Avian use of perennial biomass feedstocks as post-breeding and migratory stopover habitat. PLoS One 6:e16941.
60. ROBERTSON, B. A., T. S. SILLETT, D. A. LANDIS, E. L. LOOMIS, AND R. RICE. In press. Perennial agroenergy feedstocks as en route habitat for spring migratory birds. Bio Energy Research.
61. RODENHOUSE, N. L., L. B. BEST, R. J. O'CONNOR, AND E. K. BOLLINGER. 1995. Effects of agricultural practices and farmland structure, p. 269-293. In T. E. Martin and D. M. Finch [eds.], Ecology and management of neotropical migratory birds. Oxford University Press, New York.
62. ROTH, A. M., D. W. SAMPLE, C. A. RIBIC, L. PAINE, D. J. UNDERSANDER, AND G. A. BARTELT. 2005. Grassland bird response to harvesting switchgrass as a biomass energy crop. Biomass and Bioenergy 28:490-498.
63. SAMPLE, D. W., C. A. RIBIC, AND R. B. RENFREW. 2003. Linking landscape management with the conservation of grassland birds in Wisconsin, p. 359-385. In J. A. Bissonette and I. Storch [eds.], Landscape ecology and resource management: linking theory with practice, Island Press, Washington, DC.
64. SCHERR, S. J., AND J. A. MCNEELY. 2008. Biodiversity conservation and agricultural sustainability: towards a new paradigm of 'ecoagriculture' landscapes. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B 363:477-494.
65. SECCHI, S., AND B. BABCOCK. 2007. Impact ofhigh crop prices on environmental quality: a case of Iowa and the Conservation Reserve Program. Center for Agricultural and Rural Development (CARD) Publication 07-wp447. Iowa State University, Ames, IA.
66. SEIGEL, A. B., AND J. L. LOCKWOOD. 2010. How increasing levels of private land enrollment in conservation agreements affect the population viability of grassland birds. Biodiversity and Conservation 19:2343-2357.
67. SEMERE, T., AND F. M. SLATER. 2006. Ground flora, small mammal and bird species diversity in miscanthus (Miscanthus giganteus) and reed canary-grass (Phalaris arundinacea) fields. Biomass and Bioenergy 31:20-29.
68. STEPHENS, S. E., J. A., WALKER, D. R. BLUNCK, A. JAYARAMAN, D. E., NAUGLE, J. K. RINGELMAN, AND A. J. SMITH. 2008. Predicting risk of habitat conversion in native temperate grasslands. Conservation Biology 22:1320-1330.
69. STUBBS, M. 2011. Biomass Crop Assistance Program (BCAP): status and issues. Report #R41296. Congressional Research Service, Library of Congress, Washington, DC.
70. TILMAN, D., J. FARGIONE, B. WOLFF, C. D. D'ANTONIO, A. DOBSON, R. HOWARTH, D. SCHINDLER, W. H. SCHLESINGER, D. SIMBERLOFF, AND D. SWACKHAMER. 2001. Forecasting agriculturally driven global environmental change. Science 292:281-284.
71. TILMAN, D., J. HILL, AND C. LEHMAN. 2006. Carbon-negative biofuels from low-input high-diversity grassland biomass. Science 314:1598-1600.
72. USDA (U. S. DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE) [ONLINE]. 2009. Conservation Reserve Program, monthly summary'October 2009. (12 October 2010).
73. VICKERY, J. A., R. B. BRADBURY, I. G. HENDERSON, M. A. EATON, AND P. V. GRICE. 2004. The role of agri-environment schemes and farm management practices in reversing the decline of farmland birds in England. Biological Conservation 119:19-39.
74. WEST, T., K. DUNPHY-GUZMAN, A. SUN, L. MALCZYNSKI, D. REICHMUTH, R. LARSON, J. ELLISON, R. TAYLOR, V. TIDWELL, L. KLEBANOFF, P. HOUGH, A. LUTZ, C. SHADDIX, N. BRINKMAN, C. WHEELER, AND D. O'TOOLE. 2009. Feasibility, economics, and environmental impact of producing 90 billion gallons of ethanol per year by 2030. Sandia National Laboratories, Livermore, CA.
75. WILHELM, W. W., J. M. E. JOHNSON, D. L. KARLEN, AND D. T. LIGHTLE. 2007. Corn stover to sustain soil organic carbon further constrains biomass supply. Agronomy Journal 99:1665-1667.
76. WILLIAMS, B. K, R. C. SZARO, AND C. D. SHAPIRO. 2009. Adaptive management: the U. S. Department of the Interior technical guide. Adaptive Management Working Group, U. S. Department of the Interior, Washington, DC.
77. WILSON, K. A., E. MEIJAARD, S. DRUMMOND, H. S. GRANTHAM, L. BOITANI, G. CATULLO, L. CHRISTIE, R. DENNIS, I. DUTTON, A. FALCUCCI, L. MAIORANO, H. P. POSSINGHAM, C. RONDININI, W. R. TURNER, O. VENTER, AND M. WATTS. 2010. Conserving biodiversity in production landscapes. Ecological Applications 20:1721-1732.
78. WINTER, M., AND J. FAABORG. 1999. Patterns of area sensitivity in grassland-nesting birds. Conservation Biology 13:1424-1436.