Is sustainability certification for biochar the answer to environmental risks?

Pesquisa Agropecuaria Brasileira

Volumn 47, Issue 5, 2012, Pages 637-648

  Cowie, Annette L ^a   Downie, Adriana E ^b   George, Brendan H ^c   Singh, Bhupinder Pal ^d   Van Zwieten, Lukas ^e   O'Connell, Deborah ^f  

^a UNIVERSITY OF NEW ENGLAND   (Australia)

^b Pacific Pyrolysis Pty Ltd   (Australia)

^c UNE/NSW DPI   (Australia)

^d NSW DEPARTMENT OF PRIMARY INDUSTRIES   (Australia)

^e Rural Climate Solutions   (Australia)

^f CSIRO   (Australia)

Author keywords

Climate change; Life cycle assessment; Risk management; Sustainable land management

Indexed keywords

EID: 84865306791     PISSN: 0100204X     EISSN: 16783921     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1590/S0100-204X2012000500002     Document Type: Article

References (72)

1. Biofuelwatch. Biochar: A Critical Review Of Science And Policy. 2011. 42p. Available At:. Accessed On: 23 May 2012.
2. Bridle, T.R.; Pritchard, D. Energy And Nutrient Recovery From Sewage Sludge Via Pyrolysis. Water Science And Technology, V.50, P.169-175, 2004.
3. Brinton Junior, W.F. Characterization Of Man-Made Foreign Matter And Its Presence In Multiple Size Fractions From Mixed Waste Composting. Compost Science And Utilization, V.13, P.274-280, 2005.
4. Brown, R. Biochar Production Technology. In: Lehmann, J.; Joseph, S. (Ed.). Biochar For Environmental Management: Science And Technology. London: Earthscan, 2009. 127-139.
5. Bushnaf, K.M.; Puricelli, S.; Saponaro, S.; Werner, D. Effect Of Biochar On The Fate Of Volatile Petroleum Hydrocarbons In An Aerobic Sandy Soil. Journal Of Contaminant Hydrology, V.126, P.208-215, 2011.
6. Chen, B.; Yuan, M. Enhanced Sorption Of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons By Soil Amended With Biochar. Journal Of Soils And Sediments, V.11, P.62-71, 2011.
7. Cherubini, F. Ghg Balances Of Bioenergy Systems - Overview Of Key Steps In The Production Chain And Methodological Concerns. Renewable Energy, V.35, P.1565-1573, 2010.
8. Cherubini, F.; Bird, N.; Cowie, A.; Jungmeier, G.; Schlamadinger, B.; Woess-Gallasch, S. Energy- And Greenhouse Gas-Based Lca Of Biofuel And Bioenergy Systems: Key Issues, Ranges And Recommendations. Resources, Conservation And Recycling, V.53, P.434-447, 2009.
9. Cowie, A.L.; Smith, P.; Johnson, D. Does Soil Carbon Loss In Biomass Production Systems Negate The Greenhouse Benefits Of Bioenergy? Mitigation And Adaptation Strategies For Global Change, V.11, P.979-1002, 2006.
10. Cross, A.; Sohi, S.P. The Priming Potential Of Biochar Products In Relation To Labile Carbon Contents And Soil Organic Matter Status. Soil Biology And Biochemistry, V.43, P.2127-2134, 2011.
11. Cuypers, F.; Helsen, L. Pyrolysis Of Chromated Copper Arsenate (Cca) Treated Wood Waste At Elevated Pressure: Influence Of Particle Size, Heating Rate, Residence Time, Temperature And Pressure. Journal Of Analytical And Applied Pyrolysis, V.92, P.111-122, 2011.
12. Delucchi, M.A. Impacts Of Biofuels On Climate Change, Water Use, And Land Use. Annals Of The New York Academy Of Sciences, V.1195, P.28-45, 2010.
13. Downie, A.; Munroe, P.; Cowie, A.; Van Zwieten, L.; Lau, D.M.S. Biochar As A Geo-Engineering Climate Solution: Hazard Identification And Risk Management. Critical Reviews In Environmental Science And Technology, V.42, P.225-250, 2012.
14. Duku, M.H.; Gu, S.; Hagan, E.B. Biochar Production Potential In Ghana: A Review. Renewable And Sustainable Energy Reviews, V.15, P.3539-3551, 2011.
15. European Parliament. Directive 2009/28/Ec Of The European Parliament And Of The Council Of 23 April 2009 On The Promotion Of The Use Of Energy From Renewable Sources And Amending And Subsequently Repealing Directives 2001/77/Ec And 2003/30/E. Official Journal Of The European Union, V.140, L 140/1-L 140/61, 2009.
16. Farine, D.R.; O'connell, D.A.; Raison, R.J.; May, B.M.; O'connor, M.H.; Crawford, D.F.; Herr, A.; Taylor, J.A.; Jovanovic, T.; Campbell, P.K.; Dunlop, M.I.A.; Rodriguez, L.C.; Poole, M.L.; Braid, A.L.; Kriticos, D. An Assessment Of Biomass For Bioelectricity And Biofuel, And For Greenhouse Gas Emission Reduction In Australia. Global Change Biology Bioenergy, V.4, P.148-175, 2011.
17. École Polytechnique Fédérale De Lausanne. The Roundtable On Sustainable Biofuels. 2008. Available At: . Accessed On: 30 May 2012.
18. Fehrenbach, H.; Giegrich, J.; Reinhardt, G.; Schmitz, J.; Sayer, U.; Gretz, M.; Seizinger, E.; Lanje, K. Criteria For A Sustainable Use Of Bioenergy On A Global Scale. Dessau-Roßlau: Federal Environment Agency, 2008. 245p.
19. Fellet, G.; Marchiol, L.; Delle Vedove, G.; Peressotti, A. Application Of Biochar On Mine Tailings: Effects And Perspectives For Land Reclamation. Chemosphere, V.83, P.1262-1267, 2011.
20. Food And Agriculture Organization Of The United Nations. Bioenergy And Food Security Criteria And Indicators (Befsci) Project. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
21. Forster, P.; Ramaswamy, V.; Artaxo, P.; Berntsen, T.; Betts, R.; Fahey, D.W.; Haywood, J.; Lean, J.; Lowe, D.C.; Myhre, G.; Nganga, J.; Prinn, R.; Raga, G.; Schulz, M.; Van Dorland, R. Changes In Atmospheric Constituents And In Radiative Forcing. In: Solomon, S.; Qin, D.; Manning, M.; Chen, Z.; Marquis, M.; Averyt, K.B.; Tignor, M.; Miller, H.L. (Ed.). Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis: Contribution Of Working Group I To The Fourth Assessment Report Of The Intergovernmental Panel On Climate Change. Cambridge: Cambridge University, 2007. P.129-234.
22. Fsc-Watch. Fsc-Watch [Home Page]. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
23. Gaunt, J.; Cowie, A. Biochar, Greenhouse Gas Accounting And Emissions Trading. In: Lehmann, J.; Joseph, S. (Ed.). Biochar For Environmental Management: Science And Technology. London: Earthscan, 2009. P.317-340.
24. Global Bioenergy Partnership. Gbep Task Force On Sustainability. Available At: . Accessed On: 30 May 2012.
25. Gomez-Eyles, J.L.; Sizmur, T.; Collins, C.D.; Hodson, M.E. Effects Of Biochar And The Earthworm Eisenia Fetida On The Bioavailability Of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons And Potentially Toxic Elements. Environmental Pollution, V.159, P.616-622, 2011.
26. Hammond, J.; Shackley, S.; Sohi, S.; Brownsort, P. Prospective Life Cycle Carbon Abatement For Pyrolysis Biochar Systems In The Uk. Energy Policy, V.39, P.2646-2655, 2011.
27. International Biochar Initiative. International Biochar Initiative [Home Page]. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
28. International Institute For Sustainable Development. The Helsinki Process. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
29. International Organization For Standardization. Iso 14040:2006: Environmental Management - Life Cycle Assessment - Principles And Framework. Switzerland: International Organization For Standardization, 2006. 28p.
30. International Organization For Standardization. Tc 248: Sustainability Criteria For Bioenergy. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
31. Janowiak, M.K.; Webster, C.R. Promoting Ecological Sustainability In Woody Biomass Harvesting. Journal Of Forestry, V.108, P.16-23, 2010.
32. Jeffery, S.; Verheijen, F.G.A.; Van Der Velde, M.; Bastos, A.C. A Quantitative Review Of The Effects Of Biochar Application To Soils On Crop Productivity Using Meta-Analysis. Agriculture, Ecosystems And Environment, V.144, P.175-187, 2011.
33. Junginger, M.; Dam, J. Van; Zarrilli, S.; Mohamed, F.A.; Marchal, D.; Faaij, A. Opportunities And Barriers For International Bioenergy Trade. Utrecht: Copernicus Institute: Utrecht University, 2010. 76p.
34. Kakitani, T.; Hata, T.; Kajimoto, T.; Imamura, Y. Two Possible Pathways For The Release Of Arsenic During Pyrolysis Of Chromated Copper Arsenate (Cca)-Treated Wood. Journal Of Hazardous Materials, V.113, P.247-252, 2004.
35. Kammann, C.; Linsel, S.; Gößling, J.; Koyro, H.-W. Influence Of Biochar On Drought Tolerance Of Chenopodium Quinoa Willd And On Soil-Plant Relations. Plant And Soil, V.345, P.195-210, 2011.
36. Karhu, K.; Mattila, T.; Bergstrom, I.; Regina, K. Biochar Addition To Agricultural Soil Increased Ch4 Uptake And Water Holding Capacity - Results From A Short-Term Pilot Field Study. Agriculture, Ecosystems And Environment, V.140, P.309-313, 2011.
37. Karmann, M.; Smith, A. Fsc Reflected In Scientific And Professional Literature: Literature Study On The Outcomes And Impacts Of Fsc Certification. [S.L.]: Forest Stewardship Council, 2009. 244p.
38. Keith, A.; Singh, B.; Singh, B.P. Interactive Priming Of Biochar And Labile Organic Matter Mineralization In A Smectite-Rich Soil. Environmental Science And Technology, V.45, P.9611-9618, 2011.
39. Kinney, T.J.; Masiello, C.A.; Dugan, B.; Hockaday, W.C.; Dean, M.R.; Zygourakis, K.; Barnes, R.T. Hydrologic Properties Of Biochars Produced At Different Temperatures. Biomass And Bioenergy, V41, P.34-43, 2012.
40. Kookana, R.S.; Sarmah, A.K.; Van Zwieten, L.; Krull, E.; Singh, B. Chapter Three - Biochar Application To Soil: Agronomic And Environmental Benefits And Unintended Consequences. Advances In Agronomy, V.112, P.103-143, 2011.
41. Lehmann, J.; Gaunt, J.; Rondon, M. Bio-Char Sequestration In Terrestrial Ecosystems: A Review. Mitigation And Adaptation Strategies For Global Change, V.11, P.403-427, 2006.
42. Lehmann, J.; Joseph, S. Biochar For Environmental Management: Science And Technology. London: Earthscan, 2009. 416p.
43. Lewandowski, I.; Faaij, A.P.C. Steps Towards The Development Of A Certification System For Sustainable Bio-Energy Trade. Biomass And Bioenergy, V.30, P.83-104, 2006.
44. Liang, B.; Lehmann, J.; Sohi, S.P.; Thies, J.E.; O'neill, B.; Trujillo, L.; Gaunt, J.; Solomon, D.; Grossman, J.; Neves, E.G.; Luizão, F.J. Black Carbon Affects The Cycling Of Non-Black Carbon In Soil. Organic Geochemistry, V.41, P.206-213, 2010.
45. Luo, Y.; Durenkamp, M.; De Nobili, M.; Lin, Q.; Brookes, P.C. Short Term Soil Priming Effects And The Mineralisation Of Biochar Following Its Incorporation To Soils Of Different Ph. Soil Biology And Biochemistry, V.43, P.2304-2314, 2011.
46. Montréal Process Working Group. The Montreal Process. Available At: . Accessed On: 28 May 2012.
47. Namgay, T.; Singh, B.; Singh, B.P. Influence Of Biochar Application To Soil On The Availability Of As, Cd, Cu, Pb, And Zn To Maize (Zea Mays L.). Australian Journal Of Soil Research, V.48, P.638-647, 2010.
48. O'connell, D.; Braid, A.; Raison, J.; Handberg, K.; Cowie, A.; Rodriguez, L.; George, B. Sustainable Production Of Bioenergy: A Review Of Global Bioenergy Sustainability Frameworks And Assessment System. Canberra: Rural Industries Research And Development Corporation, 2009. 164p.
49. Park, J.H.; Choppala, G.K.; Bolan, N.S.; Chung, J.W.; Chuasavathi, T. Biochar Reduces The Bioavailability And Phytotoxicity Of Heavy Metals. Plant And Soil, V.348, P.439-451, 2011.
50. Peña-Claros, M.; Blommerde, S.; Bongers, F. Assessing The Progress Made: An Evaluation Of Forest Management Certification In The Tropics. Wageningen: Wageningen University, 2009. 76p. (Tropical Resource Management Papers, 95).
51. Peng, X.; Ye, L.L.; Wang, C.H.; Zhou, H.; Sun, B. Temperature- And Duration-Dependent Rice Straw-Derived Biochar: Characteristics And Its Effects On Soil Properties Of An Ultisol In Southern China. Soil And Tillage Research, V.112, P.159-166, 2011.
52. Purbawiyatna, A.; Simula, M. Developing Forest Certification: Towards Increasing The Comparability Ad Acceptance Of Forest Certification Systems. Yokohama: International Tropical Timber Orgazination, 2008. 126p. (Itto. Technical Series, 29).
53. Roberts, K.G.; Gloy, B.A.; Joseph, S.; Scott, N.R.; Lehmann, J. Life Cycle Assessment Of Biochar Systems: Estimating The Energetic, Economic, And Climate Change Potential. Environmental Science And Technology, V.44, P.827-833, 2010.
54. Ros-Tonen, M.A.F. The Final Report Of The Congress On 'Globalisation, Localisation And Tropical Forest Management In The 21st Century', Held In Amsterdam On 22-23 October 2003. Amsterdam: University Of Amsterdam, 2004. 40p.
55. Singh, B.P.; Cowie, A. The Mean Turnover Time Of Biochar In Soil Varies Depending On Biomass Source And Pyrolysis Temperature. In: World Congress Of Soil Science, Soil Solutions For A Changing World, 19., 2010, Brisbane. Proceedings. Brisbane: Iuss, 2010. P.235-238.
56. Singh, B.P.; Hatton, B.J.; Singh, B.; Cowie, A.L.; Kathuria, A. Influence Of Biochars On Nitrous Oxide Emission And Nitrogen Leaching From Two Contrasting Soils. Journal Of Environmental Quality, V.39, P.1224-1235, 2010.
57. Standards Australia. As 4454: Composts, Soil Conditioners And Mulches. Sydney: Standards Australia International, 2003. 55p.
58. Streubel, J.D.; Collins, H.P.; Garcia-Perez, M.; Tarara, J.; Granatstein, D.; Kruger, C.E. Influence Of Contrasting Biochar Types On Five Soils At Increasing Rates Of Application. Soil Science Society Of America Journal, V.75, P.1402-1413, 2011.
59. Stupak, I.; Lattimore, B.; Titus, B.D.; Tattersall Smith, C. Criteria And Indicators For Sustainable Forest Fuel Production And Harvesting: A Review Of Current Standards For Sustainable Forest Management. Biomass And Bioenergy, V.35, P.3287-3308, 2011.
60. Sun, K.; Keiluweit, M.; Kleber, M.; Pan, Z.; Xing, B. Sorption Of Fluorinated Herbicides To Plant Biomass-Derived Biochars As A Function Of Molecular Structure. Bioresource Technology, V.102, P.9897-9897-9903, 2011.
61. Uchimiya, M.; Bannon, D.I.; Wartelle, L.H. Retention Of Heavy Metals By Carboxyl Functional Groups Of Biochars In Small Arms Range Soil. Journal Of Agricultural And Food Chemistry, V.60, P.1798-1809, 2012.
62. Urabe, T.; Imasaka, T. Analysis Of Thermal Decomposition Products Arising From Polyvinyl Chloride Analogs By Supersonic Jet/Multiphoton Ionization/Mass Spectrometry. Talanta, V.52, P.703-709, 2000.
63. Van Dam, J.; Junginger, M.; Faaij, A.; Jürgens, I.; Best, G.; Fritsche, U. Overview Of Recent Developments In Sustainable Biomass Certification. Biomass And Bioenergy, V.32, P.749-780, 2008.
64. Van Zwieten, L.; Kimber, S.; Morris, S.; Chan, K.; Downie, A.; Rust, J.; Joseph, S.; Cowie, A. Effects Of Biochar From Slow Pyrolysis Of Papermill Waste On Agronomic Performance And Soil Fertility. Plant And Soil, V.327, P.235-246, 2010a.
65. Van Zwieten, L.; Kimber, S.; Morris, S.; Downie, A.; Berger, E.; Rust, J.; Scheer, C. Influence Of Biochars On Flux Of N2o And Co2 From Ferrosol. Australian Journal Of Soil Research, V.48, P.555-568, 2010b.
66. Verheijen, F.; Jeffery, S.L.; Bastos, A.C.; Van Der Velde, M.; Diafas, I. Biochar Application To Soils: A Critical Scientific Review Of Effects On Soil Properties, Processes And Functions. Luxembourg: European Commission, 2010. 162p.
67. Wardle, D.A.; Nilsson, M.-C.; Zackrisson, O. Fire-Derived Charcoal Causes Loss Of Forest Humus. Science, V.320, P.629, 2008. (Resumo).
68. Waters, D.; Van Zwieten, L.; Singh, Bhupinder-Pal; Downie, A.L.; Cowie, A.L.;, Lehmann, J. Biochar In Soil For Climate Change Mitigation And Adaptation. Soil Health And Climate Change, V.29, P.345-368, 2011.
69. Werhahn-Mees, W.; Palosuo, T.; Garcia-Gonzalo, J.; Roser, D.; Lindner, M. Sustainability Impact Assessment Of Increasing Resource Use Intensity In Forest Bioenergy Production Chains. Global Change Biology Bioenergy, V.3, P.91-106, 2011.
70. Wijesekara, R.G.S.; Navarro, R.R.; Matsumura, M. Removal And Recovery Of Mercury From Used Fluorescent Lamp Glass By Pyrolysis. Journal Of The National Science Foundation Of Sri Lanka, V.39, P.235-241, 2011.
71. Woolf, D.; Amonette, J.E.; Street-Perrott, F.A.; Lehmann, J.; Joseph, S. Sustainable Biochar To Mitigate Global Climate Change. Nature Communications, V.1, P.56, 2010.
72. Wu, H.; Fu, Q.; Giles, R.; Bartle, J. Production Of Mallee Biomass In Western Australia: Energy Balance Analysis. Energy And Fuels, V.22, P.190-198, 2008.