It's time to get serious-why legislation is needed to make sustainable development a reality in the UK

Sustainability

Volumn 2, Issue 4, 2010, Pages 1101-1127

  Ross, Andrea ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF DUNDEE   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Framework; Legislation; Statute; Strategy; Sustainable development

Indexed keywords

EID: 84866788832     PISSN: 20711050     EISSN: None     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.3390/su2041101     Document Type: Article

References (139)

1. WWF; Zoological Society of London; Global Footprint Network. Living Planet Report 2008; p. 2; Available online: http://www.panda.org/about_our_earth/all_publications/living_planet_ report/ (accessed on 1 April 2010). The Ecological Footprint measures the amount of biologically productive land and water area required to produce the resources an individual, population or activity consumes and to absorb the waste it generates, given prevailing technology and resource management.
2. Hadley Centre for Climate Prediction and Research. Met Office Resources; Available online: http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/climatechange/science/hadleycentre/ (accessed on 1 April 2010).
3. Secretariat of the Convention on Biological Diversity. Global Biodiversity Outlook (GBO-2), 2006; Available online: http://www.cbd.int/gbo2/ (accessed on 1 April 2010).
4. World Commission on Environment and Development. Our Common Future (The Brundtland Report); Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 1987.
5. Consolidated Versions of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union. Official Journal of the European Union, 9 May 2008, No. C 115; Available online: http://walmartstores.com/FactsNews/NewsRoom/8696.aspx (accessed on 12 April 2010); http://world.honda.com/environment/ecology/2008report/ (accessed on 12 April 2010).
6. Porritt, J. The Standing of Sustainable Development in Government, November 2009; p. 10; Available online: http://www.jonathonporritt.com/pages/2009/11/the_standing_of_sustainable_ de.html (accessed on 12 April 2010).
7. Dernbach, J. Navigating the U.S. Transition to Sustainability: Matching National Governance Challenges with Appropriate Legal Tools. Tulsa Law Rev. 2008, 44, 93-120.
8. Ross, A. Why Legislate for Sustainable Development? An Examination of Sustainable Development Provisions in UK and Scottish Statutes. J. Environ. Law 2008, 20, 35-68.
9. Jenkins, V. Placing Sustainable Development at the Heart of Government in the UK: The Role of Law in the Evolution of Sustainable Development as the Central Organising Principle of Government. Legal Studies 2002, 22, 578-602.
10. There is such a duty in Wales under the s.79 of the Government of Wales Act 2006.
11. Many of the points raised for Scotland apply equally to Northern Ireland however, progress in Northern Ireland on sustainable development lags well behind the rest of the UK due to, among other things, the suspension of devolution from to 2007 and the power-sharing arrangements for government which often lead to deadlock.
12. Turner, S. Laying the Foundations of a Sustainable Northern Ireland: The Review of Environmental Governance. N. Irel. Leg. Quart. 2007, 58, 422-458;
13. Turner, S. Transforming Environmental Governance in Northern Ireland. Part One: The Process of Policy Renewal. J. Environ. Law 2008, 18, 55-87.
14. Turner, S. Transforming Environmental Governance in Northern Ireland. Part Two: The Case of Environmental Regulation. J. Environ. Law 2008, 18, 245-275.
15. The Greening Government Initiative; Second Report of Session 1997-98, HC 517-II (1997-98) Q2 (answer given in evidence January 28, 1998); House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee: London, UK, 1998
16. Improving Policy Coherence and Integration for Sustainable Development: A Checklist; Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD): Paris, France, 2002; Available online: www.oecd.org/dataoecd/60/1/1947305.pdf (accessed on 1 April 2010).
17. Shows Promise. But Must Try Harder-An Assessment by the Sustainable Development Commission of the Government's Reported Progress on Sustainable Development Over the Past Five Years; Sustainable Development Commission: London, UK, April 2004.
18. Kavanagh, D.; Richards, D. Departmentalism and Joined-Up Government: Back to the Future? Parliament Aff. 2001, 54, 1-18.
19. Many different frameworks have been adopted and are being tested. Global Trends and Status of Indicators of Sustainable Development; Background Paper No.2DESA/DSD/2006/2; Division for Sustainable Development UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs: New York, NY, USA, 2006.
20. Hodge, R.A.; Hardi, P. The Need for Guidelines: The Rationale Underlying the Bellagio Principles for Assessment-Chapter 2. In Assessing Sustainable Development: Principles in Practice; Hardi, P., Zdan, T., Eds.; International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD): Winnipeg, Canada; 1997; Volume i-iv, pp. 1-164.
21. Ross, A. Sustainable Development Indicators and a Putative Argument for Law: A Case Study of the UK. In Global Justice and Sustainable Development; French, D., Ed.; Martinus Nijhoff: Leiden, The Netherlands, 2010; pp. 1-441.
22. Ross, A. Modern Interpretations of Sustainable Development. J. Law Soc. 2009, 36, 32-54.
23. Swanson, D.L.; Pintér, L.; Bregha, F.; Volkery, A.; Jacob, K. National Strategies for Sustainable Development: Challenges, Approaches and Innovations in Strategic and Co-ordinated Action; p. 41. Available online: www.iisd.org/pdf/2004/measure_nat_strategies_sd.pdf (accessed on 8 December 2009).
24. Dernbach, J. National Governance. In Stumbling toward Sustainability; Dernbach, J., Ed.; Environmental Law Institute: Washington DC, USA, 2002; pp. 724-727; p. 723 as cited
25. Dernbach, J. Navigating the U.S. Transition to Sustainability: Matching National Governance Challenges with Appropriate Legal Tools. Tulsa Law Rev. 2008, 44, 93-120.
26. Sustainable Development: The UK Strategy; Cm 2426; Department of Environment Food and Rural Affair: London, UK, 1994
27. Opportunities for Change-Consultation Paper on a Revised UK Strategy for Sustainable Development; Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions (DETR): London, UK, 1998
28. The 1999 strategy advocates the three prongs-social, economic, environment-whereby high economic growth is still one of four objectives
29. A Better Quality of Life: A Strategy for Sustainable Development for the United Kingdom; Cm 4345; Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions (DETR): London, UK, 1999
30. The Sustainable Development Strategy: Illusion or Reality? Thirteenth Report of Session 2003-04, Volume I, HC 624-I; House of Commons Environmental Audit Committee: London, UK, 2004
31. Sustainable Development-A Review of Progress by the Scottish Government, Sustainable Development Commission (Scotland): Edinburgh, UK, November 2008
32. Taking It On-Developing a UK Sustainable Development Strategy Together-A Consultation Paper; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA): London, UK, 2004
33. Blowers, A. Planning a Sustainable Future: Problems, Principles and Prospects. Town Country Plann. 1992, 61, 132.
34. Pearce, D. Blue Print 3-Measuring Sustainable Development; Earthscan: London, UK, 1993.
35. For a slightly stronger view see Bowers, J. Sustainability and Environmental Economics-An Alternative Text; Longman: Harlow, UK, 1997.
36. Bosselmann, K. The Principle of Sustainability-Transforming Law and Governance; Ashgate: Aldershot, UK, 2008.
37. Where We Are Now. A Review of Progress on Sustainable Development; Sustainable Development Commission: London, UK, July 2009.
38. Agenda for a Sustainable America; Dernbach, J, Ed.; Environmental Law Institute: Washington DC, USA, 2009.
39. One Future-Different Paths: The UK's Shared Framework for Sustainable Development; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA): London, UK, 2005
40. The UK Strategy for Sustainable Development-Securing the Future; Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA): London, UK, 2005
41. Choosing Our Future Scotland's Sustainable Development Strategy; Scottish Executive: Edinburgh, UK, 2005
42. Starting to Live Differently-The Sustainable Development Scheme of the National Assembly for Wales; National Assembly for Wales: Cardiff, UK, 2006
43. Sustainable Development Strategy for Northern Ireland-First Steps towards Sustainability; Northern Ireland Office: Belfast, UK, 2006 (produced while devolution was still suspended. The office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister has produced a plan of implementation for the strategy)
44. Everyone's Involved: Sustainable Development Strategy; Office of the First Minister and Deputy First Minister: Belfast, UK, 22 October 2009
45. The Government Economic Strategy; Scottish Government: Edinburgh, UK, 2007
46. Scotland Performs; Scottish Government: Edinburgh, UK, 2007
47. Scottish Planning Policy; Scottish Government: Edinburgh, UK, February 2010
48. One Wales: One Planet, a New Sustainable Development Scheme for Wales; Welsh Assembly Government: Cardiff, UK, 2009
49. Britain to pledge legally-binding emissions cut. The Independent, 16 October 2008.
50. Brown: Petrol firms must lower fuel prices or face OFT inquiry. The Independent, 17 October 2008.
51. Government green light for Stansted expansion. The Independent, 9 October 2008
52. Watson, J. Scrapping bridge toll adds half an hour to road misery across the Forth. Scotland on Sunday, 24 February 2008; Available online: http://scotlandonsunday.scotsman.com/scotland/ Scrapping-bridge-toll-adds.3809986.jp (accessed on 12 April 2010).
53. Oliver, D. Constitutional Reform in the UK; Oxford University Press: Oxford, UK, 2003.
54. Freeman, J. Private parties, public function and the real democracy problem in the new administrative law? In Recrafting the Rule of Law; Dyzenhous, D., Ed.; Hart: Oxford, UK, 1999; pp. 31-37
55. Cussons, S. Review of Statutory Sustainable Development Duties; IHPC: London, UK, 2006.
56. Birley, T. Reality Check: A Review of Scottish Executive Activity on Sustainable Development; Report to WWF Scotland; WWF Scotland: Perthshire, UK, October 2001.
57. Sustainability Counts-A Consultation Paper on a Set of Headline Indicators of Sustainable Development; Sustainable Development Unit, DEFRA: London, UK, November 1998
58. Sustainable Development Action Plans (SDA) Progress Reports-The Sustainable Development Commission's Key Findings; Sustainable Development Commission UK (SDC): London, UK, January 2008
59. Blair, F.; Evans, B. Seeing the Bigger Picture-Delivering Local Sustainable Development; Sustainable Development Commission UK (SDC): London, UK, April 2004.
60. Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 2005, s. 20.
61. Clean Neighbourhoods and Environment Act 2005, s. 88(9).
62. Transport Act, s. 207(2)(b).
63. Water Industry (Scotland) Act 2002, s. 51.
64. Rubin, E. Law and Legislation in the Administrative State. Colum. Law Rev. 1989, 89, 369-426.
65. Mader, L. Evaluating Effects: A Contribution to the Quality of Legislation. Statute Law Rev. 2001, 22, 119-131.
66. The Constitution of the Republic of Poland (1997), Article 5
67. The Constitution for the Republic of South Africa (1996) Article 24
68. Treaty of European Union (Lisbon consolidation) OJ C115/13 (9.5.2008) Article 3(3) provides that '[the Union] shall work for the sustainable development of Europe.' Article 3(5) similarly requires the Union to 'contribute to the sustainable development of the Earth'.
69. The Scotland Act 1998
70. The Northern Ireland Act 1998
71. Ross, A. The UK approach to delivering sustainable development in government: a case study in joined up working. J. Environ. Law 2005, 17, 27-49.
72. Achieving a Better Quality of Life: Review of Progress towards Sustainable Development: Government Annual Report 2000; Department of Environment, Transport and the Regions (DETR): London, UK, 2000
73. Is the Scottish Executive Structured and Positioned to Deliver Sustainable Development? Environment and Rural Development Committee 10th Report 2004 (Session 2), Volume 2, SP Paper 206; The Scottish Parliament: Edinburgh, UK, 2004; p. 43.
74. Scottish Planning Policy (SPP) 1: The Planning System; Scottish Executive: Edinburgh, UK, November 2002
75. Planning Policy Guidance (PPG) 1: General Policies and Principles; Office of the Deputy Prime Minister: London, UK, 1997
76. Planning and Compulsory Purchase Act 2004
77. Planning etc. (Scotland) Act 2006.
78. Article 11 and 191-193 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union OJ C115/47 (9.5.2008) set out the integration, polluter pays, preventative and precautionary principles.
79. Winter, G. The Legal Nature of Environmental Principles in International, EC and German Law. In Principles of European Environmental Law; Macrory, R., Ed.; Europa Law Publishing: Groningen, The Netherlands, 2004.
80. Council Directive (EC) 2000/60 establishing a framework for Community action in the field of water policy, as amended [the Water Framework Directive]
81. Natural Environment and Rural Communities Act 2006 Sch. 4-the Joint Nature Conservancy Council as an example all the UK administrations working together.
82. Reid, C.T. Nature Conservation Law, 3rd ed.; W. Green: Edinburgh, UK, 2009.
83. Bulmer, S.; Burch, M.; Hogwood, P.; Scott, A. UK Devolution and the European Union: A Tale of Cooperative Asymmetry. Publius 2006, 36, 75-85.
84. Ross, A.; Nash, H. European Union Environmental Law-Why Legislates for Whom in a Devolved Great Britain. Public Law, July 2009, pp. 564-595.
85. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c. 33.
86. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1.
87. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended.
88. Sustainable Development Act 2007 SNL cS-34. Note that statute for Newfoundland and Labrador is limited to the sustainable development of natural resources in the province and as such is of only limited use in a UK context.
89. Lindblom, C.E. Still Muddling, Not Yet Through. Pub. Admin. R. 1979, 39, 517-525.
90. Sustainable Development Annual Report 2007-2008; Welsh Assembly Government: Cardiff, UK, 2008
91. There is very weak substantive obligation imposed on the Assembly Commission (which is the contracting arm of the legislature) that 'in the exercise of the functions of the Assembly Commission due regard must be had to the principle of promoting sustainable development. In Schedule 2, clause 8(2).
92. How Effectively Has the National Assembly for Wales Promoted Sustainable Development? Report to the Welsh Assembly Government; CAG Consultants: London, UK, October 2003
93. Flynn, A.; Marsden, T.; Netherwood, A.; Pitts, R. Final Report, The Sustainable Development Effectiveness Report for the Welsh Assembly; The Welsh Assembly Government: Cardiff, UK, March 2008.
94. Sustainable Development in Wales: From Pioneer to Delivery; Sustainable Development Commission (SDC): London, UK, June 2006
95. Munday, M.; Roberts, A. Developing approaches to measuring and monitoring sustainable development in Wales. Reg. Stud. 2006, 40, 535-554.
96. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c.33, ss. 9-11.
97. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, ss. 5-12, 15.
98. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c.61 as amended s. 7.
99. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c.33, s. 7.
100. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, ss. 8,12,13.
101. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61, as amended s. 5.
102. See Auditor General Act 1985, RSC 1985 A-17 as amended s. 7, ss. 21.1-23.
103. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, s. 31.
104. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 16(1)(b).
105. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, s. 26.
106. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c.61 as amended s. 17.
107. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, ss. 7,13.
108. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 9.
109. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c. 33, ss. 6,8.
110. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 4.
111. Ross, A. Sustainable development in Scotland post devolution. Environ. Law Rev. 2006, 8, 6-32.
112. Reid, C.T. Environment and Sustainable Development. In Law Making and the Scottish Parliament: The Early Years; Sutherland, E.E., Goodall, K.E., Little, G.F.M., Davidson F., Eds.; Edinburgh University Press: Edinburgh, UK, 2010.
113. Transport Act 2000, s. 207(2)(b).
114. Water Environment and Water Services (Scotland) Act 2003, s. 2(4).
115. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c. 33, s. 9, 10.
116. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, s. 11.
117. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 7(2).
118. Climate Change Act 2008, ss. 13(3), 58(2).
119. Porritt, J. Looking Back on Nine Years at the Sustainable Development Commission; Available online: http://www.forumforthefuture.org/blog/looking-back-on-nine-years-at-the-SDC (accessed on 12 April 2010).
120. Jackson, T. Prosperity without Growth-Transition to a Sustainable Economy; Sustainable Development Commission (SDC): London, UK, 2009.
121. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, s. 1.
122. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended, s. 2.
123. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c. 33, s. 5.
124. Federal Sustainable Development Act 2008, c. 33, s. 2.
125. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, s. 2.
126. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 1.
127. Collar, N. Planning, 2nd ed.; W. Green: Edinburgh, UK, 1990.
128. Sustainable Development Act 2006, RSQ cD-8.1.1, ss. 6, 7.
129. Sustainable Development Act 1997, S.M c. 61 as amended s. 3.
130. Roberts, I.R.; Reid, C.T. Nature conservation duties: more appearance than substance. Environ. Law Manage. 2005, 17, 162-168.
131. In contrast see Abu Dhabi Law No. (16) of 2005 Reorganization of the Abu Dhabi Environment Agency, Article 3 which states that 'To fulfill the above objectives, the Agency has the followingresponsibilities: 22-Achieve sustainable development through environmental activities'.
132. Bell, S. Statutory Pollution Prevention Objectives: Are They Rules or Aims? J. Environ. Law 2003, 15, 78-81.
133. Climate Change Act 2008, s. 1(1) 'It is the duty of the Secretary of State to ensure that the net UK carbon account for the year 2050 is at least 80% lower than the 1990 baseline'.
134. Horsham D.C. v. First Secretary of State, Devine Homes plc [2004] EWHC 769.
135. R(Ludham) v. the First Secretary of State, Derbyshire D.C. [2004] EWHC 99.
136. Friends of the Earth v Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change [2009] EWCA Civ 810
137. Reid, C.T. Enforcement of Policy Duties. Scottish Plan. Environ. Law 2009, 132, 44.
138. Reid, C.T. Enforcement of Policy Duties Part II. Scottish Plan. Environ. Law 2010, 137, 15.
139. Factortame v. Sec. of State for Transport (No.1) [1989] 2 W.L.R. 997 (HL); 1990 The Times 20 June (E.C.J.); (No.2) [1990] 3 W.L.R. 818 (H.L.); [1991] 3 All E.R. 769.