Combating Counterfeit Medicines and Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products: Minefields in Global Health Governance

Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics

Volumn 40, Issue 2, 2012, Pages 326-347

  Liberman, Jonathan ^a  

^a MONASH UNIVERSITY   (Australia)

Author keywords

[No Author keywords available]

Indexed keywords

COUNTERFEIT DRUG; DRUG;

ARTICLE; CRIME; DRUG INDUSTRY; HEALTH; HEALTH CARE DELIVERY; HUMAN; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; LAW ENFORCEMENT; LEGAL ASPECT; ORGANIZATION AND MANAGEMENT; TOBACCO;

COUNTERFEIT DRUGS; CRIME; DRUG INDUSTRY; HEALTH SERVICES ACCESSIBILITY; HUMANS; INTERNATIONAL COOPERATION; LAW ENFORCEMENT; OWNERSHIP; PHARMACEUTICAL PREPARATIONS; TOBACCO; WORLD HEALTH;

EID: 84864003395     PISSN: 10731105     EISSN: 1748720X     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1111/j.1748-720X.2012.00667.x     Document Type: Article

References (121)

1. M. Chan, "The WHO Director-General Reminds Health Officials: Never Forget the People, " Address to the Sixty-fourth World Health Assembly, Geneva, Switzerland, May 16, 2011, available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
2. World Health Organization, The Future of Financing for WHO. World Health Organization: Reforms for a Healthy Future, Report by the Director-General, A64/4, May 5, 2011, at para. 27 (hereinafter cited as WHO The Future of Financing).
3. J. Liberman and A. Mitchell, "In Search of Coherence between Trade and Health: Inter-Institutional Opportunities, " Maryland Journal of International Law 25 (2010): 143-186, at 153-154; A. L. Taylor, "Governing the Globalization of Public Health, "Journal of Law, Medicine & Ethics 32, no. 3 (2004): 500-508, at 502-503; L. O. Gostin and A. L. Taylor, "Global Health Law: A Definition and Grand Challenges, "Public Health Ethics 1, no. 1 (2008): 53-63, at 60;. D. P. Fidler, N. Drager, and K. Lee, "Managing the Pursuit of Health and Wealth: The Key Challenges, "The Lancet 373, no. 9660 (2009): 325-331, at 327.
4. L. O. Gostin and A. L. Taylor, quot;Global Health Law: A Definition and Grand Challenges,"Public Health Ethics 1, no. 1 (2008): 53-63, at 60;. D. P. Fidler, N. Drager, and K. Lee, quot;Managing the Pursuit of Health and Wealth: The Key Challenges,"The Lancet 373, no. 9660 (2009): 325-331, at 327
5. D. P. Fidler, N. Drager, and K. Lee, quot;Managing the Pursuit of Health and Wealth: The Key Challenges,"The Lancet 373, no. 9660 (2009): 325-331, at 327
6. I. Kickbusch, W. Hein, and G. Silberschmidt, "Addressing Global Health Governance Challenges through a New Mechanism: The Proposal for a Committee C of the World Health Assembly, " Journal of Medicine, Law & Ethics 38, no. 3 (2010): 550-563, at 551.
7. World Health Assembly, The WHO Reform, 64th sess, WHA 64.2, 9th plen mtg, A/64/VR/9 (20 May 2011); see.M. Chan, The Future of Financing for WHO: Introductory Remarks at an Informal Consultation on the Future of Financing for WHO, Geneva, Switzerland, January 12, 2010, available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
8. World Health Organization, supra note 2, at para. 20.
9. Constitution of the World Health Organization, New York, July 22, 1946), at art. 1.
10. WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, May 21, 2003, 2302 U.N.T.S. 166.
11. J. Liberman et al., "Opportunities and Risks of the Proposed FCTC Protocol on Illicit Trade, " Tobacco Control 20 (2011): 436-438.
12. World Health Organization, WHO Technical Manual on Tobacco Tax Administration (2010); International Agency for Research in Cancer, IARC Handbooks of Cancer Prevention: Tobacco Control, Volume 14: Effectiveness of Price and Tax Policies for Control of Tobacco, Lyon, France, 2011.
13. Black's Law Dictionary, 9th ed., 2009.
14. Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, at Annex 1C, Marrakesh, April 15, 1994 (hereinafter cited as TRIPS Agreement).
15. World Health Organization, "Medicines: Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit (SFFC) Medicines, " Fact sheet No. 275, January 2010, available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
16. M. J. Davison, A. L. Monotti, and L. Wiseman, Australian Intellectual Property Law ( Cambridge : Cambridge University Press, 2008): at 66.
17. A. Bunker, "Deadly Dose: Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals, Intellectual Property and Human Health, " Journal of the Patent and Trademark Office Society 89, no. 6 (2007): 493-515, at 508;.M. Nelson, M. Vizurraga, and D. Chang, "Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals: A Worldwide Problem, "Trademark Reports 96, no. 5 (2006): 1068-1100, at 1072.
18. M. Nelson, M. Vizurraga, and D. Chang, quot;Counterfeit Pharmaceuticals: A Worldwide Problem,"Trademark Reports 96, no. 5 (2006): 1068-1100, at 1072
19. World Health Organization, Medium-Term Strategic Plan 2008-2013. World Health Organization 2007.
20. World Health Organization, "Essential Medicines and Pharmaceutical Policies, " available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
21. World Health Assembly, "Rational Use of Drugs, " 41st sess., WHA41.16, Hbk Res., Vol. III (1st ed.), 1.15.2 (Fifteenth plenary meeting, May 13, 1988 - Committee A, second report).
22. World Health Assembly, "Rational Use of Drugs; and the WHO Action Programme on Essential Drugs, " 47th sess., WHA 47.13, Res., Vol. III (3rd ed.), 1.15.2 (Twelfth plenary meeting, 10 May 1994 - Committee A, second report).
23. World Health Organization, "Counterfeit Medical Products, International Medical Products Anti-Counterfeiting Taskforce, " Report by the Secretariat, A63/23, April 22, 2010, at para. 4.
24. World Health Organization International Conference, Combating Counterfeit Drugs: Building Effective International Collaboration ('Declaration of Rome'), February 18, 2006 at para. 1.
25. World Health Assembly, 61st sess., Committee A, 10th mtg., May 23, 2008.
26. World Health Assembly, Executive Board, 124th sess., 9th mtg., January 23, 2009.
27. World Health Organization, "World Health Assembly Closes with Resolutions on Public Health, " May 22, 2009, available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
28. World Health Organization, "Counterfeit Medical Products, " Report by the Secretariat, April 22, 2010, A63/23.
29. World Health Organization, "Counterfeit Medical Products, International Medical Products Anti-Counterfeiting Taskforce, " Report by the Secretariat, April 22, 2010, A63/INF. DOC./3.
30. World Health Assembly, 63rd sess, Committee A, 6th mtg., A/63/A/PSR/6, May 19, 2010, at 5.
31. Id., at 15. See also Third World Network, "WHO's 'Counterfeit' Programme: Legitimises IP Enforcement Agenda, Undermines Public Health, " Briefing Paper, 63rd World Health Assembly, May 17-21, 2010, Geneva, Switzerland; Third World Network, "NGOs concerned over WHO's role in 'Counterfeit' Drugs, IMPACT, " SUNS #6924, May 17, 2010, at 8, available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012); Third World Network et al., "NGO Open Letter Expressing Concern Over WHO's Involvement in 'Counterfeit Medical Products' and in the International Medical Product Anti-Counterfeit Taskforce (IMPACT), " May 2010, "Open Letter to Dr Margaret Chan, Director General of the World Health Organization, "available at <> (last visited April 11, 2012).
32. World Health Assembly, A/63/A/PSR/6, at 7-8. The candidate countries Turkey, Croatia and the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, the countries of the Stabilisation and Association Process and potential candidates Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Montenegro and Serbia, as well as Ukraine, the Republic of Moldova, Armenia and Georgia aligned themselves with this statement.
33. World Health Assembly, "Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, " WHA 63(10), 63rd sess., 8th plenary meeting, May 21, 2010.
34. M. Chan, "Turn off the Tap of Unsafe Medicines, " Opening remarks at the Working Group of Member States on Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, Geneva, Switzerland, February 28, 2011, at 8, <> available at <> (last visited March 23, 2012).
35. World Health Organization Working Group of Member States on Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, Report of the Working Group of Member States on Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, Annex to Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, A64/16, March 24, 2011.
36. World Health Assembly, Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, 64th sess., Fifth Report of Committee A, (Draft) A64/61, Agenda Item 13.7.
37. World Health Organization Working Group of Member States on Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, Report of the Working Group of Member States on Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, Annex to Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products: Report of the Working Group of Member States (EB130/22) at para. 5.
38. Id., at para. 11 and Appendix 2 ("Goal, Objective and Terms of Reference").
39. Id., at paras. 9 and 10, and Appendix 1 ("Draft Resolution"), para. 4.
40. World Health Assembly Executive Board, Substandard/Spurious/Falsely-Labelled/Falsified/Counterfeit Medical Products, 130th session EB130.R13, January 21, 2012.
41. World Health Assembly, Global Strategy and Plan of Action on Public Health, Innovation and Intellectual Property, 61st sess., WHA 61.21, Eighth plenary meeting, 24 May 2008 - Committee A, (fifth report) at para. 33.
42. World Health Organization, "About PHI, " available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
43. E.U. Regulation (1383/2003).
44. Combating Counterfeit, Falsified and Substandard Medicines: Defining the Way Forward?" Chatham House Briefing Paper (): at 4; C. Dounis, quot;Enforcing Intellectual Property Rights Via EU Border Regulations: Inhibiting Access to Medicine or Preventing Counterfeit Medicine?"Brooklyn Journal of International Law 36, no. 2 (2011): 717-750, at 717
45. K. Outterson, quot;Import Safety Rules and Generic Drug Markets," in C. Coglianese, eds., Import Safety: Regulatory Governance in the Global Economy, 1st ed. (2009): at 111-113
46. See also Medicins Sans Frontieres, Letter sent to Mr László Kovács, European Commissioner for Taxation and Customs Union, and to Baroness Catherine Ashton, European Commissioner for Trade (February 12, 2009), available at <> (last visited April 11, 2012);. Oxfam, Eye on the Ball: Medicine Regulation - Not IP Enforcement - Can Best Deliver Quality Medicines, Oxfam Briefing Paper 143, at 30, February 2, 2011), available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012)
47. World Trade Organization, Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Minutes of Meeting Held 3 March 2009, IP/C/M/59, May 25, 2009.
48. World Trade Organization, Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Minutes of Meeting Held 8-9 June 2009, IP/C/M/60, September 28, 2009.
49. World Trade Organization, Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Minutes of Meeting Held 3 March 2009, IP/C/M/59, May 25, 2009, para. 123.
50. World Trade Organization, Council for Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Minutes of Meeting held 8-9 June 2009, IP/C/M/60, September 28, 2009, para. 116 (hereinafter cited as WTO Council).
51. World Trade Organization Ministerial Conference, Declaration on the TRIPS Agreement and Public Health Adopted on 14 November 2001, WT/MIN(01)/DEC/d (November 20, 2001).
52. World Trade Organization, Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes, Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, Marrakesh Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization, Annex 2, Marrakesh, April 15, 1994 (hereinafter cited as TRIPS Agreement).
53. World Trade Organization, "European Union and a Member State - Seizure of Generic Drugs in Transit (India), " available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012); and World Trade Organization, "European Union and a Member State - Seizure of Generic Drugs in Transit (Brazil), "available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012). See also. J. Zarocastas, "Brazil and India File Complaint against EU over Seizure of Generic Drugs, "BMJ (Overseas & Retired Doctors Edition) 340, no. 7757 (2010): 1107.
54. Press Information Bureau, Government of India, "India EU Reach an Understanding on Issue of Seizure of Indian Generic Drugs in Transit, " July 28, 2011, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
55. J. von Braunn and P. Munyi, "New Enforcement Mechanisms Challenge the Legality of Generics in the Name of Public Health: The Emergence of Anti-Counterfeiting Legislation in East Africa, " African Journal of International and Comparative Law 18, no. 2 (2010): 238-253
56. M. Mulumba, quot;Anti-Counterfeiting Legislation in East Africa: A New Assault Against TRIPS Flexibilities for Access to Medicine?"Equinet Newsletter 111 (May 1, 2010), available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012); see Outterson, supra note 105, at 120-121
57. The Anti-Counterfeit Bill, 2008 (Kenya).
58. The Counterfeit Goods Bill, 2009 (Uganda).
59. The Anti Counterfeiting Goods Bill, 2010 (Uganda).
60. A. Mullard, "EU Implicated in Controversial Counterfeiting Bill, " The Lancet 375, no. 9723 (2010): 1335. See also, M. Wambi, "US Intensifies Anti-counterfeit Drive in East Africa, "IPS News (July 19, 2010), available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012);.I. Agazzi, "East African Laws Confuse Fake and Generic Drugs - WHO, "IPS Africa (July 19, 2010), available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012); Medicins Sans Frontieres, "Ten Stories That Mattered in Access to Medicines in 2010, "available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
61. Australian Government Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
62. S. Sell, "The Global IP Upward Ratchet, Anti-Counterfeiting and Piracy Enforcement Efforts: The State of Play, " PIJIP 15 (2010): 1-22, at 2.
63. Id., at 12; see also P. Yu, "Enforcement, Economics and Estimates, "WIPO Journal 2, no. 1 (2010): 1-19, at 2-6
64. S. Kumar, "International Trade, Public Health, and Intellectual Property Maximalism: The Case of European Border Enforcement and Trade in Generic Pharmaceuticals, "Global Trade and Customs Journal 5, no. 4 (2010): 155-169, at 155.
65. See Sell, supra note 141, at 17.
66. See TRIPS Agreement, supra note 23, at preamble.
67. United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, The Globalization of Crime: A Transnational Organized Crime Assessment (2010).
68. World Customs Organization, Enforcement and Compliance - Responsibilities: The WCO and the Protection of Intellectual Property Rights (IPR), available at <> (last visited April 3, 2012) (hereinafter cited as WCO Enforcement and Compliance).
69. World Customs Organization, Intellectual Property Rights, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
70. See WCO Enforcement and Compliance, supra note 158.
71. The International Criminal Police Organization (INTERPOL), "Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) Programme, " available at <> (last visited July 8, 2011).
72. United Nations Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, "Mandate and Functions, " available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
73. United Nations Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, Report on the Twentieth Session (December 3, 2010 and April 1115, 2011).
74. United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime, U.N.T.S. vol. 2225, No. 39574.
75. United Nations Commission on Crime Prevention and Criminal Justice, Report on the Twentieth Session, supra note 169, at preamble.
76. Id., at operative para. 1.
77. Id., at operative para. 2.
78. Id., at operative para. 3.
79. Id., at operative para. 4.
80. Id., at operative para. 8.
81. Council of Europe Convention on the Counterfeiting of Medical Products and Similar Crimes Involving Threats to Public Health (to open for signature on October 28, 2011) (hereinafter cited as MEDICRIME Convention).
82. Council of Europe, Medicrime: Introduction, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012). The Convention is the first "binding international instrument in the criminal law field on counterfeiting of medical products and similar crimes involving threats to public health.".
83. See MEDICRIME Convention, supra note 180, at Article 4j.
84. Council of Europe Communications, Counterfeit Medical Products: Twelve Countries Join the Council of Europe Medicrime Convention, October 28, 2011, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
85. See World Health Organization, Reforms for a Healthy Future, supra note 2, at para. 20.
86. G. Silberschmidt, "How to Set Priorities for the World Health Organization, " Global Health Programme Working Paper No. 6 (2011): at 6.
87. World Health Assembly, A/63/A/PSR/6, at 14.
88. See Chan, supra note 85.
89. See World Health Organization Executive Board, supra note 99.
90. See Declaration of Rome, supra note 44, at para. 3.
91. S. Park, "Legal Aspects of Defining 'Counterfeit Medicines': A Discussion Paper, " World Health Organization Regional Office South East Asia (2009): at 1.
92. J. M. Caudron et al., "Substandard Medicines in Resource-Poor Settings: A Problem That Can No Longer Be Ignored, "Tropical Medicine and International Health 13, no. 8 (2008): 1062-1072, at 1070.
93. K. Outterson and R. Smith, "Counterfeit Drugs: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, " Albany Law Journal of Science and Technology 16, no. 3 (2006): 525-543, at 526-530; see. Park, supra note 209, at 16-19.
94. See Liberman et al., supra note 19; N. Boister and B. McGrady, "Why and How to Make a Treaty Crime of Medicine Counterfeiting: A Reply to Attaran, Bate and Kendall, "Journal of International Criminal Justice 9, no. 4 (2011): 947-951, at 949-950.
95. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Convention Secretariat, "Parties to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, "available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
96. Price and tax measures (art. 6); protection from exposure to tobacco smoke (art. 8); regulation of tobacco products contents (art. 9); regulation of tobacco product disclosures (art. 10); packaging and labelling (art. 11); education, communication, training and public awareness (art. 12); tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship (art. 13); and demand reduction measures concerning tobacco dependence and cessation (art. 14).
97. Illicit trade in tobacco products (art. 15); sales to and by minors (art. 16); and provision of support for economically viable alternative activities (art. 17).
98. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties, Elaboration of a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 2nd sess., FCTC/COP2(12) (July 6, 2007).
99. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties, Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 4th sess., FCTC/COP4(11) (November 20, 2010).
100. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, FCTC/COP/INB-IT/4/7 (March 21, 2010) (hereinafter cited as Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products), art. 3.
101. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 2nd sess., 4th plen. mtg., FCTC/COP/INB-IT/2/VR/4, October 24, 2008, at 97.
102. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, Report of the Chairperson of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products to the Fourth Session of the Conference of the Parties, FCTC/COP/4/4, May 14, 2010.
103. See World Health Organization, supra note 20; International Agency for Research in Cancer, supra note 20.
104. Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, supra note 222, at art. 12.1(b)(i).
105. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 3rd sess., 4th plen. mtg., FCTC/COP/INB-IT/3/VR/4, June 29, 2009, at 91, 93.
106. See MEDICRIME Convention, supra note 180, at preamble.
107. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties, Guidelines for Implementation of Article 5.3 of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control, 2nd sess., FCTC/COP3(7), November 22, 2008.
108. World Health Organization, Engaging and Working with the Commercial Private Sector, WHO Policy Framework, September 2010, at para. 13.
109. See generally International Tax and Investment Center, The Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products and How to Tackle It, 2010, available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
110. E. Blecher, "Commentary on Joossens et al. (2010): 'Eliminating the Global Illicit Cigarette Trade - What Do We Really Know?" Addiction 105, no. 9 (2010): 1650-1651.
111. British American Tobacco, "About Illicit Trade, " available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012).
112. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 3rd sess., 1st plen. mtg., FCTC/COP/INB-IT/3/VR/1, June 28, 2009, at 11.
113. N. Boister, "The (Un-)systematic Nature of the UN Criminal Justice System: The (Non) Relationship between the Draft Illicit Tobacco Trade Protocol and the UN Convention Against Transnational Organised Crime, " Criminal Law Forum 21, (2010): 361-397, especially at 364-367 and 389-392.
114. British American Tobacco, "How We Tackle Illicit Trade, " available at <> (last visited March 28, 2012) (emphasis added).
115. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties, Establishment of a Permanent Secretariat of the Convention, 1st sess., FCTC/COP1(10), February 17, 2006, at para. 8.
116. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Conference of the Parties, Elaboration of a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, 2nd sess., FCTC/COP2(12), July 6, 2007.
117. World Health Organization Framework Convention on Tobacco Control Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Draft Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, "Informal Working Group on the Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products: Outcome of the Two Meetings of the Working Group, "5th sess., FCTC/COP/INB-IT/5/3, October 24, 2011, at para. 5.
118. Draft Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, supra note 222, at art. 36.1.
119. World Health Assembly, A/63/A/PSR/6, at 14.
120. World Health Organization Commission on Social Determinants of Health, Closing the Gap in a Generation: Health Equality through Action on the Social Determinants of Health, 2008.
121. Report to the fifth session of the Conference of the Parties of the Chairperson of the Intergovernmental Negotiating Body on a Protocol on Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, FCTC/COP/5/7, May 11, 2012, available at <> (last visited May 21, 2012).