Will Tort Reform Bend the Cost Curve? Evidence from Texas

Journal of Empirical Legal Studies

Volumn 9, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 173-216

  Paik, Myungho ^a   Black, Bernard S ^b   Hyman, David A ^c   Silver, Charles ^d  

^a NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW   (United States)

^b NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY   (United States)

^c UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA CHAMPAIGN   (United States)

^d University of Texas Law School   (United States)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

EID: 84867355474     PISSN: 17401453     EISSN: 17401461     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1740-1461.2012.01251.x     Document Type: Article

References (52)

1. Atanasov, Vladimir, Bernard Black, Conrad Ciccotello, & Stanley Gyoshev (2010) "How Does Law Affect Finance? An Examination of Equity Tunneling in Bulgaria, " 96 J. of Financial Economics 155.
2. Avraham, Ronen, Leemore Dafny, & Max Schanzenbach (2012) "The Impact of Tort Reform on Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Premiums, " 28(4) Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization. Working paper available at
3. Baicker, Katherine, & Amitabh Chandra (2005) "The Effect of Malpractice Liability on the Delivery of Healthcare, " 8 Frontiers in Health Policy Research article 5.
4. Baicker, Katherine, Elliott S. Fisher, & Amitabh Chandra (2007) "Malpractice Liability Costs and the Practice of Medicine in the Medicare Program, " 26 Health Affairs 841.
5. Baldwin Laura-Mae, L. Gary Hart, Michael Lloyd, Meredith Fordyce, E. Roger, & A. Rosenblatt (1995) "Defensive Medicine and Obstetrics, " 274 J. of the American Medical Association 1606.
6. Bishop, Tara F., ALex D. Federman, & Salomeh Keyhani (2010) "Physicians' Views on Defensive Medicine: A National Survey, " 170 Archives of Internal Medicine 1081.
7. Black, Bernard, David Hyman, Charles Silver, & William Sage (2008) "Defense Costs in Medical Malpractice and Other Personal Injury Cases: Evidence from Texas, 1988-2004, " 10 American Law & Economic Rev. 185.
8. Carrier, Emily R., James D. Reschovsky, Michelle M. Mello, Ralph C. Mayrell, & David Katz (2010) "Physicians' Fears of Malpractice Lawsuits Are Not Assuaged by Tort Reforms, " 29 Health Affairs 1585.
9. Carter, Terry (2006) "Tort Reform Texas Style: New Laws and Med-Mal Damage Caps Devastate Plaintiff and Defense Firms Alike, " October ABA J.
10. Congressional Budget Office (CBO) (2004) Limiting Tort Liability for Medical Malpractice. Available at
11. Congressional Budget Office (CBO) (2006) Medical Malpractice Tort Limits and Health Care Spending. Available at
12. Congressional Budget Office (CBO) (2009) Letter to Sen. Orrin Hatch. Available at
13. Currie, Janet, & W. Bentley MacLeod (2008) "First Do No Harm? Tort Reform and Birth Outcomes, " 123 Q. J. of Economics 795.
14. Daniels, Stephen, & Joanne Martin (forthcoming) "It is No Longer Viable from a Practical and Business Standpoint: Damage Caps, 'Hidden Victims, ' and the Declining Interest in Medical Malpractice Cases, " International J. of the Legal Profession.
15. Danzon, Patricia (1984) "The Frequency and Severity of Medical Malpractice Claims, " 27 J. of Law & Economics 115.
16. Danzon, Patricia (1986) "The Frequency and Severity of Medical Malpractice Claims: New Evidence, " 49(2) Law & Contemporary Problems 57.
17. Dhankhar, Praveen, M. Khan, & Shalini Bagga (2007) "Effect of Medical Malpractice on Resource Use and Mortality of AMI Patients, " 4 J. of Empirical Legal Studies 163.
18. Dranove, David, & Yasutoru Watanabe (2010) "Influence and Deterrence: How Obstetricians Respond to Litigation Against Themselves and Their Colleagues, " 12 American Law & Economics Rev. 69.
19. Dubay, Lisa, Robert Kaestner, & Timothy Waidmann (1999), "The Impact of Malpractice Fears on Cesarean Section Rates, " 18 J. of Health Economics 491.
20. Frakes, Michael (2010a) The Impact of Medical Liability Standards on Regional Variations in Cesarean Utilization: Evidence from the Adoption of National-Standard Rules. Working paper. Available at
21. Frakes, Michael (2010b), Defensive Medicine and Obstetric Practices. Working paper. Available at
22. Gawande, Atul (2009) "The Cost Conundrum, " June 1 New Yorker. Available at
23. Gimm, Gilbert (2010) "The Impact of Malpractice Liability Claims on Obstetrical Practice Patterns, " 45 Health Services Research 195.
24. Grant, Darren, & Melayne Morgan McInnes (2004) "Malpractice Experience and the Incidence of Cesarean Delivery: A Physician-Level Longitudinal Analysis, " 41 Inquiry 170.
25. Guardado, Jose R. (2010) Medical Professional Liability Insurance Premiums: An Overview of the 2003-2010 Period, Policy Research Perspectives No. 2010-3. Chicago, IL: American Medical Association.
26. Hellinger, Fred, & William E. Encinosa (2006) "The Impact of State Laws Limiting Malpractice Damage Awards on Health Care Expenditures, " 96 American J. of Public Health 1375.
27. Huber, Peter (1997) "Rx: Radical Lawyerectomy, " January 27 Forbes 112.
28. ISMIE Mutual Insurance Company and Illinois State Medical Society (2010) Fear and Loathing in Illinois: Lawsuit Threat Leads to "Defensive Medicine" in Health Care. Available at
29. Jackson Healthcare (2010) Lawsuit Driven Medicine Creates $650-$850 Billion Annual Healthcare Costs. Available at
30. Kachalia, Allen, & Michelle Mello (2011) "New Directions in Medical Liability Reform, " 364 New England J. of Medicine 1564.
31. Kessler, Daniel, & Mark B. McClellan (1996) "Do Doctors Practice Defensive Medicine?" 111 Q. J. of Economics 353.
32. Kessler, Daniel, & Mark B. McClellan (2002) "Malpractice Law and Health Care Reform: Optimal Liability Policy in an Era of Managed Care, " 84(2) J. of Public Economics 175.
33. Lakdawalla, Darius N., & Seth A. Seabury (2009) The Welfare Effects of Medical Malpractice Liability. NBER working paper. Available at
34. Localio, A. Russell, An G. Lawthers, Joan M. Bengston, Liesi E. Hebert, Susan L. Weaver, Troyen A. Brennan, & J. Richard Landis (1993) "Relationship Between Malpractice Claims and Cesarean Delivery, " 269 J. of the American Medical Association 366.
35. Mello, Michelle M., Amitabh Chandra, Atul A. Gawande, & David M. Studdert (2010) "National Costs of the Medical Liability System, " 29 Health Affairs 1569.
36. Montanera, Daniel (2011) The Hidden Evidence of Defensive Medicine. Working paper.
37. Morrissey, Michael, Meredith L. Kilgore, & Leonard (Jack) Nelson (2008) "Medical Malpractice Reform and Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Premiums, " 43 Health Services Research 2124.
38. Obama, Barak (2009) Speech to Congress, September 9. Available at
39. Paik, Myungho, David A. Hyman, Bernard Black, William Sage, & Charles Silver (2012) How the Elderly Fare in Medical Malpractice Litigation, Before and After Tort Reform? Evidence from Texas. Working paper, available at
40. Pricewaterhouse Coopers' Health Research Institute (undated, approx. 2007) The Price of Excess: Identifying Waste in Healthcare Spending. Available at
41. Robeznieks, Andis (2010) "Medical Malpractice: The Fear Factor, September 13 Modern Physician 6.
42. Sclar, David, & Michael Housman (2003) "Medical Malpractice and Physician Liability: Examining Alternatives in Defensive Medicine, " 4(1) Harvard Health Policy Rev. 75.
43. Slavin, Al (2010) "Post Tort-Reform Shift Takes Hold in Texas Market, " February 8 Best Wire Services.
44. Sloan, Frank A., Paul M. Mergenhagen, & Randall R. Bovbjerg (1989) "Effects of Tort Reforms on the Value of Closed Medical Malpractice Claims: A Microanalysis, " 14 J. of Health Politics, Policy & Law 663.
45. Sloan, Frank A., & John H. Shadle (2009) "Is There Empirical Evidence for 'Defensive Medicine'? A Reassessment, " 28 J. of Health Economics 481.
46. Stewart, Ronald M., Kathy Geoghegan, John G. Myers, Kenneth R. Sirinek, Michael G. Corneille, Deborah Mueller, Danile L. Dent, Steven E. Wolf, & Basil A. Pruitt, Jr. (2011) "Malpractice Risk and Cost Are Significantly Reduced After Tort Reform, " 212 J. of the American College of Surgeons 463.
47. Studdert, David M., Michelle M. Mello, William M. Sage, Catherine M. DesRoches, Jordon Peugh, Kinga Zapert, & Troyen A. Brennan (2005) "Defensive Medicine Among High-Risk Specialist Physicians in a Volatile Malpractice Environment, " 293 J. of the American Medical Association 2609.
48. Thomas, J. William, Erika C. Ziller, & Deborah A. Thayer (2010) "Low Costs of Defensive Medicine, Small Savings from Tort Reform, " 29 Health Affairs 1578.
49. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (2002) Confronting the New Health Care Crisis: Improving Health Care Quality and Lowering Costs by Fixing Our Medical Liability System. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Health & Human Services.
50. Yang, Y. Tony, Michelle M. Mello, S. V. Subramanian, & David M. Studdert (2009) "Relationship Between Malpractice Litigation Pressure and Rates of Cesarean Section and Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Section, " 47 Medical Care 234.
51. Zabinski, Zenon, & Bernard Black (2012) The Effect of Tort Reform on Health Care Quality Patient Safety: Evidence from Texas. Working paper.
52. Zuckerman, Stephen, Randall R. Bovbjerg, & Frank Sloan (1990) "Effects of Tort Reforms and Other Factors on Medical Malpractice Insurance Premiums, " 27 Inquiry 167.