A Trade Secret Model for Genomic Biobanking

Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

Volumn 40, Issue 3, 2012, Pages 612-629

  Conley, John M ^a   Mitchell, Robert ^b   Cadigan, R Jean ^c   Davis, Arlene M ^c   Dobson, Allison W ^a,d   Gladden, Ryan Q ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA   (United States)

^b DUKE UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA SCHOOL OF MEDICINE   (United States)

^d Kilpatrick Townsend and Stockton LLP   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

ARTICLE; ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; CONFIDENTIALITY; DONOR; ETHICS; GIFT GIVING; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HEALTH CARE FACILITY; HUMAN; HUMAN GENOME; INFORMED CONSENT; LEGAL ASPECT; LICENSING; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; THEORETICAL MODEL; UNITED STATES;

ATTITUDE TO HEALTH; BIOLOGICAL SPECIMEN BANKS; CONFIDENTIALITY; GENOME, HUMAN; GIFT GIVING; GOVERNMENT REGULATION; HUMANS; INFORMED CONSENT; LICENSURE; MODELS, THEORETICAL; OWNERSHIP; TISSUE DONORS; UNITED STATES;

EID: 84867588517     PISSN: 10731105     EISSN: 1748720X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2012.00694.x     Document Type: Article

References (48)

1. M. A. Rothstein, "Expanding the Ethical Analysis of Biobanks, " Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 33, no. 1 (2005): 89-101. We use "biospecimens, ""samples, " and "human tissues" synonymously, and follow Eisman and Haga's capacious definition of "human tissue" as including both fluids, such as blood, and solids, such as muscle biopsies; see E. Eiseman and S. B. Haga, Handbook of Human Tissue Sources: A National Resource of Human Tissue Samples (Santa Monica, CA: Rand Corporation, 1999): at 7.
2. D. Shickle, "The Consent Problem within DNA Biobanks, " Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 37, no. 3 (2006): 503-519.
3. H. T. Greely, "The Uneasy Ethical and Legal Underpinnings of Large-Scale Genomic Biobanks, " Annual Review of Human Genetics 8 (2007): 343-364, at 344.
4. K. B. Jacobs, M. Yeager, S. Wacholder, D. Craig, P. Kraft, D. J. Hunter, J. Paschal, T. A. Manolio, M. Tucker, R. N. Hoover, G. D. Thomas, S. J. Chanock, and N. Chattterjee, "A New Statistic and Its Power to Infer Membership in a Genome-Wide Association Study Using Genotype Frequencies, " Nature Genetics 41, no. 11 (2009): 1253-1257.
5. E. C. Hayden, "Secrets of the Human Genome Disclosed, " Nature 478 (2011): 17.
6. T. Caulfield, R. Upshur, and A. Daar, "DNA Databanks and Consent: A Suggested Policy Option Involving an Authorization Model, " BioMed Central Medical Ethics E1, 4 (2003), at
7. T. Caulfied and B. M. Knoppers, Consent, Privacy & Research Biobanks, Policy Directions Brief Number 1, 2009-2010 Series on Genetic Information, Genome Canada (January 26, 2010): 1-10, at 4-5, available at (last visited June 26, 2012).
8. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, "Human Subjects Research Protections: Enhancing Protections for Research Subjects and Reducing Burden, Delay, and Ambiguity for Investigators (2011), " 76 Fed. Reg. 44512-44531 (July 26, 2011), available at (last visited June 26, 2012).
9. D. E. Winickoff and R. Winickoff, "Charitable Trust as a Model for Genomic Biobanks, " New England Journal of Medicine 349, no. 12 (2003): 1180-1184.
10. S. M. Fullerton, N. R. Anderson, G. Guzauskas, D. Freeman, and K. Fryer-Edwards, "Meeting the Governance Challenges of Next-Generation Biorepository Research, " Science Translational Medicine 2, no. 15 (2010): 15cm3, available at (last visited July 11, 2012).
11. K. Hoeyer, "The Ethics of Research Biobanking, " Biotechnology and Genetic Engineering Reviews 25 (2008): 429-452, at 440.
12. R. Mitchell, J. Conley, A. Davis, J. Cadigan, A. Dobson, and R. Gladden, "Genomics, Biobanks, and the Trade-Secret Model, " Science 332, no. 6027 (April 15, 2011): 309-310
13. "Letters and Response, "Science 333, no. 6051 (September 16, 2011): 1574-1576.
14. M. Mauss, The Gift, trans. W.D. Halls ( London : Routledge, 1954, orig. 1924).
15. B. Malinowski, Crime and Custom in Savage Society ( Tonowa, NJ : Helix Books, 1985, orig. 1926): at 24-27.
16. K. Sykes, Arguing with Anthropology: An Introduction to Critical Theories of the Gift ( London : Routledge, 2005): at 1.
17. R. Titmuss, The Gift Relationship: From Human Blood to Social Policy ( London : Allen & Unwin, 1970).
18. Medical Research Council (MRC), Human Tissue and Biological Samples for Use in Research ( London : MRC, 2001).
19. R. Tutton, "Gift Relationships in Genetics Research, " Science as Culture 11, no. 4 (2002): 523-542, at 526.
20. P. Rabinow, French DNA: Trouble in Purgatory (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1999): at 71-111.
21. P. Rabinow, Essays on the Anthropology of Reason ( Princeton, NJ : Princeton University Press, 1996): at 99.
22. M. Sommer, "DNA and Cultures of Remembrance: Anthropological Genetics, Biohistories and Biosocialities, " BioSocieties 5, no. 3 (2010): 366-390.
23. M. S. Lindee, A. H. Goodman, and D. Heath, "Anthropology in and Age of Genetics: Practice, Discourse, and Critique, " in A. H. Goodman, D. Heath, and M. S. Lindee, eds., Genetic Nature/Culture ( Berkeley, CA : University of California Press, 2003): 1-22, at 7.
24. J. S. Luque, G. P. Quinn, F. A. Montel-Ishino, M. Arevalo, S. A. Bynum, S. Noel-Thomas, K. J. Wells, C. K. Gwede, C. D. Meade, and Tampa Bay Community Cancer Network Partners, "Formative Research on Perceptions of Biobanking: What Community Members Think, " Journal of Cancer Education 27, no. 1 (2012): 91-99
25. S. A. Streicher, S. C. Sanderson, E. Wang Jabs, M. Diefenbach, M. Smirnoff, I. Peter, C. R. Horowitz, B. Brenner and L. D. Richardson, "Reasons for Participating and Genetic Information Needs among Racially and Ethnically Diverse Biobank Participants: A Focus Group Study, " Journal of Community Genetics, 2, no. 3 (2011): 153-163
26. C. M. Simon, J. L'Heureux, J. C. Murray, P. Winokur, G. Weiner, E. Newbury, L. Shinkunas, and B. Zimmerman, "Active Choice But Not Too Active: Public Perspectives on Biobank Consent Models, " Genetics in Medicine 13, no. 9 (2011): 821-831.
27. Some of this work, guided by the principles of "deliberative democracy, " has focused on the BC Biobank Deliberation, a four-day "public engagement event" held in British Columbia in 2007.
28. H. Walmsley, "Stock Options, Tax Credits or Employment Contracts Please! The Value of Deliberative Public Disagreement about Human Tissue Donation, "Social Science and Medicine 73, no. 2 (2011): 209-216;
29. D. Secko, N. Preto, S. Miemeyer, and M. Burgess, "Informed Consent in Biobank Research: A Deliberative Approach to the Debate, " Social Science and Medicine 68, no. 4 (2009): 781-789.
30. K. Hoeyer, "Donors Perceptions of Consent to and Feedback from Biobank Research: Time to Acknowledge Diversity?" Public Health Genomics 13, no. 6 (2010): 345-52, at 349.
31. K. Hoeyer, "The Power of Ethics: A Case Study from Sweden on the Social Life of Moral Concerns in Policy Processes, " Sociology of Health and Illness 28, no. 6 (2006): 785-801.
32. B. Johnstone, "Discourse Analysis and Narrative, " in D. Schiffrin, D. Tannen, and H. E. Hamilton, eds., The Handbook of Discourse Analysis ( Malden, MA : Blackwell Publishing, 2001): 635-649
33. J. Conley and W. O'Barr, Just Words: Law, Language, and Power ( Chicago : University of Chicago Press, 1998).
34. M. Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison ( London : Allen Lane, 1977)
35. M. Foucault, The History of Sexuality ( New York : Random House, 1978).
36. C. Goodwin, Conversational Organization: Interaction between Speakers and Hearers ( New York : Academic Press, 1982).
37. E. Goffman, The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life ( Garden City, NY : Doubleday, 1959).
38. H. Garfinkel, Studies in Ethnomethodology ( Englewood Cliffs, NJ : Prentice-Hall, 1967).
39. J. M. Atkinson and P. Drew, Order in Court: The Organisation of Verbal Interaction in Judicial Settings ( Atlantic Highlands, NJ : Humanities Press, 1979): at 18-22.
40. National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws, Uniform Trade Secrets Act, available at (last visited July 10, 2012).
41. Black's Law Dictionary, Abridged Sixth Edition (St. Paul, MN: West Publishing, 1991): at 211.
42. National Cancer Institute, Office of Biorepositories and Biospecimen Research, Custodianship and Ownership Issues in Biospecimen Research, Symposium - Workshop (2008), available at (last visited June 26, 2012).
43. Grimes v. Kennedy Krieger Institute, 366 Md. 29, 782 A. 2d 807 (2001).
44. J. Conley, J. Cadigan, A. Davis, A. Dobson, E. Edwards, R. Fortson, and R. Mitchell, "The Discourse of DNA: Giving Informed Consent to Genetic research, " in C. Heffer, F. Rock, and J. Conley, eds., Lay-Legal Communication: Textual Travel in the Legal Process ( Oxford, UK : Oxford University Press, forthcoming).
45. E. S. Dove, Y. Joly, and B. M. Knoppers, "Trade-Secret Model: Legal Limitations, " Science 333, no. 6051 (2011): 1575, at 1575.
46. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Draft Guidance on Exculpatory Language in Informed Consent (September 2011), available at (last visited June. 25, 2012).
47. Kauffman Foundation, Facilitating the Commercialization of University Innovation: The Carolina Express License Agreement (April 2010), available at (last visited June 25, 2012).
48. Office of Technology Development, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Carolina Express User Guide, at 2, available at (last visited June 26, 2012).