The potential for extraction and exploitation of DNA from parchment: A review of the opportunities and hurdles

Journal of the Institute of Conservation

Volumn 33, Issue 1, 2010, Pages 1-11

  Bower, Mim A ^a   Campana, Michael G ^a   Checkley Scott, Caroline ^b   Knight, Barry ^c   Howe, Christopher J ^a  

^a UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE   (United Kingdom)

^b UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER   (United Kingdom)

^c BRITISH LIBRARY   (United Kingdom)

Author keywords

Ancient DNA; Genetics; Historic DNA; Parchment; Polymerase chain reaction (PCR); Preservation

Indexed keywords

DNA; HISTORIC PRESERVATION; WOOD PRESERVATION;

ANCIENT DNAS; GENETICS; HISTORIC DNAS; PARCHMENT; TECHNICAL ADVANCES;

POLYMERASE CHAIN REACTION;

EID: 84862540347     PISSN: 19455224     EISSN: 19455232     Source Type: Journal    
DOI: 10.1080/19455220903509937     Document Type: Article

References (108)

1. C. de Hamel, Scribes and Illuminators (London: British Museum Press, 1992).
2. R. d'Agata, G. Grasso, S. Parlato, S. Simone and G. Spoto, 'The Use of Atmospheric Pressure Laser Desorption Mass Spectrometry for the Study of Iron-Gall Ink', Applied Physics A 89(2007):91-5;
3. G. van der Snickt, W. de Nolf, B. Vekemans and K. Janssens, 'μ-XRF/μ-RS vs. SR μ-XRD for Pigment Identification in Illuminated Manuscripts', Applied Physics A 92(2008):59-68.
4. D. L. Nelson and M. M. Cox, Lehninger: Principles of Biochemistry (New York: WH Freeman and Company, 2008).
5. P. Wandeler, P. E. A. Hoek and L. F. Keller, 'Back to the Future: Museum Specimens in Population Genetics', Trends in Ecology and Evolution 22(2007):634-42.
6. K. B. Mullis and F. A. Faloona, 'Specific Synthesis of DNA in Vitro Via a Polymerase-Catalyzed Chain Reaction', Methods in Enzymology 155(1987):335-50.
7. C. J. Howe, Gene Cloning and Manipulation, 2nd ed. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007).
8. I. Raskó and C. S. Downes, Genes in Medicine (London: Chapman and Hall, 1995);
9. P. Turnpenny and S. Ellard, Emery's Elements of Medical Genetics, 13th ed. (Oxford: Elsevier, 2007).
10. M. A. Bower and M. K. Jones, 'Ancient DNA and Archaeogenetics', in Encyclopaedia of Archaeology, ed. D. M. Pearsall (Oxford: Elsevier, 2007).
11. M. A. Zeder, E. Emshwiller, B. D. Smith and D. G. Bradley, 'Documenting Domestication: The Intersection of Genetics and Archaeology', Trends in Genetics 22(2006):139-55.
12. R. Higuchi, B. Bowman, M. Freiberger, O. A. Ryder and A. C. Wilson, 'DNA Sequences from the Quagga, an Extinct Member of the Horse Family', Nature 312, no. 5991(1984):282-4.
13. For example: S. Pääbo, 'Molecular Cloning of Ancient Egyptian Mummy DNA', Nature 314, no. 6012(1985):644-5;
14. E. Hagelberg, M. G. Thomas, C. E. Cook, A. V. Sher, G. F. Baryshnikov and A. M. Lister, 'DNA from Ancient Mammoth Bones', Nature 370, no. 6488(1994):333-4;
15. M. Höss, S. Pääbo and N. K. Vereshchagin, 'Mammoth DNA Sequences', Nature 370, no. 6488(1994):333;
16. M. Noro, R. Masuda, I. A. Dubrovo, M. C. Yoshida and M. Kato, 'Molecular Phylogenetic Inference of the Woolly Mammoth Mammuthus primigenius, Based on Complete Sequences of Mitochondrial Cytochrome b and 12S Ribosomal RNA Genes', Journal of Molecular Evolution 46, no. 3(1998):314-26;
17. C. Krajewski, A. C. Driskell, P. R. Baverstock and M. J. Braun, 'Phylogenetic Relationships of the Thylacine (Mammalia: Thylacinidae) among Dasyuroid Marsupials: Evidence from Cytochrome b DNA Sequences', Proceedings of the Royal Society, Biological Sciences 250, no. 1327(1992):19-27;
18. C. Krajewski, L. Buckley and M. Westerman, 'DNA Phylogeny of the Marsupial Wolf Resolved', Proceedings of the Royal Society, Biological Sciences 264, no. 1383(1997):911-7;
19. R. H. Thomas, W. Schaffner, A. C. Wilson and S. Pääbo, 'DNA Phylogeny of the Extinct Marsupial Wolf', Nature 340, no. 6233(1989):465-7.
20. For example: E. Hagelberg, B. Sykes and R. Hedges, 'Ancient Bone DNA Amplified', Nature 342, no. 6249(1989):485;
21. I. B. Colson, J. F. Bailey, M. Vercauteren and B. Sykes, 'The Preservation of Ancient DNA and Bone Diagenesis', Ancient Biomolecules 1(1997):109-17;
22. M. Hofreiter, H. N. Poinar, W. G. Spaulding, K. Bauer, P. S. Martin, G. Possnert and S. Pääbo, 'A Molecular Analysis of Ground Sloth Diet through the Last Glaciation', Molecular Ecology 9(2000):1975-84;
23. H. Poinar, M. Kuch, G. McDonald, P. Martin and S. Pääbo, 'Nuclear Gene Sequences from a Late Pleistocene Sloth Coprolite', Current Biology 13, no. 13(2003):1150-2;
24. T. A. Brown, R. G. Allaby, K. A. Brown and M. K. Jones, 'Biomolecular Archaeology of Wheat: Past, Present and Future', World Archaeology 25(1993):64-73;
25. V. Jaenicke-Després, E. S. Buckler, B. D. Smith, M. T. Gilbert, A. Cooper, J. Doebley and S. Pääbo, 'Early Allelic Selection in Maize as Revealed by Ancient DNA', Science 302, no. 5648(2003):1206-8;
26. A. C. Stone and M. Stoneking, 'MtDNA Analysis of a Prehistoric Oneota Population: Implications for the Peopling of the New World', American Journal of Human Genetics 62(1998):1153-70;
27. S. Dumolin-Lapègue, M.-H. Pemonge, L. Gielly, P. Taberlet and R. Petit, 'Amplification of Oak DNA from Ancient and Modern Wood', Molecular Ecology 8(1999):2137-40;
28. M. T. Gilbert, J. Cuccui, W. White, N. Lynnerup, R. W. Titball, A. Cooper and M. B. Prentice, 'Absence of Yersinia Pestis-Specific DNA in Human Teeth from Five European Excavations of Putative Plague Victims', Microbiology 150, no. 2(2004):341-54;
29. E. Stokstad, 'Paleontology: Ancient DNA Pulled from Soil', Science 300, no. 5618(2003):407a.
30. M. Hofreiter, D. Serre, H. N. Poinar, M. Kuch and S. Pääbo, 'Ancient DNA', Nature Reviews Genetics 2(2001):353-9.
31. For example: R. J. Cano and M. K. Borucki, 'Revival and Identification of Bacterial Spores in 25-to 40-million-yearold Dominican Amber', Science 268, no. 5213(1995):1060-4;
32. R. J. Cano, H. N. Poinar, N. J. Pieniazek, A. Acra and G. O. Poinar, 'Amplification and Sequencing of DNA from a 120-135-Million-Year-Old Weevil', Nature 363, no. 6429(1993):536-8;
33. R. J. Cano, M. K. Borucki, M. Higby-Schweitzer, H. N. Poinar, G. O. Poinar and K. J. Pollard, 'Bacillus DNA in Fossil Bees: An Ancient Symbiosis?', Applied and Environmental Microbiology 60(1994):2164-7;
34. R. DeSalle, J. Gatesy, W. Wheeler and D. Grimaldi, 'DNA Sequences from a Fossil Termite in Oligo-Miocene Amber and Their Phylogenetic Implications', Science 257, no. 5078(1992):1933-6;
35. R. De Salle, M. Barcia and C. Wray, 'PCR Jumping in Clones of 30-Million-Year-Old DNA Fragments from Amber Preserved Termites (Mastotermes electrodominicus) ', Experientia 49(1993):906-9;
36. H. N. Poinar, R. J. Cano and G. O. Poinar, 'DNA from an Extinct Plant', Nature 363, no. 6431(1993):677;
37. E. M. Golenberg, 'Amplification and Analysis of Miocene Plant Fossil DNA', Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B 333(1991):419-27;
38. E. M. Golenberg, D. E. Giannasi, M. T. Clegg, C. J. Smiley, M. Durbin, D. Henderson and G. Zurawski, 'Chloroplast DNA Sequence from a Miocene Magnolia Species', Nature 344, no. 6267(1990):656-8;
39. P. S. Soltis, D. E. Soltis and C. J. Smiley, 'An rbcL Sequence from a Miocene Taxodium (Bald Cypress) ', Proceedings of the National Academy of Science of the United States of America, 89(1992), 449-51;
40. S. R. Woodward, N. J. Weyand and M. Bunnell, 'DNA Sequence from Cretaceous Period Bone Fragments', Science 266, no. 5188(1994):1229-32.
41. A. Cooper and H. N. Poinar, 'Ancient DNA: Do It Right or Not at All', Science 289, no. 5482(2000):1139.
42. M. Spencer and C. J. Howe, 'Authenticity of Ancient DNA Results: A Statistical Approach', American Journal of Human Genetics 75(2004):240-50;
43. M. A. Bower, M. Spencer, S. Matsumura, R. E. R. Nisbet and C. J. Howe, 'How Many Clones Need to Be Sequenced from a Single Forensic or Ancient DNA Sample in Order to Determine a Reliable Consensus Sequence?', Nucleic Acids Research 33(2005):2549-56.
44. For example: R. G. Allaby, M. Banerjee and T. A. Brown, 'Evolution of the High Molecular Weight Glutenin Loci of the A, B, D and G Genomes of Wheat', Genome 42, no. 2(1999):296-307;
45. Jaenicke-Després et al., 'Early Allelic Selection in Maize', 1206-8;
46. C. J. Edwards, J. Connellan, P. F. Wallace, S. D. Park, F. M. McCormick, I. Olsaker, E. Eythorsdottir, D. E. MacHugh, J. F. Bailey and D. G. Bradley, 'Feasibility and Utility of Microsatellite Markers in Archaeological Cattle Remains from a Viking Age Settlement in Dublin', Animal Genetics 34, no. 6(2003):410-6;
47. J. A. Leonard, R. K. Wayne, J. Wheeler, R. Valadez, S. Guillén and C. Vilà, 'Ancient DNA Evidence for Old World Origin of New World Dogs', Science 298, no. 5598(2002):1613-6;
48. D. E. MacHugh and D. G. Bradley, 'Livestock Genetic Origins: Goats Buck the Trend', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 98, no. 10(2001):5382-4;
49. A. McGahern, M. Bower, C. J. Edwards, P. O. Brophy, G. Sulimova, I. Zakharov, M. Vizuete-Forster, M. Levine, S. Li, D. E. MacHugh and E. W. Hill, 'Evidence for Biogeographic Patterning of Mitochondrial DNA Sequences in Eastern Horse Populations', Animal Genetics 37, no. 5(2006):494-7;
50. C. Vila, J. A. Leonard, A. Gotherstrom, S. Marklund, K. Sandberg, K. Liden, R. K. Wayne and H. Ellegren, 'Widespread Origins of Domestic Horse Lineages', Science 291, no. 5503(2001):474-7;
51. G. Larson, K. Dobney, U. Albarella, M. Fang, E. Matisoo-Smith, J. Robins, S. Lowden, H. Finlayson, T. B. Brand, E. Willerslev, P. Rowley-Conwy, L. Andersson and A. Cooper, 'Worldwide Phylogeography of Wild Boar Reveals Multiple Centres of Pig Domestication', Science 307, no. 5715(2005):1618-21;
52. G. Larson, U. Albarella, K. Dobney, P. Rowley-Conwy, J. Schibler, A. Tresset, J. D. Vigne, C. Edwards, A. Schlumbaum, A. Dinu, A. Bǎlǎçsescu, G. Dolman, A. Tagliacozzo, N. Manaseryan, P. Miracle, L. Van Wijngaarden-Bakker, M. Masseti, D. G. Bradley and A. Cooper, 'Ancient DNA, Pig Domestication, and the Spread of the Neolithic into Europe', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 104, no. 39(2007):15276-81.
53. For example: J. P. Noonan, G. Coop, S. Kudaravalli, D. Smith, J. Krause, J. Alessi, F. Chen, D. Platt, S. Pääbo, J. K. Pritchard and E. M. Rubin, 'Sequencing and Analysis of Neanderthal Genomic DNA', Science 314, no. 5802(2006):1113-8;
54. H. N. Poinar, C. Schwarz, J. Qi, B. Shapiro, R. D. Macphee, B. Buigues, A. Tikhonov, D. H. Huson, L. P. Tomsho, A. Auch, M. Rampp, W. Miller and S. C. Schuster, 'Metagenomics to Paleogenomics: Large-Scale Sequencing of Mammoth DNA', Science 311, no. 5759(2006):392-4;
55. E. I. Rogaev, Y. K. Moliaka, B. A. Malyarchuk, F. A. Kondrashov, M. V. Derenko, I. Chumakov and A. P. Grigorenko, 'Complete Mitochondrial Genome and Phylogeny of Pleistocene Mammoth Mammuthus primigenius', PLoS Biology 4(2006):73;
56. R. E. Green, A. W. Briggs, J. Krause, K. Prüfer, H. A. Burbano, M. Siebauer, M. Lachmann and S. Pääbo, 'The Neandertal Genome and Ancient DNA Authenticity', EMBO Journal 28(2009):2494-502;
57. C. Lalueza-Fox, H. Römpler, D. Caramelli, C. Stäubert, G. Catalano, D. Hughes, N. Rohland, E. Pilli, L. Longo, S. Condemi, M. de la Rasilla, J. Fortea, A. Rosas, M. Stoneking, T. Schöneberg, J. Bertranpetit and M. Hofreiter, 'A Melanocortin 1 Receptor Allele Suggests Varying Pigmentation among Neanderthals', Science 318, no. 5855(2007):1453-5.
58. J. Burger, S. Hummel and B. Herrmann, 'Palaeogenetics and Cultural Heritage. Species Determination and STR-Genotyping from Ancient DNA in Art and Artefacts', Thermochimica Acta 365(2000):141-6;
59. J. Burger, I. Pfeiffer, S. Hummel, R. Fuchs, B. Brenig and B. Herrmann, 'Mitochondrial and Nuclear DNA from (Pre) Historic Hide-Derived Material', Ancient Biomolecules 3, no. 3(2001):227-38;
60. N. Poulakakis, A. Tselikas, I. Bitsakis, M. Mylonas and P. Lymberakis, 'Ancient DNA and the Genetic Signature of Ancient Greek Manuscripts', Journal of Archaeological Science 34(2007):675-80;
61. S. R. Woodward, G. Kahila, P. Smith, C. Greenblatt, J. Zias and M. Broshi, 'Analysis of Parchment Fragments from the Judea Desert Using DNA Techniques', in Current Research and Technological Developments on the Dead Sea Scrolls, ed. D. W. Parry and S. Ricks (Leiden: EJ Brill, 1996), 215-38.
62. Woodward et al., 'Analysis of Parchment Fragments', 215-38.
63. Burger et al., 'Palaeogenetics and Cultural Heritage', 141-6;
64. Burger et al., 'Mitochondrial and Nuclear DNA', 227-38.
65. Burger et al., 'Mitochondrial and Nuclear DNA', 227-38.
66. Poulakakis et al., 'Ancient DNA and the Genetic Signature', 675-80.
67. T. Lindahl, 'Recovery of Antediluvian DNA', Nature 365, no. 6448(1993):700.
68. S. Pääbo, 'Ancient DNA: Extraction, Characterization, Molecular Cloning, and Enzymatic Amplification', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 86(1989):1939-43;
69. S. Pääbo, R. G. Higuchi and A. C. Wilson, 'Ancient DNA and the Polymerase Chain Reaction. The Emerging Field of Molecular Archaeology', Journal of Biological Chemistry 264, no. 17(1989):9709-12.
70. R. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers (London and New York: Seminar Press, 1972), 48-50;
71. R. Reed, The Nature and Making of Parchment (Leeds: The Elmete Press, 1975), 31-2.
72. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 51-4, 132-3;
73. B. M. Haines, Parchment: The Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Parchment and the Materials Used in Its Conservation (Northampton: The Leather Conservation Centre, 1999), 22.
74. A. Vuissoz, M. Worobey, N. Odegaard, M. Bunce, C. A. Machado, N. Lynnerup, E. E. Peacock and M. T. P. Gilbert, 'The Survival of PCR-Amplifiable DNA in Cow Leather', Journal of Archaeological Science 34(2007):823-9;
75. Haines, Parchment: The Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Parchment, 24.
76. Haines, Parchment: The Physical and Chemical Characteristics of Parchment, 25;
77. H. N. Poinar, M. Höss, J. L. Bada and S. Pääbo, 'Amino Acid Racemisation and the Preservation of Ancient DNA', Science 272, no. 5263(1996):864-6.
78. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 170.
79. Vuissoz, 'The Survival of PCR-Amplifiable DNA in Cow Leather', 823-9.
80. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 55.
81. Lindahl, 'Recovery of Antediluvian DNA', 700.
82. E. Heidemann, 'Das Nerhalten der Haut Bei der Pergamentherstellung- Interpretiert Aus der Biophysik Und Biochemie Ihrer Struktur', in Pergament. Geschichte, Struktur, Restaurierung, Herstellung, ed. P. Rueck (Sigmaringen: Jan Thorbecke Verlag, 1991), 221-8;
83. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 218-9.
84. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 93.
85. Lindahl, 'Recovery of Antediluvian DNA', 700.
86. For example: E.-M. Geigl, 'On the Circumstances Surrounding the Preservation and Analysis of Very Old DNA', Archaeometry 44(2002):337-42;
87. M. Salamon, N. Tuross, B. Arensburg and S. Weiner, 'Relatively Well Preserved DNA Is Present in the Crystal Aggregates of Fossil Bones', Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 102(2005):13783-8.
88. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 147-52.
89. Reed, The Nature and Making of Parchment, 87-92.
90. Vuissoz, 'The Survival of PCR-Amplifiable DNA in Cow Leather', 823-9.
91. Burger et al., 'Palaeogenetics and Cultural Heritage', 141-6.
92. E. Badea, L. Miu, P. Budrugeac, M. Giurginca, A. Mascarošić , N. Badea and G. Della Gatta, 'Study of Deterioration of Historical Parchments by Various Thermal Analysis Techniques Complemented by SEM, FTIR, UV-Vis-NIR and Unilateral NMR Investigations', Journal of Thermal Analysis and Calorimetry 91(2008):17-27;
93. L. Gonzalez and T. Weiss, 'Use of Attenuated Total Reflection-Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy to Measure Collagen Degradation in Historical Parchments', Applied Spectroscopy 62(2008):1108-14;
94. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 252-81.
95. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 25-44;
96. Reed, The Nature and Making of Parchment, 18-19;
97. M. L. Ryder, 'Remains Derived from Skin', in Science in Archaeology, eds. D. Brothwell and E. Higgs (London: Thames and Hudson, 1963).
98. Reed, The Nature and Making of Parchment, 19.
99. Woodward et al., 'Analysis of Parchment Fragments', 215-38.
100. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 126.
101. de Hamel, Scribes and Illuminators.
102. Woodward et al., 'Analysis of Parchment Fragments', 215-38.
103. Poulakakis et al., 'Ancient DNA and the Genetic Signature', 675-80.
104. For example: R. J. Asher and M. Hofreiter, 'Tenrec Phylogeny and the Noninvasive Extraction of Nuclear DNA', Systematic Biology 55, no. 2(2006):181-94;
105. N. Rohland, H. Siedel and M. Hofreiter, 'Nondestructive DNA extraction method for mitochondrial DNA analyses of museum specimens', BioTechniques 36, no. 5(2004):814-21.
106. C. Chahine, 'Changes in Hydrothermal Stability of Leather and Parchment with Deterioration: A DSC Study', Thermochimica Acta 365(2000):101-10;
107. Reed, Ancient Skins, Parchments and Leathers, 314-6.
108. Haines, Parchment: The Physical and Chemical Characteristics, 23.